Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
The discussions reveal enthusiasm for the groundbreaking nature of the research, exemplified by posts highlighting evidence of cultivation 23,000 years ago and stating that this challenges the orthodox timeline of 12,000 years. The tone alternates between curiosity and skepticism, with mentions of specific archaeological sites like Ohalo II and references to technological artifacts, which demonstrate active engagement and recognition of the potential impact on understanding human history.
Most discussions acknowledge the findings of early evidence of cultivation, challenging the traditional timeline of agriculture's origins.
The engagement with the topic is high, with many posts referencing the research and expressing curiosity, as seen in questions and comments about the age of farming.
Posts include observations about archaeological discoveries, technological details like grinding stones and sickles, and debates about the implications, showing active engagement.
While some recognize the significance of the findings in rewriting agricultural history, the overall perceived influence on broader understanding remains moderate.
3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeologically your belief is wrong about first time agriculture. Now let us see what experts speak about Holocene. https://t.co/NRiHg1J2aK https://t.co/01MZVBf7OQ
Agriculture is likely much older than usually assumed! https://t.co/6pS9jK6U4Y
todas las clases de antropo alimentaria diciendo que la agricultura comienza hace 12.000 años +/- y ahora encuentro este paper que en el sitio OhaloII de Israel hay evidencias de unas minihuertas de hace 23.000 años +/-!!!!! https://t.co/qTuHTivLCW
@SIRISYSPrime @nix_bit @michellmybelle @DamienWelsh4 @AnomalousChurch @OjiisanNakamot @Testmest16 @aiambassador1 IF further chronological evidence pins more high techs to pleistocene AND we assume technologies weren't gifted to humanity from outside our system THEN agriculture and tech advancements were likely achieved many years prior to earliest evidence? https://t.co/zxmAvCVvnl https://t.co/QpFTv973QQ
@drjohnnyjohnson Before neolithic farming (≈ 25,000 yrs ago) https://t.co/cYqCAMeVRC, hunter-gatherers had no dental decay. "Mother nature" protected all humans for millions of yrs from #fluoride poisoning through dilution, excretion & skeletal sequestering. Evolution = #FluorideProtection.
What Did We Evolve To Eat? https://t.co/E84NsMELqM via @YouTube
This documentary explores the origins and evolution of human diet, covering key dietary changes from early humans to modern times, and examining the role of meat consumption and other foods in human history.
Discover the 23,000-year-old site of Ohalo II, where early humans engaged in precursor forms of agriculture by selectively harvesting and influencing plant growth, laying the foundation for modern farming and weed…
23 min in - I think the eye change/evolution could have been because they were eating insects that have eyes like that https://t.co/Q7WBaRM9lt
@MousaviDean https://t.co/n5ZHcl6H8G
Late Quaternary floods and droughts in the Nile valley, Sudan: new evidence from optically stimulated luminescence and AMS radiocarbon dating: https://t.co/JLNtTc91V8 The Origin of Cultivation and Proto-Weeds, Long Before Neolithic Farming: https://t.co/mSLvoTvzlU
What Did We Evolve To Eat? https://t.co/E84NsMELqM via @YouTube
What Did We Evolve To Eat? https://t.co/FNJZ207PEu via @YouTube
What Did We Evolve To Eat? https://t.co/kJhBpgfrya via @YouTube
A good watch https://t.co/1boO8FSP6W
What Did We Evolve To Eat? https://t.co/i3TA1atdQ4 via @YouTube
@Uknowmes1 Here's the paper that article was sourced from, if you care to read the boring parts too https://t.co/RoqtwWkBLA
#PLOSONE: The Origin of Cultivation and Proto-Weeds, Long Before Neolithic Farming https://t.co/jKqejuyUkS
@FancyChipss @DrDavidMiano The Origin of Cultivation and Proto-Weeds, Long Before Neolithic Farming. Says they were sedentary. They built huts, nothing that robust. https://t.co/ULtzfnCgig
Evidence for farming from 28,000 years ago, 11,000 years earlier than neolithic farming (2015) https://t.co/61R1oWrker
3 أظهر الموقع آثار حصاد قبل 23 ألف سنة لحبوب في صورتها القديمة البرية قبل أن تطرأ عليها ملامح التهجين التي جعلتها في صورتها الحديثة التي نراها في محاصيل القمح والشعير والحنطة وغيرها من الحبوب التي نتناولها اليوم كما تجدونها في رابط الدراسة أدناه https://t.co/4MNCz1NmFO
RT @PanaceaInd: The first evidence if farming 23,000 years ago, much earlier than previously assumed 12,000 years back in Cradle of Civiliz…
The first evidence if farming 23,000 years ago, much earlier than previously assumed 12,000 years back in Cradle of Civilization, Iraq. https://t.co/eHE8vQwAoU
@Thomas_Auriel @RoullierY @cduroc Même pour la chronologie souvent mise en avant, il y a encore bcp de questions à se poser : https://t.co/WCR5llvbBd Et le croissant fertile est loin d'être le seul endroit où est apparue l'agriculture : https://t.co/IGroKIkSyF
These glossed flint blades and sickles were used by the somewhat sedentary community in Ohalo II to grind wheat, barley and oats. They were already doing some light farming — 23 thousand years ago on the Sea of Galilee. https://t.co/cun5T21pF4 https://t.co/AXwkR16DSI https://t.co/xdgTpU2Zsh
@Plant_Detective @vinita_gowda @SutherlandBL @JChrisPires …and this evolutionary process has been happening for a very long time (and, yes, humans have been a part of it). https://t.co/4SsC53bzgx
@Chortling_Man @globalist13903 @JohnKrahn2 @SecularSandwich @RossGilroy @willsworldview @zypisfy @Cern_lXXl @BenMayhew13 @imkimaaron @AndrewRChapman @NarratingFools @BrianSlimdog77 @Cleisthenes5 @DenyThemYourEss @ralph_maglio @bearschoice2020 @VelvetEven @smug2bme @JordanBassior @TertiusIV @Wolfpak561 @RobertBrownieJ8 @Venatorgaming9 @jools6691 @savag3ap3 @DiscoJerrys @HP19763 @oohglobbits5 @TheCATheist @jea_jordan @SplinterSimba @DavidVeillon5 @Phoenix42505497 @markthorsby1 @alan244g @TechnoGAUNTLET @jd_and_coke_1 @davestewart4444 @Tris_Stock @orna_verum @SimpleS18790446 @bobfish1973 @zapher134 @randolf828 @th1rt3en_TM @PraiseHisName50 @BillReagan16 @GodflyThe Maybe read the actual paper, which contains materials and methods and point out the errors https://t.co/KjKcZQIEZz
RT @SamoBurja: Agriculture is likely much older than usually assumed! https://t.co/6pS9jK6U4Y
Agriculture is likely much older than usually assumed! https://t.co/6pS9jK6U4Y
@SIRISYSPrime @nix_bit @michellmybelle @DamienWelsh4 @AnomalousChurch @OjiisanNakamot @Testmest16 @aiambassador1 IF further chronological evidence pins more high techs to pleistocene AND we assume technologies weren't gifted to humanity from outside our system THEN agriculture and tech advancements were likely achieved many years prior to earliest evidence? https://t.co/zxmAvCVvnl https://t.co/QpFTv973QQ
When did the Hamitic ancestors of Europeans begin civilization? 23,000 year old evidence that wild cereals were cultivated on the shore of the Sea of Galilee was found @ an archeological site called Ohalo II. Read about Ohalo at https://t.co/Few4MOPOWH & @ https://t.co/DCiiICDQUr
RT @diediazcordova: todas las clases de antropo alimentaria diciendo que la agricultura comienza hace 12.000 años +/- y ahora encuentro est…
RT @diediazcordova: todas las clases de antropo alimentaria diciendo que la agricultura comienza hace 12.000 años +/- y ahora encuentro est…
todas las clases de antropo alimentaria diciendo que la agricultura comienza hace 12.000 años +/- y ahora encuentro este paper que en el sitio OhaloII de Israel hay evidencias de unas minihuertas de hace 23.000 años +/-!!!!! https://t.co/qTuHTivLCW
@TMackeown one site throws everything back thousands of years https://t.co/PpqE6o7Zb4
@PhilGarber5 @Christgodtweet @JohnJotink @SariellaHerself @IDrewMuhammad @murmalerm @malo_j @TakeThatEpi @jools6691 @spikeinthemidge @andyguy @Fierybushes @rkdoctr @JordanBassior @adrianturner01 @TJaytheist @WFatmun @TakeThatDarwin @sk3ptic1st @DoubleDoubleJon @wpcguy @1pckt @RedHorseVet @ScientiaPercept @geraldpayne25 @rmbctious2 @PainesReason @S4R41_K44R @TakeThatHistory @AprilLigeia @AtheistFurry @Ah_Science @NuckChorris16 @LeeTWimberly @WattleOfBits @bonecollector48 @RayOwen27617272 @umfpt @hugh_bothwell @th1rt3en_TM @crypt_oguru @carlsmythe @WillO61152674 @stuarthelmer @NoScienceDenial @TiffiniLOL @SpiritKing11 @guy_JustaGuy @JohnERhino @JaTapps Complete nonsense! https://t.co/djGbQhdfV0 Humans were not created 4004BC, humans evolved, the human lineage branched off from apes around 7 million years ago.
@lacicjoyce @istikanchai agricultural cultivation by humans began in mesopotamia (modern day iraq/iran, directly adjacent to afghanistan) and has continued in this area for over 23,000 years (DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0131422)
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
RT @Aabhas24: 3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeo…
3/n The paper breaks the myth that agriculture happened only ~12kabp as even @tjoseph0010 believes. So Shri Tony Ji, archaeologically your belief is wrong about first time agriculture. Now let us see what experts speak about Holocene. https://t.co/NRiHg1J2aK https://t.co/01MZVBf7OQ
@orna_verum @EdwardwongY @Chaseemmert7 @WesGerrr @Tokyogreen @Cindy007JCsGirl @robster16a @Atheist_Dragon @__Helicon__ @1stthes521 @BabeTruth2 @acneonmyshirt @zalphaprime @Canna420Uk @TakeThatEpi @mark_georgiou @imkimaaron @pray2pesci @Catheri77148739 @DriftlessProf @dougstone2019 @AtheistWombat @TertiusIII @RosaRubicon @Elucidatus @LustfulLiberal @SDarkmore @HazyPeter @JustSayingWhat1 @DarkCloset911 @donholtmac @FictionDoctrine @1pckt @DiscoJerrys @PaulDubuisson @hauxton @CandySmith74 @Simple_Shaman @MaryVMos1 @LeannEAF @James_Smythe @KingOfSalt4 @TheNobo04015677 @Schmoop0521 @jealousgod1 @Atlanticus74 @ForTheUSA2 @Terrenc58307664 @the1researcher @Atheist_1978 https://t.co/djGbQhdfV0
Rather, at least as far back as 23k-ish years ago (some) humans were experimenting with and exploiting the wild ancestors of wheat, oats, barley. These were HGs in Northern Israel. They had grinding stones, charred grain remains, stone sickles. https://t.co/JWPfSGbSBH
@alc_anthro @BottLulz @E_Gruberman @u80286 @shadowcat_mst @TheDebbieMia @MithradatesVI @OblivionVortex @JamesARobertso5 @EmilyChan223 @SGSAMII @KathrynTewson @Comic_Island @trickylilwitch @Flutflut1 @dmschmeyer @borisof007 @troycoverdale @DongerStaples @GlennNG11 @greg_doucette @jeblec @JD_SCCMGUY @AlanMcAuliffe1 @MarisaBell3B @vork77 @PEBXFAJARDO @Erimgard @Neosonic97 @banalexistence @HawkMark1 @Emm_Initiative @decafgeek @FantasySoftEnt @spikefury11 @VigsBlueBalls @XicanoX @Saiyan316 @Dupe1970 @OmeniaPhil @_RPTC4 @vicmignogna Agriculture is widely accepted to have started in 9500 BC. I mean yes, in the history of the Earth, that's quite new. But to us humans, that's much more than a lifetime ago. There also exist some evidence of at least an attempt to do it 23,000 years ago. https://t.co/5Uyd9S8nca
@LeeTWimberly @TiffiniLOL @S4R41_K44R @ScientiaPercept @1pckt @SpiritKing11 @rkdoctr @JordanBassior @guy_JustaGuy @hugh_bothwell @NoScienceDenial @SariellaHerself @JohnERhino @JaTapps @fairytalejedi @DarthCalculus @DoubleDoubleJon @crypt_oguru @umfpt @TakeThatEpi @VainVicar @carlsmythe @adrianturner01 @andyguy @theosib2 @DiscoJerrys @TakeThatHistory @malo_j @spikeinthemidge @JohnJotink @Christgodtweet @jools6691 @wiguy45 @geraldpayne25 @th1rt3en_TM @PainesReason @AprilLigeia @JimSanoBC79 @Kopernikus1966 @PaulDubuisson @Ah_Science @firefighter5511 @HLebwohl @PerryWh91094088 @keitheyoung @NuckChorris16 @RealAnonDouche @mmcdonald77 @wolfgar77 @sallyforthe Then try this.... https://t.co/djGbQhdfV0
Dicen que la agricultura apareció en el neolítico, momento en que también surgió una explosión cognitiva en el ser humano... ahora una investigación sugiere que la agricultura pudo aparecer antes del neolítico https://t.co/4vREf7qufA
RT @DrLimeback: @drjohnnyjohnson Before neolithic farming (≈ 25,000 yrs ago) https://t.co/cYqCAMeVRC, hunter-gatherers had no dental decay.…
@drjohnnyjohnson Before neolithic farming (≈ 25,000 yrs ago) https://t.co/cYqCAMeVRC, hunter-gatherers had no dental decay. "Mother nature" protected all humans for millions of yrs from #fluoride poisoning through dilution, excretion & skeletal sequestering. Evolution = #FluorideProtection.
AM
SB
DC
R
HL
B
V
DS
P
RF
ML
AA
CA
Pپ
C
AG
L
P心
MW
PR
ET
FS
TR
M
LE
MV
AJ
BS
S
H
SS
B
AD
A
Aण
TC
PP
ପର
सव
DR
SR
R
A
QI
G
Nओ
A
PA
वष
SS
RB
PI
UK
F
AV
A
AS
AT
NK
DC
J
R
रर
TW
N
DW
Rय
Cर
E
JF
UD
N