Across the discussions, many posts adopt a critical tone, debating the true efficacy of influenza drugs like Tamiflu, exemplified by mentions of limited symptom reduction and possible fraudulent practices by drug companies. Words like 'crap', 'stolen', and references to regulatory scrutiny highlight skepticism, whereas references to scientific reviews like Cochrane reviews demonstrate engagement with evidence-based evaluations.
AgreementLow agreement
Most discussions criticize the effectiveness of neuraminidase inhibitors like Tamiflu, citing reviews and meta-analyses that challenge their clinical value.
InterestModerate interest
People show some interest, especially in the scientific evidence, but many posts express skepticism or dismissiveness rather than deep curiosity.
EngagementModerate engagement
Several comments reference systematic reviews, Cochrane analyses, and regulatory reports, indicating active engagement with research findings.
ImpactLow impact
The discussions suggest these social discussions could influence perceptions about prescribing practices and drug policy, but overall impact is limited by skepticism and disagreement.
Abstract in brief
This review examines the benefits and harms of neuraminidase inhibitors like zanamivir and oseltamivir for preventing and treating influenza across all age groups by analyzing both published and unpublished clinical trial data from manufacturers and regulators.
The researchers searched multiple databases and regulatory archives up to July 2013, collected clinical study reports, and assessed the quality and bias of the trials, focusing on their effects on symptom relief, complications, hospitalizations, and adverse events, with all trials sponsored by the drug manufacturers.
They obtained a total of 107 reports, included 53 trials for initial study design evaluation, and 46 for detailed analysis, with 20 focusing specifically on oseltamivir, to provide comprehensive insight into the effectiveness and safety of these drugs in influenza management.]
Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Tamiflu is pretty worthless https://t.co/Rk55Ot8y9I. We should boycott products from Roche and governments should sue Roche https://t.co/BdbhuVx0Kn
Jun 27, 2023 · 178 likes · 71 shares · 36,859 followersView post →
CJ
Champagne Joshi
@JoshWalkos · X
Tamiflu “Pandemic Prevention” Fraud
Claim: Stockpiled globally as an essential antiviral, based on glowing trial data.
Reality: Roche withheld negative data; efficacy overstated, side effects underplayed.
https://t.co/ZZbmBKcC4m https://t.co/drMYIFR3qw
Dec 1, 2022 · 28 likes · 2 shares · 36,764 followersView post →
NM
Nick Mark MD
@nickmmark · X
@pulmtoilet @DrEricDing @DavidJoffe64 Neuraminidase inhibitors may work. In the past they had modest to minimal effect on symptoms & didn’t reduce mortality.
https://t.co/rELTA9fv5d
https://t.co/YZrBSRRGsq
My issues is with a non-HCP giving medical advice, especially advice to lie to “stockpile” prescription meds.
Jun 8, 2024 · 11 likes · 2 shares · 66,051 followersView post →
SM
Sebastián González-Dambrauskas, MD
@sgdambrauskas · X
Is Tamiflu a giant Medical Reversal?
Flu season down here and everybody prescribing again this useless medication
@VPrasadMDMPH
https://t.co/yAXzGTOyvI
Jun 9, 2023 · 11 likes · 5 shares · 7,682 followersView post →
M
MiyuMotohashi
@MiyuMotohashi · X
コロナのゾコーバ(有症状期間を8日間を7日間に出来るらしい)と大して変わらん。
製薬会社のプロモーションバイアスがかかってこれって事は実質ほとんど効果無しだと思われる。
Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children https://t.co/JVvVGlWi58
Jan 10, 2025 · 10 likes · 1 share · 14,066 followersView post →
This review examines the benefits and harms of neuraminidase inhibitors like zanamivir and oseltamivir for preventing and treating influenza across all age groups by analyzing clinical trial data for effectiveness and…
This video discusses publication bias in clinical research, its clinical and ethical implications, and highlights findings from a Cochrane review on neuraminidase inhibitors like Tamiflu, emphasizing the importance of…
@JeromeAdamsMD @Ny3Resident Tamiflu actually works a lot better as prophylaxis than treatment (virtually useless). But the side effect profile likely limits it to high risk (nursing home, immunocompromised etc.)
https://t.co/J4JineROxa
RT @MiyuMotohashi: コロナのゾコーバ(有症状期間を8日間を7日間に出来るらしい)と大して変わらん。
製薬会社のプロモーションバイアスがかかってこれって事は実質ほとんど効果無しだと思われる。
Neuraminidase inhibitors for preve…
Jan 14, 2025 · 1 share · 1,033 followersView post →
M
MiyuMotohashi
@MiyuMotohashi · X
コロナのゾコーバ(有症状期間を8日間を7日間に出来るらしい)と大して変わらん。
製薬会社のプロモーションバイアスがかかってこれって事は実質ほとんど効果無しだと思われる。
Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children https://t.co/JVvVGlWi58
Jan 10, 2025 · 10 likes · 1 share · 14,066 followersView post →
RT @nickmmark: @pulmtoilet @DrEricDing @DavidJoffe64 Neuraminidase inhibitors may work. In the past they had modest to minimal effect on sy…
Jun 8, 2024 · 2 shares · 66,051 followersView post →
NM
Nick Mark MD
@nickmmark · X
@pulmtoilet @DrEricDing @DavidJoffe64 Neuraminidase inhibitors may work. In the past they had modest to minimal effect on symptoms & didn’t reduce mortality.
https://t.co/rELTA9fv5d
https://t.co/YZrBSRRGsq
My issues is with a non-HCP giving medical advice, especially advice to lie to “stockpile” prescription meds.
Jun 8, 2024 · 11 likes · 2 shares · 66,051 followersView post →
@dick_nalton @UKHSA @ClareCraigPath @CartlandDavid They’re recommending Oseltamivir? Might be worth reading the Cochrane review before following that bit of advice.
https://t.co/TzNwT6gFQ3
Since pretty much everyone in Texas has the flu, here’s your reminder the best use of Tamiflu is prophylaxis, because as a treatment it’s got more side effects than helpful effects.
https://t.co/cAXlwpaqT0
Jan 24, 2024 · 3 likes · 12,878 followersView post →
JD
Josh Davis
@MedFactChecks · X
@Jhayesfnp @chungk1031 Here’s how a high quality SR is done, albeit older:
https://t.co/cqtx5i8Krt
And another better one on hospitalizations:
https://t.co/otbyDV7AQx
Dec 18, 2023 · 1 like · 1 share · 7,851 followersView post →
MB
Matthew Blackburn
@RigMatthew · X
RT @kerpen: @KelleyKga @VPrasadMDMPH @TracyBethHoeg Tamiflu reduces duration of flu symptoms by about a day, with trade-off of nausea and v…
Dec 6, 2023 · 1 share · 1,631 followersView post →
PK
Phil Kerpen
@kerpen · X
@KelleyKga @VPrasadMDMPH @TracyBethHoeg Tamiflu reduces duration of flu symptoms by about a day, with trade-off of nausea and vomiting. Not exactly a slam dunk but OK. https://t.co/S5u5AzcPOS
Dec 6, 2023 · 7 likes · 1 share · 127,061 followersView post →
I
Izar
@IzarZG · X
RT @JuanGrvas: El mito del Tamiflú.
https://t.co/jW2OSTgnCq
https://t.co/0yVKIUEH58
Oseltamivir (Tamiflu). No clinical value.
El Tamiflú,…
El mito del Tamiflú.
https://t.co/jW2OSTgnCq
https://t.co/0yVKIUEH58
Oseltamivir (Tamiflu). No clinical value.
El Tamiflú, una estafa
https://t.co/HOYVZHRVn1
USA. Kids with flu often don't get antiviral drugs.
En buena lógica no lo usan en niños en EEUU.
https://t.co/skk2DMhHan
Nov 16, 2023 · 1 share · 22,496 followersView post →
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 376 followersView post →
J
JN
@J_Miguelinho · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 858 followersView post →
SP
STEF . P
@POISSENOT · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 1,609 followersView post →
C
CocotteMinute12
@CocotteMinute12 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 1,726 followersView post →
HB
Hélène Banoun
@BanounHelene · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 84,515 followersView post →
V
Vivaldi
@Vivaldi64381144 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 405 followersView post →
CY
C.Young
@Beenbane6 · X
RT @Etienne_Chouard: @PGtzsche1 : «TAMIFLU pour la grippe=le plus gros VOL de l'histoire https://t.co/N3YXGxYsvw
Les DÉCLARATIONS FRAUDULE…
Jun 27, 2023 · 4 shares · 208 followersView post →
CY
C.Young
@Beenbane6 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 208 followersView post →
E
emavritsaki
@efimavritsaki · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 136 followersView post →
MB
Make Life Better
@MarcjannaGiedr1 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 36 followersView post →
LB
Luc Bonneux
@LBonneux · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 8,050 followersView post →
JG
Jim Gottstein
@jimgottstein · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 1,178 followersView post →
A
☮️ Alta
@semantic_cat · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 883 followersView post →
じ
じょーさんこっさん
@josan_cosan · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 68 followersView post →
OD
Osmo_Demonei
@Osmo_Demonei · X
RT @Etienne_Chouard: @PGtzsche1 : «TAMIFLU pour la grippe=le plus gros VOL de l'histoire https://t.co/N3YXGxYsvw
Les DÉCLARATIONS FRAUDULE…
Jun 27, 2023 · 4 shares · 1,996 followersView post →
AS
Al Soto
@AlSoto9 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 693 followersView post →
J
JPG
@bjergglad · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 170 followersView post →
P
PatrickRovit
@RovitPatrick2 · X
RT @Etienne_Chouard: @PGtzsche1 : «TAMIFLU pour la grippe=le plus gros VOL de l'histoire https://t.co/N3YXGxYsvw
Les DÉCLARATIONS FRAUDULE…
Jun 27, 2023 · 4 shares · 471 followersView post →
E
Ed
@eml229 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 434 followersView post →
ÉC
Étienne Chouard
@Etienne_Chouard · X
@PGtzsche1 : «TAMIFLU pour la grippe=le plus gros VOL de l'histoire https://t.co/N3YXGxYsvw
Les DÉCLARATIONS FRAUDULEUSES DE ROCHE ont été crues. Le Tamiflu ne vaut rien https://t.co/Zk5bf2V6iK
Nous devrions boycotter les prod. de Roche et les gouvts devraient poursuivre Roche.» https://t.co/VenVY1eoV4
Jun 27, 2023 · 1 like · 4 shares · 132,712 followersView post →
RS
+Recortes Salvajes
@Hospital_ET · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 1,601 followersView post →
DP
Davide La Palice
@DavidexEudaimon · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 216 followersView post →
SY
seki_yo
@seki_yo · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 1,367 followersView post →
E
Emilio
@Geronto84 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 15 followersView post →
TE
The Equalizer
@the_equalizerx · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 62 followersView post →
L
LizzeFC
@lizedomar · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 1,374 followersView post →
J
Jem
@mc_cabe3 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 369 followersView post →
ア
アキ
@tGltltFQB0Jis9P · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 2,707 followersView post →
DK
Dr Tim Kelly
@DrTimothyKelly · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 9,762 followersView post →
UO
Universal Octopus
@unioctopus · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 942 followersView post →
S
Superkalifragilistin
@superkalifragi4 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 883 followersView post →
Aઠ
Anil જેઠવા
@BritAsianinJap · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 623 followersView post →
VK
Varanus komodoensis
@Varanuskomodoe4 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 649 followersView post →
C
Chris
@PlausiblDenial · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 2,914 followersView post →
ジ
ジュン
@kokun20torami · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 1,518 followersView post →
内
内科医の端くれ
@naika_hashikure · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 67,075 followersView post →
B
bbddpp
@bbddpp · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 3,152 followersView post →
SR
Sune Ravn
@SuneRavn · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 120 followersView post →
U
usotsukibakari
@usotsukibakari2 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 1,334 followersView post →
M
MCS
@MedComServices · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 508 followersView post →
AM
Anja M
@AnjaMalmstr · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 723 followersView post →
EM
Erik Magnethi
@ErikMagnethi · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 5,122 followersView post →
OD
Osmo_Demonei
@Osmo_Demonei · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 1,996 followersView post →
SK
Steve K
@SteveKe61657969 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 865 followersView post →
FE
Federico Eghel
@eghel_federico · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 469 followersView post →
星
星屑
@Gfullofstars · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 12,372 followersView post →
PD
Pani z dziekanatu
@Beata01373973 · X
Tamiflu na grypę , największa kradzież w historii https://t.co/8BHEhIhNqx . Uwierzono w oszukańcze oświadczenia firmy Roche. Tamiflu jest całkiem bezwartościowy https://t.co/S0sJ1zt5uY . Powinniśmy bojkotować produkty Roche, a rządy powinny pozwać Roche https://t.co/Q4wsIWATy2
Jun 27, 2023 · 3 likes · 2,198 followersView post →
C
Carmelo
@carmelprzrz · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 451 followersView post →
CC
Chen Cihong
@CCihong · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 59 followersView post →
PP
Please_Stop_The _propaganda
@themuddytrutht · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 763 followersView post →
A
Astrid
@Astriddex · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 204 followersView post →
BB
Brian Brown
@BrianBrownFoot · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 45 followersView post →
MM
Michael Mortensen
@M_Mortensen · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 173 followersView post →
SC
Ssri fraud - you were cheated
@HuijausSsri · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 51 followersView post →
F
FiebiePup⏳
@fiebiePup · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 1,368 followersView post →
CL
Chuanfang Lee
@ChuanfangLee · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 278 followersView post →
KM
Khurram Malik
@Khurrammalik200 · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 371 followersView post →
JQ
Jose Luis Quintana
@JoseLuisQ · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 2,870 followersView post →
P
PatroninJohanna
@PatroninJohanna · X
RT @PGtzsche1: Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Ta…
Jun 27, 2023 · 71 shares · 184 followersView post →
PG
Prof. Peter C Gøtzsche
@PGtzsche1 · X
Tamiflu for influenza, the biggest theft in history https://t.co/SSeS3fV4ap. Roche’s fraudulent statements were believed. Tamiflu is pretty worthless https://t.co/Rk55Ot8y9I. We should boycott products from Roche and governments should sue Roche https://t.co/BdbhuVx0Kn
Jun 27, 2023 · 178 likes · 71 shares · 36,859 followersView post →
KL
Kurt Lass
@KurtLass1 · X
@ID_ethics This is of course not news. Tamiflu has been known to have very low efficacy and significant adverse effects of vomiting and nausea for over 9 years. @AdamUrato1
https://t.co/iGnYjnA2e3
Is Tamiflu a giant Medical Reversal?
Flu season down here and everybody prescribing again this useless medication
@VPrasadMDMPH
https://t.co/yAXzGTOyvI
Jun 9, 2023 · 11 likes · 5 shares · 7,682 followersView post →
PG
Parteira Feminista Cansada de Guerra
@NormalBirthBRAZ · X
@markumei @CoronaHeadsUp The latest updated Cochrane Review is based on full internal reports of 20 Tamiflu trials.
https://t.co/bSrvcjSZ1R
See also:
Oseltamivir for influenza in adults and children: systematic review of clinical study reports and summary of regulatory comments
https://t.co/aNsGacFInJ
May 27, 2023 · 1 like · 2,460 followersView post →
B
busneko
@busnek0 · X
@junmurot Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children - Jefferson, T - 2014 | Cochrane Library
成人および小児におけるインフルエンザの予防および治療のためのノイラミニダーゼ阻害剤
https://t.co/q53lUFBXnF
@furusatochan Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children - Jefferson, T - 2014 | Cochrane Library
成人および小児におけるインフルエンザの予防および治療のためのノイラミニダーゼ阻害剤
https://t.co/VOEWgZ955J
@Oyasumiyanyan Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children
成人および小児におけるインフルエンザの予防および治療のためのノイラミニダーゼ阻害剤
https://t.co/VOEWgZ955J
@MiyuMotohashi @giraffe19491 Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children
ノイラミニダーゼ阻害剤
成人および小児におけるインフルエンザの予防と治療
https://t.co/q53lUFBXnF
@runrunrunnekony Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children
成人および小児におけるインフルエンザの予防および治療のためのノイラミニダーゼ阻害剤
https://t.co/q53lUFBXnF
@8hkAhtTlNCJe83G Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children
成人および小児におけるインフルエンザの予防および治療のためのノイラミニダーゼ阻害剤
https://t.co/VOEWgZ955J
@kuu331108 Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children
成人および小児におけるインフルエンザの予防および治療のためのノイラミニダーゼ阻害剤
https://t.co/q53lUFBXnF
@STansuke Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children
ノイラミニダーゼ阻害剤
成人および小児におけるインフルエンザの予防と治療
https://t.co/q53lUFBXnF
Jan 6, 2023 · 3 likes · 1 share · 726 followersView post →
JL
James Lynch
@JamesLynchGTC · X
@Richbink @logosaetos Despite its limitations, oseltamivir remains an effective treatment for influenza.
https://t.co/iQnksZn1ZW
https://t.co/ZKvxMKr1rm
Dec 1, 2022 · 28 likes · 2 shares · 36,764 followersView post →
G
GalindoDoc
@GalindoDoc · X
Un claro ejemplo de esto es el Oseltamivir, ampliamente usado para tratar influenza... la última revision sistemática comprobó que solo reduce los sintomas de 7 a 6.3 dias... no reduce dias de hospitalización, no reduce complicaciones, ni mortalidad...
https://t.co/LqViW495sQ
Nov 30, 2022 · 8 likes · 6,499 followersView post →
BT
Brent Thoma
@Brent_Thoma · X
@MathewChui Do you use it frequently? If so, in which population? Benefits seem to be outweighed by side effects in most. https://t.co/LhKpXR1fQC
成人および小児におけるインフルエンザの予防および治療のためのノイラミニダーゼ阻害剤
PMID: 24718923
https://t.co/mT5KmG7tND
Analysis of influenza outcomes in prophylaxis studies
Table 13. Oseltamivir versus placebo for preventing influenza in healthy adults
タミフル
Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children
https://t.co/VOEWgZ955J
タミフルについて、国際的非営利団体「コクラン共同計画」は、2014年にタミフルの有効性を限定的とする内容のシステマティック・レビューを公開
1/
@Bertie_222 Wasn’t Tamiflu shown to be crap? https://t.co/XHFzcPM0H6
But yes I agree if ivm reduces time to symptoms alleviation at all, worth looking into. Unlike Tamiflu, no important harms.
@michaelmina_lab @CarlosdelRio7 @pranayaryal @tmprowell @pfizer @FDACommissioner @DrWoodcockFDA @DrCaliff_FDA Cochrane review here confirms NNT of 33 for prophylaxis and a 17 hour reduction in symptoms. But not much else.
https://t.co/5ST1PyFFh5 https://t.co/ev0H2izKSF
@PastorMNunez @EricTopol @NEJM But that’s just because oseltamivir is a crappy drug, no?
https://t.co/XHFzcPM0H6
0.4mg/kg is still adherent to FLCCC’s present recommendation methinks. 0.4mg probably seemed good last year. I don’t think it’s fair to say the trial is ‘unfair’.
@PauloLotufo Revisão Cochrane (2014) baseada em relatórios internos completos de 20 ensaios clinicos de oseltamivir mostra que os resultados desafiam a suposição histórica de que funciona no combate à influenza.
https://t.co/JiVTfC1BF7
Dec 20, 2021 · 1 like · 2,460 followersView post →
DN
Doctor Normal
@PentaTronic · X
@ryanlcooper https://t.co/aiM3y3IjNk
https://t.co/jJzAB1ZV6v
Yes, this used to be be prevailing wisdom, but systematic reviews and “reviews of reviews” have not borne this out. Cost:benefit and Med society views are now firmly in the realm of “high cost, high risk, maybe no benefit at all.”
@sweidanmd @PulmCrit @iBookCC I think that’s what the usual practice, but when I last checked the evidence wasn’t solid. As per the Cochrane review: reduction in symptom duration by 16 hours. No reduction in hospitalization. Yet it has become the standard of care
Jun 27, 2021 · 1 share · 2,257 followersView post →
SK
Sharah Kasny
@SharahKasny · X
@jaussot @CarlosFlosan @MnbRegis @JavierGaite @todomejorqenada @Bringbacking @sistaya @jifmpiano @ldpsincomplejos @FrayJosepho 380 páginas, revisado ante un juez. Adjunto también juicio en marcha. Lo de que no es un timo está siendo juzgado en EEUU.
Enjoy.
https://t.co/VP9Wng3ox7
https://t.co/RYHhNa7DDZ https://t.co/rlIzgN8ngy
Jun 27, 2021 · 1 like · 1 share · 2,257 followersView post →
AS
Alessandro Scholze
@alescholze · X
@fkrysti @rpynnakpobn @RogrioNazareth1 @OmarAzizSenador Bom exemplo: oseltamivir continua a ser usado para tratar influeza, ainda que os danos pareçam superar os benefícios, já que não reduz mortes ou hospitalizações.
https://t.co/PIGyfxi2TF
@jeremyelmaleh @CoronaEnglish Seeing this product makes me question how much Tamiflu (also from Roche) was stockpiled a decade ago.
https://t.co/HHq4uclvxl
@drdanielvicente @josenalencar Oseltamivir também é quase inútil em influenza: https://t.co/A0PymtNYID
https://t.co/w09pHXTnXF
Isso que a probabilidade pré-teste era BEM mais alta. Qual a chave de uma droga de repropósito ser não apenas eficaz, mas MUITO eficaz?
Feb 28, 2021 · 2 likes · 14,544 followersView post →
S
suleymandenizarslan
@arsd69 · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 8,751 followersView post →
NM
Necla Özsel MKA
@Neclazsel3 · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 4,960 followersView post →
E
EPİFİLİZ
@FLOSUFY · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 188 followersView post →
H
H.
@hulyazaferim · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 15 followersView post →
BK
Bnbk Mstf ANTİ KÜRESELCİ
@Abd_iAciz · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 1,125 followersView post →
SŞ
Süreyya Şakar
@SakarSureyya · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 743 followersView post →
S
sosyalmedyaci5534
@sosyalmedyaci51 · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 1,756 followersView post →
BN
Bekir Kuntay Nalbantoğlu
@kuntaynlb · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 309 followersView post →
AD
Abdurrahman Dilipak
@aDilipak · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 987,853 followersView post →
ZS
Zeynep Sezer
@zeynepsezer72 · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 169 followersView post →
AE
Arzu Evcil
@EvcilArzu · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 143 followersView post →
MM
Mars merkur
@mars_merkur · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 238 followersView post →
YD
YALAN DÜNYA
@siyahinci2004 · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 4,432 followersView post →
MB
mahmut belemir
@BelemiMahmut · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 1,899 followersView post →
S
sirin
@nebunnebun · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 184 followersView post →
VH
Vet. Hek. Öğr. Gör.M. E. TAŞKIN( At Hekimi )
@perseus__enigma · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 962 followersView post →
X
XALODAYİ
@xale_iram · X
RT @drahmetrasim: Kızım, sana diyom:
100 yıldır bilinen gribe karşı geliştirilen tek ilaç olan Tamiflu, sadece belirtilerin ½-1 gün azalma…
Feb 12, 2021 · 31 shares · 1,718 followersView post →
NB
Nicolás de la Barrera
@NicodelaBarrera · X
Al ser consultado sobre la pandemia de gripe A, Eduardo López dice que el tamiflú "si se daba correctamente evitaba casos graves". https://t.co/L3Q0Tv0j1q Pero hasta donde sé eso no fue demostrado
@marcsdionne @lferreiramoita Sadly not from the meta analysis
'Oseltamivir and zanamivir have small, non‐specific effects on reducing the time to alleviation of influenza symptoms in adults'
https://t.co/izFqdPPlkT
@crabb_vicki @SethCanon1 @GeoffSchuler @angela_bower @JaiKanta22 @WendyOrent @emartinez78987 @mcfunny @PaulVCooper1 @netpoette @swedishchf @3GHtweets @ChristopherGDa4 @Charitable_Fury @LightControl2 @7_DSSEVEN @flavinkins @seraphina416 @provaxtexan @FrankDElia7 @TinFoilAwards @retiredbigboy1 @AgileConcept @PongoHuston @Iron_Mechanic @MsTrixter @JakeEschen @BamaJeans24 @JaneEOpie @AndrewLazarus4 @Awithonelison @Not2BOutdid @KStateTurk @flitesurgn @DreadPirRob42 @LG28640297 @WokenLast1 @cch_ba @JosephBlowe6 @ds_siete @doritmi @ZeeInTheMoment @twitjunkie0124 @artgirl_andrea @yatesmouse1 @tarrimarkel @handmadekathy @Olivia85689083 @itisjustmebabe @LynnFynn3 In the case of Neuraminidase inhibitors I am on the side of the RCT. We find it effective in prophylaxis and for treatment(with azithromycin). As a EPI what should I do when presented with this? Cochrane was not alone in this assertion.
@thew0rd15theb1r @SHomburg @Marcus05911286 Man muss sie sehr früh einnehmen, wenn man meist noch nicht von einer Influenza ausgeht und eine Wirkung auf schwere Symptome ist eher mau: https://t.co/Nr8fj8MOhK
@almuharrmi الطبيب الذي استضافه جيفيرسون لديه ما يقول عن Tamiflu كما ترى هنا:
https://t.co/VdL5U123VD
https://t.co/6wnB06wpT7
https://t.co/JND4aIoWBw
ومشكلته ليست مع فاعليته تجاه المرض فقط، بل تجاه ضرورته لايقاف انتشاره كوباء، كما تسوق له روش.
May 18, 2020 · 1 like · 8,502 followersView post →
DH
Dr. Maen K Househ
@MaenHouseh · X
الطبيب الذي استضافه جيفيرسون لديه ما يقول عن Tamiflu كما ترى هنا:
https://t.co/i75wszUV92
https://t.co/Cow3MwkiS4
https://t.co/bDq81zAZ9F
ومشكلته ليست مع فاعليته تجاه المرض فقط، بل تجاه ضرورته لايقاف انتشاره كوباء، كما تسوق له روش. https://t.co/NsmwGIXNFj
@barttels2 @Jennife10651535 @RogueRad @chadinabhan @emilymicheleL Use is not normally recommended as benefits are small and adverse effects common.
In very sick patients there are some studies showing around 30% relative mortality reduction eerily reminiscent of Remdesivir
https://t.co/1oIcAMrqeY
But if you like to really know the dark side of stories, I would suggest the video posted on https://t.co/rEwkJYY79y
Hey. Watch it. It's worth.
There's also a 2014 Cochrane metanalysis (https://t.co/aCztqJNeNh) reinforcing the very doubtful role of neuraminidase inhibitors. https://t.co/9zSYt6hKCE
For those who want to know more...
There's this article from
@AnnalsofIM
(2012):
https://t.co/IpqywUOk4S
The
@cochranecollab
review form 2014
https://t.co/PhKHq7QQ8G
Here's an easier CME blog read from @srrezaie
and the REBEL EM team: https://t.co/QYylvK7j2E
@kksheld Ummm... Don't get your statement...
There's this article from @AnnalsofIM (2012):
https://t.co/IpqywUOk4S
The @cochranecollab review form 2014
https://t.co/AgyfWr3sOS
Here's an easier CME blog read from @srrezaie and the REBEL EM team: https://t.co/QYylvK7j2E
Oseltamivir reduced the time to first alleviation of symptoms by 16.8 hours from 7 to 6.3 days. There was no effect in asthmatic children
Zanamivir reduced the time by 0.60 days. The effect in children was not significant
Cochrane Library https://t.co/dvFmHxK4n8
@anthony_gossage @AndrewNoymer @V2019N Incorrect. By this logic we would be guided by the evidence on tamiflu. (See below)
Confidence & good intentions aren't evidence.
https://t.co/zNKlB7z0kN
Mar 31, 2020 · 1 like · 3,259 followersView post →
Mar 1, 2020 · 2 likes · 1,953 followersView post →
M
mgourmelon
@mgourmelon · X
RT @docdu16: Voici les dernières données sur la grippe saisonnière et les neuraminidases. Pas fameux. https://t.co/g5zX02vH7A
Feb 25, 2020 · 3 shares · 321 followersView post →
LF
Le Flohic
@DrGomi · X
RT @docdu16: Voici les dernières données sur la grippe saisonnière et les neuraminidases. Pas fameux. https://t.co/g5zX02vH7A https://t.co/…
Feb 25, 2020 · 3 shares · 21,034 followersView post →
D
DrJohn
@DrJohnFa · X
RT @docdu16: Voici les dernières données sur la grippe saisonnière et les neuraminidases. Pas fameux. https://t.co/g5zX02vH7A
Feb 25, 2020 · 3 shares · 9,661 followersView post →
GJ
Grange JC
@docdu16 · X
Voici les dernières données sur la grippe saisonnière et les neuraminidases. Pas fameux. https://t.co/g5zX02vH7A https://t.co/rbI8VlkvLv
Feb 25, 2020 · 2 likes · 3 shares · 5,457 followersView post →
AC
april clark
@aprillynnclark · X
(27) https://t.co/Rljav1K61P Statements made on the capacity of oseltamivir to interrupt viral transmission and reduce complications are not supported by any data we have been able to access.
@CaulfieldTim @NBCNews @BrandyZadrozny Read the Cochrane review on the effectiveness of “Tamiflu”. Moral outrage about the scientific failings of others ... when one ignores the “best evidence” is not a good look. Marginal, uncertain... at best.
https://t.co/YWAMycbH7g
The End of Medicine As We Know It - and Why Your Health Has A ...
News
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews:CD008965, https://10.1002/14651858. CD008965.pub4 98 H. H. H. W. Schmidt. advertising any other drug at that time. In ...
Nutrition Essentials For Mental Health by Leslie Corn | PDF
News
... CD008965. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008965.pub4. Johnson, E. J. (2012). A possible role for lutein and zeaxanthin in cognitive function in the elderly ...
Evaluation of Oseltamivir Used To Prevent Hospitalization-Meta ...
News
doi:10.1002/14651858.CD008965.pub4 controlled study of oral Ro 64-0796 (also known as 37. Dorkings J. Clinical study report—protocol 25. Hayashino Y ...
How To Manage Antivirals in Critically Ill Patients With Influenza | PDF
News
... CD008965. https://doi.org/ data acquisition, drafted the work, writing review and approved the 10.1002/14651858.CD008965.pub4. submitted version. N.d.P. ...
Tamiflu (oseltamivir) is an antiviral medication used to treat and help prevent #influenza . There is a national shortage currently, but is it worth stressing ...
Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in adults and children. https://www.cochranelibrary.com/cdsr/doi/10.1002/14651858.CD008965.pub4/ ...
Natural flu remedies on the last slide! Research shows that Tamiflu (oseltamivir) can shorten flu symptoms by about a day if taken within 48 hours of ...
Understanding Tamiflu: National Shortage and Medication Insights. Learn about Tamiflu, an antiviral medication used for influenza treatment and prevention.
Understanding Tamiflu: National Shortage and Medication Insights. Learn about Tamiflu, an antiviral medication used for influenza treatment and prevention.
2014 Apr 10;4:CD008965. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008965.pub4. Neuraminidase inhibitors for preventing and treating influenza in healthy adults and children ...