Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
Various posts highlight specific aspects of the publication, such as the comparison of current warming rates to historical climate changes over the last 24,000 years. Participants express astonishment at the rapid increase in temperatures and refer to terms like 'unprecedented' to describe the current situation. The tone of excitement contrasts with skepticism; for instance, some users challenge claims made against the paper, using phrases like 'it's peer-reviewed research' to emphasize its credibility, showcasing a mixture of respect for scientific rigor and a pushback against contrary opinions.
The discussions largely convey a supportive view of the publication's findings, though some posts express skepticism about the interpretation or methodology.
Participants show a high level of curiosity, engaging deeply with the publication's topic, indicated by extensive sharing of links and references.
While many discussions seem combative, especially with skepticism towards opposing views, they demonstrate a basic level of engagement through critiques and references.
There is a strong perception that the findings of the publication have significant implications for understanding climate change.
24000 سنة من بيانات درجة الحرارة تُظهر مدى سخونة العالم الحالية غير المسبوقة. وفقًا لدراسة جديدة جمعت المئات من سجلات درجات الحرارة من جميع أنحاء العالم لرسم خريطة لتغير المناخ في الماضي. https://t.co/2KYbMtJPFb https://t.co/2ES8u4qesS
Un tipo intenta refutar el hecho de que la temperatura GLOBAL ha aumentado. Para ello pone un gráfico del CENTRO DE GROENLANDIA. Cosa que NO REPRESENTA LA TEMPERATURA GLOBAL https://t.co/x8lBgvshgi https://t.co/8XAqzRZNa0 https://t.co/6FD24MzNoH
@larkam51 @hausfath @kevpluck No it isn't. https://t.co/SQcE8A8QL8 https://t.co/iapR4L44hu
@Geostrategistnl @hausfath @kevpluck Here's a longer-term dataset, including uncertainty ranges https://t.co/SQcE8A8QL8 https://t.co/CeHGuSlH7m
Das Autorenteam folgert u.a.: "When compared with recent temperature changes, our reanalysis indicates that both the rate and magnitude of modern warming are unusual relative to the changes of the past 24 thousand years." (https://t.co/RcmBZxrmT0) #Klimawandel
@climacritic Thread scritto con dati privi di senso. Ti consiglio di aggiornare la tua letteratura scientifica per esempio con Osman, et al. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum". Nature 599, 239–244 (2021). https://t.co/YmqdmCpjzI https://t.co/Oi8pmBFiYM
This video explores the complexities of modern climate science, highlighting temperature changes over the last 24,000 years. It uncovers the driving mechanisms behind temperature variability, including the roles of ice…
This video examines the assertion that climate always changes, countering it with logic and hard evidence. It references significant research showing rapid and notable global temperature increases, emphasizing the role…
or show them this and force them to explain why the planet is now rapidly warming after being stable for 10,000 years
@MatthewWielicki Scientific peer reviewed research published in Nature: Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum https://t.co/tDeXgsjCYI https://t.co/kgJ7piyPSb
I post science; you post opinions. 24,000-year graph of Earth temperatures: cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/u... Based on this paper www.nature.com/articles/s41... "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al, 2021
Drobné doplnění: „Rok nula“ v grafu vývoje teplot je definován jako rok 1950. Grafy a celá studie podrobněji viz DOI: 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4 https://t.co/6klD12HWU5
Drobné doplnění: „Rok nula“ v grafu vývoje teplot je definován jako rok 1950. Grafy a celá studie podrobněji viz DOI: 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4
@sjsimmons @BillCoriolis @ryankatzrosene They're being dishonest about GISP2, as you likely already know. https://t.co/kN98f7mRBg https://t.co/cSclAj4usn "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y https://t.co/4r5K0STvzD
Global Temperature Changes Over the Last 24,000 Years bit.ly/GMST-24kyr Osman, M. B., Tierney, J. E., Zhu, J., Tardif, R., Hakim, G. J., King, J., & Poulsen, C. J. (2021). Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature, 599(7884), 239–244.
Global Temperature Changes Over the Last 24,000 Years https://t.co/t9rEMrMyR3 Osman, M. B., Tierney, J. E., Zhu, J., Tardif, R., Hakim, G. J., King, J., & Poulsen, C. J. (2021). Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature, 599(7884), 239–244. https://t.co/gBjD885kLk
24,000-year graph of Earth temperatures: cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/u... Based on this paper: www.nature.com/articles/s41... "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al, 2021 #ClimateChange #ClimateCrisis #GreenPolitics
@FD2you @_ClimateCraze @ejwwest @davidissim None of your paranoid ranting rebuts published evidence in climate science, anymore than a flat Earther's ranting about supposed globalists rebuts published evidence in geoscience. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y https://t.co/1Be8JTWbVI
@ThomasSayre13 @ryankatzrosene Stop trolling. https://t.co/kN98f7mRBg https://t.co/cSclAj4usn "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y https://t.co/BqyTjqeJtZ
24,000-year graph of Earth temperatures: cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/u... Based on this paper: www.nature.com/articles/s41... "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al, 2021
@wideawake_media Bullshit. Source: Osman et al, "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/yEzVz3KWXs
@Sambandet @hausfath Greenland is not the globe, and your graph stops in the 1850s. You denialists love abusing GISP2. https://t.co/kN98f7mRBg https://t.co/cSclAj4usn "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y https://t.co/J3sDlkEdSo
@_ClimateCraze @Stinkhorn11 @kissingtruth @DavidPirouet It wasn't global, and you're decades later still trying to mislead your audience into thinking it was global. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWOX6 https://t.co/qUm3ZtP7sB
This is probably still one of my favorite pieces of climate science media I've ever seen Data comes from "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" Osman et al. 2021 www.nature.com/articles/s41... www.reddit.com/r/dataisbeau...
@MatthewWielicki One of my favorite is “Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum” Matthew B. Osman, Jessica E. Tierney, Christopher J. Poulsen Can’t believe it even made it to peer review as written. At best they came up with an idea that may one day be evolved
Context: https://t.co/n28uq2YWh6 https://t.co/wN4BHpy9Vk https://t.co/eU4vu6DUU9 https://t.co/E9ZBMSIvLE "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWOX6 https://t.co/T28CbuMJBe
@CymaticWave @PoyetPatrice @RobThomas14 @Konrad_Chapman @Willard1951 @kissingtruth @LxxResearcher @DoubleDumas @priscian @TWTThisIsNow @ICcrapdaily @HeidlerNeal @DarrenDrpage @ClimateRetorts @BrknMan @ejwwest @agentsinaction @NdabaningiMoyo @dsjost @BoryanLeChat @EdWellham @patfrank830 @Pow_Pop_Blam @mic12052 @covid_quest @MLiebreich @Wim_Ondewhybak_ @Frnc_prep @hairymarx1 @ericonthetrail @bobathon @Dooderoo @DuosEquis @25_cycle @WHUT @cohler @JoernWiedemann @Redoubtably10 @BStarr96522 @GeraldKutney @OceanadeSilva @ChrisMartzWX Stay mad, bro. Greenland is not the globe, and GISP2 stops in the 1850s. You denialists love abusing GISP2. https://t.co/kN98f7npqO https://t.co/cSclAj52hV https://t.co/urug9LsvMh "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWOX6 https://t.co/QpmqArrYiL
RT @balkraix: Un tipo intenta refutar el hecho de que la temperatura GLOBAL ha aumentado. Para ello pone un gráfico del CENTRO DE GROENLAN…
RT @balkraix: Un tipo intenta refutar el hecho de que la temperatura GLOBAL ha aumentado. Para ello pone un gráfico del CENTRO DE GROENLAN…
Un tipo intenta refutar el hecho de que la temperatura GLOBAL ha aumentado. Para ello pone un gráfico del CENTRO DE GROENLANDIA. Cosa que NO REPRESENTA LA TEMPERATURA GLOBAL https://t.co/x8lBgvshgi https://t.co/8XAqzRZNa0 https://t.co/6FD24MzNoH
@jgatta06 @jimdtweet @patfrank830 @isaacscradle @BubbasRanch @LexWaters7 @MLeiter42 @CDCollins5269 @Kenneth72712993 @BobPartridge16 @PushFourLeft @WHPAAD @phlannelphysics @TrixX306 @ChrisBBacon3 @craigthomler @BenKoby1911 @Mark_A_Lunn @JamesAbbott2013 @Michael_D_Crow @dafalgoutDennis @ClimateRetorts @WayneAllanH @JJ9621073059835 @priscian @RobertWager1 @nxgrs73 @TypicalDeviant @FreeSpeech4U_Me @hannon_renee @RixAutomatedMat @DaleGribble_666 @GeorgeJeff9804 @roger_clague @kevpluck @Devonian1342 @GillesnFio @Joe_Public2018 @jgorman2424 @ClimatePoet @EthonRaptor @dantrimont @Quentin__France @PoeBrianL @ilovekiirth @IBergwiesel @jpgcrowley @NoelTurner194 @TheDickKnightV2 The paper for this reconstruction is here. Osman, M.B., Tierney, J.E., Zhu, J. et al. Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature 599, 239–244 (2021). https://t.co/HhXq1ZdEt3
@morgannike49 @hausfath @bsec_wales Stop trolling. Greenland is not the globe, and your graph stops in the 1850s. You denialists love abusing GISP2. https://t.co/kN98f7mRBg https://t.co/cSclAj4usn "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y https://t.co/ssYRWBJrQK
The World That Was (22,000 years ago): The Last Glacial Maximum (-7°C cooler than today; CO2 ~190 ppm, sea levels 400’ lower) Osman et al 2021 - Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum www.nature.com/articles/s41...
Climate change. 24,000-year graph of Earth temperatures: cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/u... Based on this paper: www.nature.com/articles/s41... Title "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al, 2021
@GileadUK @hausfath https://t.co/kN98f7mRBg "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y https://t.co/fxrrLg0wBS
RT @colinleggphoto: @BobPartridge16 @akaelwopo1 @scruztiger @rahmstorf Well according to these recent papers, both CO2 (carbon) and global…
@BobPartridge16 @akaelwopo1 @scruztiger @rahmstorf Well according to these recent papers, both CO2 (carbon) and global surface temperatures are rising at “usual” rates. https://t.co/x34JhKFzSL https://t.co/VJezWho1fM
@akaelwopo1 @scruztiger @rahmstorf No. The sustained rate of change of both CO2 and “global” surface temperatures are “very” unusual geologically. As discussed here: https://t.co/x34JhKFzSL And here: https://t.co/VJezWho1fM
@br_cse_iitb @GeorgeMonbiot @BasedMillwall It’s not my claim. It’s the conclusion of climate scientist. Maybe start here: https://t.co/x34JhKFzSL
Source here I think: thecottonwoodpost.net/2019/12/10/m... It's a blog post, looks right but I have not checked it. Much more recent comparison: Current warming is progressing about 20x faster than the 1ºC/1000 years from 17kya to 11kya following Last Glacial Max: www.nature.com/articles/s41...
@Floirun6 @Nosceteipsum_24 @AssoClimatoReal Connaissez-vous le principe des données paléo-climatiques ? Voici ce que donnent les reconstitutions récentes pour le Dernier Maximum Glaciaire (LGM en anglais) : Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum - Osman et al., 2021 https://t.co/N0QlCnaqau https://t.co/cLahSCP7Ox
“Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum” www.nature.com/articles/s41...
Con t’d: [Erb et al. 2022, DOI: 10.5194/cp-18-2599-2022] [Osman et al. 2021, DOI: 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4] [Kaufmann et al. 2020, DOI: 10.1038/s41597-020-0530-7] [Marcott et al. 2013, DOI: 10.1126/science.1228026]
@madpeepdrew @hausfath @boggywood @Jnywall @CarbonBrief You would just move the goalposts in bad faith again, as per disingenuous denialism. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y [https://t.co/P2rctrxVHE https://t.co/ixaAOjUqSV] https://t.co/zBHMybaCch
@Geostrategistnl @hausfath @kevpluck Here's a longer-term dataset, including uncertainty ranges https://t.co/SQcE8A8QL8 https://t.co/CeHGuSlH7m
@NiusMarco Voici ce que donnent les reconstitutions récentes pour le LGM : Glacial cooling and climate sensitivity revisited - Tierney et al., 2020 https://t.co/Ac8nmUW38y Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum - Osman et al., 2021 https://t.co/N0QlCnaY02 https://t.co/Puma7Okenr
@larkam51 @hausfath @kevpluck No it isn't. https://t.co/SQcE8A8QL8 https://t.co/iapR4L44hu
@kissingtruth @agentsinaction @alangnixon @PoyetPatrice @Redoubtably10 @TWTThisIsNow @ejwwest @CymaticWave @DoubleDumas @ClimateRetorts @FredHikes @DanCady @Wim_Ondewhybak_ @hairymarx1 @BStarr96522 @priscian @25_cycle @JoernWiedemann @MartinJBern @IsaacCline42 @patfrank830 @GeraldKutney @OceanadeSilva @Bazthebemused @GlonvecHQ @USAMRIID_CA @Robert76907841 @WHUT @FriedrichFiles @BatcaveSlimer @BywatersRobert @BarbaraGirouard @tezisold @_InThisTogether @HmGinYYC @msdwrites @dimeinurear @thomasdenmark @theAGU @MichaelEMann @DikranMarsupial @Gavin_Cawley @NikolovScience GISP2 isn't global + doesn't include industrial-era global warming. So you misused it. No amount of deflection + goalpost moving from you changes that fact. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/t550lmGInp https://t.co/jsaaADBFzU
@Kenneth72712993 No it’s not, twit. #ClimateActionNow #ClimateBrawl “Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum” Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/eYG91fbCXQ https://t.co/Hle9jonHbb
@TWTThisIsNow @kissingtruth @LxxResearcher @DeadheadJP99 @TheDisproof @craigthomler @RobertK_2142 @DawnTJ90 @EdBohman @grumpynskeptic @priscian @Bob99292956 @FireFox_XB9R @DougBookwriter2 @ILuvCO2 @dan613 @AltUS_ARC @PACleanwater @ThomasPaine5 @SteveSGoddard @MLBinWA @Robin_Hagues @RoyPentland @Boi_dBoi_d @bjames280961 @_kevinmartin @mytk56 @gjbangar @gershuni @Dcoronata @IngersolRobert @EdDarrell @CMH19611 @ChrisMartzWX @Greg49039425 @milneorchid @bfolson18 @JohnPalkovic @TADinKaty @PlanetLuvie @ClimateRealists @BradSchrag @Forthwithtx @DrMarkImisides @david_hanselman @amidgley @miked194765 @Piers_Corbyn https://t.co/Qct4aoWOX6 [https://t.co/P2rctrytxc https://t.co/ixaAOjUYIt] https://t.co/7WqRiAgptj
RT @priscian: @EdBohman @craigthomler @PolAnimalAus @FireFox_XB9R @DougBookwriter2 @ILuvCO2 @dan613 @TWTThisIsNow @AltUS_ARC @PACleanwater…
@wdb_1954 @Neruun @CScharun Quelle: Grafik nach Andrew Dessler auf Basis der Daten von: Osman, M. B. et al. (2021): Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature, 599 (7884): 239-244.
@CColose @KatyDuke @ChrisMartzWX This reference should be mentioned as it is to my knowledge the most recent up-to-date proxy reconstruction going back to LGM. Nothing there shows anything close to 1.5-2C above pre-industrial-recent temps during the mid-holocene. https://t.co/Jm9sLL36aZ https://t.co/3slZnKEKkp https://t.co/XGsvh0HCRF
@jens_riege60911 @Keeper_86 @derfachwirt @JoergAltSJ Quelle: Grafik nach Andrew Dessler auf Basis der Daten von: Osman, M. B. et al. (2021): Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature, 599 (7884): 239-244.
@redrovera1 @RogerCoppock https://t.co/8tcFstcE3A Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum https://t.co/obl2WVtgzc Uh-Oh. Now What? Are We Acquiring the Data to Understand the Situation? https://t.co/FqSKsVlVoG Climate forcing since 1750 https://t.co/gP9GpSSKP8
@ClarkKenwxman @mom1398 @ChrisMartzWX Maybe they think if they use enough 4- and 8-letter obscenities, people will believe the baseless claims they're fabricating. https://t.co/REhC5dB0MH https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y [https://t.co/P2rctrxVHE https://t.co/ixaAOjUqSV] https://t.co/AjoSpWyF2d
@BeutlerYves @PGrasarevic Grafik nach Andrew Dessler auf Basis der Daten von: Osman, M. B. et al. (2021): Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature, 599 (7884): 239-244.
RT @priscian: @EdBohman @craigthomler @PolAnimalAus @FireFox_XB9R @DougBookwriter2 @ILuvCO2 @dan613 @TWTThisIsNow @AltUS_ARC @PACleanwater…
Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum | Nature https://t.co/QLUeixuBjG
@somedeepstuff1 @FChecker76 @JonMny @MarcEHJones Ah, that you mean. I though someone had made that claim specifically with regards to that chart. I guess you can call it unprecedented on a "human civilization" scale. I'm pretty sure temperatures changed much more quickly during planetary formation /1 https://t.co/GZLCS3JXY9 https://t.co/C4O3bCAfXl
@KolydasT Πχ απο κανονικο paper και οχι αυθαιρετη συρραφη δεδομενων απο μυθιστορηματα οπως το πανω διαγραμμα, εχουμε αυτο. Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum, 2021 Matthew Osman, J. E. Tierney, J. Zhu, R. Tardif, Gregory J. Hakim, J. King & C. J. Poulsen https://t.co/lzfNIRTbyE
Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum | Nature https://t.co/IJU8YnMNLu
His 1st screenshot (Fig 1) is an altered version of a sketched Greenland-only plot in Schönwiese 1995: Klimaänderungen—Daten, Analysen, Prognosen (Fig 2) that omits current warming. Paleotemp studies have progressed since w/ >24 ky global data (Osman 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM) https://t.co/TafwTnVIkx
@AnneFroment @SaintPalermo @LeonSimons8 @Nature @KvSchuckmann @MercatorOcean It's just not correct (et al. Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature 599, 239–244) https://t.co/TMDkGMTx9V
@dirocco1964 @rolandzumbuehl @vivienne_huber Quelle: Grafik nach Andrew Dessler auf Basis der Daten von: Osman, M. B. et al. (2021): Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature, 599 (7884): 239-244.
RT @tuedelkopp: @Apocalypse4Real @rahmstorf @magnificentb @ProfMattEngland @LeonSimons8 Matt Osman: https://t.co/cUuacmNCIU Nature article…
RT @ItsTheAtmospher: @JunkScience @NOAAClimate 1 - Editors Note (NOAA) 2 - Steve when you see a woman adjusting her garter strap - why are…
@JunkScience @NOAAClimate 1 - Editors Note (NOAA) 2 - Steve when you see a woman adjusting her garter strap - why are you repelled? 3 - explain 120kya Vooson (2019) DOI: 10.1126/science.364.6442.716 Bova (2019) DOI 10.1038/s41586-020-03155-x Osman (2021) DOI 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4 https://t.co/RAIxjOQAIb
@Ceist8 @Peters_Glen @richardabetts hmmm "Climate model simulations and proxy data have independently allowed for study of this crucial interval; however, they have at times yielded disparate conclusions." https://t.co/eAzUnJ6SsN
@AnneFroment @twgahler @Climatologist49 People did that. Countless times. E.g in "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum, 2021" by Matthew B. Osman, Jessica E. Tierney, Jiang Zhu, Robert Tardif, Gregory J. Hakim, Jonathan King & Christopher J. Poulsen, of which the attached picture came. https://t.co/Lxm5jbyZso
RT @galselo: @climacritic Thread scritto con dati privi di senso. Ti consiglio di aggiornare la tua letteratura scientifica per esempio con…
@climacritic Thread scritto con dati privi di senso. Ti consiglio di aggiornare la tua letteratura scientifica per esempio con Osman, et al. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum". Nature 599, 239–244 (2021). https://t.co/YmqdmCpjzI https://t.co/Oi8pmBFiYM
@climacritic Dati di Dansgard che si riferiscono al nord della Groenlandia e Schonwiese che arrivano al 1990. Aggiornati e prendi dati corretti, questo è Osman et al. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum". Nature 599, 239–244 (2021). https://t.co/YmqdmCpjzI https://t.co/CJRIUATwPf
@madpeepdrew @Jfederici1981 @NOAA @NOAANCEI Not globally dude. I'd suggest two papers for you to read. One is Bova, et al, & Osmond, et al, both 2021. In fact, let me help you out! https://t.co/AWho2UDx25 https://t.co/cUmvFhrZdB https://t.co/DVVZx66RCC
@JaredJMccracken @myDudeWermaus @NiusMarco @MikeHudema >The hockey stick is hi res pasted on the end of low res. Not science. I await your rebuttal to: Osman, M.B., Tierney, J.E., Zhu, J. et al. Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature 599, 239–244 (2021) https://t.co/oDXGpfZaIK
@HamiDuke @NoelTurner194 @jwickers @ClimatePoet @RegimeChangeBC @TheDisproof @Marcusgibson @caerbannog666 @AltUS_ARC @Gladfly1 @Kenneth72712993 @0Sundance @TheClimateHawk @granitereason @TQMKA @EC_Kosters @MikeH_MapleGrov @JDAvatar @Michael_D_Crow @kuhn_reinhard @secular_girl @safety_canada7 @DavidMichaelRi8 @FriendsOScience @ShopSmartResist @yota_berlin @GeraldKutney @Captbobdad @audiF1 @LesJohnsonHrvat @Zigmund_Fraud @KenworthCowboy1 @JamesRider3 @d_e_mol @RickWoollams @tan123 @DenierBot @DiogenesLamp0 @Trismos @ws_llc Again, stop trolling. https://t.co/wQ3uqp7Fvp "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/t550lmGInp https://t.co/K199UReyX1
RT @AndrewDessler: Updated using the most recent paleo reconstruction (Osman et al., 2021, 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4). The main lesson is…
@amaryllisxx_ https://t.co/Ah8kdD00vC https://t.co/WqAcA3bUHT
RT @priscian: @jgatta06 @Mathenaut @TopAlliedAceWW1 @Gladfly1 @d_e_mol @davidyoung13 @stephen47276303 @DawnTJ90 @austins_coffee @terrymorse…
@jgatta06 @Mathenaut @TopAlliedAceWW1 @Gladfly1 @d_e_mol @davidyoung13 @stephen47276303 @DawnTJ90 @austins_coffee @terrymorse @RegimeChangeBC @Captbobdad @BrunoPresents @watt4prez @birdhillll @ChrisBradley133 @craigthomler @ClaireNewton79 @BRodermund @JaggerMickOZ @Mark_A_Lunn @FriendsOScience @SylviaD32911201 @KStafford67 @brandondaly2018 @caerbannog666 @GillesnFio @haerycammel @BardLackey @andsnz @MadnessVs @sheoaks1 @CymaticWave @boggywood @truthtrumps1 @drwaheeduddin @MichiganFront @AltUS_ARC @torpet002 @StealthFlyBy @NikolovScience @MamaMac_ @Sci_Resistance @GeorgePembroke @kevpluck @davestewart3 @hllsen @Lulzmouse Recent (real) reconstructions in legit journals w/out spurious cycles causing current warming: Neukom &al 2019 https://t.co/yxMzrZaE9S Tardif &al 2019 https://t.co/WvoNUigvMI Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeSpqk Anchukaitis &al 2022 https://t.co/EOQhJNSf
@Republican_X1 @JunkScience Osman et al 2021 is cited Here’s the link “Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum” https://t.co/8n0RWiHeHQ
@_ClimateCraze Okay https://t.co/KGC1XPJXYG
@_ClimateCraze https://t.co/Fuuk0OeeW4 https://t.co/ZafPdz2JHb?
@AgrotradingExt1 @picazomario Hola Camino, sobre informaciones veraces: de dónde es tu gráfica? Aquí te comparto una imagen de Osman et al. 2021 (https://t.co/oclUaG2F1N). Te recomiendo leer el estudio. Dado que no es open access y no está aún en sci-hub, puedes escribir a los autores para que te lo manden. https://t.co/GT9tuJVW1F
@ProfMarkMaslin @FrannyArmstrong @globalhlthtwit @arhobley @ClimateHuman @coxypm @_richardblack @ExtinctionR @XRebellionUK @JustStop_Oil Read the fine print. “Globally resolved surface temperatures since the last Glacial Maximum”. “Globally resolved”= “adjusted according to an algorithm whose premises are not open to public inspection” “the last Glacial Maximum”= “the coldest estimated global temperature we have”
@Ponzinator1 @GWaldmensch Veraltete Grafik aus der Steinzeit der Paläoklimaforschung, aktuell ist zB Osman 2021 https://t.co/fyRCcNgrVe . Klar, es gab und gibt natürliche Klimaschwankungen, auch während des Holozäns, aber in Intensität und Geschwindigkeit ist die anthropogene Erderhitzung ohne Analogum. https://t.co/2Xdbm2XMoz
@WayneAllanH @NotaSheep8621 @aaa21usa @BubbasRanch @BenKoby1911 @TopAlliedAceWW1 @MisinformNoMore @philbaylisss @Veritatem2021 @rln_nelson @ChrisBBacon3 @JustinGrant923 @Kenneth72712993 @NoelTurner194 @shicks_sam @bomac_macbo @jimdtweet @freddie07068768 @pauladamsalber1 @onefromtexas @TWTThisIsNow @starkicus @ChrisManuell @Michael_D_Crow @SZOMB @MikeDel21893959 @Vlaamse_Zaak @nxgrs73 @CrispyCX @CDMarshall7 @aSinister @variegated2 @6lennybravo @mugger124 @NewNormality20 @MartinJBern @GlennCarr6 @Jeffrey75327765 @la6uoa @MedBennett @automatrix66_KC @0Sundance @Narvuntien @Matt_Clough @Jagster20548365 @Grimasaur @ponycar06 @njbtweet Osman MB, Tierney JE, Zhu J, Tardif R, Hakim GJ, et al.: Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature 599:239–244, 2021. https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM https://t.co/8RiT8LwRTZ
@WeRone777 @Dotcats1 @agentsinaction @ADevotedYogi @tunackr2020 @Kenneth72712993 @Standintruthnow @adonamusic @Gigi69030829 @7777rep @nickhedley @Liberty_Ken @Veritatem2021 @DigitalDuelist @ClimateFdbk https://t.co/0EpW8P6V6y "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y https://t.co/5RMRTyZOAy
@CorpseFreedom @ADevotedYogi @Lo_VVriter @ThugRaffles @adonamusic @Gigi69030829 @agentsinaction @7777rep @nickhedley @Liberty_Ken @Veritatem2021 @DigitalDuelist Unsourced graph of squiggles?
@CScharun Grafik ist wegen Skalen etwas verwirrend. Die aktuellste Rekonstr über 2000J ist von Pages2k (Datapaper: https://t.co/8Up3c7gvw6) Seit Glazial Osman etal https://t.co/fyRCcNgZKM. Natürlich nimmt Unsicherheit zu je weiter zurück, die genannten Steigerungen sind aber signifikant. https://t.co/MsZPhYmAgl
@RBarker0341 @LetsGeuxBrandon @umfpt @DHasper @kiwi_kent @Melinda15858273 @bruch_amy @delboy00789 @andrew7rd @375NorseLegend @marsha75353 @Unity_Coach @TakethatCt @SynthIge @Tdillon06 @musicte65902305 @JonRFleming @Millska21 @shane545786 @the_lorean @garrytomo @merlin_saint @ADevotedYogi @Gigi69030829 @CoryRove @_MAGAPatriot_ @arduatendit @WebGuyTV @1D10Two @anon5standingby @ian36613527 @GeezercitizenX @LauriWi39168137 @GoFishLynn @PinkWings66 @hammerlane46077 @giRlOvErBoArD5 @LauriHWilliams @magicnumber41 @BlaylockMooky @vandahl7 @AltavozMagalong @Michael94173566 @OOOimUrAngel @DebateOnFacts @Ravi1236541 @BreakingNewsFi2 @LeenerTep @MikeinHalifax @physorg_com Matthew Osman, Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum, Nature (2021). DOI: 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4. https://t.co/TvHdnH1ozf
RT @AtomsksSanakan: @ClimateOfGavin @throughist They're clearly trolling, as you likely already knew. "Globally resolved surface temperatu…
@ClimateOfGavin @throughist They're clearly trolling, as you likely already knew. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y [https://t.co/P2rctrxVHE] https://t.co/jrBBTx7ZIv
@feusl @AlexReichmuth Grafik nach Andrew Dessler auf Basis der Daten von: Osman, M. B. et al. (2021): Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature, 599 (7884): 239-244.
@Apocalypse4Real @rahmstorf @magnificentb @ProfMattEngland @LeonSimons8 Matt Osman: https://t.co/cUuacmNCIU Nature article (not open access): https://t.co/WmosFRgIXv
@StreamingSeagu1 @Stephen90045069 @JunkScience @janicekchen More faked memes with unpublished charts? Try published research. Here's the last 24,000 yrs of global average temperature "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/e4tWoGbxGG
RT @8pi_g: @MaximCombes Toutes ces réponses qui montrent une ignorance de la paléoclimatologie! Pour les bases, Wikipedia a un article déce…
RT @8pi_g: @MaximCombes Toutes ces réponses qui montrent une ignorance de la paléoclimatologie! Pour les bases, Wikipedia a un article déce…
RT @8pi_g: @MaximCombes Toutes ces réponses qui montrent une ignorance de la paléoclimatologie! Pour les bases, Wikipedia a un article déce…
@MaximCombes Toutes ces réponses qui montrent une ignorance de la paléoclimatologie! Pour les bases, Wikipedia a un article décent https://t.co/MUNvosbqkt Et voici les résultats publiés les plus à jour que je connaisse: https://t.co/5TVEFu3wRZ Et les derniers 10 000 ans ⤵️ 1/ https://t.co/nTXujuz2nD
@GrgoryBeauriva1 @recou62 @MaximCombes @attac_fr Exactement. Pour commencer, la dernière période glaciaire s’étale entre -120 000 et -10 000 environ, donc il suffit de regarder les derniers 10 000 ans. On a suffisamment de proxy de température pour obtenir la courbe ci-dessous. CQFD. Ref: https://t.co/5TVEFu3wRZ https://t.co/r9TksNKSiF
@hausfath I know the reference for the last 2000 years (Pages2k). I also know a reference for the last 10,000 years (Osman et al, 2021, 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4) but what would be the best reference for the last 120,000 years?
RT @priscian: @wxbywilliams @WGRZ Greenland ≠ globe. We have enough global reconstructions over that period & further back to know that glo…
@wxbywilliams @WGRZ Greenland ≠ globe. We have enough global reconstructions over that period & further back to know that global temperatures now are unprecedented in 125 ky. Kaufman &al 2020 https://t.co/fc46WdskuJ Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM Erb &al 2022 https://t.co/AIleBxDlum https://t.co/P3O7vnmMTy
@BarryESharp Draw that graph yourself, Sparky?? "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/vB1OL7Bicv https://t.co/sfn2NchOP7
@IlkkaArvola *Lisäksi jäi. Tuosta pääset lukemaan rekonstruktion pidemmältä aikaväliltä. https://t.co/hr14KnvVR1
@ADevotedYogi @KRAU5555 @agentsinaction @tunackr2020 @Kenneth72712993 @Standintruthnow @adonamusic @Gigi69030829 @7777rep @RSalgadoDArcy @nickhedley @Liberty_Ken @Veritatem2021 @DigitalDuelist @ClimateFdbk Not interested in your fake, unsourced images you likely got off of non-peer-reviewed denialist blogs. https://t.co/beFaAg6Agw "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y https://t.co/omrUeVTGgF
@ADevotedYogi @Lidski_Popov @agentsinaction @7777rep @RSalgadoDArcy @nickhedley Not interested in your unsourced, fraudulent images that likely come from non-peer-reviewed denialist blogs. https://t.co/BbwMPRVlOF "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/Qct4aoWh7y https://t.co/jYUrEcZRYK
@ADevotedYogi @Gigi69030829 @PurpleM93934266 @agentsinaction @7777rep @RSalgadoDArcy @nickhedley @Liberty_Ken @Veritatem2021 @DigitalDuelist As worthless as monetary prizes offered by Holocaust denialists or HIV/AIDS deniers. Science isn't overturned by offers you make in bad faith.
@plumber_tim @zerovswr @Peters_Glen @piersforster For comparison, a doubling of CO₂ corresponds to 1.6% more solar insulation (the effect of CO₂ only, without the feedbacks). By the way, the variation through the Holocene is actually small ⤵️ 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4 Look at the extreme right… https://t.co/FlqaP7Ze6O
RT @priscian: @ncdave4life @gargantuandwarf @Anvndarnamn5 @Devonian1342 @AGW_is_bad @BobPartridge16 @NotAHoax @Mark_A_Lunn @DaleGribble_666…
@ncdave4life @gargantuandwarf @Anvndarnamn5 @Devonian1342 @AGW_is_bad @BobPartridge16 @NotAHoax @Mark_A_Lunn @DaleGribble_666 @BenKoby1911 @ammocrypta @ChrisBBacon3 @Michael_D_Crow @Gabwbw181237 @glinch72 @MarshallCd @BJChippindale @TopAlliedAceWW1 @FredHikes @Willard1951 @adlrope @ejwwest @safcpete67 @Climatehope2 @S_D_Mannix @DenisDaly @JimBlack48 @AndersBrunstad2 @periodicaudio @JusticeTrudeau @andrewmac71 @WernerReinhard5 @Jaisans @stitchnstab @CarrudoDon @Veritatem2021 @LiveLifeBK24 @TheDisproof @AristotleMrs @Joeyd87745119 @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @waxliberty @SuperFoxyLoxy @JaapTitulaer @wjack76995 @Rocky35418823 @NobaconEgbert @balls95652097 @JustThi30117912 Greenland ≠ globe. We have enough global reconstructions over that period to know that current global warming is much faster than Younger Dryas global warming Kaufman &al 2020 https://t.co/fc46WdskuJ Osman &al 2021
@GrahamLKeegan @25_cycle He put source citations in the figure, G Bova et al Nature 589:548-553 2021 https://t.co/BZQalkWNR9 Osman et al Nature 599:239-241 2021 https://t.co/PJpjfbD291
@Jeppespip @SolvingTornadoe I don't think @SolvingTornadoe or @FatEmperor reads the journals but just in case Osman etal (2021) DOI 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4
Quelle: Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum https://t.co/EMETblYTn0
@JordiCo23005407 @SergiTuiter @ChakNorris93 Però per si et sembla poc temps, aquí tens una visió sobre 24 000 anys. I les temperatures actuals en aquest període tan immens "no tienen precendentes". Font: https://t.co/QTPIy9k7lO (Nature) https://t.co/bQ5JOC9ziY
@_ClimateCraze You do know science advances, right? "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" Osman et al, 2021: https://t.co/SJjlJ9bdP6 https://t.co/kPgvl7IUGN
Matt Osman - Optimally combining models and proxy data to reconstruct climate and the state of the Greenland Ice sheet during the last interglacial period #GRISObergen @GRISOgreenland https://t.co/ryZXyG95PT https://t.co/F1dKnn6y1m https://t.co/RBnA4L17mp
@WeRone777 @aSinister @DocSnow1 @nxgrs73 @ozzorro1 @goingglocal @Wallisbadgerson @Michael71718318 @ejwwest @RickWoollams @BenKoby1911 @njbtweet @talipes @AbbeyRae5 @glinch72 @JR4_Truth @ZombiePiano @peblackstock @nipsfortrees @Ecotainment_YT @JJJungleJim @benmooreau @Veritatem2021 @Roadshow11235 @WernerReinhard5 @Stephen90045069 @4Clearsky @toddynd @Spencerfletch0 @MikeDel21893959 @twit4thot @Robert76907841 @Vulcan_hobo @TomWhatsoeverB @BernaB_2013 @choosefreedomf1 @CDMarshall7 @insane_voice @Lo_VVriter @ALefty123 @realJohnJHoward @USNA_73 @markinkorea @mac_an_ghoill @cbeckj @Frankd06830 @LesterDent @AlexVickeryHowe Just citing to well respected and recent studies, D Here are the doi links to those papers https://t.co/PJpjfbD291 https://t.co/cobMwEsb1E
@Resilient_Futur @violin4all I will make it easier to find sources or I'm going to cheat "See doi /10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4" Or "https://t.co/7jW95FxxUe"
RT @ItsTheAtmospher: @ScienceBlog3 @AristotleMrs the video is quite good - worth the watch @AristotleMrs 's chart is directly from Osman's…
@ScienceBlog3 @AristotleMrs the video is quite good - worth the watch @AristotleMrs 's chart is directly from Osman's (2021) paper DIO 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4 side-bar I'm having significant doubts about your claims of any association with NASA's climate work https://t.co/8N42VspzJp
@Sttopnoel @DoubleDumas @Ceist8 No. YOU WERE TOLD THIS ALREADY. A smarter person would have given evidence already. Sources: https://t.co/AWho2UDx25 https://t.co/cUmvFhrZdB https://t.co/ii3oSJbJ5I
@Duderino_E @UNFCCC @ed_hawkins But you didn't look, because your claim is incorrect. Global average temperature for the last 24,000 years "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/D9x2fwZKIA
@Chrisgoesberlin @micha_bloss Mhm. Können sie mal auf einem der Graphen die warme Antike zeigen? (Erster Graph: DOI: 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4) https://t.co/cyKT2VY5jq
@duane_hallman @RedPilled1788 @GretaThunberg Show it... The fact you didn't is proof you're lying. Oh look, this shows just how low intelligence you are. And HERE'S THE DATA SOURCES: https://t.co/AWho2UDx25 https://t.co/Lt3NPhl29s https://t.co/VenBLWXHhl
RT @25_cycle: @srh_si @MrMatthewTodd There's some legends to the left of references two papers, Shakun (2013) & Marcott (2012) Marcott is p…
@srh_si @MrMatthewTodd There's some legends to the left of references two papers, Shakun (2013) & Marcott (2012) Marcott is pay walled but I have the data source here: https://t.co/0GR1U64CiY Personally, I wouldn't use either of those. I would use Osman, et al, 2021. https://t.co/AWho2UDx25
@Anarkingz @DanCady @TyotoRiffle @climate_fact @GretaThunberg GLOBAL average temperature for the last 24,000 years "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/LlDMnchufh
RT @Ceist8: @Curtains2023 @What_Doubelieve @KarenK30622352 @DanCady @climate_fact @ejwwest @MatthewWielicki Global average temperature for…
RT @Ceist8: @Curtains2023 @What_Doubelieve @KarenK30622352 @DanCady @climate_fact @ejwwest @MatthewWielicki Global average temperature for…
@Curtains2023 @What_Doubelieve @KarenK30622352 @DanCady @climate_fact @ejwwest @MatthewWielicki Global average temperature for the last 24,000 years "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/Zf3WedU52W
@brendan_galway @bdaabat @KeillerDon @RossMcKitrick Just to be sure, I plotted the Osman data from data archived at Nature (https://t.co/yZsVEGo6qA). Here's what the proxy-only reconstruction looks like. I don't view this as the strong confirmation of Hockey Stick that you claim. Rather the opposite. https://t.co/JbsIJiKx8I
RT @AndrewDessler: Updated using the most recent paleo reconstruction (Osman et al., 2021, 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4). The main lesson is…
@MatthewWielicki Only an idiot or a propagandist would infer a global trend using data from 1% of the earths surface. I guess it might fool the non-critical thinker. #ClimateBrawl “Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum” Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/vB1OL7Bicv https://t.co/sLrgyWu5vV
@mpharjo77 @goddeketal Sure. Here's 24,000 years "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/k47wErJ4cO
RT @priscian: @3GHtweets @nonsequiturmeme @NomadicQuantum @Oliver9LH @RandomRation @jimdtweet @SniemN @IBergwiesel @ammocrypta @ItsTheAtmos…
@3GHtweets @nonsequiturmeme @NomadicQuantum @Oliver9LH @RandomRation @jimdtweet @SniemN @IBergwiesel @ammocrypta @ItsTheAtmospher @Devonian1342 @BubbasRanch @Kenneth72712993 @MikeDel21893959 @Veritatem2021 @TomWhatsoeverB @MartinJBern @ClimatePoet @FillmoreWhite @automatrix66_KC @JimBowersclimb @NoelTurner194 @JimFish56837379 @Data79504085 @miller_klein @Siriuslee1776 @FriendsOScience @UlaLomu @GWrightstone @d_e_mol @QuBuBrasil @Michael_D_Crow @aSinister @Faktantarkast10 @TamikaMRobson @CDMarshall7 @Jeffrey75327765 @RushhourP @xerb1966 @TullimonstrumC @ClimateRealists @iBlatant @StevenMBelknap @RstrixxX @bluebirdpoopies @Youcantbeserio6 @joseph_postma @jwickers @Gordon_DHG @BointonGiles 573 proxies that say you're wrong. Osman MB, Tierney JE, Zhu J, Tardif R, Hakim GJ, et al.: Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature 599:239–244, 2021. https://t.co/5T
@DBHuggins36 @JFlopTop @MatthewWielicki 1/2 Remember we are referring to global average temperature, not regional temperature: eg Osman et al 2021 "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/4xsyoPBLmE
@DBHuggins36 @JFlopTop @MatthewWielicki "warming periods over the last 4000 years"? That's incorrect. Osman et al 2021 "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/7HLYXgvctZ
@RandomRation @jimdtweet @d_e_mol @SniemN @IBergwiesel @TomWhatsoeverB @BubbasRanch @3GHtweets @Veritatem2021 @Kenneth72712993 @MartinJBern @ClimatePoet @FillmoreWhite @automatrix66_KC @JimBowersclimb @NoelTurner194 @ammocrypta @JimFish56837379 @Data79504085 @miller_klein @Siriuslee1776 @FriendsOScience @UlaLomu @GWrightstone @Devonian1342 @nonsequiturmeme @QuBuBrasil @MikeDel21893959 @Michael_D_Crow @aSinister @Faktantarkast10 @TamikaMRobson @CDMarshall7 @Jeffrey75327765 @RushhourP @xerb1966 @TullimonstrumC @ClimateRealists @iBlatant @StevenMBelknap @RstrixxX @bluebirdpoopies @Youcantbeserio6 @joseph_postma @jwickers @Gordon_DHG @BointonGiles @Doctordapp @jefftonna1 • Temp curve is probably flatter; v. Fig 1 & Kaufman &al 2020 https://t.co/fc46WdskuJ, Fig 2 & Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM • "Holocene conundrum" modeling now closer to reality; v. Fig 3 & Erb
@PMgeezer @GWrightstone @FriendsOScience @JunkScience @EcoSenseNow @VijayJayaraj_CC and "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/O8IQGBOPxQ
@MatthewWielicki @damagedonegr and "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZbtYh https://t.co/TD9pEkUt6K
@MatthewWielicki Your preferred chart shows only Greenland temps. Without other proxy data it doesn’t indicate global temps. Why not use the chart from Osmans paper on Holocene temps. #ClimateBrawl “Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum” https://t.co/vB1OL7Bicv https://t.co/DCfuEOMbqL
@ChartsClimate You: "Do you believe global temps were only 1C below pre industrial 12,000 BP?" The hint is "global average temop", not regional temps. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/1gxxZJ97tV
@ulster2022 @PeterDClack and a GLOBAL temperature reconstruction of the last 24,000 years Osman et al 2021 "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/nwoMuCsQz0
@bebop789 @PeterDClack How about Osman et al 2021. The Last Glacial Maximum was about 18,000 years ago. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/ys3e4V5jC3
@BillDraeger @ChrisMartzWX "5 major warming periods in the last 6,000 years" No. I bet you've been fooled by some hack creating a mislabeled graph of the Greenland GISP2 ice core data. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/0WirJZDIDp
@Willard1951 @dferris1961 @johnson_wrjohn1 @Climate_Takes @BJChippindale @FChecker76 @GrahamKirk17 @EdBohman @imperiallocust @RichardKing633 @TheDisproof @Climatehope2 @LHaden_Climate @ejwwest @ThruNoiz @DawnTJ90 @suffect @KeillerDon @Faktantarkast10 @LemarbreStephen @Mike8Wallace @verycentrist @j70def @lyndon_staley @Stephen90045069 @WHUT @EcoSenseNow @RStabb26 @MorseBart @EDavidAn @MartinJBern @AreYouDerp @canncr @PDemichel @RHMcK1 @outsanest @Robert76907841 @ClimateSkeptic4 @coug62 @Bos77 @MhehedZherting @LesJohnsonHrvat @aDissentient @ChrisBBacon3 @algore @LeoDiCaprio @nytclimate @BBCNewsnight @MichaelEMann My fave is Bova. https://t.co/cUmvFhsx39 W/Osman close behind https://t.co/AWho2UE4RD
@ChrisManuell @jscarto GLOBAL mean temp going back 24K years. From a published paper by scientists, not a screenshot from the junk-science blog of a crackpot. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/OoQwNM7Obp https://t.co/HOPAqhVupA
@TheDisproof @yangyubin1998 In the "comment in": https://t.co/J2iwAT0D8N And then "similar articles": https://t.co/3hC3uF9H4X "Antarctic Peninsula cooled by 3-4 °C over the past 12.000 yrs" "On millennial timescales, abrupt SST fluctuations of 2-4 °C coincide with globally recognized climate variability" https://t.co/fc6pWNUmkk
climate change Articles : Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum - Nature https://t.co/wOdsiho1ys
@RealCameronDye @jordanbpeterson You might like this paper too "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/LLkOCT3DnB https://t.co/wRBh71WZvL
@Zane1968 @ZLabe @NASAViz @NASAGISS @NASAClimate Human civilization began to flourish in the last ~10,000 years while the earth's temperature was fairly stable at ~1.2C colder than now, with CO2 levels of ~280ppm "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/JgzlRdX5CU https://t.co/VP6zJ1Nydp
@STEPHaBotamus @ZLabe @tridatta1 @NASAViz @NASAGISS @NASAClimate What do you mean by "core samples of the earth"? Do you mean proxies? How about 24,000 years? "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/JgzlRdX5CU https://t.co/Cktyig5Ati
@Sessler @ZLabe @NASAViz @NASAGISS @NASAClimate Or 24,000 years "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/OoQwNM7Obp https://t.co/5jCtYxURAK
@MatthewWielicki Wrong again - from the following paper. Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/eYG91fbCXQ https://t.co/h806nAXtlA
@jer_poynton99 @PeterDClack So far, your sources are junkscience blogs and faked graphs or no sources at all. For the Holocene see: "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/OoQwNM7Obp https://t.co/nAwQGNPWQ1
@EcoSenseNow Human civilization started to flourish in the last ~10,000 years while the earth's temperature was fairly stable and with CO2 levels of ~280-300ppm. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/OoQwNM7Obp https://t.co/nru62tr8uk
@Wotans_Runen @rahmstorf Ich verstehe nicht, warum Sie in der Abbildung von Rahmstorf oben links die Quelle nicht lesen. Hierdas paper https://t.co/u9Qv1jXECG Hier die Tabelle, wo die Daten von Rahmstorf herkommen. Was wollen Sie mehr? https://t.co/zRtU6FAoUv Das hat für mich jetzt 3 Minuten gedauert
RT @25_cycle: @Caspineft @vellumone @PeterDClack btw... https://t.co/AWho2UE4RD https://t.co/cvWnmlBNjv
@Caspineft @vellumone @PeterDClack btw... https://t.co/AWho2UE4RD https://t.co/cvWnmlBNjv
@VltHilftReden Ah. Lesen ist vorteilhaft. "SST" steht ja da. Und Kanada fehlt auch. Okeh. Hier der Link zur Studie. Passte oben nich mehr hin. https://t.co/kBap6P3jUc
RT @AtomsksSanakan: PaperOfTheDay https://t.co/z5lDyLVqRI https://t.co/mSl73XmydN "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last…
Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum | Nature https://t.co/y4HjLRiAw2
@JohnBgood45 @ClimateRealists Funny, but not a global reconstruction. You're useless. Here's 1, (Osman, et al, 2021) I've got several. https://t.co/AWho2UlVDv
RT @AtomsksSanakan: PaperOfTheDay https://t.co/z5lDyLVqRI https://t.co/mSl73XmydN "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last…
PaperOfTheDay https://t.co/z5lDyLVqRI https://t.co/mSl73XmydN "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/t550lmGInp [https://t.co/P2rctrgkj4] https://t.co/ixaAOkc1Kt https://t.co/gJ9Y0K9IpK
@Jimhusband1 @tomhfh @GaiaFawkes It's been verified numerous times. There was doubt over it because of the MWP, but that turned out to cooler and more regional than thought. Here's a newer paper that shows more historic data, inc ice age: Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. https://t.co/9bliwl2PjF
@BenKoby1911 @JusticeTrudeau @glinch72 @AristotleMrs @Jaisans @Anvndarnamn5 @NolanCarlton2 @fischerfischy @CarrudoDon @Michael_D_Crow @ncdave4life @DenisDaly @Joeyd87745119 @Climatehope2 @Mark_A_Lunn @Devonian1342 @S_D_Mannix @Veritatem2021 @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @waxliberty @priscian @SuperFoxyLoxy @ChrisBBacon3 @JimBowersclimb @JaapTitulaer @Willard1951 @wjack76995 @Rocky35418823 @NobaconEgbert @balls95652097 @JustThi30117912 @SniemN @BointonGiles @ammocrypta @SeekerTheGreat1 @ubique60 @CDMarshall7 @EthonRaptor @RMcgillss @paligap17 @TheDisproof @MaggieL @Willy1000 @AuroriaTwittori @3GHtweets @RushhourP @MartinJBern @gstrandberg1 The number is zero. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/x0E6yzMS4J
@cmcateer3 Let me ask you a very important question, why are you showing only single sources and not one of these are long range contemporary global reconstructions? Is it because you know they all disagree? https://t.co/AWho2UE4RD
@glenGDN @AlastairGill3 @toadmeister Your 1969 piece on modelled paleoclimate. The scientific method demands once a hypothesis has been invalidated, it must be declared a false hypothesis. The Holocene didn't look anything like that crude drawing you showed. https://t.co/AWho2UlVDv
@dodders75 @KevinClimate @BarbReilly7 @BlasphemousBan1 @JdubAndrew @merlinseyebrow @Dudesaurus14 @GGrimalda @Autostadt @VW @JKSteinberger @ThierryAaron @CharlieJGardner @GretaThunberg @GhostPanther @ClimateEFund @ClimateHuman @dancalverley "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/D42rhmivM2 https://t.co/cGQxPUiOX9
@JohnBen30549105 @toadmeister Wrong. No scientists use the long discredited Monte Heib chart so beloved by AGW deniers. #ClimateBrawl “Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum” Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/vB1OL7Bicv https://t.co/qXDP6ukoQE
@tomdavi84459361 @Climatehope2 @Willard1951 @NobaconEgbert @balls95652097 @Veritatem2021 @JaapTitulaer @JustThi30117912 @DenisDaly @fischerfischy @JimBowersclimb @Anvndarnamn5 @SniemN @BointonGiles @AristotleMrs @ammocrypta @priscian @Hji45519156 @Rocky35418823 @Jaisans @SeekerTheGreat1 @Michael_D_Crow @ChrisBBacon3 @Mark_A_Lunn @ubique60 @CDMarshall7 @Data79504085 @ncdave4life @glinch72 @heinsenberger @EthonRaptor @RMcgillss @paligap17 @S_D_Mannix @TheDisproof @MaggieL @Willy1000 @AuroriaTwittori @3GHtweets @RushhourP @MartinJBern @gstrandberg1 @ItsTheAtmospher @Jakegsm @EricWil06256732 @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @KCTaz @Valja46Zhark5 Or 24,000 years "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/1qHasAStJ3
#ClimateBrawl Funny how he attacks me for not supplying sources while he did the same. So... Holocene sources: Osman https://t.co/AWho2UlVDv Bova: https://t.co/cUmvFhanP1 Kaufman: https://t.co/BNxFmISuxX Late Holocene, Neukom: https://t.co/2JXmTulnGw https://t.co/fu6q53ywj2 https://t.co/yDVIYQlRFj
@treptow_martin @CapitalistV3GAN Link? Tell me little child, is that global or local? Only the lowest most worthless weasels use local data, it's their admission that they're too stupid to be considered sentient. Game over, loser. https://t.co/AWho2UDx25 https://t.co/XWkHf0igaa
@ShaMikaWhoSeeks @StarLost_1701 @benmooreau @BernaB_2013 @BBfanning @MikeDel21893959 @Veritatem2021 @ALefty123 @ozzorro1 @FChecker76 @Wallisbadgerson @Ecotainment_YT @goingglocal @Stephen90045069 @insane_voice @aSinister @AndryGiles @JackJsherebkin @ZombiePiano @talipes @Andrewemcameron @AlexVickeryHowe @JohannesTuyl @JJJungleJim @mac_an_ghoill @WeRone777 @DocSnow1 @ejwwest @glinch72 @realJohnJHoward @Spencerfletch0 @USNA_73 @peblackstock @markinkorea @cbeckj @Frankd06830 @LesterDent @Lo_VVriter @toddynd @KathyGrants @Alfred_StatesX @BarnhartDooie @RstrixxX @berry_hardman @FLastrade @njbtweet @SageThinker99 @ronkonoma @choosefreedomf1 @IceAge2150 and Osman et al 2021 for the last 24,00 years: "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/jiTkClCz77
@hellgatehell @GeraldKutney @aaronflint @TuckerCarlson Okay, so they aren't global reconstructions, just single points. Yeah, so that is a failure. Here's 4 modern global reconstructions. https://t.co/AWho2UDx25 https://t.co/cUmvFhrZdB https://t.co/BNxFmJa5Wx https://t.co/JNluHbkUtf
@RobertL15069606 @ian_doktor @NASAClimate Try GLOBAL temp reconstructions, not one ice core at the top of the Greenland ice-sheet with data that ended in 1855. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/LBV7u0Y7pd
@St33lMouse @AlexandreGeneve @MrMatthewTodd "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/uOaamqnUIU
@rozjonez @PmeT99 @SciNeev @toadmeister Yes. The global mean surface temperature was pretty stable for around 10K years. That's when human civilization & agriculture started to develop. "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/OEqzX1cAjG
@LordCocksure @Rebecca74083947 @25_cycle @Bostons80113133 @charlie_cairoli @davidrvetter The warming since the pre-industrial era NOT a "natural" cycle: "Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum" -Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/7O0LrZc1NP https://t.co/TeG8Yjgl7N
@ncdave4life @Mark_A_Lunn @GreenMachineECC @AristotleMrs @Veritatem2021 @glinch72 @Data79504085 @JimBowersclimb @Climatehope2 @blackarrowxv @richietrailer @chuzbucket @mentalmal1 @ammocrypta @alison_pannell @FlowerandFist @Anvndarnamn5 @WillWat6 @CallidusDominus @3GHtweets @MAGA_Translator @TWTThisIsNow @KCTaz @0Sundance @TheDisproof @Ceist8 @TullimonstrumC @Jaisans @glehman11 @drochir_thonnuk @AlexVickeryHowe @atherton_chris @ItsTheAtmospher @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @MartinJBern @EthonRaptor @gstrandberg1 @Jakegsm @EricWil06256732 @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @Hji45519156 @Valja46Zhark5 @paulp1232 @ShroedingerBird @J0aquIm_B4rb0s4 Railing & wailing on Twitter isn't scientific data and certainty isn't a quality scientific publication, Dave You should know the papers Osman et al 2021 https://t.co/PJpjfbD291 Bova et al 2021 https://t.co/BZQalkWNR9
@JodyDahrouge @BaldryVincent @GeraldKutney @TiceRichard Not quite- what's your source for paleoclimate CO2? (See chart below) In fact, what's your sources for any of this? CO2: https://t.co/8aUPRbZSUB Temps: https://t.co/AWho2UDx25 https://t.co/cUmvFhrZdB https://t.co/aQ6RqjcFBJ
@JodyDahrouge @GeraldKutney @TiceRichard But we can explain it! Albedo change when the Wisconsin glaciers melted. And it's still more than an order of magnitude lower than modern warming. Your best source for that temperature data is Osman, 2021. https://t.co/AWho2UDx25
@Enjibenji135 @TiceRichard Osman, et al, 2021 suggests it was a bit less than 4°C. The more we study this topic the "flatter" the Earth's temperature profile seems. (Darned, paywalled...) https://t.co/AWho2UDx25
@10kClimate You're welcome to note and to cite key papers I've referred to some of these https://t.co/Y1qgVuRLtX https://t.co/cBWkp4wpCL https://t.co/XbbS5fmVH0 https://t.co/UpHLlvbe5j https://t.co/SMI9YuaAc8 https://t.co/BZQalkWNR9 https://t.co/PJpjfbD291
@MartinJBern @DaveAtherton20 @BrexitDuck @MerlynThomas @MarcoLSilva These uneducated liars think their claims without evidence have merit. They don't. https://t.co/cUmvFhrZdB https://t.co/AWho2UDx25
@catandman @TheDisproof @CAR26_ORG @LoisPerry26 @GBNEWS @LanceForman Tell you what, he's already shown and I have as well data on MWP not existing globally. You give us a GLOBAL climate reconstruction for MWP. And same for Minoan... You seem to enjoy lying. https://t.co/AWho2UDx25
@3GHtweets @fishyfish67 @jimdtweet @Kenneth72712993 @shicks_sam @BubbasRanch @SuperFoxyLoxy @Mark_A_Lunn @TWTThisIsNow @TullimonstrumC @Faktantarkast10 @Jeffrey75327765 @ejwwest @GaryNotHairy @MarkThomasIw @automatrix66_KC @Michael_D_Crow @Gladeskat @Pinheir58339900 @robhon_ @aSinister @Devonian1342 @FriendsOScience @2aQueer @JusticeTrudeau @IBergwiesel @jwickers @AGWisScience @CDMarshall7 @Veritatem2021 @joseph_postma @NoelTurner194 @ClimatePoet @Gordon_DHG @BointonGiles @Doctordapp @jefftonna1 @nicolaennio @USNA_73 @d_e_mol @EthonRaptor @Cris_Paunescu @GZzyzyx @akaelwopo1 @RushhourP @drochir_thonnuk @RstrixxX @Trudy72842064 @verycentrist Indeed I am. Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky. Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM https://t.co/Sl3loFpaKH
@paulp1232 @Metaphix1990 @GrantTally @iceman192231 @washingtonpost ‘both the rate and magnitude of modern warming are unusual relative to the changes of the past 24 thousand years.’ Osman, M.B., Tierney, J.E., Zhu, J. et al. Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature 599, 239–244 (2021). https://t.co/JN1AwGhDKb
@EdBohman @craigthomler @PolAnimalAus @FireFox_XB9R @DougBookwriter2 @ILuvCO2 @dan613 @TWTThisIsNow @AltUS_ARC @PACleanwater @ThomasPaine5 @SteveSGoddard @MLBinWA @Robin_Hagues @RoyPentland @SylviaD32911201 @Boi_dBoi_d @bjames280961 @_kevinmartin @mytk56 @gjbangar @gershuni @Dcoronata @sueytonius @IngersolRobert @DawnTJ90 @AtomsksSanakan @EdDarrell @CMH19611 @ChrisMartzWX @Greg49039425 @bigskyrad @milneorchid @bfolson18 @JohnPalkovic @TADinKaty @PlanetLuvie @GeraldKutney @ClimateRealists @BradSchrag @Forthwithtx @DrMarkImisides @david_hanselman @amidgley @miked194765 This one has a legit source. Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky. Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM https://t.co/yyiURu3JnJ
@EricWil06256732 @MartinJBern @Moderna5G_666 @priscian @ncdave4life @Mark_A_Lunn @BouchellJohn @ChrisBBacon3 @ianrowley677 @ejwwest @Willard1951 @ShroedingerBird @6lennybravo @glinch72 @tevet @JimBowersclimb @MustBeJoshing @BlasphemousBan1 @Climatehope2 @Winston43105474 @Dannyboy7293 @Jaisans @WillWat6 @Ceist8 @jbonbon91 @DarthFeodor @TWTThisIsNow @BradPKeyes @atherton_chris @3GHtweets @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @BailFund_Brawl @AristotleMrs @gstrandberg1 @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @TheDisproof @Veritatem2021 @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @KCTaz lets update this up shall we ? Osman etal. Nature (2021) Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum DOI 10.1038/s41586-021-03984-4 your only throwing up a bitch fest because Judith Curry had a major bovine birth when Osman published from Nat
@EricWil06256732 @MartinJBern @Moderna5G_666 @ncdave4life @Mark_A_Lunn @BouchellJohn @ChrisBBacon3 @ianrowley677 @ejwwest @Willard1951 @ShroedingerBird @6lennybravo @glinch72 @tevet @JimBowersclimb @MustBeJoshing @BlasphemousBan1 @Climatehope2 @Winston43105474 @ItsTheAtmospher @Dannyboy7293 @Jaisans @WillWat6 @Ceist8 @jbonbon91 @DarthFeodor @TWTThisIsNow @BradPKeyes @atherton_chris @3GHtweets @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @BailFund_Brawl @AristotleMrs @gstrandberg1 @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @TheDisproof @Veritatem2021 @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @KCTaz "Peer review information Nature thanks William Gray and the other, anonymous, reviewer(s) for their contribution to the peer review of this work. Peer reviewer reports are available." The peer review file is here https://t.co/qmJ0wJeTB6
@PeterDClack That's a bit outdated & doesn't appear to be referenced. Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky. Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM https://t.co/tq2xmlVyyb
@Stephen90045069 @EricWil06256732 @MartinJBern @Mark_A_Lunn @Ceist8 @Willard1951 @ncdave4life @foxdoom71 @TWTThisIsNow @ianrowley677 @Veritatem2021 @ItsTheAtmospher @JimBowersclimb @MustBeJoshing @BlasphemousBan1 @Climatehope2 @Winston43105474 @Dannyboy7293 @Jaisans @WillWat6 @ChrisBBacon3 @jbonbon91 @DarthFeodor @glinch72 @BradPKeyes @atherton_chris @3GHtweets @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @BailFund_Brawl @AristotleMrs @gstrandberg1 @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @TheDisproof @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @KCTaz @Valja46Zhark5 @drochir_thonnuk @paulp1232 @ShroedingerBird @US_FDA That's a nice extension of Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM that includes temps modeled from several possible future emissions scenarios. It's from here https://t.co/BnNaUWrhBS https://t.co/cLdzmEkPTL
@Canadianworker2 @jimdtweet @Kenneth72712993 @OscarsWild1 @Hakimi82421476 @insane_voice @GlennCarr6 @robhon_ @Hakimi09966557 @eric_flesch @ClimateSkeptic4 @Michael_D_Crow @IanDJbrown2 @WayneAllanH @N3S73 @BubbasRanch @IngersolRobert @MarshallCd @wlbeeton @ejwwest @NoelTurner194 @Narvuntien @oakden_wolf @rln_nelson @BlasphemousBan1 @RickLazzarini @Veritatem2021 @keithamccluskey @JimBlack48 @ChrisBBacon3 @variegated2 @njbtweet @MikeDel21893959 @jgorman2424 @hughjarse5 @HsuRina1 @pauladamsalber1 @RushhourP @StormSignalSA @HappensClimate @BrknMan @Barbarajdurkin @MedBennett @WeAreShortOTime @MichaelEMann @brandondaly2018 @WutinPladimir @Marcusgibson @HalBrow68884227 @Gladfly1 Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky. Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBf9ssk https://t.co/y2GyPPVeNw
@torpet002 @Mark_A_Lunn @BradPKeyes @gstrandberg1 @KCTaz @AlexVickeryHowe @S_D_Mannix @Ceist8 @Jaisans @atherton_chris @ItsTheAtmospher @Climatehope2 @WillWat6 @3GHtweets @TWTThisIsNow @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @TobyRayEnglish @JimBowersclimb @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @MartinJBern @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @BailFund_Brawl @AristotleMrs @ncdave4life @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @EricWil06256732 @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @TheDisproof @Veritatem2021 @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @Valja46Zhark5 @drochir_thonnuk @paulp1232 @ShroedingerBird @J0aquIm_B4rb0s4 @Sky48115666 @0Sundance @DoesThisW0rk @FD2you @glinch72 @JustThi30117912 @ChrisBBacon3 @B_Bolshevik100 Figure is reasonably correct Question is not the red line, but the blue Again, see the current back and forth on certain ocean proxies, changes in surface cover over time (wax and wane of Green Sahara), etc https://t.co/BZQalkWNR9 https://t.
@torpet002 @Mark_A_Lunn @BradPKeyes @gstrandberg1 @KCTaz @AlexVickeryHowe @S_D_Mannix @Ceist8 @Jaisans @atherton_chris @ItsTheAtmospher @Climatehope2 @WillWat6 @3GHtweets @TWTThisIsNow @DGinCheshire @BointonGiles @TobyRayEnglish @JimBowersclimb @AuroriaTwittori @RushhourP @MartinJBern @EthonRaptor @Anvndarnamn5 @BailFund_Brawl @AristotleMrs @ncdave4life @Jakegsm @ammocrypta @EricWil06256732 @DTGvmd @wille99 @PaulDFarrar @TheDisproof @Veritatem2021 @Data79504085 @Hji45519156 @Valja46Zhark5 @drochir_thonnuk @paulp1232 @ShroedingerBird @J0aquIm_B4rb0s4 @Sky48115666 @0Sundance @DoesThisW0rk @FD2you @glinch72 @JustThi30117912 @ChrisBBacon3 @B_Bolshevik100 Climate history (paleoclimate science) says Holocene picture is coming together That picture strongly suggests we're now warmer than any period in the last 100,000 years due to AGW And lots of lively debate https://t.co/BZQalkWNR9 https://t.
@RickLazzarini @rln_nelson @BlasphemousBan1 @Hakimi82421476 @Veritatem2021 @insane_voice @Michael_D_Crow @IanDJbrown2 @keithamccluskey @JimBlack48 @OscarsWild1 @NoelTurner194 @Kenneth72712993 @jimdtweet @ChrisBBacon3 @WayneAllanH @variegated2 @BubbasRanch @njbtweet @IngersolRobert @MikeDel21893959 @jgorman2424 @hughjarse5 @oakden_wolf @HsuRina1 @pauladamsalber1 @wlbeeton @eric_flesch @RushhourP @robhon_ @StormSignalSA @HappensClimate @ejwwest @GlennCarr6 @Canadianworker2 @BrknMan @Narvuntien @Barbarajdurkin @MedBennett @WeAreShortOTime @MichaelEMann @brandondaly2018 @WutinPladimir @Marcusgibson @HalBrow68884227 @Gladfly1 @Moderna5G_666 @Militant_Gnomes @Hakimi45926227 @AGWIsHappening Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky. Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM. & we know that it's likely warmer now than for the past 100 ky (e.g. Snyder 2016 https://t.co/AEoPH
@rln_nelson @Gladfly1 @insane_voice @OscarsWild1 @NoelTurner194 @IngersolRobert @borngeek @jimdtweet @BubbasRanch @Kenneth72712993 @oakden_wolf @HsuRina1 @pauladamsalber1 @wlbeeton @MikeDel21893959 @BlasphemousBan1 @ChrisBBacon3 @Michael_D_Crow @eric_flesch @RushhourP @robhon_ @StormSignalSA @HappensClimate @ejwwest @GlennCarr6 @Canadianworker2 @BrknMan @Narvuntien @Barbarajdurkin @njbtweet @MedBennett @keithamccluskey @WeAreShortOTime @MichaelEMann @brandondaly2018 @WayneAllanH @WutinPladimir @Marcusgibson @HalBrow68884227 @Moderna5G_666 @Militant_Gnomes @Hakimi45926227 @AGWIsHappening @amcelha3 @RobMeekel @RidaAller @TommyG35138533 @JimBlack48 @Stephen90045069 What cold period do you mean—the one 24 ky ago? (Figure 1 from Marcott & Shakun 2021 https://t.co/E3ijhTZwJP, adapted from "Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky," Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRR
@BailFund_Brawl @TheDisproof That's from a single site only in Greenland. Now let's look at a longer global multi-proxy reconstruction: Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky. Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM https://t.co/l9TRTXuKC8
@ThomBradley8 @sueytonius @PeterDClack That doesn't show up globally. Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky. Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM https://t.co/ElU9ttSvSK
@WeiZhangAtmos @brandondaly2018 "Plenty of proxy reconstructions fly in face of that data." Not large-scale. Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky. Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM https://t.co/cbbuarFB9m
@ykiwm2022 @johnnymknox @EcoSenseNow Source please? Seriously now, I'm sure you think that's right but it isn't. This is exactly why you guys are always going to look foolish, you are the most gullible idiots that walk the globe. https://t.co/zhVeu8laNQ Source data: https://t.co/L5BGpSQLpG
@Kenneth72712993 @jimdtweet @jgorman2424 @BubbasRanch @MikeDel21893959 @eric_flesch @pauladamsalber1 @Michael_D_Crow @StormSignalSA @HappensClimate @ejwwest @GlennCarr6 @OscarsWild1 @IngersolRobert @insane_voice @Canadianworker2 @BrknMan @Narvuntien @Barbarajdurkin @njbtweet @MedBennett @keithamccluskey @rln_nelson @WeAreShortOTime @MichaelEMann @brandondaly2018 @NoelTurner194 @WayneAllanH @WutinPladimir @ChrisBBacon3 @Marcusgibson @HalBrow68884227 @Gladfly1 @robhon_ @Moderna5G_666 @Militant_Gnomes @Hakimi45926227 @wlbeeton @AGWIsHappening @amcelha3 @RobMeekel @RidaAller @borngeek @TommyG35138533 @JimBlack48 @Stephen90045069 @Michael01172716 @LogicalAtheist3 @MephistoTabern1 @JohnDublin10 "Holocene" Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky. Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM https://t.co/6kUl6Snu9S
@MikeDel21893959 @jimdtweet @HappensClimate @ejwwest @GlennCarr6 @Michael_D_Crow @eric_flesch @OscarsWild1 @IngersolRobert @insane_voice @Canadianworker2 @BrknMan @Narvuntien @Barbarajdurkin @njbtweet @MedBennett @keithamccluskey @rln_nelson @WeAreShortOTime @MichaelEMann @brandondaly2018 @Kenneth72712993 @NoelTurner194 @WayneAllanH @WutinPladimir @pauladamsalber1 @BubbasRanch @StormSignalSA @ChrisBBacon3 @Marcusgibson @HalBrow68884227 @Gladfly1 @robhon_ @Moderna5G_666 @Militant_Gnomes @Hakimi45926227 @wlbeeton @AGWIsHappening @amcelha3 @RobMeekel @RidaAller @borngeek @TommyG35138533 @JimBlack48 @Stephen90045069 @Michael01172716 @LogicalAtheist3 @MephistoTabern1 @JohnDublin10 @meganjherbert Okay. Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky. Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM https://t.co/xM9FrClpcQ
@DanCady to head off the odd denier who will complain about a pre-print, this was published in Nature with data and code Osman, M.B., Tierney, J.E., Zhu, J. et al. Globally resolved surface temperatures since the Last Glacial Maximum. Nature 599, 239–244 (2021). https://t.co/qSaBBBxmS2
@gazza_d Here's the latest and best available information on global temperature. What is it about these people? See https://t.co/k3Ex7kIp93 (behind paywall) https://t.co/vCbawliMpS
@ReneDercksen @RushhourP @BubbasRanch @Kenneth72712993 @jimdtweet @shicks_sam @MikeDel21893959 @mtobis @MedBennett @DrDMurray1 @cfreespeech @IBergwiesel @Narvuntien @fishyfish67 @MartinJBern @Keeper_86 @KCTaz @dan613 @thinks_about_it @andrewp109 @d_e_mol @RoyPentland @cjtjgeol @TheDisproof @JimBlack48 @Climatehope2 @KingMetal7 @10kClimate @rcubed17 @MarkJohnsonTw @KeillerDon @Willy1000 @N_Schmid @Barbarajdurkin @janusPrime @HalleVerkehrt @FriendsOScience @imsuresteve @Icecinder @Disorganised1 @EdItor87411083 @automatrix66_KC @Robert76907841 @RjeanGirard1 @ClimateCatastr3 @AldoSterone111 @rogermarksmen @CarrudoDon @johnson_wrjohn1 @Osprey0 Global mean surface temperature change over the past 24 ky. Osman &al 2021 https://t.co/5TkYBeRRAM https://t.co/Fg6wXwCgF8
RT @DWD_klima: Das Autorenteam folgert u.a.: "When compared with recent temperature changes, our reanalysis indicates that both the rate an…
RT @DWD_klima: Das Autorenteam folgert u.a.: "When compared with recent temperature changes, our reanalysis indicates that both the rate an…
RT @DWD_klima: Das Autorenteam folgert u.a.: "When compared with recent temperature changes, our reanalysis indicates that both the rate an…
Das Autorenteam folgert u.a.: "When compared with recent temperature changes, our reanalysis indicates that both the rate and magnitude of modern warming are unusual relative to the changes of the past 24 thousand years." (https://t.co/RcmBZxrmT0) #Klimawandel
@EarthObserver4 @wrmazurek @Robin_Hagues @_Lost_My_Way_ @adlrope @27Legin @TethLL @ClimateSkeptic4 @MickGreenhough @PierreTherrie17 @3GHtweets @Veritatem2021 @WanderSci @AGRichard1 @mugger124 @insane_voice @TomPlesier @ejwwest @DedRed18 @WReynolds20 @SegmentOverrun @DamienHamilto17 @SConwaySmith @fagandr1 @DrMarkJoyce1 @NdabaningiMoyo @BarbaraGirouard @gregchoat @TheRealStranded @DeeKay_mcmxcii @gjcats @IngersolRobert @PolAnimalAus @Visitor22 @joe_possibly @GZzyzyx @bjames280961 @GeraldKutney @Dsp3ncr @BointonGiles @Cypress_NL @jonsaxon67 @bendynaa @ddasser @StewartNial @NOVisOver @DawnTJ90 @AltYelloNatPark @DrMarkImisides @tan123 https://t.co/eJPIYve9vu
@ThomBradley8 @RaeSean8 @TIME @Indigoag >“Greenland 11th century” Summer in Greenland were warmer at that time even though global average temperature was cooler than it is today (https://t.co/eJPIYve9vu) >“The only thing they had to burn was wood which produces far more CO2 then fossil fuels” No, FFs add more CO₂: https://t.co/KVrcCjNVVI
@ClimateSkeptic4 @TethLL @MickGreenhough @EarthObserver4 @PierreTherrie17 @3GHtweets @Veritatem2021 @WanderSci @AGRichard1 @_Lost_My_Way_ @mugger124 @insane_voice @TomPlesier @ejwwest @DedRed18 @WReynolds20 @SegmentOverrun @DamienHamilto17 @adlrope @SConwaySmith @fagandr1 @DrMarkJoyce1 @NdabaningiMoyo @BarbaraGirouard @gregchoat @TheRealStranded @DeeKay_mcmxcii @gjcats @27Legin @IngersolRobert @PolAnimalAus @Visitor22 @joe_possibly @GZzyzyx @bjames280961 @GeraldKutney @Dsp3ncr @BointonGiles @Cypress_NL @Robin_Hagues @jonsaxon67 @bendynaa @ddasser @StewartNial @NOVisOver @DawnTJ90 @AltYelloNatPark @DrMarkImisides @tan123 @COP26 Greenland temperatures are a poor proxy for global temperatures. See the latest global temperature reconstruction by Osman et al.: https://t.co/eJPIYve9vu https://t.co/6zYRYD8YD8 https://t.co/wbqMxcFq79
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
24000 سنة من بيانات درجة الحرارة تُظهر مدى سخونة العالم الحالية غير المسبوقة. وفقًا لدراسة جديدة جمعت المئات من سجلات درجات الحرارة من جميع أنحاء العالم لرسم خريطة لتغير المناخ في الماضي. https://t.co/2KYbMtJPFb https://t.co/2ES8u4qesS
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…
RT @TerliWetter: Wir schießen raus aus der Zone, die für uns Menschen überlebenswichtig ist. Weiter so, immer weiter. Übrigens die #Klimaka…