December 2021 PMID 34636929

Do collagen supplements reduce symptoms of osteoarthritis? Meta-analytic results do not support strong conclusions.

Paul T von Hippel

Mentions

17
Peak: 9 in Dec 2024
across 2 sources since Jan 2022

Extended reach

413,563
potential audience

Total likes

1,395

Video views

312,992

Mentions per month

Jan 2022 – Jan 2025

Where it's discussed

  • YouTube12 videos
  • X / Twitter5 posts

AI synopsis

What people are saying

Discussions reflect a consensus that current research does not support the effectiveness of collagen supplements, as seen in comments like 'meta-analysis suggests no strong evidence,' and skepticism about industry-funded studies, with tone ranging from cautious to critical. This highlights the influence of scientific findings and media on public perception, driven by phrases such as 'not confident' and references to expert opinions for authority.

AgreementStrong agreement

Most discussions align with the article's conclusion that current evidence does not strongly support collagen supplements for osteoarthritis, with comments referencing the meta-analysis as conclusive or emphasizing the need for caution.

InterestModerate interest

The discussions show some interest, especially among those skeptical of industry-funded studies and interested in recent research or expert opinions, but overall, the topic does not seem to generate widespread enthusiasm.

EngagementModerate engagement

Participants cite specific articles, express skepticism with phrases like 'not confident,' and refer to expert opinions, indicating moderate active engagement with the topic.

ImpactHigh impact

The conversations appear to influence perceptions about the supplement's effectiveness, reinforcing skepticism and highlighting the importance of evidence-based conclusions, which suggests a significant impact on public understanding.

Abstract in brief

  • Collagen supplements are being studied to see if they can help reduce symptoms of osteoarthritis.
  • A recent meta-analysis, which combines results from multiple studies, suggests that there isn't enough strong evidence to confirm their effectiveness.
  • Overall, the current research does not strongly support the idea that collagen supplements significantly relieve osteoarthritis symptoms.]

Top posts

Most liked on X and Bluesky
JM Mulet
@jmmulet · X

@YolandaLanza Hola. Que la "receta" parezca un folleto publicitario no inspira confianza, de entrada. Buscando en la literatura, lo más reciente... https://t.co/w5FKscPnYz La respuesta parece seguir siendo que no.

Jan 19, 2023 · 1 like · 74,197 followers View post →
TheFrenchEpidemiologist
@frenchepidemio · X

3 ans plus tard (ça en a mis du temps !), une lettre démonte cette méta-analyse https://t.co/034eUYfY6Z Les 5 études étaient financées par l’industrie produisant du collagène 2) Publication sélective des résultats significatis https://t.co/JaKrKPfznW

Sep 6, 2023 · 1 like · 15,105 followers View post →
Luuk Hilkens
@luukhil · X

@ScepticalDoctor Also worth a read is this letter to the editor by prof. @PaulvonHippel about research on collagen supplements to reduce symptoms of osteoarthritis( https://t.co/cN2Wc2Ybyt). In line, check his article on @statnews https://t.co/0YtFrUWDIf

May 7, 2023 · 1 like · 510 followers View post →
PF Anderson @pfanderson@disabled.social
@pfanderson · X

Do collagen supplements reduce symptoms of osteoarthritis? Meta-analytic results do not support strong conclusions https://t.co/ZmmsXnwv2y #sysrev

Jan 23, 2022 · 10,752 followers View post →

All mentions

TheFrenchEpidemiologist
@frenchepidemio · X

3 ans plus tard (ça en a mis du temps !), une lettre démonte cette méta-analyse https://t.co/034eUYfY6Z Les 5 études étaient financées par l’industrie produisant du collagène 2) Publication sélective des résultats significatis https://t.co/JaKrKPfznW

Sep 6, 2023 · 1 like · 15,105 followers View post →
Luuk Hilkens
@luukhil · X

@ScepticalDoctor Also worth a read is this letter to the editor by prof. @PaulvonHippel about research on collagen supplements to reduce symptoms of osteoarthritis( https://t.co/cN2Wc2Ybyt). In line, check his article on @statnews https://t.co/0YtFrUWDIf

May 7, 2023 · 1 like · 510 followers View post →
JM Mulet
@jmmulet · X

@YolandaLanza Hola. Que la "receta" parezca un folleto publicitario no inspira confianza, de entrada. Buscando en la literatura, lo más reciente... https://t.co/w5FKscPnYz La respuesta parece seguir siendo que no.

Jan 19, 2023 · 1 like · 74,197 followers View post →
PF Anderson @pfanderson@disabled.social
@pfanderson · X

Do collagen supplements reduce symptoms of osteoarthritis? Meta-analytic results do not support strong conclusions https://t.co/ZmmsXnwv2y #sysrev

Jan 23, 2022 · 10,752 followers View post →
アリ:ARI
@ARI02333059 · X

メタアナリシスの結論に「待った!」:膝OAのコラーゲンサプリ効果を否定した理由とは・・・|Super Human | >>> https://t.co/Z2VWN09EkP #エビデンス #変形性膝関節症 #コラーゲン #文献抄読 #英文抄読 #利益相反 #緒方洪庵 #批判的吟味 #COI #出版バイアス https://t.co/2gKno7VnyV

Jan 7, 2022 · 10 followers View post →