Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood: a pilot randomized controlled trial - PubMed Be good to see this type of study done over a longer period. https://t.co/9EF9DKvNGT
Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood: a pilot randomized controlled trial.
Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
Mentions per month
Jun 2016 – Jun 2024Where it's discussed
-
Facebook90 posts
-
X / Twitter48 posts
-
News24 articles
-
Blogs9 articles
-
YouTube4 videos
-
Reddit2 posts
AI synopsis
What people are saying
The discussions mainly revolve around the article's findings that restricting meat can enhance mood, supported by references to specific studies and data, with some users emphasizing the importance of RCTs and meta-analyses. The tone varies from supportive to skeptical, with language highlighting the potential impact on mental health and diet choices, illustrating a high level of interest and moderate engagement.
Most discussions support the idea that reducing meat intake can improve mental health, citing both experimental studies and observational data.
Users show high curiosity and focus on the research, referencing specific trials and meta-analyses, indicating strong engagement with the topic.
Some participants reference the methodology, such as the pilot RCT, and compare it to other forms of evidence, demonstrating thoughtful engagement but not overly detailed discussion.
The discussions suggest the article could influence opinions on diet and mental health, although some dismissive comments indicate mixed perceived significance.
Top posts
Most liked on X and Bluesky@drdairy50 @SherylHendriks @FAOScienceChief @TyRBeal @vanvlietphd @fleroy1974 @kevinnbass It's not surprising because people who eat meat seem to not care about the harm they're causing, but there's also this: https://t.co/YcYP0x8KRb
Estudio donde la restricción de carne, pescado y aves de corral mejora estado de ánimo a corto plazo https://t.co/ylwZ9gKmml
@skinny_keto @theveganparent @imromains @xeyedmess @RossWenk @Scottyhile @ed_flava @InternalMentalC @zanya_x @itsokdadsgotit @Edival @Steve08859630 @your_vegan @VeganRedemption @Cynwel73 @elizedge2 @sansbuIIcrap @Af_donnerwetter @Charlotte_0499 @Wildrosebeef @1AVintageAffair @tofukkers @TriNutrition @partysausageuk @est_sep2018 @IronLindaJ @Dave06031956 @jadeo09 @LentilDestroyer @SGT_Stampede @fightitnow @vegansince96 @kentman43 @CelticCarnivore @oregontinker11 @fatboybeastmode @cpet27054480 @meattherapy @furyu_me @Femivegana @TheStoppedClock @KetoMojoGogo @Drakgun66 @copper_teal @SecretDevose @optxtop @VeganRoo @EdgarB_Friendly @hilltopgina @StickmanBleedin Regards your above ad hominem mental health issue this may help: "Omnivorous diets are high in arachidonic acid (AA) ... high intakes of AA promote changes in brain that can disturb mood… omnivores reported significantly worse mood t
And another: https://t.co/ghCEBlm1Il
@chest_mop Silti vähemmän vihaisia! https://t.co/VRWy5EP8Kh
All mentions
Impact of Dietary Protein on Mental Health and Mortality Risk
This video examines the relationship between dietary protein sources and mental health, specifically addressing claims that meat improves mental health. We analyze a controversial study that links vegetarians and vegans…
Debunking Misconceptions About Vegan Diets and Mental Health Evidence
Recent claims about vegan diets suggest potential negative impacts on mental health, but this video addresses major inaccuracies. We critically analyze the relationship between these diets and depression, providing…
Impact of Vegan Diet on Mental Health: Depression and Anxiety Risks
In this video, we explore a review highlighting that vegans are at a greater risk of depression and anxiety, showing poorer psychological health compared to meat-eaters. The analysis of studies indicates that while some…
Enhancing Mood Through Dietary Choices
Is it really possible to improve your mood by eating more of certain foods? Research indicates that dietary changes, such as reducing meat, fish, and poultry, can positively affect mood. This video explores how food…
@ErnestLancaste7 @LauraDelano @wjwmhlf While getting off the SAD is so beneficial that vitamin-soaked cardboard is better, study after study shows that increasing plant-based foods improve mental health. https://t.co/fEdCNLMY8h https://t.co/hp3TVu9KFN https://t.co/0w7NBv3kFu https://t.co/0w7NBv3kFu
@sibaburck @Strider76258818 That's why interventional studies always show benefits on mental health of not eating meat This one for instance https://t.co/THCj0fYu5F
@AnaL39753296 Manger mieux https://t.co/YwxsgSbxZV + faire du sport
@GannStyle @laviefoods_fr C'est complètement faux rien que sur la dépression, l'acide arachidonique augmente les neuro inflammations (le lithium agit dessus d'ailleurs) https://t.co/THCj0fYu5F
@minijig1 @SBakerMD @drawandstrike https://t.co/THCj0fYu5F
@Jaydee_Old_Boy @RobertS05624254 @PlantBasedNews Interventional studies show the benefits of eating less meat. There is also this RCT: https://t.co/THCj0fYu5F There is no RCT or intervention studies showing the benefits of eating more meat or eggs A plant based diet also improve microbiome and inflammation
@Lateralthinka75 @jnsalema @jester48602 @JohnVerley97 @SBakerMD https://t.co/ogIYVaAnNd
@MiKkoC64 @MaiKivela Itsekin voin kirjoittaa noin ja täysin päinvastoin. Tutkimustieto ei tosin tue alakuloisuutta. Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood: A pilot randomized controlled trial https://t.co/VRWy5EP8Kh
@CrohnsCarnivore @SteAssent We do have higher forms of data. There is a meta analysis on this topic. Only semi vegetarians had a higher risk of depression. Vegans did not have a higher risk of depression. There is also an RCT and it shows reduction of meat improved mood lol. https://t.co/I8rF18vjF8 https://t.co/fenr7AwtGQ
@conservative559 @RebelMoons_ @realMeetJames @nutrition_facts There are tons of observational studies that say that omnivorous are more depressed than plant based eaters or the contrary. But on randomized control trials, the plant based always win. https://t.co/YwxsgSbxZV the placebo effect should make them feel worse, but they felt better
@SaulNutri Este es el ganador... Ensayo controlado aleatorio de como la reducción de carnes y pescados mejoran el "estado anímico" en omnívoros. Esto es evidencia! https://t.co/BjkdtdlI1l
@emiliogarbar @suckmyeye1 https://t.co/E2Jh6gjb3T
@HartiaSimo @matti_saarni @sryhma Sulla on vaan noita subjektiivisia iltahömppölinkkejä jossa joku on epäonnistunut.. Tästä parempaa luettavaa. Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood: A pilot randomized controlled trial https://t.co/VRWy5EPGzP
@herbivore_club A worksite vegan nutrition program is well-accepted and improves health-related quality of life and work productivity. https://t.co/74LlvRGp38 Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood: a pilot randomized controlled trial. https://t.co/0j6WsZIBGF
RT @BTGDearlyLoved: @bluemoonSM_ Eating meat can lead to negative emotions. https://t.co/QQ9upZMFwt
@bluemoonSM_ Eating meat can lead to negative emotions. https://t.co/QQ9upZMFwt
@DrMcFillin https://t.co/RLWN65SJNx
@GTRules314 @ShrekBane @RebelsAnimal This is not true. https://t.co/VRWy5EP8Kh
https://t.co/vEIfAYX5Ol https://t.co/TcDp1UJQcq
https://t.co/vEIfAYFupL https://t.co/5ycAWj63Ry
Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood: A pilot randomized controlled trial | Nutrition Journal | Full Text https://t.co/RL3l5yS12z
@AuneDagfinn @kevinnbass @ScepticalDoctor Short but at least an RCT https://t.co/9EF9DKvNGT
@drdairy50 @SherylHendriks @FAOScienceChief @TyRBeal @vanvlietphd @fleroy1974 @kevinnbass It's not surprising because people who eat meat seem to not care about the harm they're causing, but there's also this: https://t.co/YcYP0x8KRb
@Skeptoidius @FITrebelde @NutriRebel De hecho, te voy a dejar algunos de lo artículos que citan para que lo compruebes https://t.co/5hc3mUjxDB https://t.co/atd4AWjOOq https://t.co/30OM1yOAE4 https://t.co/dtJFmK6tb0 https://t.co/qdEYISdMUS https://t.co/BGNtzDSe3j https://t.co/7mUrpYRdV1 https://t.co/kuipXKC3Qm
@mayrocksaul @ArtKaisa @LeoStranius Ehkäpä tarvitset apua mielenterveysongelmiisi ja agressioosi? https://t.co/VRWy5EP8Kh
Tell all the grumpy omnivores: "Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood: a pilot randomized controlled trial" https://t.co/YcYP0xqlIJ
RT @Plant_proof: Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood: a pilot randomized controlled trial - PubMed Be good t…
RT @Plant_proof: Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood: a pilot randomized controlled trial - PubMed Be good t…
Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood: a pilot randomized controlled trial - PubMed Be good to see this type of study done over a longer period. https://t.co/9EF9DKvNGT
To be clearer, in this RCT mentioned two tweets above, a vegetarian diet appeared to improve several mood scores, while neither a pescatarian diet nor an omnivorous diet containing other meats appeared to be similarly effective: https://t.co/umDvyKRZHE
Estudio donde la restricción de carne, pescado y aves de corral mejora estado de ánimo a corto plazo https://t.co/ylwZ9gKmml
@HenriLindroos @lauri_linden Lisäksi https://t.co/VRWy5EP8Kh
@nopenopenanna @leonakoo Tämäkin on häneltä virheellinen väite https://t.co/VRWy5EP8Kh
RT @drmatthewnagra: @Jevan @KetoCarnivore @MattMadore576 @ScepticalDoctor @TheBhupiThakur @Alecsplaining @ZacharyWenger @jerryteixeira @Tre…
In this RCT, a vegetarian diet, but not a pescatarian diet, significantly improved several mood scores: https://t.co/umDvyKRZHE
@Jevan @KetoCarnivore @MattMadore576 @ScepticalDoctor @TheBhupiThakur @Alecsplaining @ZacharyWenger @jerryteixeira @TrejbalChris @jonnettlefold @AmandaZZ100 @SBakerMD @cambridge_pt Not a meta (another typo? lol). Regardless, you should read the totality of RCTs. https://t.co/YX9fdkz3Uy https://t.co/VTrzw18CR9 https://t.co/wRv0xFPKX5
@MaiKivela https://t.co/VRWy5ExxlH
@chest_mop Silti vähemmän vihaisia! https://t.co/VRWy5EP8Kh
@DavidClothier5 @standardnews @ChrisGPackham There is some evidence to suggest that reducing animal product consumption results in better mental health (e.g. https://t.co/gLu3o8T1r6), perhaps because of many lifespan-shortening compounds found therin.
And another: https://t.co/ghCEBlm1Il
@KemMinnick @Tweets4Vegans https://t.co/F4XdzKBHJv
@KimJonguN9836 @herbivore_club https://t.co/VRWy5EP8Kh
@alemora222 @VEnfadada @FridaSiKahlo @gamendezlabbe He aquí el estudio del que se habla en la captura: https://t.co/9f4YrgF9If https://t.co/gEVw1eGQm2
RT @eatingourfuture: @skinny_keto @theveganparent @imromains @xeyedmess @RossWenk @Scottyhile @ed_flava @InternalMentalC @zanya_x @itsokdad…
@skinny_keto @theveganparent @imromains @xeyedmess @RossWenk @Scottyhile @ed_flava @InternalMentalC @zanya_x @itsokdadsgotit @Edival @Steve08859630 @your_vegan @VeganRedemption @Cynwel73 @elizedge2 @sansbuIIcrap @Af_donnerwetter @Charlotte_0499 @Wildrosebeef @1AVintageAffair @tofukkers @TriNutrition @partysausageuk @est_sep2018 @IronLindaJ @Dave06031956 @jadeo09 @LentilDestroyer @SGT_Stampede @fightitnow @vegansince96 @kentman43 @CelticCarnivore @oregontinker11 @fatboybeastmode @cpet27054480 @meattherapy @furyu_me @Femivegana @TheStoppedClock @KetoMojoGogo @Drakgun66 @copper_teal @SecretDevose @optxtop @VeganRoo @EdgarB_Friendly @hilltopgina @StickmanBleedin Regards your above ad hominem mental health issue this may help: "Omnivorous diets are high in arachidonic acid (AA) ... high intakes of AA promote changes in brain that can disturb mood… omnivores reported significantly worse mood t
@clairegcoleman @imromains @paigebethers re: "veganism is jpknown [sic] to cause mental health problems" please provide a scientific source to back that up. Meanwhile this may help to explain why some omnis are so cranky about other people (like vegans) doing positive things for the world https://t.co/59CKhoJbP1 https://t.co/6SPiSJdCWZ
@KemMinnick @itsjillgardner @theveganparent Nutrition Journal: “Omnivorous diets are high in arachidonic acid (AA) compared to vegetarian diets. Research shows that high intakes of AA promote changes in brain that can disturb mood… omnivores reported significantly worse mood than vegetarians ..." https://t.co/59CKhoJbP1
@GeorgiaEdeMD @globeandmail @hbelfry Regarding Plant based diets: B L Beezhold, C S Johnston. Restriction of meat, fish, and poultry in omnivores improves mood: a pilot randomized controlled trial. Nutr J. 2012 Feb 14;11:9. So junk food maybe, but I'd blame societal stress and increased alienation.