The overall tone reflects a mix of skepticism and scientific inquiry, with discussions citing meta-analyses showing no clear protective effect of dairy on osteoporosis, while others defend dairy's benefits with references to specific studies. Words like 'lies' and 'bias' demonstrate active debate, while mentions of 'systematic reviews' and 'cohort studies' show deep engagement with the research evidence.
AgreementModerate agreement
Most social discussions support the findings that dairy intake is not conclusively linked to reduced osteoporosis or fracture risk, with some posts emphasizing conflicting studies or skepticism.
InterestModerate interest
The discussions are moderately engaging, with participants citing studies, sharing opinions, and debating the health impacts of dairy consumption.
EngagementModerate engagement
Posts reference scientific articles, meta-analyses, and contrast different types of studies like cohort and cross-sectional, indicating active participation and analysis.
ImpactModerate impact
The conversations influence perceptions by highlighting conflicting evidence and promoting critical thinking about dairy's role in bone health.
Abstract in brief
The systematic review and meta-analysis found that overall dairy intake is associated with a reduced risk of osteoporosis, especially with moderate consumption (0-250 grams per day), but milk alone was not significantly linked to osteoporosis risk overall.
There was an inverse linear relationship between increased dairy and milk intake and osteoporosis risk, with every additional 200 grams of dairy or milk associated with a 22% and 37% risk reduction respectively; however, this benefit was primarily observed in cross-sectional and case-control studies, not cohort studies.
While some studies suggested dairy and milk might reduce hip fracture risk, especially in cross-sectional and case-control studies, cohort studies indicated that higher milk intake could be associated with an increased risk of hip fracture; overall, the evidence does not conclusively support that more milk and dairy reduce the risk of osteoporosis or fractures.
@SiBarberPhoto @DrRanj @TheAHDB This is actually not true, cohort studies show sometimes there is an increased risk of bone fracture, or at best there is no correlation.
Even if it was true, you can simply get calcium from plants, without hormones and bad stuff & without animal cruelty.
https://t.co/E6waQ4Ti49
Jan 6, 2023 · 113 likes · 5 shares · 21,475 followersView post →
May 23, 2023 · 13 likes · 16,627 followersView post →
BL
bagher larijani
@LarijaniBagher · X
هر چند #لبنیات هم حاوی کربوهیدرات میباشد و بایددرافراد #دیابتی در حداعتدال مصرف شود ولی بدلیل وجود کلسیم، پروتئین، فسفر برای سلامتی مفید بوده و به پیشگیری از بیماریهای قلبی-عروقی و استئوپروز کمک میکند.محصولات لبنی تخمیر شده سبب کاهش خطر #سرطان نیز میشوند.
https://t.co/NIOT7CXwA1
Nov 22, 2021 · 7 likes · 1 share · 421 followersView post →
BL
bagher larijani
@LarijaniBagher · X
Although #dairy products contain considerable amounts of carbohydrates and should be consumed in moderation by #diabetics, they are rich in calcium, protein, and phosphorous, and can prevent from cardiovascular disease and #osteoporosis.
https://t.co/NIOT7CXwA1
Mar 10, 2025 · 2 likes · 33,393 followersView post →
令日
令和の神風を巻き起こせ 日本
@TzbwI6VE0xf6ILg · X
@hide_Q_ Consumption of milk and dairy products and risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture: a systematic review and Meta-analysis
Hanieh Malmir et al. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2020.
確かに
乳製品と【股関節骨折】は
増加する可能性があるが
【骨粗鬆症】のリスクをあげる
とは一言も書いていません
@AlexMurray14 @Ariodante79 @Papaioeajake 1) nutrition:
https://t.co/cd7QxfVKTL
https://t.co/qefve5tzQY
https://t.co/JoRpQgwxAG
It is better to get your calcium and protein from another source that doesn’t come from cows pumped up full of hormones so that they can be perpetually pregnant and breastfeeding :)
RT @Jiemb1: @touristsmg @ncapeyronSABA @CainHeleverok @AEGRW @JMJancovici Il y a d'autres méta-analyses sur le sujet, sur celle-ci, on retr…
Aug 15, 2024 · 1 share · 1,408 followersView post →
J
Jiembé
@Jiemb1 · X
@touristsmg @ncapeyronSABA @CainHeleverok @AEGRW @JMJancovici Il y a d'autres méta-analyses sur le sujet, sur celle-ci, on retrouve un lien négatif entre consommation de lait et ostéoporose (c-a-d que le lait réduit le risque d'ostéoporose), sur les études cas témoins, mais pas sur les études de cohortes.
→ https://t.co/EK9eyna7kW https://t.co/Tt8VmQnBRU
Aug 15, 2024 · 1 like · 1 share · 1,101 followersView post →
@CarnivoreIs @hvfreerangefarm @JustinTemplerSr @Voteblue4boogs @FarmsGarland @diamondback_xx It is also an established fact that dairy intake has no benefit when it comes to protection against fracture
https://t.co/T9DjVaXj0z https://t.co/bkp1SuKJgQ
@Charliepapabean @healthmama26 @Thekeksociety And you have no critical thinking, discernment or your own research skills...
Learn how to use google
https://t.co/7h4WbfcdP2
@KirkwoodEinir @SPTomos from systematic reviews of evidence and meta-analyses, especially looking at cohort studies (analyses done over long periods of time on large populations) and a 2020 one shows this: https://t.co/tZQ7E1CXxI https://t.co/mSOdjZnP9l
@dennymishler @veganmillsy Meta-regression of inc. studies revealed inverse linear assoc. between dairy & milk intake & risk of osteoporosis; such that every additional 200-gram intake of dairy and milk was associated with a 22% and 37% reduced risk of osteoporosis, respectively. https://t.co/hEMz1zHxla.
https://t.co/fWAvedgVFq
https://t.co/bsIeG5VM9V
https://t.co/fsAeroB7y7
cansado de gente falando merda sobre nutrição. Boa leitura! https://t.co/UdfLng1OTz
RT @Nutradvance: One of the best examples of bias here.
It's a tweet that fails to value truth & dresses up ethical beliefs as nutritiona…
Aug 10, 2023 · 1 share · 2,520 followersView post →
MJ
Michael Joseph
@Nutradvance · X
One of the best examples of bias here.
It's a tweet that fails to value truth & dresses up ethical beliefs as nutritional misinformation to scare people.
1) Most studies show an inverse or neutral effect of dairy on fractures (per sys reviews)
Ref: https://t.co/Zn6ClKCCCU 1/6 https://t.co/tO7V2UMh68
Aug 10, 2023 · 3 likes · 1 share · 11,778 followersView post →
CS
Cody Shandraw
@ShandrawCody · X
@DanSnowden @VICE I know you’re vegan but it’s irresponsible to be telling others that milk causes osteoporosis https://t.co/zJ6To3HSko
@CarnivoreIs @AsarCadyn @hvfreerangefarm @LuckyHoofer @JustinTemplerSr Despite an amazing 1900s advertising campaign, dairy does not do what we all thought it did.
https://t.co/ouLUXl68SE https://t.co/k9SIEzBwt7
*Meta analysisجمعت نتائج
Cohort study "دراسات زمنية بتقارن مجموعات من الناس"
وcross sectional study "دراسة بتجمع بيانات ف نقطة زمنية واحدة"
https://t.co/qoS67xMj8A
ملخص الدراسةأن بالرغم من أن نتائج الcross sectional بتأكد أن الزيادة في استهلاك اللبن مفيدة للعظام
@NieminenMatti77 @BenjaminPitkane Tutkimus yllätti: Kalat tuntevat kipua https://t.co/7gQvlWBNkI
Dairy products linked to increased risk of cancer https://t.co/RqmyJcC2e1
Consumption of milk & dairy products and risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture: a systematic review and Meta-analysis https://t.co/UpEzy2x0KA
@CakeNutrition If a doctor recommends cow's milk that in itself is a problem. Cow's milk is linked to prostate cancer (+34% risk) among other issues.
"[Cow's milk] comes with saturated fat, cholesterol, bovine growth factors and IGF, etc." - Dr. Faraz Harsini
https://t.co/MhSKmpDb0b
RT @DrFarazHarsini: @SiBarberPhoto @DrRanj @TheAHDB This is actually not true, cohort studies show sometimes there is an increased risk of…
Jan 7, 2023 · 5 shares · 9,905 followersView post →
DH
Dr. Faraz Harsini
@DrFarazHarsini · X
@SiBarberPhoto @DrRanj @TheAHDB This is actually not true, cohort studies show sometimes there is an increased risk of bone fracture, or at best there is no correlation.
Even if it was true, you can simply get calcium from plants, without hormones and bad stuff & without animal cruelty.
https://t.co/E6waQ4Ti49
Jan 6, 2023 · 113 likes · 5 shares · 21,475 followersView post →
DN
don't call me by my full name
@all_betz_off_ · X
@WomenWineSongPC Well yeah, that's a given. The dairy industry is a big offender:
https://t.co/Cavg3cIYba
"[...]we concluded that a greater intake of milk and dairy products was not associated with a lower risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture."
@hairyhillfarmer @farmer_richiet @Rosewood_Farm A greater intake of milk and dairy is not associated with a lower risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture.
Malmir H et al. Consumption of milk and dairy products and risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture: a systematic review and Meta-analysis.
Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2020;60(10):1722
@TheDirtyPolak @avalon_nh @MetroUK You build strong bones by doing weight bearing exercise and consuming plant based calcium. Get off the teat.
https://t.co/yCAf7nBCwr
@_peter_beard @Simonvibert @RebelsAnimal So does plant food. Vitamin D = Sunshine is the main source. Did you know they supplement animals food? Osteoporosis claim is false. https://t.co/UpEzy2x0KA
@WebMD https://t.co/YjSUy64VYu
"...we concluded that a greater intake of milk and dairy products was not associated with a lower risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture."
@algingersmith @kiteconsulting It’s not like the UK’s massive over consumption of dairy keeps our hospitals or GPs empty.
No, there’s more to dairy than nutrition. There’s raised cholesterol, CVD, obesity and so on. Oh, and dairy probably has little effect on osteoporosis. #YouandYours
https://t.co/pIw4xGZyft
RT @LarijaniBagher: هر چند #لبنیات هم حاوی کربوهیدرات میباشد و بایددرافراد #دیابتی در حداعتدال مصرف شود ولی بدلیل وجود کلسیم، پروتئین، فسفر…
Nov 22, 2021 · 1 share · 1,446 followersView post →
BL
bagher larijani
@LarijaniBagher · X
هر چند #لبنیات هم حاوی کربوهیدرات میباشد و بایددرافراد #دیابتی در حداعتدال مصرف شود ولی بدلیل وجود کلسیم، پروتئین، فسفر برای سلامتی مفید بوده و به پیشگیری از بیماریهای قلبی-عروقی و استئوپروز کمک میکند.محصولات لبنی تخمیر شده سبب کاهش خطر #سرطان نیز میشوند.
https://t.co/NIOT7CXwA1
Nov 22, 2021 · 7 likes · 1 share · 421 followersView post →
BL
bagher larijani
@LarijaniBagher · X
Although #dairy products contain considerable amounts of carbohydrates and should be consumed in moderation by #diabetics, they are rich in calcium, protein, and phosphorous, and can prevent from cardiovascular disease and #osteoporosis.
https://t.co/NIOT7CXwA1
@Langlai73410097 @docnono2000 @LoranG76 @fredhermel @ChayriguesMarc @Fragritwittos @B_Rouille_Idele @PeruchoPierre @cduroc @Veaulin1 @Yannzerodeux @JulienViala @TourAgri En parlant de sources
"we concluded that a greater intake of milk and dairy products was not associated with a lower risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture"
https://t.co/XVed0lHTNq
Oct 21, 2021 · 1 like · 1,466 followersView post →
Many say "Milk is good for bones" Is this true? This meta-analysis of cohort studies has an answer. Higher consumption of milk is NOT associated with lower risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture (meta-linear regression analysis show greater risk instead).
https://t.co/BzfELFHCN1
Jul 28, 2021 · 1 like · 2 shares · 585 followersView post →
C
CK♾
@Ckeithhhh · X
@connortweetmore @lenalenalenaxo @WrittenByHanna Busy today so may have to investigate in steps but read this for your first claim https://t.co/uDkqtOXgHp
@r4v5t4r @VeganOlive1 Bit concerned that there doesn't seem to be a commonality between the respective studies. Your meme referencing that study is from 2016, this troubling one is from 2019...
https://t.co/YWGZ7Snj2H
@drkohilathas @KimKardashian No, I really do not understand how vegan diet means that you *must* stuff your face with an 'increased amount of processed food & carbs'. & to my knowledge it is consumption of milk & diary products which is linked to fractures. Look: https://t.co/utOlMGZA2e
Feb 21, 2021 · 1 like · 1,741 followersView post →
Feb 15, 2021 · 2 likes · 5,394 followersView post →
AK
Antti Kivivalli
@AnttiKivivalli · X
@JarkkoKoykka @Ptterz @MailVeikko @YlvaHelsinki Joo, maitotuotteilla on ravintoarvonsa. Nyt valitettavasti käsitys, että maidon kulutus vähentäisi esim. osteoporoosin todennäköisyyttä ei siis ole totta.
https://t.co/NQqkWy6gxO https://t.co/ZyZ5PuWJ80
An interesting outcome given previous advice!
"we concluded that a greater intake of milk and dairy products was not associated with a lower risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture"
https://t.co/QZSZwrL8We
May 26, 2020 · 3 likes · 3,413 followersView post →
SG
Steve Glen
@TheRealSteveGle · X
@veggvictoria seems it helps if you have little, but more makes it worse?
https://t.co/JDTVXevg0l
Bardzo ciekawa metaanaliza. Jej konkluzją jest, że z badań kohortowych nie wynika, jakoby większe spożycie mleka i nabiału było związane z mniejszym ryzykiem osteoporozy i złamań.
#dietetyka #fitlipiec #medycyna #zdrowie #osteoporoza #nabial #dieta
https://t.co/1ABRVY25nP
https://t.co/99PqkEIWQh
Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2019 Mar 26:1-16.
Consumption of milk and dairy products and risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture: a systematic
牛乳や乳製品の摂取は骨粗鬆症や大腿骨骨折のリスクには関連しない.
多く摂取してもリスクは低下しない.
Consumption of milk and dairy products and risk of osteoporosis and hip fracture: a systematic review and Meta-analysis https://t.co/SssUpWgpLC
Apr 2, 2019 · 1 like · 2 shares · 1,235 followersView post →
DN
Dr. José Luis Neyro
@doctorneyro · X
Total #dairyintake was protectively associated with reduced #risk of #osteoporosis based on cross-sectional and case-control studies (0.63; 95% CI: 0.55-0.73) https://t.co/vkUWAh9Q7z https://t.co/804jFRL3xR
Nutricionista Karina Narimatsu | Taboão da Serra SP - Facebook
Facebook
Referências: doi: 10.1007/s00394-025-03758-y doi: 10.1080/10408398.2019.1590800 PMID: 21092700. May be an image of test li jgħid 'VEGANISMO E 地:キーマソル ...
... 10.1080/10408398.2019.1590800; Menon, V., et al. (2020). Vitamin D and depression: A critical appraisal of the evidence and future directions. https://www ...