Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
Multiple discussions include references to the alarming increase in adolescents seeking treatment for gender dysphoria, with users using figures like '4,400% increase' to underscore their concerns. Additionally, phrases like 'important new paper' and 'must read' reveal a serious tone and urgency regarding the implications of the study, suggesting that the article resonates strongly within certain communities focused on mental health and gender identity, reinforcing the complexities surrounding gender affirming care.
While there is a mix of responses, many posts express a general support for the article's critical perspective on current practices in gender-affirming care.
High interest is evident as numerous discussions revolve around the implications of the findings and personal anecdotes relating to detransitioning.
The level of engagement varies, with some users providing detailed critiques and references to the publication, while others present simplistic reactions that lack depth.
Several users express that the article has the potential for significant influence on public understanding and discussion regarding gender affirming care and detransitioning cases.
Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “concretizes psychic pain, locates it in the body, and seeks biomedical treatments for it.” The full paper is available below. /6 https://t.co/OOmKdNITyD
Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
By @LisaMarchiano: "My view is that the affirmative model of care concretizes psychic pain, locates it in the body, and seeks biomedical treatments for it. Paradoxically, it also offers a compensatory belief in a disembodied, ineffable essence." https://t.co/XEeByTPI1T
Gender detransition: a case study - Marchiano - 2021 - Journal of Analytical Psychology - Wiley Online Library https://t.co/V7onrYTiE8
“Gender detransition: A case study”, by Genspect advisor &Jungian analyst @LisaMarchiano (& her client Maya) describes a case that illustrates the complex & overlooked mental health needs of young people presenting with gender distress. https://t.co/K5qRayKBTv
EP52 with @LisaMarchiano!https://t.co/HwgRDMmOwA
In this episode, Sasha and Stella analyze existing research on detransition experiences. They discuss surveys and case studies, exploring reasons individuals detransition, including misattributed distress and…
Lisa Marchiano is a writer and Jungian analyst with over 20 years in practice. She presents insights on the rising trend of young people identifying as transgender and the cases of detransitioning, critically examining…
@Claire13492 @thenation As i said it varies. https://t.co/RktsXpAJVJ https://t.co/ni5PIdQTZS https://t.co/9Dz9y4yA6o https://t.co/chxbPnKihU https://t.co/Q42XwTJsK6 https://t.co/DehjawN6g4 https://t.co/fI1nguAXcv
@XenoSN_ @Polish_ConLib @_konliberal Ciekawe że zacząłeś wyzywać bez powodu. Tutaj masz link do artykułu w którym ktoś wyleczył dysforię, nie jest to stosowane ponieważ nacisk progresywno-liberalnych mediów jest tak duży że lekarze się boją to robić. https://t.co/sYYVV5FqGb
@catayuumi @ph534071018 @mileyandramente @updatecharts O efeito de manada já foi relatado anteriormente (relatos pessoais de detrans), e você deveria tem em mente que uma pessoa que detransiciona é vista como herege (ou como alguém que abandona a religião). https://t.co/kKE9uFEMUj https://t.co/8J69UEUM83 https://t.co/ILvpml1Pgq https://t.co/oXuo8d6mli
✍️: [1] Marchiano L., Gender detransition: a case study, „Journal of Analytical Psychology” 2021, v. 66, iss. 4. [2] Heneghan C., Jefferson T., Gender-affirming hormone in children and adolescents, BMJ EBM Spotlight 2019. [3] Palveluvalikoimaneuvoston suositus (PALKO),
@AverageProtest1 @tradrmum @jburgo55 See Jungian analyst @LisaMarchiano's perceptive writings. For example, https://t.co/yEY9wTB6ac and https://t.co/VDbNsAjhu1
@angela102065 @BrockP1977 @10TV Do some actual reading and not the brainwashing kind. https://t.co/fiW076wbmC https://t.co/yqPbUjlJ3S https://t.co/yf1Qlf3eaC
@PoliticsMichael @kayyyroxx @Whitney37048414 @kelly_cadigan Hey lazy here is another article to read on the increase. https://t.co/G1JBTBOGwU
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @GETAtherapy: "Gender detransition: a case study" - we're so happy to see this article by @LisaMarchiano reaching a large audience.
"Gender detransition: a case study" - we're so happy to see this article by @LisaMarchiano reaching a large audience. https://t.co/jVPrLU9iyC
RT @SiegneilWortek: @manelmarquez Manel, ¿le parecen bulos los resultados d estos estudios? https://t.co/eboV8qpu6O https://t.co/gxN3UAGzPX…
@manelmarquez Manel, ¿le parecen bulos los resultados d estos estudios? https://t.co/eboV8qpu6O https://t.co/gxN3UAGzPX https://t.co/ApmN9ExkJS https://t.co/CchDkqFeXf https://t.co/CMUQsCncTC
RT @GDSNsupport: #detransawarenessday A Case Study of detransition by @LisaMarchiano https://t.co/bSQDn9WGMn
RT @GDSNsupport: #detransawarenessday A Case Study of detransition by @LisaMarchiano https://t.co/bSQDn9WGMn
@LulaOnStage @soseducation @Colinou13 @mbockcote @CNEWS "In the last 10 years gender clinics in the U.K. have seen a 4,400% increase in teen girls seeking treatment for gender dysphoria" Source : https://t.co/GmHfZkwued.
RT @GDSNsupport: #detransawarenessday A Case Study of detransition by @LisaMarchiano https://t.co/bSQDn9WGMn
RT @GDSNsupport: #detransawarenessday A Case Study of detransition by @LisaMarchiano https://t.co/bSQDn9WGMn
#detransawarenessday A Case Study of detransition by @LisaMarchiano https://t.co/bSQDn9WGMn
This might be one of two case reports on detransitioners that's been published EVER. https://t.co/KfA0d7Y5eY
@rochambo76 @robbysoave This isn't about kids feeling safe to express themselves at school. We're not talking about wearing goth clothes. https://t.co/BIGLaUefjC
@dtrifuno @AjQwertzy @jessesingal https://t.co/BIGLaUefjC
@AjQwertzy @jessesingal An anecdote, you have zero evidence of. Sounds like you could stand to hear this anecdote. https://t.co/BIGLaUefjC
@DerDrachenKater @tagesschau 2/ Ihr "Progressiven" seid eben auf dem Auge blind und wollt euch gar nicht bewusst werden, was ihr vielen Menschen antut und noch antun werdet. Auch in einer unsicheren Phase, in der Pubertät, den Mist zu pushen, ist extrem perfide. https://t.co/QIZCyWDbuH
RT @podTransparency: EP52 with @LisaMarchiano!https://t.co/HwgRDMmOwA
le premier chiffre semble être alarmant, on parle de 4400% d'augmentation sur 10 ans des demandes de transitions chez les filles et femmes. le lien retourne sur cette étude https://t.co/OoaH8Ydefc. qui utilise comme source pour son chiffre.. un artigle du daily telegraph... https://t.co/YyqhF5DMMI
RT @podTransparency: EP52 with @LisaMarchiano!https://t.co/HwgRDMmOwA
RT @podTransparency: EP52 with @LisaMarchiano!https://t.co/HwgRDMmOwA
RT @podTransparency: EP52 with @LisaMarchiano!https://t.co/HwgRDMmOwA
RT @podTransparency: EP52 with @LisaMarchiano!https://t.co/HwgRDMmOwA
RT @podTransparency: EP52 with @LisaMarchiano!https://t.co/HwgRDMmOwA
RT @podTransparency: EP52 with @LisaMarchiano!https://t.co/HwgRDMmOwA
EP52 with @LisaMarchiano!https://t.co/HwgRDMmOwA
EP52 - Contagious, Like Laughter - with Lisa Marchiano https://t.co/rT6SvEIzC8 via @YouTube
@TheAntifaBrujah @999tinted @transphobeslmao @TransphobeWs_ No, it's on their fucked up psyches lol but cute quote tho https://t.co/5lVpIiJSFk
@AmeliaAltare1 @SzymiFlacko @cynicalcreep @RespectfulMemes You cited another meta analysis that cite selection biased studies that don't take participant observation into account. Here's a few: https://t.co/TrCnH6i8WN https://t.co/YxaFNNrITu https://t.co/EQXhZdCH8x https://t.co/Duc9FXYfX2
@SubLt_Skydreams @TransphobicLs https://t.co/YxaFNNrITu lol
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
@i__heart__this @JamesD_45 @Lily_the_empath @FemmaFetale @ErinInTheMorn Yes, she did and I've got articles and screenshots to support my argument. https://t.co/5hXrxOK3xA https://t.co/h4JDfeNASV https://t.co/FfMtALVrHU https://t.co/K3zA5RZDjj https://t.co/cYooln2Ak8
@TarMairon3 @mareile_s @StockportCoven There's very little study of the real trans suicide rate (the studies showing a 41-47% rate in teens are not particularly good). On the increase, here's a source with links to some studies: https://t.co/RbxKSy5eub
@MarkBurgess10 @LogicIllustrat @ry_serene This took 3 seconds to find. https://t.co/SkO87NUEsl
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @segm_ebm: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “co…
@D5Meter @SAshworthHayes https://t.co/v78p6OzdNg
@PinkNews https://t.co/v78p6OzdNg
@PinkNews https://t.co/v78p6OzdNg
@RatinaF @newthoughtcrime https://t.co/Cr5v9ZveQR
@CCoudereau @biconicwomann @fiery_godmother @Freshlysquashed @jk_rowling @RosieDuffield1 Both of those issues have been raised by academics in the field in recent years, despite a serious paucity of research in this area. Neither is a "myth". https://t.co/wTwJymu9ZG https://t.co/pAVFSZZ9Wj
@jk_rowling Thank you for highlighting the experience of detransitioners. Their needs are also increasingly being highlighted in the academic literature. https://t.co/THKCkvBUrP
RT @JackieLane2020: Gender detransition: a case study - Marchiano - 2021 - Journal of Analytical Psychology - Wiley Online Library https://…
Gender detransition: a case study - Marchiano - 2021 - Journal of Analytical Psychology - Wiley Online Library https://t.co/HtTj66XYN4
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
@LisaMarchiano has published an incredible scientific article that must be read for those concerned about #ROGD, #detrans people and what they went through. https://t.co/r95jYFlCTr
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
Lisa Marchiano, 2021. Gender detransition: a case study. The Journal of Analytical Psychology, https://t.co/fRCr0XLyzp, 10 November 2021.
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
RT @SEGMtweets: Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “…
Marchiano cautions clinicians against “colluding with an avoidance of reality” and opines that the affirmative care model “concretizes psychic pain, locates it in the body, and seeks biomedical treatments for it.” The full paper is available below. /6 https://t.co/OOmKdNITyD
@estherbeeee @uuuomo Bei adolescent onset gender dysphoria: https://t.co/TMwFBt6lF7 https://t.co/bmVVuRTb9p https://t.co/3HbI7nJKz1 https://t.co/nKyrQvjmbI https://t.co/Um4Mv7eT3G https://t.co/1rmb9lWLeJ https://t.co/dx0rogFs8W
RT @BayswaterSG: .@LisaMarchiano's new case study of a detransitioned young woman highlights the risk that 'affirmative' care may leave und…
@detrans_de Das hier wären ein paar gute Quellen, die sich die Damen und Herren beim "Regenbogenportal" mal gerne zu Gemüte führen dürften. Fall sie denn willens sind, sinnentnehmend zu lesen. https://t.co/7Sr0Tiu6az https://t.co/8YvFcvIiQF
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
Gender detransition: a case study - Marchiano - 2021 - Journal of Analytical Psychology - Wiley Online Library https://t.co/V7onrYTiE8
Gender detransition: a case study - Marchiano - 2021 - Journal of Analytical Psychology - Wiley Online Library https://t.co/4uUbL5GqCr
Gender detransition: a case study - Marchiano - 2021 - Journal of Analytical Psychology - Wiley Online Library https://t.co/sKLZ0wGo52
@jordanbpeterson This is a really important piece of work too from @LisaMarchiano A psycho-analytical journey with a detransitioner - it's much more complex than anyone would have you believe https://t.co/OVE9kD8yL8
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @genspect: “Gender detransition: A case study”, by Genspect advisor &Jungian analyst @LisaMarchiano (& her client Maya) describes a c…
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @daringplurality: By the brilliant @LisaMarchiano. Gender detransition: a case study https://t.co/RHls8JegkQ
RT @JuanDiazCG: 3) Lo último me parece importante, porque es común encontrar testimonios de "detransisionadores" que comentan que fue más f…
The way into superstition and back. https://t.co/CAaFBwSIBz
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
3) Lo último me parece importante, porque es común encontrar testimonios de "detransisionadores" que comentan que fue más fácil afirmarse socialmente como trans "heteros" que como homosexuales, tal como el caso de Livia, mencionada aquí: https://t.co/CmcRWxrp81 Por lo que no dejo
RT @DebbieHayton: By @LisaMarchiano: "My view is that the affirmative model of care concretizes psychic pain, locates it in the body, and s…
Gender detransition: a case study - Marchiano - 2021 - Journal of Analytical Psychology - Wiley Online Library https://t.co/8u8Gg0biq5
RT @DebbieHayton: By @LisaMarchiano: "My view is that the affirmative model of care concretizes psychic pain, locates it in the body, and s…
By @LisaMarchiano: "My view is that the affirmative model of care concretizes psychic pain, locates it in the body, and seeks biomedical treatments for it. Paradoxically, it also offers a compensatory belief in a disembodied, ineffable essence." https://t.co/XEeByTPI1T
RT @genspect: “Gender detransition: A case study”, by Genspect advisor &Jungian analyst @LisaMarchiano (& her client Maya) describes a c…
RT @genspect: “Gender detransition: A case study”, by Genspect advisor &Jungian analyst @LisaMarchiano (& her client Maya) describes a c…
RT @genspect: “Gender detransition: A case study”, by Genspect advisor &Jungian analyst @LisaMarchiano (& her client Maya) describes a c…
RT @genspect: “Gender detransition: A case study”, by Genspect advisor &Jungian analyst @LisaMarchiano (& her client Maya) describes a c…
RT @genspect: “Gender detransition: A case study”, by Genspect advisor &Jungian analyst @LisaMarchiano (& her client Maya) describes a c…
“Gender detransition: A case study”, by Genspect advisor &Jungian analyst @LisaMarchiano (& her client Maya) describes a case that illustrates the complex & overlooked mental health needs of young people presenting with gender distress. https://t.co/K5qRayKBTv
RT @ebswa: Highly recommend this article by Lisa Marchiano. https://t.co/9MOV5XqsDC https://t.co/MSb95Z86yQ
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @daringplurality: By the brilliant @LisaMarchiano. Gender detransition: a case study https://t.co/RHls8JegkQ
Jung as quoted by @LisaMarchiano in https://t.co/dQKiqCUiMN: https://t.co/g3ecVYx7RG
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
@LisaMarchiano speaks truth: "My view is that the affirmative model of care concretizes psychic pain, locates it in the body, and seeks biomedical treatments for it. Paradoxically, it also offers a compensatory belief in a disembodied, ineffable essence." https://t.co/fIRP0U8EZ4
RT @daringplurality: By the brilliant @LisaMarchiano. Gender detransition: a case study https://t.co/RHls8JegkQ
RT @Mom2004hms: “The affirmative model takes at face value a child or teen’s declaration about feelings and thoughts related to gender. It…
RT @Mom2004hms: “The affirmative model takes at face value a child or teen’s declaration about feelings and thoughts related to gender. It…
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @daringplurality: By the brilliant @LisaMarchiano. Gender detransition: a case study https://t.co/RHls8JegkQ
By the brilliant @LisaMarchiano. Gender detransition: a case study https://t.co/RHls8JegkQ
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
Gender detransition: a case study https://t.co/zRsf1p5JuQ #PubMed #Transgender
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
RT @LisaLittman1: Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
Important new paper published by @LisaMarchiano: Gender detransition: a case study. https://t.co/nuxtqMwpDs
The number of adolescents seeking treatment for gender dysphoria has been rising since 2004, with sharp increases noted especially over the last decade... Gender detransition: a case study https://t.co/ckKWT2AVHs
S
L
DH
DH
G
JJ
LJ
L
DS
PI
ER
J
G
ES
TF
PX
SW
PT
SW
JC
BG
NB
R
S
I
J
MM
M
Ğ
DD
K
DS
SE
S
LG
PA
JL
S
MS
QQ
JM
JR
GC
M
P
MD
MM
J
KD
J
C
CK
DM
A
HW
V
E
BK
JS
N
HW
K
AB
RB
C
C
KC
AR
BS
V
DG
K
MW
C
JD
LD
MC
AP
M
CF
SL
JM
N
DD
BI
L
KT
TO
PD
LA
DH
F
TM
LB
AM
LF
I
T
F
LB
CR
S
I
GU
ST
S
G
A
DR
PP
F