Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
The discussions demonstrate a high level of agreement and engagement, with users referencing specific scientific studies and findings, such as cortisol levels indicating stress, to argue that aversive methods are harmful. The overall tone and language convey urgency and advocacy for positive training, reflecting the significant impact of the publication on attitudes and potential practices.
Most discussions explicitly support the article's findings, emphasizing that aversive training harms dog welfare.
Participants show high curiosity, citing multiple studies, sharing insights about cortisol levels, and discussing long-term effects.
Posts involve detailed references to research, including hormones, behavior tests, and citations, indicating deep involvement.
The strong consensus and detailed exchanges suggest these discussions could influence dog training practices and animal welfare policies.
Study finds that using punishment (including yanking on leash, scolding/yelling, shock collars, restraint) to train hurts dogs both in the short and long term. Study: https://t.co/tVdH4GUCLS. Analysis: https://t.co/YfSTUVqYHB. https://t.co/IeqExCdY6V
Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @CatarinaVCastro #PLOSONE: Does training method matter? Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companio ... https://t.co/x3JXWtNJJy 1/6
Dogs trained with aversive-based methods showed more stress behaviours, had higher cortisol levels and were more pessimistic in a cognitive bias test than dogs trained using reward-based methods. PLOS ONE, December 2020 Link to paper: https://t.co/oqEHRTHAxF https://t.co/IeXkC76IY1
Dogs Trust uses evidence-based positive methods for our training and behavioural modifcation programmes
Exciting study supported by UFAW showing the effects of dog training methods on welfare by @CatarinaVCastro and colleagues. https://t.co/xIca7JEZt2 Full paper: https://t.co/kMtuGITE6S https://t.co/OevrxtigmI
ポルトガルのポルト大学によるリサーチ。 報酬ベースを採用している所と嫌悪刺激ベースを採用している犬の訓練学校を比較。 訓練中と訓練後の行動やホルモン値の変化を観察したら、嫌悪ベースでは明らかに犬に過大なストレスが確認されたというある意味当然の結果です。 https://t.co/LH8eob5Hjp
This podcast interview with Dr. Zazie Todd explores the negative impact of aversive-based training methods on companion dog welfare. Delve into the scientific discussions that aim to end outdated practices in dog…
Dogs excel at understanding human pointing gestures to find objects, unlike chimpanzees who struggle with referential cues. The study highlights species differences in interpreting human communicative signals and their…
This video explores dominance in canine behavior, with insights from a professional webinar. Learn about age-graded hierarchies and social tolerance in free-ranging dog packs, and how training methods impact dog…
@Armedgolem @Awk20000 Shock collars is a really bad method for dog training:https://t.co/0gsQaoZ0gE
@huwusteenie @TheOmniLiberal Aversive dog training methods, like shock collars, cause more than just pain. They lead to increased stress behaviors, higher cortisol levels, and even a "pessimistic" emotional state. The research is clear, these methods compromise a dog's overall welfare:https://t.co/0gsQaoZ0gE
@huwusteenie @TheOmniLiberal A shock collar is an aversive tool, and a dog can absolutely make a negative association with the handler. This can damage trust and lead to fear. Positive, reward-based training builds a bond and teaches desired behaviors safely. Again:https://t.co/0gsQaoZ0gE
@DramaAlert I'm just gonna leave this here:https://t.co/0gsQaoYsr6
@huwusteenie @TheOmniLiberal Again your opinion is not relevant. I couldn't care less about your opinion. Buy hey have a read:https://t.co/0gsQaoZ0gE
@kennygdude @NuffPlaces2Hide @Tectone Here are some studies for your light reading. https://t.co/rf1v5nyBSt https://t.co/Sr4IzxTDL3 https://t.co/LDnoTLmCaX https://t.co/TG3HtkzOOR https://t.co/UtuHPdkRHH https://t.co/IDhP9Uqdrl https://t.co/u43QOq0hV6
I spoke to @zakgeorge.bsky.social about dog training and the methods we use. You can watch on Youtube or listen wherever you get your podcasts youtu.be/TnCqpIfya6I
@Forgotten004 @KaitenNeo dog welfare, the existing literature indicates that, at least at some level, aversive-based methods generate stress in dogs." https://t.co/ycSJV6kmNz "These findings indicate that aversive-based training methods, especially if used in high proportions, compromise the
One of the referenced dog training articles: Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1...
@LikeaS0uvenir Does training method matter? Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare” (en español, “¿Importa el método de adiestramiento? Pruebas del impacto negativo de los métodos basados en la aversión en el bienestar de los perros de compañía”)+
ⓒ Universican
La evidencia es clara: Los estímulos aversivos perjudican el bienestar del perro y su aprendizaje. ⓒ Universican https://t.co/MUS4RqEOb5
@ Universican
RT @universican: Modo ironía: Encendido. La evidencia es clara: Los estímulos aversivos perjudican el bienestar del perro y su aprendizaje…
Modo ironía: Encendido. La evidencia es clara: Los estímulos aversivos perjudican el bienestar del perro y su aprendizaje. ⓒ Universican - Todos los derechos reservados.
ⓒ Universican - Todos los derechos reservados.
ⓒ Universican - Todos los derechos reservados. https://t.co/MUS4RqEOb5
@umboose For example also see https://t.co/Dl5wQKJ3ez
Does training method matter? Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/IgN7k6fsUr
@MDR_SAN @MISachsenAnhalt @TamaraZieschang dass es aversive Methoden zwingend braucht, halte ich für schwer vertretbar. Andere Länder bekommen das auch hin. https://t.co/HOwbQMTMm0 Schluss mit VPMethoden! Studien: https://t.co/mcGBBeuq4z https://t.co/j40mR3AlqZ https://t.co/z1GzGQuXDH
Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/nAcepd4w2t
I will shamelessly also plug for our paper here https://t.co/aNmcO4HX4P. Both papers are Open Access so available for anyone to read. Both teams studied companion dogs in behaviour tests, a method that is less prone to bias than the widespread owner-report methods.
"These findings indicate that aversive-based #training methods, especially if used in high proportions, compromise the #welfare of companion #dogs both within and outside the training context."https://t.co/oFId8d4jZH
@DoUBelieveInDog @DrEmilyB @DrRachelCasey @SciReports Thanks for sharing! If you're not convinced, see also: https://t.co/ud829NRiM0
@ThomasRowland90 This one by @CatarinaVCastro & @animalogues has behavior, hormones & mood. One of my favorite papers of the year. https://t.co/ud829NzHUs
RT @DTScholars: Dogs Trust uses evidence-based positive methods for our training and behavioural modifcation programmes
RT @DTScholars: Dogs Trust uses evidence-based positive methods for our training and behavioural modifcation programmes
RT @DTScholars: Dogs Trust uses evidence-based positive methods for our training and behavioural modifcation programmes
RT @DTScholars: Dogs Trust uses evidence-based positive methods for our training and behavioural modifcation programmes
RT @DTScholars: Dogs Trust uses evidence-based positive methods for our training and behavioural modifcation programmes
RT @DTScholars: Dogs Trust uses evidence-based positive methods for our training and behavioural modifcation programmes
RT @DTScholars: Dogs Trust uses evidence-based positive methods for our training and behavioural modifcation programmes
Dogs Trust uses evidence-based positive methods for our training and behavioural modifcation programmes
RT @PLOS: Training methods based on punishment leave #dogs stressed and anxious, say Ana Catarina Vieira de Castro and colleagues of @UPort…
RT @PLOS: Training methods based on punishment leave #dogs stressed and anxious, say Ana Catarina Vieira de Castro and colleagues of @UPort…
Training methods based on punishment leave #dogs stressed and anxious, say Ana Catarina Vieira de Castro and colleagues of @UPorto.
RT @Aki_Gunning: ポルトガルのポルト大学によるリサーチ。 報酬ベースを採用している所と嫌悪刺激ベースを採用している犬の訓練学校を比較。 訓練中と訓練後の行動やホルモン値の変化を観察したら、嫌悪ベースでは明らかに犬に過大なストレスが確認されたというある意味当然の結…
RT @Aki_Gunning: ポルトガルのポルト大学によるリサーチ。 報酬ベースを採用している所と嫌悪刺激ベースを採用している犬の訓練学校を比較。 訓練中と訓練後の行動やホルモン値の変化を観察したら、嫌悪ベースでは明らかに犬に過大なストレスが確認されたというある意味当然の結…
RT @Aki_Gunning: ポルトガルのポルト大学によるリサーチ。 報酬ベースを採用している所と嫌悪刺激ベースを採用している犬の訓練学校を比較。 訓練中と訓練後の行動やホルモン値の変化を観察したら、嫌悪ベースでは明らかに犬に過大なストレスが確認されたというある意味当然の結…
ポルトガルのポルト大学によるリサーチ。 報酬ベースを採用している所と嫌悪刺激ベースを採用している犬の訓練学校を比較。 訓練中と訓練後の行動やホルモン値の変化を観察したら、嫌悪ベースでは明らかに犬に過大なストレスが確認されたというある意味当然の結果です。 https://t.co/LH8eob5Hjp
RT @dogsciencesays: Dogs trained with aversive-based methods showed more stress behaviours, had higher cortisol levels and were more pessim…
RT @dogsciencesays: Dogs trained with aversive-based methods showed more stress behaviours, had higher cortisol levels and were more pessim…
RT @dogsciencesays: Dogs trained with aversive-based methods showed more stress behaviours, had higher cortisol levels and were more pessim…
RT @dogsciencesays: Dogs trained with aversive-based methods showed more stress behaviours, had higher cortisol levels and were more pessim…
RT @dogsciencesays: Dogs trained with aversive-based methods showed more stress behaviours, had higher cortisol levels and were more pessim…
RT @dogsciencesays: Dogs trained with aversive-based methods showed more stress behaviours, had higher cortisol levels and were more pessim…
Does #training method matter? Yes! Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion #dog welfare. #study #positiverocks https://t.co/GvJb60xH4I
RT @dogsciencesays: Dogs trained with aversive-based methods showed more stress behaviours, had higher cortisol levels and were more pessim…
RT @dogsciencesays: Dogs trained with aversive-based methods showed more stress behaviours, had higher cortisol levels and were more pessim…
RT @UFAW_1926: Exciting study supported by UFAW showing the effects of dog training methods on welfare by @CatarinaVCastro and colleagues.…
Dogs trained with aversive-based methods showed more stress behaviours, had higher cortisol levels and were more pessimistic in a cognitive bias test than dogs trained using reward-based methods. PLOS ONE, December 2020 Link to paper: https://t.co/oqEHRTHAxF https://t.co/IeXkC76IY1
RT @UFAW_1926: Exciting study supported by UFAW showing the effects of dog training methods on welfare by @CatarinaVCastro and colleagues.…
RT @UFAW_1926: Exciting study supported by UFAW showing the effects of dog training methods on welfare by @CatarinaVCastro and colleagues.…
RT @UFAW_1926: Exciting study supported by UFAW showing the effects of dog training methods on welfare by @CatarinaVCastro and colleagues.…
RT @animalogues: Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @Cata…
RT @UFAW_1926: Exciting study supported by UFAW showing the effects of dog training methods on welfare by @CatarinaVCastro and colleagues.…
Exciting study supported by UFAW showing the effects of dog training methods on welfare by @CatarinaVCastro and colleagues. https://t.co/xIca7JEZt2 Full paper: https://t.co/kMtuGITE6S https://t.co/OevrxtigmI
RT @animalogues: Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @Cata…
Training methods based on punishment leave #dogs stressed and anxious, say Ana Catarina Vieira de Castro and colleagues of @UPorto.
RT @animalogues: Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @Cata…
RT @animalogues: Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @Cata…
RT @animalogues: Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @Cata…
RT @animalogues: Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @Cata…
RT @animalogues: Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @Cata…
RT @animalogues: Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @Cata…
RT @animalogues: Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @Cata…
RT @animalogues: Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @Cata…
Our latest paper out! First large-scale study of the effect of dog training methods on stress and dog welfare led by @CatarinaVCastro #PLOSONE: Does training method matter? Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companio ... https://t.co/x3JXWtNJJy 1/6
These findings indicate that aversive-based training methods, especially if used in high proportions, compromise the welfare of companion dogs. https://t.co/HhSPqYYUaR #DogTraining #Dogs #AnimalWelfare
This is fantastic! Check out those cortisol levels... Cortisol is the nasty stress hormone
RT @nwinograd: Study finds that using punishment (including yanking on leash, scolding/yelling, shock collars, restraint) to train hurts do…
RT @nwinograd: Study finds that using punishment (including yanking on leash, scolding/yelling, shock collars, restraint) to train hurts do…
RT @nwinograd: Study finds that using punishment (including yanking on leash, scolding/yelling, shock collars, restraint) to train hurts do…
RT @nwinograd: Study finds that using punishment (including yanking on leash, scolding/yelling, shock collars, restraint) to train hurts do…
RT @nwinograd: Study finds that using punishment (including yanking on leash, scolding/yelling, shock collars, restraint) to train hurts do…
RT @nwinograd: Study finds that using punishment (including yanking on leash, scolding/yelling, shock collars, restraint) to train hurts do…
RT @nwinograd: Study finds that using punishment (including yanking on leash, scolding/yelling, shock collars, restraint) to train hurts do…
RT @nwinograd: Study finds that using punishment (including yanking on leash, scolding/yelling, shock collars, restraint) to train hurts do…
RT @nwinograd: Study finds that using punishment (including yanking on leash, scolding/yelling, shock collars, restraint) to train hurts do…
#noviolenzasuglianimali #dogs #animalidomestici #dog #dogsoftwitter Secondo una #ricerca, l'addestramento dei #cani da compagnia basato su stimoli e sensazioni spiacevoli. Hanno un impatto negativo sullo stato mentale dell'animale a lungo termine. https://t.co/wTvReckkNP
Study finds that using punishment (including yanking on leash, scolding/yelling, shock collars, restraint) to train hurts dogs both in the short and long term. Study: https://t.co/tVdH4GUCLS. Analysis: https://t.co/YfSTUVqYHB. https://t.co/IeqExCdY6V
DOES TRAINING METHOD MATTER? "...evaluate the effects of aversive- and reward-based training methods on companion dog welfare within and outside the training context." #dogs #perros #собака #dogbehavior #dogtraining #clickertraining #caninescience https://t.co/SKZSkQN69S
Training methods based on punishment compromise dog welfare. We can say it louder but not clearer. Stop hurting your dogs Very needed article. https://t.co/eM0PjOja1y
Çalışma, "“Does training method matter? Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare" başlığı ile PLOS ONE'da yayınlandı. https://t.co/8Z2q2Dlmv3
Does training method matter? Yes. Yes it does. https://t.co/CPMU5V0aY7
Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/vrwdOSvogO
RT @abvma: Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/P…
"Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare" In case you're wondering, the answer is... https://t.co/isCbf3auem
Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare: https://t.co/fPYhOR8VvE #dogtraining #dogs
RT @abvma: Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/P…
Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/PKt9ywEHXq
Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/t0Pl6GuRuK
Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/yPVknw5Y7g
Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/acf6nIqNbO
Yelling could harm your dog's longevity. Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare: https://t.co/w9Y3ktHE91
Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/5yHyMyXzHL
Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/p9JX4d1Ovj
Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/OsGGPENurj
Does training method matter?: Evidence for the negative impact of aversive-based methods on companion dog welfare https://t.co/h5AmTM77cc #bioRxiv
NW
AO
DS
DT
U
AW
F
RC
EM
LG
U
AM
EV
MS
F
DL
FM
KP
LR
DD
R
SS
PF
NW
O
IF
SH
P
N
イ
へ
DP
SF
JF
CJ
JA
K
IB
JW
BM
KT
TC
JL
CC
LH
VO
AV
AC
MS
NF
SB
JS
HG
AC
U
B
KF
C
KA
TV
M
WC
B
KR
SV
DM
TS
EC
RP
JW
NT
P
LA
A
IT
V
AJ
F
P
BP
BC
B