Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
Overall, the group's explorations of the article reveal a strong consensus that excess mortality data exposes a much higher COVID-19 toll in Russia than officially acknowledged. The tone and word choices, such as 'ridiculous undercount,' 'manipulation,' and references to detailed studies, emphasize skepticism and the urgency to question official statistics, indicating a high level of interest and engagement with the subject's societal impact.
Most discussions strongly support the idea that Russia's official COVID-19 death toll is underestimated, often citing excess mortality data and studies to back their claims.
Participants show high curiosity about the true impact of COVID-19 in Russia, referencing detailed analyses, studies, and regional data.
Many posts analyze statistical discrepancies, comment on governmental transparency, and cite research, indicating deep involvement in the topic.
The discussions highlight significant concern about underreporting and its implications, suggesting the findings could influence public perception and policy debates.
For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg and the accompanying @signmagazine paper: https://t.co/jhPus0HUCw https://t.co/ZpwcbbOmHU
Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous underdispersion, strong undercount (3.3). Reporting is based on lies. (See also my previous paper in @signmagazine on Russia: https://t.co/IfDEGhgiul.) /10 https://t.co/Vttt5QrPMG
9/15 Вот данные об избыточной смертности Дмитрия Кобака https://t.co/Qwcato2Ko1 вот данные по регионам России https://t.co/6CMFvzUD2w и статья Дмитрия в журнале Significance Королевского статистического общества https://t.co/meR1KGdS44
Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the #covid19 death toll than the official daily updated number, argues Dmitry Kobak (@hippopedoid) https://t.co/GiiJC7oMb5 #freetoread https://t.co/qBZlb3qJAc
שותפי למחקר @hippopedoid עוקב אחר התמותה העודפת ברוסיה גם בחלוקה אזורית (עד סוף נובמבר 2021): https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg וכתב על כך מאמר לכתב העת @signmagazine: https://t.co/jhPus0HUCw https://t.co/FvWD7YCgmu
From the other direction: Russia, where the trend is NEGATIVE. Less people died every passing year during 2015-2019. Ignoring it will lead to UNDER-estimation of excess deaths. Russia's NSO predicted deaths to fall in 2020 before COVID! See Kobak (2021): https://t.co/QDW2hicxmA https://t.co/AVvWO6sn3O
This case report discusses a severe SARS-CoV-2 reinfection with the South African 501YV2 variant, involving a 58-year-old male with prior mild COVID-19. Despite previous infection, he experienced severe respiratory…
The official Covid-19 death toll stands at about 55 million as of January 2022, but excess mortality estimates suggest a death toll between 1222 million, highlighting widespread underreporting. This video explores how…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
@KaplanJohannes @El_Zocko87 @LeTinou80 @hosjon00 https://t.co/i91KQuxnVO
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
RT @hippopedoid: Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous u…
Getting back to Russia and Ukraine. Ukraine: no underdispersion, moderate undercount (1.8). Honest. Russia: ridiculous underdispersion, strong undercount (3.3). Reporting is based on lies. (See also my previous paper in @signmagazine on Russia: https://t.co/IfDEGhgiul.) /10 https://t.co/Vttt5QrPMG
@WrongAgainIvor Russia's official COVID-19 statistics are probably about as real as their official election results. Putin gonna Putin.
24/B Similarly, one wouldn't claim the pandemic is over just because Russia etc. eased off restrictions, with a large number of excess deaths caused by COVID-19. https://t.co/9EpxiCghLh https://t.co/exCxe9CruD @ArielKarlinsky from 30:11 - 31:16 : https://t.co/jAQupHyIkV
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
@msabouri @PienaarJm Re: "We know with some certainty that over 2 years Russia has had way more excess deaths than Covid deaths." So you don't realize Russia's government under-estimated (likely willfully) COVID-19 deaths?
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
שותפי למחקר @hippopedoid עוקב אחר התמותה העודפת ברוסיה גם בחלוקה אזורית (עד סוף נובמבר 2021): https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg וכתב על כך מאמר לכתב העת @signmagazine: https://t.co/jhPus0HUCw https://t.co/FvWD7YCgmu
RT @ArielKarlinsky: For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg an…
For an in-depth regional analysis of excess mortality in Russia (Up to November 2021), see: https://t.co/HfwtER2NFg and the accompanying @signmagazine paper: https://t.co/jhPus0HUCw https://t.co/ZpwcbbOmHU
It has the regularly updated analysis of the two influential papers @ArielKarlinsky @hippopedoid World Mortality Dataset @eLife mid 2021 https://t.co/sI3iCEht6H and @hippopedoid paper on Russia in @signmagazine early 2021 https://t.co/Wfc5sVI7II https://t.co/cf8KUGLHLe
RT @hippopedoid: My paper analyzing excess mortality in Russia in April-November 2020 (264k deaths) is out in @signmagazine with great edit…
@DeepSchneider @haskelloween по всем смертям? а как это объяснить тогда лол https://t.co/8Fp70KxOZt
@thehowie There is actual data supporting this. They've been really bad. https://t.co/BKcjRrjeKz
@srbonfiretoffee Yes, sure, the undercount ratio in last months in Russia has been between 2 and 3. It used to be much higher by the way, but got better recently. Still too high of course. https://t.co/083u98Q847 https://t.co/IfDEGhgiul https://t.co/wN2pmJEXBw https://t.co/SSGHxRJR1E
@Ynav @BenGera9 https://t.co/1S5iveIcZ5 https://t.co/5zdqZrCsEC הממצאים האלה נמצאים גם במאמר שלנו שעבר ביקורת עמיתים: https://t.co/bokyV6B6EI וגרסה קצת יותר מוקדמת אבל גם קצת יותר נגישה במאמר של עמיתי @hippopedoid: https://t.co/QDW2hicxmA
RT @ArielKarlinsky: @leonardocarella @AndreasShrugged There's ample evidence that Russia manipulates their COVID death counts. See Kobak (…
@BallouxFrancois There's ample evidence that Russia manipulates their COVID death counts. See Kobak (2021) and Karlinsky & Kobak (2021). https://t.co/QDW2hicxmA https://t.co/bokyV6B6EI https://t.co/o77fQ3ia4N
@leonardocarella @AndreasShrugged There's ample evidence that Russia manipulates their COVID death counts. See Kobak (2021) and Karlinsky & Kobak (2021) https://t.co/QDW2hicxmA https://t.co/bokyV6B6EI https://t.co/rXgf50azWZ
@Krieger66362259 Surmortalité en Russie en 2020 : https://t.co/Wbcb0nPsqh https://t.co/iLuLl5UC7w
RT @ArielKarlinsky: From the other direction: Russia, where the trend is NEGATIVE. Less people died every passing year during 2015-2019. I…
From the other direction: Russia, where the trend is NEGATIVE. Less people died every passing year during 2015-2019. Ignoring it will lead to UNDER-estimation of excess deaths. Russia's NSO predicted deaths to fall in 2020 before COVID! See Kobak (2021): https://t.co/QDW2hicxmA https://t.co/AVvWO6sn3O
19/U Levin et al. implies ~1% IFR for St. Petersburg, Russia. But the Russian government's official total under-estimates COVID-19 deaths: https://t.co/exCxe9CruD https://t.co/9EpxiCghLh [https://t.co/K4WblKl3A6] Excess deaths fits the prediction: https://t.co/Ao1ALyWydy https://t.co/LI2fSl6pKr
Note that Russian COVID-19 deaths are likely underreported. See, e.g., https://t.co/XFAnDOzXxw by @hippopedoid Updates here https://t.co/rAXU7qM6Bx @ikashnitsky may also chip in
Here's a study about the large discrepancy in reported deaths, last year was likely twice as bad as in terms of deaths than the US. https://t.co/k976wYQIuK
@Fockdatshitt @XtazGamess @JLGagnaire @Le_Figaro @MLP_officiel @JLMelenchon Mais dans la mesure où tu sembles être totalement abruti, ou totalement de mauvaise foi a dire qu'il n'y a toujours pas de source Tu peux aller lire et te documenter sur les travaux de Kobak Tu veux pas non plus une traduction et surligner des passages ? https://t.co/wGGCDFbdGF
@dudkevi4 @shcherbininainn @maria09121953 Ось тут коеф трохи менший - 1,8. Більше, ніж в 3 рази - то вигадки або, скажімо, песимістичні гіпотези https://t.co/QTtGJvfOZu
@saifedean Gray column is official COVID deaths, red one - real, based on numbers of excessive death. https://t.co/zAbE02lZPV https://t.co/IpYNijz6EN https://t.co/6Rwp7UtBDw
Оросын дарж байгаа жинхэнэ Ковидын нас баралтын тоо мэдээлэгдэж байгаагаас 6 дахин их байх магадлал байна гэнэ. Нийт ковидын нас баралт 2020 оны 11 сар хүртэл: 200 000 гарам... https://t.co/oV49GYural
@yahireu0071 @GDANIELDS @vonderleyen https://t.co/xS1mgmVJmj for instance
RT @hippopedoid: My paper analyzing excess mortality in Russia in April-November 2020 (264k deaths) is out in @signmagazine with great edit…
RT @PGuerendel: @vincentglad Plus!, car il y a en Russie certainement + que 250K de deces cumule maintenant https://t.co/nxyC0l1oOh et il…
@vincentglad Plus!, car il y a en Russie certainement + que 250K de deces cumule maintenant https://t.co/nxyC0l1oOh et il y a aussi bcp d'excess mortality ailleurs en Europe https://t.co/yH40ASK1C3
@lonougou @dr_l_alexandre @OlivierBabeau @nbouzou @YvesPDB @LezatDarcourt @alainhoupert @GilbertDeray @nathanpsmad Mis à part Moscow & Saint-Pete, les chiffres officiels en Russie ne sont pas représentatif de la réalité (~ 7 fois + de décès). Et donc la baisse pourrait s’expliquer par un taux d’immunisation déjà élevé de gens précédemment contaminés https://t.co/nxyC0l1oOh
@andrey_malgin https://t.co/QTtGJvfOZu
@novaya_gazeta Ого, интересная информация. Только согласно анализу на основе открытых данных, только с апрель по ноябрь 2020 было больше 200 тысяч человек. https://t.co/k9feQ5k44O Судя по достоверности, это данные ВЦИОМА, так не пи**ит даже Росстат.
@MBKhMedia Ого, интересная информация. Только согласно анализу на основе открытых данных, только с апрель по ноябрь 2020 было больше 200 тысяч человек. https://t.co/k9feQ5k44O Судя по достоверности, это данные ВЦИОМА, так не пи**ит даже Росстат.
@aavst Тут, конечно, анализ с апреля по ноябрь 2020, но статья интересная. https://t.co/k9feQ5k44O
@greg_doucette This might be of interest https://t.co/XFAnDOzXxw See also https://t.co/fTfqhV5lZn
RT @glinch72: Estimate of excess deaths: https://t.co/4KZdIA8PyP https://t.co/DNlFODMkKr
Estimate of excess deaths: https://t.co/4KZdIA8PyP https://t.co/DNlFODMkKr
@Rhiannashair @GregDee20 @Moss_Stenson @FergalBowers @rtenews https://t.co/YyXduYusCP
https://t.co/h746A7APiI
RT @hippopedoid: My paper analyzing excess mortality in Russia in April-November 2020 (264k deaths) is out in @signmagazine with great edit…
@WahnSager Russland meldete für Apr-Nov'20 40.500 Covid-19-Tote, gleichzeitig aber 264.100 Tote Übersterblichkeit, das 6.5-fache. Das versteht unser Statistik-Genie nicht. https://t.co/rl8e6x0Q2y https://t.co/YjkHxpqItk
RT @hippopedoid: My paper analyzing excess mortality in Russia in April-November 2020 (264k deaths) is out in @signmagazine with great edit…
@brubrubraz I don’t know how much we can trust official stats though, because Russia has issues with excess deaths. https://t.co/85R67QMpRA So we are almost as the US...but our population is way smaller https://t.co/GMiNhZEblR
RT @sguriev: 9/15 Вот данные об избыточной смертности Дмитрия Кобака https://t.co/Qwcato2Ko1 вот данные по регионам России https://t.co/6C…
RT @sguriev: 9/15 Вот данные об избыточной смертности Дмитрия Кобака https://t.co/Qwcato2Ko1 вот данные по регионам России https://t.co/6C…
RT @sguriev: 9/15 Вот данные об избыточной смертности Дмитрия Кобака https://t.co/Qwcato2Ko1 вот данные по регионам России https://t.co/6C…
9/15 Вот данные об избыточной смертности Дмитрия Кобака https://t.co/Qwcato2Ko1 вот данные по регионам России https://t.co/6CMFvzUD2w и статья Дмитрия в журнале Significance Королевского статистического общества https://t.co/meR1KGdS44
@PAlfthan @mtmalinen @GraviolaDOTfi ... Suomessa, koska epidemia ei ole päässyt leviämään rajoitustoimien ansiosta. Sitten taas esim. Yhdysvalloissa on. Tai Venäjällä, jossa ylikuolleisuus viime vuonna oli 250 000 ihmisen luokkaa. https://t.co/4BftjU2HAs
@i_eto_projdet Уже посчитали. У нас первое место, если не считать Перу. И по Индии статистики нет, там вообще непонятно что творится https://t.co/oh2SnC6ItA
RT @signmagazine: Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the #covid19 death toll than the official daily u…
RT @niktwick: Assuming a population of 41 million, that amounts to 78 deaths per 100,000 instead of the official 45. But that is still much…
RT @signmagazine: Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the #covid19 death toll than the official daily u…
Assuming a population of 41 million, that amounts to 78 deaths per 100,000 instead of the official 45. But that is still much, much less than Russia's estimated excess death rate of 256 (officialy 55) see https://t.co/owBIRHY6un
@BandyXLee1 https://t.co/gpqFtPAYh2 Dr John Campbell @Johnincarlisle Excess mortality, etc. Published Feb 15, 2021
RT @old_akela: В журнале Significance британского Королевского статистического общества и Американской статистической ассоциации вышла стат…
Reinfection with South African variant https://t.co/7YxxaV09f7 via @YouTube
RT @signmagazine: Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the #covid19 death toll than the official daily u…
RT @signmagazine: Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the #covid19 death toll than the official daily u…
Update https://t.co/mTrYPs9h5S via @YouTube
RT @signmagazine: Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the #covid19 death toll than the official daily u…
RT @Russ1314: @CaraMia200 @DavidKehoe10 @DanielAndrewsMP Interesting comments from UK authority Dr John Campbell about Victoria (& Australi…
@CaraMia200 @DavidKehoe10 @DanielAndrewsMP Interesting comments from UK authority Dr John Campbell about Victoria (& Australia) handling the pandemic - about 13 minutes in: https://t.co/rGYZFxZR64
Update (engels) over geneesmiddelen voor #Covid_19 #covid19 en #griep #influenza met #peerreview https://t.co/PJ6Rvs0JX9 via @YouTube
Update https://t.co/2AAiAFJVwB John Campbell reviewing re-infections, which are rare
Excess deaths under-reporting. https://t.co/OACMoT9pfM
RT @signmagazine: Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the #covid19 death toll than the official daily u…
https://t.co/n4lCN9UQVq https://t.co/lY49K0dfDO
Update https://t.co/e78uj5icnl via @YouTube
RT @signmagazine: Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the #covid19 death toll than the official daily u…
RT @signmagazine: Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the #covid19 death toll than the official daily u…
RT @signmagazine: Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the #covid19 death toll than the official daily u…
Data on excess deaths in Russia in 2020 paint a much bleaker picture of the #covid19 death toll than the official daily updated number, argues Dmitry Kobak (@hippopedoid) https://t.co/GiiJC7oMb5 #freetoread https://t.co/qBZlb3qJAc
https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1740-9713.01486
Der korrekte Link zu der #Corona-Studie über die epidemiologische Situation in #Russland und die dortige #COVID19-Sterblichkeit: https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/1740-9713.01486
And... we're still #1 https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley. com/doi/full/10.1111/1740-9713.01486?af=R · No photo description available. Diana Di ...
And... we're still #1 https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley. com/doi/full/10.1111/1740-9713.01486?af=R · No photo description available. Diana Di ...
... 10.1111/1740-9713.01486. Kontis, V. et al. (2020) /// Magnitude, demographics and dynamics of the effect of the first wave of the COVID-19 ...
Available from: https://doi.org/10.1111/1740- 9713.01486 (accessed: 15 June 2022). 5. OECD. Health at a Glance. Europe 2022. Available from ...
https://doi.org/10.1111/1740-9713.01486. 140. Kontis, V. et al. (2020) /// Magnitude, demographics and dynamics of the effect of the first ...
com/doi/full/10.1111/1740-9713.01486?af=R · No photo description available. Diana Di Rosa and 4 others. 5 reactions ·. 1 comment. Heiko Stang ...
And... we're still #1 https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley. com/doi/full/10.1111/1740-9713.01486?af=R · No photo description available. Diana Di ...
com/doi/10.1111/1740-9713.01486 https://www.bmj. com/content/372/bmj.n440 https://www.bmj. com/content/371/bmj.m4975 https://www ...
And... we're still #1 https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley. com/doi/full/10.1111/1740-9713.01486?af=R · No photo description available. Diana Di ...
And... we're still #1 https://rss.onlinelibrary.wiley. com/doi/full/10.1111/1740-9713.01486?af=R · No photo description available. Diana Di ...
AK
DK
SG
S
RE
MM
DS
MS
ピ世
JT
煩
PC
LS
HR
JC
CI
MG
HA
AS
R
ZK
B
FB
TO
GA
M
LP
AK
ÁC
K
SH
IP
M
F
PD
K
M
ID
MP
JC
LB
С
KF
AG
MН
LF
S
PG
Д
DK
LM
D
A
B
TD
NR
T
HG
PT
M
ПТ
MY
NT
L
MB
SV
JA
K
VZ
RS