This collection of social discussions consistently supports the scientific consensus that spanking causes harm, exemplified by phrases like 'meta-analysis of over 160,000 children,' 'it's associated with negative outcomes,' and calls to 'stop beating children.' The tone is assertive and urgent, with participants citing specific studies and emphasizing the long-term consequences, which reflects a high level of engagement and recognition of research impact.
AgreementStrong agreement
Most discussions strongly endorse the findings of the meta-analyses, emphasizing that spanking is harmful and ineffective based on extensive research.
InterestHigh interest
Participants display high curiosity and concern, frequently citing multiple studies and meta-analyses, showing active engagement with the scientific evidence.
EngagementHigh engagement
Many individuals reference detailed studies, quote research papers, and debate implications, indicating deep involvement and critical evaluation.
ImpactHigh impact
The collective tone suggests these discussions could influence attitudes and policies, advocating for changes in discipline practices based on strong evidence.
Abstract in brief
Spanking is a controversial topic with ongoing debates about whether it is beneficial or harmful to children.
Meta-analyses of 111 studies involving over 160,000 children show that spanking is generally linked to negative outcomes for kids.
The negative effects of spanking are similar in strength to those of physical abuse and are consistent across different study types and designs.]
México es un país donde los castigos físicos en niños es aún “socialmente aceptado”. Lamentablemente estos tiene varias consecuencias adversas que incluyen alteraciones en el desarrollo socio emocional, físico y en aprendizaje.
...że klapsy są dobre dla dzieci, a wszystkie dowody wskazują na ryzyko wyrządzenia szkody."
Źródła: Spanking and Child Outcomes: Old Controversies and New Meta-Analyses.
Risks of Harm from Spanking ... (The University of Texas at Austin).
Film znaleziony u @gromotapl
@amandadeibert The worst internet hellfire I've ever experienced was when I shared the 50-year spanking metastudy. People who believe in violence towards children will turn it on others when pressed. It's terrifying (and important to push back).
https://t.co/vWF1RTIFOi
Jun 29, 2022 · 33 likes · 2 shares · 2,911 followersView post →
AL
Alex Leaf
@AlexJLeaf · X
@Newnameel A meta-analysis involving over 160,000 children found that spanking significantly hurt 13 of 17 cognitive and behavioral outcomes later in life and that its effect was no different from other forms of physical abuse.
https://t.co/QOal2Tme0F
Dec 3, 2024 · 29 likes · 4,438 followersView post →
JT
Jorge Tamayo
@JorgeMTamayo · X
@NoticiasRCN Tal como va mostrando la encuesta, el 43% de los colombianos justifica el maltrato físico a los menores
Oct 7, 2020 · 16 likes · 11 shares · 861 followersView post →
P
peachmilfshake
@peachmilfshake · X
@thicctatorx This one has 5 decades of research on I believe over 160,000 children! https://t.co/GtT1EARrZZ
We often carry the weight of words our parents said even years later. This video explores 10 toxic phrases parents say that can harm a child's self-worth and emotional health, highlighting the importance of awareness…
This video discusses the controversy surrounding spanking and its effects on children, based on meta-analyses of over 160,000 children, showing that spanking is linked to negative outcomes similar to physical abuse…
@25LegParlay @kanacookiechoco @katyspeppurmint See:
- Gershoff, E. T., & Grogan-Kaylor, A. (2016). https://t.co/PihR6kKcV4
- Gershoff, E. T. (2013). https://t.co/UrK1YtPajG
- Cuartas, J., Weissman, D. G., Sheridan, M. A., Lengua, L., & McLaughlin, K. A. (2021). https://t.co/rKI3RZ6mb3
@Mind_Maelstrom @pfwedE @autocorrect2_0 https://t.co/CcT9vFgvmR
How about a meta analysis of 111 unique effect sizes representing 160,927 children. It's the broad consensus of hundreds of studies that spanking and other forms of corporal punishment are ineffective and potentially harmful.
@gxrtnessjnXii @VyronJohnson @Defenestrate123 @Logic_n_Data @brutalfightz Gershoff, E. T., & Grogan-Kaylor, A. (2016). “Spanking and Child Outcomes: Old Controversies and New Meta-Analyses.” Journal of Family Psychology.
American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) Policy Statement: “Effective Discipline to Raise Healthy Children.” Pediatrics (2018).
@BBCPolitics The research has been done. The science is in. The outcomes of 160,000 children studied, across many decades. The verdict: smacking achieves none of the things it sets out to achieve and tends to make the child's outcomes worse:
https://t.co/kbavRN9Rxl
https://t.co/7vUCNGFMK1
@benonwine The research has been done. The science is in. The outcomes of 160,000 children studied, across many decades. The verdict: smacking achieves none of the things it sets out to achieve and tends to make the child's outcomes worse:
https://t.co/kbavRN9Rxl
https://t.co/7vUCNGFMK1
@spikedonline The research has been done. The science is in. The outcomes of 160,000 children studied, across many decades. The verdict: smacking achieves none of the things it sets out to achieve and tends to make the child's outcomes worse:
https://t.co/kbavRN9Rxl
https://t.co/7vUCNGFMK1
What does the research say about long term effects of spanking a child?
A relatively recent study (2016) done by Elizabeth T Gershoff and Andrew Gorgan-Kaylor looked at “Spanking and Child Outcomes: Old Controversies and New Meta-Analyses”
This was their conclusion after https://t.co/vXHh184AAL
@MattRamsey80 The meta-analysis I'm citing addresses this issue directly and critiques prior analyses exactly on this point. They specifically define spanking as open palm hit to the butt, as commonly defined, and everything else as more severe physical abuse.
https://t.co/jLXZFK2aPW
@8bit_gun @shutup_m3g A meta-analysis involving over 160,000 children found that spanking significantly hurt 13 of 17 cognitive and behavioral outcomes later in life and that its effect was no different from other forms of physical abuse.
https://t.co/jLXZFK2aPW
@MyTikTokFYP @ItsPhigs @revenant_MMXX Sorry, no. A meta-analysis involving over 160,000 children found that spanking significantly hurt 13 of 17 cognitive and behavioral outcomes later in life and that its effect was no different from other forms of physical abuse, like beatings.
https://t.co/jLXZFK2IFu
Dec 4, 2024 · 2 likes · 4,438 followersView post →
AL
Alex Leaf
@AlexJLeaf · X
@immrwatcher A meta-analysis involving over 160,000 children found that spanking significantly hurt 13 of 17 cognitive and behavioral outcomes later in life and that its effect was no different from other forms of physical abuse.
https://t.co/jLXZFK2IFu
@Newnameel A meta-analysis involving over 160,000 children found that spanking significantly hurt 13 of 17 cognitive and behavioral outcomes later in life and that its effect was no different from other forms of physical abuse.
https://t.co/QOal2Tme0F
Dec 3, 2024 · 29 likes · 4,438 followersView post →
I
internautico
@inter_nautico · X
@Jrnier2 @Batista_Isr @AneldoArosemena Gershoff, E., & Grogan-Kaylor, A. (2016). Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses.. Journal of family psychology : JFP : journal of the Division of Family Psychology of the American Psychological Association, 30 4, 453-69 . https://t.co/Kq9qhNWeN1.
@Wilfred0nTwt @MiguelM24243815 @PorqueTTDalas Gershoff, E. T., & Grogan-Kaylor, A. (2016). Spanking and child outcomes: old controversies and new meta-analyses. Journal of Family Psychology, 30(4), 453-469.
@Wilfred0nTwt @MiguelM24243815 @PorqueTTDalas Gershoff, E. T., & Grogan-Kaylor, A. (2016). Spanking and Child Outcomes: Old Controversies and New Meta-Analyses. Journal of Family Psychology, 30(4), 453–469.
@NicolasGalita Oui plutôt dans le monde anglo-saxon : Gershoff, E. T., & Grogan-Kaylor, A. (2016). « Spanking and Child Outcomes: Old Controversies and New Meta-Analyses»
Afifi, T. O., Mota, N. P., Dasiewicz, P., MacMillan, H. L., & Sareen, J. (2012). «Physical punishment and mental disorders»
@SaltSeaDog @godlywomanhood A meta-analysis involving over 160,000 children found that spanking significantly hurt 13 of 17 cognitive and behavioral outcomes later in life and that its effect was no different from other forms of physical abuse.
https://t.co/jLXZFK2IFu
Jul 19, 2024 · 1 like · 4,438 followersView post →
AL
Alex Leaf
@AlexJLeaf · X
A meta-analysis involving over 160,000 children found that spanking significantly hurt 13 of 17 cognitive and behavioral outcomes later in life, and that it's effect was no different from other forms of physical abuse.
https://t.co/jLXZFK2IFu
Jun 30, 2024 · 7 likes · 4,438 followersView post →
AL
Alex Leaf
@AlexJLeaf · X
@Wild_XW A meta-analysis involving over 160,000 children found that spanking significantly hurt 13 of 17 cognitive and behavioral outcomes later in life, and that it's effect was no different from other forms of physical abuse.
https://t.co/jLXZFK2IFu
@Gilbino_81 @MarePythia @andynotserious @streethistory @relloworld6 @ChefAnthonyDC “One of those studies” I think you answered your own question here lmao
There’s a mountains worth of evidence on this, can you cite a study that says otherwise? https://t.co/gxmfko4F40
@8therealization It doesn't work, it's abuse and more likely than not those kids grow up to be abusers themselves. This is well documented and we have good studies on it.
https://t.co/8y5jaKwuP5
https://t.co/XXO5HQk1vI
@Wil_Im_Not @SamtheNightOwl @DrakeArmstrongX A meta analysis of 111 different studies with 160,000 kids—>adults and the results are breathtaking. Nearly universally, there is no difference between “spanking” and “abuse” to kids. It’s abuse. And the long term outcomes are bad.
https://t.co/IvpYgcuLIB
Oct 3, 2023 · 12 likes · 1 share · 513 followersView post →
H
hbuff
@hbuff67 · X
@UzuNeymar @tyler02020202 Straight up wrong
https://t.co/6fU48YE1PN
PS; Gdyby ktoś chciał dowiedzieć się jak bardzo jednoznaczne są negatywne konsekwencje nawet sporadycznych "klapsów" polecam pracę "Spanking and Child Outcomes: Old Controversies and New Meta-Analyses (Gershoff ET, Grogan-Kaylor A. 2016)
https://t.co/e6rmemgxqX
@derekradney @Christ_like_ish @_nomadic_soul The data is in - spanking is statistically indistinguishable from other forms of abuse. Across the board, it’s associated with negative outcomes.
https://t.co/6zX6NbmJWo
...że klapsy są dobre dla dzieci, a wszystkie dowody wskazują na ryzyko wyrządzenia szkody."
Źródła: Spanking and Child Outcomes: Old Controversies and New Meta-Analyses.
Risks of Harm from Spanking ... (The University of Texas at Austin).
Film znaleziony u @gromotapl
@AustralianCelt @ravensrockmusic I'm against nearly all violence against children.
The evidence is pretty clear that it's not good.
https://t.co/miLBu6gjvo
…detrimental child outcomes.'
Gershoff, E. T., & Grogan-Kaylor, A. (2016). Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses. Journal of Family Psychology, 30(4), 453-469.
(2/2)
@acdoctor88 There are ways to raise respectful children without spanking. (2016). Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses. Journal of Family Psychology, 30(4), 453-469.(2013). Harsh physical punishment in childhood and adult physical health. Pediatrics, 132(2)
@iRichard_AP @LisaSmi38025729 @islandgirll8 @thegrldivs101 Decades of studies and evidence showing that “discipline” AKA spanking is abuse
https://t.co/UUneGRflu6
@Liberty17768 @FrankChecked @ComicDaveSmith @HannahDCox You do realize that many researchers don’t make $ off of published articles or funded by pediatric institutions? There are plenty of studies meeting the criteria you asked about including:
https://t.co/6u67Jp8EVO
https://t.co/DU35brnxa8
https://t.co/7oD1n9rcwz
New MA on the effects of spanking children as a disciplinary approach: increased risk for detrimental outcomes and no immediate or long-term “benefits”: https://t.co/BhnDl6PqKr
RT @Lara_Schwartz: @amandadeibert The worst internet hellfire I've ever experienced was when I shared the 50-year spanking metastudy. Peopl…
Jun 29, 2022 · 2 shares · 1,301 followersView post →
LS
Lara Schwartz
@Lara_Schwartz · X
@amandadeibert The worst internet hellfire I've ever experienced was when I shared the 50-year spanking metastudy. People who believe in violence towards children will turn it on others when pressed. It's terrifying (and important to push back).
https://t.co/vWF1RTIFOi
Jun 29, 2022 · 33 likes · 2 shares · 2,911 followersView post →
The problem with spanking is that it's politicized, so if you don't think it does any good because there's no evidence for it, you're automatically a Democrat. Likewise if you believe in a flat tax rate, you probably spank your children. It's nonsense.
https://t.co/VAc08mQeNl https://t.co/FGkoKZjpSW
@BrettPajaro @FocusFamily You may not be able to get beyond the paywall if you’re not in academia, but here’s one where you can read the abstract:
https://t.co/aQgkyS2ZYA
May 6, 2022 · 1 like · 41,804 followersView post →
TP
tetrarchangel (no other names, not a real person)
@tetrarchangel · X
It's really simple. We can check whether smacking does anyone any harm or not. And we have. And we can compile those results, to give us confidence in them. We've done that.
https://t.co/UGRV5nzEp2
Apr 21, 2022 · 1 like · 1 share · 646 followersView post →
TD
The devil in disguise
@molokokiki · X
RT @docramiro: México es un país donde los castigos físicos en niños es aún “socialmente aceptado”. Lamentablemente estos tiene varias cons…
México es un país donde los castigos físicos en niños es aún “socialmente aceptado”. Lamentablemente estos tiene varias consecuencias adversas que incluyen alteraciones en el desarrollo socio emocional, físico y en aprendizaje.
@RubenDavidFF Lo que sé es que Dunker puede opinar lo que quiera, pero meta-análisis sobre la relación entre dar una pela y learning outcomes es clara, los efectos son significativos y no difieren del abuso físico aún controlando por varias covariantes: https://t.co/johydL0Xzz
@ArmyJohn85 Anyway, HERE are my sources. Pay the $12 to read the full texts, I’ll even lend you my school login if you’d like. Studies. By scientists.
https://t.co/N5rouxuaQL
https://t.co/fOP6BaYi5z
https://t.co/Wa2rspvX2T
https://t.co/9mzn2UFGgH
It will never cease to gut me that America is so sheltered & used to violent authoritarianism that despite over 50yrs of studies, people insist the best way to raise children is with fear & physical violence.
https://t.co/5cj0A7iaiy
Jun 22, 2021 · 2 likes · 1,509 followersView post →
K
Kyō
@KyosanAU · X
It's ineffective at achieving its aims and creates negative results, but that's besides the point.
https://t.co/clGBuvHEgb
@jadegamering @its_furaidei @Sensei_Booda @PiEispie4 @nmercadowrites @1NuttyGirl Try looking at the Journal of Family Psychology's study: Spanking and Child Outcomes, Old Controversies and New Meta Analyses
Jun 2, 2021 · 12 likes · 1 share · 34,948 followersView post →
LL
Liberal, Not Lefty
@liberalnotlefty · X
@mheusser @ZacSmall_ Are you trying to suggest the current literature supports spanking? It very clearly doesn’t. Here you go:
https://t.co/W8PdnSHYBs
https://t.co/NrQjvimTTU
https://t.co/x7SHCSF02E
https://t.co/t9f3lf8T7f
https://t.co/AkQGJBVIjS
https://t.co/QHf8WfTZVK
https://t.co/LL5ywklvDk
@4xalmis @jkn2k @pictoline Ningún articulo publicado en Pubmed y de parte de dos investigadores con mas estudios en el tema del castigo parental, sería sarcasmo. https://t.co/ggcjZd4aC3
@SocDoneLeft Hitting kids is the one thing that really gets to me - it's very well trodden ground at this point and how this isn't viewed as rediculously as antivaxxing at this point is beyond me
https://t.co/03IMf2y9E9
#Scotland is the first UK nation to ban #smacking of children. Reminded me of this other report 4 years ago outlining the risks of harm ascertained by a meta-analysis of 50 years: https://t.co/gxkwLR7FFy
#stopCP #bancorporalpunishment #childprotection
https://t.co/JqjLfgxgpv
Nov 8, 2020 · 2 likes · 1,976 followersView post →
SB
Spencer J Barrett
@spencerofgrove · X
@OhioYangerOn Sorry, more direct link https://t.co/HLDmkvwFkp
RT @JorgeMTamayo: @NoticiasRCN Tal como va mostrando la encuesta, el 43% de los colombianos justifica el maltrato físico a los menores
Oct 7, 2020 · 11 shares · 3,352 followersView post →
JP
Julián Peinado
@JulianPeinadoR · X
RT @JorgeMTamayo: @NoticiasRCN Tal como va mostrando la encuesta, el 43% de los colombianos justifica el maltrato físico a los menores
Oct 7, 2020 · 11 shares · 6,112 followersView post →
ER
El Diván Rojo ®
@eldivanrojo · X
RT @JorgeMTamayo: @NoticiasRCN Tal como va mostrando la encuesta, el 43% de los colombianos justifica el maltrato físico a los menores
Oct 7, 2020 · 11 shares · 13,169 followersView post →
FR
Fundación Red
@FundacionRed · X
RT @JorgeMTamayo: @NoticiasRCN Tal como va mostrando la encuesta, el 43% de los colombianos justifica el maltrato físico a los menores
Oct 7, 2020 · 11 shares · 7,420 followersView post →
AA
Asociación Afecto
@afectoenlinea · X
RT @JorgeMTamayo: @NoticiasRCN Tal como va mostrando la encuesta, el 43% de los colombianos justifica el maltrato físico a los menores
Oct 7, 2020 · 11 shares · 2,037 followersView post →
CC
Corporacion Cariño
@corpcarino · X
RT @JorgeMTamayo: @NoticiasRCN Tal como va mostrando la encuesta, el 43% de los colombianos justifica el maltrato físico a los menores
Oct 7, 2020 · 11 shares · 3,085 followersView post →
IC
IPS Creciendo con Cariño
@IpsCreciendo · X
RT @JorgeMTamayo: @NoticiasRCN Tal como va mostrando la encuesta, el 43% de los colombianos justifica el maltrato físico a los menores
Oct 7, 2020 · 11 shares · 415 followersView post →
AM
Angelica Aparicio MD
@tupsiquiatraa · X
RT @JorgeMTamayo: @NoticiasRCN Tal como va mostrando la encuesta, el 43% de los colombianos justifica el maltrato físico a los menores
Oct 7, 2020 · 11 shares · 1,147 followersView post →
JT
Jorge Tamayo
@JorgeMTamayo · X
@NoticiasRCN Tal como va mostrando la encuesta, el 43% de los colombianos justifica el maltrato físico a los menores
Oct 7, 2020 · 16 likes · 11 shares · 861 followersView post →
D
Diogo
@Diogo32454707 · X
@Antonio02415437 @BungeLucas @caiocgomes Poisé, até vi matérias, não cheguei na fonte. Não consegui chegar.
https://t.co/ziK6Sivm0Z
Essa não tem link, https://t.co/u6YyyFooQl é paga, alguém tem isso de graça? (https://t.co/rRCOy1KEwl)
Como que pesquisa pode ser algo pago?
@Super_NoHero @RonyBeverly @InkedRanjei heres a study on a link between spanking and behavioral problems
https://t.co/sO2xgxkOT0
heres a study showing spanking doesnt help childrens behavior
https://t.co/XCoIawRufh
heres a study on reduced brain matter in kids exposed to corporal punishment
https://t.co/5Ps6KfYsn0
May 13, 2020 · 1 share · 36,869 followersView post →
دا
د. أمل حسين العوامي
@amel612 · X
RT @DrAbdullahGh_: جدول يوضح العلاقة بين الضرب البسيط بغرض الترهيب وبعض النتائج السلبية.
لاحظ أن كلها احصائياً مهمة.
هذا البحث بالكامل لمن…
May 13, 2020 · 25 shares · 36,869 followersView post →
CO
complex case (official)
@fohfuu · X
@Capchildxo @Webcamparrot @TheBlursedTimes @ninjastep13 @NotEvilJeremy @DGDDavidson @VitoGesualdi Sigh.
Spanking and child outcomes: old controversies and new meta-analyses (E Gershoff, A Grogan-Kaylor) Journal of family psychology 30 (4), 453, 2016
Gershoff, E. T., & Grogan-Kaylor, A. (2016). Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses. Journal of Family Psychology, 30(4), 453–469. doi:10.1037/fam0000191
（参考）Gershoff, E. T., & Grogan-Kaylor, A. (2016). Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses. Journal of Family Psychology, 30(4), 453-469. https://t.co/tmNm91vvKq https://t.co/uRpHGoEEF5
@SaisBro @sfvsfsqfs @Amarykitty @holy_Phoenixx Celles-ci montrent le lien statistiquement significatif entre fessée et maltraitance entre autres :
https://t.co/httHqOTJ7I
@ATMology I literally lay out why assaulting and abusing children doesn't work. It's not just me! It's literally DECADES of research
https://t.co/jGbuEua922
https://t.co/1XQoSPaqbP
RT @finalvent: げ、こんな研究あった。
———Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses. PsycNET https://t.co/3X8U0Cp4yL
Feb 7, 2019 · 1 share · 1,790 followersView post →
F
finalvent
@finalvent · X
げ、こんな研究あった。
———Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses. PsycNET https://t.co/3X8U0Cp4yL
Feb 7, 2019 · 2 likes · 1 share · 20,621 followersView post →
RH
RailRen's going home
@RailRen · X
@AmaiDolce2x Anecdotes are not evidence. Studies are.
"Physical Punishment and Mental Disorders: Results From a Nationally Representative US Sample"
"Spanking and child outcomes: Old controversies and new meta-analyses."
These are just two studies I found in a couple minutes.
➤ https://doi.org/10.1037/fam0000191. Michel Foucault, Surveiller et punir (1975) ➤ Livre : Surveiller et punir. Naissance de la prison, Gallimard, 1975
Journal of Family Psychology, 30(4), 453-469. https://doi.org/10.1037/fam0000191 Kazdin, A. E. (2001). Behavior modification in applied settings. Waveland Press ...
Psyc 1504-01 Discussion Forum 3 | PDF | Punishments ...
News
Journal of Family Psychology, 30(4), 453-469. https://doi.org/10.1037/fam0000191. Seligman, M. E. P. (1972). Learned helplessness. Annual Review of Medicine ...
To Spank or Not To Spank-2 | PDF | Spanking | Corporal ...
News
https://doi.org/10.1037/fam0000191. Kazdin, A. E. (2005). Parenting the defiant child: The clinically proven five-week program for. parents of two- to six ...
RE
OK
LS
AL
JT
P
E
BK
RA
R
I
CL
AF
OD
DB
I
B
JA
BM
Y
F
K
A
RS
H
MP
A
O
AG
MJ
C
T
NW
L
MH
HL
D
OE
SS
VO
ЕП
S
FC
D
W
M
SH
TP
TD
PP
CM
WM
VA
W
GD
DK
IP
S
GR
LM
A
OA
CH
K
ᕗ
TR
LL
O
N
DD
SH
SB
PT
JA
PH
JP
ER
FR
AA
CC
IC
AM
D
SS
KE
N
Α
دا
CO
采
OR
E
S
JS
DO
E
NV
多
F
RH