Psychol Sci April 2018 PMID 29505339

To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses.

Victoria F Sisk, Alexander P Burgoyne, Jingze Sun, Jennifer L Butler, Brooke N Macnamara

Mentions

194
Peak: 19 in Jul 2019
across 6 sources since Nov 2018

Extended reach

1,089,378
potential audience

Total likes

9,828

Video views

309,255

Mentions per month

Nov 2018 – May 2025

Where it's discussed

  • X / Twitter129 posts
  • News39 articles
  • Blogs17 articles
  • Reddit4 posts
  • Facebook3 posts
  • YouTube2 videos

AI synopsis

What people are saying

The collection of discussions reflects a cautious tone, with many referencing key meta-analyses from 2018 showing weak effects of growth mindset on achievement, exemplified by phrases like 'overall effects were weak' and 'might be a mirage.' The tone and word choice—such as 'dumbest argument' or critiques of methodology—convey skepticism, indicating that these debates are more reflective and critical than optimistic or motivational.

AgreementLow agreement

Most discussions highlight the weak or negligible effects of growth mindset interventions based on recent meta-analyses, indicating skepticism about their importance.

InterestModerate interest

Participants show moderate curiosity, referencing multiple meta-analyses and debating methodological issues, but there is no overwhelming enthusiasm.

EngagementModerate engagement

Some posts delve into methodological critiques and discuss implications, demonstrating thoughtful engagement, but most are brief and focus on summarizing studies.

ImpactLow impact

The overall tone suggests that these discussions have limited practical impact, emphasizing that growth mindset effects are small and potentially overstated.

Top posts

Most liked on X and Bluesky
Dorothy Bishop
@deevybee · X

I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior studies with claimed positive effects, when there's many studies not finding this; e.g. see https://t.co/hyeT71ENMR https://t.co/4JIQzLyJ0b

Jul 14, 2019 · 59 likes · 22 shares · 36,864 followers View post →
特別期間
@periodoespecial · X

中室牧子氏の「能力より努力をほめられた子供の方が意欲は上がる」説は、ドゥエックとミューラーの論文を参照していると思われるが、それには再現性がないとの主張もある。 https://t.co/HttCoezmxQ https://t.co/vW5qz2cgRv 心理学の論文の7割はその後再現性がなかったという話もあるが、条件の… https://t.co/47GWT5VpeA

Nov 16, 2021 · 24 likes · 11 shares · 191 followers View post →
Yuta Kashino
@yutakashino · X

To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses - Victoria F. Sisk et al. 2018 https://t.co/fViDD67ZER 有名なキャロル・デュエックの「しなやかマインドセット」,メタアナリシスではほとんど効果無しと.なるほど…

Jun 26, 2019 · 14 likes · 3 shares · 14,747 followers View post →
Experimental Philosophy
@xphilosopher · X

Mindset interventions designed to promote "incremental theories" as opposed to "entity theories" of achievement don't seem to have nearly as much impact as we thought they did @VictoriaSisk2 @BrookeMacnamara https://t.co/iaX4ea0kAw

May 21, 2022 · 13 likes · 5 shares · 20,306 followers View post →
Talk for Teaching.
@PaulGarvey4 · X

@lovessinging1 @Mr_JTyers @deputygrocott @Toriaclaire @chrisdysonHT @RaeSnape @CensoredHead @theprimaryhead @MrTs_NQTs @dylanwiliam @Headteacherchat @EmmaGaunt5 @mr_bache Yes. Even the study to which Josh referred, shows that significant gains can be made by pupils of lower achievement by employing Growth Mindset. For other pupils, there are gains, but they are not strong. https://t.co/FiyxkZbUeD

Jun 20, 2020 · 7 likes · 2 shares · 101,464 followers View post →
Nicole Barbaro
@NicoleBarbaro · X

The two best and recent studies on growth mindset (GM) are a 2018 meta-analysis and a 2019 large scale intervention. The meta-analysis concluded that GM impacts are minimal, effect size around .10, but may show some impact for low SES + at risk students. https://t.co/THhSCwA0yr

Oct 12, 2022 · 7 likes · 1 share · 16,612 followers View post →

All mentions

ぼくの人生の主人公のむすこちゃん
@Grasshopper_www · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Jun 24, 2024 · 45 shares · 90 followers View post →
はげひげ(菊仙人)
@96hage · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Jun 23, 2024 · 45 shares · 5,804 followers View post →
Meedo21
@xXMRmeedo21Xx · X

@loui450 @hubermanlab @AliaCrum What about this huge double meta analysis that shows the there is little to no correlation between growth mindset and achievement, the same for growth mindset intervention @hubermanlab @AliaCrum https://t.co/yrkNFK9FAY

Jan 25, 2024 · 1 like · 6 followers View post →
トキワエイスケ
@etokiwa999 · X

@sayaka03150915 マインドセット、効果がない研究結果はある 1、マインドセットで学校の成績は上がるのか調べなおしたところ、あまり影響はなかった https://t.co/pB1cQGkfMd 2、マインドセットに関する63の研究をまとめたうえで、大半の実験には複数の間違いがあると報告 https://t.co/loyY5vJS6a 参考まで

Nov 15, 2023 · 1,179 followers View post →
トキワエイスケ
@etokiwa999 · X

マインドセット、効果がない研究結果はある 1、マインドセットで学校の成績は上がるのか調べなおしたところ、あまり影響はなかった https://t.co/pB1cQGkfMd 2、マインドセットに関する63の研究をまとめたうえで、大半の実験には複数の間違いがあると報告 https://t.co/loyY5vJS6a https://t.co/I78VXAocTc

Nov 15, 2023 · 2 likes · 1,179 followers View post →
おみみ
@omiminomura · X

@DrYametai https://t.co/ibOYXUGp9F

Aug 14, 2023 · 1 like · 466 followers View post →
Joel Fish
@joelwatsonfish · X

@PsychRabble Not 100% sure, but I think this one: https://t.co/XjAJEIQYEH

Jul 19, 2023 · 1 like · 1,408 followers View post →
Todd Pugatch
@toddpugatch · X

@JohnHolbein1 Yikes. An earlier meta-analysis didn't address study flaws so much, but found similar results. This is why we can't have nice things. https://t.co/RU42s2OfOA

Jul 18, 2023 · 2 likes · 487 followers View post →
UX Design | Andrew Lipski
@ux_andrew84 · X

@hubermanlab There were those two meta-analyses in 2018 that hit Growth Mindest hard. Victoria F. Sisk, Alexander P. Burgoyne, Jingze Sun, Jennifer L. Butler, Brooke N. Macnamara. "To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement?"

Jul 5, 2023 · 113 followers View post →
Mike Axelrod
@miaxelrod · X

Some things aren't what they seem... https://t.co/wYjOGjT1oC

Nov 18, 2022 · 151 followers View post →
closty-sportpsyc
@CiaraLosty · X

RT @sportpsychWIT: To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses -…

Nov 15, 2022 · 1 share · 2,814 followers View post →
sportpsychSETU
@sportpsychWIT · X

To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses - Victoria F. Sisk, Alexander P. Burgoyne, Jingze Sun, Jennifer L. Butler, Brooke N. Macnamara, 2018 https://t.co/F3trFQbyKu

Nov 14, 2022 · 1 like · 1 share · 2,294 followers View post →
Dr. Paul Penn
@Dr_Paul_Penn · X

Two further meta-analyses about Growth Mindset reported here. https://t.co/4hhN2R1Qi8

Nov 14, 2022 · 6 likes · 2,870 followers View post →
Sander Koole
@SLKoole · X

RT @NicoleBarbaro: The two best and recent studies on growth mindset (GM) are a 2018 meta-analysis and a 2019 large scale intervention. Th…

Oct 12, 2022 · 1 share · 2,236 followers View post →
Nicole Barbaro
@NicoleBarbaro · X

The two best and recent studies on growth mindset (GM) are a 2018 meta-analysis and a 2019 large scale intervention. The meta-analysis concluded that GM impacts are minimal, effect size around .10, but may show some impact for low SES + at risk students. https://t.co/THhSCwA0yr

Oct 12, 2022 · 7 likes · 1 share · 16,612 followers View post →
伊利
@MAGA_Nerd · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Oct 10, 2022 · 45 shares · 632 followers View post →
The Diet Buddhist
@TheDietBuddhist · X

This is the DUMBEST fucking argument for doing more work than what your job title pays for There is NO evidence to support this viewpoint, NONE And a TON to contradict it: https://t.co/jEbLQKyiyN https://t.co/y6aTh8TlSX https://t.co/DkArQJOXzA

Aug 24, 2022 · 15 followers View post →
加藤 51
@fareaststyle51 · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Aug 24, 2022 · 45 shares · 1,843 followers View post →
hitonoia
@hitonoia · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Aug 17, 2022 · 45 shares · 1,709 followers View post →
Paul W Bennett
@Educhatter · X

Scrutinizing Psychological Theory: Is #GrowthMindset Overblown in its Effect on Student Achievement? Two 2018 Meta-Analyses suggest effect is small and that it might be a mirage. Hard work and perseverance may matter more @researchEDCan @EdCanNet #cdned https://t.co/qf7hDrTc4q

Jun 29, 2022 · 1 like · 5,932 followers View post →
Dr Sally Larsen
@SallyLars_27 · X

@johncosgrove405 @Aintropy @everettis1 I would read wider than Dweck's work too. This 2x meta-analysis for a start, concludes "Overall effects (for growth mindset) were weak for both meta-analyses" https://t.co/qQduaPmxVB

Jun 7, 2022 · 2 likes · 1,236 followers View post →
nabeso
@nabeso · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Jun 2, 2022 · 45 shares · 1,168 followers View post →
のとす㌠
@notos2 · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Jun 2, 2022 · 45 shares · 394 followers View post →
カズマ@ゲムマ秋11/22(土) P59
@_kazuma0221 · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Jun 2, 2022 · 45 shares · 1,217 followers View post →
世紀末敗者@チャッキー・こけし
@NOJIMAXRACING · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Jun 2, 2022 · 45 shares · 291 followers View post →
よんなな
@yonnnana · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Jun 2, 2022 · 45 shares · 2,506 followers View post →
ゆなす(juner.net)
@juners · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Jun 2, 2022 · 45 shares · 4,134 followers View post →
Tobias Wingen
@WingenTobias · X

RT @xphilosopher: Mindset interventions designed to promote "incremental theories" as opposed to "entity theories" of achievement don't see…

May 27, 2022 · 5 shares · 1,036 followers View post →
Sander Koole
@SLKoole · X

RT @xphilosopher: Mindset interventions designed to promote "incremental theories" as opposed to "entity theories" of achievement don't see…

May 27, 2022 · 5 shares · 2,236 followers View post →
Benny Prawira Siauw
@bennysiauw89 · X

RT @xphilosopher: Mindset interventions designed to promote "incremental theories" as opposed to "entity theories" of achievement don't see…

May 22, 2022 · 5 shares · 30,911 followers View post →
Shane McLoughlin
@DrShaneMcL · X

RT @xphilosopher: Mindset interventions designed to promote "incremental theories" as opposed to "entity theories" of achievement don't see…

May 22, 2022 · 5 shares · 954 followers View post →
Yury.
@ytspar · X

RT @xphilosopher: Mindset interventions designed to promote "incremental theories" as opposed to "entity theories" of achievement don't see…

May 22, 2022 · 5 shares · 1,254 followers View post →
Experimental Philosophy
@xphilosopher · X

Mindset interventions designed to promote "incremental theories" as opposed to "entity theories" of achievement don't seem to have nearly as much impact as we thought they did @VictoriaSisk2 @BrookeMacnamara https://t.co/iaX4ea0kAw

May 21, 2022 · 13 likes · 5 shares · 20,306 followers View post →
Dr Sally Larsen
@SallyLars_27 · X

@mikesalter74 @greg_ashman Having just done my annual "growth mindset critical evaluation of the literature" lecture for 4th yr psych honors students, I'd say this result was pretty typical for GM research. This meta analysis is a really great summary - esp the effect size figures https://t.co/xdMUKCMjHe

Apr 18, 2022 · 2 likes · 1,236 followers View post →
ianrobertson
@ihrobertson · X

@WiringTheBrain I weight science over plausibility - see the meta-analyses. No dogs, no fight! https://t.co/Kkkh7l5Agh https://t.co/vuEOJdLFEp https://t.co/YICGo5momp https://t.co/utVl23YU6p

Feb 21, 2022 · 1 like · 6,010 followers View post →
Shin Okada
@nshinshi_ · X

RT @periodoespecial: 中室牧子氏の「能力より努力をほめられた子供の方が意欲は上がる」説は、ドゥエックとミューラーの論文を参照していると思われるが、それには再現性がないとの主張もある。 https://t.co/HttCoezmxQ https://t.c…

Dec 16, 2021 · 11 shares · 191 followers View post →
.
@ferurferur · X

RT @periodoespecial: 中室牧子氏の「能力より努力をほめられた子供の方が意欲は上がる」説は、ドゥエックとミューラーの論文を参照していると思われるが、それには再現性がないとの主張もある。 https://t.co/HttCoezmxQ https://t.c…

Nov 19, 2021 · 11 shares · 209 followers View post →
(ΦωΦ) 祝園(*ΦωΦ*)
@Housono · X

RT @periodoespecial: 中室牧子氏の「能力より努力をほめられた子供の方が意欲は上がる」説は、ドゥエックとミューラーの論文を参照していると思われるが、それには再現性がないとの主張もある。 https://t.co/HttCoezmxQ https://t.c…

Nov 18, 2021 · 11 shares · 384 followers View post →
Ishida the Brain Damaged
@tbs_i · X

RT @periodoespecial: 中室牧子氏の「能力より努力をほめられた子供の方が意欲は上がる」説は、ドゥエックとミューラーの論文を参照していると思われるが、それには再現性がないとの主張もある。 https://t.co/HttCoezmxQ https://t.c…

Nov 18, 2021 · 11 shares · 352 followers View post →
黒木玄 Gen Kuroki
@genkuroki · X

RT @periodoespecial: 中室牧子氏の「能力より努力をほめられた子供の方が意欲は上がる」説は、ドゥエックとミューラーの論文を参照していると思われるが、それには再現性がないとの主張もある。 https://t.co/HttCoezmxQ https://t.c…

Nov 17, 2021 · 11 shares · 15,566 followers View post →
天むす名古屋 Temmus
@temmusu_n · X

RT @periodoespecial: 中室牧子氏の「能力より努力をほめられた子供の方が意欲は上がる」説は、ドゥエックとミューラーの論文を参照していると思われるが、それには再現性がないとの主張もある。 https://t.co/HttCoezmxQ https://t.c…

Nov 17, 2021 · 11 shares · 884 followers View post →
RochejacMonmo
@RochejacMonmo · X

RT @periodoespecial: 中室牧子氏の「能力より努力をほめられた子供の方が意欲は上がる」説は、ドゥエックとミューラーの論文を参照していると思われるが、それには再現性がないとの主張もある。 https://t.co/HttCoezmxQ https://t.c…

Nov 17, 2021 · 11 shares · 1,152 followers View post →
もむ
@momentumyy · X

RT @periodoespecial: 中室牧子氏の「能力より努力をほめられた子供の方が意欲は上がる」説は、ドゥエックとミューラーの論文を参照していると思われるが、それには再現性がないとの主張もある。 https://t.co/HttCoezmxQ https://t.c…

Nov 17, 2021 · 11 shares · 2,740 followers View post →
特別期間
@periodoespecial · X

中室牧子氏の「能力より努力をほめられた子供の方が意欲は上がる」説は、ドゥエックとミューラーの論文を参照していると思われるが、それには再現性がないとの主張もある。 https://t.co/HttCoezmxQ https://t.co/vW5qz2cgRv 心理学の論文の7割はその後再現性がなかったという話もあるが、条件の… https://t.co/47GWT5VpeA

Nov 16, 2021 · 24 likes · 11 shares · 191 followers View post →
John McIntosh
@jrsmcintoshNI · X

7. A 2018 meta-analysis of GM interventions by Victoria Sisk and others suggested overall weak effects, although the paper recognised positive effects for low-income students and those at academic risk… https://t.co/C85z3cu45H

Nov 3, 2021 · 6 likes · 474 followers View post →
北村生
@ikur · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Oct 31, 2021 · 45 shares · 2,277 followers View post →
Simon Fleming
@OrthopodReg · X

RT @JacAshby: To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses #ICRE2…

Oct 20, 2021 · 1 share · 53,467 followers View post →
J. Ashby
@JacAshby · X

To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses #ICRE2021 https://t.co/VegPaoIDrn

Oct 20, 2021 · 4 likes · 1 share · 240 followers View post →
zenoist.republican @anarchomorphist.bsky.social
@anarchomorphist · X

@shovnr @sbkaufman Sure, but on the flip side there are also problems with the modern "growth" rhetoric. Does this inherently invalidate its value? If it doesn't then we can also admit that the acceptance rhetoric has its value too https://t.co/5ZjlTsnLxT

Oct 4, 2021 · 1,516 followers View post →
Better Learning Experiences
@BetterLearning8 · X

Sisk, V. F., Burgoyne, A. P., Sun, J., Butler, J. L., Macnamara, B. N. (2018). To what extent and under which circumstances are Growth MIND-SETS important to academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses. Psychological Science, 29(4), 549–571. https://t.co/VfvCYJPbcZ

Sep 27, 2021 · 1 like · 62 followers View post →
Geoff Lewis
@GeoffLewis_ · X

@sventurac @allthingsphd @PhDVoice @AcademicChatter This 2018 paper provides two interesting meta analyses on the existing research on mindset specifically and has further links to other studies: https://t.co/ik5PZrCElK

Aug 25, 2021 · 2 likes · 195 followers View post →
Claudia Lewis
@MBDscience · X

He criticises the methodology of some of the "DIKR lobby studies" which is fair enough, but then he talks about growth mindset. You can't have it both ways. (There have been issues with the reproducibility of Dweck's findings, also: https://t.co/5IJjZFNXCb )

Aug 19, 2021 · 1 like · 5,547 followers View post →
そくらてす
@7danmoroboshi · X

RT @askoma: その記事は存じませんでした。僕が知ってたのはこちらの論文です。 https://t.co/3XhDYLL66X

Jun 27, 2021 · 1 share · 1,986 followers View post →
あすこま
@askoma · X

その記事は存じませんでした。僕が知ってたのはこちらの論文です。 https://t.co/3XhDYLL66X https://t.co/8Ytg6UcCsa

Jun 27, 2021 · 3 likes · 1 share · 11,337 followers View post →
Christian Bokhove
@cbokhove · X

In the presentation Dylan referred to this meta-analysis on mindset by Sisk et al. and that one actually has some other publication bias methods as well including p-curve. Agree that indeed ‘exemplary’! https://t.co/UlR6KUcAew

Jun 22, 2021 · 2 likes · 6,223 followers View post →
Haryo Aswicahyono
@Aswicahyono · X

RT @SherlockGantan: @ThereseClaire_ @Aswicahyono https://t.co/u9elgFkIvI

Apr 29, 2021 · 1 share · 15,084 followers View post →
Ganetika
@SherlockGantan · X

@ThereseClaire_ @Aswicahyono https://t.co/u9elgFkIvI

Apr 29, 2021 · 2 likes · 1 share · 2,472 followers View post →
マルゴ@typo105
@typo105 · X

マインドセット本を引用して書いたところで、マインドセット微妙かもメタ分析を見てしまい悲しみに。エビデンスあるといっても、後のメタ分析で覆ったり、それがまた覆ったりで

Mar 23, 2021 · 1 like · 272 followers View post →
パース
@Peirce39 · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 21, 2021 · 45 shares · 431 followers View post →
Richard Hughes-Jones
@rhughesjones · X

I can't take any more of this

Mar 19, 2021 · 2 likes · 2,245 followers View post →
アザーン
@taihanrom · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 15, 2021 · 45 shares · 216 followers View post →
ふみ
@snitori · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 14, 2021 · 45 shares · 3,630 followers View post →
危ないサル
@odoro8 · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 14, 2021 · 45 shares · 2,491 followers View post →
know thyself(子豚のオリバー)
@thyself_know · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 14, 2021 · 45 shares · 1,226 followers View post →
N
@bludgeoning_ten · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 14, 2021 · 45 shares · 275 followers View post →
脂身生ハム
@ABURAMI9641 · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 14, 2021 · 45 shares · 536 followers View post →
カイテル
@LassieHarvey · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 14, 2021 · 45 shares · 416 followers View post →
Teruichi
@teruichi81 · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 13, 2021 · 45 shares · 293 followers View post →
tsukip@FF外から失礼します♪
@o_tsukip · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 13, 2021 · 45 shares · 792 followers View post →
Kanade Akiyoshi
@KanadeAkiyoshi · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 13, 2021 · 45 shares · 506 followers View post →
ひきた ぶんごろう
@hikita_bungorou · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 13, 2021 · 45 shares · 482 followers View post →
石部統久
@mototchen · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 13, 2021 · 45 shares · 1,093 followers View post →
紀伊ニゴ
@nigo · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 13, 2021 · 45 shares · 866 followers View post →
tociss
@tociss · X

RT @ykamit: こういうメタアナリシスも https://t.co/hBCxbRbsxd 全体に効果は弱いが、社会経済地位が低いグループには効くかも

Mar 13, 2021 · 45 shares · 13,073 followers View post →
Mathias Hasse
@mhsousa · X

[1] https://t.co/dFPLtAkjxA [2] https://t.co/kUozk430E0 [3] https://t.co/6quAq8hmP4 [4] https://t.co/p3sB24giQs

Jan 11, 2021 · 2 likes · 4 shares · 734 followers View post →
JabroniCoin.USD
@TheBenSchmark · X

@DanielSLoeb1 https://t.co/tx1ehGJlmZ https://t.co/Vs0tO1FAVg

Dec 13, 2020 · 1 like · 5,945 followers View post →
天むす名古屋 Temmus
@temmusu_n · X

RT @LeisurePrince: @NT19890524 成長マインドセット(努力次第で変えられるという信念)と学業成績の関係性は弱い。https://t.co/jYRLigXENi

Dec 12, 2020 · 2 shares · 884 followers View post →
諸遊戯
@shoyugi · X

RT @LeisurePrince: @NT19890524 成長マインドセット(努力次第で変えられるという信念)と学業成績の関係性は弱い。https://t.co/jYRLigXENi

Dec 12, 2020 · 2 shares · 2,672 followers View post →
Kiran Johny
@johnywrites · X

@bartderre To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyse https://t.co/e5MgRvp7yE

Nov 6, 2020 · 955 followers View post →
Sean Lyons, PhD
@proflyons · X

@FiRawle @AcademicChatter Let's keep pulling this thread and talk about mindset...the other darling of proponents of teaching interventions https://t.co/QVW9BCBxx8

Nov 1, 2020 · 738 followers View post →
Research in Education - Ontario Tech
@OT_FEDgrad · X

To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth MindSets Important to Academic Achievement? Students with low socioeconomic status or who are academically at risk might benefit from mindset interventions https://t.co/ChORTW0SIj #growthmindset #edresearch #otumed https://t.co/vvg1D5qxYC

Oct 25, 2020 · 3 likes · 5,557 followers View post →
Daiki Nakamura
@d_nakamuran · X

@NT19890524 成長マインドセット(努力次第で変えられるという信念)と学業成績の関係性は弱い。https://t.co/jYRLigXENi

Aug 8, 2020 · 6 likes · 2 shares · 1,572 followers View post →
infra
@infra_cave · X

@DavidLcitizen @OlivierBabeau "Overall effects were weak [for growth mindset] for both meta-analyses. However, some results supported [...] that students with low socioeconomic status or who are academically at risk might benefit from mind-set interventions." https://t.co/WisYJaaCzm

Jul 30, 2020 · 53 followers View post →
Yuta Kashino
@yutakashino · X

Testing the association of growth mindset and grades across a challenging transition: Is growth mindset associated with grades? https://t.co/rO6HSayt7P デュエックのグロース・マインドセットの再現がまた失敗….メタアナリシスではその効果は疑問視されてます. https://t.co/fViDD67ZER

Jul 19, 2020 · 1 like · 14,747 followers View post →
18 Years A Head - NPQEL
@RaeSnape · X

RT @PaulGarvey4: @lovessinging1 @Mr_JTyers @deputygrocott @Toriaclaire @chrisdysonHT @RaeSnape @CensoredHead @theprimaryhead @MrTs_NQTs @dy…

Jun 20, 2020 · 2 shares · 22,311 followers View post →
Chris Dyson FCCT
@chrisdysonHT · X

RT @PaulGarvey4: @lovessinging1 @Mr_JTyers @deputygrocott @Toriaclaire @chrisdysonHT @RaeSnape @CensoredHead @theprimaryhead @MrTs_NQTs @dy…

Jun 20, 2020 · 2 shares · 48,024 followers View post →
Talk for Teaching.
@PaulGarvey4 · X

@lovessinging1 @Mr_JTyers @deputygrocott @Toriaclaire @chrisdysonHT @RaeSnape @CensoredHead @theprimaryhead @MrTs_NQTs @dylanwiliam @Headteacherchat @EmmaGaunt5 @mr_bache Yes. Even the study to which Josh referred, shows that significant gains can be made by pupils of lower achievement by employing Growth Mindset. For other pupils, there are gains, but they are not strong. https://t.co/FiyxkZbUeD

Jun 20, 2020 · 7 likes · 2 shares · 101,464 followers View post →
Tom Joyce
@atomicjoy · X

RT @EricCrampton: The hook for this morning's column was the weakness of evidence around 'growth mindset' interventions https://t.co/6UGqB…

May 4, 2020 · 2 shares · 522 followers View post →
Lewis Garrad
@LewisGarrad · X

RT @LewisGarrad: To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses: ht…

Mar 18, 2020 · 1 share · 14,409 followers View post →
Carl Hendrick
@C_Hendrick · X

@adamboxer1 This is a significant one: https://t.co/7sqtYOeD5Z

Mar 5, 2020 · 6 likes · 38,865 followers View post →
Peter Pun
@eltplanning · X

@Toriaclaire Loads of responses so prob linked already, but worth reading Sisk et al (2018) https://t.co/pdaEMQsJgB

Feb 29, 2020 · 2 likes · 3,016 followers View post →
Amy Bernath
@mybernath · X

@DaveEvansPhD Interesting! Potential connection here to meta-analysis on growth mindset in high income countries that shows impact primarily with academic at-risk and low SES student populations https://t.co/5L21D5Jpl4

Feb 5, 2020 · 1 like · 271 followers View post →
Matthieu Chabert
@matt_chabert · X

@anthilemoon Funny I just stumbled into this article in my twitter feed earlier today wdyt? https://t.co/7PHB60ogvV

Jan 28, 2020 · 157 followers View post →
Lewis Garrad
@LewisGarrad · X

To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses: https://t.co/0C1oBv6UWh

Jan 25, 2020 · 1 share · 14,409 followers View post →
Federico Vaggi
@F_Vaggi · X

@rickstonkin @Noahpinion Later measurements of the growth mindset showed that it had a much smaller than initially supposed: https://t.co/30FrYrv84x & https://t.co/dSe02R7ion at best, it has a small positive effect on underperforming students.

Dec 31, 2019 · 3 likes · 1,911 followers View post →
ゆうな
@sandyxw1 · X

RT @RayGowlett: @jcaru19 @NumCog @joboaler @EducationNext @macd97 @SheldonKeefe Cool! Thank you! Mindset is the growth mindset proposed by…

Dec 19, 2019 · 1 share · 70 followers View post →
RayGowlett
@RayGowlett · X

@jcaru19 @NumCog @joboaler @EducationNext @macd97 @SheldonKeefe Cool! Thank you! Mindset is the growth mindset proposed by @joboaler. The issue seems to be that when the attempt is made to 'prove' it with RCTs that can demonstrate causality, there is mostly a zero effect and often lowers academic performance. https://t.co/2o252ac3aq

Dec 18, 2019 · 1 share · 244 followers View post →
RayGowlett
@RayGowlett · X

@joboaler @NumCog @EducationNext Ad hominem. Good one. Now we can completely ignore the central claims. (...doesn't seem like you're much of a stranger to that strategy...) While we're on the topic, still waiting for your response to this paper. (I've asked more than a few times.) https://t.co/2o252ac3aq

Dec 18, 2019 · 6 likes · 244 followers View post →
Donald Clark
@DonaldClark · X

@julianstodd See here.. correlation but weak... https://t.co/0hUFpG31jX

Dec 9, 2019 · 1 like · 15,384 followers View post →
Dr. Anna Radke
@aradprof · X

@drhunger Is it this? https://t.co/VtsLVJGUZG

Aug 5, 2019 · 1 like · 2,228 followers View post →
Ramón Nogueras
@RamonNogueras · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 22, 2019 · 22 shares · 41,969 followers View post →
Fernando Blanco
@FBpsy · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 22, 2019 · 22 shares · 7,924 followers View post →
Andreas Lieberoth
@lieberothdk · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 22, 2019 · 22 shares · 3,317 followers View post →
Evander
@Hereditarian98 · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 21, 2019 · 22 shares · 2,262 followers View post →
Fiona O'Neill
@Fi_Contextual · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 21, 2019 · 22 shares · 4,689 followers View post →
Russell T. Warne
@Russwarne · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 21, 2019 · 22 shares · 7,712 followers View post →
Piping Gorst
@Piping_Gorst · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 15, 2019 · 22 shares · 49 followers View post →
Toby Payne-Cook
@CREducATE · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 15, 2019 · 22 shares · 2,171 followers View post →
Sue Gerrard
@suzyg001 · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 15, 2019 · 22 shares · 2,466 followers View post →
Christian Miller
@CharacterGap · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 14, 2019 · 22 shares · 5,237 followers View post →
Oleg Urminsky
@OlegUrminsky · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 14, 2019 · 22 shares · 3,986 followers View post →
Dr Caro Rowland
@CaroRowland · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 14, 2019 · 22 shares · 3,948 followers View post →
EvidenceIntoPractice
@Nick_J_Rose · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 14, 2019 · 22 shares · 5,302 followers View post →
Krishna Regmi
@Krishnaregmi186 · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 14, 2019 · 22 shares · 179 followers View post →
Kevin Mitchell
@WiringTheBrain · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 14, 2019 · 22 shares · 40,363 followers View post →
Tiziana Metitieri
@timetit · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 14, 2019 · 22 shares · 2,556 followers View post →
Richard Freeman
@RPJF68 · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 14, 2019 · 22 shares · 358 followers View post →
@jamesfern.bsky.social
@JamesFern83 · X

RT @deevybee: I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior…

Jul 14, 2019 · 22 shares · 1,649 followers View post →
Dorothy Bishop
@deevybee · X

I'm reading more on growth mindset research following EEF null trial. Concerned that the report introduction cites only prior studies with claimed positive effects, when there's many studies not finding this; e.g. see https://t.co/hyeT71ENMR https://t.co/4JIQzLyJ0b

Jul 14, 2019 · 59 likes · 22 shares · 36,864 followers View post →
Kazuhiko Fujiyama
@quantumbtc · X

RT @yutakashino: To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses - V…

Jun 28, 2019 · 3 shares · 247 followers View post →
レッサーパンダ♀Lesserpanda
@21centurypanda · X

RT @yutakashino: To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses - V…

Jun 26, 2019 · 3 shares · 349 followers View post →
天候
@hixxxxki0 · X

RT @yutakashino: To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses - V…

Jun 26, 2019 · 3 shares · 461 followers View post →
Yuta Kashino
@yutakashino · X

To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses - Victoria F. Sisk et al. 2018 https://t.co/fViDD67ZER 有名なキャロル・デュエックの「しなやかマインドセット」,メタアナリシスではほとんど効果無しと.なるほど…

Jun 26, 2019 · 14 likes · 3 shares · 14,747 followers View post →
パース
@Peirce39 · X

RT @myuuko: 知能に関する成長マインドセット(vs. 固定マインドセット)が学業成績に与える影響をメタ分析。効果は小さいが、低SESや学業が苦手な子には成長マインドセットの介入が効果的だよという研究。/ To What Extent and Under Which C…

May 27, 2019 · 7 shares · 431 followers View post →
パース
@Peirce39 · X

RT @uranus_2: 知能は努力しだいで高められるという考えと学績との関連は弱い。しかし、社会経済的地位が低かったり、学業的なリスクが高いと、成長マインドセットを促すことで、学績が高まりやすい。メタ分析。To What Extent and Under Which Cir…

May 27, 2019 · 9 shares · 431 followers View post →
ἀλήθεια
@Kaukning · X

To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses - Victoria F. Sisk, Alexander P. Burgoyne, Jingze Sun, Jennifer L. Butler, Brooke N. Macnamara, 2018 https://t.co/CXExEtGupz

May 19, 2019 · 85 followers View post →
ohmohm
@ohmohm · X

RT @ohmohm: Asymmetry ? https://t.co/FBtVSgAyFP doi:10.1177/0956797617739704

Mar 16, 2019 · 1 share · 3,752 followers View post →
Russell T. Warne
@Russwarne · X

This should be a #psychology scandal. I wish the authors had named the researcher because that person is actively contributing to the #replication crisis in psychology and publication bias. https://t.co/nzjQR6qhvC https://t.co/4zBHr2EUYy

Mar 14, 2019 · 1 like · 7,712 followers View post →
ohmohm
@ohmohm · X

Asymmetry ? https://t.co/FBtVSgAyFP doi:10.1177/0956797617739704

Feb 4, 2019 · 1 share · 3,752 followers View post →