Neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors: a technical review of the observational and clinical data.

HS

Hervé Berbille, sojaïste

@hberbille · X

@Langlai73410097 Le #soja n’est pas un perturbateur endocrinien, alors que la viande est un cancérogène avéré (cf. avis CIRC/OMS)… https://t.co/pWOAF5qKpF

AG

Aguará Guazú

@elchacaldelint1 · X

El pronunciamiento de la agencia francesa está a contramano del grueso de la evidencia sobre la seguridad del consumo de isoflavonas en las dosis típicas (1, 2). 1- https://t.co/aM9shT9X14 2- https://t.co/3MtYL8E4xB https://t.co/t336nN8GDV https://t.co/K8WuKjGsHO

PS

perpetual joyless scold

@TalonPipes · X

@Powered_541 @TheShadoutMapes @Younganarchi @shoe0nhead I'm "feminine," so they won't listen to me. They're obsessed with confirmation bias and genetic fallacies. https://t.co/nnqcLzZeEX https://t.co/fRbWJ8Oxvc

Oui parce que la littérature scientifique va dans le sens de l’innocuité du soja est que je reste prudente. Lire par ex. Messina & al., 2021 : "the evidence does not support classifying isoflavones as endocrine disruptors." pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33775173/

NR

Nancy Clark MS RD

@nclarkrd · X

If you hesitate to consume #soy foods, thinking they will alter your hormones, think again. This article reports otherwise: https://t.co/obVKHoUvk4

NC

Nanci Guest PhD, RD, CSCS

@NanciGuestRDPhD · X

@profitnessnj @ScepticalDoctor @Alan_Watson_ @DaveKeto @Veganella_ @vanvlietphd @krosenque Egg whites is wasting a very nutritious part of the egg and it’s not doing anything for animal welfare! The soy-breast cancer link has been debunked for over a decade. This is a helpful meta analysis published in 2021

DP

Dave@ French Polynesia

@davemitten_once · X

RT @davemitten_once: @iluminatibot Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition - Review of 417 studies on soy and hormones https://t.co/…

DP

Dave@ French Polynesia

@davemitten_once · X

@iluminatibot Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition - Review of 417 studies on soy and hormones https://t.co/UsbXkcEhko

H

Helbeets

@Helbeets · X

@juan_revenga @Anses_fr @consumidorglob Qué opinas de esta información? https://t.co/7VMblKO1yM

GA

G.Abitbol

@trollnostrum · X

2min pour découvrir que l'Anses sort l'avis de son cul et que le soja n'a pas d'effet connu comme parturbateur endocrinien .... Le point toujours premier sur la désinformation scientifique https://t.co/gXAXauQtXT https://t.co/DFX9KyhVrr

JA

Juan Arina

@jm_arina · X

RT @elchacaldelint1: El pronunciamiento de la agencia francesa está a contramano del grueso de la evidencia sobre la seguridad del consumo…

FS

Federico Sisti

@fbsisti · X

RT @elchacaldelint1: El pronunciamiento de la agencia francesa está a contramano del grueso de la evidencia sobre la seguridad del consumo…

AG

Aguará Guazú

@elchacaldelint1 · X

@DarioColombatto No tanto. Ver: https://t.co/aM9shT9X14 https://t.co/3MtYL8E4xB

AG

Aguará Guazú

@elchacaldelint1 · X

El pronunciamiento de la agencia francesa está a contramano del grueso de la evidencia sobre la seguridad del consumo de isoflavonas en las dosis típicas (1, 2). 1- https://t.co/aM9shT9X14 2- https://t.co/3MtYL8E4xB https://t.co/t336nN8GDV https://t.co/K8WuKjGsHO

Oui parce que la littérature scientifique va dans le sens de l’innocuité du soja est que je reste prudente. Lire par ex. Messina & al., 2021 : "the evidence does not support classifying isoflavones as endocrine disruptors." pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33775173/

N

nyctophobia

@nyctophobia23 · X

@MartaMH13

N

nyctophobia

@nyctophobia23 · X

@bumb_y @Mr_Slave1892 @gputz83 @MartaMH13 und bezüglich "mal so, mal so" das geht zwischenzeitlich eindeutig in die Richtung "keinen negativen Einfluss" Hier mal ein recht aktueller Überblick https://t.co/krrxLhaENF

L

LegoMyEggo

@LegoMyEggoV3 · X

@FADE_TTRPG @Kneon No??? https://t.co/zWcP1lmQHA https://t.co/IrAq9j1Lyh https://t.co/vLfFuLtkoZ https://t.co/cxuMzK3zQB

BB

Biomass Bob

@SentientBlobBob · X

@r55414771 @ElieJarrougeMD https://t.co/5khIokL1XE Neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors: a technical review of the observational and clinical data

IK

Instant Kairos

@ProjetKairos · X

@sainteselection @lenadesbois Quitte à être un peu sérieux https://t.co/CKYlvra0lX

วแ

วันนี้นางแบก แบกอะไร

@SaHutSuriya · X

@j_rythme https://t.co/0n47nbbdft https://t.co/SPloFUKvGK

RD

RanD_D Ⓥ

@Rdavis67 · X

@ORDER1090AD @HorrorGorl Here’s a conclusion of a review of over 400 reports on human trials https://t.co/FO5o7RXamc

Big meta-analyses pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33775173/ & pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33383165/! Dr Shireen Kassam, who examines a lot of nutrition evidence and has no tie to the soy industry, wrote this: shireenkassam.medium.com/review-of-th...

S

Sāvedasa

@rbhunyaksan · X

@tsmalolan After extensive review, the evidence does not support classifying isoflavones as endocrine disruptors https://t.co/GabyLY879X

HS

Hervé Berbille, sojaïste

@hberbille · X

@Langlai73410097 Le #soja n’est pas un perturbateur endocrinien, alors que la viande est un cancérogène avéré (cf. avis CIRC/OMS)… https://t.co/pWOAF5qKpF

V

Valoche

@Orko_Q3 · X

@FischerDje94752 @brunoj31 @futur_asso @VELEMEBB @LeatherZombieV Après si tu veux qu'on regarde la science plutôt que se fier à l'avis de pôpa : https://t.co/06IvhCYo3N

FG

Francesco Grassi

@FrancescLP · X

@aCarnivoreDiet You literally invented it. https://t.co/6D3vxJgsk5 https://t.co/wabJHi2TVt https://t.co/4tp8fNQoMU https://t.co/X9bRMDWfHS https://t.co/QWUBqI7MJm I dare you to find more relevant studies than those that prove your point (spoiler: you won't)

J

Joris

@herbiJoor · X

@nijlorac @annefleurdd Zie ook: https://t.co/BHVbCgg4Yt

HS

Hervé Berbille, sojaïste

@hberbille · X

@bennetau1 Perso, je m'en tiens aux études scientifiques "peer review"... https://t.co/pWOAF5qKpF

SG

Soy Nutrition Institute (SNI) Global

@Soy_Nutrition · X

Observational and clinical data indicate that neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors

R

remombie

@tuetenremo · X

@jensenhealthch @Tofuwa_Bohu @BorysWalentek @frutti_el_mare 13% hoehere testosteron-konzentration als bei omnivore und sonst keine auswirkung auf die hormonaktivitaet. https://t.co/yk92AjNUdV https://t.co/piuzFE1KRX

V

Valenthym

@valen_thym · X

@SuzannAusteen @GTroikar @emma_ducros https://t.co/9dde2sjsvu

N

Naja

@aurel2899 · X

@ursa_minoral @safe38277551 @El_Orenzo @PETA_France Ici il est question de complément d'isoflavones et non de soja https://t.co/d3OmzhJyJe

J

Joris

@herbiJoor · X

@JoepBC Ik raad je aan om dit even te lezen: https://t.co/BHVbCgg4Yt Over fyo-oestrogenen hoef je je echt geen zorgen te maken. Gewoon gevarieerd eten, dat is altijd goed!

TC

Trail of Compassion

@trailcompassion · X

@hiraeth16091400 @teamveganfta Messina M, Mejia SB, Cassidy A, et al. Neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors: a technical review of the observational and clinical data. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2021;1-57. doi: 10.1080/10408398.2021.1895054

TC

Trail of Compassion

@trailcompassion · X

@7ruthHurts @jedimindwarp @teamveganfta E. Ref: *Messina M, Mejia SB, Cassidy A, et al. Neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors: a technical review of the observational and clinical data. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr. 2021;1-57. doi: 10.1080/10408398.2021.1895054

E

Everton

@Evertonnaf · X

@csar_maciel1 E não, gorduras poliinsaturadas nao n reduzem testosterona, mas enfim aqui está os artigos que eu li e com boas evidências. Você se quiser leia e tire suas conclusões se tiver algo errado só informar https://t.co/8LGxQ0joHM https://t.co/cSR2y6XjuW

SB

Steven Boothe

@stvnbth · X

@ElenaSgarbossa @schkimb @RepTroyCarter @USDA Thank you for that. However that link only references a quote from the abstract. Here’s a link to the complete study. Kindest regards. https://t.co/2pFr3HPLbD

PS

perpetual joyless scold

@TalonPipes · X

@Powered_541 @TheShadoutMapes @Younganarchi @shoe0nhead I'm "feminine," so they won't listen to me. They're obsessed with confirmation bias and genetic fallacies. https://t.co/nnqcLzZeEX https://t.co/fRbWJ8Oxvc

V

Vdaron

@Vgarou · X

@saphorocoeur @leilaouanan @Ecrins6 https://t.co/cbwvOyRfSj

N

nutriscicomm

@nutriscicomm · X

"Review of that examined the relationship between soy and/or isoflavone intake and endocrine-related endpoints" Data from 417 reports:

J

Joris

@herbiJoor · X

@MichielT37 @moeva18 @marcel1410641 Deze is ook leuk: https://t.co/BHVbCfYtzT

MI

M. Irma

@MonsieurIrma · X

@DelAvocado @Tyllou @RepliqueEthique @Balthazar_Again https://t.co/0jcv3kmadv

MI

M. Irma

@MonsieurIrma · X

@ItiponKanrat @TBegoud @JohannLECLERCQ4 Non c'est faux et à moins de disposer de données scientifiques fiables et contraire à cette méta analyse il va falloir admettre que vos déductions ne reposent que sur du vent. Bonne journée. https://t.co/0jcv3kmadv

TA

The OG Devil's Agvocate

@MGigger · X

@WhySoSerious06 Fight? We were having a discussion where I mentioned that many people need formula so you tweeted I was a Karen Oh, look, another meta analysis that’s stood up to time & peer review. I can’t wait to see how you “debunk” it based on your personal vendetta https://t.co/DZHUJmniv2

J

Joris

@herbiJoor · X

@yo_slg Nu nog wachten op de eerste die over hormonen begint, kunnen we lachen: https://t.co/BHVbCgg4Yt

NC

Nanci Guest PhD, RD, CSCS

@NanciGuestRDPhD · X

@madhulika2810 @narayannat @PRuchiSoya @vezlay @chiragbarjatyaa Absolutely! A few recent summaries as well. We have lots of safety data. And soy is one of the few foods that can make an FDA-approved heart healthy claim. I am expanding organic soy at my farm this spring -- steaming a soy pod direct from the plant

TS

thatspiderbyte.bsky.social

@ThatSpiderByte · X

@thecomeUP229 @TheCoachFriso also entirely wrong https://t.co/Cebz0LaLrV https://t.co/20v6zhA5uq https://t.co/6pVA0hNgC9

J

Joris

@herbiJoor · X

@Eukeltje1 @SjoerdWouw Zie bijvoorbeeld dit onderzoek: https://t.co/BHVbCgg4Yt

C

Chad

@NietzscheanHobo · X

"Neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors: a technical review of the observational and clinical data" https://t.co/iMENUKa5Ww

FI

Florence Dellerie (compte inactif)

@FlorenceDell · X

@A_Beauc J'ai fait une capture d'écran de Wikipédia par souci de simplicité, mais encore une fois je vous invite à consulter la littérature scientifique citée dans la fiche + en ressources sur mon site, notamment : https://t.co/ENU0hhpXlf (doi: 10.1080/10408398.2021.1895054)

CO

Crypt-oh

@Cryptoh8 · X

@ImMaxwellington @MyzraelCreates @Zajac_na_Pive @nic__carter All the latest evidence shows that is in fact a myth. Latest meta analysis here: https://t.co/Qb0n8lySsF and technical review of the literature here: https://t.co/CfnHt1nNs5

S

SJones

@SJonesWasTaken · X

@TeriBarna2 @DietHeartNews https://t.co/L8HFlK0M1B

HS

Hervé Berbille, sojaïste

@hberbille · X

Les génies de @UFCquechoisir "saisissent l’Anses et la DGCCRF" à propos des "Perturbateurs endocriniens dans les produits à base de #soja", c'est-à-dire des substances qui... n'existent pas ! (dans le soja s'entend...)... #pathétique https://t.co/pWOAF5qKpF

NC

Nanci Guest PhD, RD, CSCS

@NanciGuestRDPhD · X

@anonrc @julesserkin @antidictator13 @DietHeartNews Soy as a hormone disruptor - no effect https://t.co/kOJP6WsJVc Soy has a neutral effect for bone Soy has a #positive effect for hot flashes' https://t.co/NNjJH8xxVF heart health https://t.co/rAcDlBxoUZ colon cancer https://t.co/gZP4g3iH2S breast cancer https://t.co/gCc5dXa4Tq

BC

Brett Chrest

@Chrest_brett · X

@kevinnbass When looking up your tweet and the study, I found another big review: "neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors" https://t.co/3xWE1QgWK2

NC

Nanci Guest PhD, RD, CSCS

@NanciGuestRDPhD · X

@profitnessnj @ScepticalDoctor @Alan_Watson_ @DaveKeto @Veganella_ @vanvlietphd @krosenque Egg whites is wasting a very nutritious part of the egg and it’s not doing anything for animal welfare! The soy-breast cancer link has been debunked for over a decade. This is a helpful meta analysis published in 2021

D

Das

@shivadas29 · X

Here are the references I made in the thread. Links1 https://t.co/6VkPoNBP28 Link 2 https://t.co/5oH8QeQ6GT https://t.co/tPd0JDvzQr

D

Dingemanse

@Dingemanse · X

@AriaanBreevaart @danser_david @ericklaassen @DierenRecht @NancyGroningen Toevallig is er een nieuwe metastudie gedaan. Wat je hele opmerking meteen naar het land der fabelen verwijst: https://t.co/fyPXFTYtYi

M

marcy

@marcy57211006 · X

RT @nclarkrd: If you hesitate to consume #soy foods, thinking they will alter your hormones, think again. This article reports otherwise: h…

JN

James Nance

@jnance3489 · X

RT @nclarkrd: If you hesitate to consume #soy foods, thinking they will alter your hormones, think again. This article reports otherwise: h…

AM

Anita Macken

@anitamacken · X

RT @nclarkrd: If you hesitate to consume #soy foods, thinking they will alter your hormones, think again. This article reports otherwise: h…

NR

Nancy Clark MS RD

@nclarkrd · X

If you hesitate to consume #soy foods, thinking they will alter your hormones, think again. This article reports otherwise: https://t.co/obVKHoUvk4

PL

Patricia Lasseter

@PLasseter · X

Neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors: a technical review of the observational and clinical data - PubMed https://t.co/A31nMVHYBJ

JF

Joel "Heart Prevention" Kahn MD, FACC

@drjkahn · X

Soy is healthy. #kahnchronicle https://t.co/25xLzPnzhZ

CP

Catarina Petisca

@CatarinaPetisca · X

#DYK #myths abt #soy? #Isoflavones (soy natural comp) are usually classified as #endocrinedisruptors Previous studies were based on animals& don’t reflect the human biology acc to a

K

Klaatu

@houmoussaka · X

@BordeOlivier @TPMP Méta-étude sur 417 études et rapports qui conclut à l'innocuité des isoflavones. Et qui explique au passage que l'étude qui concluait au risque des isoflavones avait été faite sur des animaux, pas sur des humains. https://t.co/BtGMEOrCk5

VA

Veg_analytic

@Veganalytic · X

Issus de : M. Messina et al, Neither soyfood nor isoflavones warrant classificatioasas endocrindisruptorsrsa a technicareviewew of thobservationalal anclinicalal data, Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition (2021) https://t.co/8CNfvfvcaq

HT

Harry Tuttle

@harry_tuttle_x · X

RT @hberbille: Depuis plusieurs années, @UFCquechoisir @LotzJulie C. Pelissero-Bennetau tentent imposer idée selon laquelle #soja = perturb…

VP

Victor Prandt

@Prandt_Victor · X

RT @hberbille: Depuis plusieurs années, @UFCquechoisir @LotzJulie C. Pelissero-Bennetau tentent imposer idée selon laquelle #soja = perturb…

VA

Veg_analytic

@Veganalytic · X

RT @hberbille: Depuis plusieurs années, @UFCquechoisir @LotzJulie C. Pelissero-Bennetau tentent imposer idée selon laquelle #soja = perturb…

HS

Hervé Berbille, sojaïste

@hberbille · X

Depuis plusieurs années, @UFCquechoisir @LotzJulie C. Pelissero-Bennetau tentent imposer idée selon laquelle #soja = perturbateur endocrinien. 1 solide revue scientifique siffle fin de la récrée... (dont rédacteur I. Rowland, expert sollicité/@Anses_fr)... https://t.co/pWOAF59915

AM

annelies moons

@anneliesmoons · X

Neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors: a technical review of the observational and clinical data https://t.co/TrkLEKfrA9

CM

Claudia Guillén-López MD

@claudiaegl92 · X

Neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors: a technical review of the observat… https://t.co/IZhTAEesIw

C

CenkMuharremBlanqui

@mehmetblanqui · X

40 yillik tum "Soya urunleri kadinlarda yumurtlamayi bozar, menopoz tetikler, erkekleri feminize eder, meme buyutur, prostat kanseri yapar" spekulasyonuna dair datalari tum istatistik modellerle bastan incelemisler. Uzun erimli calismalari not etmisler. https://t.co/QWcpR2fpDp

TS

Travis Statham

@Travis_Statham · X

I just posted "Neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors: a technical review of the observational and clinical data -- Mark Messina (Soy industry's main apologist)" on Reddit https://t.co/QgijfI7Gyx

S

SoybeanPapers

@SoybeanPapers · X

Neither soyfoods nor isoflavones warrant classification as endocrine disruptors: a technical review of the observational and clinical data https://t.co/dHbphNdkEV https://t.co/8mpljI3J7W

P

PREKURE

@PREKUREOfficial · X

I'd probably be convinced by this snowjob, despite the conflicts of interest, if I hadn't myself experienced worrying and unpleasant hormonal effects from eating tofu back when I thought it was a health food. YMMV. https://t.co/FltmzpziHw