Discussions reflect a nuanced view, with some participants highlighting that seeing loved ones after death is a common part of grieving, citing the article to support these claims, while others express skepticism about the factual basis of historical accounts. The tone varies from neutral factual references to critical skepticism, contributing to a balanced yet somewhat cautious exchange.
AgreementNeither agree nor disagree
The discussions show a mix of support and skepticism regarding the article's implications about post-bereavement hallucinatory experiences, with some acknowledging their prevalence and others questioning their interpretation.
InterestModerate interest
Participants are somewhat interested, as they reference the publication and its research but don't delve deeply into the methodology or clinical implications.
EngagementModerate engagement
The comments demonstrate moderate engagement, with some sharing personal or cultural perspectives and referencing studies and historical texts, indicating active thought but not exhaustive analysis.
ImpactNeutral impact
Overall, these discussions seem to have a neutral impact; they raise awareness or curiosity but don't appear to significantly influence broader perceptions or policies about grief or hallucinations.
Abstract in brief
PBHEs are abnormal sensory experiences that many bereaved individuals report, often without any history of mental illness, raising questions about whether these experiences are pathological or part of normal grief.
Research shows a high prevalence of PBHEs among widowed people, with estimates ranging from 30% to 60%, but studies vary widely in methods and sample sizes, especially in the bereaved population.
Although current evidence suggests PBHEs are common, more research is needed to better understand these experiences, improve evaluation methods, and distinguish between normal and abnormal reactions to grief.
Unfortunately I'm in the middle of something so will have to watch later. But you should go join if you can!
https://t.co/jZzZmBz3IN
Apr 28, 2023 · 1 like · 1,056 followersView post →
DR
Dave Rowlands
@TrolleyDave1971 · X
Raising Jesus Without God - A Natural Alternative || Minimal Facts Part 3 https://t.co/jZzZmBz3IN via @YouTube
Apr 27, 2023 · 1 like · 1,056 followersView post →
D
Dessany
@Dessany2 · X
@Jeffery4Pi @victorvheerden @paulogia0 & quite a few ppl do see loved ones after death. It's a normal part of grieving. If the stories in the bible are factual which is quite an assumption, it's more likely these ppl had a normal grieving experience of seeing their deceased loved one.
https://t.co/f2bxKWvurv
@Jeffery4Pi @victorvheerden @paulogia0 Saying these ~2 millennia old stories are true is what's false. We don't know what is true & what isn't. That's why there is no consensus on what actually happened. However there is data on what happens w/bereavement
https://t.co/f2bxKWvurv
The video discusses plausible natural explanations for Jesus' resurrection, focusing on the Minimal Facts approach, and examines related theories including visionary experiences and apocalyptic teachings.
Are fleeting encounters with the deceased a sign of illness or normal grief? This episode examines when such phenomena are normal and when they signal caution, providing insights on assessment, communication, and…
@zac_eki @paulogia0 Seems like you’re referencing Rees 1971. Olson and Grimbly have higher estimates (around 30% for visual). See: “Post-bereavement hallucinatory experiences: A critical overview of population and clinical studies” for a review. Now, while I suspect Paul would not contend an…
Unfortunately I'm in the middle of something so will have to watch later. But you should go join if you can!
https://t.co/jZzZmBz3IN
Apr 28, 2023 · 1 like · 1,056 followersView post →
DR
Dave Rowlands
@TrolleyDave1971 · X
Raising Jesus Without God - A Natural Alternative || Minimal Facts Part 3 https://t.co/jZzZmBz3IN via @YouTube
Apr 27, 2023 · 1 like · 1,056 followersView post →
D
Dessany
@Dessany2 · X
@Jeffery4Pi @victorvheerden @paulogia0 & quite a few ppl do see loved ones after death. It's a normal part of grieving. If the stories in the bible are factual which is quite an assumption, it's more likely these ppl had a normal grieving experience of seeing their deceased loved one.
https://t.co/f2bxKWvurv
@Jeffery4Pi @victorvheerden @paulogia0 Saying these ~2 millennia old stories are true is what's false. We don't know what is true & what isn't. That's why there is no consensus on what actually happened. However there is data on what happens w/bereavement
https://t.co/f2bxKWvurv
Death As An Altered State of Consciousness (Imants Baruss) (Z ...
News
10.1016/j.jad.2015.07.032. Champlain, S. [We Don't Die Radio]. (2021, March 3). Sonia Rinaldi presents “Images from the afterlife” 7 June 2020 on wedontdie ...
Cognitive Rehabilitation and Neuroimaging-Book | PDF | Functional ...
News
https://doi.org/10.3233/JAD-142061. Dodge, H. H., Du, Y., Saxton, J. A. ... Brain Research, 1624, 167–174. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brainres.2015.07.032
Death As An Altered State of Consciousness by Imants Baruss | PDF ...
News
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jad.2015.07.032. Champlain, S. [We Donʼt Die Radio]. (2021, March 3). Sonia Rinaldi presents “Images from the afterlife” 7 June ...