The discussions reveal a strong consensus that cognition is not limited to neural systems, with examples like cell signaling, bioelectricity, and evolutionary perspectives emphasizing the broad implications of the article. The tone is enthusiastic and exploratory, reflecting a keen interest in expanding traditional views of cognition.
AgreementStrong agreement
Most discussions strongly support the idea that cognition exists beyond brains, reflecting high agreement with the article's premise.
InterestHigh interest
Posts show strong curiosity and enthusiasm, indicating high interest in the concepts presented.
EngagementHigh engagement
Commenters reference specific examples, such as molecular mechanisms, cellular decision-making, and bioelectricity, demonstrating deep engagement.
ImpactHigh impact
Many posts highlight the transformative potential of recognizing cognition throughout biological systems, indicating high perceived impact.
Abstract in brief
The central nervous system (CNS) is key for memory and decision-making in organisms, but neural networks are not the only biological systems capable of signaling functions; many signaling processes predate the CNS in evolution and are used in cellular activities like development and behavior.
Different biological hardware, such as single-celled organisms, plants, and tissues, can implement cognitive processes like memory and learning through molecular mechanisms, highlighting the diversity of ways cognition can occur beyond neural networks.
Exploring cognition in non-neural systems is an interdisciplinary area with broad implications for understanding evolution, cell biology, medicine, and bioengineering, and it raises questions about how information processing can happen in biological systems without a brain.]
This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell swarms during morphogenesis) is inflationary. I do a careful argument about it here https://t.co/KdfLl7cUOP and here https://t.co/ipclSBzdRj, but
Feb 18, 2024 · 344 likes · 73 shares · 70,329 followersView post →
A
Anastasia
@demystifysci · X
First episode of 2022! A conversation with @drmichaellevin about the not-so-distant future where medicine is able to fix what is broken simply by knowing the languages and motivational structures of cells: https://t.co/rbAlXeuf0l
Jan 10, 2022 · 54 likes · 10 shares · 6,241 followersView post →
M
Misha
@drethelin · X
"On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems"
https://t.co/I5pVsln9Yj
This is the good shit right here. #EmbodiedCognition #neurology #biology
Aug 29, 2019 · 13 likes · 4 shares · 5,657 followersView post →
MJ
Micah Johnston
@micahrjohnston · X
On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems https://t.co/r23c0gUtsu https://t.co/Wlixm6kijh
Feb 4, 2022 · 11 likes · 1 share · 1,207 followersView post →
D
Djindji5
@djindji5 · X
Speaking with Cells: the Electrical Future of Regenerative Medicine with Dr. Michael Levin
Full video: https://t.co/8VWaZ13BQY https://t.co/1Gudb9W7Fa
Nov 3, 2023 · 7 likes · 2 shares · 2,340 followersView post →
ML
Michael Levin
@drmichaellevin · X
@GeorgeB_Green https://t.co/8FeX2MC7Bm and many similar reviews in the diverse intelligence literature - there are tons, from microbes and minimal active matter to cells, organs, swarms, colonies, etc.
Mar 30, 2023 · 6 likes · 70,329 followersView post →
Dr. Michael Levin discusses how bioelectric signals influence cell growth and regeneration, emphasizing the role of electrical communication in biological systems beyond neural networks, with implications for medicine…
The central nervous system is key for memory and decision-making, but many biological systems predate the CNS and perform cognitive functions through molecular mechanisms, broadening our understanding of cognition in…
References
Alevizos, P. D. (2018). Scatter-Radio Networks for IoT. IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications.
Baluška, F., & Levin, M. (2016). On having no head: Cognition throughout biological systems. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, 902.
Commey, D., et al. (2024). Securing
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 812 followersView post →
PJ
priya joseph
@ayirpelle · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 4,975 followersView post →
FS
For Yet Better Science
@ForYetBetterSci · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 863 followersView post →
AV
Adrienne Vancura
@AdrienneVancura · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 209 followersView post →
M
madison
@dearmadisonblue · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 2,729 followersView post →
WB
wjmccartan-Billy
@WilliamJMcCart7 · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 2,442 followersView post →
LG
language gamer
@davemotorcycle1 · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 662 followersView post →
SV
scott volk
@destician · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 64 followersView post →
PW
Princess Mat Waldie
@tminusmat · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 1,465 followersView post →
C
CybrMadHatter
@OCCUPYMARS2025 · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 2,216 followersView post →
Z
Zex
@MillePlateaux6 · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 95 followersView post →
CJ
Christopher Jensen
@ChrisMJ_73 · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 1,839 followersView post →
BN
Bears NW
@makayla7 · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 569 followersView post →
ا
ارهومه
@KaNakht__ · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 10,693 followersView post →
DS
Dale Schenck
@tocatchahacker_ · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 1,138 followersView post →
OM
Octavio Medina
@octavio_medina · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 5,172 followersView post →
BB
B. Branisa
@BBranisa · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 1,157 followersView post →
ON
Ovelha Negra
@fllamber · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 1,305 followersView post →
IP
Ian Timotheos Pilon
@IanTimotheos · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 592 followersView post →
BG
Bobby van Gilder
@mindnotnull · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 320 followersView post →
DL
Damon Lurie
@Damon_Lurie · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 559 followersView post →
B
Brock
@BrockMcKean · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 2,606 followersView post →
G
geistoooor
@geistoooor · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 298 followersView post →
WL
wayne lewis
@waynelforBernie · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 1,892 followersView post →
AA
augerd ⓧ augrd
@fearthewave_eth · X
RT @drmichaellevin: This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell…
Feb 18, 2024 · 73 shares · 3,215 followersView post →
ML
Michael Levin
@drmichaellevin · X
This thread https://t.co/UlF9cof7i1 discussed whether applying cognitive terms to things other than brains (e.g., cell swarms during morphogenesis) is inflationary. I do a careful argument about it here https://t.co/KdfLl7cUOP and here https://t.co/ipclSBzdRj, but
Feb 18, 2024 · 344 likes · 73 shares · 70,329 followersView post →
Speaking with Cells: the Electrical Future of Regenerative Medicine with Dr. Michael Levin
Full video: https://t.co/8VWaZ13BQY https://t.co/1Gudb9W7Fa
Nov 3, 2023 · 7 likes · 2 shares · 2,340 followersView post →
LC
Lionel Costes
@RLDI_Lamy · X
RT @theomitsa: On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems
https://t.co/U9dWQN2oyx
@enilev @JagersbergKnut @EstelaMandela
@…
Nov 3, 2023 · 2 shares · 18,195 followersView post →
E
Estrella
@EstelaMandela · X
RT @theomitsa: On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems
https://t.co/U9dWQN2oyx
@enilev @JagersbergKnut @EstelaMandela
@…
Nov 3, 2023 · 2 shares · 2,614 followersView post →
DM
Dr. Theophano Mitsa ☦️
@theomitsa · X
On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems
https://t.co/U9dWQN2oyx
@enilev @JagersbergKnut @EstelaMandela
@bimedotcom @KevinClarity @RLDI_Lamy
Nov 3, 2023 · 5 likes · 2 shares · 9,654 followersView post →
RC
reg challis
@RegChallis · X
Speaking with Cells: the Electrical Future of Regenerative Medicine with... https://t.co/E3km2sAg5G via @YouTube
@paredes916 @jonathanstea Everything is made of atoms. Except for dark matter, which we think exists because of our measurement of atoms. And since single cell organisms can have memory and make decisions, we're just larger. https://t.co/30zZdZFEv1
And answer the earth measurement question, please.
@AnnaCiaunica This has been thought before. In fact, once you see how cognition is not "thinking" but processing of information, then all of life is cognitive to one degree or another.
https://t.co/1kk0Ur3AW4
@leecronin There are many levels of intelligence exhibited in the plant and animal kingdoms already. Predicting your environment is a fitness trait; evolution selects for it. Intelligence is not mystical. It's a fundamental fact of life.
https://t.co/1kk0Ur3AW4
@GeorgeB_Green https://t.co/8FeX2MC7Bm and many similar reviews in the diverse intelligence literature - there are tons, from microbes and minimal active matter to cells, organs, swarms, colonies, etc.
Mar 30, 2023 · 6 likes · 70,329 followersView post →
NL
Nuno Luciano
@nunoluciano · X
New approaches to target the processes that implement anatomical decision-making without genetic engineering.
On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems
https://t.co/sUqfZpDvR5
RT @MikaelKrauze: Insightful open-access paper from František Baluška and @drmichaellevin on basal cognition and the value of an informatio…
Feb 6, 2023 · 1 share · 4,375 followersView post →
MT
Mikael Krauze - Telic Thoughts
@MikaelKrauze · X
Insightful open-access paper from František Baluška and @drmichaellevin on basal cognition and the value of an informational perspective over a mechanistic perspective. https://t.co/tcFwyRaHil
Feb 6, 2023 · 2 likes · 1 share · 761 followersView post →
釜
釜屋憲彦
@kamaUmwelt · X
memo.
Frontiers | On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems https://t.co/FlesoXmB4R
Jan 27, 2023 · 2 likes · 1,531 followersView post →
K
khellstr
@kHellstr · X
@MikeDonio What keeps life living. What drives life. As clearly it is not the genomics.
Also, how gravity works and what comes after Einsteins delusions are finally thrown away.
https://t.co/TlNHw8wVT8
Today's morning reading is about cognition without neurons: Baluška F and Levin M (2016) On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems https://t.co/0SUerEtTl0 https://t.co/oHDp6i7o5f
RT @demystifysci: First episode of 2022! A conversation with @drmichaellevin about the not-so-distant future where medicine is able to fix…
Jan 12, 2022 · 10 shares · 147 followersView post →
HL
Harikanth Lingutla
@harikanth_eth · X
@drmichaellevin
https://t.co/zeuLxu3ZXP
at 25:20 Dr. Levin says, we evolved to experience agencies outward but not at micro/nano timescales or levels.
Wonderful ideas all around. Do we as humans have ability to inward at nano levels/timescales but lost it ?
RT @demystifysci: First episode of 2022! A conversation with @drmichaellevin about the not-so-distant future where medicine is able to fix…
Jan 11, 2022 · 10 shares · 407 followersView post →
TB
Thomas O'Brien
@listenaddress · X
RT @demystifysci: First episode of 2022! A conversation with @drmichaellevin about the not-so-distant future where medicine is able to fix…
Jan 11, 2022 · 10 shares · 225 followersView post →
DS
Daniel of the Shire
@countrsignal · X
RT @demystifysci: First episode of 2022! A conversation with @drmichaellevin about the not-so-distant future where medicine is able to fix…
Jan 11, 2022 · 10 shares · 751 followersView post →
ME
Marcus van der Erve✨
@MarcusErve · X
RT @demystifysci: First episode of 2022! A conversation with @drmichaellevin about the not-so-distant future where medicine is able to fix…
Jan 11, 2022 · 10 shares · 2,094 followersView post →
PC
Postgenetic Code
@Postgenetic · X
RT @demystifysci: First episode of 2022! A conversation with @drmichaellevin about the not-so-distant future where medicine is able to fix…
Jan 11, 2022 · 10 shares · 201 followersView post →
ND
nessun dorma ☺️
@mmdr36 · X
RT @demystifysci: First episode of 2022! A conversation with @drmichaellevin about the not-so-distant future where medicine is able to fix…
Jan 11, 2022 · 10 shares · 600 followersView post →
WR
Will Ratcliff
@wc_ratcliff · X
RT @demystifysci: First episode of 2022! A conversation with @drmichaellevin about the not-so-distant future where medicine is able to fix…
Jan 11, 2022 · 10 shares · 8,475 followersView post →
ML
Michael Levin
@drmichaellevin · X
RT @demystifysci: First episode of 2022! A conversation with @drmichaellevin about the not-so-distant future where medicine is able to fix…
Jan 11, 2022 · 10 shares · 70,328 followersView post →
A
Anastasia
@demystifysci · X
First episode of 2022! A conversation with @drmichaellevin about the not-so-distant future where medicine is able to fix what is broken simply by knowing the languages and motivational structures of cells: https://t.co/rbAlXeuf0l
Jan 10, 2022 · 54 likes · 10 shares · 6,241 followersView post →
CC
CD Castillo
@sndlg · X
Insisto, sé que hablamos de eucariotas pequeños, pero parece descripción de los políticos de la actual administración federal.
On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems https://t.co/wOPGWPJTyh
@JRBneuropsiq @hildherlo Este artículo, desde mi punto de vista, describe de forma muy bonita los múltiples niveles de organización biológica y sugiere una perspectiva unificada de los sistemas cognitivos. https://t.co/fWVp6yFAhZ
@danbri @olcan The focused one is still being written, but pieces are in: https://t.co/f0z9S9OMKe
https://t.co/yWpa0MwFsb
https://t.co/27cRN5ZhIG
https://t.co/BM6CrVsK1g
https://t.co/ipclSBzdRj
https://t.co/p14Yviw86m
https://t.co/K095xgm4Ts
https://t.co/k4Zf7hbAPL
https://t.co/uGMXVfunFF
May 20, 2021 · 2 likes · 70,329 followersView post →
RL
Richard Lucas
@EpistemiclyRich · X
Excellent survey paper. At first it seems like it goes too far (everything is thinking!?), but once you look at the evidence, how else could plants and animals do so well?
https://t.co/1kk0Ur3AW4
New approaches to target the processes that implement anatomical decision-making without genetic engineering.
On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems
https://t.co/KiT7wE1jRt
RT @drethelin: "On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems"
https://t.co/I5pVsln9Yj
This is the good shit right here. #E…
Jun 27, 2020 · 4 shares · 5,657 followersView post →
M
Misha
@drethelin · X
RT @drethelin: "On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems"
https://t.co/I5pVsln9Yj
This is the good shit right here. #E…
Oct 14, 2019 · 4 shares · 5,657 followersView post →
MK
MΔ5K
@maskoficarus · X
RT @drethelin: "On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems"
https://t.co/I5pVsln9Yj
This is the good shit right here. #E…
Aug 30, 2019 · 4 shares · 1,363 followersView post →
M
Misha
@drethelin · X
"On Having No Head: Cognition throughout Biological Systems"
https://t.co/I5pVsln9Yj
This is the good shit right here. #EmbodiedCognition #neurology #biology
Aug 29, 2019 · 13 likes · 4 shares · 5,657 followersView post →
Z
zenrud
@ZenrudMB · X
On Having No Head: Cognition Throughout Biological Systems (2016) https://t.co/kC5WG7eVQa #Head #CognitionThroughoutBiologicalSystems
The Sentient Cell The Cellular Foundations of Consciousness | PDF ...
News
https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00902. Baluška, F. & Lyons, S. (2018a). Energide-cell body as smallest unit of eukaryotic life. Annals of Botany 122, 741 ...
-C., et al. biological systems. Front. Psychol. 7:902. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00902 (2007). Evidence for wavelike energy transfer through quantum coherence ...
The Computational Boundary of A "Self": Developmental ...
News
10:2688. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02688 Keywords: development, bioelectricity, gap ... doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00902. Arnellos, A., and Moreno, A. (2015) ...
Universal Organic Superintelligence Explained | PDF ...
News
biological systems. Frontiers in Psychology, 7, 902. [DOI:10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00902] ○ This paper discusses cognitive processes in non-neural organisms ...
Front. information processing in developmental and 18. Prindle A, Liu J, Asally M, Ly S, Garcia-Ojalvo J, Süel Psychol. 7, 902. (doi:10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00902)