Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
The discussions reveal both support and critique of the genetic and archaeological interpretations, exemplified by comments referencing seminal studies (such as Damgaard et al. 2018) and questioning conclusions about migrations and cultural diffusion, with tone varying from analytical to skeptical, indicating active engagement with the article’s implications for understanding ancient Eurasian history.
Most discussions agree that the findings challenge simplistic narratives about Indo-European migrations and emphasize the complexity of ancient population movements.
The discourse is highly engaging, with many referencing specific studies and debates, indicating strong interest in ancient genetics and cultural history.
Participants analyze methodologies and implications, showing a moderate level of deep engagement, especially regarding genetic evidence and historical interpretations.
The conversations highlight that the article influences ongoing debates in archaeology and genetics, potentially reshaping understanding of early Bronze Age expansions and language spread.
MAKALE ELEŞTİRİSİ İlk atlı çobanlar ve erken Tunç Çağı bozkır genişlemelerinin Asya'ya etkisi The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia Yamnaya kültüründen göçler üzerine "popülist genetikçilik”⬇️ https://t.co/WFi5btEZEm
The fact that SC Asian ancient populations are very good proxies for the Iranian component in Indians was well known since Damgaard et al 2016 who first published an ancient SC Asian sample from 3200 bce Namazga. https://t.co/D2TymiJtGr https://t.co/L80tLQ0H0J
نتائج لرفات من تركيا تعود لحقبة الحيثيون احداها نشرت هنا في مشجرة Yfull [https://t.co/6ijz9h1XOI](https://t.co/cROYr6hrIR) العينات من دراسة: The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia https://t.co/BtidzUNBzz
@BiniciDeprem Örnek bu makaleden: https://t.co/xqeVxpJYAZ
Taylor & Barron-Ortiz Rethinking the evidence for early horse domestication at Botai https://t.co/lXFnxw0NWm Damgaard et al The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia https://t.co/zTGF5OLXTn
The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia | Science https://t.co/m91Yrfo8K6
Explore the Indo-European language family's complexities, challenging the notion that everything is known. Recent research indicates significant gene flow from West Asia into Anatolia, suggesting a different origin for…
@grok @hailo_berto Grok çarpıtıyor ve avrupanın aryan hint-avrupa merkezli kendilerini dünyanın fatihi olarak gördüğü saçma tarih anlatışına kaptırıyorsun gerçekler ise Damgaard et al., Science, 2018, DOI: 10.1126/science.aar7711 Di Cosmo (2002), Ancient China and Its Enemies; Beckwith (2009), https://t.co/lWZvZ9FUd3
@BiniciDeprem Örnek bu makaleden: https://t.co/xqeVxpJYAZ
@gargivach Read this eLetters (not the article): https://t.co/lS6v1uqVeU Admixture analysis is fraudulent & goes against ur logical claims here & the textbook axioms (higher diversity = native) the opposite of your tweets. (1/2)
@razibkhan No Evidence Yamnaya groups migrated to India in the timeframe to unite the languages: https://t.co/hDfMhIvDij No Iranian farmer or Steppe Pastoral genome to support the conquest theory the idea of an Indo-European language tree hinged on: https://t.co/BFxQeCzRLh https://t.co/mBJnccCIgO
RT @AnadoluTarihii: MAKALE ELEŞTİRİSİ İlk atlı çobanlar ve erken Tunç Çağı bozkır genişlemelerinin Asya'ya etkisi The first horse herders…
RT @AnadoluTarihii: MAKALE ELEŞTİRİSİ İlk atlı çobanlar ve erken Tunç Çağı bozkır genişlemelerinin Asya'ya etkisi The first horse herders…
RT @AnadoluTarihii: MAKALE ELEŞTİRİSİ İlk atlı çobanlar ve erken Tunç Çağı bozkır genişlemelerinin Asya'ya etkisi The first horse herders…
RT @AnadoluTarihii: MAKALE ELEŞTİRİSİ İlk atlı çobanlar ve erken Tunç Çağı bozkır genişlemelerinin Asya'ya etkisi The first horse herders…
MAKALE ELEŞTİRİSİ İlk atlı çobanlar ve erken Tunç Çağı bozkır genişlemelerinin Asya'ya etkisi The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia Yamnaya kültüründen göçler üzerine "popülist genetikçilik”⬇️ https://t.co/WFi5btEZEm
@duygu_pinkhouse @UmitSiraci https://t.co/HENzCQS56t https://t.co/wAMyM4xC68 Makalenin sonuç kısmında değilinilmiş.
@Harvard @ChrisStringer65 @BarackObama @damasiousc @APApsychiatric @MIT @APA The lack of steppe ancestry in samples from Anatolia indicates that the spread of the earliest branch of IE languages into that region was not associated with a major population migration from the steppe. Source: https://t.co/SucJvhRLJi https://t.co/lQJmzXbmFh
https://t.co/7jwh0iVbsS Who thinks these are our candidates for centaurs? Chiron training Hercules unit on Olympus? Remember hero/terrorist training camp to take over the old Greek titan kings. I’m being fair to some a hero. To others face down beheaded in a ditch (terrorist).
@LC3OnFeminists @JeffRegan476223 @johnny_eire Nope...https://t.co/H53HvaIayd
@nih62806 @VedicWisdom1 https://t.co/lJmgT91WTB here's a well sourced out reference for you https://t.co/ADNnmPKEOB
RT @Hatashirorz: 以前にアンソニーの本を紹介するときに、馬の家畜化の起源についてもツイートした。 最近、RTされたので改めて調べたら、以下の論文が2018年に出ていたことを知ったのでメモとして残す。 https://t.co/PDbN4klHLr
RT @Hatashirorz: 以前にアンソニーの本を紹介するときに、馬の家畜化の起源についてもツイートした。 最近、RTされたので改めて調べたら、以下の論文が2018年に出ていたことを知ったのでメモとして残す。 https://t.co/PDbN4klHLr
RT @Hatashirorz: 以前にアンソニーの本を紹介するときに、馬の家畜化の起源についてもツイートした。 最近、RTされたので改めて調べたら、以下の論文が2018年に出ていたことを知ったのでメモとして残す。 https://t.co/PDbN4klHLr
RT @agenetics1: The fact that SC Asian ancient populations are very good proxies for the Iranian component in Indians was well known since…
Sana da birkaç araştırma atiyim da bu konu hakkında biraz bilgilen. Gösterdiği kaynak da Ancestry
@peixingjian01 Kaynağın yok hala saçma sapan konuşuyorsun. Eğer bilgilenmek istiyorsan birkaç araştırma okumanı öneririm. Bunlar sadece birazi ikincisinde bir suru kaynak var onlara da bak. Genler karmaşıktır ve düzgün arastirilmasi gerekir. https://t.co/WEYnL4R5fU https://t.co/ABppbXa5rg
@Hannah553824726 @ckscary @isqueezegatz @empireenjoyer10 @quityourmeds Oh wait I forgot to link this. Light skin in Northern Indians is almost certainly due to at least one later wave of neolithic European genetic influx(invasion) into India, penetrating the genetics... https://t.co/ET6dTqilyg https://t.co/bRGNHtNVYU
The fact that SC Asian ancient populations are very good proxies for the Iranian component in Indians was well known since Damgaard et al 2016 who first published an ancient SC Asian sample from 3200 bce Namazga. https://t.co/D2TymiJtGr https://t.co/L80tLQ0H0J
Atlantis the Antediluvian World by Ignatius L. Donnelly: The Birth of the modern idea of Atlantis https://t.co/nrnZSoNGtu #Atlantis #AtlantistheAntediluvianWorld #IgnatiusDonnelly #myth #mythology #book #books
@FSvedang @yajnadevam @HINDprehistory Where is prove of disproving Norduck Supremacy Theorist Aryan Invasion Theory, Sorry Neo Nazis just Cope , here is your answer https://t.co/vpVEQYQTM8
RT @Hatashirorz: 以前にアンソニーの本を紹介するときに、馬の家畜化の起源についてもツイートした。 最近、RTされたので改めて調べたら、以下の論文が2018年に出ていたことを知ったのでメモとして残す。 https://t.co/PDbN4klHLr
The paper discussed : https://t.co/adPyinZ9aN https://t.co/rphcmK6fS4
https://t.co/2RA9b1KiCY
@Daniellaaadolly https://t.co/SxI1dZ6GlZ
RT @Akkadian_DNA: نتائج لرفات من تركيا تعود لحقبة الحيثيون احداها نشرت هنا في مشجرة Yfull [https://t.co/6ijz9h1XOI](https://t.co/cROYr6hr…
نتائج لرفات من تركيا تعود لحقبة الحيثيون احداها نشرت هنا في مشجرة Yfull [https://t.co/6ijz9h1XOI](https://t.co/cROYr6hrIR) العينات من دراسة: The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia https://t.co/BtidzUNBzz
الدراسة الثانية DamgaardNature2018 The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia https://t.co/iFr8qsGiBg
The First Horse Herders and the Impact of Early Bronze Age Steppe Expansions into Asia https://t.co/ldwiVYLpVd
@Barry_io @AnnPran1 https://t.co/QZMe5cd7tw https://t.co/7xpVL36yrn
@torontocards1 @awanti_semite It’s academic samples from the Daamgard study. There are 20+ samples each for Yusufzai, Uthmankhel and Tarkalani tribes from Swat/Dir. He didn’t mention phenotype. https://t.co/rjPW8O1tAq
Taylor & Barron-Ortiz Rethinking the evidence for early horse domestication at Botai https://t.co/lXFnxw0NWm Damgaard et al The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia https://t.co/zTGF5OLXTn
RT @LudovicLorlando: The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia https://t.co/CvaYoG6Ur9
@TrueShoebill @Vritrahan2014 You know what that "[38]" is after that sentence? The statement you are quoting isint even part of the studies analysis, it's a citation to https://t.co/w25dSweoBm this study, and if you read the complete abstract you will realise what they mean
RT @PlanetaExplora: The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia | Science https://t.co/m91Yrfo8K6
The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia | Science https://t.co/m91Yrfo8K6
The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia | Science https://t.co/fDqOcqDiRu
The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia https://t.co/FhgneLox5s
@Gula_ciya_ @Zer_Kurd @Geshti_Azadi @issarro @USConGenErbil Damgaard, Peter de Barros (2018), The First Horse herders and the Impact of Early Bronze Age Steppe expansions into Asia Wang, Chuan-Chao (2018), The genetic prehistory of the Greater Caucasus Grolle, Johann (12 May 2018), "Invasion aus der Steppe", Der Spiegel
The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia https://t.co/ndc1hnZztk
The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia https://t.co/Yp6DvasPnm
The first horse herders and the impact of early Bronze Age steppe expansions into Asia http://science.sciencemag.org/content/360/6396/eaar7711
AT
A
AV
A
CP
PE
AT
P
NC
A
TK
ÖÜ
K
TC
JN
RR
LW
AM
O
葛B
か
GD
R
H
DS
A新
EM
WC
LB
عا
J
DU
V
BS
AB
A
GG
ВЦ
Մ
CH
V