Curr Neurol Neurosci Rep August 2017 PMID 28656532

Current Controversies on Wernicke's Area and its Role in Language.

Jeffrey R Binder

Mentions

36
Peak: 15 in Jan 2020
across 3 sources since Dec 2019

Extended reach

779,445
potential audience

Total likes

13,630

Video views

499,028

Mentions per month

Dec 2019 – Apr 2024

Where it's discussed

  • X / Twitter32 posts
  • YouTube3 videos
  • Bluesky1 posts

AI synopsis

What people are saying

The discussions actively explore how recent findings challenge outdated notions of Wernicke's area, with comments like 'traditional concept is outdated' and references to broad neural networks involved in language. Words such as 'misconceptions' and 'disconnects' underscore a tone of correction and evolving understanding, reflecting strong interest in scientific advancement but a cautious view on immediate practical impact.

AgreementModerate agreement

Most discussions acknowledge that the traditional view of Wernicke's area as solely responsible for speech comprehension is outdated, reflecting a consensus shift supported by recent research.

InterestHigh interest

Posts show a strong curiosity about the complex functions of brain regions involved in language and neuroplasticity, with several highlighting misconceptions or new evidence.

EngagementModerate engagement

Many comments engage deeply with the neurobiological details, such as references to cortical networks, phonological processing, and neuroimaging, indicating thoughtful reflection.

ImpactModerate impact

While some discussions suggest the article may influence future research or clinical approaches, the overall perception is that it has a moderate impact rather than a groundbreaking one.

Abstract in brief

  • The study reviews historical and current understandings of Wernicke's area, highlighting that its anatomical location is typically the left posterior superior temporal gyrus and neighboring areas.
  • Recent evidence indicates that Wernicke's area is not essential for speech perception or understanding words; instead, it is involved in retrieving phonological forms used for speech production and short-term memory.
  • Neuroimaging studies show that language comprehension relies on a broad network across the temporal, parietal, and frontal regions, and the traditional concept of Wernicke's area as critical for speech understanding is now considered outdated.]

Top posts

Most liked on X and Bluesky
SciShow
@SciShow · X

Lingering misconceptions about our brains' "language centers" hamper our ability to effectively treat people who struggle to communicate. https://t.co/3juJGU0hpG https://t.co/Wj5WWrtHi2

Jan 27, 2020 · 21 likes · 4 shares · 115,460 followers View post →
SciShow
@SciShow · X

Sometimes when people have an impairment or disability, they don't seem to be able to acknowledge or experience it. And it's not that they're in denial. https://t.co/BCtDaslDPB https://t.co/uaJqeXWYn7

Dec 16, 2019 · 18 likes · 1 share · 115,460 followers View post →
Erik Middlebrooks, MD
@EMiddlebrooksMD · X

No discrete comprehension area. Wernicke aphasia results from damage to extensive cortical & subcortical networks around this area. Wernicke area related to phonological processing & leads to phonemic paraphasia without impairing word comprehension. 3/4 https://t.co/a0jmPSj0QW

Apr 2, 2023 · 10 likes · 2 shares · 8,419 followers View post →
Charles Ikenna
@CharlesIkenna23 · X

When Your Brain Can't Accept Reality: Anosognosia https://t.co/jhIOWTROdD via @YouTube

Dec 16, 2019 · 2 likes · 3,224 followers View post →
Malcolm Ocean 
@Malcolm_Ocean · X

Halfway thru this 6min video he notes that while patients overestimate their abilities, ignoring to absurd lengths paralysis of their own limbs, "some be more realistic when asked about someone else in their condition" https://t.co/KyibuvTBaG

Mar 14, 2020 · 1 like · 10,416 followers View post →
MentalChillness
@MentalChillin · X

When Your Brain Can't Accept Reality: Anosognosia https://t.co/jCSsTdUuNO via @YouTube

Dec 16, 2019 · 1 like · 2,078 followers View post →

All mentions

Dahved Malik Lillacale'nia
@DahvedLilly01 · X

When Your Brain Can't Accept Reality: Anosognosia https://t.co/fKhs279WuZ via @YouTube

Apr 29, 2024 · 45 followers View post →
Nicolin Hainc, MD
@nicolinHAINC · X

RT @EMiddlebrooksMD: No discrete comprehension area. Wernicke aphasia results from damage to extensive cortical & subcortical networks arou…

Apr 3, 2023 · 2 shares · 1,100 followers View post →
LDR
@ldr1020 · X

RT @EMiddlebrooksMD: No discrete comprehension area. Wernicke aphasia results from damage to extensive cortical & subcortical networks arou…

Apr 2, 2023 · 2 shares · 365 followers View post →
Erik Middlebrooks, MD
@EMiddlebrooksMD · X

No discrete comprehension area. Wernicke aphasia results from damage to extensive cortical & subcortical networks around this area. Wernicke area related to phonological processing & leads to phonemic paraphasia without impairing word comprehension. 3/4 https://t.co/a0jmPSj0QW

Apr 2, 2023 · 10 likes · 2 shares · 8,419 followers View post →
Jim Bloom
@jimmyroybloom · X

When Your Brain Can't Accept Reality: Anosognosia - YouTube https://t.co/IWmcknl7qP

Feb 26, 2023 · 2,428 followers View post →
Yuji Marutani | The Exiled Emperor
@YujiMarutani · X

When Your Brain Can't Accept Reality: Anosognosia https://t.co/bCzxlgirWd via @YouTube

Nov 3, 2022 · 1,577 followers View post →
Hammad
@AliHammadArtist · X

https://t.co/eAWw4KAQL6

Jul 16, 2022 · 470 followers View post →
3.M.O.H
@avery_day · X

When Your Brain Can't Accept Reality: Anosognosia https://t.co/BoczYqjBAh via @YouTube

Aug 16, 2021 · 1,412 followers View post →
Zero One
@ZeroOne33408052 · X

https://t.co/eafJCHxZoD

Jul 6, 2021 · 2,372 followers View post →
Gohsuke Takama
@gohsuket · X

( ¯−¯ )フーム "What We Often Get Wrong About the Brain's "Language Centers"" on YouTube - https://t.co/ybwC88t10L

Jul 7, 2020 · 2,988 followers View post →
Malcolm Ocean 
@Malcolm_Ocean · X

Halfway thru this 6min video he notes that while patients overestimate their abilities, ignoring to absurd lengths paralysis of their own limbs, "some be more realistic when asked about someone else in their condition" https://t.co/KyibuvTBaG

Mar 14, 2020 · 1 like · 10,416 followers View post →
Celine Signoret W
@Celinuchis90 · X

What We Often Get Wrong About the Brain's "Language Centers" https://t.co/FItP5fnjUf via @YouTube #PsiShow

Mar 11, 2020 · 1,215 followers View post →
จจจ
@sgj0nsea · X

https://t.co/G8VL3VMYsN

Jan 31, 2020 · 106 followers View post →
OP’s Terrifying Answer
@Deus_Ex_Human · X

Misconceptions about the Human Brain's "Language Centers" https://t.co/Pg9Lon1c22

Jan 29, 2020 · 1,481 followers View post →
Evan Wilhelms
@evanwilhelms · X

RT @SciShow: Lingering misconceptions about our brains' "language centers" hamper our ability to effectively treat people who struggle to c…

Jan 28, 2020 · 4 shares · 152 followers View post →
Gerardo G
@lggg78 · X

RT @SciShow: Lingering misconceptions about our brains' "language centers" hamper our ability to effectively treat people who struggle to c…

Jan 28, 2020 · 4 shares · 30 followers View post →
Simon Tombs
@tombssimon · X

RT @SciShow: Lingering misconceptions about our brains' "language centers" hamper our ability to effectively treat people who struggle to c…

Jan 28, 2020 · 4 shares · 212 followers View post →
Charles Ikenna
@CharlesIkenna23 · X

What We Often Get Wrong About the Brain's "Language Centers" https://t.co/6h5b1NMQxL via @YouTube

Jan 28, 2020 · 3,224 followers View post →
William Wallace
@bill14051 · X

RT @SciShow: Lingering misconceptions about our brains' "language centers" hamper our ability to effectively treat people who struggle to c…

Jan 27, 2020 · 4 shares · 340 followers View post →
João M
@nababu · X

Jan 27, 2020 · 569 followers View post →
Rev. Lunar @lunar@mas.to
@rev_lunar · X

Jan 27, 2020 · 97 followers View post →
SciShow
@SciShow · X

Lingering misconceptions about our brains' "language centers" hamper our ability to effectively treat people who struggle to communicate. https://t.co/3juJGU0hpG https://t.co/Wj5WWrtHi2

Jan 27, 2020 · 21 likes · 4 shares · 115,460 followers View post →
MentalChillness
@MentalChillin · X

What We Often Get Wrong About the Brain's "Language Centers" https://t.co/pycVSkqEHJ via @YouTube

Jan 27, 2020 · 2,079 followers View post →
Jim Rose
@JimRosenz · X

What We Often Get Wrong About the Brain’s “Language Centers” https://t.co/V3lGqreX88 https://t.co/SiaZDV0oWj

Jan 27, 2020 · 1,483 followers View post →
Elise Larsson
@EliseLarsson · X

When Your Brain Can't Accept Reality: #Anosognosia https://t.co/1noakwD0Yw via @YouTube

Jan 4, 2020 · 240 followers View post →
QUADRUPLE X
@NightbaneAUS · X

.@dpakman This might help connect a few dots about Trump's behaviour. Maybe his chopper talk, using the loud noises to help him focus, or his baffling denial of obvious events. Hope you find it interesting. #HappyNewYear

Jan 1, 2020 · 854 followers View post →
Real Skeptic
@RealSceptic · X

When Your Brain Can't Accept Reality: Anosognosia https://t.co/I5q6TG2efH

Dec 28, 2019 · 49 followers View post →
N. Petrenko
@npetrenko13 · X

When Your Brain Can't Accept Reality: Anosognosia https://t.co/9lDoUbnC18 via @YouTube

Dec 17, 2019 · 77 followers View post →
ivacheung.com
@ivacheung.com · Bluesky

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wt0q1xjEFgk

Dec 16, 2019 View post →
William Wallace
@bill14051 · X

RT @SciShow: Sometimes when people have an impairment or disability, they don't seem to be able to acknowledge or experience it. And it's n…

Dec 16, 2019 · 1 share · 340 followers View post →
SciShow
@SciShow · X

Sometimes when people have an impairment or disability, they don't seem to be able to acknowledge or experience it. And it's not that they're in denial. https://t.co/BCtDaslDPB https://t.co/uaJqeXWYn7

Dec 16, 2019 · 18 likes · 1 share · 115,460 followers View post →
MentalChillness
@MentalChillin · X

When Your Brain Can't Accept Reality: Anosognosia https://t.co/jCSsTdUuNO via @YouTube

Dec 16, 2019 · 1 like · 2,078 followers View post →
Charles Ikenna
@CharlesIkenna23 · X

When Your Brain Can't Accept Reality: Anosognosia https://t.co/jhIOWTROdD via @YouTube

Dec 16, 2019 · 2 likes · 3,224 followers View post →