Synopsis of Social media discussions
The discussions show strong agreement with the article's thesis, with posts citing its explanation of why animal communication lacks productivity and stressing the necessity of social cooperation, using words like 'fantastic' and phrases like 'high-level cooperation,' which reflect genuine interest and engagement that could impact how people view evolutionary linguistics and animal behavior.
Agreement
Moderate agreementMost users agree that animal communication systems are complex and do not qualify as simple languages, supported by statements emphasizing the importance of cooperation and social context.
Interest
High level of interestDiscussions demonstrate high interest, with mentions of the article's insights, references to further research, and curiosity about animal and extraterrestrial communication.
Engagement
Moderate level of engagementWhile some posts merely share the article or express short reactions, others delve into explanations of evolutionary factors and compare human and animal communication, indicating moderate engagement.
Impact
Moderate level of impactThe conversation reveals that the article influences perspectives on communication complexity in animals, and some posts highlight its relevance to broader questions like exobiology, suggesting it has a meaningful scientific impact.
Social Mentions
YouTube
2 Videos
21 Posts
Blogs
2 Articles
Metrics
Video Views
7,136
Total Likes
727
Extended Reach
91,570
Social Features
25
Timeline: Posts about article
Top Social Media Posts
A.Benítez-Burraco
Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages?
https://t.co/Gse5rnuZSF
❌Cognitive and signal production mechanisms are necessary pre-adaptations, but this is not enough
✔️ A socio-ecology that requires high-level cooperation b/w signalers and receivers is also needed https://t.co/gAMpmtp6wt
view full post
Animal Prattle
Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/ZSOX30MFGW
view full post
Radical Anthropology
This article is right on it as to why nonhumans don't evolve a 'simple' language. Signaler and receiver are too competitive! Humans only did it through aligning near-identical interests of signaler and receiver across wide social contexts 1/
https://t.co/Mm9PF7qLob
view full post
Alireza Dehbozorgi
Fantastic article on "Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? (2021)" by Prof. Michael D. Beecher (https://t.co/RrpW3WWjm7). A 16-page paper abundant with treasured information on animal communication systems and the comparisons and contrasts with human langs.
view full post
Frontiers - Psychology
New Research: Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/P739UxehWN #Psychology #Psych
view full post
Posts referencing the article
Do All Dogs Speak the Same Language? Scientific Insights on Canine Communication
Do dogs understand each other's barks? This video explores how different dog breeds have distinct vocalizations and covers scientific findings on animal communication's complexity, focusing on why animal languages aren't simple and how cooperation influenced human language development.
May 2, 2022
1,575 views
-
@pedrocertezas Explicado aqui: https://t.co/XyBH3P1RHP e a resposta é ASSISTA.
view full postNovember 12, 2024
-
Animal Prattle
@animal_prattle (Twitter)You, a tourist in animal communication, with your AI and your ignorance of the definition of the word language: "I'm building a birdsong chatbot"
view full postOctober 18, 2024
2
-
Altay de Souza
@altayals (Twitter)@guimarrocos @caiocgomes Ep 212 - Cachorros podem se comunicar como humanos? https://t.co/PzL8xvzzWN Ep 332 - Todos os cachorros falam a mesma língua? https://t.co/G0cVEWYF53
view full postJanuary 14, 2023
1
-
Arnold Doray
@arnolddoray (Twitter)RT @BDehbozorgi83: https://t.co/t9S1idXk3f
view full postJune 27, 2022
1
-
Alireza Dehbozorgi
@BDehbozorgi83 (Twitter)https://t.co/t9S1idXk3f
view full postJune 27, 2022
2
1
-
Alireza Dehbozorgi
@BDehbozorgi83 (Twitter)Fantastic article on "Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? (2021)" by Prof. Michael D. Beecher (https://t.co/RrpW3WWjm7). A 16-page paper abundant with treasured information on animal communication systems and the comparisons and contrasts with human langs.
view full postJune 27, 2022
7
1
-
Pierre F. Lherisson
@P_F_Lherisson_ (Twitter)If humans❌talk to other life forms on earth, how they will talk with exobiology beings? Why Are No Animal Communication Systems.? https://t.co/HLs9PffYFT By Dec 2021, 1 billion surveillance cameras will be installed worldwide. Surveil camera statistics https://t.co/V6oOEW7uhg
view full postMay 25, 2021
-
Frontiers - Psychology
@FrontPsychol (Twitter)New Research: Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/P739UxehWN #Psychology #Psych
view full postApril 25, 2021
2
-
Radical Anthropology
@radicalanthro (Twitter)RT @radicalanthro: This article is right on it as to why nonhumans don't evolve a 'simple' language. Signaler and receiver are too competit…
view full postApril 18, 2021
2
-
bioartsociety
@bioartsociety (Twitter)RT @radicalanthro: This article is right on it as to why nonhumans don't evolve a 'simple' language. Signaler and receiver are too competit…
view full postApril 18, 2021
2
-
Radical Anthropology
@radicalanthro (Twitter)This article is right on it as to why nonhumans don't evolve a 'simple' language. Signaler and receiver are too competitive! Humans only did it through aligning near-identical interests of signaler and receiver across wide social contexts 1/ https://t.co/Mm9PF7qLob
view full postApril 18, 2021
7
2
-
Daniela Pörtl
@mensch_hund (Twitter)RT @abenitezburraco: Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/Gse5rnuZSF ❌Cognitive and signal production mec…
view full postApril 12, 2021
8
-
Cervelle d'Oiseau - Studies
@d_studies (Twitter)RT @animal_prattle: Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/ZSOX30MFGW
view full postApril 8, 2021
3
-
Matthew McKim Louder
@MIMLouder (Twitter)RT @animal_prattle: Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/ZSOX30MFGW
view full postApril 7, 2021
3
-
Animal Prattle
@animal_prattle (Twitter)Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/ZSOX30MFGW
view full postApril 7, 2021
9
3
-
Inna Vorobey
@inna_vorobey (Twitter)RT @abenitezburraco: Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/Gse5rnuZSF ❌Cognitive and signal production mec…
view full postApril 7, 2021
8
-
Tom Sawallis
@TomSawallis (Twitter)RT @abenitezburraco: Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/Gse5rnuZSF ❌Cognitive and signal production mec…
view full postApril 6, 2021
8
-
Claire Pérez
@clairecprez1 (Twitter)RT @abenitezburraco: Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/Gse5rnuZSF ❌Cognitive and signal production mec…
view full postApril 6, 2021
8
-
Mélissa Berthet
@BerthetMelissa (Twitter)RT @abenitezburraco: Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/Gse5rnuZSF ❌Cognitive and signal production mec…
view full postApril 6, 2021
8
-
kepkee
@kepkeeloh (Twitter)RT @abenitezburraco: Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/Gse5rnuZSF ❌Cognitive and signal production mec…
view full postApril 6, 2021
8
-
A.Benítez-Burraco
@abenitezburraco (Twitter)Why Are No Animal Communication Systems Simple Languages? https://t.co/Gse5rnuZSF ❌Cognitive and signal production mechanisms are necessary pre-adaptations, but this is not enough ✔️ A socio-ecology that requires high-level cooperation b/w signalers and receivers is also needed https://t.co/gAMpmtp6wt
view full postApril 6, 2021
13
8
Abstract Synopsis
- The article explains why animal communication systems are not simple languages, even though some animals can learn basic versions of human language, by examining key features that define language, like productivity and social cooperation.
- Bird song is used as a case study to show that, while it has complex and nuanced features, it lacks true productivity, meaning animals cannot use it to convey many different meanings.
- The evolution of human language likely depended on high-level cooperation and aligned interests among individuals in early human societies, especially within hunter-gatherer groups, which fostered the development of fully productive language systems.
kbecatv
@kbecaTV (Twitter)