March 2023 PMID 36877840

Narrow range of early habitable Venus scenarios permitted by modeling of oxygen loss and radiogenic argon degassing.

Alexandra O Warren, Edwin S Kite

Download social card

Mentions

Peak: 27 in Mar 2023

across 6 sources since Mar 2023

Extended reach

5,560,736

potential audience

Total likes

130,080

Video views

3,775,785

Mentions per month

Mar 2023 – Jun 2025

Where it's discussed

News48 articles
X / Twitter37 posts
Blogs5 articles
Bluesky2 posts
YouTube2 videos
Facebook2 posts

AI synopsis

What people are saying

Various discussions explore the research's implications, using words like 'interesting' and questions about Venus's past habitability to express curiosity. The tone ranges from casual curiosity to humorous warnings, reflecting both engagement with scientific details and broader concerns about planetary evolution.

AgreementModerate agreement

Most discussions acknowledge the research's findings, with comments like 'Venus: always dead?' and 'They better hurry up' showing cautious support and recognition of the study’s implications.

InterestHigh interest

Posts demonstrate high curiosity and engagement, indicated by questions about Venus's habitability and comments like 'Very interesting!' which highlight active curiosity.

EngagementModerate engagement

Several posts engage deeply by referencing specific details such as oxygen loss, radiogenic argon degassing, and planetary evolution, showing thoughtful consideration of the scientific content.

ImpactModerate impact

Overall, these discussions suggest that the article influences perceptions of planetary habitability, with some comments humorously linking Earth's climate issues to Venus's history, indicating an awareness of broader implications.

Abstract in brief

The study suggests that only a narrow set of early Venus scenarios could have supported liquid water and habitable conditions, mainly due to the limitations imposed by oxygen loss and radiogenic argon degassing.
Models indicate that if Venus had a habitable era, it likely ended before 3 billion years ago, with the planet's atmosphere losing a significant amount of oxygen through space escape, volcanic activity, and surface oxidation.
The findings emphasize that maintaining a modern atmospheric composition on Venus would require very specific conditions, including low oxygen fugacity in volcanic melts and a limited duration of habitable conditions, making such scenarios quite constrained.

Read the full abstract

All mentions

How Venus Became an Inhospitable Planet

Venus, the most Earth-like planet in size and composition, likely once had liquid water and possibly life. This video explores how Venus transformed from a potentially habitable world to a hostile environment due to…

Ciência Todo Dia · Nov 27, 2023 3,547,466 views

New Insights on Volcanic Activity on Venus Revealed by Magellan Data

This video explores unexpected discoveries from Venus, focusing on surface changes observed on a volcano during the Magellan mission. Notably, a significant 22-square-kilometer volcanic vent exhibited shape changes in…

Anton Petrov · Mar 30, 2023 228,320 views

Sistema Socialista de Futebol

@brfmatos.bsky.social · Bluesky

youtu.be/3ysda_jcpQg?...

Jun 10, 2025 · 1 like · 1 share View post →

Amber Greenn

@_beachmama · X

RT @edwinkite: Venus: always dead?

Jan 18, 2025 · 1 share · 556 followers View post →

The Crypto Keeper

@giftedmuscle · X

@EdKrassen Uh, no. https://t.co/DDTdt7IC2v

Mar 29, 2024 · 128 followers View post →

Eli Rabett

@EthonRaptor · X

@Cocoaisadog @LabourOutOfScot @ScienceBlog3 @GillesnFio @Gladfly1 @priscian @DaleGribble_666 @CymaticWave @EQKimball7 @Athol94519002 @Over400ppm @ILuvCO2 @3GHtweets @AtomsksSanakan @jonsaxon67 @EdwardBernays7 @Billybobtn @willyv96 @Canadian_logic_ @Ancientengineer @GregoryMakles @EdDarrell @1_TMF_ @craigthomler @brandonrgates @Tokyo_Tom @4TimesAYear @CitronCockatoo @MonkeyMyBack @GustavoRejivik @miked194765 @Mark_Fraser_ @NoelTurner194 @JoKiwi55 @climatefrauds @icarus62 @usanorthcoast @drwaheeduddin @FriendsOScience @LindsayyuleS @climatecancel @kmpetersson @dblebuck @Tea4gunsSC @nstokesvic @wattsupwiththat @RichardAMuller @ProfBrianCox @hausfath Would you settle for early Earth like? Your friend the sun and a lot of greenhouse gases cooked the water vapor out of the system https://t.co/rJYAJ4Vty9

Feb 2, 2024 · 2 likes · 2,374 followers View post →

molina molina

@molinam36323338 · X

@cfhinor @DavidUllrich202 @dangerousbeenz You quoted part of what Eric said in 2010, in a dogmatic sense? Why did not you quote Vogue magazine as The Great Truth? Eric published it moinths after your quote: https://t.co/OrjYmU65N0 and this was published in 2023. https://t.co/XCKBBDmPbb https://t.co/Esz0VtZjc6

Dec 28, 2023 · 1 like · 79 followers View post →

indkarinne

@indkarinne.bsky.social · Bluesky

Como VÊNUS virou um INFERNO? youtu.be/3ysda_jcpQg?... via @YouTube

Nov 28, 2023 View post →

Dr. Larry B Keating

@DrLarryBKeating · X