Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
The discussions reflect a range of sentiments, from skepticism about the validity of the research, as seen in posts accusing it of being pseudoscience, to supportive comments highlighting the importance of recognizing transgender children's identities from a young age. Phrases like 'trans kids already know who they are as early as 3' and references to the 'extraordinary complexity of sex determination' showcase a mix of enthusiasm and criticism. The word choices and the tone, with some being confrontational while others appeal to scientific grounding, shape the overall discourse around the article significantly.
There is a mix of supportive and critical views towards the publication, showing a divided opinion.
Many users demonstrate high curiosity about the findings and discuss their implications, showing that the topic resonates strongly.
While participants share opinions, few delve deeply into the methodologies or specifics of the study itself.
There is a perception that the article's findings could have moderate impact in discussions on gender identity, though this is debated.
@MichealConraoi @NBCNews @LetToysBeToys @letclothesbe @LetBooksBeBooks You should have a read of that paper. It's a pile of nonsense. They showed pictures of just 4 toys to kids - they say 1 was a doll bit I can't see that they what the others were. They are basing their conclusions on this & other similarly sloppy criteria. https://t.co/yHhocLEJfo
@mybeautifulneed @crab_rare @BarnabyJDixon @SashaLPC Let's see what science says about children and gender identity "Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development | PNAS" https://t.co/6Clq67JbnH
Full academic research paper “Similarity in Transgender and Cisgender Children’s Gender Development” for reference ➡️ https://t.co/QnawE8qNcJ
@kamahara_lito @DanannOficial La identidad de género es un aspecto básico de la identidad que se desarrolla a edad temprana con personas cis o no-trans. Las personas trans no son una excepción a eso. https://t.co/HsQKbX0X4f https://t.co/k8BCgjLHkU
@ivanmkurnia @cIickbanget Ah, yes, you are right. Toddler. Haha. And trans kids already know who they are as early as 3 y.o. Trans kids are also focused on learning about the characteristics of their gender, a different gender with their assigned one since early ages. https://t.co/FrmW5LHZKo
You’ll find evidence in the scholarly research which clearly shows trans children know who they are as early as non-trans kids, and believe it as strongly as their friends who aren’t transgender. https://t.co/FXsOU3tvF0 https://t.co/ul4mW4tRGM
Welcome to The Dialog Show, a weekly debate and discussion podcast. This episode addresses whether elementary school students should learn about sex and gender. The discussion features prominent political streamers…
@bentichy @grok @Juliesnark1731 PNAS clearly has a liberal bias, and is onboard with pseudoscience. There are no transgender children. Take note gullible leftists. https://t.co/5A7xfYL5wY
@saltyoldbag 12. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/c3AjgwKZL5 13. Similarity in transgender and cîsgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/ia4NWdYPdu I'll be waiting for you to show any issues in ANY of these!
@Ferno9 @Pantera_pe @lalunaenlibra Desarrollo infantil y persistencia de la identidad trans Olson, K. R., (2019). Gender identity 5 years after social transition. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 116(52), 26714–26716. https://t.co/5EqAnAvuws
@CabezaCascabel todo esto lo saqué de acá, ta todo en inglés https://t.co/wVNsCMGNhL https://t.co/eBwdd9Qfcq https://t.co/eQyuT08Rxo
@DanyestuDIOS @RocioInfantesb https://t.co/KUiuMVCsWt https://t.co/lR2KqlwBnb https://t.co/VVHks16iuV O de qué punto en particular? Hay varios artículos, estudios y revisiones. Usa el método científico, el análisis y la comparación para refutar esto, no intento convencerte, duda.
@MunkusLunkus @shogglastresort @mittaposting 12. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/c3AjgwKZL5 13. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/ia4NWdYPdu This is fun!
@LadyLaurk 12. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/c3AjgwKZL5 13. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/ia4NWdYPdu
@Anisogamyrules 12. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/c3AjgwKZL5 13. Similarity in transgender and cîsgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/ia4NWdYPdu
https://t.co/cMg5J8BmKr
@steelhandgod 13. Similarity in transgender & cîsgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/FlpxySClFm 14. Transgender, intersex, & gender NC people #WontBeErased by pseudoscience: https://t.co/hegKj9y3DD 15. The idea of two sexes is simplistic: https://t.co/GmG1w8ZNYT
@TotoffromParis @NoShirleyNo @GothicNumpty @sartay2001 @ArtFromTheShed @gracebrod1e Oh wow more! 12. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/MQVkcMkiwk… 13. Similarity in transgender and císgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/rjC1S9DviV… Lololol and you have NOTHING dawg. Stay deluded.
https://t.co/1RygkUVInN https://t.co/JOA446FxGG https://t.co/gXobhVI5ox https://t.co/uP5QVV2bQg https://t.co/ya5uG4pnra https://t.co/Yr0q9VEbpD https://t.co/XKlE1zfUwr https://t.co/8k7u1xW48u https://t.co/zmaVl9st2o https://t.co/oYN7LUoUay
RT @KirstiMiller30: You’ll find evidence in the scholarly research which clearly shows trans children know who they are as early as non-tra…
You’ll find evidence in the scholarly research which clearly shows trans children know who they are as early as non-trans kids, and believe it as strongly as their friends who aren’t transgender. https://t.co/FXsOU3tvF0 https://t.co/ul4mW4tRGM
@OliLondonTV You’ll find evidence in the scholarly research which clearly shows trans children know who they are as early as non-trans kids, and believe it as strongly as their friends who aren’t transgender. https://t.co/FXsOU3tvF0
@sainte_electre Explication de sa par exemple ? https://t.co/lKsi2kEutX
@Luintas @sainte_electre On parle de généraliter, et dans la plus grand étude réalisée avec des enfants trans ou observe qui ont des similarité de comportement avec les cis malgré la diff du sex qui leurs et assimilés à la naissance https://t.co/lKsi2kDWEp
@Pivan82 @Cinemelodic https://t.co/fx8gEtuLUk Esta en inglés pero espero que con ayuda de un traductor te pueda ser de utilidad.
@Eduardo78478021 https://t.co/BbwMayfIeh
@NoRedText @Studio2Paw @NicotineLozeng @lecanardnoir @protraviso @FrancaisFarage "The similarity between the transgender group and the cisgender comparison groups was apparent not only in the means but in the distributions, with all groups displaying variability in responses." Similarity in transgender and cisgender children's gender development, Gulgoz, 2019
@AriaALake @Shelleybe3 @JanuaryJames Study measures "trans identities" of kids as young as 3 in terms of color and toy preferences. https://t.co/DcoP6uYzyw
@GordoDan_ @migangnoguera nada de lo que decis, está fundado, nunca. https://t.co/FOnrWiTnRC
https://t.co/BbwMayfaoJ
@RockenLima @JonaBcr @_DystopianGirl_ https://t.co/BbwMayfaoJ
@narkhokommunist zienzia Male-to-female transsexuals have female neuron numbers https://t.co/zISmNNxttF Transgender brains are more like their desired gender from an early age https://t.co/rENrK0aCO5 Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development https://t.co/uJ10oCzLJy
@alejodeividy @HispaLibertario @juancamiloredi @VerdESAColores @AlcaldiaDeCali @alejoeder @MauroToroO @CaroGiraBo @AlejoGarciaRios @AngelicaLozanoC @PartidoVerdeCoL @CancimanceL @tamaraargote @Caribeafirmativ @LuisCarlosLealA @davalho 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/shzuWB7EsF 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/Y5GjG8uc5Z
@ChrisFourOhFour Their scientists are saying it too: "transgender boys .. favored stereotypically masculine toys and clothes, and preferred to be friends with boys." https://t.co/DcoP6uYzyw
@Venezolhadita @Anagendermore @PalacioPep50106 @RafaelRCTS @MariaVFH https://t.co/zvFaJIrTd2
@DuxfortDooberry @legaltweetz Like this. It’s easy. Unless you can’t
@Susy_M_M @LefrankRivera @teresacastellmx https://t.co/zvFaJIrTd2
@GusMtz79714867 @QarlosCDMX @teresacastellmx @ThePosieParker 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/shzuWB7EsF 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/Y5GjG8uc5Z
@Nandi_vegan @_MariaFatal @maxpumpkin_ @ReduxxMag @ReduxxMagEs 12: Similitud de desarrollo de genero en niños cis y transexuales: https://t.co/a9DvaZODb7... 13: Las personas transexuales, transgenero y no conforme que son genero: https://t.co/B71ABhwvDi
@Nievessebastia1 @_MariaFatal @Nandi_vegan @maxpumpkin_ @ReduxxMag @ReduxxMagEs 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/a9DvaZODb7... 15. Transgender, intersex, and gender non-conforming people #WontBeErased by pseudoscience: https://t.co/B71ABhwvDi
@ElenaCataln4 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/a9DvaZODb7... 15. Transgender, intersex, and gender non-conforming people #WontBeErased by pseudoscience: https://t.co/B71ABhwvDi
@Varg_Vikernes79 @meztliunchained @_MariaFatal @Nandi_vegan @maxpumpkin_ @ReduxxMag @ReduxxMagEs 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/a9DvaZODb7... 15. Transgender, intersex, and gender non-conforming people #WontBeErased by pseudoscience: https://t.co/B71ABhwvDi
@meztliunchained @Varg_Vikernes79 @_MariaFatal @Nandi_vegan @maxpumpkin_ @ReduxxMag @ReduxxMagEs 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/8YQc8RBTFC 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/a9DvaZPb0F...
@luceroDlapaz @CaroCarisima https://t.co/zvFaJIrTd2
@karlylawyer @HollowDelta_ https://t.co/zvFaJIrTd2
@DefAMustRead @KatyMontgomerie No, we don't really have evidence for that being the case. I haven't seen any research showing this to be true, even when I've read papers from anti-trans academics. This study seems to disprove that hypothesis :https://t.co/OP3EsZqPTt
@E_A_A_D_L_O @CualquieraOnvre @erika2268275806 @ser_mordaz https://t.co/zvFaJIrTd2
@RedPillMayan @Dead_Euronymous @BimagoElCinico https://t.co/zvFaJIrTd2
@RafaelV_Abs @josue30891352 @LuisGuiSan @SoyLexMex https://t.co/zvFaJIrTd2
@Spartan992jaime @LuisGuiSan @IvanJak14 @HellagoodBby @SantiagoRomanD7 https://t.co/zvFaJIrTd2
@jay_dee_chx @ChloeMcLeftie @AllieHBNews Here's a paper that talks about some similarities in cis and trans gender identity formation, and the discussion of this formation notably starts at three years old. https://t.co/wDmdkwGxxT
@BK_McCallum @0diar3 @ZJemptv https://t.co/5aYSGB5NGh It’s not a “form” of Munchhausen’s, and until you have actual scholarly research that could prove a causal relationship, you’re just hypothesizing. On the contrary, we have actual peer-reviewed research showing “early sex assignment and parental…
In other words, tomboy = trans. https://t.co/8YBq1V4YIc https://t.co/qBWY0tolbI
@Empiricist871 @LGBwiththeT No, it wasn't - here's the study" Participants received a battery of tasks assessing multiple indicators of gender development" https://t.co/Giuikqxh4M.
@BrettJohn17 @DarkEden21 13. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/IbeZb9HSLi 14. Transgender, intersex, and gender non-conforming people #WontBeErased by pseudoscience: https://t.co/VjYidf4KV3 7/
@cleemput_t @fakerholic Deel even het wetenschappelijk onderzoekt dat dit van toepassing is op gender
@Pirulla25 @EliVieiraJr Aliás, fica a sugestão desse notável e interessante estudo (acho que o maior sobre o tema): Gülgöz et al. (2019). Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development. PNAS, 116(49)24480-24485. https://t.co/7BozKkZtcL
@HankRacette @switchinblades @LGBwiththeT 13. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/IbeZb9HSLi 14. Transgender, intersex, and gender non-conforming people #WontBeErased by pseudoscience: https://t.co/VjYidf4KV3 8/
@Friended4Ever @PSA_Sitch SDL debated Counterpoints https://t.co/Y47RZmhugr
@_counterpoints_ @SocDoneLeft Also on Youtube! https://t.co/YNc1M5ROW3
@Tastavins73 @DuraMauricia @martitze2 @VelvetMolotov https://t.co/6kcJI1GuSh
@CheckIzquierdoz @negrosonik1 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/9PdhwZNuPU 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/aaiWxqj4oO
@GarpBrasileiro @jovemnerd @DiogoMRG @Katiucha @pedrohduarte @sr_k_ @principevidane
@Janine_Brinck @ec0anarch0 @robishungry @ErinInTheMorn https://t.co/HG25rrMrmd https://t.co/UqzHfQ7BhQ https://t.co/Ma3Q43OMOC https://t.co/3KqYkrf2An This last one reviews 50+ studies. Y'all just hate trans people and it shows.
@hertsengland @MissSilverWitch @GayMaterialist @HelenWebberley https://t.co/2MMMFLogkr And https://t.co/dXFqv5Fp0S biggest study ever done on kids. There’s a lot more in the latter links that have links inside them. Yes Newsweek is a media site but this is the actual paper https://t.co/pLPPYmr0g4 You can always 2/
@herefortoday_ @orgalorgs @FlemPhatale @PierreJouet @ThomasWillett9 @BlytheGetsCross What basis does anyone to know how it feels to be anyone else? If you look at another woman and go that person is a woman like me that's the same documented process kids go through as they develop their understanding or gender including trans kids. https://t.co/ddoJcedGlf
@LilithLovett @localquackhead Examples of academic and medical uses by cis and trans people: https://t.co/qurhLBVuOe https://t.co/Yf6CaLlk5V https://t.co/oYR9lYqJyu https://t.co/Yq6jQXDgWC https://t.co/W6qAxw3Idc
@1stCaliph @AriDrennen https://t.co/SDdYgvBd1C https://t.co/VSrhe9Atx8 https://t.co/XwBY92ZgBw https://t.co/1HOSq3VXSk
@ICareAbt5Things @AriDrennen Several papers from the large, ongoing University of Washington study of affirmed trans children show consistent similarity in gender aspects to same-gender peers from a young age. Eg
@blackadder12358 @Repeal_the_GRA @Nihilarity @KateAndersonLTD Again those are gender expressions there are effeminate Trans boys and Tomboy trans girls as usual the shocking ignorance of gender criticals about a subject they think justifies stripping others of their rights and essential healthcare is on full display. https://t.co/ddoJcedGlf
@FTFDesert @FranzPiga @MiguelMcSporra1 @ThomasWillett9 Again nobody but GC think that. Trans kids have just as much variation in gender expression as cis kids there are just as many trans Tom boys and their sense of their gender identity is just as strong https://t.co/ddoJcedGlf
@CassandraCmplex @atomicrebelo @magicpanda_703 @finngalkn "I mean gender isn't a natural thing" https://t.co/YTSVjE4m6z. https://t.co/XwBY92ZgBw https://t.co/Z8KHMu7vMX
@fkurpronouns @utahthemiller @finngalkn "Wrong, there are no trans kids." https://t.co/Z8KHMu7vMX https://t.co/YTSVjE4m6z. https://t.co/XwBY92ZgBw
@JonPerne @kenswift @KatyMontgomerie Not only there are many trans adults saying they knew they were trans from a very early age and without influence from parents or other ppl (considering they lived in conservative areas) but there are studies talking about this. THERE ARE TRANS KIDS. https://t.co/HsQKbX0X4f
@doisdedosdeteo Uma afirmação forte, enviesada e cientificamente inválida. Existe toda uma discussão sobre a transexualidade infantil, com estatísticas apontando que a maioria das crianças trans após 5 anos não mudam de orientação. Pode começar aqui https://t.co/JyEkJmJp4E
@TomasHolgado 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/KLc3bLe6TH
@MrJibs369 @HunterAA6 @kelly_cadigan https://t.co/vxL1P0fV3a 300 trans kids aged 3 to 12 years old https://t.co/llDIFSKMXK 315 trans kids and adults aged 12 to 20 years old https://t.co/Q1Mbep1ov9 27,715 transgender adults https://t.co/xFT8542DU7 104 trans youth /45
@DonutMooch @H_Schoenbaum @ErinInTheMorn @AP @esballentine Humans form a concept of gender identity by age 3 on average, including trans humans. https://t.co/Z8KHMu7vMX https://t.co/vxL1P0fV3a
@blurrrgh @tomblackwell @earlobeKeloid @realsnoopbailey @chrislhayes https://t.co/2VupP8ieXU https://t.co/N0M1bYvEZ6 https://t.co/SCc1OjmpE1 https://t.co/58l3Vy0uJ5 https://t.co/QCrSFZat1l https://t.co/z7MtsSnP36 https://t.co/nxqEqrDChg https://t.co/csRdJiWuyT
@NCLRights @AltDIA https://t.co/18SYIX1EiL Researchers at the University of Washington (https://t.co/qubTytYVY5) in Seattle found gender identity — the concept of knowing whether one’s self is male, female or non-binary — is as strong in trans kids as it is among those identifying as cis.
@las_jacob @lauren_vasiliou @RealMarkLatham Kids develop a sense of their own gender identity around age 18 months to 3 years, & that sense of gender identity stays mostly constant throughout childhood for both cisgender and transgender children, via a 2019 PNAS study that included nearly 900 kids https://t.co/728D5gR5GS
@kamahara_lito @DanannOficial La identidad de género es un aspecto básico de la identidad que se desarrolla a edad temprana con personas cis o no-trans. Las personas trans no son una excepción a eso. https://t.co/HsQKbX0X4f https://t.co/k8BCgjLHkU
@aceiturra @BelfrRipeado Seguro que tus libros de 1920 son más relevantes (dado que hay teorías desde 1960 que hablan de la identidad de género desde los 3 años supongo que tus libros son anteriores) https://t.co/8xGgSWoozM
@silverscreen97 @kamahara_lito @DanannOficial Evidentemente, ser gender non-conforming≠ser trans. Sobre que los niños no saben nada de género, en eso sí que te equivocas (dependiendo de la edad). Las personas cis o no-trans saben su género a temprana edad y las personas trans no son diferentes. https://t.co/HsQKbX0X4f
Trancegender D-G https://t.co/LXp4P5KAG6
@facha_sr @nadie1920 @JorgeFT777 @srgolaz000 @CualquieraMujer @AgustinLaje 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/UkPBjFQQxy 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/GvaTlaPjHH
@serna_se @nadie1920 @AgustinLaje @ClickDgo @INEGI_INFORMA @LeonHdezF @victtorhdez 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/GvaTlaPjHH 15. Transgender, intersex, and gender non-conforming people #WontBeErased by pseudoscience: https://t.co/TeuMSLd3DC
@NoName49082036 @PomeranianGod @mysicksadlife @FuzzysNutts @ErinInTheMorn
RT @bennysiauw89: @ivanmkurnia @cIickbanget Ah, yes, you are right. Toddler. Haha. And trans kids already know who they are as early as 3…
@davidpitts62 @ParodyCzar @GEsenhourn @linapoo @gravell_wayne @JackPosobiec No evidence? Read: https://t.co/FpQZN1cu8m
@ivanmkurnia @cIickbanget Ah, yes, you are right. Toddler. Haha. And trans kids already know who they are as early as 3 y.o. Trans kids are also focused on learning about the characteristics of their gender, a different gender with their assigned one since early ages. https://t.co/FrmW5LHZKo
@lolitalady123 @dubbleEL @TrumpWarRoom Are you talking about gender-affirming care or being trans? If it's the latter, they absolutely do considering children show natural, pre-linguistic expressions of being trans before knowing that concept at all. https://t.co/HsQKbX1uTN
@djoseph626 @peterjrainford @KaeleyT Also you just lied, cause there are plenty of studies on gender in cis children https://t.co/JiSEkzuWBs
@AlanMackeyJr @0ceanicAtr0city @davenewworld_2 Example https://t.co/fMuoKAKDyy https://t.co/1p6OuSigT4
@watkins82 @WorldOfOrdinary @theFoxFisher @Mermaids_Gender @GoodLawProject @mygenderation i don't know if you can read this as it may be locked for non students/professionals in the field but here you go https://t.co/BdLrl64BYC
@telreth @A_God_inthe_TV @fantasticalicef @22_Gilly @BevJacksonAuth https://t.co/BdLrl64BYC
@WilliamCardonaa @YouTube 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/UkPBjFRon6 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/GvaTlaPRxf
@fraynelson 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/W6W349fExa 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/yXrSoly9st
@fraynelson 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/W6W349fExa 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/yXrSoly9st
@eric_layland @HYarger_PhD @selingulgoz https://t.co/ee8dppwP2t
@El__Canario 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/UkPBjG8rp6 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/GvaTlaxIj7
@cgmkucera @TheBaptstMartyr @sushicat2021 @SethDillon Sounds like one of many indicators in pattern leading to believe an individual can be trans. https://t.co/Xg64fhCJF9
@leugim_legna_74 @jose83502496 @balkraix @CarlRamirezA 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/nj5bmLXnzk 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/HexqKyBCRW
@PJavierOR 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/nj5bmLXnzk 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/HexqKyBCRW
@Joel81185317 @PipetianQueen @AlberdianoArg Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/PpkxlRBgga
@mavr009 @AuraOrt82520607 @UnMarcianoChido @Frida_Espinosaa 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/Zu9snTcyxh 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/jvoUaJcccr
@AuraOrt82520607 @fraynelson 13. Beyond XX and XY. The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination: https://t.co/Zu9snTcyxh 14. Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development: https://t.co/jvoUaJcccr
@mybeautifulneed @crab_rare @BarnabyJDixon @SashaLPC Let's see what science says about children and gender identity "Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development | PNAS" https://t.co/6Clq67JbnH
@SuperStraightM3 @OliLondonTV See also the early gender development section of this article: https://t.co/2cULfzh5OH
Araştırmanın ismi "Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development". Şuradan ücretsiz ulaşabilirsiniz: https://t.co/acPMGs7Kyk
@Aquileo161 @amaya_rami @nararodriguez0 @danidiazxo Neurobiology of gender identity and sexual orientation https://t.co/xx8YmcSfQ0 Beyond XX and XY: The Extraordinary Complexity of Sex Determination https://t.co/3VpgTJeyT9 Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development https://t.co/BTTq8CEXBG
Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development | PNAS https://t.co/i167V4IiQq
Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development | PNAS https://t.co/G1XmE6pTvo
I think the exact article may have got lost in the shuffle so I’ll put it again here. https://t.co/SQ6KFPZcsX
@FBPE75 @mamelsberg @ayahuascaah @Witkicker @craggypeaks @BoyGeorge @FionneOrlander Actually the other study by Gülgöz et al was in 2019 as well so check out "gender essentialism in transgender and cisgender children" as well as "similarity in transgender and cisgender children's gender development"
@tmandalaywala Last one (for now, unless you want more): Amazing paper on trans* children's development from last year: Gülgöz, S., et al, (2019). Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 116(49), 24480-24485.
RT @zeno001: @MichealConraoi @NBCNews @LetToysBeToys @letclothesbe @LetBooksBeBooks You should have a read of that paper. It's a pile of no…
@NBCNews 1/2 Two paragraphs quoting a certain Dr. Stuart Chipkin “who wasn’t involved in the study” !? While 11 others are!? Here’s the PNAS page about the research: "Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development" https://t.co/FnbtkbQ8kM
RT @zeno001: @MichealConraoi @NBCNews @LetToysBeToys @letclothesbe @LetBooksBeBooks You should have a read of that paper. It's a pile of no…
Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development https://t.co/SIT7dLT10Z
@MichealConraoi @NBCNews @LetToysBeToys @letclothesbe @LetBooksBeBooks You should have a read of that paper. It's a pile of nonsense. They showed pictures of just 4 toys to kids - they say 1 was a doll bit I can't see that they what the others were. They are basing their conclusions on this & other similarly sloppy criteria. https://t.co/yHhocLEJfo
Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development PNAS December 3, 2019 116 (49) 24480-24485 https://t.co/1alPIpztHU
Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development https://t.co/JFq7C9zZOX
トランスジェンダーとシスジェンダーの子供の比較研究。親の性別割当とそれに基づく養育は子供の性同一性への必ずしも影響しない → Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development https://t.co/BWwYuafGKd
Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development https://t.co/5tWnDfIxEN
Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development | PNAS https://t.co/boXcHECoMG
Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development https://t.co/S8GRfj0xrx
These findings illustrate that children develop a sense of identity at an early age, that this identity is not necessarily determined by sex assigned at birth, and that children may hold on to this identity even when it conflicts with others’ expectations. https://t.co/UCsvKu18SA https://t.co/IPdu7yvdYg https://t.co/aMnhLdN0uo
Similarity in transgender and cisgender children's gender development. https://t.co/L0EtC3vv5I #PubMed #Transgender
Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development https://t.co/vxyD9n7829
Similarity in transgender and cisgender children’s gender development | PNAS #SOGIE #ChildDevelopment #Gender https://t.co/H1YMKmt7dl
Full academic research paper “Similarity in Transgender and Cisgender Children’s Gender Development” for reference ➡️ https://t.co/QnawE8qNcJ