Several posts emphasize the strength of the scientific evidence supporting common ancestry, such as claims that it is 'proven beyond reasonable doubt' and 'statistically rock solid.' The tone is largely supportive and confident, often highlighting detailed genetic data and the consistency across multiple studies to reinforce their acceptance of the findings. Words like 'overwhelming,' 'proof,' and 'support' showcase an overall tone of validation and endorsement, reflecting a broad consensus in the discussion community.
AgreementStrong agreement
Most posts strongly support the publication, citing overwhelming evidence and statistical support for common ancestry, with phrases like 'overwhelming weight of evidence' and 'proven beyond reasonable doubt'.
InterestHigh interest
Posts demonstrate high engagement, referencing specific studies, statistical methods, and detailed scientific explanations, indicating active curiosity and relevance.
EngagementHigh engagement
Many discussions delve into complex scientific methods like genetic analysis and statistical validation, showing deep engagement with the material.
ImpactHigh impact
Widespread recognition of the strong evidence’s significance is evident, with several individuals emphasizing that the findings are conclusive and foundational to understanding human evolution.
Abstract in brief
The article discusses how evidence strongly supports the idea that primates share a common ancestor, using various data types like morphology, genetics, and geography, and employs different statistical methods to confirm this.
New statistical techniques were developed to test if ecological traits influence data and whether fossil primates show fewer differences than living ones, further supporting common ancestry.
The results overwhelmingly rejected the idea that each species or family of primates originated separately, reinforcing Darwin's theory of descent with common ancestry, and the paper explores broader implications for testing historical hypotheses.]
"A Critique of Intelligent Design": https://t.co/qakABU9mFq
Dec 5, 2019 · 5 likes · 2 shares · 2,837 followersView post →
DE
Dr Theosib, CPU expert
@theosib2 · X
@gabenorman13 @BilboUnbeliever @achilles1974 @JacksonWheat1 @lord_skeptic @The_Duginator @sygarte Here. If you can show how the math in this article has been done incorrectly, I'll consider believing creationist claims.
https://t.co/fR9ietOZte
Jan 6, 2021 · 4 likes · 1 share · 1,412 followersView post →
Dec 28, 2023 · 3 likes · 5,510 followersView post →
NC
No Such Thing as Too Many Cycles
@TakethatCt · X
@DavidJayJordan @penguinteamsix @REPENTHELLFIRE @SecularSmurf @of_hate65489 @Paleoguy073 @MartinJBern @SpudEternal @Kitty71052501 @Call_Me_Emo1 @leroyb756 @ScientiaPercept @RJDownard @DavidCamham1 @ForrestRichardA @ArkEncounter Human populations have evolved, but selection pressures in modern societies are weaker
In any case, we have evolved from other populations of primates
https://t.co/8Ao9TW7Nsf
Dec 9, 2023 · 3 likes · 5,510 followersView post →
This video critiques Emily Reeves' articles responding to my review of statistical evidence for common ancestry in primates, exploring the scientific discussion and underlying genomic research in primate evolution.
It looks like Evolution News has decided to tackle the Primate Phylogeny paper. The article discusses how evidence strongly supports the idea that primates share a common ancestor, using various data types like…
This video discusses strong evidence supporting primates sharing a common ancestor, using morphology, genetics, and geography, and introduces new statistical methods confirming this, reinforcing Darwin's theory of…
This video discusses research on long-term fitness evolution in E. coli, highlighting that fitness increases follow a powerlaw model, indicating indefinite potential for adaptation without upper limits.
This video explores how entropy impacts biological evolution, examining how fitness gains persist over time without an upper limit, supported by long-term E. coli studies showing continuous adaptation and variability in…
This study investigates long-term fitness evolution in E. coli populations, demonstrating that fitness increases follow a powerlaw model, allowing indefinite gains and ongoing variability among populations due to…
This video discusses long-term fitness evolution in E. coli, showing that fitness increases follow a powerlaw model, suggesting continuous gains without a limit. Over 1100 assays confirmed the model's accuracy…
This video examines strong statistical evidence supporting the idea that primates share a common ancestor, highlighting data from morphology, genetics, and geography, and discussing new methods used to confirm…
The article discusses how evidence strongly supports the idea that primates share a common ancestor, using various data types like morphology, genetics, and geography, and employs different statistical methods to…
@pgarrett25 @darwintojesus It seems you don't even understand the paper you posted:
Statistical evidence for common ancestry: Application to primates.
Ignores this study from Galina Glazko at UAMS:
Eighty percent of proteins are different between humans and chimpanzees: https://t.co/V4npmFvSYZ
The
Jul 19, 2024 · 1 like · 14,461 followersView post →
PG
Paul Garrett
@pgarrett25 · X
@aletechview @darwintojesus You being willfully ignorant doesn't change anything.
https://t.co/WA4KeboINi
Why is this paper incorrect?
Jun 15, 2024 · 1 like · 5,510 followersView post →
KN
King Nothing
@_king__nothing_ · X
@JohnWilkinson__ @JordyRen93 @bibleradioapp @NotEvolution1 @erichovind @redeemed_zoomer Except when we did a statistical analysis of genetic, physiological and bio-geographical data we found overwhelming support for evolution and common ancestry. With a near infinitesimal P value.
I’d suggest reading the paper if you get a chance
https://t.co/wra113oyUu
@Nonlin_Org @TheHistoryGuy07 Yeah, "not necessarily"... here is a paper that takes several similar correlations, and calculates the likelihood that those occurr in a separate ancestry scenario to be about 10^-1000 .
https://t.co/cVNZAVXBpG
@Lesterdiamonds7 This does it with many different datapoints, including silent sites:
https://t.co/cVNZAVXBpG
This specifically with silent sites (preprint):
https://t.co/pKXf19w3am
@ScienceQriosity And of course silent sites still fall in the same nested hierarchy.
Mentioned here as a small part of a bigger, but inho hard to read study:
https://t.co/cVNZAVXBpG
And here with a focus on silent sites only - but only as a preprint.
https://t.co/pKXf19w3am
@MinistriesMicah @ATimeswift @FinnWilson9 @Will_D_Fi @JacksonWheat1 LGT doesn't cause any particular problem for the concept of gene based cladistics at all
It might complicate matters, but it doesn't undermine the fact that all life does indeed share a universal common ancestor
https://t.co/KdsIToE1SU
https://t.co/N997FSKfs4
Dec 30, 2023 · 1 like · 1,891 followersView post →
@DavidJayJordan @penguinteamsix @REPENTHELLFIRE @SecularSmurf @of_hate65489 @Paleoguy073 @MartinJBern @SpudEternal @Kitty71052501 @Call_Me_Emo1 @leroyb756 @ScientiaPercept @RJDownard @DavidCamham1 @ForrestRichardA @ArkEncounter Human populations have evolved, but selection pressures in modern societies are weaker
In any case, we have evolved from other populations of primates
https://t.co/8Ao9TW7Nsf
Dec 9, 2023 · 3 likes · 5,510 followersView post →
@pcollier79c @Figment_Imagine @AugustineParzi1 @Chris48263851 @autocorrect2_0 No. DNA shows that populations of humans evolved out of shared ancestors with other primates. And beyond that to shared ancestors with ALL life on earth
https://t.co/SQWbAscYhw
Aug 30, 2023 · 2 likes · 5,510 followersView post →
@Thyzn22W @sanity1001 @freemonotheist “Beyond Reasonable Doubt: Evolution from DNA Sequences”
https://t.co/2z32gbhaRI
“Statistical evidence for common ancestry: Application to primates”
https://t.co/1e7yPxvVS4
@IDiseverywhere @TakeThatDarwin @TJaytheist @DianeRavitch @nobodyonit What’s funny is that it’s the complete opposite.
Beyond Reasonable Doubt: Evolution from DNA Sequences
https://t.co/2z32gbhaRI
Statistical evidence for common ancestry: Application to primates
https://t.co/1e7yPxvVS4
@Stripey @1karus_ @infinitemagnus1 @Ah_Science @TakeThatDarwin @billhowes747 Statistical evidence for common ancestry: Application to primates
https://t.co/1e7yPxvVS4
Beyond Reasonable Doubt: Evolution from DNA Sequences
https://t.co/2z32gbhaRI
@NullifyingGod @ScottyMcYachty @ICRscience Yes in fact this is STATISTICALLY supported.
https://t.co/iPMiIGfB81
https://t.co/VjUhwbre3k
Here’s my favorite quote from the first paper https://t.co/Reggjymnd4
@StephenCMeyer //We overwhelmingly rejected both species and family SA (separate ancestry) with infinitesimal P values. We compare these results with those from two companion papers, which also found tremendously strong support for the CA of all primates//
https://t.co/I0L3agPNaf
RT @MyassesDragon: Intelligent Design Website Attempts to Explain Primate Phylogeny https://t.co/5Zbs3xoZA3 via @YouTube
Jan 28, 2022 · 1 share · 4,152 followersView post →
M
MyassesDragon
@MyassesDragon · X
Intelligent Design Website Attempts to Explain Primate Phylogeny https://t.co/5Zbs3xoZA3 via @YouTube
Jan 27, 2022 · 1 like · 1 share · 708 followersView post →
HF
Hontas Farmer
@Hontas_Farmer · X
Intelligent Design Website Attempts to Explain Primate Phylogeny https://t.co/LvKLHDuPDI via @YouTube
Jan 26, 2022 · 1 like · 1,294 followersView post →
KT
KaRAYgeous TRANTIFA ☽☾
@kraywhiseheart · X
@Gutsick_Gibbon is making my brain bigger
Jan 26, 2022 · 1 like · 7,968 followersView post →
DE
Dr Theosib, CPU expert
@theosib2 · X
RT @theosib2: @OtangeloG @Alliste35661241 @ErichKays @Uncle_Grosstoes "It's impossible because some other creationists say so!"
You know w…
Jan 13, 2022 · 1 share · 1,412 followersView post →
DE
Dr Theosib, CPU expert
@theosib2 · X
@OtangeloG @Alliste35661241 @ErichKays @Uncle_Grosstoes "It's impossible because some other creationists say so!"
You know what's also impossible? Special creation.
Here's actual peer-reviewed research that shows this:
https://t.co/fR9ietOZte
Jan 13, 2022 · 1 like · 1 share · 1,412 followersView post →
DE
Dr Theosib, CPU expert
@theosib2 · X
@triggerman1976 @Empirical18 Homology makes a relationship more likely than not. In fast a LOT more likely. We can compute it.
See these two articles:
https://t.co/fR9ietOZte
https://t.co/hvDgGXCKye
@gabenorman13 @BilboUnbeliever @achilles1974 @JacksonWheat1 @lord_skeptic @The_Duginator @sygarte Here. If you can show how the math in this article has been done incorrectly, I'll consider believing creationist claims.
https://t.co/fR9ietOZte
Jan 6, 2021 · 4 likes · 1 share · 1,412 followersView post →
DE
Dr Theosib, CPU expert
@theosib2 · X
@achilles1974 @AmputeeAtheist @sygarte Here's one paper: https://t.co/fR9ietOZte
@Prophecy_YEC @norcalfather @ctuton1 @AiG So you accept that all life is related via common ancestry then?
https://t.co/SQWbAscYhw
https://t.co/VXEug9qd3N
@MatthewHudgins7 @hairybadger74 @mikewhiteatcj @Nat1Newf @yakityxax @TakeThatDarwin @MeMysel41161908 Come on. Let's look at the evidence
https://t.co/SQWbAscYhw
Too scared?
@slwn43 @BillyPhysics @RegTheDude @TruthOls @BilboUnbeliever @Ah_Science @AiG Common ancestry between humans and other primates isn't remotely in doubt
https://t.co/K5sDyFIZLY
https://t.co/SQWbAscYhw
May 24, 2020 · 1 like · 5,510 followersView post →
RD
Rulon James Downard
@RJDownard · X
@TakeThatEpi @AtyHans @maphosa_thabani @ScientiaPercept @ei9iw @matigary @nelsonchamisa @ShingiMunyeza @misscailah @Auzqn @ali_naka @nigelchanakira @MensaOtabil @NoScienceDenial Would that be https://t.co/FUbK1gYN0V from 2016?
May 9, 2020 · 2 likes · 3,604 followersView post →
Feb 24, 2020 · 2 likes · 5,510 followersView post →
NC
No Such Thing as Too Many Cycles
@TakethatCt · X
@ptjon68 @keep_it_K9 @mazola523 @GMA @20thcentury There are ZERO DNA studies that back this up. None whatsoever.
In fact quite the opposite
https://t.co/SQWbAscYhw
NC
DE
PG
AC
CV
KN
TP
BC
KR
KL
N
JN
JW
NH
DB
TB
RD
PF
SE