September 2020 PMID 32621306

Skin colour and vitamin D: An update.

Andrea Hanel, Carsten Carlberg

Mentions

147
Peak: 11 in Dec 2023
across 6 sources since Jul 2020

Extended reach

1,116,260
potential audience

Total likes

17,096

Video views

892,406

Mentions per month

Jul 2020 – Sep 2025

Where it's discussed

  • X / Twitter124 posts
  • YouTube11 videos
  • News5 articles
  • Blogs3 articles
  • Facebook2 posts
  • Reddit2 posts

AI synopsis

What people are saying

The discussions frequently reference specific genetic mutations like OCA2 and associated historical timelines, indicating when certain traits developed in Europe. Phrases such as 'incredible good news' and 'game changer' highlight excitement around debunking white supremacist narratives related to evolution. The tone is crucial here; while many affirm the study’s findings, others challenge the interpretations, suggesting a vigorous debate influenced by the article's content.

AgreementModerate agreement

A significant portion of the discussions reflect a consensus on the core findings of the publication, though some responses indicate alternative viewpoints.

InterestHigh interest

Participants show heightened curiosity, delving into the genetic and historical implications of skin color evolution, indicating a strong relevance of the topic.

EngagementHigh engagement

Many users reference specific studies, genes, and evolutionary theories, demonstrating a deep engagement with the material rather than surface-level comments.

ImpactHigh impact

The conversations suggest that users believe the publication will significantly contribute to ongoing discussions about human genetics and societal narratives on race.

Abstract in brief

  • The original dark skin of Homo sapiens, evolved in East Africa for UV protection, posed challenges for vitamin D synthesis when humans migrated to higher latitudes.
  • Recent findings suggest that skin lightening in Europe occurred around 5,000 years ago due to the influx of lighter-skinned populations, rather than solely as a response to vitamin D synthesis needs.
  • Genetic variations in vitamin D-related proteins may have allowed populations in northern latitudes to adapt and avoid deficiencies without necessarily changing skin pigmentation.

Top posts

Most liked on X and Bluesky
Highly Cited
@highlycited · X

Origin of Blue Eyes was 42,000 years ago in the Caucasus (which is also where and when lots of Neanderthal interbreeding occurred) https://t.co/A9sYML6N4G https://t.co/CQVG2CGuhw

Sep 28, 2025 · 38 likes · 1 share · 397 followers View post →
Andrey
@Andreyfs · X

@jonesmanoel_PCB Detalhe (conhecimento científico do séc XXI agora) que a população europeia foi ficar embranquecida só há uns 5 mil anos atrás. E o embranquecimento teve origens externas à Europa. https://t.co/ZXJCehHsV5

Jun 20, 2022 · 33 likes · 132 followers View post →
El nombre no puede estar en blanco
@CalcetinLetal · X

@PutoMikel 1- https://t.co/MJoS60GErG 2- https://t.co/vby32M25HR 3-https://t.co/P3LzL3v64V 4-https://t.co/6tpWFWg2rw Es clave diferenciar entre WHG y SHG. Y los estudios que mencionas dicen que los WHG tenían la piel "darker" que los europeos actuales, pero no "subsaharian dark".

Dec 10, 2024 · 25 likes · 1 share · 754 followers View post →
Trevor Sutcliffe
@TrevorSutcliffe · X

Skin Color and Vitamin D: An Update "Yamnaya ancestry...had a dominant effect on the phenotype of northern Europeans...Yamnayas also brought high vitamin D sensitivity to Europe, which may have originated predominantly from ancient North Eurasians." https://t.co/JmSu3ZUMgg https://t.co/XSKUa9dgXK

Apr 6, 2022 · 24 likes · 3 shares · 6,338 followers View post →
الجـيـنـوم الأثــري ❲ض❳
@Geno_Mena · X

أبحاث علوم الوراثة البشرية حددت منشأ التحورات المحددة لسمات البشرة الفاتحة وتلون العيون بمنطقة غرب آسيا بالفترة الباليوليثية قبل 22.000 سنة كما يظهر بالخارطة المرفقة : >> Origin of Blue Eyes and Light Skin الدراسة : Hanel & Carlberg 2020 Skin colour and vitamin D: An update https://t.co/Cp75rueSj7

Dec 5, 2021 · 15 likes · 8 shares · 11,931 followers View post →
Lusulpher #CutTheCheck B1
@Lusulpher1 · X

@JJLK4R False #WhiteSupremacy narratives on EVOLUTIONARY THEORY/NATURAL SELECTION/"MASTER RACE", are OVER! Incredible good news!

Dec 28, 2023 · 14 likes · 7 shares · 1,107 followers View post →

All mentions

Bruce R. Fenton
@GeologicalSETI · X

@Deepneuron There is some contrary research that indicates the mutation on OCA2 dates right back to the time of the first modern humans in Europe, likely initially among people in the Caucasus region 42,000 years ago. https://t.co/Nu0SCxUZQK https://t.co/gqiRNlx6dN

Sep 30, 2025 · 20,272 followers View post →
Lusulpher #CutTheCheck B1
@Lusulpher1 · X

RT @Lusulpher1: @JJLK4R False #WhiteSupremacy narratives on EVOLUTIONARY THEORY/NATURAL SELECTION/"MASTER RACE", are OVER! Incredible good…

Sep 29, 2025 · 7 shares · 1,107 followers View post →
dinostavern
@hmtozcetin · X

RT @highlycited: Origin of Blue Eyes was 42,000 years ago in the Caucasus (which is also where and when lots of Neanderthal interbreeding o…

Sep 28, 2025 · 1 share · 1,591 followers View post →
Highly Cited
@highlycited · X

Origin of Blue Eyes was 42,000 years ago in the Caucasus (which is also where and when lots of Neanderthal interbreeding occurred) https://t.co/A9sYML6N4G https://t.co/CQVG2CGuhw

Sep 28, 2025 · 38 likes · 1 share · 397 followers View post →
Highly Cited
@highlycited · X

Origin of Blue Eyes was 42,000 years ago in the Caucasus (which is also were and when lots of Neanderthal interbreeding occurred) https://t.co/A9sYML6N4G https://t.co/jNpVyw9L6H

Sep 28, 2025 · 397 followers View post →
Detachment Paradigm (Dou)
@dpdiarra · X

RT @Lusulpher1: @JJLK4R False #WhiteSupremacy narratives on EVOLUTIONARY THEORY/NATURAL SELECTION/"MASTER RACE", are OVER! Incredible good…

Sep 15, 2025 · 7 shares · 890 followers View post →
Detachment Paradigm (Dou)
@dpdiarra · X

RT @JJLK4R: https://t.co/wCcgLIv3oT So the reason why people are "light skin" is not due to evolutionary factors of vitamin d deficiency a…

Sep 15, 2025 · 5 shares · 890 followers View post →
Lusulpher #CutTheCheck B1
@Lusulpher1 · X

RT @JJLK4R: https://t.co/wCcgLIv3oT So the reason why people are "light skin" is not due to evolutionary factors of vitamin d deficiency a…

Sep 15, 2025 · 5 shares · 1,107 followers View post →
Ashley
@xashtreex · X

@bryansairwell @RadioGenoa Nope https://t.co/KhsfVpN0us https://t.co/XwAa5m7e8w

Sep 7, 2025 · 451 followers View post →
Ashley
@xashtreex · X

@bryansairwell @RadioGenoa What is it that this says about Western Hunter Gatherers? https://t.co/KhsfVpN0us https://t.co/RuzIyAe9lU

Sep 7, 2025 · 451 followers View post →
The Santarogan 
@santarogan · X

@Kashou_Kashou @J1Zs4756 @tomalxbr Sources : https://t.co/OlX3lCCDbT https://t.co/GUDnX2pPFI

Aug 3, 2025 · 125 followers View post →
Alberto Diaz
@Alberto75553207 · X

@BREIQ_ @AgainUly @pitu_LAJ @iarsuaga Hanel, Andrea; Carlberg, Carsten (2020). «Color de piel y vitamina D: Una actualización» . Dermatología Experimental . 29 (9): 864–875 . doi : 10.1111/exd.14142 . PMID:  32621306. S2CID  : 220335539 . UCL News

Jul 29, 2025 · 688 followers View post →
P
@moralesforprez · X

@kingtravis1244 @AblazeMonkee @ahmdcore Well you're wrong about Europe at the least: "...skin lightening happened as late as 5000 years ago through immigration of lighter pigmented populations from western Anatolia and the Russian steppe..." https://t.co/xl7b51JS17

Jun 24, 2025 · 262 followers View post →
Oğuzhan TEKDEN
@oguzhantekden · X

@Oktayzkn19 @CerrahYaln Makale şurada. https://t.co/8kryr9fvWw Ancak açıkça belirteyim, dillerin sınıflandırılması gibi konularda yeterli bilginiz yok. Bu düzeyde bilgi ile herhangi bir ulusun dilinin diğeriyle akrabalığı için bir yorum yapmazdım yerinizde olsam.

May 28, 2025 · 4 likes · 6,378 followers View post →
Oğuzhan TEKDEN
@oguzhantekden · X

@nezih_seven Sarı saç ve mavi gözle ilgili makale: https://t.co/8kryr9fvWw

May 23, 2025 · 9 likes · 6,378 followers View post →
Pandemos
@ThePandemos · X

@Xenofilms_ @LycanrocYuri @nyaraVT https://t.co/7URwqj84VM https://t.co/5lJO1UteLa https://t.co/AwbnLBrOrw

May 18, 2025 · 5 likes · 757 followers View post →
Martyn Sharpe
@WetWorker666 · X

@razibkhan Pretty sure their skin color was close to modern Mediterranean peoples. https://t.co/5MgWmWY5Nn

May 7, 2025 · 1 like · 260 followers View post →
Sóis
@idrispukke_ · X

@hereb4_nd_after @owen_mccor They did not. https://t.co/oMeswuREbR https://t.co/LxKFQx5xrt

Apr 11, 2025 · 1 like · 125 followers View post →
Berat
@berattsyldz_ · X

@ancient_euro3 @oguzhantekden @NomadicEnjoyer @DanDavisWrites Yes, another question? https://t.co/JGqM2A7JbS https://t.co/EZAqHhWHdS

Mar 9, 2025 · 7 likes · 372 followers View post →
JP
@juandia07842974 · X

@wlan0_up @AlexanderC11360 @argdefender Pendejo, la piel clara precisamente viene de Oriente Próximo, los europeos originales no la tenian, si hoy la tienen es porque una población de Oriente Próximo (los agricultores neoliticos que menciono el otro sujeto) migro y lo introdujo https://t.co/4RuoK9R1Km https://t.co/HvX4g0nXDH

Feb 26, 2025 · 1 like · 322 followers View post →
Sean
@SeanBekkers · X

@steppingrazor90 @hawley_tami @PopBase Blonde hair evolved in Eurasia, like light skin, and never spread to Sub-Saharan Africa You can't have a mutation that never occurs in your population without mixed genetics Crazy how shocked you all are by this as if you know any blonde black people https://t.co/r9JyGutmTG

Feb 7, 2025 · 1 like · 396 followers View post →
⚜️ Evolved Melanin
@EvolMelanin · X

RT @Lusulpher1: @JJLK4R False #WhiteSupremacy narratives on EVOLUTIONARY THEORY/NATURAL SELECTION/"MASTER RACE", are OVER! Incredible good…

Jan 11, 2025 · 7 shares · 102 followers View post →
HagazagaH
@HagazagaH · X

@Greensharkfin @Tom_Rowsell https://t.co/dsYUZsN5HQ

Jan 9, 2025 · 1 like · 2,926 followers View post →
Nilakantha
@Nilakantha98751 · X

@DevarajaIndra @yajnadevam That paper seems to be just citing a 2008 study for this claim. See this 2020 paper: https://t.co/9XOp5qFCBX . A figure from the paper: @DevarajaIndra @yajnadevam https://t.co/UaGa9gWzrm

Jan 3, 2025 · 1 like · 143 followers View post →
JP
@juandia07842974 · X

@moreonthat99473 @nianello6 @kaido544 @wuttamadder @MelaninExtracts @KemiteGaming @KeMeT_roots @graytown68100 @Calamondins1 @WellnessCheck12 @U740_2 @kemetnubiakamp @KingEzana77 @BlackPa10086717 @Vic18246223 @Fv07wX9IdQEjEwU @hhhhhhbbhhbbbb @JBCrpted @Mikey234 @Woosey7945 @U780_2 @crypto_drm @iamfozzy27 @DOmowale @MiroCyo "Europeans arent a mix of short brown indigenous that's why they arent as dysgenic u idiot" XD XD The native Europeans were dark-skinned, very retarded, white skin comes from the Middle East. https://t.co/4RuoK9RzzU

Dec 23, 2024 · 3 likes · 322 followers View post →
Le nomade mental
@nomade_mental · X

@NicolasAlfonsi @marin_eben Les premiers chasseurs-cueilleurs d’Europe avaient bien la peau très foncée. C’est clairement documenté, y’a rien "idéologique". Faudrait veiller à ne pas prendre vos lubies pour des vérités absolues. https://t.co/fexik2q5C1 https://t.co/aD3VkHTKJw

Dec 14, 2024 · 662 followers View post →
JP
@juandia07842974 · X

@mmoreoe @Mr__Usher Tienes razón en el comentario anterior, pero no este. No es necesario que alguien de oriente Próximo tenga ascendencia europea para tener piel clara, de hecho lps genes de piel clars vienen de Oriente Próximo asinque es alreves https://t.co/4RuoK9R1Km

Dec 12, 2024 · 322 followers View post →
JustWatching
@KrieEis · X

@NurichH85083 @Einerlei123 @ottonisch @SILVERF26971227 Die Studie von Hanel und Carlberg schließt das übrigens mit ein und sagt dass es in Nord/Mitteleuropa bereits fortgeschrittener war mit weißer Haut. https://t.co/wlAuyiOB9G

Dec 11, 2024 · 12 followers View post →
PPV
@PedroPicazoVer · X

RT @CalcetinLetal: @PutoMikel 1- https://t.co/MJoS60GErG 2- https://t.co/vby32M25HR 3-https://t.co/P3LzL3v64V 4-https://t.co/6tpWFWg2rw Es…

Dec 10, 2024 · 1 share · 431 followers View post →
Mar
@25mar20001 · X

@365janeswf @PGonz8 Toma un estudio, de todas formas no entiendo porque tanto revuelo. https://t.co/i6JY3y67Vq

Dec 10, 2024 · 6 likes · 3 followers View post →
El nombre no puede estar en blanco
@CalcetinLetal · X

@PutoMikel 1- https://t.co/MJoS60GErG 2- https://t.co/vby32M25HR 3-https://t.co/P3LzL3v64V 4-https://t.co/6tpWFWg2rw Es clave diferenciar entre WHG y SHG. Y los estudios que mencionas dicen que los WHG tenían la piel "darker" que los europeos actuales, pero no "subsaharian dark".

Dec 10, 2024 · 25 likes · 1 share · 754 followers View post →
CT
@Cuttingtorch · X

@brinigad @GarbageHuman24 An update, Experimental Dermatology Volume 29, Issue 9, pg. 864-875, September 2020 (DOI:10.1111/exd.14142)

Dec 9, 2024 · 238 followers View post →
ecotono_
@ecotono_ · X

@Martin66052773 @ScottMicha95088 @runarorama @RadioGenoa The history of ancient european people https://t.co/7lZ2NCLyLC

Dec 7, 2024 · 11 likes · 245 followers View post →
Berat Yıldız
@z_berat82068 · X

https://t.co/nqgJlRIR7d https://t.co/rXCWUYC6S0

Nov 29, 2024 · 7 followers View post →
CT
@Cuttingtorch · X

@josephcotten2nd @jorymicah and the Near East [Eden}." - Prof. Carsten Carlberg & Andrea Hanel - Skin colour and Vitamin D: An update, Experimental Dermatology Volume 29, Issue 9, pg. 864-875, September 2020 (DOI:10.1111/exd.14142)

Nov 28, 2024 · 238 followers View post →
CT
@Cuttingtorch · X

@auny_marie @ComfyJager14 @StevePender @MetropolitanKi1 @la_chatte_verte @KarlRadl As if that wasn't enough we have the words of Carsten Carlberg and Andrea Hanel in their work Skin colour and Vitamin D: An update, Experimental Dermatology Volume 29, Issue 9, pg. 864-875, September 2020 (DOI:10.1111/exd.14142) (cont)

Nov 10, 2024 · 238 followers View post →
CT
@Cuttingtorch · X

@ComfyJager14 @StevePender @MetropolitanKi1 @la_chatte_verte @auny_marie @KarlRadl Experimental Dermatology Volume 29, Issue 9, pg. 864-875, September 2020 (DOI:10.1111/exd.14142)

Nov 9, 2024 · 238 followers View post →
CT
@Cuttingtorch · X

@ComfyJager14 @StevePender @MetropolitanKi1 @la_chatte_verte @auny_marie @KarlRadl "the light skin colour of today's Europeans is primarily based on non-synonymous SNPs of the genes SLC24A5 and SLC45A2, the geographical origin of which is western Asia and the Near East [Eden}." - Prof. Carsten Carlberg & Andrea Hanel - Skin colour and Vitamin D: An update,

Nov 9, 2024 · 238 followers View post →
Jeffrey G. Rosenberg
@JGRosie · X

@NiohBerg In fact, light skin and blue eyes have existed in the Middle East/Levant since at least 22,000 years ago (Look at Figure 2), over 10,000 years before many of the Indigenous Tribes formed in the region: https://t.co/nqfPN25GFX

Oct 13, 2024 · 1 like · 1,074 followers View post →
Baptiste Gilbert
@GilbertBap39155 · X

Bullshit. https://t.co/4MhPkHBNeZ https://t.co/IzHnfCxoUr

Sep 25, 2024 · 213 followers View post →
Baptiste Gilbert
@GilbertBap39155 · X

@ancient_euro3 @breton_bruce @dwengado Bullshit https://t.co/4MhPkHBNeZ

Sep 25, 2024 · 213 followers View post →
Sean
@SeanBekkers · X

@PrivateChefBari @ahawk1492 @chrsx_x878 @Mynamis_Private @GarbageHuman24 Genes for lighter skin originated 22,000 - 28,000 years ago The Giza pyramids are less than 5000 years old And FYI, "race" isn't a biological thing. The modern concept of race is only a few centuries old https://t.co/r9JyGutmTG

Sep 2, 2024 · 396 followers View post →
Sean
@SeanBekkers · X

@Coldcrush86 @EzekielRabeen @HomerFriedman @youreaquim @King19Tower @DreamLeaf5 Why would you look at the genetic history of "modern Europe" when talking about lighter skin? Light skin far precedes modern European ancestry A mutation for lighter skin was already carried by a person 22,000 - 28,000 years ago https://t.co/r9JyGutmTG

Aug 25, 2024 · 3 likes · 396 followers View post →
Average Chaos Space Marine Enjoyer
@AvgChsSpcMrn · X

@anarcho_app @NatchezIndian @darvidosiris So: To discuss this we need to discuss specifics Pale skin doesn’t evolve immediately, we know paler skin kicks off in west Asia. https://t.co/PBAtKCBmpR This is an update regarding a study that found two specific genes that correlated to lighter skin.

Aug 13, 2024 · 60 followers View post →
Who is the modern White Race and Jews?
@imgnocountries · X

It’s also imperative that I mention that recent studies say that skin color wound Not have developed due to environmental factors but instead changes in gene structure https://t.co/zWDBB15PyK

Aug 11, 2024 · 95 followers View post →
Who is the modern White Race and Jews?
@imgnocountries · X

@David_AI_ @Orwellsghost28 https://t.co/zWDBB15PyK some of your fellows are waking up but are still afraid to call it what it is. Why you so mad about the truth?

Aug 11, 2024 · 95 followers View post →
childeagrestis
@childeagrestis · X

@Tom_Rowsell @DanCollins2011 "variations in genes encoding for proteins ...provide alternative mechanisms of adaptation to a life in northern latitudes without suffering from consequences of vitamin D deficiency." https://t.co/dXCi0b0E7E

Jun 25, 2024 · 2 likes · 3 followers View post →
Lusulpher #CutTheCheck B1
@Lusulpher1 · X

RT @Lusulpher1: @JJLK4R False #WhiteSupremacy narratives on EVOLUTIONARY THEORY/NATURAL SELECTION/"MASTER RACE", are OVER! Incredible good…

Jun 24, 2024 · 7 shares · 1,107 followers View post →
isaacmczy
@isaacmczy · X

RT @Lusulpher1: @JJLK4R False #WhiteSupremacy narratives on EVOLUTIONARY THEORY/NATURAL SELECTION/"MASTER RACE", are OVER! Incredible good…

Jun 16, 2024 · 7 shares · 2,385 followers View post →
Julien Long
@nuitsbrumeuses · X

@eve_59699 @Ikersama @jeraeve @Luciana1235634 Rappelle toi que l'archéogénetique que la plupart des européens ne seraient blancs que depuis 8000 ans.

Jun 8, 2024 · 1 like · 310 followers View post →
jjjjj
@JJLK4R · X

@__FToni @WeWhiteWuz @Backagainpart37 @RAISRAEL2 https://t.co/PdGL7qmgLt

Apr 30, 2024 · 2 likes · 80 followers View post →
blkice
@sonikku956 · X

@sirgalahad76 @MulhollandL0ver The blue eyed mutation arose about 50,000 years ago in West Asia, and it made its way into Europe some time after before Europeans adapted light skin. https://t.co/khTGEN0p1p

Apr 23, 2024 · 5 likes · 175 followers View post →
Lusulpher #CutTheCheck B1
@Lusulpher1 · X

RT @JJLK4R: https://t.co/wCcgLIv3oT So the reason why people are "light skin" is not due to evolutionary factors of vitamin d deficiency a…

Mar 30, 2024 · 5 shares · 1,107 followers View post →
LeRaptorSauvage
@RaptorSauvage · X

@Kryss077 @konowryyyy_ https://t.co/PhRJn0qxIE

Mar 18, 2024 · 1 like · 1,351 followers View post →
LeRaptorSauvage
@RaptorSauvage · X

@Cyrus19159552 Vous êtes sûr de vos affirmations, vous avez des preuves scientifiques ? Car la génétique et les données paléoanthropologique ne corroborent pas vos affirmation. -https://t.co/PhRJn0qxIE -https://t.co/DWF4A1vSCD

Mar 18, 2024 · 10 likes · 1,351 followers View post →
SkibidiUltimate
@konowryyyy_ · X

@LeRaptorWild Les européens avaient tous la peau noire jusqu'il y a environ 10000 ans, et ils n'ont contribué que peu au génome des européens modernes (qui viennent ancestralement plutôt de diverses parties de l'Asie). https://t.co/fiRcNTudOy https://t.co/irBfWPKBNI https://t.co/cMfPbgWo8m https://t.co/KQP1zRXFT9

Mar 18, 2024 · 2 likes · 96 followers View post →
jjjjj
@JJLK4R · X

@ThoBelmont @EndWokeness This is bullshit https://t.co/wCcgLIuvzl https://t.co/3XpIkaQAXc

Mar 18, 2024 · 80 followers View post →
Jack
@IWasJack06807 · X

@OoJson @GaboPlayero @lufd_hamsda @iamyesyouareno "from your scientists"

Mar 4, 2024 · 2 followers View post →
Vajravarman
@kanhaibhatt1 · X

@KANZIGORE One more thing. Blue eyes come from West Asia too. Muh Aryan https://t.co/ZrerSPK2FU

Feb 21, 2024 · 145 followers View post →
BULKAN
@BULKAN35180551 · X

Skin colour and vitamin D: An update - Hanel - 2020 - Experimental Dermatology - Wiley Online Library https://t.co/bURq6tcaoV

Feb 16, 2024 · 160 followers View post →
Lusulpher #CutTheCheck B1
@Lusulpher1 · X

RT @Lusulpher1: @JJLK4R False #WhiteSupremacy narratives on EVOLUTIONARY THEORY/NATURAL SELECTION/"MASTER RACE", are OVER! Incredible good…

Feb 7, 2024 · 7 shares · 1,107 followers View post →
Meme Gene
@ofreacharound · X

“In summary, there is no convincing evidence of a direct evolutionary effect of vitamin D on skin lightening of Europeans.”

Jan 25, 2024 · 2 likes · 2,388 followers View post →
Þolandameðvirkur
@HaspennuHaffi · X

@Alice_LeClaire8 https://t.co/sm7fvwtdcT Poor guy’s a bit deaf. If you’re from northern europe you’re still way more genetically similar to his *very seperate Indo-Aryan not at all related to Indo-European* ancestors, even moreso if blonde hair’s common in your bloodline.

Jan 2, 2024 · 142 followers View post →
Þolandameðvirkur
@HaspennuHaffi · X

@Indo__Aryan https://t.co/sm7fvwtdcT You’re completely braindead https://t.co/63Er7mJTAF

Jan 2, 2024 · 1 like · 142 followers View post →
prahaar2
@prahaar_bharat · X

RT @dikgaj:

Dec 30, 2023 · 2 shares · 27 followers View post →
മെല്ലെ, മെല്ലെ പോവൂ.
@LenteCurrite · X

RT @dikgaj:

Dec 29, 2023 · 2 shares · 620 followers View post →
dikgaj
@dikgaj · X

Dec 29, 2023 · 2 shares · 7,923 followers View post →
Tom Dixon
@dixo27409033 · X

@superhumanic @dufrianord The genes for those traits didn’t come from Sweden, they migrated there. https://t.co/0XelZvBycW

Dec 28, 2023 · 220 followers View post →
jjjjj
@JJLK4R · X

RT @JJLK4R: https://t.co/wCcgLIv3oT So the reason why people are "light skin" is not due to evolutionary factors of vitamin d deficiency a…

Dec 28, 2023 · 5 shares · 80 followers View post →
Lusulpher #CutTheCheck B1
@Lusulpher1 · X

RT @Lusulpher1: @JJLK4R False #WhiteSupremacy narratives on EVOLUTIONARY THEORY/NATURAL SELECTION/"MASTER RACE", are OVER! Incredible good…

Dec 28, 2023 · 7 shares · 1,107 followers View post →
Lusulpher #CutTheCheck B1
@Lusulpher1 · X

@JJLK4R False #WhiteSupremacy narratives on EVOLUTIONARY THEORY/NATURAL SELECTION/"MASTER RACE", are OVER! Incredible good news!

Dec 28, 2023 · 14 likes · 7 shares · 1,107 followers View post →
Lusulpher #CutTheCheck B1
@Lusulpher1 · X

RT @JJLK4R: https://t.co/wCcgLIv3oT So the reason why people are "light skin" is not due to evolutionary factors of vitamin d deficiency a…

Dec 27, 2023 · 5 shares · 1,107 followers View post →
jjjjj
@JJLK4R · X

https://t.co/wCcgLIv3oT So the reason why people are "light skin" is not due to evolutionary factors of vitamin d deficiency and "dark skin" is not a prominent inhibiter of vitamin d synthesis? https://t.co/wOShZNcvbP

Dec 27, 2023 · 4 likes · 5 shares · 80 followers View post →
Lyly_Lei_Lei
@Lyly_Lei_Lei · X

@uhdinma @ZER06ON3 https://t.co/JrpWl5UNdD No because you didn’t link the original Wikipedia article nor the sources document. I found it but where in that image does it say blue eyes came from inbreeding? The closest it comes to that is interbreeding between species, as far as I can tell. https://t.co/g6lAHRtGfb

Dec 26, 2023 · 4 likes · 264 followers View post →
Knightsheart
@Knightsheart0 · X

@hori_s4 @TheRealNeoThe Hanel, Andrea: "Skin colour and vitamin D: An update". "Homo sapiens arrived in Europe from Near East some 42 000 years ago. These humans had dark skin but due to variations of their OCA2 gene many of them had blue eyes.

Dec 18, 2023 · 62 followers View post →
Bed$tuy
@BedStuy718347 · X

SLC24A5 , SLC45A2 https://t.co/DRDoAH1tWV https://t.co/7tEHlhyrPB

Nov 23, 2023 · 27 followers View post →
ja, älskling
@EnStillaUndran · X

Citat från https://t.co/r6Rkw9ps3Y som i sin tur refererar till https://t.co/RadXQdr4ty

Nov 13, 2023 · 1,244 followers View post →
Roy
@realRoyLiu · X

@urbanismguy @GraphCrimes Found one article that attributes skin lightening to migration from Anatolia and Central/Northern Asia to Europe, which kinda goes against the Vitamin D hypothesis. https://t.co/XxoOtYa7zz https://t.co/A83BOkG2YG

Nov 8, 2023 · 119 followers View post →
jjjjj
@JJLK4R · X

@feelingfineee @Berry_gojii @RandylVlarsh @natsocmedia @buymybooks2 @Lucas_Gage_ https://t.co/wCcgLIuvzl https://t.co/3N9b5rmNvx

Oct 22, 2023 · 80 followers View post →
Random
@rent_hero · X

@JenniferALeoni @_SchwarzenMann_ @eleanorzjames @stillgray According to your own source: "skin lightening happened as late as 5000 years ago" Which means pale white skin didn't develop in Europe until around 3000 BC. https://t.co/1GM400ya8n

Sep 25, 2023 · 986 followers View post →
R. Hotzenplotz
@Daseinsuhr · X

@LeoKlenze @redder66 @MartinKiesler https://t.co/7O5JdPpv1c

Aug 17, 2023 · 3 likes · 389 followers View post →
Luis Carlón
@LuisCarln2 · X

@WhiteRabbit36 Aquí una revisión bastante reciente y, parece, seria (no la he leído, a ver esta noche) de lo que hay y no hay de verdad en ese cuento mío: https://t.co/046n3RxBPK

Aug 16, 2023 · 43 followers View post →
سعد العريبي
@DSzbu0UWn4ewTXy · X

@wha_know @PhilistiaForeva أصل البشرة البيضاء هو من الشرق الأوسط والذي مرجعه فرد واحد عاش قبل ٢٢ إلى ٢٨ ألف سنة المصدر : https://t.co/irm8K2M1DN https://t.co/1Z6auGBXtb

Jun 1, 2023 · 1,078 followers View post →
Nexxo
@Nexxo00 · X

@scottishslander @SpeakinPieces @LeapIntoFoil @GraduatedBen https://t.co/1ifOdkzI5S

May 11, 2023 · 410 followers View post →
Red November
@RedNovember89 · X

@SinMinGav @Ardipithicus57 @LloydGeorge57 @theactivist113 Here a peer-reviewed study on light skin gene https://t.co/mA9NsexgU7

May 8, 2023 View post →
ALewis89
@masharn_lewis · X

RT @im_ready_tho: https://t.co/1TuHcEjvK2 https://t.co/1NQMyaj97D

Apr 30, 2023 · 1 share · 1,478 followers View post →
you_dont_know_me
@im_ready_tho · X

https://t.co/1TuHcEjvK2 https://t.co/1NQMyaj97D

Apr 29, 2023 · 2 likes · 1 share · 535 followers View post →
Hari
@Hari374432891 · X

@kemetnubiakamp @mxdmullah @Irish___Rose https://t.co/2KS1vzw2qh

Mar 21, 2023 · 410 followers View post →
ShoebillStork
@TrueShoebill · X

@Doreswami108 @Ugra___ that mediated it to EHG/SHG per the lightening paper Hanel & Carlberg 2020 https://t.co/ood8CfmhMx I don't want to suppose more than that we have data for. https://t.co/2xlyXfUIhV

Feb 4, 2023 · 745 followers View post →
ShoebillStork
@TrueShoebill · X

RT @TrueShoebill: Thanks to @bhaanavi for notifying me of paper Hanel & Carlberg 2020, "Skin colour and vitamin D: An update" https://t.co/…

Feb 2, 2023 · 1 share · 745 followers View post →
Amassing Dilettante
@GirardHolistic · X

RT @TrevorSutcliffe: Skin Color and Vitamin D: An Update "Yamnaya ancestry...had a dominant effect on the phenotype of northern Europeans.…

Feb 1, 2023 · 3 shares · 764 followers View post →
West Bestern
@western_bester · X

RT @TrevorSutcliffe: Skin Color and Vitamin D: An Update "Yamnaya ancestry...had a dominant effect on the phenotype of northern Europeans.…

Feb 1, 2023 · 3 shares · 29,515 followers View post →
ShoebillStork
@TrueShoebill · X

Thanks to @bhaanavi for notifying me of paper Hanel & Carlberg 2020, "Skin colour and vitamin D: An update" https://t.co/ood8CfmPC5 https://t.co/O20LPUEZJX

Feb 1, 2023 · 2 likes · 1 share · 745 followers View post →
Issachar Zevulun ✡♓
@blazar_jones · X

Anatolian Farmers were not white either... https://t.co/I2jEXNalRx https://t.co/Bqd3vqkN9s

Jan 27, 2023 · 2,702 followers View post →
NA
@nadjmaayth · X

https://t.co/L4Rnmft8iI

Jan 24, 2023 · 140 followers View post →
mobilization indicated
@shulamithbond · X

Another fun fact: The gene associated with light/"white" skin appeared about 22,000-28,000 years ago. The first humans to settle Europe migrated there about 40,000-50,000 years ago. Dark-skinned Europeans have always existed. https://t.co/jIslj5zRTl https://t.co/GFFCvXAvzP

Dec 7, 2022 · 282 followers View post →
King of the Bondo mystery apes
@AlannuhG · X

RT @Beyoku: Bio-Anthro Space. https://t.co/z42iJsBLxM https://t.co/tjHzucYp3L https://t.co/DdfFv434Bn https://t.co/w7Ck6PPAGv

Nov 21, 2022 · 2 shares · 593 followers View post →
AstenB
@Beyoku · X

Bio-Anthro Space. https://t.co/z42iJsBLxM https://t.co/tjHzucYp3L https://t.co/DdfFv434Bn https://t.co/w7Ck6PPAGv

Nov 21, 2022 · 6 likes · 2 shares · 1,174 followers View post →
Taranis Aquilois
@Aradi_20 · X

@ParisiiBlood https://t.co/IqiHAkcfhx

Nov 16, 2022 · 5,882 followers View post →
0mohamedkhalifa
@0mohamedkhalif1 · X

RT @AtlasGeoTopo: خارطة ظهور وانتشار الطفرات المحددة لتلون البشرة والعيون والمقترنة بالمورثات التالية : SLC24A5 SLC45A2 OCA2 KITLG _____ Ha…

Oct 30, 2022 · 1 share · 1,582 followers View post →
GeoAtlas الأطلس الجغرافي
@AtlasGeoTopo · X

خارطة ظهور وانتشار الطفرات المحددة لتلون البشرة والعيون والمقترنة بالمورثات التالية : SLC24A5 SLC45A2 OCA2 KITLG _____ Hanel & Carlberg 2020 Skin colour and vitamin D: An update https://t.co/Lfv2EDzsJE

Oct 30, 2022 · 2 likes · 1 share · 698 followers View post →
JPretellEsq
@JPretellEsq · X

@ragnars_repos @TalbertSwan Their is light skin and there is light skin. The light skin of northern regions without tanning capacity, probably. The light skin common in mediterranean populations, not so much. The near east was the origin. https://t.co/RY4XFN76NG https://t.co/lRcjMfPKgG

Sep 29, 2022 · 1 like · 761 followers View post →
Adi Arya
@adi__arya · X

@nrken19 https://t.co/LtpV1uQFOQ

Jun 27, 2022 · 1 like · 592 followers View post →
Adi Arya
@adi__arya · X

— via Wiley Library https://t.co/LtpV1uQFOQ

Jun 22, 2022 · 1 like · 592 followers View post →
Andrey
@Andreyfs · X

@jonesmanoel_PCB Detalhe (conhecimento científico do séc XXI agora) que a população europeia foi ficar embranquecida só há uns 5 mil anos atrás. E o embranquecimento teve origens externas à Europa. https://t.co/ZXJCehHsV5

Jun 20, 2022 · 33 likes · 132 followers View post →
Europäischer Ureinwohner
@Trilobot · X

@AdmiralHip @BryanMillsFist @DavidJonFuller @erik_kaars @ISASaxonists https://t.co/sMTBqexSrS the evolution of european light skin began with the development of agriculture roughly 11'000 years ago in anatolia and the levant. A more vegetarian diet (due to agriculture) provided less vitamin D. So the first farmers had to compensate their lack 1/x

May 23, 2022 · 136 followers View post →
American girl
@NeanderthalYT · X

RT @TrevorSutcliffe: Skin Color and Vitamin D: An Update "Yamnaya ancestry...had a dominant effect on the phenotype of northern Europeans.…

Apr 6, 2022 · 3 shares · 2,557 followers View post →
Trevor Sutcliffe
@TrevorSutcliffe · X

"In a north-south gradient, persons with ancestry from western European hunter-gatherers may show an intermediate responsiveness to vitamin D and those with Anatolian farmers the lowest" https://t.co/JmSu3ZUMgg

Apr 6, 2022 · 3 likes · 6,338 followers View post →
Trevor Sutcliffe
@TrevorSutcliffe · X

Skin Color and Vitamin D: An Update "Yamnaya ancestry...had a dominant effect on the phenotype of northern Europeans...Yamnayas also brought high vitamin D sensitivity to Europe, which may have originated predominantly from ancient North Eurasians." https://t.co/JmSu3ZUMgg https://t.co/XSKUa9dgXK

Apr 6, 2022 · 24 likes · 3 shares · 6,338 followers View post →
Guus Kroonen
@KroonenGuus · X

Blond haar is ook niet ontstaan bij de Indo-Europeanen, maar bij jagers-verzamelaars in Siberië en was rond 18.000 v.Chr. al aanwezig bij het Baikalmeer. Deze oer-Noord-Euraziaten brachten het na de IJstijd naar Noord-Europa. Lang vóór de Jamnajacultuur. https://t.co/Qp4qmFbFYy

Feb 3, 2022 · 1 like · 1,271 followers View post →
Dr.Mohammed Jabbar د.محمد جبار
@MohammedHJabbar · X

RT @Geno_Mena: أبحاث علوم الوراثة البشرية حددت منشأ التحورات المحددة لسمات البشرة الفاتحة وتلون العيون بمنطقة غرب آسيا بالفترة الباليوليثية…

Dec 7, 2021 · 8 shares · 295 followers View post →
0mohamedkhalifa
@0mohamedkhalif1 · X

RT @Geno_Mena: أبحاث علوم الوراثة البشرية حددت منشأ التحورات المحددة لسمات البشرة الفاتحة وتلون العيون بمنطقة غرب آسيا بالفترة الباليوليثية…

Dec 5, 2021 · 8 shares · 1,582 followers View post →
abo Ahmed
@R1a_HG · X

RT @Geno_Mena: أبحاث علوم الوراثة البشرية حددت منشأ التحورات المحددة لسمات البشرة الفاتحة وتلون العيون بمنطقة غرب آسيا بالفترة الباليوليثية…

Dec 5, 2021 · 8 shares · 24,832 followers View post →
Xx_faisal
@Xxfaisal4 · X

RT @Geno_Mena: أبحاث علوم الوراثة البشرية حددت منشأ التحورات المحددة لسمات البشرة الفاتحة وتلون العيون بمنطقة غرب آسيا بالفترة الباليوليثية…

Dec 5, 2021 · 8 shares · 686 followers View post →
الحارثة الثالث
@J1_FGC4415 · X

RT @Geno_Mena: أبحاث علوم الوراثة البشرية حددت منشأ التحورات المحددة لسمات البشرة الفاتحة وتلون العيون بمنطقة غرب آسيا بالفترة الباليوليثية…

Dec 5, 2021 · 8 shares · 230 followers View post →
زبيد طيىء مذحج FGC4421
@Zubaid_Tey · X

RT @Geno_Mena: أبحاث علوم الوراثة البشرية حددت منشأ التحورات المحددة لسمات البشرة الفاتحة وتلون العيون بمنطقة غرب آسيا بالفترة الباليوليثية…

Dec 5, 2021 · 8 shares · 5,158 followers View post →
فجري نصار بن فجري العازمي
@fajr123445 · X

RT @Geno_Mena: أبحاث علوم الوراثة البشرية حددت منشأ التحورات المحددة لسمات البشرة الفاتحة وتلون العيون بمنطقة غرب آسيا بالفترة الباليوليثية…

Dec 5, 2021 · 8 shares · 5,293 followers View post →
الجـيـنـوم الأثــري ❲ض❳
@Geno_Mena · X

أبحاث علوم الوراثة البشرية حددت منشأ التحورات المحددة لسمات البشرة الفاتحة وتلون العيون بمنطقة غرب آسيا بالفترة الباليوليثية قبل 22.000 سنة كما يظهر بالخارطة المرفقة : >> Origin of Blue Eyes and Light Skin الدراسة : Hanel & Carlberg 2020 Skin colour and vitamin D: An update https://t.co/Cp75rueSj7

Dec 5, 2021 · 15 likes · 8 shares · 11,931 followers View post →
Clown Hunter
@Clown22500580 · X

@_TheKingC evidence to suggest it already existed in the Near East and also the Middle East. https://t.co/frdkmjpRZY

Apr 23, 2021 · 3 likes · 263 followers View post →
François Booream
@BooraemFrancois · X

https://t.co/KDEn8aB8kt

Mar 19, 2021 · 718 followers View post →
Ken Gusler
@kgusler · X

Skin colour and vitamin D: An update - Hanel - Experimental Dermatology - https://t.co/rG0oDwV4fO

Sep 12, 2020 · 20,041 followers View post →
Gonzalo de Berceo/Puerta de Tannhäuser
@alftab3 · X

RT @librosdeholanda: "...skin lightening happened as late as 5000 years ago through immigration of lighter pigmented populations from weste…

Sep 8, 2020 · 1 share · 1,758 followers View post →
Pureza y peligro
@przyplgr · X

"...skin lightening happened as late as 5000 years ago through immigration of lighter pigmented populations from western Anatolia and the Russian steppe" https://t.co/CIfoVss69T

Sep 8, 2020 · 3 likes · 1 share · 538 followers View post →
ExpDermatol
@ExpDermatol · X

Skin colour and vitamin D: An update #VitaminD #skincolour https://t.co/tXnGhNEx93

Jul 29, 2020 · 2 likes · 1,077 followers View post →