Discussions emphasize the nature of the hot spring hypothesis with examples like field experiments in New Zealand and references to well-known scientists, demonstrating active engagement and curiosity. The tone varies from supportive to inquisitive, highlighting the topic's relevance and potential for influencing future research.
AgreementModerate agreement
Most discussions express support or curiosity about the hot spring hypothesis, with some references to prior experiments and the significance of wet-dry cycles, indicating general agreement with the article's premise.
InterestHigh interest
The high interest score reflects frequent mentions of experiments, theories, and related topics, suggesting that participants are genuinely curious and engaged with the subject.
EngagementHigh engagement
Multiple posts include detailed mentions of experiments, personal experiences, and references to new publications, indicating deep engagement with the material.
ImpactModerate impact
The moderate impact score arises from the publication's promotion, open access, and the ongoing experimental discussions, which could influence future research but are not yet widely transformative.
Abstract in brief
The hypothesis suggests that life may have begun in volcanic hot spring pools on land, where cycles of wetting and drying helped synthesize primitive cell-like structures called protocells, which could develop basic functions needed for life.
These protocells could form clusters called progenotes, which can undergo natural selection and create early ecosystems, eventually evolving into microbial communities like stromatolites, which leave fossil evidence.
The authors compare the land-based hot spring scenario with oceanic vent theories, propose experiments to test their ideas, and discuss how this pathway could lead to more complex life forms, including plants, highlighting a continuous evolution from simple protocells to fully developed organisms.]
The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 395 likes · 51 shares · 524,089 followersView post →
DD
Dr. Bruce Damer
@bdamer · X
Our Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life article is out! Forty years of cogitating, coding and testing is now presented to science... here in the journal Astrobiology: https://t.co/iJ7Vv0jJ7Z https://t.co/rANviyPICT
Jan 13, 2020 · 24 likes · 8 shares · 2,019 followersView post →
DS
Dr Darren R Flower drdarrenrflower.bsky.social
@DrDarrenRFlower · X
Widening environments & biochemistry fit for life
https://t.co/0O1nPqpgOP
https://t.co/N4k0NZ4Jjn
@anjbth @_fcampelo @grawoig @foxymania @16_shab
@madrynha2012 @DifferentSpaces @TrevKnight @NoreenBrenner2 @mims #terrahawks #HPLovecraft #newhaven #Space #dccomics https://t.co/SpwCyO4MLh
The Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life (Damer)
https://t.co/xz6YO1zNZ5 https://t.co/reItsWhZXy
Dec 18, 2019 · 13 likes · 4 shares · 1,217 followersView post →
EU
EES Update
@EES_update · X
The Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life by Bruce Damer and David Deamer is a testable hypothesis about an origin of life on land in which fluctuating volcanic hot spring pools play a central role. New publication here at Astrobiology: https://t.co/XFD4flCSHE
Jun 21, 2020 · 8 likes · 2 shares · 2,991 followersView post →
AJ
Astrobiology Journal
@Astrobiology_jn · X
Looking for some reading material during #WorldSpaceWeek? Check out a selection of our top-read open access articles!
https://t.co/VKT7J1ne8T
https://t.co/aeqakpun8K
https://t.co/Wxf6sWlHqp
https://t.co/6lSgajx5Kc
https://t.co/ZStAwUXxqw https://t.co/RLeOvTWO45
Oct 6, 2021 · 6 likes · 5 shares · 6,571 followersView post →
How do astrobiologists attempt to explain the beginning of life? This video explores hypotheses including life originating in volcanic hot spring pools on land and the role of organic compounds from meteorites…
This video explores the hypothesis that life began in volcanic hot spring pools on land, where wetting and drying cycles facilitated the formation of primitive cell-like structures called protocells, leading to early…
@lonna_camacho @darwintojesus That particular one was in a lab but abiogenesis experiments are increasingly being performed in situ.
https://t.co/go0jQXOHAQ
@SentinelSam1 @creationnews "This brings us to a conundrum known as the “water problem”. Proteins and the other key polymers of life, RNA and DNA, must function in an aqueous medium, but in the absence of continuous synthesis, they undergo hydrolytic decomposition ..."
https://t.co/IGsHP19txb
May 30, 2024 · 1 like · 16,582 followersView post →
R
Rhys
@RhysLindmark · X
@againstutopia agreed there was a pre-RNA World stage
creating the background chemical regularity for RNA to build on
...still haven't fully synthesized how hot springs fits in though. Like, idk if i believe the hot springs thing about organics from space
https://t.co/p3lnzOjNKe
@serroba @caleb_scharf Reminds me of wet-dry cycling in geothermal pools, proposed by Deamer & @bdamer as how layers of lipid vesicles full of long-chain organic compounds formed in "the primordial soup" — without the periodic drying out, nothing consolidates.
https://t.co/AWVzpr6DIX https://t.co/iFAly1gtW3
@BrianRoemmele https://t.co/PasYeXKuc6
Great share Brian. Led me 2 this as well. I kinda like the space theory more though and not just bc its a more intriguing/exciting one.
This week is #WorldSpaceWeek! Celebrate with @Astrobiology_jn by exploring top-read articles dedicated to the understanding of life's origin, evolution, & distribution in the universe:
https://t.co/7gjAhquwZw
https://t.co/K6U4XLPZPi
https://t.co/dCOcNenIxW
https://t.co/CHpmuwOEba https://t.co/c7tMUwHMii
Looking for some reading material during #WorldSpaceWeek? Check out a selection of our top-read open access articles!
https://t.co/VKT7J1ne8T
https://t.co/aeqakpun8K
https://t.co/Wxf6sWlHqp
https://t.co/6lSgajx5Kc
https://t.co/ZStAwUXxqw https://t.co/RLeOvTWO45
Oct 6, 2021 · 6 likes · 5 shares · 6,571 followersView post →
FP
☿ Footnotes2Plato ☼☽
@ThouArtThat · X
https://t.co/v7T06EFyfE
May 28, 2021 · 1 like · 9,237 followersView post →
JS
Jennifer Macalady @jmacalad.bsky.social
@jmacalad · X
RT @AstrobiologyPsu: Origin of Life hypothesis paper: "...protocells aggregating into a hydrogel in the intermediate moist phase of wet-dry…
Mar 5, 2021 · 1 share · 1,494 followersView post →
MR
Mason Hargrave | AI Researcher
@MasonHargrave · X
@MarkusDeserno @McdarghZach Thanks Markus!
Unrelated but since you're a lipid vesicle guy and don't have you're private messaging open, I thought I'd share this work from my colleagues which takes lipid vesicles as central to the origin of life.
https://t.co/e7QKHJ96L8
How life originated is still a mystery. Many theories have been proposed with little success (primordial soup, extremophiles etc.). Now a new one is proposed - Hot Springs Theory. Periodic dry/wet cycles create the forces resulting in complex synthesis https://t.co/a5dGMshCUW
My friend and colleague @DrBruceDamer gave a wonderful talk on The Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life in my @IAstrobiologia #VCIAB #prebioticchemistry session. Check it! https://t.co/EuNnRWWiU4
"We present a testable hypothesis related to an origin of life on land in which fluctuating volcanic hot spring pools play a central role."
Wonderful article. It's a bit of a long-read but the topic isn't bitesize either.
https://t.co/EwDaJWiCg0
Nov 1, 2020 · 4 likes · 14,420 followersView post →
MB
MSU Extreme Biology
@MSUExtremeBio · X
@AltYelloNatPark @environmicrobio There is also the possibility that life began in terrestrial hot springs and later found its way to marine habitats. https://t.co/Wb80RKOoDQ
Next our PhD student @steller_luke on the hot spring hypothesis for an origin of life: the next stage in experiments.
Luke and co were out in the field in NZ - trying these experiments out in the field, but on 3.5 billion year old rocks to mimick early Earth
1/ #AAM2020
RT @EES_update: The Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life by Bruce Damer and David Deamer is a testable hypothesis about an origin of…
Jun 21, 2020 · 2 shares · 419 followersView post →
EU
EES Update
@EES_update · X
The Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life by Bruce Damer and David Deamer is a testable hypothesis about an origin of life on land in which fluctuating volcanic hot spring pools play a central role. New publication here at Astrobiology: https://t.co/XFD4flCSHE
Jun 21, 2020 · 8 likes · 2 shares · 2,991 followersView post →
S
Suagosal
@javi_suagosal · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 210 followersView post →
TG
the_logic_guy
@thelogicguy2 · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 105 followersView post →
R
realneil
@realneil3 · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 666 followersView post →
L
Luke
@lukeasmith95 · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 219 followersView post →
RW
Rob Wegner
@robwegnerdj · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 6,328 followersView post →
KJ
Kiwwi J Jackson
@j_kiwwiJackson · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 94 followersView post →
RF
Ronald A. Primas,MD,FACP,FACPM
@Primas · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 6,720 followersView post →
NS
Nicholas Steel
@bogizemlja · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 14,575 followersView post →
DC
Dan Croghan
@dancroghan · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 414 followersView post →
MM
Melchior Meijer
@PolderPaleo · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 5,172 followersView post →
CA
Christian Angermayer
@C_Angermayer · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 34,130 followersView post →
A
A 2.0
@A_2_0_London · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 382 followersView post →
MC
Maria Clemencia
@MariaCle_27 · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 743 followersView post →
S
Sandy
@Sandy010101011 · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 41 followersView post →
AA
Advance Global Australians
@Advance · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 4,462 followersView post →
FS
Frank Da Silva
@frankdasilva · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 2,757 followersView post →
L
LT
@NderituNick · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 267 followersView post →
AP
Andrea Pinos
@la_andrepinos · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 3,145 followersView post →
BH
Ben Hopkins
@Bchopkins2 · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 139 followersView post →
A
Alex
@alex_zurich · X
RT @davidasinclair: The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 51 shares · 167 followersView post →
DS
David Sinclair
@davidasinclair · X
The new Origin of Life theory, which you may have read in my book 'Lifespan', is now published. Genetic material
Jun 11, 2020 · 395 likes · 51 shares · 524,089 followersView post →
EU
EES Update
@EES_update · X
"We present a testable hypothesis related to an origin of life on land in which fluctuating volcanic hot spring
pools play a central role."
Bruce Damer & David Deamer's "The Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life" is now out https://t.co/Hwbvm6Re9a #openaccess https://t.co/KWiev2KvYn
Jun 5, 2020 · 3 likes · 2,991 followersView post →
MI
Mary Ann Liebert Inc
@LiebertPub · X
3 for FREE from @Astrobiology_jn:
Jan 30, 2020 · 2 likes · 2 shares · 4,622 followersView post →
MI
Mary Ann Liebert Inc
@LiebertPub · X
3 for FREE from @Astrobiology_jn:
Jan 30, 2020 · 1 share · 4,622 followersView post →
EU
EES Update
@EES_update · X
RT @bdamer: Our Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life article is out! Forty years of cogitating, coding and testing is now presented…
Jan 26, 2020 · 8 shares · 2,991 followersView post →
JW
John S. Wilkins
@john_s_wilkins · X
RT @bdamer: Our Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life article is out! Forty years of cogitating, coding and testing is now presented…
Jan 14, 2020 · 8 shares · 1,643 followersView post →
KM
KLI: A Home to Theory that Matters
@KLIAustria · X
RT @bdamer: Our Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life article is out! Forty years of cogitating, coding and testing is now presented…
Jan 14, 2020 · 8 shares · 2,644 followersView post →
DV
Dr. Walter Veit
@wrwveit · X
RT @bdamer: Our Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life article is out! Forty years of cogitating, coding and testing is now presented…
Jan 13, 2020 · 8 shares · 13,405 followersView post →
TS
Tomislav Stolar
@StolarTomislav · X
RT @bdamer: Our Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life article is out! Forty years of cogitating, coding and testing is now presented…
Jan 13, 2020 · 8 shares · 840 followersView post →
C
ComplexityExplorer
@ComplexExplorer · X
RT @bdamer: Our Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life article is out! Forty years of cogitating, coding and testing is now presented…
Jan 13, 2020 · 8 shares · 20,097 followersView post →
WW
Wandering Wim
@WanderingWim · X
RT @bdamer: Our Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life article is out! Forty years of cogitating, coding and testing is now presented…
Jan 13, 2020 · 8 shares · 362 followersView post →
DD
Dr. Bruce Damer
@bdamer · X
Our Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life article is out! Forty years of cogitating, coding and testing is now presented to science... here in the journal Astrobiology: https://t.co/iJ7Vv0jJ7Z https://t.co/rANviyPICT
Jan 13, 2020 · 24 likes · 8 shares · 2,019 followersView post →
AB
Arturo Becerra
@arturobecerra · X
RT @PrebioticChem: The Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life (Damer)
https://t.co/xz6YO1zNZ5 https://t.co/reItsWhZXy
Dec 19, 2019 · 4 shares · 369 followersView post →
L
letschatovercoffee
@inner_voice321 · X
RT @PrebioticChem: The Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life (Damer)
https://t.co/xz6YO1zNZ5 https://t.co/reItsWhZXy
... (Last Universal Common Ancestor). Life requires three polymers ... For Full Document Please See: https://www.liebertpub.com/doi/pdf/10.1089/ast. 2019.2045.
Microbial Diversity and Ecology of Geothermal Springs in T - 2022 ...
News
https://doi.org/10.1089/ast.2019.2045. reveals shared bacterial community properties along the temperature gradients of. Diamond, R.E., Harris, C., 2000 ...
Hot Spring Origin of Life Theory | PDF | Abiogenesis | Life
News
Mary Ann Liebert, Inc. DOI: 10.1089/ast.2019.2045. The Hot Spring Hypothesis for an Origin of Life. Bruce Damer and David Deamer. Abstract. We present a ...