Multiple discussions emphasize that recent scientific evidence confirms fish feel pain, with examples like Lynne Sneddon’s work and references to studies showing behavioral and physiological responses. The tone is analytical and assertive, underscoring the research's influence on scientific and ethical debates about fish welfare.
AgreementStrong agreement
Most discussions clearly support the idea that fish experience pain, citing scientific evidence and expert opinions, indicating a high level of agreement.
InterestHigh interest
Participants show strong interest by referencing recent studies, highlighting the significance of this research, and discussing evolutionary implications.
EngagementHigh engagement
Many comments analyze the mechanisms of nociception and compare fish to mammals, demonstrating a deep level of engagement.
ImpactHigh impact
The overall tone emphasizes the importance of recognizing fish pain for animal welfare and scientific understanding, suggesting substantial impact on perspectives and policies.
Abstract in brief
Fish have the ability to detect harmful stimuli through nociceptive mechanisms, which are essential for their survival and avoiding injury.
Research shows that the biological and behavioral responses to pain in fish are very similar to those in mammals, indicating an evolutionary conservation of pain mechanisms.
Behavioral changes in fish, such as reduced activity and abnormal movements after potentially painful events, suggest that fish likely experience pain, and these responses are affected by pain-relieving drugs.
@PSYKO_BAER @selenagomez Ok I read the paper, its best argument is lack of cerebral cortex that he says is "fundamental for the awareness of sensory stimuli."
Convergent evolution may lead species with distinct evolutionary paths to develop dissimilar neural systems that serve https://t.co/VoxxUDbm43
Mar 7, 2023 · 38 likes · 4 shares · 21,547 followersView post →
P
PAZ
@paz_zoopolis · X
LES POISSONS RESSENTENT LA DOULEUR DE LA MÊME FAÇON QUE LES MAMMIFÈRES
Cf. @LynneUSneddon, Evolution of nociception and pain: evidence from fish models, 23.09.2019
https://t.co/C2hmBJlpKg https://t.co/cgZuwJ05gG
Feb 18, 2021 · 32 likes · 7 shares · 9,398 followersView post →
T
Tay
@BioTay · X
Revisión de las evidencias de experiencia de dolor en peces. El dolor puede alterar el comportamiento de los peces por largo tiempo, dominando su atención (no es solo una respuesta automática/inmediata; paper) https://t.co/KKuvk6iKVN (blog) https://t.co/vE1x7g0Mqq
This video addresses five widespread myths about animal consumption in vegan debates, clarifying misconceptions based on false information and natural arguments. It emphasizes ethical considerations and promotes…
This video delves into the fascinating world of quantum entanglement. It explores its significance in quantum mechanics and technology, highlighting real-world applications and implications for our understanding of the…
@heisbwidnwoan @ItsSteveMiner69 Well firstly I’ll go with the fact that the sturgeon is essentially dry drowning since they can’t breathe out of water.
Secondly, fish feel pain https://t.co/JegyTI3zM1
Dec 24, 2023 · 3 likes · 58,440 followersView post →
FI
Florence Dellerie (compte inactif)
@FlorenceDell · X
Nov 20, 2023 · 16 likes · 9,398 followersView post →
C
Claud
@spectrodreams · X
@LoughribiYahya @christheyouth @kandiiXkitten @success1st_ all animals can feel pain. pain receptors are called nociceptors and all animals have them. https://t.co/2GHGLCVUth.
@BadKKarma_ @earth2abii @VlRGOJAY23 @txlightskin @success1st_ This study came 5 years after the study you linked
The general consensus these days is "fish do feel pain, just not in the way humans feel pain" https://t.co/tUJ6fC8ydo
@PSYKO_BAER Ok I read the paper, its best argument is lack of cerebral cortex that he says is "fundamental for the awareness of sensory stimuli."
Convergent evolution may lead species with distinct evolutionary paths to develop dissimilar neural systems that serve https://t.co/VoxxUDbm43
@PSYKO_BAER @selenagomez Ok I read the paper, its best argument is lack of cerebral cortex that he says is "fundamental for the awareness of sensory stimuli."
Convergent evolution may lead species with distinct evolutionary paths to develop dissimilar neural systems that serve https://t.co/VoxxUDbm43
Mar 7, 2023 · 38 likes · 4 shares · 21,547 followersView post →
We also have #PEER #reviewed fresh research that #sharks very quickly learn to #RETURN to areas they know will be #baited..
#Trophy #Shark #hunting is a ticking time bomb for ANY West Aussie ocean user.
@410fredo @ChadNotChud @evilevilevil_ @veganunabomber @lucisevs this paper on nociception in fish (which as a side note also concludes there is ample evidence that fish feel pain) uses zebra fish and rainbow trout as representative of teleosts
https://t.co/0feXoKAfBo https://t.co/YkE05Jbbrt
@Holofernes334 @LeducMathurin @Sylvain__Pacte https://t.co/1h4aWg30g8
https://t.co/HCmgjbH4xb (étude en question confirmant l'existence de douleur(s) chez les poissons : https://t.co/xGAJXbm1X6)
Bien que certains contredisent ce positionnement, ils sont aujourd'hui minoritaires dans le monde académique/scientifique
Jul 20, 2022 · 1 like · 212,730 followersView post →
R
Relic
@The_Only_Cross · X
@A_Frayed_Mind @CosmicSkeptic https://t.co/RUZ13ckHGg
This is one of a few good studies suggesting fish do feel pain. At least from what I've seen, studies trying to suggest the opposite only say why our idea that they feel pain may be wrong, rather than proving that they're right.
@BeardedHeretic_ @philipmuller @RenTheAngelic @answersinreason so it would appear that fish do show behavioural modification due to pain stimuli and the fact that the behaviour is reversed by pain relieving medication suggests some fish do indeed feel conscious pain and not just nociception
https://t.co/bhe9VD3xVU
@oraljoy0 En tapant études scientifiques sur la souffrance des poissons vous en trouverez pleins. Mais si vous ne voulez pas chercher, voici la dernière en date (en anglais par contre) mais il y en a d'autres : https://t.co/rzdV025ktu
Selon une récente revue de la littérature scientifique, il est désormais avéré que les poissons ressentent la douleur, et qui plus est, de façon très similaire à la nôtre.
source: https://t.co/O6zibRB2TP https://t.co/uUvDyOLTG7
El original https://t.co/mFXq70UF1q @jjschmittersoto aunque me causa un poco incertidumbre l concluyen: The empirical evidence in fish demonstrates pain-related behaviours are conserved across vertebrates, with more research needed in invertebrates to investigate....
@JesuisPecheur @ZAD_PARTOUT @MishaRome @RichardFerrand @C_Najdovski "Chez nous un piercing ne fait pas mal" : en fait, vous ne comprenez toujours pas la définition du CONSENTEMENT ?
Études sur la souffrance des poissons :
https://t.co/4sNAyrzMNJ
https://t.co/tUyZZ8BGu8
https://t.co/nKAWrTzaAz
https://t.co/nrzaDe3Q1c
@BarreOlivier1 @AriaMath1 @Le_dauphinois64 @ParisZoopolis @Decathlon Bonjour Monsieur, en réponse à votre interrogation, oui, les poissons ressentent la douleur. Nombreuses études scientifiques l’ont prouvé des années auparavant. Je vous joins un article très intéressant. Bien à vous.
https://t.co/HjlNZWpA6i
@InamoratoC @soy_milk_latte_ @pippa_marshall "Studies in fish have shown...the nociceptive system is... strikingly similar to that found in mammals. Further, potentially painful events result in behavioural and physiological changes...which are all prevented by the use of pain-relieving drugs." https://t.co/ZhzxHpUAEB
¿Los peces sienten dolor al igual que los mamíferos e incluso los seres humanos?
Evolution of nociception and pain: evidence from fish models | Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences https://t.co/36J8GbPcS7
RT @FlorenceDell: - @LynneUSneddon Evolution of nociception and pain: evidence from fish models, 23.09.2019 : https://t.co/pxIbUbcUaH
Mar 29, 2020 · 2 shares · 3,224 followersView post →
CC
Chapi & Chapo
@ChapiEtChapo · X
RT @FlorenceDell: - @LynneUSneddon Evolution of nociception and pain: evidence from fish models, 23.09.2019 : https://t.co/pxIbUbcUaH
Mar 28, 2020 · 2 shares · 1,781 followersView post →
FI
Florence Dellerie (compte inactif)
@FlorenceDell · X
- @LynneUSneddon Evolution of nociception and pain: evidence from fish models, 23.09.2019 : https://t.co/pxIbUbcUaH
Mar 28, 2020 · 8 likes · 2 shares · 9,398 followersView post →
CB
Colin Bean
@ProfColinBean · X
Evolution of nociception and pain: evidence from fish models | Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences https://t.co/iVBklSwITR
Kalad tunnevad valu ning reageerivad sellele, sarnaselt imetajatega @LynneUSneddon #animalresesrch #animalwelfare #3Rs
https://t.co/XKUNlzixiO https://t.co/hYovVRQrCW
İkinci çalışma ise İngiltere Liverpool Üniversitesi @LivUni profesörü @LynneUSneddon ‘ın kaleminden. Bu yazıda farklı balık türlerinin de memeliler gibi acı karşısında benzer fizyolojik ve davranışsal belirtiler sergilediği tartışılıyor. https://t.co/7uSqaEocmf
Peixes sentem dor, mostra estudo publicado no Philosophical Transactions of Royal Society B. A suposta ausência de dor dos peixes não pode mais ser uma desculpa para comê-los.
O estudo, é claro, chegou a essa conclusão torturando p…https://t.co/FTubI4oK3B https://t.co/A53zfBifS5
RT @LynneUSneddon: What can fishes tell us about the evolution of pain in animals - read all about it published in Philosophical Transactio…
Oct 4, 2019 · 14 shares · 3,358 followersView post →
NB
Nathalie Boulogne
@NatBoulogne · X
Résumé
"Afin de survivre, les animaux doivent éviter les blessures et être capables de détecter des stimuli potentiellement nocifs via des mécanismes nociceptifs. Si la blessure est accompagnée d'une composante... https://t.co/FEZrxoSDQ0
Revisión de las evidencias de experiencia de dolor en peces. El dolor puede alterar el comportamiento de los peces por largo tiempo, dominando su atención (no es solo una respuesta automática/inmediata; paper) https://t.co/KKuvk6iKVN (blog) https://t.co/vE1x7g0Mqq
@Sciences_Avenir @sciencemagazine @NatGeoFrance @SciencePost_fr [L’étude à découvrir] 23/09 > Une preuve de l’évolution de la #nociception et de la #douleur chez les #poissons https://t.co/xpRNw3VHGr via @royalsociety #LaMethSci
Sep 27, 2019 · 1 like · 1 share · 57,514 followersView post →
IC
Isabel Fife-Cook
@IsabelFifeCook · X
RT @LynneUSneddon: Pain in fish in the news! https://t.co/DwaltnLVrk Taken from the Philosophical Transactions @RSocPublishing publication…
A Functional Role for an Opiate System in Snail Thermal Behavior ...
News
https://doi.org/10.1098/rstb.2019.0290 · Crossref. Sarah Pellett,; Michelle O'Brien,. Exoskeleton Repair in Invertebrates, Veterinary Clinics of North America ...
#Karen Harasses Fishermen for catching shark : r/LivestreamFail
Reddit
... 10.1098/rstb.2019.0290. Here's a study on nociceptors in fish. This is stressful and painful for the shark. [deleted]. • 6y ago. sounds gay and ...
DH
P
FI
T
BC
HR
ᵀ
G
JC
V
C
BM
P
RC
S
SS
SE
SM
HO
JH
SW
R
LE
R
G
AO
AB
R
GE
LG
V
LF
LS
AG
CC
AH
IV
SK
T
Aᕗ
VI
G
L
CB
EE
ƟE
ET
SM
SM
NB
CN
SB
B
DS
G
RL
M
F
Y
RR
L
DD
E
ES
ID
H
SV
V
MV
SM
KE
BC
DL
P
SM
VB
C
AW
RP
LN
JM
W
FC
SG
ID
IE
ZL
H
AN
GS
D
HE
MB
R
LC
IC
FM
RP
マ世
N
K
CD
AV
S
MA
AS
JK
CB