PubHawk
Arch Intern Med May 2009 PMID 19433697

A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain.

Daniel C Cherkin, Karen J Sherman, Andrew L Avins, Janet H Erro, Laura Ichikawa, William E Barlow, Kristin Delaney, Rene Hawkes, Luisa Hamilton, Alice Pressman, Partap S Khalsa, Richard A Deyo

Download social card

Mentions

71
Peak: 11 in Nov 2023
across 5 sources since Sep 2019

Extended reach

91,707
potential audience

Total likes

90

Video views

10,437

Mentions per month

Sep 2019 – Nov 2023

Where it's discussed

  • X / Twitter22 posts
  • Blogs21 articles
  • News15 articles
  • Facebook11 posts
  • YouTube2 videos

AI synopsis

What people are saying

This collection of discussions suggests a cautious and somewhat skeptical attitude toward the study, highlighted by comments on conflicts of interest and the use of simple tools like toothpicks for simulated acupuncture. The tone varies from critical to curious, reflecting mixed perceptions of the study's validity and significance.

AgreementNeither agree nor disagree

The discussions show mixed reactions, with some skepticism about the study's findings and others recognizing the ambiguous role of sham acupuncture, leading to a neutral overall stance.

InterestModerate interest

Participants display moderate interest, especially in the methodological aspects like the use of simulated acupuncture and conflicts of interest, but some dismiss the topic as inconclusive.

EngagementModerate engagement

Comments indicate a genuine curiosity, with references to specific details such as the use of a toothpick for simulated acupuncture, reflecting a level of in-depth discussion.

ImpactNeutral impact

While some participants express concern over biases and the influence of external interests, there is little indication that the study is perceived as having a groundbreaking impact on clinical practice.

Abstract in brief

  • The trial compared the effectiveness of real acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain, finding that both real and simulated acupuncture improved back function more than usual care at 8 weeks and after one year, though symptom relief was similar across groups.
  • Results suggest that the specific placement of needles and skin penetration may not be crucial for acupuncture’s benefits, raising questions about how acupuncture actually works.
  • Overall, acupuncture appears to provide some benefits for chronic back pain, but the mechanisms behind its effectiveness remain uncertain, especially since sham procedures seem to have similar short-term effects.]
Read the full abstract

Top posts

Most liked on X and Bluesky
Mark Gibson
@mgibsonphysio · X

Just had it pointed out to me the simulated acupuncture in this trial was a toothpick.

Sep 14, 2019 · 34 likes · 11 shares · 1,433 followers View post →
若林理砂
@asilliza · X

あ、これ面白い。「模擬挿入では、各ツボ周辺の皮膚を緊張させ、つまようじを入れた標準鍼管を皮膚にあてた。」←これで効いているのだ。 A Randomized Trial Comparing Acupuncture, Simulated Acupuncture, and Usual Care for Chronic Low Back Pain https://t.co/CFLzNx4iaA

May 1, 2022 · 4 likes · 17,254 followers View post →
Óscar{T} sci-phi
@Oscar_Teix · X

@LuceroMengano @KeynRto @girosus Varios estudios sobre su ineficacia: https://t.co/Q5mLRX86lY https://t.co/J45ZkY1IrO https://t.co/Ux8Riq9e2N Muchos estudios favorables a la acupuntura tienen conflictos de interés evidentes: https://t.co/hnhfNdIZEO Otros están retractados: https://t.co/QS72ebtwQE

Aug 17, 2023 · 2 likes · 8,432 followers View post →
ɹǝʇlnoԀ pıʌɐᗡ
@Retlouping · X

RT @mgibsonphysio: Just had it pointed out to me the simulated acupuncture in this trial was a toothpick.

Sep 15, 2019 · 11 shares · 26,406 followers View post →
EurekaMag
@EurekaMag · X

A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/CY5RWTKhe7 https://t.co/bh0pJhcq0e

Nov 10, 2023 · 6 shares · 6,527 followers View post →
EurekaMag
@EurekaMag · X

RT @EurekaMag: A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/CY5RW…

Nov 11, 2023 · 6 shares · 6,527 followers View post →

All mentions

EurekaMag
@EurekaMag · X

RT @EurekaMag: A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/CY5RW…

Nov 11, 2023 · 6 shares · 6,527 followers View post →
POPLINE
@POPLINE_org · X

RT @EurekaMag: A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/CY5RW…

Nov 10, 2023 · 6 shares · 5,182 followers View post →
GeoScience.net
@GeoSciences · X

RT @EurekaMag: A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/CY5RW…

Nov 10, 2023 · 6 shares · 401 followers View post →
amnatacharoen
@amnatacharoen · X

RT @EurekaMag: A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/CY5RW…

Nov 10, 2023 · 6 shares · 4 followers View post →
Science Alerts
@Science_Alerts · X

RT @EurekaMag: A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/CY5RW…

Nov 10, 2023 · 6 shares · 1,212 followers View post →
Scien.net
@Scien_net · X

RT @EurekaMag: A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/CY5RW…

Nov 10, 2023 · 6 shares · 65 followers View post →
POPLINE
@POPLINE_org · X

RT @songdaon: A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/BQjwVn…

Nov 10, 2023 · 3 shares · 5,182 followers View post →
Science Alerts
@Science_Alerts · X

RT @songdaon: A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/BQjwVn…

Nov 10, 2023 · 3 shares · 1,212 followers View post →
Scien.net
@Scien_net · X

RT @songdaon: A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/BQjwVn…

Nov 10, 2023 · 3 shares · 65 followers View post →
songdaon
@songdaon · X

A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/BQjwVnbzLf https://t.co/tRG6g3pHT8

Nov 10, 2023 · 3 shares · 19 followers View post →
EurekaMag
@EurekaMag · X

A randomized trial comparing acupuncture, simulated acupuncture, and usual care for chronic low back pain https://t.co/CY5RWTKhe7 https://t.co/bh0pJhcq0e

Nov 10, 2023 · 6 shares · 6,527 followers View post →
Óscar{T} sci-phi
@Oscar_Teix · X

@LuceroMengano @KeynRto @girosus Varios estudios sobre su ineficacia: https://t.co/Q5mLRX86lY https://t.co/J45ZkY1IrO https://t.co/Ux8Riq9e2N Muchos estudios favorables a la acupuntura tienen conflictos de interés evidentes: https://t.co/hnhfNdIZEO Otros están retractados: https://t.co/QS72ebtwQE

Aug 17, 2023 · 2 likes · 8,432 followers View post →
Dr. Dion M. Blackmon
@jaguarintegra · X

A Randomized Trial Comparing Acupuncture, Simulated Acupuncture, and Usual Care for Chronic Low Back Pain https://t.co/ze1X7vsBgr

Jun 30, 2023 · 35 followers View post →
若林理砂
@asilliza · X

あ、これ面白い。「模擬挿入では、各ツボ周辺の皮膚を緊張させ、つまようじを入れた標準鍼管を皮膚にあてた。」←これで効いているのだ。 A Randomized Trial Comparing Acupuncture, Simulated Acupuncture, and Usual Care for Chronic Low Back Pain https://t.co/CFLzNx4iaA

May 1, 2022 · 4 likes · 17,254 followers View post →
Dan Dettman, PT, DPT
@DanDettman · X

RT @mgibsonphysio: Just had it pointed out to me the simulated acupuncture in this trial was a toothpick.

Sep 16, 2019 · 11 shares · 163 followers View post →
West 12 Health
@West12Health · X

RT @mgibsonphysio: Just had it pointed out to me the simulated acupuncture in this trial was a toothpick.

Sep 16, 2019 · 11 shares · 130 followers View post →
Daniel Godeassi
@dangodeassi · X

RT @mgibsonphysio: Just had it pointed out to me the simulated acupuncture in this trial was a toothpick.

Sep 15, 2019 · 11 shares · 202 followers View post →
Colm Davis
@ColmDavis1 · X

RT @mgibsonphysio: Just had it pointed out to me the simulated acupuncture in this trial was a toothpick.

Sep 15, 2019 · 11 shares · 58 followers View post →
craig elliott
@craigdocelliott · X

RT @mgibsonphysio: Just had it pointed out to me the simulated acupuncture in this trial was a toothpick.

Sep 15, 2019 · 11 shares · 156 followers View post →
ɹǝʇlnoԀ pıʌɐᗡ
@Retlouping · X

RT @mgibsonphysio: Just had it pointed out to me the simulated acupuncture in this trial was a toothpick.

Sep 15, 2019 · 11 shares · 26,406 followers View post →
Prateek Vinduwa
@BrainBodyRehab · X

RT @mgibsonphysio: Just had it pointed out to me the simulated acupuncture in this trial was a toothpick.

Sep 15, 2019 · 11 shares · 321 followers View post →
Mark Gibson
@mgibsonphysio · X

Just had it pointed out to me the simulated acupuncture in this trial was a toothpick.

Sep 14, 2019 · 34 likes · 11 shares · 1,433 followers View post →