プラセボ舐めてませんか? IBS(過敏性腸症候群)の人に 「これは偽薬(砂糖の錠剤)ですが、効果があると示されています」と伝えて飲んでもらったら…… 本当に症状が改善してます。 "思い込み"の力、侮れません。 僕も正露丸飲む時は正露丸を信じて飲んでます。 https://t.co/5fr1HUH5B3 https://t.co/sMz4QzF8aw
Placebos without deception: a randomized controlled trial in irritable bowel syndrome.
Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
Mentions per month
Apr 2019 – Sep 2025Where it's discussed
-
News104 articles
-
Blogs71 articles
-
X / Twitter69 posts
-
Facebook36 posts
-
Reddit6 posts
-
YouTube4 videos
-
Bluesky1 posts
AI synopsis
What people are saying
The discussions highlight varied perceptions of the study, with individuals citing evidence and sharing personal insights, such as 'placebos can work even when patients know they are receiving one,' showing a blend of curiosity and skepticism. Terms like 'ethical' and 'impactful' reflect a serious tone suggesting that the findings could shift medical practices, as seen in phrases like 'game changer' and questions about the ethics of using placebos transparently.
Many participants express agreement with the conclusions of the study, emphasizing the positive effects of placebos without deception.
There is strong interest as users delve into discussions about how this research may reshape treatment options.
The depth of engagement varies, with some posts dissecting the research methodology and its implications, while others are more casual in nature.
Participants recognize the potential for significant impact on medical practice, indicating that this research could alter how placebos are used in treatment.
Abstract in brief
- The study explored the effectiveness of open-label placebo treatments (non-deceptive) versus no treatment in patients with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS).
- Results showed that participants receiving open-label placebo experienced significantly greater improvements in IBS symptoms and overall quality of life compared to the no-treatment group.
- The findings suggest that non-deceptive placebo treatments can be beneficial for IBS management, indicating a need for further research in this area and potentially other health conditions.
Top posts
Most liked on X and BlueskyThank you for reading! Sources: 1. https://t.co/If2H0OLNnO 2. https://t.co/SUJoqNwoe8 3. https://t.co/HJPe504QBp 4. https://t.co/4vVeTcj0dB 5. https://t.co/w9g29r4Vhr
@Kachelmann @Dinsteru @skt_johann @Susannchen01 Jupp. Placeboeffekte können auch auftreten, wenn man aufgeklärt wurde: https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l https://t.co/WGdGhGl2NT
@Mami_mit_Herz @FrankBettina Auch offene Placebogabe kann zu Effekten führen. Eine verdeckte Gabe - und damit das Belügen des Patienten - wäre unethisch. https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l
@marc_cram @bmj_latest https://t.co/GN9pgNLNCL
@toshikimh @Tipuncho @_batou_ Non même pas. Un placebo fonctionne aussi quand on dit au patient que d'en est un. https://t.co/zvKXNm4mvT
All mentions
Understanding Placebos: The Power of the Mind in Healing
Ralph Caspers shares his experiences with the placebo effect, demonstrating how even non-active treatments can lead to significant improvements in condition. A study shows that open-label placebos can enhance patients'…
The PLACEBO EFFECT: Shockingly Effective!
The Role of Social Support and Hugs in Health and Immunity
This video explores how perceived social support and the act of hugging can protect against stress-induced vulnerability to infections. Through a study involving 404 adults, the findings demonstrate that social…
The Truth About Supplements: Creatine, Collagen, and Marketing Misconceptions
Explore the necessity of creatine, collagen, vitamin C, and omega-3s in our diets. Discover why many people opt for supplements despite a healthy diet, and differentiate between genuine health benefits and marketing…
Ep 1 – The Fire & the Field Desire and the Principle of Mentalism
RT @tarou_ymd_: プラセボ舐めてませんか? IBS(過敏性腸症候群)の人に 「これは偽薬(砂糖の錠剤)ですが、効果があると示されています」と伝えて飲んでもらったら…… 本当に症状が改善してます。 "思い込み"の力、侮れません。 僕も正露丸飲む時は正露丸を信じ…
RT @tarou_ymd_: プラセボ舐めてませんか? IBS(過敏性腸症候群)の人に 「これは偽薬(砂糖の錠剤)ですが、効果があると示されています」と伝えて飲んでもらったら…… 本当に症状が改善してます。 "思い込み"の力、侮れません。 僕も正露丸飲む時は正露丸を信じ…
プラセボ舐めてませんか? IBS(過敏性腸症候群)の人に 「これは偽薬(砂糖の錠剤)ですが、効果があると示されています」と伝えて飲んでもらったら…… 本当に症状が改善してます。 "思い込み"の力、侮れません。 僕も正露丸飲む時は正露丸を信じて飲んでます。 https://t.co/5fr1HUH5B3 https://t.co/sMz4QzF8aw
RT @DrSamuelBHume: Thank you for reading! Sources: 1. https://t.co/If2H0OLNnO 2. https://t.co/SUJoqNwoe8 3. https://t.co/HJPe504QBp 4.…
Thank you for reading! Sources: 1. https://t.co/If2H0OLNnO 2. https://t.co/SUJoqNwoe8 3. https://t.co/HJPe504QBp 4. https://t.co/4vVeTcj0dB 5. https://t.co/w9g29r4Vhr
@kereonnec @Elexod @KasprzykRemi @ThoGui Oui ça peut fonctionner même si les patients sont au courant https://t.co/cImVUTyIxJ
@lours @Dermatopoullos @KasprzykRemi @ThoGui En fait un placebo peut fonctionner même si les patients sont au courant
El placebo tiene efecto aunque la persona sepa que lo que se le está administrando es un placebo. El efecto placebo no es un auto-engaño si no una respuesta automática del organismo. https://t.co/7OD276SQMR
@MauricioAP18 @Olavokkor @MampperSP também temos o estudo: Kaptchuk, T. J., et al. (2010). "Placebos without deception: A randomized controlled trial in irritable bowel syndrome." PLoS ONE, 5(12), e15591. Em pessoas com síndrome do intestino irritado.
“harnessing placebo effects without deception is possible in the context of […]
@module5 @miamologue j'ai pas ca. Je te propose de leur parler de cet article: https://t.co/t25Z2GFiAn ça marche bien pour comprendre les facteurs influencant
Kaptchuk TJ, Friedlander E, Kelley JM, Sanchez MN, Kokkotou E, Singer JP, et al. Placebos without deception: a randomized controlled trial in irritable bowel syndrome. PLoS ONE. 2010;5(12):e15591. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0015591. [PMC free article] [PubMed] [CrossRef] [Google Scholar]
@Nos_Ket @Herr_Elle @auressaion @vinceflibustier Ah ? Quid des études suivantes : - https://t.co/ZvH7Dw7nZK - https://t.co/Z6f3aIDWUY
@Glace15840573 @nim_chimpsky_ Open label placebos have been found to have effects on what are basically affect measures: https://t.co/jzp5khSKJl
https://t.co/HXBlr9R6th
@seriengruender "Placebos administered without deception may be an effective treatment for IBS." Es ist ja nicht gesagt, dass Täuschung Voraussetzung ist, dass Placebo wirkt. https://t.co/mU0YjTcUI7
@jittabaumann @Daggi17 @stagerbn @globuleaks Bei dem Wissenstand darüber erklären Sie Mal besser nichts, ja? https://t.co/aq5KA1Q9yT https://t.co/GOp3VT3Yhu https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/XpC1ajChgJ https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l https://t.co/SJ6so67SOp https://t.co/rRW2k11YRB https://t.co/C6FMzQmBVF
@erinomarakunz One of my favs. Placebos without Deception: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Irritable Bowel Syndrome https://t.co/6T4JpryTd4
@Die_Apitz @erik_fluegge Ja, das suggeriert zumindest einige Evidenz. Wäre auf jeden Fall ethisch vertretbarer. https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l https://t.co/pw3XVSBoH9.
@SwimPommes @ralfschmidt158 @ganCheangal @Jasmin97561525 @Karl_Lauterbach https://t.co/pw3XVSBoH9. https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l
@666WAYNTRAIN999 @DerWebschreiner Unter anderem: https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l https://t.co/pw3XVSBoH9
@tief_kultur @franke_karsten @Lam3th @tomdabassman @Peter55263714 Hier ein paar, die Evidenzlage ist dazu aber noch relativ dünn, da auch relativ neu. https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l https://t.co/aq5KA1Q9yT
@freeheinz @xxSkyeHighxx @FrauHaensch @NatalieGrams @katjaberlin Nein, Placeboeffekte können auch dann auftreten, wenn man bescheid weiß.
@sejehomi Tipo aqui https://t.co/qUxztLl0Bg
@DavidPerrott_ Not sure about the best, but Kaptchuk has extensively research the placebo effect. A good place to start is: Kaptchuk et al (2010). Placebos without Deception: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Irritable Bowel Syndrome https://t.co/ux3gocvmBj
@BlaueSeelentore @schnudelmann @tlnue Das stimmt so nicht. Placeboeffekte können auch dann auftreten, wenn der Patient bescheid weiß:https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l Interessant dazu auch: https://t.co/CWz1To16NO
@Norabelle124 @KopfYvonne 1/2 Es gibt einige Evidenz, die zeigt, dass Placeboeffekte auch dann noch auftreten können, wenn man aufgeklärt darüber ist:https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l
@MirusOrbis @Judybread @BlloollB https://t.co/pQSQWs1Wr3 La publication source est: https://t.co/S5RXj42zR6 C'est une parmi plusieurs, juste la premiere que j'ai retrouvé.
@SvenKoe @kaschewi Placeboeffekte können auch dann funktionieren, wenn man darüber bescheid weiß:https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l
@28Jahre2020 @NicErzer @instanthero Das ist falsch. Placeboeffekte können auch dann auftreten, wenn man bescheid weiß:https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l Und Homöopathie wirkt nicht über Kontexteffekte hinaus. Das ist Fakt.
@munichlion @LissysFrauchen @Naturschuetzen @ApothekerDer @wolke_sieben Das ist nicht richtig. Placeboeffekte können auch auftreten, wenn ethisch gehandelt und aufgeklärt wird: https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ
@awoodall19 @Colettew1979 @welshgaryevans Completely agree with those points but you’re not hoodwinking if you tell them that there’s no evidence that it works. Placebos without deception still have clinical effect https://t.co/GRmZK09UFD
@Kachelmann @Dinsteru @skt_johann @Susannchen01 Jupp. Placeboeffekte können auch auftreten, wenn man aufgeklärt wurde: https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l https://t.co/WGdGhGl2NT
@CaliperKitten This paper was a follow up to earlier research which had similar findings. https://t.co/dje8MoNb3N
@lapinougris @NicolasVdrines1 @LMucchielli @lemondefr @decodeurs Le niveau de bruit de l'effet placebo est parfaitement mesurable. Un pharmacien m'avait sorti cette étude "pas de traitement" contre "placebo" qui m'avait bien surpris. Ce n'est pas si énorme mais bien mesurable. https://t.co/PHJWoRBC33
@toshikimh @Tipuncho @_batou_ Non même pas. Un placebo fonctionne aussi quand on dit au patient que d'en est un. https://t.co/zvKXNm4mvT
RT @GuevarraDarwin: @sarahpressman In some cases, placebos can work without deception. https://t.co/6T4Jprylnw
@sarahpressman In some cases, placebos can work without deception. https://t.co/6T4Jprylnw
@marc_cram @bmj_latest https://t.co/GN9pgNLNCL
@Mami_mit_Herz @FrankBettina Auch offene Placebogabe kann zu Effekten führen. Eine verdeckte Gabe - und damit das Belügen des Patienten - wäre unethisch. https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l
@chriss3138 @homeopathy_inh https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l Placeboeffekte sind aber trotzdem keine Rechtfertigung für Homöopathie. Die Behandlung müsste dann auch wirklich offen, ohne Dogmen etc. erfolgen. Und dafür gibt's auch P-Tabletten.
üstelik, plasebo etkisi için gizlenmesine de gerek yok. açık açık plasebo olduğu söylenen ilaçlar da ibs'in (rahatsız bağırsak sendromu) tedavisinde etkili bulunmuş. https://t.co/I6kbo1oksV
@Herming1Stephan @DailyKaffee @AndreasMaierHom Falsch. Sie kennen sich Mal so gar nicht aus, ne? Auch offene Placebogabe „wirkt”... Wäre auch als einziges ethisch vertretbar.
@sandygautam @sandyosullivan We didnt do it here. But most non-deceptive placebo studies are set up like this. Check out Kaptchuk et al. 2010. https://t.co/jYl9VZFJ4M
@Eduardo61962868 @Alma75614899 Ja, gibt es. Gucken Sie Mal hier: https://t.co/bIYL8jiUZg https://t.co/DUwocxQlmC https://t.co/IZ5qayyjTT https://t.co/4enJxVP6TD
@fractality @tailor281 @drluebbers Das geht tatsächlich: https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/2LmxTg7Dwu
@luise_michaelis @CS070798 @HNR_shook0 @slidecurry @fabiandoehla Wieso denn nicht? Placeboantworten hängen nicht unbedingt vom Glauben daran ab. Studien zeigen, dass es auch ohne Lügen geht: https://t.co/IZ5qaygJ2l https://t.co/DUwocy7WLc https://t.co/bIYL8jAwnQ https://t.co/CWz1To16NO
RT @GuevarraDarwin: Here's a seminal paper on placebos without deception by Kaptchuk and colleagues (2010) from @Harvard_PiPS. First RCT co…
Here's a seminal paper on placebos without deception by Kaptchuk and colleagues (2010) from @Harvard_PiPS. First RCT comparing a control group with placebos without deception in irritable bowel syndrome. Must read. #PLOSONE https://t.co/qZLC6N7sp0
@Retlouping If placebo is given to a patient, and it's said it's (ineffective) a placebo- then it becomes a nocebo& nocebo effect? There's some studies that would not agree: https://t.co/2K9zOVd7IB BUT: https://t.co/eXLbGHpYom 1/2
@CthulhuSudaca @fatilatti Yo hablaba más bien de esto https://t.co/VKf324P1Fw
Crazy fact of the day: Placebo works even if the patient know he is getting placebo https://t.co/TsAc2zyBNP
Placebos without Deception: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Irritable Bowel Syndrome https://t.co/94BGmTuN4B
RT @john_damianos: @TuesdayNightIBS Additionally, #IBS has ~40% response to placebo, even when patients know they are getting placebo -http…
@TuesdayNightIBS Additionally, #IBS has ~40% response to placebo, even when patients know they are getting placebo -https://t.co/6UgYqY54yl -https://t.co/6pCNwvWHX0 This is another reason to start slowly and not overload with interventions. #TuesdayNightIBS
@Mariableuee Ce n'est pas mon affirmation, c'est celle de chercheurs : Kaptchuk TJ, Friedlander E, Kelley JM. et al., « Placebos without Deception: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Irritable Bowel Syndrome », PLoS ONE, vol. 5, n°12, 2010, e15591. Je leur transmets votre tweet.
@Mariableuee Source : Kaptchuk TJ, Friedlander E, Kelley JM. et al., « Placebos without Deception: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Irritable Bowel Syndrome », PLoS ONE, vol. 5, no 12, 2010, e15591
@AllenFrancesMD Have you heard of the research finding that placebos can still work even when patients know they’re on placebo? https://t.co/yatqslMQjK
#Placebos without Deception: A Randomized Controlled Trial in Irritable Bowel Syndrome. #meaning #response https://t.co/DAPKIcdHqI
@Grovannii @LeBrainiac @TroncheBiais Vous faites l’hypothèse que l’effet #placebo requiert une tromperie pour être efficace mais non : ça fonctionne aussi en expliquant que le médicament n’est que du sucre mais qu’il aide à activer un mécanisme #psychosomatique. https://t.co/IYEKPWsOmx
@drmiguelmarcos @JGANTL Es cierto, es paradójico. Hay estudios que dicen que incluso si sabes que es placebo muchas veces funciona https://t.co/2MXnkApuXW Te dejo también un artículo interesante, con una visión diferente, del gran @FITrebelde https://t.co/fCOFg2V59S
RT @podoron: その「偽の薬・治療と患者があらかじめ知っていても効果が出る」ことを明らかにした2010年の有名な論文 https://t.co/p4HjUZOMVU 「偽薬でした。何の効果もありません」と明かした後も効果が持続した研究 https://t.co/m4…
RT @podoron: その「偽の薬・治療と患者があらかじめ知っていても効果が出る」ことを明らかにした2010年の有名な論文 https://t.co/p4HjUZOMVU 「偽薬でした。何の効果もありません」と明かした後も効果が持続した研究 https://t.co/m4…
RT @podoron: その「偽の薬・治療と患者があらかじめ知っていても効果が出る」ことを明らかにした2010年の有名な論文 https://t.co/p4HjUZOMVU 「偽薬でした。何の効果もありません」と明かした後も効果が持続した研究 https://t.co/m4…
RT @podoron: その「偽の薬・治療と患者があらかじめ知っていても効果が出る」ことを明らかにした2010年の有名な論文 https://t.co/p4HjUZOMVU 「偽薬でした。何の効果もありません」と明かした後も効果が持続した研究 https://t.co/m4…
RT @podoron: その「偽の薬・治療と患者があらかじめ知っていても効果が出る」ことを明らかにした2010年の有名な論文 https://t.co/p4HjUZOMVU 「偽薬でした。何の効果もありません」と明かした後も効果が持続した研究 https://t.co/m4…
RT @podoron: その「偽の薬・治療と患者があらかじめ知っていても効果が出る」ことを明らかにした2010年の有名な論文 https://t.co/p4HjUZOMVU 「偽薬でした。何の効果もありません」と明かした後も効果が持続した研究 https://t.co/m4…
RT @CecileDuflot: @corsedurable @LaurentLantieri Ah non :) . La littérature médicale - la même et aussi sérieuse et évaluée qui mesure l’ab…
@corsedurable @LaurentLantieri Ah non :) . La littérature médicale - la même et aussi sérieuse et évaluée qui mesure l’absence d’effet de l’homéopathie abonde sur les effets cliniques mesurables des placebo :) y compris lorsque le patient sait que c’en est un. https://t.co/hDJeU1aCeb
@Conactico @Random_Dragon @silmarway @HelmuthMedina @xavigranda @Seheiha @FDaviddc @JaimeGoig @lagamez @AMUHMadrid @apetp_ @JAA00197397 @Hondoncity @PomesTraigo @LuxAeternaSB @Solof1sincirco @Yeimschateau @globnexus @Black_29 @VaryIngweion @FerFrias @AdelinaG20 @EMalvarrosa @Oscar_Tagrend @jvicenteprieto @FranRuiz10 @FEMHomeopatas @SHMatritense @RaquelBlascoR @SEMH_99 @AMHB2 @OMC_Espana @SaludsinBulos @AieSalud @ElenaC_S @escepticos @ICOMVALLADOLID @cescept @jmgomezsoriano Placebos sin engaño: un ensayo controlado aleatorio en el síndrome del intestino irritable, PLOSOne https://t.co/vthUc0K63f La prescripción de" tratamientos placebo ": resultados https://t.co/Crc2b63wBl comunicación y sistema