Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
Several discussions reference the article's critique of traditional experimental methods, particularly noting that in-lab experiments may not accurately generalize to real-world scenarios. Phrases like 'the coolest paper I have read' and questions about the applicability of experimental findings to naturalistic contexts demonstrate enthusiasm and concern, enhancing the overall tone of critical appraisal and recognition of the article's relevance.
Many discussions reflect a favorable view of the article's arguments, indicating a general consensus about the importance of rethinking experimental paradigms.
The discussions show a high level of curiosity and relevance to current research themes, indicating that many find the topic engaging.
While some posts highlight specific aspects of the article, most maintain a moderate level of depth, suggesting a mix of casual interest and serious consideration.
Multiple users express belief that the publication will influence future research methods, showcasing its perceived significance in the field.
We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articulate what a more "ecological" human neuroscience might look like—with a brief history of the term "ecological validity" https://t.co/SNcYmIIrvf https://t.co/L8vQFSA9yO
実験心理学の研究の多くは脳が解釈が容易な機能単位とプロセスから構成されるという仮定を含んでいるが、脳が単純な変数に依存して設計されている保証はなく、変数が信号とノイズに綺麗に分離できて実験計画に課された理論的境界を尊重するとも限らないという批判はある。 https://t.co/sw8VmBuc7L
The coolest paper I have read in 2020 Thanks @samnastase Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience https://t.co/PHtrPGMpOO
Este primer artículo la crítica está en q los experimentos realizados con neuroimagen en general, no se corresponde con naturalistic environment... xo no os suena q esta crítica la recibe tb una rama de la psicología q usa mucho los modelos animales?
Are in-lab experiments generalisable to real-world contexts? How can we have more naturalistic experiments? (Nastase, et al., 2020, Neuroimage) paper: https://t.co/etOUFz6six our discussion: https://t.co/PbrYVMbF8s @LiangQianchen @conscious_tlab @samnastase
7/8 は生態学的妥当性と一般化可能性について。 Nastase, S. A., Goldstein, A., & Hasson, U. (2020). Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience. NeuroImage, 222, 117254. https://t.co/OcUlyzJhpA
This episode discusses key memories and forgotten details from scientific papers related to brain-behavior relationships. We assess assumptions that might undermine research findings and emphasize the importance of…
This episode discusses the importance of naturalistic experimental paradigms in neuroimaging. It challenges the effectiveness of highly controlled experiments, emphasizing the need for approaches that reflect real-world…
RT @tociss: 認知科学ですでにそういう議論があるから二の舞になってもなとは Illusory Essences: A Bias Holding Back Theorizing in Psychological Science https://t.co/agOD9Bh…
認知科学ですでにそういう議論があるから二の舞になってもなとは Illusory Essences: A Bias Holding Back Theorizing in Psychological Science https://t.co/agOD9Bhar9 Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience. https://t.co/sw8VmBuc7L
RT @tociss: 実験心理学の研究の多くは脳が解釈が容易な機能単位とプロセスから構成されるという仮定を含んでいるが、脳が単純な変数に依存して設計されている保証はなく、変数が信号とノイズに綺麗に分離できて実験計画に課された理論的境界を尊重するとも限らないという批判はある。…
実験心理学の研究の多くは脳が解釈が容易な機能単位とプロセスから構成されるという仮定を含んでいるが、脳が単純な変数に依存して設計されている保証はなく、変数が信号とノイズに綺麗に分離できて実験計画に課された理論的境界を尊重するとも限らないという批判はある。 https://t.co/sw8VmBuc7L
“Inference and prediction data are dependent”というのは意識研究に限らずあるあるな気もする あんまり誰もつつきたがらないだけで https://t.co/sw8VmBuc7L https://t.co/agOD9Bhar9 https://t.co/oPApHutVPY
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @YotaKawashima: Are in-lab experiments generalisable to real-world contexts? How can we have more naturalistic experiments? (Nastase, et…
Are in-lab experiments generalisable to real-world contexts? How can we have more naturalistic experiments? (Nastase, et al., 2020, Neuroimage) paper: https://t.co/etOUFz6six our discussion: https://t.co/PbrYVMbF8s @LiangQianchen @conscious_tlab @samnastase
7/8 は生態学的妥当性と一般化可能性について。 Nastase, S. A., Goldstein, A., & Hasson, U. (2020). Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience. NeuroImage, 222, 117254. https://t.co/OcUlyzJhpA
RT @aczeszum: The coolest paper I have read in 2020 Thanks @samnastase Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in co…
RT @aczeszum: The coolest paper I have read in 2020 Thanks @samnastase Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in co…
RT @aczeszum: The coolest paper I have read in 2020 Thanks @samnastase Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in co…
RT @aczeszum: The coolest paper I have read in 2020 Thanks @samnastase Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in co…
RT @aczeszum: The coolest paper I have read in 2020 Thanks @samnastase Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in co…
The coolest paper I have read in 2020 Thanks @samnastase Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience https://t.co/PHtrPGMpOO
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @umbertoleon: Este primer artículo la crítica está en q los experimentos realizados con neuroimagen en general, no se corresponde con na…
Este primer artículo la crítica está en q los experimentos realizados con neuroimagen en general, no se corresponde con naturalistic environment... xo no os suena q esta crítica la recibe tb una rama de la psicología q usa mucho los modelos animales?
Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience https://t.co/hLaOdQaNE1
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
NeuroImage Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience https://t.co/hIxSIg21Lc
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
RT @samnastase: We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articula…
We have a short perspective piece out in the @NeuroImage_EiC special issue on Naturalistic Imaging where we try to articulate what a more "ecological" human neuroscience might look like—with a brief history of the term "ecological validity" https://t.co/SNcYmIIrvf https://t.co/L8vQFSA9yO
NI: Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience https://t.co/3aMpJQcsoO
RT @PsyArXivBot: Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience https://t.co/7OThIVxsMW
RT @PsyArXivBot: Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience https://t.co/7OThIVxsMW
Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience https://t.co/7OThIVxsMW
SN
T
AC
UD
YK
RT
カハ
SO
LQ
HS
JW
C
LS
KL
MI
Π
SP
RH
MA
DR
GA
KM
ML
AD
CC
S
D
R
GN
FM
BP
MG
JB
CH
黒K
YP
YK
AC
JS
SS
SO
LS
F
BG
DV
JH
ZD
SB
LY
JD
RM
MR
NS
DT
IG
MS
JM
TG
JY
AR
Q吕
AP
HL
N
PN
SA
CS
ZZ
EF
SR
MT
AH
J
ED
JF
MP
M
BJ
PB