Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
Overall, the discussions reflect strong support and active engagement, with examples such as multiple mentions of 'multiscale integration' as a key framework, and comments about the paper's influence on debates about internalism and externalism, illustrating how wording such as 'great work,' 'must read,' and 'opens new perspectives' conveys both enthusiasm and perceived significance.
Most discussions highlight support and appreciation for the article, emphasizing its relevance and connections to ongoing research on multiscale integration and cognitive boundaries.
Thanks to mentions of open access publications, upcoming discussions, and references to foundational theories, the discussions demonstrate high curiosity and engagement with the subject.
Many posts delve into specific concepts like the Markov blanket, variational principles, and implications across disciplines, showing deep involvement in the topic.
The discussions include praise for the paper’s significance, its influence on ongoing debates, and calls for broader dissemination, indicating a moderate level of impact within the academic and philosophical communities.
Extremely pleased to see such great and creative work, which builds on the account of nested selfhood that we propose in our paper "Multiscale integration: Beyond internalism and externalism." The paper addresses symbiotic selves under the free-energy principle. Must read! https://t.co/FV6bxPZhBx
New paper accepted with Michael Kirchhoff, @ConstantAxel, and @FarlKriston at Synthese. Contribution to the new Special Issue on Radical Views on Cognition. "Multiscale Integration: Beyond Internalism and Externalism" https://t.co/SQL1vN58hw
Following up on yesterday's awesome discussion. What do you think of this idea: the Markov blanket x generative model construct is both epistemological and ontological. I'm trying to find a third way between realism and anti-realism Argument is here: https://t.co/ILYug1tBto 1/6
Joining @mjdramstead @InferenceActive (+others?) on the team_comm open podcast this morning @ 10 to discuss "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism" -- should be fun! https://t.co/szmpyORt19
Multiscale Integration: beyond Internalism and Externalism https://t.co/4Ma2en3rP1 https://t.co/9dqJo7mREa
Awesome discussion on the team_comm podcast @InferenceActive! This episode sets the stage for our open podcast discussion. Really looking forward to team_comm 5.1 next Tuesday 29 September, on "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism"! https://t.co/ILYug1tBto https://t.co/ZWaskBZ6qo
Journal club discussion of Ramstead et al 2019 on multiscale cognitive integration using the Markov blanket formalism to bridge internalist and externalist perspectives, emphasizing flexible, context-dependent…
Contextualizing discussion of the upcoming journal club discussion on Ramstead et al 2019 Multiscale integration beyond internalism and externalism. The article proposes a multiscale integrationist view of cognitive…
Followup journal club discussion of the article Ramstead et al 2019 Multiscale integration beyond internalism and externalism. The article proposes a multiscale integrationist view of cognitive boundaries using the…
@HusbandOfLuck @AntonellaTrama3 Yes very related! Their abstract sounds very reasonable and reminds me of this paper - https://t.co/V9SEoGjkJt from @mjdramstead
RT @neuropoetic: @PsychScientists Yeah see for example one of Maxwell Ramstead’s earliest papers: https://t.co/4GuUc7adz7 Ps enjoy seeing…
@PsychScientists Yeah see for example one of Maxwell Ramstead’s earliest papers: https://t.co/4GuUc7adz7 Ps enjoy seeing you becoming more open minded towards FEP-AI
@dataengines @NoahGuzman14 @WiktorRorot Fair question. I’d point to the multi-scaleness of the free energy principle formulation: hyperparameters of densities at one scale are set by dynamics at superordinate scales, see e.g.: https://t.co/ILYug1c04O or https://t.co/5DJfFo0Mko
@MahaultAlbarra1 @BillardVincent @nonod971 @oakpope @wufert @Melanie_Vogel_ Plus spécifiquement avec Pierre Poirier, même si l'article sur l'approche variationnelle des scripts est tout aussi bon (j'avais juste un problème avec les parties internalisme/externalisme dont j'ai eu quelques réponses ici : https://t.co/USIC2eJbaU)
@cielclea ... et encore moins la psychiatrie biologique : https://t.co/ZOYlyLIFo6
@jeremy_royaux @3smog J'ai parlé de la dépression. La dépendance n'est pas une maladie pour d'autres raisons, valable aussi dans le débat "internaliste-externaliste" https://t.co/dSUWWXQPIH
@3smog ... la cognition. https://t.co/dSUWWXQPIH
RT @AndyFiloScience: A integração multiescala pode ser aplicada a uma colônia para determinar se ela é um sistema cognitivo? https://t.co/…
A integração multiescala pode ser aplicada a uma colônia para determinar se ela é um sistema cognitivo? https://t.co/mTdICq4hQH
@mjdramstead @KathrynNave We also consider operational closure under the FEP in this relatively recent paper: https://t.co/wWrdPuEzvP and we touch on it here as well: https://t.co/dUqyiSSnhi
RT @InferenceActive: Hello, here is a solo contextualization of some big #Philosophy of #Science topics, and how they relate to #ActiveInfe…
RT @exilefaker: Joining @mjdramstead @InferenceActive (+others?) on the team_comm open podcast this morning @ 10 to discuss "Multiscale int…
RT @exilefaker: Joining @mjdramstead @InferenceActive (+others?) on the team_comm open podcast this morning @ 10 to discuss "Multiscale int…
RT @exilefaker: Joining @mjdramstead @InferenceActive (+others?) on the team_comm open podcast this morning @ 10 to discuss "Multiscale int…
RT @exilefaker: Joining @mjdramstead @InferenceActive (+others?) on the team_comm open podcast this morning @ 10 to discuss "Multiscale int…
Joining @mjdramstead @InferenceActive (+others?) on the team_comm open podcast this morning @ 10 to discuss "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism" -- should be fun! https://t.co/szmpyORt19
RT @mjdramstead: Awesome discussion on the team_comm podcast @InferenceActive! This episode sets the stage for our open podcast discussion.…
RT @mjdramstead: Please consider joining us tomorrow (Tuesday 29 September) on the team_comm open podcast to discuss "Multiscale integratio…
Please consider joining us tomorrow (Tuesday 29 September) on the team_comm open podcast to discuss "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism," especially if you identify as women or as a racialized person https://t.co/ILYug1tBto DM @InferenceActive to join :)
RT @mjdramstead: Awesome discussion on the team_comm podcast @InferenceActive! This episode sets the stage for our open podcast discussion.…
RT @mjdramstead: Awesome discussion on the team_comm podcast @InferenceActive! This episode sets the stage for our open podcast discussion.…
Awesome discussion on the team_comm podcast @InferenceActive! This episode sets the stage for our open podcast discussion. Really looking forward to team_comm 5.1 next Tuesday 29 September, on "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism"! https://t.co/ILYug1tBto https://t.co/ZWaskBZ6qo
Hello, here is a solo contextualization of some big #Philosophy of #Science topics, and how they relate to #ActiveInference & #FEP https://t.co/bXeaySQSXZ , specifically the paper of @mjdramstead @ConstantAxel @MdKirchhoff from 2019 which we will discuss in ActInf Stream #5.1
RT @mjdramstead: Extremely pleased to see such great and creative work, which builds on the account of nested selfhood that we propose in o…
Extremely pleased to see such great and creative work, which builds on the account of nested selfhood that we propose in our paper "Multiscale integration: Beyond internalism and externalism." The paper addresses symbiotic selves under the free-energy principle. Must read! https://t.co/FV6bxPZhBx
Our next 6 weeks will be covering 3 exciting papers, and we are announcing them now so you have time to read & digest the ides: Sept 29th = 5.1 "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism", 2019 https://t.co/AszivKfCXr Oct. 6th = 5.2 builds on 5.1 4/5
@adamimos @InferenceActive @ineshipolito @bayesianboy Oh also, this is a companion philosophical paper that unpacks the implications of our variational approach to niche construction and ecology for the debates over internalism and externalism "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism" https://t.co/ILYug1tBto
@NeuroYogacara @rudzinskimaciej @StephenSillett FWIW, we make the argument about multiscale integration via policy selection in these papers: "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism" https://t.co/ILYug1c04O "Variational ecology and the physics of sentient systems" https://t.co/fCpKSxfg7V 3/2 lol
@_SalvorHardin @manuelbaltieri @_fernando_rosas @exilefaker @danijarh @conorheins @anilkseth @a_tschantz @drclbuckley @casper_hesp @lancelotdacosta @KaiUeltzhoeffer @GaneshNatesh @marcolin91 @jkbren @FranzKuchling @SantoshManicka @drmichaellevin Mine is here: "A tale of two densities" https://t.co/eNT2b1Bfz9 "Multiscale integration" https://t.co/ILYug1tBto "Variational ecology and the physics of sentient systems" https://t.co/EONNEjn70Q "Is the free-energy principle a formal theory of semantics?" https://t.co/6U1iCqZ9Xo
@IntuitMachine @SurviveThrive2 @StephenSillett @ineshipolito @manuelbaltieri 3. Autopoiesis: “Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism” https://t.co/ILYug1tBto “Where There is Life There is Mind” https://t.co/rVVQFBQueQ "The Markov blankets of life: autonomy, active inference and the free energy principle" https://t.co/itHc4E7Fts
@metadiogenes "Answering Schrödinger's question: A free-energy formulation" https://t.co/rB9P5JSkPI "Variational ecology and the physics of sentient systems" https://t.co/fCpKSxwRwv "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism" https://t.co/ILYug1tBto 1/2
RT @mjdramstead: @GaneshNatesh Yes, I think so. I have a paper about this "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism." We…
@GaneshNatesh Yes, I think so. I have a paper about this "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism." We argue that the boundaries of cognitive systems are multiple and nested, and that the relevant ones are relative to one's explanatory interest https://t.co/ILYug1tBto
@NoahGuzman14 "Variational ecology and the physics of sentient systems" https://t.co/fCpKSxwRwv "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism" "https://t.co/ILYug1tBto" Also see "Sentience and the Origins of Consciousness" https://t.co/uMjZsvBcgq 3/n
@gwenthomasdgi @twillierod @StephenSillett @ineshipolito @anjalibhat92 @dimitrisbolis @leoschilbach @sandervdc @ConstantAxel For a general, philosophically motivated take on the free-energy principle applied beyond the brain, I think my most accessible piece is "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism" https://t.co/ILYug1tBto P.S. All my publications are open access, no paywall :)
@neuropoetic @C_Allefeld @neurobongo @MGrrrls Yes, you have :) Thanks again so much. I think this is my most accessible piece and one of the easier ways into the free-energy principle literature "Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism" https://t.co/ILYug1tBto
RT @neuropoetic: @tim_elmo @rplevy I see... Well, it's time for me to do that "instead ramstead: So, for people like you who care about th…
@tim_elmo @rplevy I see... Well, it's time for me to do that "instead ramstead: So, for people like you who care about the philosophical nuances that you _won't_ find in Karl (not to be mean, it's just not his thing or priority), you should instead read @mjdramstead ! https://t.co/4GuUc79FJz
@MarkMJames @PsychScientists @bayesianboy 3. Ramstead, M. J. D., Kirchhoff, M. D., Constant, A., & Friston, K. J. (In press; online 2019). Multiscale integration: Beyond internalism and externalism. Synthese. https://t.co/yI4jIbKCdW (3/4)
@TransformSoc @ddrrnt @EnggMainR Since you dropped by.. I think this article helps nemetics.. https://t.co/18t3lmY7wf think I'm right?
@freerecall @EPoe187 @erikphoel edit: The development of my personal views was initiated by reading Erik Hoel's work, but there's lots of other cool stuff that impacted me afterwards. Strongly recommend these two works to bridge bio -> cogneuro https://t.co/4GuUc79FJz https://t.co/eCPnZJS4pk
RT @mjdramstead: Following up on yesterday's awesome discussion. What do you think of this idea: the Markov blanket x generative model cons…
RT @mjdramstead: Following up on yesterday's awesome discussion. What do you think of this idea: the Markov blanket x generative model cons…
RT @mjdramstead: Following up on yesterday's awesome discussion. What do you think of this idea: the Markov blanket x generative model cons…
RT @mjdramstead: Following up on yesterday's awesome discussion. What do you think of this idea: the Markov blanket x generative model cons…
Following up on yesterday's awesome discussion. What do you think of this idea: the Markov blanket x generative model construct is both epistemological and ontological. I'm trying to find a third way between realism and anti-realism Argument is here: https://t.co/ILYug1tBto 1/6
Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism - https://t.co/TcZD6ADzVx
Open Access UCL Research: Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism https://t.co/KF0jaCEdOg
Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism https://t.co/SGhIuJ2zP9
Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism https://t.co/U53huY5Ggo
@hardmaru Obligatory multiscale integration mention! Internal-external distinctions are blurry and context/goal-sensitive but @mjdramstead probably can find a better way to connect with this :D https://t.co/4GuUc79FJz
RT @mjdramstead: @distributedcog @Valar_Festivus @joe_dewhurst @danwilliamsphil @wrwveit also see: Korbak @tomekkorbak, "Computational ena…
@distributedcog @Valar_Festivus @joe_dewhurst @danwilliamsphil @wrwveit also see: Korbak @tomekkorbak, "Computational enactivism under the free energy principle" https://t.co/xSgoiLt0M3 Ramstead et al. "Multiscale integration" https://t.co/ILYug1tBto Ramstead et al. "Variational ecology" https://t.co/OpePGuIFgp 1/2
RT @marcolin91: @theblub @PabloRedux @eripsa @WiringTheBrain @jjfahrenfort @ProfFeynman @JamesGleick @fluffycyborg Or course I find myself…
RT @marcolin91: @theblub @PabloRedux @eripsa @WiringTheBrain @jjfahrenfort @ProfFeynman @JamesGleick @fluffycyborg Or course I find myself…
@theblub @PabloRedux @eripsa @WiringTheBrain @jjfahrenfort @ProfFeynman @JamesGleick @fluffycyborg Or course I find myself mentioning multiscale integration and @mjdramstead
RT @marcolin91: @joe_dewhurst @theblub @ancopeeters @IrisVanRooij @eripsa Obligatory @mjdramstead mention and multiscale integration paper…
@joe_dewhurst @theblub @ancopeeters @IrisVanRooij @eripsa Obligatory @mjdramstead mention and multiscale integration paper https://t.co/jLRGjSEIWF Someone please make a bot for dropping this in any int/ext debate
@distributedcog @neuroconscience @eripsa @mjdramstead @evantthompson @a_tschantz @micahgallen @seanmcarroll @the_mindwanders @HaymanG Enactivism has always been part&parcel of the foundations of active inference. Then again, so has internalism! Internal models emerge and have meaning only in our full coupling to the external world. See @mjdramstead 's new paper on multiscale integration https://t.co/eM5THe0owb
@davidarredondo @RealtimeAI @ToKTeacher @Crit_Rat @reasonisfun @cognazor I did touch on that but didn't expand on it, with "fuzzy, multi-level". https://t.co/rbVGigzVXt Here's a lucid account of the same view on this matter by some very lovely folks: https://t.co/jLRGjSEIWF
RT @mjdramstead: @eripsa @marcolin91 @joe_dewhurst @IrisVanRooij @theblub @ConstantAxel Interesting discussion. I deeply agree that the res…
RT @mjdramstead: @eripsa @marcolin91 @joe_dewhurst @IrisVanRooij @theblub @ConstantAxel Interesting discussion. I deeply agree that the res…
RT @mjdramstead: @eripsa @marcolin91 @joe_dewhurst @IrisVanRooij @theblub @ConstantAxel Interesting discussion. I deeply agree that the res…
@eripsa @marcolin91 @joe_dewhurst @IrisVanRooij @theblub @ConstantAxel Interesting discussion. I deeply agree that the resources of classical enactivism may be insufficient. Thankfully, there are other variants. Here's the open access version of our new compromise position, via Bayesian enactivism: https://t.co/ILYug1tBto
Multiscale integration: beyond internalism and externalism https://t.co/VLEqRjBU7G
@Scienc3 @introspection @ConstantAxel @FarlKriston Thanks :) We're quite pleased with the paper - and it's open access courtesy of the Wellcome Trust, so it can be shared far and wide - for free! https://t.co/O5Ju3Pd007
RT @introspection: Multiscale Integration: beyond Internalism and Externalism https://t.co/4Ma2en3rP1 https://t.co/9dqJo7mREa
Multiscale Integration: beyond Internalism and Externalism https://t.co/4Ma2en3rP1 https://t.co/9dqJo7mREa
Multiscale Integration: Beyond Internalism and Externalism https://t.co/Zrebl1uKZp
RT @mjdramstead: New paper accepted with Michael Kirchhoff, @ConstantAxel, and @FarlKriston at Synthese. Contribution to the new Special Is…
RT @mjdramstead: New paper accepted with Michael Kirchhoff, @ConstantAxel, and @FarlKriston at Synthese. Contribution to the new Special Is…
RT @mjdramstead: New paper accepted with Michael Kirchhoff, @ConstantAxel, and @FarlKriston at Synthese. Contribution to the new Special Is…
RT @mjdramstead: New paper accepted with Michael Kirchhoff, @ConstantAxel, and @FarlKriston at Synthese. Contribution to the new Special Is…
RT @mjdramstead: New paper accepted with Michael Kirchhoff, @ConstantAxel, and @FarlKriston at Synthese. Contribution to the new Special Is…
RT @mjdramstead: New paper accepted with Michael Kirchhoff, @ConstantAxel, and @FarlKriston at Synthese. Contribution to the new Special Is…
RT @mjdramstead: New paper accepted with Michael Kirchhoff, @ConstantAxel, and @FarlKriston at Synthese. Contribution to the new Special Is…
RT @mjdramstead: New paper accepted with Michael Kirchhoff, @ConstantAxel, and @FarlKriston at Synthese. Contribution to the new Special Is…
New paper accepted with Michael Kirchhoff, @ConstantAxel, and @FarlKriston at Synthese. Contribution to the new Special Issue on Radical Views on Cognition. "Multiscale Integration: Beyond Internalism and Externalism" https://t.co/SQL1vN58hw
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-019-02115-x. Ramstead, M. J. D., Veissière, S. P. L., & Kirmayer, L. J. (2016). Cultural affordances: Scaffolding local worlds ...
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-019-02115-x. Sato, R. (2016). Perceptual phenomenology and predictive processing: Five aspects of perception as a challenge ...
1479 10.1007/s11229-019-02115-x. 1480 Ramstead, M.J.D., Friston, K.J., & Hipólito, I. (2020). Is the free-energy principle a. 1481 formal theory of semantics ...
URL https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-019-02115-x. Anand S Rao, Michael P Georgeff, et al. BDI agents: from theory to practice. In Proceedings of ...
MR
QE
GD
MT
BC
NR
N
PP
AF
MK
ER
MM
DV
MC
CM
A
AI
DO
RA
MJ
CP
BK
D
UD
IW
C
C
PH
ML
CH
EC
IR
BF
LS
PA
AC
DM
AC
CW
CH
JH
AT