Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
Overall, the discussions reflect skepticism toward the scientific quality and societal implications of gender-affirming treatments, with phrases like 'claims without evidence' and references to normative standards, illustrating a critical stance and deep engagement by participants. The tone varies from questioning to confrontational, emphasizing the importance of scientific validity and societal norms in evaluating the article’s themes.
Most discussions question the effectiveness and scientific basis of gender-affirming treatments, revealing a general skepticism rather than full disagreement or support.
The discussions actively analyze the research findings, critique societal norms, and critique medical practices, indicating moderate to high interest in the subject.
Many comments cite studies, question scientific validity, and discuss broader implications, showing deep engagement with the article and its themes.
These social discussions challenge prevailing narratives and question medical standards, which could influence perspectives on gender-affirming care, thus having notable potential impact.
I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the basis of personal desire and autonomy." https://t.co/YbqFKax4G6
Pitt parents do not believe “Treatments should be provided simply because young people desire them.” This was from the author of the Dutch protocol. https://t.co/6Y3hcJUX4l
@datwokegedram @NUnl Het ontbreekt aan een wetenschappelijke en medische onderbouwing voor het transitioneren van kinderen/jongeren. Onlangs heeft Annelou de Vries dat samen met collega's zelf toegegeven. https://t.co/iw32PDfCH6
@benryanwriter 2) Non other than the Dutch gender ideologue DeVries MD herself (of the Dutch Protocol infamy) recently published a paper declaring the shift to autonomy herself. Thus turning the practice of modern medicine into a vending machine. https://t.co/s6b6NKU7Yq
@Floatinginwaves @jk_rowling @zaqrider https://t.co/YPvFrUchyo
https://t.co/T20ln8klhr
This video discusses the ethical considerations and concerns regarding gender-affirming medical treatments for adolescents, highlighting limited long-term data and societal norms influencing treatment outcomes, based on…
This video discusses theories of gender dysphoria, the impact of gender identity on LGBTQ individuals, and critically examines gender-affirming treatments, focusing on societal norms, treatment goals, and the importance…
This video critically examines the evidence and assumptions behind gender-affirming medical treatment for adolescents, highlighting concerns about long-term outcomes, societal norms, and the criteria used to evaluate…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
@HetIsKerstMan @BevJacksonAuth @_Johan_C_ @mkeulemans Een claim zonder enige onderbouwing. Lees het laatste onderzoeksverslag van Annelous de Vries (weet je überhaupt wie zij is?) en vertel me nog een keer dat de wetenschap bewijst dat transities noodzakelijk zijn. https://t.co/iw32PDgawE
@toad_emeritus @ElPrimero410 @47ShadesOfMaga @pesach_lattin @calleymeans Science vs science. The better science shall win. Truth always wins in the end https://t.co/EzYFN8J14F
@Alice_Weidel WOKEN Irrsinn
@Juliiietha57624 @sghxl @AgustinLaje Son los mismos que realizan estos estudios https://t.co/7MLS3k5hKc Claramente hay varios en contra, este artículo critica que muchos estudios califican como efectivos
@Elsi_funkt @Alice_Weidel @PM_ViktorOrban https://t.co/Q429PyB4v2 Theoretische Linse: Trans-Negativität ... GAMT oft als „Heilung“ dargestellt wird, die darauf abzielt, die Personen an vorherrschende heteronormative Geschlechternormen anzupassen ... https://t.co/ttYTcLvkKZ
@TVLbe https://t.co/Q429PyB4v2 Invoering Dit artikel verschijnt op een kritiek moment in de verlening van genderbevestigende medische behandelingen ... individuen in lijn te brengen met dominante heteronormatieve https://t.co/nwA5NuVcyJ
@jreichelt https://t.co/Q429PyB4v2 Theoretische Linse: Trans-Negativität ... GAMT oft als „Heilung“ dargestellt wird, die darauf abzielt, die Personen an vorherrschende heteronormative Geschlechternormen anzupassen ... https://t.co/ttYTcLvkKZ
@vrtnws https://t.co/mgL6RTlVAo Theoretische lens: trans negativiteit Het heersende verhaal van “geboren worden in het verkeerde lichaam” https://t.co/b7smrMijZS
@Alice_Weidel https://t.co/mgL6RTlVAo Theoretische Linse: Trans-Negativität ... GAMT oft als „Heilung“ dargestellt wird, die darauf abzielt, die Personen an vorherrschende heteronormative Geschlechternormen anzupassen ... https://t.co/Op6eEiUs4Q
@DoorbraakBe https://t.co/mgL6RTlVAo Invoering Dit artikel verschijnt op een kritiek moment in de verlening van genderbevestigende medische behandelingen ... individuen in lijn te brengen met dominante heteronormatieve https://t.co/HCLVSninXk
@busboy4u @Tynach @LunaM656 @EderOneElegy @hausofdecline opinion of one individual. Consider this peer-reviewed piece of research, Oosthoek, E.D., et al. BMC Med Ethics 25, 154 (2024). https://t.co/GTLADFTc5d
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
@Floatinginwaves @jk_rowling @zaqrider https://t.co/YPvFrUchyo
RT @LeorSapir: A new paper argues that “gender-affirming care” for adolescents should not be measured by whether it’s “effective” at reduci…
@ArabaciNejsou @StephanieJaneG6 https://t.co/dWdXjgGjGe https://t.co/gvbCA4YWt3 https://t.co/Gp3VAYexOw
RT @LeorSapir: A new paper argues that “gender-affirming care” for adolescents should not be measured by whether it’s “effective” at reduci…
@benryanwriter 2) Non other than the Dutch gender ideologue DeVries MD herself (of the Dutch Protocol infamy) recently published a paper declaring the shift to autonomy herself. Thus turning the practice of modern medicine into a vending machine. https://t.co/s6b6NKU7Yq
RT @LGBT_Courage: https://t.co/T20ln8klhr
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @LGBT_Courage: https://t.co/T20ln8klhr
https://t.co/T20ln8klhr
RT @LeorSapir: A new paper argues that “gender-affirming care” for adolescents should not be measured by whether it’s “effective” at reduci…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
@marcelbuehrig @fraumelea @Blue_Johnny_ https://t.co/GwETWeKUVj Hier eine Studie die aufzeigt, dass man die Bewertungsmaßstäbe für "Zufriedenheit" geändert hat damit man eine höhere Zufriedenheit vorlegen kann.
RT @MariekeIsBoos: @datwokegedram @NUnl Het ontbreekt aan een wetenschappelijke en medische onderbouwing voor het transitioneren van kinder…
RT @MariekeIsBoos: @datwokegedram @NUnl Het ontbreekt aan een wetenschappelijke en medische onderbouwing voor het transitioneren van kinder…
@datwokegedram @NUnl Het ontbreekt aan een wetenschappelijke en medische onderbouwing voor het transitioneren van kinderen/jongeren. Onlangs heeft Annelou de Vries dat samen met collega's zelf toegegeven. https://t.co/iw32PDfCH6
A group in The Netherlands synthesized evidence on the perceived effectiveness and implicit and explicit normative assumptions surrounding gender-affirming medical treatment (GAMT) for youth. A study (https://t.co/szBZSNAlJu) published in #BMCMedEthics. https://t.co/tVeXbgRvdj
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
@meharmsen Ja ik bedoel dit onderzoek; https://t.co/EiB2tOx6aI Kan inderdaad zo zijn dat ze het deden als voorbereiding op die 2 systematische reviews die jij net deelt!
RT @Focusscience1: (1/3) Door een post van J.K. Rowling hierop gewezen, heb ik geprobeerd onderstaand artikel te lezen, door vijf medewerke…
RT @Focusscience1: (1/3) Door een post van J.K. Rowling hierop gewezen, heb ik geprobeerd onderstaand artikel te lezen, door vijf medewerke…
Clinicians associated with the creation of pediatric gender medicine acknowledge that there may be a lack evidence that these interventions improve patients' well-being and functioning.
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the…
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
@stefanvanlaar @GuduleMartens Lees het zelf maar. Ze schrijven doodleuk dat de uitgangspunten van de medische wetenschap niet geschikt zijn voor wat zij doen in de genderklinieken. Nogmaals: schokkend. https://t.co/iw32PDfCH6
@LaurenLloyd40 @MarkLoosmore @prof_curiosity1 Yes, blinkers. I fully appreciate that the very idea of the possibility I may be right even a little is something you can't entertain. The implications are too big. PS Seen this yet? The source should appeal to you. I doubt the contents will. https://t.co/KRSjudDsFg
These people think that gender-affirming care is black-and-white, with no shades of gray between. I don't understand how anybody can read this paper and think that the problem is binary. https://t.co/Vn10UGpujg https://t.co/XrntfPSrXP
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the…
RT @Focusscience1: (1/3) Door een post van J.K. Rowling hierop gewezen, heb ik geprobeerd onderstaand artikel te lezen, door vijf medewerke…
@leitenroth @hiesigeFlora hier die Quelle: https://t.co/WiTdlORjj3
This is making the rounds and causing a stir: https://t.co/T5Q0ZgIFqK
RT @pittparents: Pitt parents do not believe “Treatments should be provided simply because young people desire them.” This was from the a…
RT @pittparents: Pitt parents do not believe “Treatments should be provided simply because young people desire them.” This was from the a…
Pitt parents do not believe “Treatments should be provided simply because young people desire them.” This was from the author of the Dutch protocol. https://t.co/6Y3hcJUX4l
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the…
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the…
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the…
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the…
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the…
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the…
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the…
RT @JuliaMasonMD1: I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the…
I kid you not, they put the word "effective" in scare quotes, in the title. Apparently it's all about treatment "on the basis of personal desire and autonomy." https://t.co/YbqFKax4G6
Let’s do some research on outcomes … 2024 ‘Gender-affirming medical treatment for adolescents: a critical reflection on “effective” treatment outcomes | BMC Medical Ethics | Full Text https://t.co/7VDFZVGpgN
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
">Desire and happiness are independent agents.< Chu’s perspective contributes an alternative for moving beyond the logic of improvement narrative, and therefore beyond diagnostic prerequisites and “effective” treatment outcomes." Perspective, sic! https://t.co/vwPi18ixKb
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
@Jilliantweeting @RANZCP @Mark_Butler_MP @TimNichollsMP @DavidCrisafulli Theoretical lens: trans negativity The prevailing narrative of being “born in the wrong body”
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @Focusscience1: (1/3) Door een post van J.K. Rowling hierop gewezen, heb ik geprobeerd onderstaand artikel te lezen, door vijf medewerke…
RT @LeorSapir: A new paper argues that “gender-affirming care” for adolescents should not be measured by whether it’s “effective” at reduci…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @LeorSapir: A new paper argues that “gender-affirming care” for adolescents should not be measured by whether it’s “effective” at reduci…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
@jessesingal Have you seen this study (a review I think) by the VU Amsterdam gender team? Apparently trans surgery is legitimate even if its ‘effectiveness’ (their scare quotes) isn’t proven https://t.co/G2HBxOAXhn
RT @jk_rowling: This astounding paper reminds me of Hannah Arendt's The Banality of Evil: 'The net effect of this language system was not t…
DOI: 10.1186/s12910-024-01143-8. Unequal geographies of gender-affirming care: A comparative typology of trans-specific healthcare systems across Europe ...
DOI: 10.1186/s12910-024-01143-8. Unequal geographies of gender-affirming care: A comparative typology of trans-specific healthcare systems across Europe (se ...
com/articles/10.1186/s12910-024-01143-8. bmcmedethics.biomedcentral.com. Gender-affirming medical treatment for adolescents: a. 8 mos. Josh ...
com/articles/10.1186/s12910-024-01143-8. bmcmedethics.biomedcentral.com. Gender-affirming medical treatment for adolescents: a. 9 mos. Josh ...
JM
PT
M
DF
R
LC
RT
BA
S
G
SW
?
DF
M
MM
WD
D
G
MV
C
J
XK
KX
MO
RO
BS
G
DN
HB
M
GK
GL
O
P
KK
Q
숭
SD
E
J
RV
C
C
NF
JC
NN
O
DM
CC
I
BK
PF
RR
JS
DP
DO
HH
CŻ
A
F
AW
MB
M
DR
DS
ZH
T
RS
J
JS
A
M
RK
LW
E
GP
OJ
VG
JR
M
T
K