A consensus-based transparency checklist.
Balazs Aczel, Barnabas Szaszi, Alexandra Sarafoglou, Zoltan Kekecs, Šimon Kucharský, Daniel Benjamin, Christopher D Chambers, Agneta Fisher, Andrew Gelman, Morton A Gernsbacher, John P Ioannidis, Eric Johnson, Kai Jonas, Stavroula Kousta, Scott O Lilienfeld
January 2020 Nat Hum BehavSynopsis of Social media discussions
The discussions include reactions such as 'Looks like a good initiative' and 'would be great to see a sample of papers' indicating both interest and caution regarding the practical use of the checklist. The varied use of terms like 'wary' and 'exciting initiative' illustrates a mix of enthusiasm and skepticism, showing that while many see the potential benefits of increased transparency, others are concerned about how effectively the checklist will be applied.
Agreement
Moderate agreementMany discussions reflect a positive outlook on the checklist, though some express reservations about its application.
Interest
High level of interestThere is significant curiosity, as evidenced by multiple users sharing or summarizing the article.
Engagement
Moderate level of engagementWhile engagement is moderate, several posts delve into the implications and potential applications of the checklist.
Impact
High level of impactParticipants believe the checklist could greatly enhance transparency in research reporting.
Social Mentions
YouTube
2 Videos
4 Posts
66 Posts
Blogs
9 Articles
2 Posts
Metrics
Video Views
7,217
Total Likes
258
Extended Reach
241,277
Social Features
83
Timeline: Posts about article
Top Social Media Posts
Marcus Munafò
A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in social and behavioural research https://t.co/0NOlxpWOKs in @NatureHumBehav
view full post
Jelte Wicherts
A consensus-based transparency checklist
https://t.co/CtVHapBIHg https://t.co/LoM93p0OPv
view full post
John Antonakis
Want to showcase the scientific transparency of your research?
Use this on-line tool in Nature Human Behavior @NatureHumBehav :
"A consensus-based transparency checklist"
https://t.co/1TCh9hc6qP
view full post
METRICStanford
"We present a consensus-based checklist to improve and document the transparency of research reports in social and behavioural research"
A consensus-based transparency checklist, Nature Human Behaviour https://t.co/U1ELzbSBLK
view full post
UCL Brain Sciences
Profs David Shanks and Pasco Fearon @UCLPALS are among 63 editors and open science advocates who have developed a consensus-based Transparency Checklist for the social and behavioural sciences, newly published in @NatureHumBehav.
https://t.co/qnAEhOz2xf @PascoFearon https://t.co/RBycgxS5Rf
view full post
Posts referencing the article
Enhancing Transparency in Research Reporting with Checklists
This episode discusses the usefulness of checklists in scientific work and how they promote transparency in reporting, data sharing, and authorship determination. We present examples of checklists that enhance the documentation process, important for researchers and the scientific community.
July 14, 2022
7,202 views
Enhancing Transparency in Open Science Workflows
In this conversation with senior lecturer Tom Hostler, we explore the enhanced workload linked to open science practices. The discussion includes a new checklist designed to improve transparency in social and behavioral research, streamlining the documentation process.
January 18, 2024
15 views
-
A dzisiaj polecamy Wam kolejne wydanie podcastu "Otwarta nauka" z udziałem @katarzyna_jasko z @psychologyUJ i Bartosza Janika z @USinKatowice :) https://t.co/Ql2DM8e2s2
view full postJuly 25, 2022
3
-
Hideki Sato
@hidekis_psych (Twitter)社会・行動科学研究の透明性を担保するためのチェックリスト。ブラウザ上で評価できる。 Aczel, B., Szaszi, B., Sarafoglou, A. et al. A consensus-based transparency checklist. Nat Hum Behav 4, 4–6 (2020). https://t.co/hqetYU1E6c
view full postNovember 10, 2021
-
Oleksandr Z
@zov911 (Twitter)She’s wary of the consensus based transparency checklist, and here’s a paragraph we should’ve added to that zillion-authored paper: Megan Higgs writes: A large collection of authors describes a “consensus-based transparency checklist” in the Dec 2, 2019… https://t.co/Vh5Gwc9J5F
view full postOctober 14, 2020
-
Kyra Hamilton
@DrKyraHamilton (Twitter)RT @BeauchampDr: A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/E1tolO6Bpq
view full postApril 3, 2020
1
-
Mark Beauchamp
@MarkRBeauchamp (Twitter)A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/E1tolO6Bpq
view full postApril 2, 2020
2
1
-
hassoun
@hassoun18603430 (Twitter)RT @METRICStanford: "We present a consensus-based checklist to improve and document the transparency of research reports in social and beha…
view full postMarch 22, 2020
4
-
UCSF Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences
@UCSFPsychiatry (Twitter)#Research reading: A consensus-based transparency checklist - https://t.co/3P6h5vkaI1
view full postMarch 17, 2020
-
Linda Galliher
@LindaGalliher (Twitter)RT @METRICStanford: "We present a consensus-based checklist to improve and document the transparency of research reports in social and beha…
view full postMarch 1, 2020
4
-
Joop Hox
@JoopHox (Twitter)RT @LisaHarlow3: If interested, see a transparency checklist by a large number of editors and researchers: Aczel, B., Szaszi, B., Sarafoglo…
view full postJanuary 30, 2020
2
-
Lisa Harlow
@LisaHarlow3 (Twitter)If interested, see a transparency checklist by a large number of editors and researchers: Aczel, B., Szaszi, B., Sarafoglou, A. et al. (2020). A consensus-based transparency checklist. Nature Human Behavior, 4, 4–6. Open access (https://t.co/uFQG3RLSyM).
view full postJanuary 29, 2020
3
2
-
Alexandra Winter, DVM, DACVS
@alexandralw2 (Twitter)RT @METRICStanford: "We present a consensus-based checklist to improve and document the transparency of research reports in social and beha…
view full postDecember 19, 2019
4
-
ZBW MediaTalk
@ZBW_MediaTalk (Twitter)A consensus-based transparency checklist #openaccess https://t.co/4Lx2lbpinv
view full postDecember 19, 2019
1
-
Simon Worthington @mrchristian@openbiblio.social
@mrchristian99 (Twitter)RT @lfvopenscience: A consensus-based transparency checklist to improve and document the transparency of research reports in social and beh…
view full postDecember 16, 2019
1
-
Leibniz Strategy Forum on Open Science
@lfvopenscience (Twitter)A consensus-based transparency checklist to improve and document the transparency of research reports in social and behavioural #research. An online application allows users to complete the form and generate a report to submit with their manuscript. https://t.co/0bixexST8K
view full postDecember 16, 2019
1
-
Co•Production Norfolk
@CoProNorfolk (Twitter)RT @UCLBrainScience: Profs David Shanks and Pasco Fearon @UCLPALS are among 63 editors and open science advocates who have developed a cons…
view full postDecember 12, 2019
4
-
@PPIEglobal #GlobalHealthDialogue #PPIE
@PPIEglobal (Twitter)RT @UCLBrainScience: Profs David Shanks and Pasco Fearon @UCLPALS are among 63 editors and open science advocates who have developed a cons…
view full postDecember 12, 2019
4
-
Bernard W.T. Coetzee
@BernardScience (Twitter)RT @JelteWicherts: A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/CtVHapBIHg https://t.co/LoM93p0OPv
view full postDecember 10, 2019
8
-
UCL Discovery
@ucl_discovery (Twitter)Open Access UCL Research: A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/dWIJwEZbiB
view full postDecember 10, 2019
-
Aberdeen Open Research Working Group
@AberdeenOrwg (Twitter)RT @jessbutler284: Summary thread for: A Consensus-based Transparency Checklist by @BalazsAczel et al "Ideally, science is characterized…
view full postDecember 9, 2019
2
-
Gözde Özakıncı
@Gozde786 (Twitter)A consensus-based transparency checklist - https://t.co/ihkb3rI7pf #ScholarAlerts
view full postDecember 9, 2019
-
Marcus Munafò
@MarcusMunafo (Twitter)RT @jessbutler284: Summary thread for: A Consensus-based Transparency Checklist by @BalazsAczel et al "Ideally, science is characterized…
view full postDecember 9, 2019
2
-
Jess Butler
@JessButler284 (Twitter)Summary thread for: A Consensus-based Transparency Checklist by @BalazsAczel et al "Ideally, science is characterized by a ‘show me’ norm, meaning that claims should be based on observations that are reported transparently, honestly and completely" https://t.co/tg7eeAB05Z
view full postDecember 9, 2019
4
2
-
UCL Psych & Lang Sci
@UCLPALS (Twitter)RT @UCLBrainScience: Profs David Shanks and Pasco Fearon @UCLPALS are among 63 editors and open science advocates who have developed a cons…
view full postDecember 9, 2019
4
-
Dr. Sheri Madigan (she/her)
@sherimadigan (Twitter)RT @UCLBrainScience: Profs David Shanks and Pasco Fearon @UCLPALS are among 63 editors and open science advocates who have developed a cons…
view full postDecember 9, 2019
4
-
UCL Brain Sciences
@UCLBrainScience (Twitter)Profs David Shanks and Pasco Fearon @UCLPALS are among 63 editors and open science advocates who have developed a consensus-based Transparency Checklist for the social and behavioural sciences, newly published in @NatureHumBehav. https://t.co/qnAEhOz2xf @PascoFearon https://t.co/RBycgxS5Rf
view full postDecember 9, 2019
4
4
-
Liz Hoffman
@LizHoffmanbmc (Twitter)RT @iainh_z: A consensus-based transparency checklist in @NatureHumBehav https://t.co/erIObSrcTJ Looks like a good initiative but it would…
view full postDecember 9, 2019
1
-
Iain Hrynaszkiewicz
@iainh_z (Twitter)A consensus-based transparency checklist in @NatureHumBehav https://t.co/erIObSrcTJ Looks like a good initiative but it would be great to see a sample of papers/researchers where it's been used, or tested, and outcomes evaluated in practice
view full postDecember 9, 2019
1
-
Open Science Feed
@OpenScienceR (Twitter)A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/C6EVH9BPtd
view full postDecember 8, 2019
1
-
Sebastian Hendricks (he/him)
@Hearing4Kids (Twitter)RT briandavidearp: A consensus-based transparency checklist | Nature Human Behaviour https://t.co/eDCscMxss6
view full postDecember 8, 2019
-
Brian D. Earp, Ph.D.
@briandavidearp (Twitter)A consensus-based transparency checklist | Nature Human Behaviour https://t.co/lighAeQ0aV
view full postDecember 7, 2019
2
-
Maya Goldenberg
@maya_goldenberg (Twitter)A consensus-based transparency checklist | Nature Human Behaviour https://t.co/ucTvpUiXaJ
view full postDecember 7, 2019
1
-
Florian Naudet
@NaudetFlorian (Twitter)RT @METRICStanford: "We present a consensus-based checklist to improve and document the transparency of research reports in social and beha…
view full postDecember 6, 2019
4
-
METRICStanford
@METRICStanford (Twitter)"We present a consensus-based checklist to improve and document the transparency of research reports in social and behavioural research" A consensus-based transparency checklist, Nature Human Behaviour https://t.co/U1ELzbSBLK
view full postDecember 5, 2019
8
4
-
The Declaration to Improve Health Research
@ImproveHealthR (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 5, 2019
25
-
Megan Higgs
@critical_infer (Twitter)Decided to share a bit of wariness about the consensus-based transparency checklist (wary about a checklist approach, not transparency): https://t.co/ynQp6Spp3Y https://t.co/JlVhQUK41c
view full postDecember 3, 2019
-
Remi Gau
@RemiGau (Twitter)RT @JelteWicherts: A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/CtVHapBIHg https://t.co/LoM93p0OPv
view full postDecember 3, 2019
8
-
CAN Clinic & Research Group
@CANexeter (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
James Booth
@DrJamesBooth (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Loek Brinkman
@LoekBrinkman (Twitter)RT @JelteWicherts: A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/CtVHapBIHg https://t.co/LoM93p0OPv
view full postDecember 3, 2019
8
-
Dr. Priya Silverstein
@priyasilverst (Twitter)RT @JelteWicherts: A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/CtVHapBIHg https://t.co/LoM93p0OPv
view full postDecember 3, 2019
8
-
IGDORE
@IGDOREinstitute (Twitter)RT @JelteWicherts: A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/CtVHapBIHg https://t.co/LoM93p0OPv
view full postDecember 3, 2019
8
-
Gwyneth Gordon
@gwynnotpaltrow (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Singapore ReproducibiliTea
@SingReproTea (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Dr. Christina Bergmann - Skies are blue...
@chbergma (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Louis
@Louis_Chenxf (Twitter)A consensus-based transparency checklist | Nature Human Behaviour https://t.co/EMJndEP2ZY
view full postDecember 3, 2019
1
-
Alessandro Sancino
@alesancino (Twitter)RT @JohnAntonakis: Want to showcase the scientific transparency of your research? Use this on-line tool in Nature Human Behavior @NatureH…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
2
-
Project TIER
@Project_TIER (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Jesse Kaye
@KayeJesseT (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
LauraBringmann
@bringmann_laura (Twitter)RT @JelteWicherts: A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/CtVHapBIHg https://t.co/LoM93p0OPv
view full postDecember 3, 2019
8
-
MiguelCorderoVega
@macordero (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
British Neuroscience Association
@BritishNeuro (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Ari Haukkala
@AriHaukkala (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
David Mehler
@neuroccino (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Florian Naudet
@NaudetFlorian (Twitter)RT @JelteWicherts: A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/CtVHapBIHg https://t.co/LoM93p0OPv
view full postDecember 3, 2019
8
-
Nora Maria Raschle
@NoraMRaschle (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Florian Ph.S Fischmeister
@FPFischmeister (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Stepan Bahnik
@bahniks (Twitter)RT @JelteWicherts: A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/CtVHapBIHg https://t.co/LoM93p0OPv
view full postDecember 3, 2019
8
-
Claudia von Bastian
@cvonbastian (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Jelte Wicherts
@JelteWicherts (Twitter)A consensus-based transparency checklist https://t.co/CtVHapBIHg https://t.co/LoM93p0OPv
view full postDecember 3, 2019
21
8
-
Hu Chuan-Peng | @hcp4715.bsky.social
@hcp4715 (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Gustav Nilsonne
@GustavNilsonne (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Dr Jessie Baldwin
@jessiebaldwin (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
JoodiG
@JoodiG (Twitter)RT @MarcusMunafo: A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in soci…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
25
-
Marcus Munafò
@MarcusMunafo (Twitter)A consensus-based transparency checklist - intended to improve and document the transparency of research reports in social and behavioural research https://t.co/0NOlxpWOKs in @NatureHumBehav
view full postDecember 3, 2019
56
25
-
Gregg R. Murray
@GreggRMurray (Twitter)RT @JohnAntonakis: Want to showcase the scientific transparency of your research? Use this on-line tool in Nature Human Behavior @NatureH…
view full postDecember 3, 2019
2
-
John Antonakis
@JohnAntonakis (Twitter)Want to showcase the scientific transparency of your research? Use this on-line tool in Nature Human Behavior @NatureHumBehav : "A consensus-based transparency checklist" https://t.co/1TCh9hc6qP
view full postDecember 3, 2019
12
2
Abstract Synopsis
- A new checklist has been created to enhance transparency in social and behavioral research reports.
- This checklist is based on consensus among experts and aims to standardize the documentation process.
- An online tool is available to help users fill out the checklist and generate a report for submission with their research manuscripts or for sharing publicly.
Psychology JU
@psychologyUJ (Twitter)