Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
The group portrays a strong overall interest in scientific studies like Reiner and Gearhart's 2004 research, emphasizing neurological and genetic factors; their tone varies from respectful to dismissive, reflecting both curiosity and frustration, which shapes the nuanced but sometimes polarized discussion about biological sex and gender identity.
Most comments acknowledge the validity of scientific research on the topic, with some referencing peer-reviewed studies and scientific terminology.
Discussions show high curiosity, with participants seeking specific evidence, research papers, and scientific explanations about gender and biological development.
Participants demonstrate deep engagement through detailed references, debate about scientific findings, and calls for credible sources.
The overall discussions could influence understanding of gender complexity, although some tone and dismissiveness slightly limit broad impact.
[Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/hQG8cixpVA
@JadderWilson @brunomarotodv5 @eixopolitico não, a ciência comprova que sexo e gênero são coisas diferentes também comprova que ser trans é natural biólogos sérios apoiam a comunidade trans vou te passar uns artigos sobre https://t.co/nK6u9Xdtab https://t.co/DvXtE8kPUY https://t.co/W16tTVbzru
Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth William G. Reiner, M.D., and John P. Gearhart, M.D. January 22, 2004 N Engl J Med 2004; 350:333-341 DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa022236 https://t.co/ooIsbYKYwF
@missdelein2 Frau @AglajaStirn "Es gibt keine durch wissenschaftliche Studien bewiesenen Hinweise auf angeborene Rollenbilder oder Identitäten als Frau oder Mann": kennen sie diese Studien: https://t.co/fvEHhB4vVg https://t.co/1y53Uyouft https://t.co/d9wM9NZzCD https://t.co/8PGBceoDTz
@harlot_scara @SamJulieAnders @eaz__zee @RespectfulMemes Here, I got some papers for you both that disagree with https://t.co/kBoPbLLi47 https://t.co/DvXtE8kPUY https://t.co/SaViE2LQXg https://t.co/XP0zbIi1W8 https://t.co/s5tN4QQ5I3 Of course, I'll wait for a peer reviewed rebutal of them since you two are so knowledgeable
@whocares466 @catalystmic @Esqueer_ Er... sometimes they did. They had to. https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W
This video discusses how genetics influence sex diversity, including variations beyond male and female categories. It explains the role of genes and chromosomes in sexual development and highlights the importance of…
This video explores how genetics influence sex diversity beyond typical male and female categories, discussing genes, chromosomes, and biological factors shaping sexual development and identities.
@AlbaVeeDub @Ironman92Kona @WildfireWhisper Which facts? These? https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@Festivalkyrie @Ironman92Kona @WildfireWhisper Rocket science? Nah its much more complex. Its neuroscience . Here are the facts currently being researched https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@WildfireWhisper @Ironman92Kona Scientists and doctors dont care about your feels. Stfu shit the fuck down you ignorant ass moron. Here is what neuroscience says https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@WaltIsHereNow @buttonslives Here is neuroscience https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@MooshHello1234 @buttonslives Nooooo This is science https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@Miulahung @buttonslives Twitter post is not science This is https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@rosykaren @falsedichotoman @buttonslives You read a children's pamphlet??? LoL I have confidence in your brain being better then that Here https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@rosykaren @falsedichotoman @buttonslives You read a child's book? Im sure your capable of better https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@Kevin_1_618 @falsedichotoman @buttonslives Says who??? Whats you evidence? trust me bro https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@0x9cc9 @buttonslives Here are some exemples Read em https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@Kevin_1_618 @chicken_trapp @buttonslives Here buddy https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@real_artisan @buttonslives Always neuroscience wins in the end https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@buttonslives @aldestrawk @SwipeWright @CityJournal Here is some neuroscience studies https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@aldestrawk @buttonslives Here is some easily available amunition https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@BallisticDaddyO @marycatedelvey Calm down Read this Educate yourself https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@babybeginner @shunechkai Cant fix stupid... But ill try Here is neuroscience about it. Please provide your supoorting evidence that rans are lying https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@RoisinMichaux Reimer suggests that ‘gender identities’ are real. Research on 16 males with pelvic anomalies which resulted in them being raised female showed a little under half remained female at 16 https://t.co/6y2dNqr7R7
@StellarFox16 @sappholives83 Well if you get your info from twitter.... Here ill help read this. https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@JadeL8282 @X_Aeon_X Here are references for what your saying https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@nnonarch @JadeL8282 @X_Aeon_X Brain development starts before your trsticles develop. but nice try. Here is a more detailed explanation https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@vvsgus @JadeL8282 @X_Aeon_X Nope. Here is a slightly more complicated but incidentally much more compelling explanation. https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@rady_aphrodite @JadeL8282 @X_Aeon_X Well lets see. Here: for your enlightenment https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@X_Aeon_X @JadeL8282 Please provide your source I would love to see the research. In the mean time ill take your trust me bro and raise you some real science. https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk
@chooseliberty_ @TheJoeySwoll Source: meme I see we have lots of work to do here boys... Lets stary with a few studies on the subject. https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@sourpanda7 @theresaverity @Serena_Partrick Ok dr sourpanda. Someone's mom never taught them to stay silent when they dont know what they are talking about. Source: https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@Rover_Pilot @Serena_Partrick @mylifegoingdown Bold statement. "You think" based on what? This morning fart's smell? Here is some real studies https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@Taylorzeke11 @Rover_Pilot @Serena_Partrick @mylifegoingdown Here are real studies https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@StumpyRabbitt @Rover_Pilot @Serena_Partrick @mylifegoingdown What research brought you to these conclusions? Trust me bro? Here are some real studies https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@Makoto_Says @ThatAussieWoman Here is the info your looking for. Neuroscience studies on the subject https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@exxster @ThatAussieWoman Says Dr still typos? Here https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@Lyte_House @ThatAussieWoman Here Real discussion about it From people with knowledge https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@WomenReadWomen Ita not rocket science! Its neuroscience! Here have fun https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@EggBoxOfTricks @jwit2049 @JamesEsses Lets look at neuroscience Here are some studies https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@OBlossie @jwit2049 @JamesEsses Well lets see here https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@jwit2049 @JamesEsses Lets see some studies about it https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@jacrispy42069 @JamesEsses Here is some information on gender itself https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@rocksdloki @MeghanEMurphy Here is some studies for your enlightenment https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@roseveniceallan Here. For your learning pleasure https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@Sandra45629898 @roseveniceallan Here is actual studies about it https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@MonkeyFlorest35 @TonyBaduy @DanniBrener Well lets see. Here are some actual studies https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@TonyBaduy @DanniBrener For your learning pleasure First one is most important in regards to this comment specifically https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@IsaInsane1 @mcucolo57 https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@OmarRobau @sundiamondshine @mcucolo57 This should help understand https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@youlynew @Rosselanor1 @hecheateddotorg Here you go. Lets fix your ignorance https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@hecheateddotorg @sheawilliamsy The fact that you dont understand trans doesnt make it go away. It should make you stop talking about it tho... Here is some help. https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@MakerOfTears69 @pancatalanisme Reiner, W. G., & Gearhart, J. P. (2004). Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth Testa, R. J., et al. (2017). Gender Minority Stress and Mental Health: The Role of Discrimination and Internalized Transphobia
@ThatAussieWoman Here. This might explain things. Hopefuly this helps. https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@rndmruminations @ChoooCole https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@Cally12750 @ChoooCole @elonmusk https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@jh336405 @Sadie_NC https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@TheGlobal_Index @Sadie_NC https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@Vinod_r108 @Sadie_NC https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@TeamPfizer @BillboardChris https://t.co/qkTSFGC57R https://t.co/oO0ZcmwrPO https://t.co/bjKR4glW2b https://t.co/Tu19DsJabb https://t.co/nezFMIy9Dk https://t.co/J2NHm2ZRCp
@JAWsInfinity @ZoeyStarwind @nor4aaaa @nyaraVT Then may I ask you for your opinion on this paper? https://t.co/HXnLgT07jc
@anammostarac @jk_rowling Here is biology for your ass https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@Fer_Procrastina @anammostarac @jk_rowling https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@DrJessicaRitter Das ist die feministische Theorie (zumindest die bisherige, in der neueren sind ja schon dank trans Frauen einiges an Biologie eingezogen) Aber die Forschung dazu ist dennoch anders: https://t.co/fvEHhB4vVg https://t.co/1y53Uyouft https://t.co/d9wM9NZzCD https://t.co/OfDe0hMiez
@radfemlesbi @sadleaning But since you wanted to bring it up https://t.co/iAWhWKAA8f https://t.co/qlY3FBRXoU https://t.co/kFgG8LxA1r https://t.co/zGJe5Sety3 https://t.co/qg3E4gLViv https://t.co/ama0sF7Vi8 https://t.co/JTCugl9bjo https://t.co/3ji1UU4bH5
@BradKort @laurel_libby Their genes didn’t provide a definitive description of what they felt was their sexual identity. Humans are complex creatures, not fully understood. https://t.co/dC2sycsmHb
@PrintsSavvy @iamnormalbciam @DK_Able @LostMediaBuster https://t.co/HXnLgT0F8K This is quite old but the newer studies I saw where paywalled
@jimmyincognito1 @LanceUSA70 @MrChrishere I hear a lot about control groups. However, I have more articles. You are just believing what you want to support your rhetoric. https://t.co/GT8I26CQcI https://t.co/0W4J10Ujy0 https://t.co/9TUuv4JXiP https://t.co/Os8tYAZAOk https://t.co/t3SUYXdgco
@Espalda @buhlockay_ @mjfree https://t.co/iqQPryVWev https://t.co/t3SUYXcImQ https://t.co/Os8tYAZ2YM https://t.co/9TUuv4Jpth https://t.co/Yr4LSg6NtV https://t.co/0W4J10TLIs https://t.co/GT8I26Cina Please try to educate yourself more.
@Eggingpumpkins @buhlockay_ @mjfree https://t.co/Os8tYAZAOk https://t.co/9TUuv4JXiP https://t.co/Yr4LSg7ljt https://t.co/0W4J10Ujy0 https://t.co/GT8I26CQcI
@ButterFriedCat @CatchUNextTuesd @ThePoliticalHQ @buhlockay_ @mjfree Hello, I have some peer reviewed articles for you that state that transgenders have differing brain development than people who are not transgender. https://t.co/GT8I26Cina https://t.co/0W4J10TLIs https://t.co/Yr4LSg6NtV https://t.co/9TUuv4Jpth https://t.co/Os8tYAZ2YM
@rosykaren @buhlockay_ @mjfree I have more, too. Allow me to get them. https://t.co/t3SUYXcImQ https://t.co/Os8tYAZ2YM https://t.co/9TUuv4Jpth https://t.co/Yr4LSg6NtV https://t.co/0W4J10TLIs https://t.co/GT8I26Cina
@VexedVortices @anne__onymous_ @gynemimesis @TiresianRhodie what do you make of the fact that only 8/14 in this sample of males with cloacal exstrophy who were assigned female declared themselves to be male? https://t.co/jCcGirRgl6
@Sylvan_Cat @SangerPilled For those with cloacal exstrophy raised as girls https://t.co/cjacE9VPhu https://t.co/IbOD2w9Ozi
@MF_TROON Does this guy have an intersex condition bc not having the lower half of your body impacts your sexual development? Thats not what it means, they dont have chromossomal sex discordant with phenotypic sex nor do they have female sex characteristics https://t.co/swEk1zDmRR https://t.co/9AW858W9QH
@AdeptusViewer @hrcsamael @lalo18_april_19 @MaeBlight_ lo indica, primero habla de que es un borrador de la HHS, que procede a analizar, y cuando habla más en especifico del tema cita el trabajo "Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth" de W.G. Reiner
@lampjaded @jack_turban Reiner did a landmark study which found most had transitioned to their chromosomally suggested gender, or would if they socially could. Hence chromosome tests pretty much rule in assigning gender in DSD now in many centres. Cass seems not to know that https://t.co/6FVDnZiwtH
@BradMil95712875 @jk_rowling Which science are you referring to? The meme science? https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@_Rachel_Roberts @jk_rowling https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@GarfieldUtd @jk_rowling https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@X_Beast_ETH @jk_rowling https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@jk_rowling https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@Eisenhorny @Angelica_Reed1 @jk_rowling https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@Angelica_Reed1 @jk_rowling https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@cyndiclaire1984 @SteveLovesAmmo https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@CraigRozniecki @CarlosV86651732 @elonmusk https://t.co/qkTSFGBxij https://t.co/oO0ZcmvU0g https://t.co/bjKR4glocD https://t.co/Tu19DsIClD https://t.co/nezFMIxBNM https://t.co/J2NHm2ZjMR
@shamanspirit13 @StellaOfSalem @mrslalique @BTB_Trade_Team @jamieelisefoto3 @zaelefty https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W This illustrates the problems faced when we ignore testimony from patients, or intervene surgically before they can tell us what sex they are. Or, if you like, what their gender identity is. Sex identity would be a better term, but we're stuck with it.
@GaslightPros @sharp_tonberry Uh no https://t.co/UycISj3Pqn
@berk_hamstead @GypsyDanger1013 @stephenwhittle Gender identity is a pretty big deal to intersex kids. Some of whom have been surgically altered to conform to what parents, pastors, or paediatricians prefer, regardless of their wishes. See for example https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W
@NewFifeRight14 @MForstater https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W The victims here would disagree with you.
@stilling_time @ConSelfOwns @RichardDawkins https://t.co/qVhsA638VZ
@HebbenNikolai https://t.co/IhuuloXNDw
@NeuroSGS This is essentially what was done in the 2006 study "Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth" [https://t.co/ROYXZZ0wRg]
@missdelein2 Frau @AglajaStirn "Es gibt keine durch wissenschaftliche Studien bewiesenen Hinweise auf angeborene Rollenbilder oder Identitäten als Frau oder Mann": kennen sie diese Studien: https://t.co/fvEHhB4vVg https://t.co/1y53Uyouft https://t.co/d9wM9NZzCD https://t.co/8PGBceoDTz
@maxima_8 @suboptimal79 @lawen4cer @ap_schulz @RotesSteinhaus @Dylynn7 @forn0ught @polphiloecon @Sub_Versia @wilderbeest @KockRowdy @vanneunern @Demistantana @FrauZora @mostranostra @ExBW @missdelein2 @schnabelkatz Was belegt denn aus deiner Sicht, dass sie soziologisch und kulturell geprägt sind? Ich würde dagegen diese Studien anführen: https://t.co/gpb5e4RHDO https://t.co/lACsTDswdu https://t.co/d9wM9NZzCD https://t.co/OfDe0hMiez https://t.co/rH7QiDmKKh https://t.co/1W0HMKT0g3
@SwipeWright @bhaktigardener1 1)This research points to immutable male imprinting of the developing brain by fetal gonadal hormones . Reiner, 2004,NEJM DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa022236 16 XX males with DSD (cloacal exstrophy) studied. 14 raised female. 8/14 detransed to male eventually; the knew they were males.
@JeremyShawMD @SwipeWright 1)This research points to immutable male imprinting of the developing brain by fetal gonadal hormones . Reiner, 2004,NEJM DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa022236 16 XX males with DSD (cloacal exstrophy) studied. 14 raised female. 8/14 detransed to male eventually; the knew they were males.
@ClayReith @hemantmehta NOBODY chooses their gender.
@maxo531 @IAmBadWolf717 @earthywater @elucinate @monsalore I refer you upthread to how XY children with cloacal exstrophy, when raised female, usually have male gender identity—they insist they’re male despite being raised female from birth. That’s evidence of gender identity. https://t.co/o9148pnerY
@IAmBadWolf717 @earthywater @elucinate @monsalore Here’s the original paper on children with cloacal exstrophy. If there were no innate gender identity, these children with XY chromosomes should identify as the gender they’re raised with, which is female. But they usually identify as male instead. https://t.co/o9148pnerY
@VeryBig_Brain @garylfrancione @lulusolomo86641 The boys in this study had a sex/gender identity. That's how they knew they were boys. Had they been raised as boys they may never have been aware of their sex/gender identity as many cis people aren't. Try read something other than anti-trans websites https://t.co/FlkxIEIzuT
@lulusolomo86641 @VeryBig_Brain @garylfrancione And yet there is strong published evidence for a metaphysical feeling of sex: https://t.co/FlkxIEIzuT The evidence for autogynephilia is weak and unfalsifiable, later studies have not supported Blanchard's two type model.
@HeadWarriorTWM https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W ": Eight of the 14 subjects assigned to female sex declared themselves male during the course of this study, whereas the 2 raised as males remained male." Gender identity exists.
@tiredgirl428 @hasbranscombe @Pollik @christapeterso Innate gender identity is proven to exist by intersex people, and cases like David Reimer. See for example https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W
@zaelefty https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W It depends not on genital appearance, but on neurology.
@ec0anarch0 @zaelefty Who? Those who assign sex to intersex kids. They mean well. They have a history of getting it wrong, so now they listen to the child and believe them when they say what sex they are. Otherwise it can all go horribly wrong. See for example https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W
@KnownHeretic @kenswift Example: https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W
@donttread_br @birdplnk @marcellomello83 @tesoureiros https://t.co/9GVygI4VtL
@marcellomello83 @birdplnk @tesoureiros https://t.co/9GVygI4VtL Fácil.
@Capucine_no @KatyMontgomerie @jk_rowling It's interesting. Maybe not a true hypothesis test, given what Katy is saying . . . https://t.co/apGtXbuyPs
@The_Canddyman @lgbtqnation https://t.co/3De3uiXT2Z
@FemmeLoves @KirstyStevo48 An intersex child who has been surgically "normalised" to look like one sex but insists that they are actually the other, despite being treated in all ways as the apparent one. That's the classic, easy to determine, case. See https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W
@ClarineJHall @papi_sierra @PennyRed @TPointUK https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W
https://t.co/0wSVZOMNzt
@Hakumigi @greg_price11 The lines of evidence include that children with XY chromosomes and cloacal exstrophy strongly tend to have male gender identity even when raised from birth as girls. https://t.co/o9148pnerY
@streetrcr986 @johnburk1776 @AriDrennen Transing of kids... the only time that happens is when Intersex kids get "normalised" . Around 1 in 3 ends up Gender Dysphoric. As here https://t.co/V2oHEiT0iY All the new anti trans laws specifically permit this.
RT @Hvedrungr5: @Ligmaba07939051 Nei. Kjønn er litt mer enn den forklaringa av gender, og også kjønnsidentitet later til å ha biologiske as…
@Ligmaba07939051 Nei. Kjønn er litt mer enn den forklaringa av gender, og også kjønnsidentitet later til å ha biologiske aspekter. https://t.co/Mz65ddWioj https://t.co/IxI549iyYv https://t.co/N2oc7dT4jG https://t.co/g8YnMPmXJa
@ibefuzz https://t.co/kKxeBslyXQ https://t.co/IFUDQotX2U https://t.co/gkp2m1qCEP https://t.co/uO71tfuJR1 Most people haven't heard of it. Neither had I until I stumbled upon it while researching the topic of gender. And I find it's very telling.
@wrenske @DreyfusJames @DanielAndrewsMP Being fair, also assigned female at birth were this group. https://t.co/V2oHEiT0iY
@Blckdmndskr @LeorSapir Example: https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W Yes, sex is assigned at birth, based on observations. The interpretation of those observations can vary. Not everything is know or obvious .
@ElecGillespie @TrumpsTaxes Nope. There are biological males born with female genitalia. https://t.co/oXT4wVoiII
@Purplewykr @tropdepieds @nicholasb44 @KatyMontgomerie That is *exactly* what happens with children born with ambiguous genitalia. Though usually they are assigned female because the conversion surgery is easier. 2/3 of the time they can live with it. 1/3 they become gender dysphoric. https://t.co/IaxseT8pyB
@SupremeLocust0 @lordeu3 https://t.co/nK6u9Xdtab https://t.co/DvXtE8kPUY https://t.co/W16tTVbzru
@JadderWilson @brunomarotodv5 @eixopolitico aqui alguns artigos de biólogos sérios explicando o assunto https://t.co/nK6u9Xdtab https://t.co/DvXtE8kPUY https://t.co/W16tTVbzru
@MiniskJr @EdersonBitenc @LtSilva123 @eixopolitico https://t.co/nK6u9Xdtab https://t.co/DvXtE8kPUY https://t.co/W16tTVbzru Duvido que vá ler, você parece ser mente fechada e arrogante a ponto de achar que sabe de tudo, mesmo só tendo o conhecimento básico sobre biologia Mas se uma hora quiser se tornar uma pessoa melhor, tá ai
@JadderWilson @brunomarotodv5 @eixopolitico não, a ciência comprova que sexo e gênero são coisas diferentes também comprova que ser trans é natural biólogos sérios apoiam a comunidade trans vou te passar uns artigos sobre https://t.co/nK6u9Xdtab https://t.co/DvXtE8kPUY https://t.co/W16tTVbzru
@renatadoochaves @eixopolitico https://t.co/nK6u9Xdtab https://t.co/DvXtE8kPUY https://t.co/W16tTVbzru
@PerceptivePlant @AidanCTweets There is no lack of identity. It can be pretty strong. It just may not match appearance at birth. See for example this attempt to "normalise" intersex infants. https://t.co/IaxseT7RJ3
@stormrobinson @RozKaveney @kaelairish https://t.co/V2oHEiT0iY Why? Assignment of a sex at birth happens to everyone. It can be a disaster if it's the wrong one, though that only happens to trans and intersex kids. Only the latter get surgery as infants.
@EmmaRincon Cf. Reiner, William G. y John P. Gearhart. "Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth", The New England Journal of Medicine, 2004, 350, no. 4, pp. 333-341. Mayer y McHugh. "Sexuality and Gender", p. 93.
@roseveniceallan Observed not assigned you say... https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W
@AnnHutc89625442 @leo_hih_ @Gerwyn247 "Assigners" have a very difficult job when it comes to intersex kids. They often get it wrong. Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth by Reiner and Gearhart, N Engl J Med. 2004 January 22; 350(4): 333–341.
@AFleetingImpre1 @Rjinswand @MYST_MX9 Contradicted is a strong word. It talked about a lot of types of intersex people and I was talking about a very specific type of intersex person. Here it is again the study I was originally referring to. https://t.co/fMyuKRRgxu
@AFleetingImpre1 @Rjinswand @MYST_MX9 Here is the study I was referring to originally, and the study doesn't have to mention these things to make its point. If you want the details of how many exactly had surgery or took puberty blockers/hormones you can check the references. https://t.co/fMyuKRRgxu
@Pixelcake2244rl @Pokukeki @Allinair @ShitpostGate https://t.co/kBoPbLLi47 https://t.co/DvXtE8kPUY https://t.co/JaPdEnefTv https://t.co/XP0zbIi1W8 https://t.co/s5tN4QQ5I3
@harlot_scara @SamJulieAnders @eaz__zee @RespectfulMemes Here, I got some papers for you both that disagree with https://t.co/kBoPbLLi47 https://t.co/DvXtE8kPUY https://t.co/SaViE2LQXg https://t.co/XP0zbIi1W8 https://t.co/s5tN4QQ5I3 Of course, I'll wait for a peer reviewed rebutal of them since you two are so knowledgeable
@Woodywing @thembo_coach @SpiderJ @runthinkwrite @Alisdisgrace @sharrond62 @cathydevine56 @FondOfBeetles @Scienceofsport @thebricksession https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W
@gypsyjackcooper @simonjedge So all humans are either male or female, never both, never neither, never one and then another? https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W
@whocares466 @catalystmic @Esqueer_ Er... sometimes they did. They had to. https://t.co/5OO1rEr48W
RT @VaryIngweion: [Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/h…
@electric_meat @MatlockJustyn @neilfaz @thomas_wall65 @lostfem80 @natachakennedy Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth by Reiner and Gearhart, N Engl J Med. 2004 January 22; 350(4): 333–341. Pediatricians have to do genital reconstruction on these kids. M or F? It matters.
RT @VaryIngweion: [Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/h…
Eight of the 14 subjects assigned to female sex declared themselves male during the course of this study Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth | NEJM https://t.co/5vGk7VhyDm
@HoppityR @sphericaltime @drnovocalcords @woke_guitarist @GregoryWhitta13 @MandoQ3R0 @EmilyBanting1 @QueenofNihilism @Talwynsilverha1 @Curious13512995 @Seb_81_ @KaAmInAa_ @ruprekt79 @luluchoochooX @ajlieshere @BleffyII @king_tuscan @h00pla434 @Paul62753492 @SparkMcarthur @mccavfefe @PomPomQuadSquad @arthurfaeleith @SlaggitySlag @bullrike @lecanardnoir @Seinneann @MelodyFenton4 @twitone @the_damn_muteKi @latsot @Spideythefifth @Gimpuslegend @MeToobirdy @Wifty8 @bitchylaughter @evanandpiesayhi @Megalodon_16 @WJClark4 @pinkichiban @TheNestSystem @nuffyknuckles @MValentine68 @RebeccaJones_03 @K08110054 @Aibagawa @ChrisLeePike @Maryboo10549677 @Blakey_Is_Back @CatladyBG Only citation was "Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth" How is that tangential to "The research and medical community now sees sex as more complex than male
Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth https://t.co/oAmWCKUm8q
Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth William G. Reiner, M.D., and John P. Gearhart, M.D. January 22, 2004 N Engl J Med 2004; 350:333-341 DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa022236 https://t.co/ooIsbYKYwF
RT @VaryIngweion: [Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/h…
RT @VaryIngweion: [Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/h…
@Joannie38616679 @Census2021 [3] https://t.co/mG2xnBIyg0 Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth Be VERY wary of TERFs and reactionaries online, they enjoy poising the well because it discredits trans people, i advise doing your own research
@IainKinnish @breezeinwood @zaelefty Reiner, W. G., & Gearhart, J. P. (2004). Discordant sexual identity in some genetic males with cloacal exstrophy assigned to female sex at birth. New England Journal of Medicine, 350(4), 333-341. DOI: 10.1056/NEJMoa022236 https://t.co/0fnr9jYmgx
@Lux_fae @Keir_Starmer @MarshadeCordova But I didn't say that did I? I said their sex (not gender) becomes obvious in that they were male all along with a medical condition. 'Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth' Clue is in the title 'genetic males'
RT @VaryIngweion: [Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/h…
RT @VaryIngweion: [Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/h…
@endikaaspe7 https://t.co/UaS1ckiEev https://t.co/ydjY78xe9p https://t.co/7OgYT1rvzK
@SinapsisHeisen Pueden tener pene y sigue siendo mujer ya que su mente es de una mujer, ya no hablo de "me siento" si no lo que me dice la neurología https://t.co/UaS1ck13mX
Fuentes transexualidad https://t.co/UaS1ck13mX https://t.co/ydjY78OPxZ https://t.co/7OgYT19UIc
Literal nadie dice eso... tiene que ver más por la neurología te paso unos paper para que entiendas, "no es sentir" es coloquialmente dicho tienen el cerebro de una mujer pero organos masculinos https://t.co/HoRb7IF58g Fuentes transexualidad https://t.co/UaS1ck13mX https://t.co/OID5Y86cy7
RT @VaryIngweion: [Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/h…
RT @VaryIngweion: [Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/h…
RT @VaryIngweion: [Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/h…
RT @VaryIngweion: [Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/h…
RT @VaryIngweion: [Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/h…
[Ref.1] https://t.co/O9W69lGYQw [Ref.2] https://t.co/QTmPyMs9OO [Ref.3] https://t.co/larVgEWFHr [Ref.4] https://t.co/hQG8cixpVA
Discordant sexual identity in some genetic males with cloacal exstrophy assigned to female sex at birth https://t.co/ocLMvs4sCs 2004 study
記事の３頁目の「総排泄腔外反症児」の手術についての評価があまりにもひどいと思います。確認して訂正していただけたらと思います。 こちらが、もともとの記事。結論をしっかり読んでください。 Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy https://t.co/CBp4ypjkMZ https://t.co/byOElW74uz
「Intersex Initiative Japan」代表 (or「インターセックス支援」に携わる者) がしていいような発言だったのでしょうか。 あなたは、実際にはただ「弱者探し」をしているだけみたいですね。 Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy Assigned to Female Sex at Birth https://t.co/e7WeagML77
Discordant sexual identity in some genetic males with cloacal exstrophy assigned to female sex at birth https://t.co/SwhIcH71aW 2004 study https://t.co/Wg1AP0vkRE
@tonton1965 @YahooNewsTopics 3 現在は既にご存じかもしれませんが、問題の「総排泄腔外反症児」に関する文献へのリンクを以下にはっておきます。 Discordant Sexual Identity in Some Genetic Males with Cloacal Exstrophy https://t.co/RNrsHRRUJE
VE
PA
L
CE
ZB
J
D
X
JM
P
SD
A
A
R
MG
O
S
MG
SC
DF
PD
G
JD
DE
GF
KE
A
ZB
A
G
RS
IS
E
AD
VV
BC
R
US
S
F
SS
MW
CD
S
DD
C
L
AM
NP
ÓP
A
DD
S