Synopsis of Social media discussions
Discussions reflect a balanced consideration of the article, with posts mentioning the 2015 review and questioning dairy's role in bone health, using factual language and skepticism, which indicates high interest and moderate engagement, but limited direct impact on changing public perceptions or healthcare guidelines.
Agreement
Moderate agreementMost discussions acknowledge the modest benefits of calcium for bone mineral density, aligning with the article's findings that increases are small and not significantly reducing fracture risk.
Interest
High level of interestPosts demonstrate high interest by debating dietary sources, nutritional implications, and health risks associated with calcium, indicating active engagement with the subject.
Engagement
Moderate level of engagementSeveral comments reference specific research studies, like the 2015 systematic review, and question the quality of evidence, showing thoughtful analysis rather than superficial engagement.
Impact
Neutral impactWhile the discussions highlight nutritional debates and conflicting evidence, the overall influence on medical practices or public health recommendations appears limited, hence a neutral impact score.
Social Mentions
YouTube
3 Videos
47 Posts
9 Posts
Blogs
14 Articles
News
161 Articles
2 Posts
Metrics
Video Views
9,738
Total Likes
366
Extended Reach
25,123
Social Features
236
Timeline: Posts about article
Top Social Media Posts
Ada McVean
From a 2015 systematic review and meta-analysis in the @bmj_latest
https://t.co/rNSLdEjndj https://t.co/AGyQcuClDU
view full post
Physicians Association for Nutrition
Today's bite-sized episode of Nutrition Nuggets is about #calcium. Find out what happens when you don't get enough in your #diet and which #plantbased sources are best.
Let us know if you try the tasty calcium-rich #recipe at the end of the video.
https://t.co/K1kZRfWsPo
view full post
Physicians Association for Nutrition
How healthy is #milk for human consumption?
view full post
Ryckie Wade
@bendean1979 Thanks but what evidence are you referring to?
Dairy != BMD (DOI 10.1136/bmj.h4183)
Dairy != fracture risk (DOI 10.1016/S2213-8587(18)30265-1)
Mammalian milk hormones ⬆️ prostate CA risk (DOI 10.1007/s10552-017-0883-1)
68% of humans are lactose intolerant (not baby cows)
view full post
Dr. Jule Kunkel
Is Milk Healthy? | Physicians Association for Nutrition https://t.co/dW8GnQS1oz #dairy #nutrition #healthpromotion #healthylifestyle #health
view full post
Posts referencing the article
Vitamin D and Calcium: Benefits, Risks, and Optimal Intake Strategies
Discover the intricate relationship between Vitamin D and Calcium in our latest video. The systematic review shows modest BMD improvements from increased calcium intake but no significant fracture risk reduction. Learn how to optimize your intake for bone health and overall wellness.
March 16, 2024
6,963 views
Assessing Milk's Health Benefits and Risks Based on Scientific Evidence
This video explores milk's health implications, examining recent research on bone health, associations with diabetes and cancer, and environmental impact. It provides a science-based analysis of milk consumption for informed choices.
March 26, 2021
2,021 views
-
@boogie_gou 출처 1) Tai V, Leung W, Grey A, Reid I R, Bolland M J. Calcium intake and bone mineral density: systematic review and meta-analysis BMJ 2015; 351 :h4183 doi:10.1136/bmj.h4183
view full postMay 13, 2025
-
harold jitschak and engelien bueno de mesquita
@bdmesq (Twitter)https://t.co/yGKmR5mkR1
view full postMarch 16, 2024
-
Ada McVean
@AdaMcVean (Twitter)From a 2015 systematic review and meta-analysis in the @bmj_latest https://t.co/rNSLdEjndj https://t.co/AGyQcuClDU
view full postAugust 22, 2022
3
-
Dr. Jule Kunkel
@JuleKunkel (Twitter)Is Milk Healthy? | Physicians Association for Nutrition https://t.co/dW8GnQS1oz #dairy #nutrition #healthpromotion #healthylifestyle #health
view full postApril 18, 2021
-
WHOLEFOOD
@WHOLEFOOD7 (Twitter)RT @PAN_Int: How healthy is #milk for human consumption?
view full postMarch 26, 2021
1
-
Physicians Association for Nutrition
@PAN_Int (Twitter)How healthy is #milk for human consumption?
view full postMarch 26, 2021
1
1
-
Physicians Association for Nutrition
@PAN_Int (Twitter)Today's bite-sized episode of Nutrition Nuggets is about #calcium. Find out what happens when you don't get enough in your #diet and which #plantbased sources are best. Let us know if you try the tasty calcium-rich #recipe at the end of the video. https://t.co/K1kZRfWsPo
view full postFebruary 8, 2021
3
-
Ryckie Wade
@ryckiewade (Twitter)@bendean1979 Thanks but what evidence are you referring to? Dairy != BMD (DOI 10.1136/bmj.h4183) Dairy != fracture risk (DOI 10.1016/S2213-8587(18)30265-1) Mammalian milk hormones ⬆️ prostate CA risk (DOI 10.1007/s10552-017-0883-1) 68% of humans are lactose intolerant (not baby cows)
view full postSeptember 5, 2020
1
-
Dr.やまて@海外の最新健康情報/親子向け情報/NEWSシェア
@yamatedentist (Twitter)59のランダム化比較試験をメタ分析した結果、カルシウムは食事から採ろうとサプリメントから採ろうと、骨密度の増加に大きな差はなかった件。（ビタミンDを併用しても同様） ちなみにカルシウムを採ることによって、別に骨折しにくくなるわけじゃないよ、というオマケ付き。 https://t.co/1MaisIYz5U
view full postAugust 28, 2020
Abstract Synopsis
- The systematic review and meta-analysis examined whether increasing calcium intake from food or supplements improves bone mineral density (BMD) in people over 50, finding small increases at certain sites but no significant impact on fracture risk.
- Calcium from dietary sources slightly increased BMD at the hip and spine after one and two years, while calcium supplements improved BMD across multiple skeletal sites, but the overall effects were modest and similar between the two sources.
- The study concluded that although both methods modestly raise BMD, these increases are unlikely to significantly reduce the risk of fractures in older adults.]
링고
@33e____ (Twitter)