Overall, the group enthusiastically discusses the underestimation of protein needs, referencing new research methods, outdated sources, and the necessity to revise dietary guidelines. The tone ranges from critical to inquisitive, with some users backing their points with scientific evidence, which reinforces a collective push for change.
AgreementModerate agreement
Most discussions agree that the current protein recommendations are outdated and underestimate actual needs, as evidenced by references to new research and criticism of traditional methods.
InterestHigh interest
Many posts show high curiosity and concern, especially with calls for updating dietary guidelines and citing recent advances in research.
EngagementModerate engagement
Users actively critique outdated sources, share additional evidence, and engage in debates about methodology, indicating moderate but meaningful participation.
ImpactModerate impact
The discussions could influence opinions and practices related to nutrition guidelines, though they mainly serve as academic debates at this stage.
Abstract in brief
Recent research indicates that protein needs for adults may be considerably higher than previously estimated, challenging the current dietary guidelines.
The traditional method of determining protein requirements through nitrogen balance studies has been re-evaluated using more accurate two-phase linear regression and a new technique called indicator amino acid oxidation, both of which suggest higher protein needs.
As a result, the study recommends urgently updating dietary protein intake guidelines for adults to better reflect these new findings.]
@RedPillVegan @kevinnbass Here's a re-analysis of the Rand N balance studies (that form the basis of the RDA) in this paper https://t.co/VHaAyPJLMF
Jun 16, 2021 · 6 likes · 56,102 followersView post →
CH
con H de heterótrofo
@NutriRebel · X
Contestación top del vegano cuando le muestro que el balance de nitrógeno está mal analizado en los estudios sobre proteína de la EFSA como explican aquí. Con radicales no se puede.
Evidence that protein requirements have been significantly underestimated
https://t.co/YNyROx5CjY https://t.co/nBVIzpRzS4
@SavyasanchiSha5 @gowri_rock @ProgramErgoSum We need more than rda. Not sure if you are even informed or not https://t.co/N6X7jqhDmx
Feb 6, 2025 · 2 likes · 99,683 followersView post →
CH
con H de heterótrofo
@NutriRebel · X
@ancelkeyslegacy @raulmartin_n De la EFSA del 2012? Sí. Pero esa recomendación está desactualizada y tiene muchos peros. Por ejemplo, los estudios que utiliza para el balance de nitrógeno están mal analizados.
Evidence that protein requirements have been significantly underestimated
https://t.co/YNyROx5CjY
CSN #13 : L'apport journalier en protéines (animales/végétales) doit être compris entre 0.91g/kg et 0.99g/kg de poids de corps. Pour un homme adulte très sportif ce chiffre peut monter jusqu'à 1.8-2g/kg. Trop n'atteignent pas la moitié de ces valeurs...
https://t.co/wVXyW4auzK
Recent research indicates that protein needs for adults may be considerably higher than previously estimated. The study recommends urgently updating dietary protein guidelines to reflect these new findings, using more…
This episode discusses two key questions that simplify meals and enhance health, emphasizing the importance of protein and produce based on extensive research, including recent findings suggesting higher protein needs…
While pushing the old | outdated RDA protein recommendation @nntaleb still won’t acknowledge nitrogen balance is an outdated way to calculate protein needs.
Evidence that protein requirements have been significantly underestimated - PubMed https://t.co/RPaWgdYFHm
Indicator https://t.co/S3OVqVjZSm
@NanciGuestRDPhD @JackNorrisRD @ScepticalDoctor @Alecsplaining @TheVeganRD @JohnG_UK @JackNorrisRD.
The IoM document you use is from 2005, since then there have been many advances in research on the subject. E.g., the well-founded criticism made in 2010 of the RDA values, which although you name it later, it seems that you forget. 1/n
https://t.co/YNyROx5CjY
CSN #13 : L'apport journalier en protéines (animales/végétales) doit être compris entre 0.91g/kg et 0.99g/kg de poids de corps. Pour un homme adulte très sportif ce chiffre peut monter jusqu'à 1.8-2g/kg. Trop n'atteignent pas la moitié de ces valeurs...
https://t.co/wVXyW4auzK
Contestación top del vegano cuando le muestro que el balance de nitrógeno está mal analizado en los estudios sobre proteína de la EFSA como explican aquí. Con radicales no se puede.
Evidence that protein requirements have been significantly underestimated
https://t.co/YNyROx5CjY https://t.co/nBVIzpRzS4
@ancelkeyslegacy @raulmartin_n De la EFSA del 2012? Sí. Pero esa recomendación está desactualizada y tiene muchos peros. Por ejemplo, los estudios que utiliza para el balance de nitrógeno están mal analizados.
Evidence that protein requirements have been significantly underestimated
https://t.co/YNyROx5CjY
Dietary Supplements, B. Brian Haycock | PDF | Tablet (Pharmacy ...
News
doi:10.1097/mco.0b013e328332f9b7. Evans, G.H., S.M. Shirreffs, and R.J. Maughan. 2009. Postexercise Rehydration in Man: The Effects of Osmolality and ...