物理学者マックス・テグマーク氏が発表した論文"Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes"をご存知でしょうか?2000年にPhysi… https://t.co/Rx5hqVYLQF #mond_hayashiyus
Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes.
Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
Mentions per month
May 2019 – Oct 2025Where it's discussed
-
X / Twitter34 posts
-
News15 articles
-
Blogs14 articles
-
Facebook4 posts
-
YouTube2 videos
AI synopsis
What people are saying
A number of discussions express doubt about quantum coherence's role in consciousness, citing authors like Penrose and Tegmark and emphasizing skepticism through phrases like 'no such proof' and 'biologically implausible.' The tone varies from critical to inquisitive, with users referencing scientific literature and debating the implications, highlighting a community engaged but largely doubtful of the article's significance.
Most discussions challenge or question the validity of quantum effects in brain function, reflecting disagreement with the publication's conclusions.
Many posts delve into detailed debates and reference multiple papers, indicating high curiosity and engagement with the topic.
Posts discuss specific scientific arguments and cite sources, showing a moderate level of depth in engagement.
While influential within academic debates, discussions mostly revolve around skepticism, so perceived impact on broader understanding appears limited.
Abstract in brief
- The text argues that the neural processes in the human brain should be viewed as classical systems because the quantum decoherence times are extremely short, making quantum effects irrelevant for brain function.
- The calculated decoherence times (around 10^-13 to 10^-20 seconds) are much shorter than the time scales of neural activity (about 10^-3 to 10^0 seconds), supporting the idea that the brain operates on classical rather than quantum principles.
- This conclusion challenges theories by Penrose and others who suggest that quantum coherence plays a fundamental role in consciousness, proposing instead that classical neural models are sufficient for understanding brain processes.]
Top posts
Most liked on X and Bluesky物理学者マックス・テグマーク氏が発表した論文"Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes"をご存知でしょうか?2000年にPhysical Review誌に出版されたこの論文では,数理物理学者ロジャー・ペンローズと麻酔科医スチュアート... (残り555字) #mond_hayashiyus https://t.co/Rx5hqVYLQF
@neuralkn0t @ataiiam Tegmark - The Importance of Quantum Decoherence in Brain Processes - MIT Kavli Institute https://t.co/klerJ6wTHx What Is It Like to Be a Bat? https://t.co/BaeFcmfDlf IIT - https://t.co/YebvzIIscD Erik Hoel - https://t.co/xCONcogJDv Church-Turing Thesis https://t.co/GF1oyUnEUO
"Roger Penrose'un Kuantum Bilinç Teorisi ispatlandı mı?" https://t.co/TOmkcCbeb9
@fgenovese1987 @Mortebianca000 Allora come fai a trovare un paper che dice cosa NON c'è? Nel caso dei microtuboli stranamente dato lo "splash" si è perfino cercato di fare questo e diversi modelli fra loro non concordi arrivano alla stessa conclusione: https://t.co/wOmsiFDaZ2 https://t.co/WWyg6jwoXv
Citované zdroje
All mentions
Evaluating the Role of Quantum Coherence in Brain Function and Consciousness
The neural processes in the human brain are primarily classical due to extremely short quantum decoherence times, challenging theories that propose quantum coherence is fundamental to consciousness. This supports the…
Quantum Tunneling and Brain Function: Exploring Consciousness and Thought Patterns
Scientists suggest your brain may tap into quantum tunneling, allowing thoughts to emerge before conscious awareness. Research debates whether quantum effects influence consciousness or if classical neural processes…
Roger Penrose'un "Kuantum Bilinç Teorisi" (Orch-OR Hipotezi) İspatlandı mı? https://t.co/2vNUHWZPsz @YouTube aracılığıyla
@StuartHameroff There is no such a thing as quantum-based consciousness not a single proof that QM has anything to say about that. On the contrary, there are very solid arguments from QM against it. Check this paper: https://t.co/4XRB5IIVyk https://t.co/3QpQFE7BCr
Roger Penrose'un "Kuantum Bilinç Teorisi" (Orch-OR Hipotezi) İspatlandı mı? https://t.co/VIvnWYWK5h @YouTube aracılığıyla
RT @ontosqualia: "Roger Penrose'un Kuantum Bilinç Teorisi ispatlandı mı?" https://t.co/TOmkcCbeb9
"Roger Penrose'un Kuantum Bilinç Teorisi ispatlandı mı?" https://t.co/TOmkcCbeb9
https://t.co/pM2O98XjLx
https://t.co/pM2O98XRB5
https://t.co/pM2O98XjLx
https://t.co/pM2O98XRB5
Tegmark, M. (2000). “Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes.” Physical Review E, 61(5), 4194-4206.
The Importance of Quantum Decoherence in Brain Processes by @tegmark https://t.co/gaajsZNazG
物理学者マックス・テグマーク氏が発表した論文"Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes"をご存知でしょうか?2000年にPhysical Review誌に出版されたこの論文では,数理物理学者ロジャー・ペンローズと麻酔科医スチュアート... (残り555字) #mond_hayashiyus https://t.co/Rx5hqVYLQF
RT @hayashiyus: 物理学者マックス・テグマーク氏が発表した論文"Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes"をご存知でしょうか?2000年にPhysi… https://t.co/Rx5hqVYLQF…
RT @hayashiyus: 物理学者マックス・テグマーク氏が発表した論文"Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes"をご存知でしょうか?2000年にPhysi… https://t.co/Rx5hqVYLQF…
RT @hayashiyus: 物理学者マックス・テグマーク氏が発表した論文"Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes"をご存知でしょうか?2000年にPhysi… https://t.co/Rx5hqVYLQF…
物理学者マックス・テグマーク氏が発表した論文"Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes"をご存知でしょうか?2000年にPhysi… https://t.co/Rx5hqVYLQF #mond_hayashiyus
@neuralkn0t @ataiiam Tegmark - The Importance of Quantum Decoherence in Brain Processes - MIT Kavli Institute https://t.co/klerJ6wTHx What Is It Like to Be a Bat? https://t.co/BaeFcmfDlf IIT - https://t.co/YebvzIIscD Erik Hoel - https://t.co/xCONcogJDv Church-Turing Thesis https://t.co/GF1oyUnEUO
RT @Captain_Outis: @wintertao The little footnote cites a 1999 paper by Max titled “The importance of quantum decoherence in brain processe…
RT @physics_brain: The Importance of Quantum Decoherence in Brain Processes https://t.co/lH8aEl3U4J
RT @K00TSUKA: 「The importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes」 It has been debated whether the brain can maintain quantum cohere…
RT @mtbabels: [quant-ph/9907009] The importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes https://t.co/asPeviPMM1
「The importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes」 It has been debated whether the brain can maintain quantum coherence. Stapp argued that the interaction with the environment is negligibly small. Zeh, Zurek, Scott, Hawking, Hepp predicted that environment-induced
「The importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes」 脳の神経回路網が量子的な一貫性を保てるかどうかが議論されてきた. Stappは環境との相互作用は無視できるほど小さいと主張し, Zeh, Zurek, Scott, Hawking,
[quant-ph/9907009] The importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes https://t.co/asPeviPMM1
Citované zdroje
Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes (2000), https://t.co/N3O9W0icpQ #QC #1d1pm
@VeraSeraph AFAIK the only serious scientific attempt to argue that is Orch-OR, which argues that consciousness/free-will manifests through quantum-random events, however it's considered biologically implausible that quantum-random events could really affect brains https://t.co/X1ONFvMZos
The Importance of Quantum Decoherence in Brain Processes https://t.co/lH8aEl3U4J
@VickerySec The Importance of Quantum Decoherence in Brain Processes https://t.co/FOWfU4ngnO › by M Tegmark · 2000 ·The axon quickly recovers. After less than ∼ 1 ms,the sodium channels close regardless of voltage, / Oh FINE! They can run it through me-but they don't let me in to view this
Dois artigos interessantes de @tegmark sobre a consciência. Consciousness as a State of Matter Max Tegmark https://t.co/J5oO1xtfbD The importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes Max Tegmark https://t.co/7xLzzlQaVG
@wintertao The little footnote cites a 1999 paper by Max titled “The importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes” https://t.co/SYWXm72G14
@fgenovese1987 @Mortebianca000 Allora come fai a trovare un paper che dice cosa NON c'è? Nel caso dei microtuboli stranamente dato lo "splash" si è perfino cercato di fare questo e diversi modelli fra loro non concordi arrivano alla stessa conclusione: https://t.co/wOmsiFDaZ2 https://t.co/WWyg6jwoXv
Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes (2000), https://t.co/N3O9W003bI #QC #1d1pm
Importance of quantum decoherence in brain processes (2000), https://t.co/N3O9W003bI #QC #1d1pm
Y林
PP
AI
ZV
RS
ᴅ
まA
KN
中Y
HF
JB
K大
MB
SC
FS
ES
DS
AF
O