April 2021 PMID 32583127

Given that the detailed original criteria for deliberate practice have not changed, could the understanding of this complex concept have improved over time? A response to Macnamara and Hambrick (2020).

K Anders Ericsson

Download social card

Mentions

13
Peak: 2 in Dec 2020
across 5 sources since Oct 2020

Extended reach

5,774
potential audience

Total likes

24

Video views

1,035

Mentions per month

Oct 2020 – Feb 2025

Where it's discussed

  • News4 articles
  • X / Twitter3 posts
  • YouTube3 videos
  • Bluesky2 posts
  • Facebook1 posts

AI synopsis

What people are saying

Discussions reflect active engagement with the topic, such as mentioning following a follow-up piece and referring to the Ericsson & Macnamara debate, with tone ranging from curiosity to critical analysis, highlighting ongoing interest but not reaching strong consensus or high impact.

AgreementNeither agree nor disagree

The discussions show mixed opinions, with some posts indicating agreement and others expressing disagreement or curiosity, leading to a neutral overall stance.

InterestHigh interest

There is high interest evidenced by references to follow-up pieces, discussions of historical debates, and inquiries about the research details.

EngagementModerate engagement

Posts include thoughtful mentions of articles, responses to specific points like replication attempts, and references to lectures, suggesting active engagement.

ImpactNeutral impact

While some comments highlight ongoing debates and interpretations, the overall influence of the discussion on broader perspectives remains moderate.

Abstract in brief

  • The text discusses whether the understanding of the concept of deliberate practice has improved over time, even though its original criteria have not changed, and responds to criticisms that it has been redefined.
  • The author argues that Macnamara and Hambrick misinterpreted the original, specific criteria of deliberate practice—such as individualized training—by broadening the definition to include more general activities like lectures and studying, which don't meet these criteria.
  • The author emphasizes that the original meaning of deliberate practice remains consistent and suggests that differences in perspectives can be reconciled through proper interpretation of the original criteria.]

Top posts

Most liked on X and Bluesky
Terry Pearson
@TPLTD · X

@cbokhove @AndrewEMC @Ofstednews Interesting follow up piece here: https://t.co/30Tc4IsZGZ

Dec 15, 2022 · 1 like · 719 followers View post →
Nick Byrd, Ph.D.
@byrd_nick · X

Curious about the Ericsson & Macnamara saga? Check out Ericsson's replies to (1) an alleged failed replication (2019): https://t.co/gaNvNdpSHp (2) accusations of changing the definition of "deliberate practice" over the course of his career (2020): https://t.co/IShqEzxMdp https://t.co/VbX0ESF65h

Dec 3, 2020 · 3,490 followers View post →
Roxana Castaneda
@roxminu · X

Very interesting lecture: https://t.co/3uM0LuEchW

Oct 30, 2020 · 477 followers View post →
Texas Toland
@texastoland.com · Bluesky

Should you use AI to learn (anything)? This response is wonderfully even-handed. I both agree and disagree. Listening to other takes before I stake mine

Feb 1, 2025 · 1 share View post →

All mentions

Texas Toland
@texastoland.com · Bluesky

Should you use AI to learn (anything)? This response is wonderfully even-handed. I both agree and disagree. Listening to other takes before I stake mine

Feb 1, 2025 · 1 share View post →
Terry Pearson
@TPLTD · X

@cbokhove @AndrewEMC @Ofstednews Interesting follow up piece here: https://t.co/30Tc4IsZGZ

Dec 15, 2022 · 1 like · 719 followers View post →
Nick Byrd, Ph.D.
@byrdnick.com · Bluesky

career (2020): https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00426-020-01368-3

Dec 3, 2020 · 1 share View post →
Nick Byrd, Ph.D.
@byrd_nick · X

Curious about the Ericsson & Macnamara saga? Check out Ericsson's replies to (1) an alleged failed replication (2019): https://t.co/gaNvNdpSHp (2) accusations of changing the definition of "deliberate practice" over the course of his career (2020): https://t.co/IShqEzxMdp https://t.co/VbX0ESF65h

Dec 3, 2020 · 3,490 followers View post →
Roxana Castaneda
@roxminu · X

Very interesting lecture: https://t.co/3uM0LuEchW

Oct 30, 2020 · 477 followers View post →
McLeod 2021 How Students Use Deliberate Practice During The ...
News

https://doi.org/10.1007/s1045​9-010-9246-3 deliberate practice handbook ... Artigo - s00426-020-01368-3. 7 pages. Motivational Interviewing: Deliberate ...

Dec 16, 2025 View →
Chapter 1 Hihi (22 | PDF | Credibility | Social Media
News

https://doi.org/10.1007/s00426-020-01368-3. Fedeli, G. (2019). 'Fake news' meets tourism: a proposed research agenda. Annals of Tourism Research, 80, 102684 ...

Dec 16, 2025 View →
Harwell, K. & Southwick, D. 2021. Beyond 10,000 Hours ...
News

Psychological Research. https://doi.org/ Back Bay Books/Little, Brown and Company. 10.1007/s00426-020-01368-3 Haggerty, B.

Dec 16, 2025 View →
Deliberate Practice - What Is It | PDF | Behavior Modification ...
News

https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02505024. You might also like. How Important Is ... Artigo - s00426-020-01368-3. 7 pages. Deliberate Practice and ...

Nov 26, 2020 View →
When it comes to bettering ourselves as artists, it involves a lot of ...
Facebook

com/article/10.1007/s00426-020-01368-3. 5 yrs. 1. Patrick Oliver Jones. Absolutely, he's had his own thoughts and adjustments to deliberate ...

Nov 11, 2020 View →