https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “Scapular dyskinesis is NOT more prevalent in those with shoulder pain. Rating was influenced by an examiner's knowledge of shoulder pain presence
Observational Scapular Dyskinesis: Known-Groups Validity in Patients With and Without Shoulder Pain.
Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
Mentions per month
Jul 2017 – Sep 2025Where it's discussed
-
X / Twitter77 posts
-
Facebook23 posts
-
YouTube3 videos
-
News3 articles
AI synopsis
What people are saying
Several posts explicitly reference the study's conclusion that scapular dyskinesis prevalence is similar in patients with and without shoulder pain. For instance, comments highlight the influence of examiner bias on diagnosis, with phrases such as 'movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain.' The discussions often employ a critical tone, emphasizing that preconceived notions can mislead assessments, thereby shaping the overall perception of the article's findings.
The majority of posts agree with the findings of the study, particularly the notion that scapular dyskinesis is not more prevalent in individuals with shoulder pain.
Users expressed high levels of curiosity and found the study relevant, highlighting the topic in various discussions.
While many posts referenced the article, the level of detailed analysis varied, with some indicating deeper engagement by exploring implications.
The overall consensus is that the publication has high significance, influencing perceptions about shoulder pain and assessment.
Abstract in brief
- The study aimed to evaluate the prevalence of scapular dyskinesis in individuals with and without shoulder pain using the scapular dyskinesis test (SDT).
- Results showed no significant difference in the prevalence of dyskinesis between the two groups during shoulder movements, although ratings varied based on whether the examiner was aware of the participants' pain status.
- Ultimately, the study concluded that scapular dyskinesis is not more common in those experiencing shoulder pain, but the knowledge of pain status significantly impacted examiners' ratings.
Top posts
Most liked on X and BlueskyInteresting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” in painful versus non-painful shoulders. But when they know a shoulder hurts, they are more likely to see dysfunction. https://t.co/Gtz7aQ2ZbO
Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by its elegant and simple design. Do clinicians see what we want to see when assessing for movement faults? https://t.co/II7OPK0sye
https://t.co/XrcLjtepI4 https://t.co/REl9YswHqt
@Robptatcscs And also common and asymptomatic in other populations too! https://t.co/b5rsDglCXG
自然に起こりうるこういったバイアスをかき分けるためにも問診からしっかり情報を得る必要があるし、自身の評価を疑いつつ進める必要がある https://t.co/jGlrk0Vwfp だからこそ、複数のテスト・エクササイズを実行しながらボトルネックを探す 今日も今日とて。 #AT #PT #リハビ #トレーニング https://t.co/q27aZQ2s6u
All mentions
Scapular Dyskinesis and Shoulder Pain: A Critical Review of Evidence
This video explores scapular dyskinesis and its relationship to shoulder pain. Contrary to common belief, recent studies indicate that scapular dyskinesis is not more prevalent in those experiencing shoulder pain…
Reevaluating Scapular Stabilization in Shoulder Rehabilitation
This video discusses the misconceptions about scapular stabilization exercises and their effectiveness. It critically examines current beliefs, explores scapular motion, and presents evidence-based insights to improve…
Understanding Scapular Dyskinesis and Baseline Rates in Patients
Nelson and Matas analyze scapular dyskinesis and its prevalence in individuals with and without shoulder pain, challenging the assumption that it is more common in those with pain. They emphasize the impact of examiner…
RT @LoriMichener: @Robptatcscs And also common and asymptomatic in other populations too! https://t.co/b5rsDglCXG
@Robptatcscs And also common and asymptomatic in other populations too! https://t.co/b5rsDglCXG
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
Observational Scapular Dyskinesis: Known-Groups Validity in Patients With and Without Shoulder Pain https://t.co/QgMkONyUfl
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
RT @JaredPowell12: Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by it…
Every so often I re-read this paper by Plummer et al on identifying scapular dyskinesia and I am always mesmerised by its elegant and simple design. Do clinicians see what we want to see when assessing for movement faults? https://t.co/II7OPK0sye
Plummer HA, Sum JC, Pozzi F, Varghese R, Michener LA. Observational Scapular Dyskinesis: Known-Groups Validity in Patients With and Without Shoulder Pain. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther. 2017 Aug;47(8):530-537. doi: 10.2519/jospt.2017.7268. Epub 2017 Jul 6. PMID: 28683230.
RT @AP21618613: 自然に起こりうるこういったバイアスをかき分けるためにも問診からしっかり情報を得る必要があるし、自身の評価を疑いつつ進める必要がある https://t.co/jGlrk0Vwfp だからこそ、複数のテスト・エクササイズを実行しながらボトルネック…
自然に起こりうるこういったバイアスをかき分けるためにも問診からしっかり情報を得る必要があるし、自身の評価を疑いつつ進める必要がある https://t.co/jGlrk0Vwfp だからこそ、複数のテスト・エクササイズを実行しながらボトルネックを探す 今日も今日とて。 #AT #PT #リハビ #トレーニング https://t.co/q27aZQ2s6u
RT @CorKinetic: https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “S…
RT @CorKinetic: https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “S…
RT @CorKinetic: https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “S…
RT @CorKinetic: https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “S…
RT @CorKinetic: https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “S…
RT @CorKinetic: https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “S…
RT @CorKinetic: https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “S…
RT @CorKinetic: https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “S…
RT @CorKinetic: https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “S…
RT @CorKinetic: https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “S…
https://t.co/YkqLMLnAUq Movement flaws are more likely to be diagnosed when there is pain than when there isn’t. #BIAS “Scapular dyskinesis is NOT more prevalent in those with shoulder pain. Rating was influenced by an examiner's knowledge of shoulder pain presence
Season 6, Episode 13 with Lori Michener: Observational Scapular Dyskinesis: Known-Groups Validity in Patients With and Without Shoulder Pain https://t.co/vDZSqF3Gol
RT @E3Rehab: https://t.co/XrcLjtepI4 https://t.co/REl9YswHqt
RT @E3Rehab: https://t.co/XrcLjtepI4 https://t.co/REl9YswHqt
https://t.co/XrcLjtepI4 https://t.co/REl9YswHqt
✅評価者は”有痛者”であるとわかった場合、姿勢や動作の問題により高い罹患率を報告した (Plummer et al 2017) https://t.co/jGlrk0UYpR 先入観を省くには実施する検査を増やしたり、可視化したりが必要でしょうか。 そして大事なのは何が(+)を(-)に変えるか #AT #PT #リハビリ #トレーニング https://t.co/SAzJD7EY8z
【評価感度を上げたその先に】
9/ Critical and Theoretical Perspective on Scapular Stabilization... https://t.co/zsROCGZSy6 Observational Scapular Dyskinesis... https://t.co/6zZITUZbD7 @LoriMichener The narrative on scapular dyskinesis has changed over the years and these highlight some contemporary ideas
Scapula Winging and Shoulder pain!!! A study done in 2017 by Plummer et al says otherwise. They concluded, Scapular dyskinesis as assessed with the SDT is not more prevalent in those with shoulder pain. LINK- https://t.co/q1TMwzCFSC https://t.co/BPMiYl6YNL
・多くの要因から機能を探る ・複数テストの結果を総合して判断する ・そもそも自分の腕を疑う クライアントと向き合ううえで大切にしていることの一部になっているリサーチです #リハビリ #トレーニング #AT #PT #自分で自分を疑え https://t.co/jwHPZDDH1z https://t.co/nA1xYJf4ED
RT @AndrsLogrono: 3) La correlación con los síntomas del hombro es una mierda. Ver: https://t.co/PzhnsDNqem La prevalencia de discinesia es…
3) La correlación con los síntomas del hombro es una mierda. Ver: https://t.co/PzhnsDNqem La prevalencia de discinesia escapular fue muy similar en participantes con y sin dolor de hombro. @MichaelRayDC #Fisioterapia #ejercicio #Ecuador https://t.co/PiKrZMUIYO
https://t.co/pI1et4K8C2
3) Correlation to shoulder symptoms is crap. See: https://t.co/omP159biT5 Prevalence of scapular dyskinesis was very similar in participants with and without shoulder pain. 411
Heard a PT student talking about the importance of scapular dyskinesis in shoulder pain today. I'll just leave this here: https://t.co/4NABovP38F https://t.co/4NABovP38F
Heard a PT student talking about the importance of scapular dyskinesis in shoulder pain today. I'll just leave this here: https://t.co/4uhOHFL153
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
Alors, selon cet article, les "dyskinésies" des mouvements de l'omoplate sont la norme et pas une anomalie. Qui plus est, les physios en trouvent autant sur des épaules saines que sur des épaules douloureuses lorsqu'évaluées à l'aveugle. https://t.co/v6PSMrpGzo
Alors, selon cet article, les "dyskinésies" des mouvements de l'omoplate sont la norme et pas une anomalie. Qui plus est, les physios en trouvent autant sur des épaules saines que sur des épaules douloureuses lorsqu'évaluées à l'aveugle. https://t.co/nsb9ph8sUH
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
"There were no significant differences for scapular dyskinesis prevalence between the shoulder pain group and control group during the SDT in abduction. There were significant differences... https://t.co/DataUkurZf
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
RT @ToddHargrove: Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” i…
Interesting paper (via @bencormack): Blinded physios examining scapula movement don’t find higher rates of “dyskinesia” in painful versus non-painful shoulders. But when they know a shoulder hurts, they are more likely to see dysfunction. https://t.co/Gtz7aQ2ZbO