The social discussions reflect a high level of interest, with references to advanced theories such as predictive processing and Bayesian models, and examples like Long Covid and FND being discussed as potentially explained by brain prediction errors. The tone varies from curiosity to cautious support, highlighting both the relevance and ongoing debates surrounding the article's implications.
AgreementModerate agreement
Most posts express curiosity and some support for the ideas in the publication, indicating moderate agreement, especially with ideas about symptom perception and predictive processing.
InterestHigh interest
Posts show high engagement and curiosity, referencing complex theories like predictive coding and discussing conditions like ME and Long Covid, demonstrating strong interest.
EngagementHigh engagement
Several comments actively analyze the article's concepts, question traditional views, and cite related research, indicating deep engagement.
ImpactModerate impact
Discussions suggest the publication influences current debates in medicine and psychology, though its direct impact on practice remains uncertain, hence moderate impact score.
Abstract in brief
The relationship between physical symptoms and objective physiological dysfunction is complex and can vary depending on individual characteristics, context, and interactions, often breaking down in cases of medically unexplained symptoms.
The paper reviews current theories explaining this relationship and introduces a new model based on predictive coding, which aims to unify and improve understanding of how symptoms relate to bodily processes.
This new framework helps clarify when symptoms are closely linked to physiological changes and when they diverge, offering potential insights for both research and clinical practice.]
The 6th theme, building upon themes 4 & 5, is that the science of PREDICTIVE PROCESSING, across sensorimotor and emotion domains, has been proposed to be IMPORTANT in the biology of #FND. Mark Edwards.
10.1093/brain/aws129
10.1016/j.neubiorev.2017.01.015
10.1093/brain/awac204 https://t.co/TEFfIDGTel
Jan 25, 2023 · 18 likes · 1 share · 4,392 followersView post →
D
DrLJ
@drlaurajane · X
Read more fascinating stuff on the relationship (or lack of) between the conscious experience of physical symptoms & indicators of objective physiological dysfunction from Prof Omer Van den Bergh https://t.co/2Bw230NyoR
#dyspnea2022
Jeg ble nysgjerrig på denne påstanden og tok en titt på den oppgitte kilden:
Van den Bergh et al. "Symptoms and the body: Taking the inferential
leap" (https://t.co/rUqparc13S) 4/
Det er ikke nødvendigvis sammenheng mellom fysiske symptomer og det som skjer i kroppen, spesielt når det gjelder symptomer som ikke kan forklares med vanlige tester #CFS #ME https://t.co/7GiZRAhlP6
Nov 24, 2023 · 1 like · 3,066 followersView post →
LL
Live Landmark
@Livelandmark · X
«Symptoms and the body» Må fysiske symptomer ha en fysiologisk årsak? https://t.co/7GiZRAhlP6
Nov 25, 2021 · 1 like · 3,066 followersView post →
LL
Love Your Lungs
@KingsResp · X
We can also use a pychological framework to describe & understand the disconnect between physiology & symptoms, using Bayesian theory & the concept of priors (expectations/previous experiences) https://t.co/omPAwH0wlr #RespEd #longread #breathlessness 9/ https://t.co/uFr8d4lZIe
Jul 16, 2022 · 1 like · 1,617 followersView post →
Becca Kennedy MD and Howard Schubiner MD explore how the brain influences our perception of symptoms, emotions, and reality, discussing the role of predictive coding in understanding bodily experiences and unexplained…
This presentation explores pain as an experience that goes beyond mere sensation. It examines the relationship between pain, attention, and interoceptive predictions, highlighting how these factors contribute to the…
This review cites the same paper (https://t.co/PcrDTpeuaA) as the infamous "Oslo chronic fatigue consortium" arguing Long Covid can be physiologically explained as brain prediction errors.
Asinine yes, nevertheless this group and idea has quite the traction across Scandinavia. https://t.co/DDzsly5NZW
Det er ikke nødvendigvis sammenheng mellom fysiske symptomer og det som skjer i kroppen, spesielt når det gjelder symptomer som ikke kan forklares med vanlige tester #CFS #ME https://t.co/7GiZRAhlP6
Nov 24, 2023 · 1 like · 3,066 followersView post →
JJ
Jakob Juhola
@s_jakke · X
Jeg ble nysgjerrig på denne påstanden og tok en titt på den oppgitte kilden:
Van den Bergh et al. "Symptoms and the body: Taking the inferential
leap" (https://t.co/rUqparc13S) 4/
The 6th theme, building upon themes 4 & 5, is that the science of PREDICTIVE PROCESSING, across sensorimotor and emotion domains, has been proposed to be IMPORTANT in the biology of #FND. Mark Edwards.
10.1093/brain/aws129
10.1016/j.neubiorev.2017.01.015
10.1093/brain/awac204 https://t.co/TEFfIDGTel
Jan 25, 2023 · 18 likes · 1 share · 4,392 followersView post →
LL
Love Your Lungs
@KingsResp · X
We can also use a pychological framework to describe & understand the disconnect between physiology & symptoms, using Bayesian theory & the concept of priors (expectations/previous experiences) https://t.co/omPAwH0wlr #RespEd #longread #breathlessness 9/ https://t.co/uFr8d4lZIe
Jul 16, 2022 · 1 like · 1,617 followersView post →
AH
Adam Lewis (He/Him)
@apl104 · X
RT @drlaurajane: Read more fascinating stuff on the relationship (or lack of) between the conscious experience of physical symptoms & indic…
Read more fascinating stuff on the relationship (or lack of) between the conscious experience of physical symptoms & indicators of objective physiological dysfunction from Prof Omer Van den Bergh https://t.co/2Bw230NyoR
#dyspnea2022