Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
The overall tone reflects skepticism and curiosity, with users quoting the original study, questioning its methodology, and recalling its historical controversy, especially emphasizing phrases like 'físicamente 100% descabida' and references to its publication in a prestigious journal, which underline the ongoing debate about its validity and impact.
Most discussions question the validity of the findings and express skepticism about the water memory concept, indicating mild disagreement.
Users show curiosity and interest, referencing the controversial nature of the research and its implications.
Several participants actively debate and reference specific experiments, critiques, and historical contexts, demonstrating moderate engagement.
The discussions highlight the paper's influence on debates about scientific credibility and the water memory hypothesis, implying moderate impact.
@JeanBacino @StopPseudo @MedicAcupuntura @TaitaroBnS @mrosastw @pelodytes @VaryIngweion Sí, el infame artículo de Benaviste, publicado en nature, donde "demuestra" el mecanismo de la homeopatía: https://t.co/uG4c0E4ujP Me sorprende que no lo conozca, este artículo ha sido bastante famoso.
2/ Benveniste’s team reported that human basophils degranulated (released histamine) in response to anti-IgE antibodies that had been serially diluted beyond Avogadro’s limit—meaning no molecules were likely left. Nature (1988): https://t.co/dddDES9qmR
Thread mémoire de l'eau : 1. En 1988, Jacques Benveniste publie dans Nature : "Human basophil degranulation triggered by very dilute antiserum against IgE". Il y affirme que des solutions d'IG, diluées au-delà du nbre d'Avogadro, provoquent une réaction des basophiles humains. https://t.co/rwTsl3bCRh
@jm4change @_Sheethal_ That's not true. There *has* been scientific research on the topic. Most of it either later turns out to be low quality, e.g. [1], or find only a tiny effect, maybe just placebo; see e.g. [2]. After a while one learns. [1] https://t.co/WKh7Iddr9B [2] https://t.co/muOvBIXVGA
@jlindcary @StephenABoydPh1 @strangetruther @CapRadioNews Don't pooh-pooh water,
@sadhak_1111 @spandan108 @LuitelBibhu Human Basophil Degranulation Triggered By Very Dilute Antiserum Against IgE. The first paper ever in which it was proposed that water had memory, authored by Benveniste et al. It was published in Nature. https://t.co/FCuvz0t7VX (Use scihub if u wanna read it.)
Current understanding shows the heart is more than a pumping organ; it has an intrinsic nervous system with over 40,000 neurons, functioning as a quantum and electromagnetic device capable of anticipating events before…
Modern neurocardiology reveals that the heart is more than a pump; it contains a complex neural network with over 40,000 neurons. This system enables the heart to anticipate events up to 45 seconds before the brain…
RT @IntegralAnswers: 2/ Benveniste’s team reported that human basophils degranulated (released histamine) in response to anti-IgE antibodie…
RT @IntegralAnswers: 2/ Benveniste’s team reported that human basophils degranulated (released histamine) in response to anti-IgE antibodie…
2/ Benveniste’s team reported that human basophils degranulated (released histamine) in response to anti-IgE antibodies that had been serially diluted beyond Avogadro’s limit—meaning no molecules were likely left. Nature (1988): https://t.co/dddDES9qmR
Thread mémoire de l'eau : 1. En 1988, Jacques Benveniste publie dans Nature : "Human basophil degranulation triggered by very dilute antiserum against IgE". Il y affirme que des solutions d'IG, diluées au-delà du nbre d'Avogadro, provoquent une réaction des basophiles humains. https://t.co/rwTsl3bCRh
Les résultats de cette étude invraisemblable ont été publiés dans la prestigieuse revue Nature. https://t.co/fAfcTPNzWn 7/
@jlindcary @StephenABoydPh1 @strangetruther @CapRadioNews Don't pooh-pooh water,
@JeanBacino @StopPseudo @MedicAcupuntura @TaitaroBnS @mrosastw @pelodytes @VaryIngweion Sí, el infame artículo de Benaviste, publicado en nature, donde "demuestra" el mecanismo de la homeopatía: https://t.co/uG4c0E4ujP Me sorprende que no lo conozca, este artículo ha sido bastante famoso.
@Sailendra01 Human Basophil Degranulation Triggered By Very Dilute Antiserum Against IgE. The first paper ever in which it was proposed that water had memory, authored by Benveniste et al. It was published in Nature. https://t.co/FCuvz0t7VX (Use scihub if u wanna read it.)
@sadhak_1111 @spandan108 @LuitelBibhu Human Basophil Degranulation Triggered By Very Dilute Antiserum Against IgE. The first paper ever in which it was proposed that water had memory, authored by Benveniste et al. It was published in Nature. https://t.co/FCuvz0t7VX (Use scihub if u wanna read it.)
@jm4change @_Sheethal_ That's not true. There *has* been scientific research on the topic. Most of it either later turns out to be low quality, e.g. [1], or find only a tiny effect, maybe just placebo; see e.g. [2]. After a while one learns. [1] https://t.co/WKh7Iddr9B [2] https://t.co/muOvBIXVGA
@leandrotessler Sou mais cético com tais periódicos, Leandro! Na era Maddox a Nature publicou o clássico artigo de Jacques Benveniste. Mas a hipótese homeopática é fisicamente 100% descabida: por que então publicaram sem antes replicar? https://t.co/BsJVxrbtWu https://t.co/mjHr43cnx8
@cheprofessor @MLevitt_NP2013 Nature also published a BS paper on homeopathy and "water memory" which was never retracted. Not likely they will retract this one unless there is fraud. But they every right (and perhaps obligation) to publish critiques of the paper. https://t.co/nR6OXa3WYm
@nlopeztrujillo Solo recordarte que Nature publicó hace años este articulo que "demostraba" la memoria del agua, el supuesto fundamento de la homeopatía. https://t.co/egf42NjDFz
@Aentwan @TroncheBiais D'ailleurs, tellement cachée qu'elle est publiquement accessible => https://t.co/JBdek4fYnS
A
I
NG
MW
CA
BH
MI
BN
DC
N
RD
GS
MP