Reporting of Positive Results in Randomized Controlled Trials of Mindfulness-Based Mental Health Interventions.

Stephanie Coronado-Montoya, Alexander W Levis, Linda Kwakkenbos, Russell J Steele, Erick H Turner, Brett D Thombs

August 2016 PLoS One

Synopsis of Social media discussions

Several discussions reflect cautious interest, such as references to evidence of bias and methodological issues, exemplified by phrases like 'potential there, for sure' and questions about control groups. The tone is mostly analytical and inquisitive, emphasizing the contentious nature of research in this field and signaling a nuanced view of the publication's implications.

A
Agreement
 Neither agree nor disagree

The discussions show a mixed view, with some posts questioning bias and methodology while others acknowledge potential bias, leading to a neutral overall stance.

I
Interest
 Moderate level of interest

Most posts seem moderately interested, as they reference related studies, biases, and methodological concerns without deeply engaging with new insights.

E
Engagement
 Neutral engagement

Posts mostly share opinions, references, and questions rather than in-depth analysis, indicating a moderate level of engagement.

I
Impact
 Moderate level of impact

The social discussions highlight ongoing debates about the credibility and interpretation of mindfulness research, suggesting some influence but not a transformative shift.

Social Mentions

YouTube

3 Videos

Facebook

10 Posts

Twitter

16 Posts

Blogs

6 Articles

News

24 Articles

Metrics

Video Views

19,080

Total Likes

813

Extended Reach

666,375

Social Features

59

Timeline: Posts about article

Top Social Media Posts

Posts referencing the article

Understanding Mindfulness: Benefits and Risks of Meditation Practices

Understanding Mindfulness: Benefits and Risks of Meditation Practices

Mildred Lyons

March 28, 2022

19,022 views

The Benefits and Insights of Solo Travel and Self-Discovery

The Benefits and Insights of Solo Travel and Self-Discovery

In this episode, I explore the transformative power of solo exploration, focusing on self-discovery, personal growth, and mental wellbeing during independent journeys. Discover how embracing solitude can enhance wellbeing and foster profound experiences.

Cori's Corner

April 8, 2024

47 views

The Benefits of Solo Exploration for Self-Discovery and Personal Growth

The Benefits of Solo Exploration for Self-Discovery and Personal Growth

In this episode I delve into the transformative power of solo exploration where individuals embark on journeys to discover both themselves and the world beyond. I discuss the importance of embracing solitude, overcoming fears, and nurturing mental and spiritual wellbeing during these adventures.

Cori's Corner

April 8, 2024

12 views

  • rm
    @rm42001 (Twitter)

    Take this paper by Corondo-Montoya et al. (2016) as an example. https://t.co/m0fn34IKzB. It talks about how majority of findings from studies on mindfulness and mental health produce significant results, even with low statistical power. https://t.co/wC6kgxh51U
    view full post

    August 4, 2023

  • Robin N. Kok
    @robinnkok (Twitter)

    @altini_marco More background info: https://t.co/S3kQShUcrg
    view full post

    May 27, 2022

    1

  • Give Me Mangos
    @Lyn50971800 (Twitter)

    RT @CaulfieldTim: @DrJenGunter @gorskon Yes, evidence of bias in alt med studies. Some examples: Mindfulness: https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc Acu…
    view full post

    September 17, 2020

    14

  • Edzard Ernst
    @EdzardErnst (Twitter)

    RT @CaulfieldTim: @DrJenGunter @gorskon Yes, evidence of bias in alt med studies. Some examples: Mindfulness: https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc Acu…
    view full post

    September 17, 2020

    14

  • Menopause Doctor
    @DrTarylFelhaber (Twitter)

    RT @CaulfieldTim: @DrJenGunter @gorskon Yes, evidence of bias in alt med studies. Some examples: Mindfulness: https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc Acu…
    view full post

    September 16, 2020

    14

  • Beans
    @FionaNaylor2 (Twitter)

    RT @CaulfieldTim: @DrJenGunter @gorskon Yes, evidence of bias in alt med studies. Some examples: Mindfulness: https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc Acu…
    view full post

    September 16, 2020

    14

  • Jim Mooney
    @docmooney (Twitter)

    RT @CaulfieldTim: @DrJenGunter @gorskon Yes, evidence of bias in alt med studies. Some examples: Mindfulness: https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc Acu…
    view full post

    September 16, 2020

    14

  • Dmellieonzier
    @dmellieon (Twitter)

    RT @CaulfieldTim: @DrJenGunter @gorskon Yes, evidence of bias in alt med studies. Some examples: Mindfulness: https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc Acu…
    view full post

    September 16, 2020

    14

  • PokéGirl
    @LindsayLavigne2 (Twitter)

    RT @CaulfieldTim: @DrJenGunter @gorskon Yes, evidence of bias in alt med studies. Some examples: Mindfulness: https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc Acu…
    view full post

    September 16, 2020

    14

  • Edward Nirenberg
    @ENirenberg (Twitter)

    RT @CaulfieldTim: @DrJenGunter @gorskon Yes, evidence of bias in alt med studies. Some examples: Mindfulness: https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc Acu…
    view full post

    September 16, 2020

    14

  • Jennifer Gunter
    @DrJenGunter (Twitter)

    RT @CaulfieldTim: @DrJenGunter @gorskon Yes, evidence of bias in alt med studies. Some examples: Mindfulness: https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc Acu…
    view full post

    September 16, 2020

    14

  • Timothy Caulfield
    @CaulfieldTim (Twitter)

    @DrJenGunter @gorskon Yes, evidence of bias in alt med studies. Some examples: Mindfulness: https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc Acupuncture: https://t.co/7A7hQIMgzl (by @EdzardErnst) Example publication bias: https://t.co/EOPpZsR0yf And (of course) close ties to industry: https://t.co/CD6qhbUzW3
    view full post

    September 16, 2020

    29

    14

  • Timothy Caulfield
    @CaulfieldTim (Twitter)

    @graemedmoffat @ntvandam @jonathanstea @StanKutcher @GidMK @cecilejanssens @drkiki @crackedscience @HealthNewsRevu @garyschwitzer @ConscienHealth Aware of that interesting study from 2015. Potential there, for sure. I'm curious if (much critiqued) methodology limitation in this area are getting better (read the 2018 analysis). See also https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc.
    view full post

    September 7, 2020

    2

  • David Mehler
    @neuroccino (Twitter)

    @argStringaris Haven't read this yet but what were the control groups to control for unspecific effects (placebo, suggestion etc)? Just to mention that the publication bias is likely quite high, eg: https://t.co/q9r00bZSUO
    view full post

    January 15, 2020

    1

  • Timothy Caulfield
    @CaulfieldTim (Twitter)

    @Farmer_MindBody @CoyneoftheRealm There is a huge amount of scrutiny on this topic. And more is needed. In fact, I use mindfulness bias (see https://t.co/3ENPwT5ptc) to highlight this exact point. Hype/bias is everywhere. People often think it exists only with Big Sci. We need good method/science everywhere.
    view full post

    April 29, 2019

  • Robin N. Kok
    @robinnkok (Twitter)

    @Research_Tim @williamspsych @AlanBOCallaghan Here's a reference for Tim's claim that the effects of mindfulness are hyped. https://t.co/S3kQShUcrg
    view full post

    April 1, 2019

    4

Abstract Synopsis