Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
Several discussions critically analyze the quality of evidence cited in the publication, with posts highlighting the low reliability of studies on gender-affirming care, such as references to poor follow-up rates and high regret. Some use dismissive language like 'Bollocks' and question the ethical implications, indicating a highly skeptical tone. This mixture of concern and distrust emphasizes widespread doubts about the validity and impact of the publication's arguments.
Most discussions strongly question or outright dispute the publication's conclusions, citing low-quality evidence and potential harm, indicating disagreement with the article's implications.
@KBlgbNoT @MattWalshBlog Lol, yes. References like “body dysmorphia in adults” and “psychiatry’s ethical involvement in gender affirming care.” Classically unbiased works of “science.”
@ManiaWillim @kolektyw_labrys Przeczytaj sobie o jakości tych "badań". https://t.co/xF4j7054TW Powodzenia
@oolon @RunchieC @FromTipToToeXX As opposed to the findings of https://t.co/eZMkixgDqO https://t.co/lYsPgXYRro https://t.co/a24M6gIeun https://t.co/h7QXnb87C2
@eff_off_now @johnnyfrederix @endofpatriarchy @k8souphead @francesweetman @TullipR https://t.co/STX3MAymPa https://t.co/BFNWpfjUwt https://t.co/Ipg8T9cRk8 https://t.co/3C2uoiO7bE
@paul_wilson_nz @bwhVycwky56 @Daderp1242389 @amy_sargeant_ The 98% figure of very unreliable and comes from studies with very significant uncertainties. Huge numbers of non responders to studies and lack of active follow up make the whole field a bad joke. https://t.co/mURMdyH2up
@hauseoffunk @DerpyErika @TonyDiMeo1370 @BennieDotGay There's no evidence that gender affirming surgeries save lives. There's some evidence that undergoing gender affirming surgery increases risk of suicide. https://t.co/xF4j7054TW
This video discusses a study involving 100 individuals who transitioned due to gender dysphoria and later detransitioned. Key findings highlight reasons for detransition, including personal comfort and insufficient…
This video explores insights from a survey of 100 individuals who transitioned due to gender dysphoria and later opted to detransition. Key reasons for this decision include personal comfort and medical concerns…
This video explores a survey of 100 individuals who transitioned due to gender dysphoria and later detransitioned. It highlights key findings on the experiences and concerns surrounding medical transitions, emphasizing…
@TheSmallMadman @its_indianaTV @nyaraVT You are factually wrong on this... https://t.co/KMP5MrmjIb https://t.co/nmSjeViRjq https://t.co/DrKdA10a0E https://t.co/lxU8XaKAO4 https://t.co/1KA9xV8KA1 https://t.co/dyUEDBCAKj
@GreaterFireweed @AnonInclusive @Fudds13 Studies show 30-75% young dysphoric patients are lost to follow up; satisfaction rates are therefore skewed. Indeed it is likely these children desisted. https://t.co/URGD7lRhyH
RT @OZlzOpMaDTl0XQo: 死亡する可能性が19.1倍高いことが示された、と。 「Psychiatry’s ethical involvement in gender-affirming care」(2018)は、性同一性障害の理学療法に関する2005年以降の研…
死亡する可能性が19.1倍高いことが示された、と。 「Psychiatry’s ethical involvement in gender-affirming care」(2018)は、性同一性障害の理学療法に関する2005年以降の研究をMediline検索し分析、多くの患者が転帰が悪く、自殺の危険にさらされていると指摘。 https://t.co/SQCRB3cl4N
Psychiatry's ethical involvement in gender-affirming care Australasian Psychiatry Bulletin of Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists 26(5): 460-463 2018 ISSN/ISBN: 1440-1665 PMID: 29783857 https://t.co/kJoD8IUllv https://t.co/cZJi1gTmoU
@AveryOfBirds @panzieman @lesthecroc Here's just one. https://t.co/Ii5LUWoN2M
@nobrainworms @Forge_of_Angles @darkest_roasted @trundimolisher @MilkTeaIsabelle @TTExulansic I’m not trying To change your mind. And you aren’t going to change mine. We can go back and forth like this forever and never budge TIP Need HELP! Mental health help Not mangling their bodies Do what you want IDGAF https://t.co/3qrV5veAY0 https://t.co/k5gyQB5neA
@GTea30 @Thylittlehands [3]: infertility, micropenis, detrans/regret, as these should be obvious. As for the rest: -https://t.co/kOO8Z0Ykaz -https://t.co/VORPRldGP8 -https://t.co/Jh1JR3ueYz -https://t.co/hLVA0rlIPF -https://t.co/aA59zMdh0X -https://t.co/jW9nG0Js4h -etc...
@catteronii_ @TheWhiteOreo2 @TheJrbdog @powerfulwizerd https://t.co/sjrWFeW2Jn
@PUK161 @DrMariekedOuden @Magica08678935 "An Australian paper notes that many patients have poor outcomes, which put them at risk of suicide." Studie: https://t.co/LHkD2NnpEp
@hauseoffunk @DerpyErika @TonyDiMeo1370 @BennieDotGay There's no evidence that gender affirming surgeries save lives. There's some evidence that undergoing gender affirming surgery increases risk of suicide. https://t.co/xF4j7054TW
@oolon @RunchieC @FromTipToToeXX As opposed to the findings of https://t.co/eZMkixgDqO https://t.co/lYsPgXYRro https://t.co/a24M6gIeun https://t.co/h7QXnb87C2
@ManiaWillim @kolektyw_labrys Przeczytaj sobie o jakości tych "badań". https://t.co/xF4j7054TW Powodzenia
@NykaraNizri @connie_war69582 @TheR33f @speakoutsister With regards to regret after transition the loss to follow up is so huge, that we do not even know what we don't know https://t.co/xF4j7054TW The 80% is a rate of natural resolution of gender dysphoria without any intervention https://t.co/zHp23KLK8K I'd strongly suggest that https://t.co/4CEeiYpzy4
@ABillionSuns @gigilarue4 @WnukPaul @LeorSapir D’Angelo, R. (2018). Psychiatry’s ethical involvement in gender-affirming care. Australasian Psychiatry 26 (5): 460-463. American Journal of Psychiatry (2020). Correction to Bränström and Pachankis. Published online: 1 August 2020.
@litztsong @MonarchBiden @JusticeLibert19 @InsaneCope In statsforgender page they have the sources with links to studies like this: https://t.co/b4iRp4dLuy
@becca_begotten @Nataleo71379448 Low quality is meaningful. It tells us that your conclusions aren’t based on any reliable evidence. Here’s a 2018 study showing similar findings. Notable is that trans identified people are overwhelmingly mentally ill. https://t.co/9XVFbBYM0n
@DrownedMarzanna @klosu2002 @zoha_phaguette O negatywnym wpływie tranzycji społecznej: https://t.co/aH2ttnp7kb O negatywnym wpływie wiązania piersi: https://t.co/Xxbw4WZbIS O kiepskiej jakości dowodach naukowych na jakiekolwiek korzyści tranzycji medyczniej: https://t.co/xF4j7054TW https://t.co/xF4j7054TW
@paul_wilson_nz @bwhVycwky56 @Daderp1242389 @amy_sargeant_ The 98% figure of very unreliable and comes from studies with very significant uncertainties. Huge numbers of non responders to studies and lack of active follow up make the whole field a bad joke. https://t.co/mURMdyH2up
@adhayeladim @KnessetT @GadiTaub1 @polly_bronstein קודם כל באמת שאין לכם סיבה להיעלב. אני רק מנסה לבין יותר את הנושא ובמקרה פספסתי את השרשור. שנית, אשמח לשמוע מה לגבי המחקרים האלה שחקרו סיכיי מוות והתאבדות לאחר התעקבות רפואית: https://t.co/xZ9P0hMCu7 https://t.co/IAuiuEHzr6 https://t.co/L9GQ5y7dWk https://t.co/GT6PoR7wFz
@ConnorLillis @RobProvince @kara_kirsten @RepDanCrenshaw So many showing the harm that follows. Either due to not treating the actual, underlying cause/s of the issues in the first place, due to complications from procedures, etc. https://t.co/PQ58WnLAMy https://t.co/YPV4f4XAo9
@Schmaniel @tazerface43 @prof_curiosity1 @rizpossnett [2] Zucker, K.J., Lawrence, A.A., Kreukels, B.P. (2016). Gender Dysphoria in Adults. Annu Rev Clin Psychol. 12: 217-47. [Link] [3] D’Angelo, R. (2018). Psychiatry’s ethical involvement in gender-affirming care. Australasian Psychiatry 26 (5): 460-463. [Link]
@cort_dizzle @JandJDad @iamthemayer @EdKrassen Similarly, an Australian paper [3] notes that many patients have poor outcomes, which puts them at risk of suicide. Source studies: [2] https://t.co/93Bt7JruVX [3] https://t.co/p2J6gXGVq2 3/3
@KBlgbNoT @MattWalshBlog Lol, yes. References like “body dysmorphia in adults” and “psychiatry’s ethical involvement in gender affirming care.” Classically unbiased works of “science.”
@eff_off_now @johnnyfrederix @endofpatriarchy @k8souphead @francesweetman @TullipR https://t.co/STX3MAymPa https://t.co/BFNWpfjUwt https://t.co/Ipg8T9cRk8 https://t.co/3C2uoiO7bE
@Zoe_Brain @MinModulation Also, it is disputed by doctors, too. https://t.co/Waab2APDIj
@NotJames66 @MinModulation Here you go. I looked it up especially for you ❤️ https://t.co/Waab2APDIj
@theSelfishMan @heyitsnatalie00 @Lila_333000 @RazorsharpG96 @Eric_Biggz @DeificDragon @patriotjism @jk_rowling @VaushV This one notes that many patients have poor outcomes, which puts them at risk of suicide. https://t.co/7KRVzfX7a5
@AsInTheJar @SalwayBrewer @almay292 @BramhamAlex So, no postgrad study. "Research through data" ... Bollocks. Just talk us through one study I've cited for you. Explain how it fails, or is irrelevant, as you see it. https://t.co/tBfxsRxIev https://t.co/H0UtTK5Ife
@RohanIrvine @comingupcharlie @exfundyfeminist An Australian paper states that most available evidence indicating positive outcomes for gender reassignment is of poor quality. https://t.co/otJYCAEp35
@WeepingRoses93 @CTVNews "Similarly, an Australian paper notes that many patients have poor outcomes which put them at risk of suicide." D’Angelo, R. (2018). Psychiatry’s ethical involvement in gender-affirming care. Australasian Psychiatry 26 (5): 460-463.
@Random_Neuro123 @doug_lee42 https://t.co/C3EZyP9lA8 I paid for this, but the references are all accessible, so PLEASE DO YOUR RESEARCH before calling people Nazis when you are involved in a fascist cult. Psychiatry’s ethical involvement in gender-affirming care
An Australian paper [1] states that most available evidence indicating positive outcomes for gender reassignment is of poor quality. https://t.co/LbTg1UGfs1
@Dystopusa @chuckschmurda @MattWalshBlog https://t.co/N7Xase8tj3
@Dystopusa @chuckschmurda @MattWalshBlog 2. It is not known whether they also have good outcomes, or whether they have not been helped or indeed harmed, and most concerning, it is generally not known whether they are alive or dead.” https://t.co/N7Xase8tj3
@estherbeeee @uuuomo Bei Erwachsenen: https://t.co/Ub7bM8RuaS https://t.co/O2i8qkQvmK https://t.co/TdUSV9xmeQ
@bigbd1978 @AidanCTweets @SakuraNoSeirei @Henriettaspoon @setoacnna @jonronson @anitambyrne D’Angelo, R. (2018). Psychiatry’s ethical involvement in gender-affirming care.[online] Australasian Psychiatry. Available at: https://t.co/Z7bnDJE07b
T
ML
NS
SW
A
H
BM
布
E
MM
S
LP
DB
F
LG
EC
R
M
BV
MM
FT
JM
R
AH
PL
L
J
J
J
N
SM