Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
The discussions surrounding the publication show a notable emphasis on the low regret rates—0.6% for trans women and 0.3% for trans men—cited frequently as evidence of the effectiveness of gender-affirming treatments. Phrases like 'very low regret rates' and 'transformative care' were commonly used to convey the positive impacts of these treatments on individuals' well-being. The tone varies from supportive to critical, reflecting differing views on healthcare standards and societal implications of gender dysphoria management.
Most discussions reflect a general consensus that the findings of the study on regret rates and treatment efficacy are well-supported.
A large number of posts express high levels of curiosity regarding the study, indicating its relevance to ongoing debates about gender dysphoria treatment.
Many users interact in-depth, referencing specific statistics from the study and comparing it to other studies, demonstrating a serious investment in the topic.
Participants believe that the conclusions drawn from the study will significantly influence public and medical perceptions of transgender healthcare.
Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to lock in feelings of dysphoria and make a continuation to further medicalisation virtually guaranteed. https://t.co/tGhRcgrxpq https://t.co/yurmhDDdcd
21. Wiepjes et al, 2018 https://t.co/WTX5GWldVH 4863 patients underwent surgery, 14 expressed regrets (0.3%) * This is a retrospective study (i.e., authors looked at medical records and did not follow up with patients directly).
Next they reference "The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets. (J Sex Med. 2018 Apr;15(4):582-590" This paper claims a 0.5% rate of regret, but define this as only the patients who make an app't to discuss regret.
@texandogdad @KatyMontgomerie I am one of the people lost to follow-up in this study. Not because I regret transition, but simply because I decided to stop traveling across the country twice yearly for a prescription I can also get from my local endocrinologist. https://t.co/iowgXRP5Jv
We don't have any concrete numbers for Germany, but in the neighboring Netherlands, nearly 80% of trans adults and adolescents (once they reached adulthood) underwent genital surgery within five years of starting HRT. https://t.co/3NPSwA7kwg (30/31)
@LeeForWomen @MrMennoTweets @JapanesePolar @AndrewDoyle Dhejne 2011 is one study commonly cited. https://t.co/1lvmMWNeDB Also Wiepjes 2018 https://t.co/o25k7UFfOR You could say those studies involved a very different patient profile from today. This article also cites more recent studies https://t.co/LT7WFjWHnh See references 82,
This video explores the mental disorder known as gender dysphoria, highlighting trends in prevalence and treatment from 1972 to 2015. With increasing numbers seeking help, it emphasizes the importance of access to…
Transgender is a term that encompasses a diversity of experiences. This video discusses gender dysphoria, the low regret rates of gender-affirmation surgeries, and insights from experts on the societal challenges faced…
This video examines the trends in prevalence and treatments for gender dysphoria from 1972 to 2015. Findings indicate a significant increase in individuals seeking help from gender identity clinics, highlighting the…
Stories about mental health face many hurdles. This video explores the increase in individuals seeking help for gender dysphoria between 1972 and 2015, highlighting trends in treatment and revealing the importance of…
@GuntherEagleman APPARENTLY its a european import https://t.co/wv54JsvsU0 the first cases of what were then called transexual studies occured in the early 1970s in the Netherlands The first EVER trans people recorded were in the 1930s, at a place the Nazis burned https://t.co/EyXSfFhIUH
@Kenshiro19901 @kmkrynicka @archetypfuturae Mała garstka która nie jest jakkolweik reprezentatywna dla ogólnego środowiska naukowego które dalej to uznaję tranzycję za najlepszą metodę leczenia dysforii. Głos tej Pani jest wyjątkiem potwierdzającym regułę. Bo większość tranzycji nie żałuje https://t.co/DKVIgKQ5Ob
@gen1853 @grandaljotape https://t.co/ZyzmLIxPeW te la mandaste negrito
@just_comm1 @cortementi773 To dosłownie tranzycja i affirmujące środowisko polepsza u nich dobrostan a nie gówno memy o 40% xd https://t.co/yNU8KosQzI https://t.co/Afjj7kAdKc https://t.co/JZua6uJgwQ https://t.co/NUw6RKXyre
@BenteRaatz @SofieMosgaard Jeg tvivler stærkt, Bente. Eftersom fortrydelsesraten er langt lavere end 1-2% fortryder deres behandling. https://t.co/gbKh4Rxsbj https://t.co/OhBDNm9ywj Ud af dem der fortryder, gør en stor del det pga. ydre omstændigheder (familie, venner og omverdens manglende accept).
@novelwritergal @TTExulansic Have you even read the abstract? no where does it say 36% dropped out of the study in fact they couldn't have because the design of the study doesn't allow people to drop out https://t.co/k9Zn9bGEXU
@WrenGreen08 @TTExulansic The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972–2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets a remarkably high 36% dropped out of the study.
@TheMithaecus @TakedownMRAs @PinkNews https://t.co/WF9qi8BBzG more than 40 years is considered long term. Cope harder please.
@TheMithaecus @TakedownMRAs @PinkNews https://t.co/WF9qi8C9pe sure, sure, denial is the only thing you've got left
@TheMithaecus @TakedownMRAs @PinkNews https://t.co/WF9qi8BBzG sure , sure....
@TheMithaecus @TakedownMRAs @PinkNews https://t.co/90XDDdVdrW cry harder please.
@TheMithaecus @TakedownMRAs @PinkNews Yes but actually no. Is a 40+ long study enough for you or will you say that it's too short ? https://t.co/90XDDdVdrW
@imsarahbella @helenalucky13 https://t.co/nCtqMb0J3G
@AndInTheEnd2 @metabebop @WildeFocker @BrileyF64401 @sitnspinning69 @RigoIrizarry https://t.co/FD0SiMLPzN U criticized one. But u implied that gac has good mental health outcomes for 2 years. But 2 years wasnt long enough to know for sure. Here is a study done over like 40 years. The cass review doesnt say “stop now” it says “do research now”
@AndInTheEnd2 @WildeFocker @metabebop @BrileyF64401 @sitnspinning69 @RigoIrizarry I have studies that say the opposite. Some children do have feelings cancer and need gac. In the study the only difference between more suicidal patients and less suicidal patients was access to gac. Already sent this to u. https://t.co/FD0SiMLPzN
@GlitchAmer85803 @therealjoshuaS_ @Dipl_Hurensohn https://t.co/6KlcvF5E0Y
@JuicyJuuce @pwrynz @nikicaga @legaltweetz https://t.co/Pcui3bW9xA https://t.co/T6dr4eLmjs Funny. I don’t see this massive rate of desisting. Odd.
@SpiritusRexx @YamiryuNoKage @KyleKulinski https://t.co/6KlcvF5E0Y
@punnishedcurls @rejserin @jk_rowling @lumos @JamesChiavarini The second and third appear to be entirely based on self-report and, as with the first study, I see no mention of a control group in the second study. 3/4 2nd: https://t.co/9LqZcV5tBA 3rd: https://t.co/PyeXm25Wn8
@SageofFire313 @PBanpoys @ddanielash Here's a simple video explaining gender dysphoria, its not really something to debate about https://t.co/u9Ay5a1cAT
You mean the less than 1% of people who receive gender affirming care? pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29463477/ “Only 0.6% of transwomen and 0.3% of transmen who underwent gonadectomy were identified as experiencing regret.”
@shir0wan You are just telling complete and total lies now. You think I haven't done the research? https://t.co/9UFhUjYyYB https://t.co/Y7A2UfOU06 https://t.co/Q4ulJZlNgr https://t.co/FXX9AlF0yE https://t.co/2Xl2lvpaqf
0.6% to 1% of people in the United States are trans. Of those, <1% report regretting their gender affirming treatment. This is one of the lowest regret rates of any type of procedure. Additional Sources: https://t.co/Q4ulJZlNgr https://t.co/FXX9AlF0yE https://t.co/dLvpzSAGhL https://t.co/g6K8f6XzhT
@memeticsisyphus E.g. 6,800 people here, regret rates below 1% https://t.co/QjSJGdoPRX
@zachrobert15 @DawgWitDaDawg @kaamonsense @Teezy6354 @bluefolf “It helps” Physicians quote a 1% regret rate. This statistic is based on The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets. This study had significant limitations and cannot be used as a baseline for the current cohort:
@a69774 @esjesjesj @AaronMikita I mean if this study alone disproves your whole conviction, I don’t think I have to take your calumny as truth which I know you got from right wing propaganda tanks
@HedonismEnjoyer @kikisstufff @WastelandHulk98 @bluefolf The number is smaller than many other surgeries. Should they also be illegal? https://t.co/68j0zBnVgA
@CaptianOfLexx @Sheikh37351514 @GarbageHuman24 "Only 0.6% of transwomen and 0.3% of transmen who underwent gonadectomy were identified as experiencing regret" https://t.co/Rxz2bgzbFo
@crystalandqueue @GarbageHuman24 https://t.co/Rxz2bgzbFo Oh honey, there are countless of stats to back up my claim. Conservatives just choose to ignore science, when it suits them
@Ambisont_ @LaraDCookie @signoria_pros https://t.co/w8qG3qeR3W
@Slagathoro @mpfive0 @Emilio2763 More: https://t.co/FgQi6FGUo5 More: https://t.co/fpygjiIM6E https://t.co/FIw5PyF8A2 When Gender Identity is formed and accurate: https://t.co/yaZkGOjoH9 Stats for stopping puberty blockers: https://t.co/FBlBXH964B Stats for youth: https://t.co/K6nJLIc3PI Please educate yourself.
@Orzech_0707 @Ajronek Badania wykazują że daleko temu do "leczenia palitywnego" https://t.co/yNU8KosQzI https://t.co/Afjj7kAdKc https://t.co/7nTZbH1w8u https://t.co/NUw6RKXyre https://t.co/JZua6uJgwQ https://t.co/sLGqjW7XeE
@robert83047 @laura_tee_mdgi Both figures come from the Dutch gender clinic, who has treated transgender adolescents for over 30 years. https://t.co/GCzKbk2Pbw https://t.co/iowgXRP5Jv
@RealMDForsyth @mushycrouton clearly u dont know what u talking about https://t.co/LDHELiK9WU
@virtusnobilitas @Anazaskiam @CBerth92 @zouavedeservice La moindre des politesse quand on donne des sources, c'est de fournir le lien. Bon, voyons cette AmsterdamCohortofGenderDysphoria. https://t.co/pqS3qI3jv5
@Shilisad1 @Telegraph You're basically admitting that you haven't done any research. 1) Both studies I referenced have follow-up times well over 3 years. 2) Treatment in the Netherlands has increased significantly well over 10 years ago. https://t.co/iowgXRPDz3 https://t.co/r3jRUKZ16R
@Shiva_EP @DasIstEine_Frau oder sowas hier https://t.co/TgzVRL3e8e https://t.co/MukmwE8tMe https://t.co/HQDHZFPByI
- https://t.co/maaQkuVkCY 1% (less actually!) regret rate in trans people undergoing gender affirming surgery - https://t.co/aw6nTlvn6D less than a 1% regret rate for trans people who underwent gender affirming surgery in the Netherlands over a span of 40+ years
@BartsTwitt @HPdeTijdNL Chantal Wiepjes heeft een onderzoek gedaan, Wiepjes et al (2018), waarin ze onderzoek deed naar detransitioners. Haar onderzoek was met name om de redenen van detransitie (transitiespijt) te achterhalen. >> https://t.co/QPaa0llHyJ
@EroticNapkin @mlmlmlml31 @Erin4Parents "had a loss-to-follow-up rate of 36%. If you’re losing track of a third of your patients, you obviously don’t really know how they’re doing and can’t make any strong claims about their regret rates." https://t.co/o91BMBhpie
@ambeanmhor https://t.co/uSzAWNjgY6
@Caimbra_12 @mattheu93928985 @viizedek Essa outra pesquisa até possui alguns resultados interessantes, porém ela não se aplica a crianças e adolescente ("ou seja, completamente inútil para o tema que está sendo debatido"): https://t.co/LeJsjKNc61 https://t.co/YxYqQgzjje
@VetWarrior76 @ChoooCole @hannahsbee @triggerpod 0.5% is 0,5% - of the entire population. That's those diagnosable, not the lower number actually diagnosed, and that's largely replicating across the West. There are patient outcome studies. but I don't have American or British ones at hand. https://t.co/D8ajUteuOf
@parisa002 @PortBhoy11 @mimmymum Nope. I quote established science: https://t.co/xlKQd29TDj https://t.co/xa2Ol9hilf https://t.co/6z3uz9jxU7 https://t.co/dBwqlc5CTn https://t.co/WUeBnJt01q.
@detransaqua @AureaSophia1 It looks like people mean this study for the less than 1% number — done in Amsterdam from 1972-2015. Could be other ones. Best to consult the article from above because that article is a very recent systematic review of all studies. https://t.co/v9V3azUg66
@ErikCumps @dorien1954 @EGoethard @RoeliendenOuden @VickerC1 @sigridschollen @SEeckelaerts @KavanuKvn @leovdd @DrMariekedOuden @LucDeCoster @10pondt @nocnsf @HoebekePiet Deze Nederlandse studie loopt van 1972 tot 2015 Van de 6793 deelnemers bleken 14 mensen spijt te hebben. https://t.co/iowgXRPDz3 https://t.co/0yjnJ0sd2R
@mato_albert @DrozdVelky @bratricek Absolutní většina pacientů jež tranzici podstoupila, dané operace nelitovala. Většina studií uvádí jen něco mezi 0.5 - 1% případů. To co píšete prostě není pravda. Jen skoro až zanedbatelná minorita skutečně operace lituje. https://t.co/WBXSyL88XY
@AndySocrat800 @legaltweetz Another 2021 systematic review in JAMA Surgery analyzed 27 studies involving thousands of trans individuals, finding that the overall regret rate across different types of gender-affirming surgery was around 1%. https://t.co/bOOo2oLsvD
@curtisM255 @ChoooCole https://t.co/mI88JPwNA4
@socraticpsych7 @ShelleyBWoke A study from the Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Patients reported in The Journal of Sexual Medicine in 2021, showed a regret rate of less than 1% among the 6,793 people who had undergone surgery between 1972 and 2015. https://t.co/bOOo2oLsvD
@ShireenMcQuade1 @MrMennoTweets @voskat55 I am referring to these studies: https://t.co/TBjNeudWjB https://t.co/iowgXRP5Jv
@carolineetsgra1 @W1se0N3 @PunishedAG That's not what the study found. The study found that 1.9% stopped puberty suppression from a total 6,793 patients at their clinic. From that, whoever wrote your dogshit article decided to conflate that with regret. https://t.co/w9JbbMlHij
de partij voor een betrouwbare overheid meent dat het genderteam gewoon maar wat doet en dat ze verder helemaal geen onderzoek doen. nonsens natuurlijk www.vumc.nl/research/ove...
@IamTheImmortal https://t.co/20deVOg2j1
@BaronBoehm @XzentheTired @InternetH0F The science disagrees with you: https://t.co/68j0zBnVgA https://t.co/zNM0xYfvDn https://t.co/m1b94obbeL https://t.co/OTnREtkW7f https://t.co/MnSrfp5KSl The evidence shows that gender affirming care improves quality of life, reduces dysphoria, and improved functioning.
@SenseCertain @BadWritingTakes https://t.co/SwURVi01Oh
@pubmechanic @krack932 Sources https://t.co/4LqMJsmw79 https://t.co/kWsIbdnMC0 https://t.co/sfGU3ZqjFy https://t.co/TIhSMu2L8B https://t.co/hwBDlcAQDz https://t.co/X4xNR69QOL https://t.co/xSzxVlZ8Nd https://t.co/JB8juFIhNk https://t.co/sn3uZGleUG
@krack932 @MeowyWood Don’t need to read, I’ve read them before, I recognize them. As I’ve stated I’ve done this before and have my own stats. You claim it has a “negative effect” when statically that’s incredibly rare. https://t.co/4LqMJsmw79 https://t.co/kWsIbdnMC0 https://t.co/sfGU3ZqjFy
@ColeMole_ @ZackMamba__ @pushinpama @Zentotic @FearedBuck Here's just 3 https://t.co/8i2CcMG22n https://t.co/VVeD9nsIWP https://t.co/wu0mNVE54q
@Rye2539 @Jamjar627 @DanburyMatt @EFCevie https://t.co/XWG5PJaAK1
We don't have any concrete numbers for Germany, but in the neighboring Netherlands, nearly 80% of trans adults and adolescents (once they reached adulthood) underwent genital surgery within five years of starting HRT. https://t.co/3NPSwA7kwg (30/31)
@Conspiracytzard @LordAslanThe2nd @InsaneCope https://t.co/7FmGzLBM3j
@Steven96235409 @Orangutan231 @jessesingal We already know that transition works for many people. The question is if people are getting surgery that shouldn't be getting surgery. And smaller studies do not point in that direction. https://t.co/Mam8RIq6WJ https://t.co/I5yicwUxxF https://t.co/4vULraPDW2
@SevendersOTW @jessesingal https://t.co/tjZCMMZFsM
RT @Bernard_Lane: @LeeForWomen @MrMennoTweets @JapanesePolar @AndrewDoyle Dhejne 2011 is one study commonly cited. https://t.co/1lvmMWNeDB…
RT @Roishin_Rose: @texandogdad @KatyMontgomerie I am one of the people lost to follow-up in this study. Not because I regret transition, b…
@LeeForWomen @MrMennoTweets @JapanesePolar @AndrewDoyle Dhejne 2011 is one study commonly cited. https://t.co/1lvmMWNeDB Also Wiepjes 2018 https://t.co/o25k7UFfOR You could say those studies involved a very different patient profile from today. This article also cites more recent studies https://t.co/LT7WFjWHnh See references 82,
@texandogdad @KatyMontgomerie I am one of the people lost to follow-up in this study. Not because I regret transition, but simply because I decided to stop traveling across the country twice yearly for a prescription I can also get from my local endocrinologist. https://t.co/iowgXRP5Jv
@jessesingal @ijbailey And here’s a large retrospective cohort study spanning several decades https://t.co/tjZCMMZFsM
@jk_rowling @DawnButlerBrent Epub 2018 Feb 17.. 2018 Apr;15(4):582-590.J Sex Med The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and RegretsChantal M Wiepjes 1, Nienke M Nota 1, Christel J M de Blok 1, Maartje Klaver 1, Annelou L C de Vries 2, S Annelijn
@rowlinglibrary @jk_rowling Epub 2018 Feb 17.. 2018 Apr;15(4):582-590.J Sex Med The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and RegretsChantal M Wiepjes 1, Nienke M Nota 1, Christel J M de Blok 1, Maartje Klaver 1, Annelou L C de Vries 2, S Annelijn
Epub 2018 Feb 17.. 2018 Apr;15(4):582-590.J Sex Med The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets Chantal M Wiepjes 1, Nienke M Nota 1, Christel J M de Blok 1, Maartje Klaver 1, Annelou L C de Vries 2, S Annelijn
Many physicians quote a 1% regret rate. This statistic is based on The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets. This study had significant limitations and cannot be used as a baseline for the current cohort: https://t.co/43wM8Jq7vF
@AlexOliver69FL @ErinInTheMorn You’re the second or third person to claim that in a discussion with me recently. Who is telling you that? https://t.co/ljChLAx9uJ https://t.co/Xc42OaBS4M https://t.co/nkG4s63UDK
@bowie19872 @ex_nerd @ErinInTheMorn https://t.co/aKvfV07q1j
@AlexJHarman Go away and do some reading on the Dutch protocol for a start. I hope it will change your mind. https://t.co/uPIyFHbxxl https://t.co/geQrie9d6q https://t.co/SeF1h0iQ0P https://t.co/bfPaZL6uKl
@repmorgan @jsantangelo13 https://t.co/79RZoOcAh7
@irene_gp @eldiarioes Toma loca del coño me puedes comer los huevos: https://t.co/7ybFtmd0cv
@RadioFreeStPaul @FeelTheWeightOf @BriannaWu The system works as it's supposed to. Trans kids who medically transition undergo prolonged non medical social and counseling, among other things, before they are allowed to medically transition. /1 https://t.co/mG596KpHlf https://t.co/aPgke2EB01
@LadyLlangollen @RealistIdealis3 @Busanitian @Docstockk https://t.co/CWddltvdGO
Amsterdam cohort of gender dysphoria study (1972–2015): Trends in prevalence, treatment, and regrets, par Chantal Wiepjes, Nienke Nota et al. (The journal of sexual medicine, février 2018) : https://t.co/nGCIzYQoG5
@sarasiobhan @MarkNeary1 @APowellLaw The 98% figure comes separate studies looking at UK (Carmichael et al 2021) and Dutch children (Wiepjes et al 2018) But you keep pretending there's no harm Sara https://t.co/drX6oYFEVl https://t.co/r52uepEEcw
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
RT @pagd_vic: Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to l…
Claims that PBs allow a pause and time to think are disputed as evidence suggests that use of puberty blockers is likely to lock in feelings of dysphoria and make a continuation to further medicalisation virtually guaranteed. https://t.co/tGhRcgrxpq https://t.co/yurmhDDdcd
@JonkheerErnst as stated this is just a retrospective view of data of a gender clinic in amsterdam but the results indicate that the rate of people detransitioning shows no signs of increasing in any significant quantity https://t.co/9eluz10kFg
@WildfireWhisper Me too! I'm hoping it stops GAC, especially for children. The other ones I want to see destroyed is the Dutch Protocol for Juvenile Transsexuals and The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets. Those 2 have spawned a
Gender dysphoria: definition, diagnosis, treatment and challenges https://t.co/DLLPbgFuP4 via @YouTube
@justkiddin1984 @RTLnieuws Geen probleem, asteblaf: https://t.co/iowgXRP5Jv https://t.co/gvaWS4o7bt
@jerzKwasniewski A tutaj trochę badań dowodzących czemu wasz projekcik to szuria https://t.co/BryCE4Qedn https://t.co/p2g5FOpP4C https://t.co/A48pn0cQ0g https://t.co/OETGCSsvyN https://t.co/U8sO43MDz7 https://t.co/hOoqDIHXlN
@Suprsaiyanmura @JokerFactor1 @Collins__VG @BartoniScliff @TSS_13_ okay you asked for it! here's your homework: https://t.co/odXuNG6eOm https://t.co/gMhVfeftNy https://t.co/ApKftFBwS0 https://t.co/X1SBycjuVq https://t.co/5zxMP9M57B
@Suprsaiyanmura @JokerFactor1 @Collins__VG @BartoniScliff @TSS_13_ https://t.co/odXuNG6eOm here's a study that includes participants from 1972! isnt that wild!
RT @quizzicalsteve: @IanCopeland5 Only 0.6% of transwomen and 0.3% of transmen who underwent gonadectomy were identified as experiencing re…
@IanCopeland5 Only 0.6% of transwomen and 0.3% of transmen who underwent gonadectomy were identified as experiencing regret. https://t.co/W0x1WH4eKV
@HailieAB @SereneArc @TullipR https://t.co/mg2so331Fs
@PattyPeixinha @Malefici777 @patrizia Valutazione a lungo termine di Pazienti pre-puberi trattati con Triptorelina (C.M. Wiepjes, , Cohen-Kettenis et all) Però se insisti con un altro paio di twitt sono sicuro che le cose cambieranno e le nostre tasse saranno impiegate meglio. Coraggio!
@IzaPalinska @KatarzynaSzuml2 @Ariel80492037 @totylkoteoria @kayaszu @myslozbir Dane jak najbardziej są to że je zignorujesz lub nazwiesz je "zindoktrynowanymi przez trans lobby" czy coś tego nie zmienia https://t.co/yNU8KosQzI https://t.co/Afjj7kAdKc https://t.co/7nTZbH1w8u https://t.co/NUw6RKXyre https://t.co/urQfhdCzIy
RT @LestradeCM: @Opaopa13 @No7Sammy the five year thing isn't even true, there's a 40 year study they just ignore https://t.co/RNMwIKZEQX
@ProVitaFamiglia @M_Rachele Voi fanatici bigotti, oltre l'approccio medico-scientifico, quali altre soluzioni prevedete, terapie di conversione basate su preghiere, acqua santa e punizioni corporali? #troglobigots "Valutazione a lungo termine di pre-puberi trattati con Triptorelina" https://t.co/wCobJWKyuc
RT @LestradeCM: @Opaopa13 @No7Sammy the five year thing isn't even true, there's a 40 year study they just ignore https://t.co/RNMwIKZEQX
@_LadyBadger_ @startrekdaddy @AusSkeptic @imnotyomom @BarnoneB @detransaqua Netherland, study from 1972 to 2015, 6,793 trans people who had genital surgery. 0.3% regret rate for trans men, 0.6% regret rate for trans women https://t.co/Oe7xcZLazF US, study from 2016 to 2021, 1989 trans people who had surgery. 0.3% regret rate https://t.co/H7H6CXRYc3
feit: geen enkel andere medische behandeling kent zulke hoge tevredenheidsscores en zo'n laag percentage spijtoptanten pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29463477/
Dle medicínských záznamů v Nizozemsku dostalo 221 dětí pod 12 let blokátory puberty a k nim dalších 333 dalších nezletilých. Oproti 70. letům se počet MtF pacientů navýšil 7,8× a FtM 17,3×. Populace Nizozemska přitom vzrostla jenom 1,3×. https://t.co/XVuRdpm738
@DogLoverOfPI @ErinInTheMorn The source above is doi 10.1016/j.jsxm.2018.01.016. Their other is doi 10.1007/s10508-014-0300-8 , which states "There was a significant decline of regrets over the time [50 years] period", which ...
@KendraaZgaa @StevieS_Patriot @LibertyCappy OK, I found the full text and did a very brief review. The largest weighted study was this one: https://t.co/bpwLtTZci3 which only considered a person regretting their decision to undergo surgery if they came back to the same clinic to undergo a reversal surgery. So the
@csmeadows @ZackSpence99 @fuxblm @McGreevious_ @hutchinson Out by doing my own research. Maybe start with this. https://t.co/Llby4l1cuT https://t.co/cdXjI1s5kH https://t.co/oAIxiJW8Sq Plenty out there you just need to look.
RT @tilehopper: Wiepjes CM, et al. The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets…
Wiepjes CM, et al. The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets. Pfäfflin F, Junge A. Sex Reassignment. Thirty Years of International Follow-up Studies After Sex Reassignment Surgery: A Comprehensive Review, 1961-1991.
@tizon_tom @ckwadrat @totylkoteoria ...detranzycji, lub przerywa tranzycję, na przykład tutaj (tylko trzeba przeczytać całość, a nie jedynie abstrakt): https://t.co/N6pKH6UuJG
@gargoylesingrey @logical_psycho_ 19) Wiepjes, Nota, de Blok, Klaver, de Vries, Wensing-Kruger, de Jongh, Bouman, Steensma, Cohen-Kettenis, Gooren, Kreukels & den Heijer, (2018). The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets. JSM 15 (4).
@le1measkyouthis @MeganLarimer @s_e_t_h_w_ people aren't told that they need to transition or they'll kill themselves. also, here are two studies on detransition rates: https://t.co/K7AlcYPlTX https://t.co/VZ3kJppqa2
RT @somenuancepls: 21. Wiepjes et al, 2018 https://t.co/WTX5GWldVH 4863 patients underwent surgery, 14 expressed regrets (0.3%) * This is…
RT @somenuancepls: 21. Wiepjes et al, 2018 https://t.co/WTX5GWldVH 4863 patients underwent surgery, 14 expressed regrets (0.3%) * This is…
21. Wiepjes et al, 2018 https://t.co/WTX5GWldVH 4863 patients underwent surgery, 14 expressed regrets (0.3%) * This is a retrospective study (i.e., authors looked at medical records and did not follow up with patients directly).
@sundown_alley Wiepjes, C. M., Nota, N. M., de Blok, C. J., Klaver, M., de Vries, A. L., Wensing-Kruger, S. A., ... & den Heijer, M. (2018). "The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets." The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 15(4), 582-590
RT @JP2023ASP: @ABC Guy, who shot up the school, has a mental illness: https://t.co/UXmV6q7uD5
@ABC Guy, who shot up the school, has a mental illness: https://t.co/UXmV6q7uD5
@AshesAutumns @BarnickJason @Esqueer_ @IsaacAkap @CronynDrew “Original Research Transgender Health The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972–2015): Trends in Prevalence”
@JLCederblom How do you get the 2627 number? It isn't explicitly stated in the https://t.co/xycrJTBj2r And quick maffing table 1 you have total 5433 and 77.7 % had gonadectomy and the adolescent (after reaching 18...) 812 and 78.2 % getting 4856. https://t.co/AnCa5v2who
⚠️Deadly
@Sisterray63 @MonkeMa20831883 @AMZNSLAYER @ABC @TaraBull808 @TheDemocrats @GOP The Amsterdam cohort of gender dysphoria study (1972–2015): Trends in prevalence, treatment, and regrets. J Sex Med 2018;15:582–590. Crossref, Medline, Google Scholar
@elizamondegreen @sippyvanakker https://t.co/6Hrp0ixi2w
@barranoff @jessesingal The biggest study in that metaanlysis defined "regret" in people on cross sex hormones for 5 years, followed by gonadectomy. The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets
#GenderDysphoria: definition, diagnosis, treatment and challenges https://t.co/KLjmnCzGab via @YouTube
@Roishin_Rose @COCNederland Wiepjes, C. M., Nota, N. M., de Blok, C. J. M., Klaver, M., de Vries, A. L. C., Wensing-Kruger, S. A., den Heijer, M. (2018). The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972–2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets. The Journal of Sexual Medicine, 15(4), 582–590.
The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets - PubMed https://t.co/aEre2ZkFEG
@mousetitties @KhmerRougeSissy @twinkmodin Wiepjes et al, "The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets" (2018) [4] - found that hormone therapy and surgical intervention significantly reduce dysphoria, and that regret for surgery remains small. (7/10) https://t.co/d3w2ElQYlH
@horizonpoint23 @yummymuscle @mattxiv So, for the sources : The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972–2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets and Regret after Gender-affirmation Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Prevalence They agree that less than 1% of transgender have regrets
@conamorechiara di Wiepjes et al., The Amsterdam cohort of gender dysphoria study (1972–2015): trends in prevalence, treatment, and regrets. J Sex Med. 2018; 15:582–590 - è la bibbia degli studi per chi si occupa di transizione di genere ✨
RT @DutchessT_: @NOS Debunking van beweringen door de Trans campagne in comments: 1. "Spijt van transitie komt nauwelijks voor, is 0,5-1%."…
@NOS Debunking van beweringen door de Trans campagne in comments: 1. "Spijt van transitie komt nauwelijks voor, is 0,5-1%." ❌Studies met laag % spijt verloren veel patiënten gedurende follow-up. In studie van VUmc 36%. Hier zitten spijtoptanten in verborgen. https://t.co/puECql5cjx https://t.co/a5DZ7Qs8yo
"Gender dysphoria: definition, diagnosis, treatment and challenges" https://t.co/AV8RVKk892 #eddieizzard
RT @TPOnl: Op deze extreme minderheid zijn media en politiek dus zó extreem gefocust: "Het aantal mensen met genderdysforia in NL is offic…
RT @TPOnl: Op deze extreme minderheid zijn media en politiek dus zó extreem gefocust: "Het aantal mensen met genderdysforia in NL is offic…
RT @TPOnl: Op deze extreme minderheid zijn media en politiek dus zó extreem gefocust: "Het aantal mensen met genderdysforia in NL is offic…
Op deze extreme minderheid zijn media en politiek dus zó extreem gefocust: "Het aantal mensen met genderdysforia in NL is officieel 0,036 % mannen en 0,0193 % vrouwen (Wiepjes et al 2018 https://t.co/0PfF7x5XV9)" Via (in comments): https://t.co/V7KiW7jWRd
@AndrewR66191235 @RevTerfy @accioAMORE @lacroicsz Unsupported? https://t.co/w2AQKeQvHZ https://t.co/mRmRlvyYuW https://t.co/UsdIsbKrMb 1/2
@MountainGal18 @classamaroon @jessesingal source: https://t.co/FsQLvcAqLS
@Psychologiseren @kwakzalverij Schrikbarend hoge aantal spijtoptanten? Dat laat onderzoek niet zien, bijv. in NL: https://t.co/5PiSndRyMe
@Jusrangers https://t.co/OCg8xb8pUQ
@KatysCartoons For those interested to read more about how this regret rate was established, here is the full article. It is the average regret taken over the period 1972-2015 and is decreasing over time. https://t.co/inNKUwQsqS
@estherbeeee @uuuomo Bei Erwachsenen: https://t.co/Ub7bM8RuaS https://t.co/O2i8qkQvmK https://t.co/TdUSV9xmeQ
@amqg_ch @DrLauraEL @rothofharry https://t.co/fRZHlbWBvs To read without a paywall, find a working sci-hub instance and enter the DOI: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2018.01.016
@Display_Geek @BlanchardPhD @LisaLittman1 @YouTube Meanwhile, for the Netherlands, total prevalence of gender dysphoria is estimated at around 26 in 100,000 for MTF and 19 in 100,000 for FTM, in 2015, w increase in prevalence over time: https://t.co/YKS6D0wVoC This too is a lower bound-it only counts those at a single GIC.
@SsupMRC @TLJoshy Its not the best but i think its a beginning https://t.co/HfPmOpnDBO Sorry about my rude answer I have little tolerance for transphobic comments and i miss understood your intent
@BansheesRevenge @NaturalTop @logicxxreason @BlanchardPhD https://t.co/VsXJPCHhbV
@PolicyFact @toombytoomby @NaturalTop @logicxxreason @BlanchardPhD I think I expressed myself poorly: I meant that most who start HRT get it within five years of starting HRT. Sorry for the confusion. https://t.co/VsXJPCHhbV https://t.co/YpWmvqpTLC
https://t.co/LB3rAtDxyZ
@blueboatmom @pbuttercup11 Since there are no long term studies with sane definitions, we don't have a clue. There are some studies (https://t.co/XynyQ62z41, https://t.co/rYD0d3WtvI) that suggest 8+ years is common for cases with surgery.
@tovarischjana @MaioraAne @bazterrak En "The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in prevalence, treatment and regrets" hay una pérdida del 36% de pacientes durante el estudio, otros como "Long-Term Follw-Up of Adults with Gender Identity Disorder. Archives of Sexual Behavior" el 49,3...
The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study blijkt dat tussen 1972 en 2015 slechts 0.6% van de transgender vrouwen en 0.3% van de transgender mannen spijt bleken te hebben. Maar van na 1 juli 2014 zijn er geen cijfers https://t.co/7SEZzsm3IN
@BWLhoogendoorn @MathijsvdTang @Roishin_Rose https://t.co/cZyMRg8kbi Ik heb dit kunnen vinden
The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972–2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets https://t.co/HuTS0aPWI1
@ClaudiaLuisa16 @DerSchwede_nrm @LGBAlliance_DE Ich vermute stark, dass es um diese studie geht: "The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets". Wie man am Titel erkennen kann war ein Großteil der Studie vor 2010.
@TheOnlySprout @NHSEngland This study shows that transition-related regret is vanishingly small; between 0.6% and 0.3%. So the idea that there are a large number of regretters is quite simply false. https://t.co/3O3xBGtylP
** Print de Demystifying Medicine - https://t.co/0RteHhF6Bc **
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: Next they reference "The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Re…
@amyagirl64 @nuffyknuckles That seems to be an inaccurate statement, for example if we look at https://t.co/XynyQ62z41 and https://t.co/rYD0d3WtvI, for all their major problems they did find that regret and detransition is something that manifests years down the line.
@NeasaLee @michellelynn097 @gordon_slash @SoManyBats @ALLIANCELGB @miss_demeanour1 @Plaindaneaspie @AWifmann @seXXyLady10 @LeahtheMoon @EmilyBanting1 @CardinalLanded @psflaps @VaporwavNashira @Natme15 @CritFacts @EU_ScienceGeek @flyraccoonfly @intersexfacts @sylvander2 @gwennelsonuk @TransGirlTerra @comedy_joey @Carnard_Bastle @RosieDuffield1 @notCursedE @trustednerd @janeclarejones @Docstockk The "Amsterdam cohort" study is "The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972–2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets", which as you can see takes a lot more precious Twitter characters than "Amsterdam cohort".
Next they reference "The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets. (J Sex Med. 2018 Apr;15(4):582-590" This paper claims a 0.5% rate of regret, but define this as only the patients who make an app't to discuss regret.
@BrianEquator @socratic86 @michaelshermer In the largest study of its kind only 0.6% of transwomen and 0.3% of transmen who experienced regret in transitioning. https://t.co/ftjLXPzkFl Another study in Sweden backs these findings up. https://t.co/myatNKDTTX
@JimTimberthing @DebbieHayton @GeorgeTakei Yes, every procedure has risks; but some procedures are worth the risk. Also, no. Gender dysphoria is dangerous. Professionals recommend transitioning to most patients for a reason. https://t.co/smKZDHcdBd
@jk_rowling I'd like to clear up any misconception about trans people. There is a lot of science behind why people are trans. I can't fit it in a tweet so to educate yourself, I recommend these videos. https://t.co/YjP5vIMYw8 https://t.co/zdS1bVGEAG
Wiepjes C M, Nota N M, de Blok C J, et al. (2018). The Amsterdam cohort of gender dysphoria study (1972–2015): trends in prevalence, treatment, and regrets. The journal of sexual medicine, 15(4), 582-590.
@DrRachelHeath I found the study with Dutch numbers "only 0.6% of transwomen and 0.3% of transmen who underwent gonadectomy were identified as experiencing regret" The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets. https://t.co/kyxHMf2LAy
@scottberry912 @tomhfh The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (https://t.co/6iauBroUQ1 "a large follow-up study involving 6,793 people who transitioned from 1972 to 2015 indicated a regret rate of 0.5%. None of the people who indicated regret transitioned as an adolescent."
@Sven_Roman @SvD Kan även tipsa om denna: Wiepjes C M, Nota N M, de Blok C J, et al. (2018). The Amsterdam cohort of gender dysphoria study (1972–2015): trends in prevalence, treatment, and regrets. The journal of sexual medicine, 15(4), 582-590
The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972-2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets. - PubMed - NCBI https://t.co/ywKUt3TeQV
The Amsterdam Cohort of Gender Dysphoria Study (1972–2015): Trends in Prevalence, Treatment, and Regrets. Only 0.6% of transwomen and 0.3% of transmen who underwent gonadectomy were identified as experiencing regret. https://t.co/wA9T1EMWdO
@BayneMacGregor @munro_nell @Fizzsnap @raineyblue3 @stonewalluk This study found that only 1.9% of kids put on blockers do not go to cross-sex hormones. this is an issue bc we already know most kids with GD grow out of it: https://t.co/rsEtaAVrQx