L'auteur se permet aussi d'affirmer sans source de l'individu « en transition » que « plus il avance, plus il se déprime, jusqu’à des épisodes dépressifs sévères ». Sauf que la littérature scientifique sur la question établit plutôt le contraire : https://t.co/GC83Ocr3dS
Providing Affirmative Care to Transgender and Gender Diverse Youth: Disparities, Interventions, and Outcomes.
Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
Mentions per month
Apr 2021 – Jan 2025Where it's discussed
-
X / Twitter83 posts
-
News32 articles
-
YouTube6 videos
-
Blogs5 articles
-
Bluesky1 posts
AI synopsis
What people are saying
Many discussions highlight critical points from the publication, with posts pointing to specific studies and statistics that showcase the effectiveness of affirmative care, such as a reduction in depression and suicide ideation among TGD youth. For example, one post mentions '60% less probability of depression and 73% less probability of suicide,' which emphasizes the life-saving potential of these interventions. The tone across various posts ranges from supportive and informative to confrontational, with users employing phrases like 'scientific evidence supports' and 'consider the positive outcomes,' lending a sense of urgency and importance to the conversation.
The majority of posts express strong support for the publication's findings regarding the benefits of affirmative care for transgender and gender-diverse youth.
There is a notable curiosity shown in the discussions around the article, with many users eager to dive deeper into the subject matter.
Several posts reflect deep engagement, with users referencing studies and methodologies, which indicates a serious consideration of the topic.
Most contributors believe the publication's insights can lead to substantial improvements in healthcare practices and outcomes for TGD youth.
Abstract in brief
- The paper reviews research on the mental health of transgender and gender-diverse (TGD) youth, highlighting the harmful effects of stigma and discrimination they face in family, school, and community settings.
- There is evidence that gender-affirming interventions can lead to better mental health outcomes for TGD youth, especially when they are in supportive environments.
- To improve healthcare access and outcomes, providers should consider intersectional identities and create affirmative spaces in their practices, while also assisting TGD youth in connecting with supportive resources in their communities.]
Top posts
Most liked on X and Bluesky@TheAmz2017 @RightWingCope they do the very same thing with vaccines, btw. so no, she doesn't "love" her child. She sees it as her property and as something to value her status. https://t.co/ovSVA86pSn
@glock_molly @DotJason1 @KatysCartoons @KatyMontgomerie https://t.co/Aw1q6R29t5 https://t.co/MxRM9EPlRh https://t.co/QyZNJHiavv https://t.co/3w2KY1Kr9Q https://t.co/a173rezK63
"Providers can best support transgender and gender diverse youth by considering ways they can affirm these youth in their healthcare settings, and helping them access support in schools, family systems, and communities." https://t.co/OezzSTZAG8 https://t.co/8n7HM12JEA
@PoorDecisionsMW @sirscranner @MrGrEenFR @kommanderkarl https://t.co/ES1rRLpjSo https://t.co/LNnbnbjUdr https://t.co/zSFbxwIHey
@BloodWulker I don't expect you to change your mind, but I really hope you do. https://t.co/HAezsr6wKG https://t.co/DAGGpA3yhA https://t.co/fDzwQrBxJ9 https://t.co/CFKQDdOUEu
All mentions
Insights on Trans Healthcare from Recent Hearing Discussions
In this video, conure analyzes Matt Walsh's interaction during the Tennessee hearing on gender-affirming care. We will explore the impact of stigma on transgender youth and highlight the importance of supportive…
The Exploitation of Detransitioners by Antitrans Activists
This video examines how secret groups exploit detransitioners to oppose gender-affirming healthcare. It discusses the case of Elisa Rae Shupe and reveals the connection between these tactics and broader anti-trans…
Debunking Misconceptions About Trans Youth Healthcare Practices
In this video, Conure discusses debunking claims about a transgender clinic in St. Louis and the evidence surrounding gender-affirming care. The focus includes the mental health impacts of stigma and the importance of…
Understanding Transgender Healthcare Standards and Misconceptions
In this video, Conure reacts to Donald Trump's recent anti-transgender video, discussing the importance of the evolving Standards of Care for transgender individuals. Explore key facts about transgender healthcare and…
Exploring Standards of Care for Transgender Health and Well-being
In this video, conure reacts to misconceptions surrounding transgender identities, informed by the evolving guidelines from the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH). Join the discussion on…
Understanding Gender Dysphoria and Its Impact on TGD Youth
@Msnobody333 @burtwalker @IsabellaScar2 @InsanityIsFree And yet still all these studies say otherwise https://t.co/TlJBkpjams
@PoorDecisionsMW @sirscranner @MrGrEenFR @kommanderkarl https://t.co/ES1rRLpjSo https://t.co/LNnbnbjUdr https://t.co/zSFbxwIHey
@ringofsour @lxeagle17 - cite an example. - https://t.co/lTqou6Hpx6 - https://t.co/4ON0ZmMszI
Call, D., Challa, M., & Telingator, C. (2021). Providing Affirmative Care to Transgender and Gender Diverse Youth: Disparities, Interventions, and Outcomes. Current Psychiatry Reports, 23. doi.org/10.1007/s119....
@JordzWilliamz @FLNative285812 @gh0stfxcelvr @paintedpontoon @sapphyreblayze https://t.co/gjBo1P7Bxi https://t.co/1B4SawLiVK https://t.co/Bl5ES3Okc9 https://t.co/vFcc1nojTE https://t.co/g7cbwNgFR9 I can provide more, but it wont matter to someone like you. Maybe one day you will accept the reality that you want to harm children. Seek help.
@thekingofnido @WillVV3 @coldcoffee23567 @ImWatson91 @ThomasWillett9 Second source: https://t.co/dFmi3IBwpx
Matt Walsh ROLLED In Trans Healthcare Ban Hearing, Gets Triggered By Me https://t.co/6qiCkk84sJ via @YouTube
@GeorgeHclownwrl @OhDanniGirl @LilahRPGtt I'm just gonna drop this and make you understand they're not delusional. Please give it at least a read if you have time https://t.co/ZgR5mLRfnN
@Love_Being_Fit @SomberPrincess3 Im just gonna post that and say nothing else :) (btw 106 references...) https://t.co/ZgR5mLQHyf
@ChrisBalchin4 @BPFTR7474 @xxxypher @legaltweetz Then read this, look at how many studies there are inside, and prove me wrong. https://t.co/ZgR5mLRfnN
https://t.co/7h3fvdoHKb
@BelucciMon @I_dont_care_al1 @JGuty1985 @Bio_comunidad El enfoque afirmativo reduce las ideaciones suicidas y mejora la salud mental. https://t.co/llOmPfNlCd
@tonysullybooks @BadWritingTakes @ChtyCommission https://t.co/IM7f938p9O
@rangersdaz @spy_historian @APowellLaw @alibali50 @Regenbo5en Hmm... what do you think of this? https://t.co/eDhUh9Osf4
@DraAbigailCeva1 @resistrinker @juana_gallego Metaestudio que correlaciona la terapia afirmativa con una mejora de la salud mental en adolescentes trans ⤵️ https://t.co/Uqx1ydCTf4
@Estacadebares @ajfrojo2 @AnianMarti1000x @CALDirector @Amanda_DGIR https://t.co/c8CvRzRNj8
@mattyglesias the answer i saw is that *just* medical intervention is not enough. the second part, which he mentions later in the article, is social stigma. https://t.co/12Ct13M0oB https://t.co/8wTzHiHSoU https://t.co/xQqU4rSgwN https://t.co/Cqr3JLaQBC
@carmenpaton88 @BelucciMon Aquí tienes el enlace al pdf ⤵️ https://t.co/0E27RUFsxL
@nacheldon @Harada_1964 @J0p0o @JMSanchis70 @karinacastelao @Gutierrezana50 @carme_gamero Y la evidencia científica avala que una perspectiva afirmativa es la mejor opción. https://t.co/c8CvRzRNj8
@scrufwiththecat @GenderReceipts @AlanFarrell Here are 5 published within the last 10 years. Happy reading https://t.co/UtHw7SxtTY https://t.co/50Hfe36SAm https://t.co/rn8M3hoi1b https://t.co/qono189gdM https://t.co/iY3ixuhe8k
@S4TRN @PhotobombingC @EliErlick Actually there are tangible benefits to gender affirming care on teens https://t.co/TvM8sHKuhN https://t.co/FtlsrkBE5j https://t.co/dr7sQ8Ud2Q https://t.co/Gy0CmCCwF6
@mariadesancha @JMSanchis70 @CarlesCasanova7 @lalunaenlibra Distintos metaestudios demuestran que este enfoque es el más efectivo para disminuir la disforia de género y los problemas asociados a ellos ⤵️ 3/n https://t.co/0E27RUG0nj
@Kuro_Neko2023 @RobnHudSuplidos Por tanto, si deseamos comprobar la efectividad del enfoque afirmativo habrá que comparar el mismo grupo poblacional antes y después. Aquí dejo un enlace a un metaestudio ⤵️ https://t.co/0E27RUFsxL
@JuanaB1963 https://t.co/c8CvRzRNj8
«... observamos 60% menos probabilidades de depresión y 73% menos probabilidades de suicidio entre los jóvenes que habían iniciado PBs o GAHs en comparación con los jóvenes que no lo habían hecho.» https://t.co/c8CvRzRNj8 Sigo esperando tu análisis... https://t.co/0T1D0BLw1u
Here's 5 studies demonstrating that gender affirming care has a positive effect on children https://t.co/rgikpZMf0Y https://t.co/0VMtJ7GLhD https://t.co/MEVAD78ZN0 https://t.co/b4tQpLnS37 https://t.co/D2c6gufLgC
@AnaLizadeCide @EnMantis De hecho, estudios longitudinales demuestran el efecto positivo de la afirmación ⤵️ https://t.co/c8CvRzRNj8
RT @Bunker_D_: L'auteur se permet aussi d'affirmer sans source de l'individu « en transition » que « plus il avance, plus il se déprime, ju…
RT @Bunker_D_: L'auteur se permet aussi d'affirmer sans source de l'individu « en transition » que « plus il avance, plus il se déprime, ju…
RT @Bunker_D_: L'auteur se permet aussi d'affirmer sans source de l'individu « en transition » que « plus il avance, plus il se déprime, ju…
RT @Bunker_D_: L'auteur se permet aussi d'affirmer sans source de l'individu « en transition » que « plus il avance, plus il se déprime, ju…
RT @Bunker_D_: L'auteur se permet aussi d'affirmer sans source de l'individu « en transition » que « plus il avance, plus il se déprime, ju…
RT @Bunker_D_: L'auteur se permet aussi d'affirmer sans source de l'individu « en transition » que « plus il avance, plus il se déprime, ju…
L'auteur se permet aussi d'affirmer sans source de l'individu « en transition » que « plus il avance, plus il se déprime, jusqu’à des épisodes dépressifs sévères ». Sauf que la littérature scientifique sur la question établit plutôt le contraire : https://t.co/GC83Ocr3dS
@PeakedBimbo @notprogboofer @JUNlPER @benshapiro Yeah that source on the left is talking about one specific clinic with poor assessment and the one on the right was a study with about 300 participants from 1972 to 2002 and didn’t seem to note any societal factors. https://t.co/HNLVFWv6AC https://t.co/hLsvNDWkfb
@DaMerkster12 @betterutah There’s a ton! If you don’t mind me sharing a few- https://t.co/eFSND2FE3F
@g_lamarche @TorontoStar Every claim you're making there is completely untrue. There are penty of studies into the effects of puberty blockers & cross-sex hormones, and they've been shown to cause dramatic positive changes in mental health and suicidality. You're just lying. https://t.co/2qibjp6xM6
@RomeTimed @Lukestonehm @TPostMillennial https://t.co/h11yO28Pu3
@TheAmz2017 @RightWingCope they do the very same thing with vaccines, btw. so no, she doesn't "love" her child. She sees it as her property and as something to value her status. https://t.co/ovSVA86pSn
@MrsG503 @ACMESalesRep @itsjillgardner Sure. Here's a comprehensive review of the literature. https://t.co/2qibjp6xM6 https://t.co/Yg6vyXLoR8
@DOCiiLEBULL @kelly_cadigan There are countless of studies showing precisely that. https://t.co/i5AzRZt83i https://t.co/RxtwsdUhCK https://t.co/RlwynQLNAy https://t.co/Z6Wa1np3Az
What Nobody Gets About Gender Dysphoria ... https://t.co/RS1kfinyG0
@AndrewFazzolare Pic 1: https://t.co/EhiikCkeB4 Pic 2: https://t.co/2UK2k3lsIk Pic 3: https://t.co/6T0jthSXP2 Pic 4: https://t.co/a2i6mdLTth
@Lamar76metal @libsoftiktok Gender affirming care for children. https://t.co/mQqOj8OJgw
Anti-Trans Gender Clinic "Whistleblower" HILARIOUSLY DEBUNKED By Parents https://t.co/mB27ubOTVk
@Trassk33 @seriesable @LilySimpson1312 detransitioners are respected for their choice on the assumption that they don't become raging TERFs. detransition is also most often caused by social/financial pressure. see timestamp in this video. https://t.co/0FH62Lw5Sw
Anti-Trans Gender Clinic "Whistleblower" HILARIOUSLY DEBUNKED By Parents https://t.co/K2wkvydF25 via @YouTube
Remember the chick that worked at the gender affirming care clinic, that wrote an article about it and calls herself a whistleblower? Her name was Jamie Reed? Yeah just like I thought she was a fake. https://t.co/H7IHsngGXq
#Trans #Ally #JamieReed Holy shit this is hot! I thought something was up? https://t.co/9506i25DTI
Anti-Trans Gender Clinic "Whistleblower" HILARIOUSLY DEBUNKED By Parents https://t.co/jHTD8Qg2AG
@FriendsRobots @GorinMoti For anyone not dishonest; Adult: Regret rate is low (first img) Youth (obv low sample): https://t.co/NyAoTl2pW3 https://t.co/q6GPkGvCqB https://t.co/dzLSJJNeLZ https://t.co/iJ3b2qO7ca https://t.co/j0yfDeccKW https://t.co/87ZVH6glfA Ongoing: https://t.co/84cJDtZAca https://t.co/6BjeguF2Nq
@GorinMoti https://t.co/i3aO1ur83m https://t.co/RP0EZFPEQc https://t.co/jOkFrdpIvI https://t.co/DNPvnXERP1 https://t.co/45gDqZTCun https://t.co/i3aO1ur83m https://t.co/LC5rlhxWZz Let me know if you need more, lying liar.
@FriedCh41287569 @chaquetadecarne @ConterPatrick @TheOmniLiberal Except we do. here's another study: https://t.co/Qou52M8Mwg And here's a list of Organizations who have opposed legislation to limit gender-affirming medical care for trans youth. But I'm assuming all of these organizations and studies are just more propaganda to you. https://t.co/q8wDLciRXS
@BellaOrnot Call et al, “Providing Affirmative Care to Transgender and Gender Diverse Youth: Disparities, Interventions, and Outcomes”, Child and Adolescent Disorder, 2021 https://t.co/GC83Ocr3dS https://t.co/vLZBMBbbP5
Matt Walsh ROLLED In Trans Healthcare Ban Hearing, Gets Triggered By Me https://t.co/zCJaRMdLMU ผ่าน @YouTube
@TanFi99 @Sha14978250 @conmomma @Fishing_Huuker You don't think the Dr's ever thought of that? Research shows there are no underlying causes and mental health issues come from how they are treated. Only 27% of trans youth report supportive parents and 12% supportive schools. https://t.co/ETJXDN4wRs https://t.co/0RQc8w4dLN https://t.co/k8PiPSKYt8
@BloodWulker I don't expect you to change your mind, but I really hope you do. https://t.co/HAezsr6wKG https://t.co/DAGGpA3yhA https://t.co/fDzwQrBxJ9 https://t.co/CFKQDdOUEu
@TheBuonaVita @Riverview_dave @leeredguard65 @RonFilipkowski https://t.co/2bbBiNCBX9 your version of "truth" results in suicide, so I guess yeah, it's pretty important
@WeimarEnjoyer @Tazerrtot @Adam72533614 @BoozieGrace @crotweet @scrowder @WhatIsAWomanBot https://t.co/TeyfJKt723
@A7medd86 @IHATETHERAMS @BasedChristian8 @GullGlaucous @cheveyotg13 @louise__attack @Lanception @ElijahSchaffer @elonmusk sure. affirmation works. https://t.co/4EQQRTnlqt https://t.co/faJAZe4g7t https://t.co/rdpcJsBwjX
@GCSchoolTeacher @KatyMontgomerie here's a meta review on affirmitive care that says you are lying. https://t.co/3ZEhC4DhXA
@JennyCl63339184 @LydiaNusbaum All of the examples I saw of surgeries on minors were breast removals, not genital surgery Source on the claim that puberty blockers aren’t permanent btw, maybe read an academic paper some day https://t.co/udNKEFpNOu
@annwright95 @WeAreWomen1234 @mjeslfc @BBCJamesCook I mean, the fact you're clinging to an anti-science ideology being able to override the evidence and science, and you don't even see how this blows back on things like abortion rights... Oof https://t.co/bRAPX5N8HH
@FLY0VERCOUNTRY @VaushV @benshapiro these ones are good: https://t.co/rdpcJsBwjX
@soniasodha @francesweetman Hi Sonia, maybe you should try reading instead of talking all the time? It would make your tweets marginally more tolerable. https://t.co/3hcrg3Q8OQ https://t.co/5seddNneYA
@the_average_jon @AriDrennen @mmfa @anyazoledz Isn’t the burden of proof on you to prove that puberty blockers are harmful? Isn’t the standard assumption that something is neutral until proven otherwise? Also here’s a study, I can link more if you’re so inclined https://t.co/3hcrg3PAZi
@DPeteworthy @ZenOfDesign @chensonmusic @clockland_ @jk_rowling *cherrypicked by you from random paper indexed by the library of medicine *does not know what the National Library of Medicine even is or how it works
@overwolken @Ravendubh2 @KimIversenShow /2 And this is part of the body of evidence, on top of the statistics I cited earlier, of the enormous mental health benefits to gender-affirming interventions including surgery. The data is extremely clear and straightforward: https://t.co/EkCZGrK426
@regnbueraad @CreaDanFlex @JSCowland Værsgo: Gennemgang af litteratur S4: Stophormon virker midlertidigt, er reversibelt, giver tid til at udforske kønsidentitet, har være brugt længe til behandling af børn med fremmelig/for tidlig pubertet og viser ingen længerevarende bivirkninger. https://t.co/AsoNv3uCTZ 1/
@nicholasb44 @AArFEverything @ThotlessDoll @DylanBurns1776 oh boy on hrt in generall evidence on adolescents https://t.co/12Ct13M0oB https://t.co/kpynH7Fmsf https://t.co/iRTG28uD7X evidence on adults https://t.co/PQlnICf5yw https://t.co/sANGYM0iot (there's more with small-ish sample sizes)
@JD25101236 @Glendathebad @NiaPere98304469 https://t.co/7AqEVXzUHN
@FuckyourselfG0 @MForstater Supporting teens mental health following decades worth of research backed health care led to a whole host of individual and societal issues? Mkay... I'm guessing you have a source for this. (My citation: https://t.co/YbTTUmkIxE )
@ElectricClair @Von_Dred @MandoQ3R0 Get access rather than a paywall: https://t.co/cLACtlTnwg Add https://t.co/SXSePSX5De to the DOI URL when sharing articles to promote scholarly communication
But take Good Friday as an opportunity to engage in some self-reflection about how negative health outcomes in the transgender community only really come about because of how we as a society respond to vulnerable minorities amongst us. https://t.co/jfp8tcQntT
@CjgbVictoria @AraucariaArauc1 @AstroLlamaBeans @EHRC "Watch and wait" is an awful practice and not used in most free countries, with good reason. Affirmation has been well proven to help kids. "There is increasing evidence that gender-affirming interventions improve mental health outcomes for TGD youth." https://t.co/PUb2GcpXPh
@DieuwertWubbe @JamesEsses @brettg1974 Puberty blockers are probably physically reversible, but it is true that we don't yet know everything about their use; however we do know that denying gender affirming healthcare to gender diverse individuals worsens their health - https://t.co/7g6MggTzhI
@SinNomb54107159 @ACLU i think you may misunderstand... in most cases, its not physical surgery. puberty can cause trans children to become depressed, suicidal, etc, so puberty blocking medication can be life saving! https://t.co/0vvuzxSTIS there are studies supporting hormone therapy (nonsurgical)
@glock_molly @DotJason1 @KatysCartoons @KatyMontgomerie https://t.co/Aw1q6R29t5 https://t.co/MxRM9EPlRh https://t.co/QyZNJHiavv https://t.co/3w2KY1Kr9Q https://t.co/a173rezK63
@DramaSchoolSec @zorzokoko @S_U_A_R @CentristDad5 @holland_tom https://t.co/bRAPX5MAS9
RT @drkellyallen: Providing Affirmative Care to Transgender and Gender Diverse Youth: Disparities, Interventions, and Outcomes https://t.co…
RT @drkellyallen: Providing Affirmative Care to Transgender and Gender Diverse Youth: Disparities, Interventions, and Outcomes https://t.co…
RT @LiemAndrian: "Providers can best support transgender and gender diverse youth by considering ways they can affirm these youth in their…
"Providers can best support transgender and gender diverse youth by considering ways they can affirm these youth in their healthcare settings, and helping them access support in schools, family systems, and communities." https://t.co/OezzSTZAG8 https://t.co/8n7HM12JEA
Providing Affirmative Care to Transgender and Gender Diverse Youth: Disparities, Interventions, and Outcomes https://t.co/q8Qfq9iDTc #PubMed #Transgender