Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
Numerous discussions center around the study's findings, such as the statement that 94% of trans youth maintained their gender identity five years after social transition. Phrases like 'trans youth stay true to their identity' and 'low rates of detransition' signal the belief that early social transitions are generally beneficial. Additionally, participants react critically to opposing viewpoints, underscoring the importance of evidence-based discussions in shaping public understanding of transgender issues.
The majority of posts indicate a moderate to strong agreement with the findings of the article, showcasing a belief in the persistence of gender identity among trans youth.
Many participants express high interest in the study's implications and findings, indicating a connection to broader discussions regarding gender identity.
There is significant engagement depth, with users referencing statistical details and engaging in robust discussions that critique or support the study's claims.
A strong belief exists among participants regarding the article's potential impact on societal perceptions of transgender youths and their experiences.
Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor, A. (2022). https://t.co/1mQZ3qxGZW 85/
@Psygrav @Marmala27217367 @SkullMutant @aqueerius8 @rickspenguin @RoronoaBayo @CritRacePapers @itsjacksonbbz @KCMiller1225 https://t.co/vXUqmVjmv6 https://t.co/o7wVjwOGXp https://t.co/dUBj51m3CR here https://t.co/2nevWApiNj
Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of young people who identified as transgender as children still identified as transgender after five years of social transition. https://t.co/FHIUOlCXEG
Also there is already information on long-term outcomes published by Olson et al (2022). 94% of children under the age of 12 who socially transition remain socially transitioned after five years. https://t.co/TJW1Cgwh7z
Un estudio longitudinal con 317 jóvenes transidentificados encontró que, cinco años después de la transición social, el 94% seguía identificándose como transgénero, lo que sugiere que esta intervención solidifica la identidad trans en estos casos. https://t.co/lG5l3MN4QU
@SOCryptoKapital @SBalveda @KatyMontgomerie @Bluesoulreggae Several. Dysphoria is a well studied thing. Here are some sources https://t.co/Q4zVvOreQ5 https://t.co/TbJ6ivRyXl https://t.co/11cqilcaxJ
Neo's identity is characterized as non-binary and gender fluid, reflecting a society in transition. Despite legal advancements, societal acceptance remains a challenge, particularly in the face of rising anti-queer…
This episode breaks down the newest data on how often trans youth stop hormone therapy and retransition to a cisgender identity. It explores a study of over 1000 adolescents, shedding light on their experiences and the…
@grok Trans desistance, steensma and zucker, I'd suggest https://t.co/wwpfCKnj2q
@grok https://t.co/wwpfCKnQRY
@Mr_Paul_2022 @PseudoJester @Wrensayschill @BJurns48955 @Will481046 @sappholives83 Wrong https://t.co/w4GsmSiolb https://t.co/f2BQ6bd46t https://t.co/htrzuY9XJ8 https://t.co/GNVtbBcjTv https://t.co/AyvRuveBq2 https://t.co/zfIZGGv0qF https://t.co/UWByaseya6 https://t.co/PvgXumWHGB https://t.co/TO5qZCZyAB https://t.co/iaR5NkCFtE
@Mr_Paul_2022 @PseudoJester @Wrensayschill @Will481046 @sappholives83 Nope. https://t.co/pAoKytBhU7 https://t.co/vlAZNJ9dVr https://t.co/Y3YW8S89Qg https://t.co/a0qrYdl9jf https://t.co/zmRQIIpX5u https://t.co/j2zBJXp5XM https://t.co/UkbpmvZaDq https://t.co/pLQRHhERnR https://t.co/Bbqq6D7bm8 https://t.co/MSIxyxhqjk
@SimonTuffen @Mx_Jayjay @nogulagsagain https://t.co/qSYmA6quzX
@RaffRouser @nyaraVT According to (present though subject to change with further research) data, the majority (94%) of transkids don't de-transition. https://t.co/F6frpqISbm. The study also implies, however, that transitioning, med or otherwise, shouldn't be done before age 6 (not 18). Id.
@Ronny_funk @VatosOoC Ah entonces un niño de preescolar nunca responde si es niño o niña... Recién me entero que es un pensamiento "complejo" responder eso. Y sobre que es "hasta la adolescencia" acá le refutan: estudio de antes de la adolescencia: https://t.co/pLxbRfWChd
@RegulusAlpha64 @VatosOoC 1. Lo experimento? 2. La experiencia le gana a la investigación a profundidad sobre la formación de identidades? https://t.co/pLxbRfWChd
@Lfromthenorth @brocflower 2/? On gender identity being consistent: https://t.co/5yzxLertbL
@ZeroShift7 @stone_toss Here are some studies that I'm sure you won't read that support my beliefs. https://t.co/qK83kQcFPv https://t.co/ZsOtgDCQrY https://t.co/dg0Y4386WV
@ReaverXXI @nyaraVT It's actually 2.5 percent. https://t.co/EGrjhj0sNz All those studies looked at gender-nonconforming c1s kids, not trans kids.
@kaamonsense @nyaraVT @Asmongold 2.5% https://t.co/EGrjhj10D7
@TinaD56971 https://t.co/vLyAsRAJjx https://t.co/c4rV4xVWne en effet on a pas les mêmes chiffres . quand aux effets secondaires on parle des quels? genre la voix qui s'aggrave sous la testostérone ? ou la pilosité? genre vous voulez dire des effets voulus en fait?
@Providence_777 @NinjaTHaii @stephenwhittle @yvonne83417362 I go by the most recent reputable science. From the APA, quote: "We found that an average of 5 years after their initial social transition.... At the end of this period, most youth identified as binary transgender youth (94%)..." full study: https://t.co/KFY8bBZjKj
@anitasleep @Stewart_2028 Weird you would claim that
@HoldforChrist @cullenators @macemaeday I need citations for those claims. I can prove my position with them showing that suicidal ideation REDUCES when they receive care and that trans minors STAY trans after they become adults. https://t.co/H4XqZilR8R https://t.co/ztbbrXOVdg
@Schwettynerd @aeroxsun Modern longitudinal studies tell a very different story. In a 5-year follow-up of socially transitioned children, 94% still identified as trans or nonbinary, and only 3.5% retransitioned, usually to another gender-diverse identity. https://t.co/57cy9fn1eU
RT @Espilbergo: @AgustinLaje ¿Posta decís "Abuso" Agustin, hablando de acompañar infancias trans? Pero los datos dicen otra cosa: En el es…
@AgustinLaje ¿Posta decís "Abuso" Agustin, hablando de acompañar infancias trans? Pero los datos dicen otra cosa: En el estudio más grande, 94% de los chicos que transicionan siguen firmes en su identidad años después. ¿Dónde está el "engaño"? https://t.co/OjYAKvdulU ¿Sabés qué sí es
@XoanaTintos @AlexandraLadyXY @Pantera_pe @alina0 @pazlat @b4tb0n3ss Con gusto: 1. https://t.co/iG4IGB1OnW 2. https://t.co/y0aKs9G5aE 3. https://t.co/pqV8bD7JSN
@FiadhBaikal @TheOldeWyrm A more in-depth view of the study. It's a very interesting read if you'd like. https://t.co/aIaRqrdxwq
@FiadhBaikal @TheOldeWyrm How many examples can you give though? Why are you looking at individual cases that support what you believe instead of the studies that say otherwise? https://t.co/aIaRqrdxwq
@Valoney_ Sure! Here are studies showing 1) regret rate for gender affirming surgery, 2) detransition rates (including temporary) along with the reasons, and 3) detransition rates for youth after 5 years: https://t.co/wxIDe0SMh6 https://t.co/CYjB544MeB https://t.co/aIaRqre5lY
@wiseASDF @chaelp1 @avaricum777 @christoaivalis Science says you are wrong https://t.co/7HkIUqyjiw
@aleda_27 @sirDukeDevin @Sec_Noem The 2022 Pediatrics study ("Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition") had a sample size of 317 transgender youth participants, with a mean age of 8.1 years at initial social transition. It found 94% persisted as binary transgender after an average of 5 years. Source:
@CordyHaig DSM 4 and DSM 5, isn't different in it's statements. The only difference is "MUST REQUIRED" part, which I have shown you. Study done with DSM 5, isn't long term as DSM 5 is relatively new. https://t.co/YRhBJQNbxB
@franytucker @noebah
@franytucker @noebah Estudie un poco. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., DeMeules, M., & McLaughlin, K. A. (2022). Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. JAMA Network Open, 5(5), e2214561. https://t.co/985DVpSE8n
@StoicSchism @SocialistSauce @ChuckIsLucky @theklutzydom @alley_robin_ @vanessa_blk @TheCurtismMKII @RebeccaMtn @angelatalbot01 @TheGoldenMask5 @TheCurtism255 @legaltweetz There are more studies but I'm not listing them all to prove how wrong you. https://t.co/YylUAlue5d https://t.co/OyEs4tlS5P
@SoloSunnySol Avery is non-binary and has said themselves that they're happy with their transition. Most kids are persistent in their trans identity: https://t.co/2HhPWm6r5C
@Ferno9 @Pantera_pe @lalunaenlibra Desarrollo infantil y persistencia de la identidad trans Olson, K. R., (2019). Gender identity 5 years after social transition. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 116(52), 26714–26716. https://t.co/5EqAnAvuws
@Rohanburdened @garylfrancione @endostranding @HelenWebberley I can't access it, but I know Kristina Olson published a study in which she found as much as 90% of children with GID reported that their gender aligned with their birth sex. Regardless, the claim of mass desistance is not born out in recent research. https://t.co/AbcTUDZr9p
@irvgotsoul @nivrama36 @ChiefsOutWest @psf023 @PeterRB1965 @PHLEaglesNation @washingtonpost I know you really don’t know but here you go you sick bastard. https://t.co/3GnFaSARBX
@nunyabu32540639 @theresaverity @grok https://t.co/BF1WFJyhk3
@lunettaporchett @theresaverity https://t.co/lZBjXzCrYF
https://t.co/wvVNQxn5Yj
https://t.co/EdcvynhYe9
@TheMithaecus @TakedownMRAs @PinkNews 2 out of 200 as written in the fucking study. which is 0.5%. https://t.co/vLyAsRBh95 other studies have values that are in that range. Not my problem if you don't understand what you're talking about.
@TheMithaecus @TakedownMRAs @PinkNews oh another study proving you wrong, that's so sad for you https://t.co/vLyAsRAJjx
@5intage7000 children aren't a black box. plenty trans adults knew they were trans back when they were children. the vast majority of transgender children accurately identify that they are indeed transgender, as studies like this https://t.co/yRJgYPSLCI show.
@TaylrTheGreat @SantosSuperFan @ZeroTheTwat @nyaraVT https://t.co/LqKPaoK1oO
@terfnurse Yes https://t.co/JjgwfS7Eb6
@BillyCarruther3 @theserfstv Relevant, and more recent paper. Its sample size is also about 4x that of the Dutch study. https://t.co/6K3s5Nz4fu Other thing, but from what I've read/skimmed, the Netherlands continue to be largely supportive of trans people.
@merjuutta @0Seea44907 @KatriinaRepone1 Amerikkalaisia on ainakin nämä kaksi, jotka nyt löysin: https://t.co/9XPpd7zK9J https://t.co/cVngzO1emD
RT @ser_real_esp: Un estudio longitudinal con 317 jóvenes transidentificados encontró que, cinco años después de la transición social, el 9…
@Volsky_8 ЭТО МЕНЬШЕ ЧЕМ КОЛИЧЕСТВО ЛЮДЕЙ СОЖАЛЕВШИХ О НЕУДАЧНЫХ ТАТУИРОВКАХ! Вот исследование https://t.co/y7hS4vwn2Z То есть количество откатившихся крайне мало. Это настоящие редкости и за этими редкостями ведётся охота! ДА, охота
@vermithrax12 When I look it up on Google all I get is articles saying that the number is defunct lmao. Also worse? From what I see it's at 2.5% for trans kids from a more recent study. Older studies don't have the same strict criteria as we do now for GD. https://t.co/apxajZq1jd
@renatajbarreto @Como_Tanka recomendo q se atualize nos estudos os mais recentes reportam menos de 10% de desistência e destransição, inclusive com o Cass Review mostrando apenas 11 destransições em mais de 3 mil crianças e adolescentes https://t.co/4Y9XIcgBX8 https://t.co/HJXH6xEyST https://t.co/4Y9XIcgBX8
RT @ser_real_esp: Un estudio longitudinal con 317 jóvenes transidentificados encontró que, cinco años después de la transición social, el 9…
RT @ser_real_esp: Un estudio longitudinal con 317 jóvenes transidentificados encontró que, cinco años después de la transición social, el 9…
@NekoKirito7 @DIaskevich36656 @Tekrao_Norma Olson KR et al. Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. 2022 Aug 1;150(2):e2021056082. doi: 10.1542/peds.2021-056082. PMID: 35505568; PMCID: PMC9936352.
RT @ser_real_esp: Un estudio longitudinal con 317 jóvenes transidentificados encontró que, cinco años después de la transición social, el 9…
Un estudio longitudinal con 317 jóvenes transidentificados encontró que, cinco años después de la transición social, el 94% seguía identificándose como transgénero, lo que sugiere que esta intervención solidifica la identidad trans en estos casos. https://t.co/lG5l3MN4QU
@strinam @CrazyFenaker @NBCNews https://t.co/p4wiMujiE3 Your made up number is actually the opposite. 94% of trans youth, stay that way into adulthood. Of course right wingers have never been known for spewing actual facts.
Such an underrated video, with regards to Trans healthcare and the facts. The fact that even if max was 2% retransition (to Cis, a different gender, or still exploring), then that still doesn't explain eliminating 98%'s ability to get their gender affirming healthcare. 1/2 youtu.be/UO1kujD8BIE?...
@CvxrC84783 @LOTrolhello @allie__voss @bottleneckloser Honey no, it typically doesn't
@JuicyJuuce @pwrynz @nikicaga @legaltweetz https://t.co/Pcui3bW9xA https://t.co/T6dr4eLmjs Funny. I don’t see this massive rate of desisting. Odd.
5/
@How86917508 @Lilith_Atheist Sure, here you got a 5 year follow up of 317 transgender boys and girls. 94% of them continued to identify as their initial gender identity, 3.5% came to identify as non-binary, and 2.5% reverted to identifying as cisgender. https://t.co/t1rQDxzflA
@mamamizaa54556 @StarshineYazawa @gabycaq https://t.co/Qk8cD23bOS
@Providence_777 @skarjay92 @Clutch_DWG @grok @Riley_Gaines_ @Jessica12uk Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition by Kristina R Olson et al. involved a longitudinal study in which the drop out rate was very low but it briefly discusses the issue present in other articles. Generally dropped out participents are removed entirely from the data.
@NeuroSGS Theres also evidence that social transition is associated with persistence of trangender identity, and if most kids who have a cross gender identity go on to socially transition nowadays, then they might not reidentify with their birth sex. https://t.co/VNg7dixcKJ https://t.co/TIFrXvln1H
@snoopsmom123 @EastEndJoe 1) You always, always lie. Kids detransition at about 7% rate. 2) I agree that below 18 is too young for surgery. Even when your mentally ill TERF mascot who found both god, detransition & $ while tripping on LSD wants to eliminate ALL transgender adults. https://t.co/pzZTIXPyMT https://t.co/YsXmweqf84
Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition - summary: yeah the rate of desistance of trans kids, even very young ones, doing social transition is exceedingly low. Let kids be themselves!! Stop telling kids they are evil and bad and wrong!!
@AndToddsaid @AT0ZER0 @megbasham @NBCNews Don’t be dishonest. You didn’t ask for information on trans youth. Don’t worry, we have that information too. https://t.co/qCotmbmaLt https://t.co/tYG42ogudv https://t.co/fTwBqsq5Vk https://t.co/0llahI4DZx https://t.co/TnF9rDZj9j https://t.co/GOyC3WdiPM https://t.co/s9qhLRNQk6
RT @andromedas_mom: @zkanSheol @MinModulation here's a great study without the glaringly flawed taxonomy. https://t.co/wOBmrCjJyV And here…
@zkanSheol @MinModulation here's a great study without the glaringly flawed taxonomy. https://t.co/wOBmrCjJyV And here's a great paper critiquing the methodology and interpretation of data from a handful of studies (a few included in your list) https://t.co/9cbwuoLdff
@inksearcher @Sophie7VWs Yea because you are looking at biased info that examined all kids getting care for gender issues not just gender dysphoria. You are just repeating terf lines and saying you care about medicalization https://t.co/GwZGjPzRtz
@dex_sk @DVTVcz že by mělo být součástí informací to, co jste sdělil v první části zprávy, naprosto souhlasím. nicméně ten konec je absolutní nesmysl, bez pardonu. studie uvádějí, že z dětí, které prošly sociální tranzicí, se 94 % z nich vnímalo jako trans i v dospělosti. https://t.co/HAbiPeQ17Z
@xxxDreaxxxx @MadMadViking @CNviolations 94% https://t.co/g5IqUDzbBy
@beckyk21k @ParatooperBrady You’re waffling pointlessly now. My original argument stands: transgender education influences kids—97.5% of socially transitioned kids persist, often with irreversible medical steps (https://t.co/3Uocl5F1aj). Your “mimicking isn’t permanent” dodge ignores the data: early
@beckyk21k @ParatooperBrady Drag aside, introducing kids to transgender concepts can increase the likelihood they identify as such 97.5% of socially transitioned kids persisted as transgender after 5 years, compared to 12.2% without (https://t.co/3Uocl5F1aj). That’s influence with irreversible risks, unlike
@dr_strangedays @Alexand97814370 @how_do_i_pdf @boy__onion @DrTrenton @KeyserSozeBluth @BettyLies @notbryancannoy @LGBwiththeT @grok The detransition rate in youth because they've realized it wasn't for them? Less than one percent. https://t.co/9uSepWoEes
@Cap_D17 @GRUGCEL https://t.co/nDFDGMzJxn https://t.co/6zLIfWI3rh https://t.co/2eOeuoXEPA https://t.co/eVjah8isTF https://t.co/F3cxZCGdGr https://t.co/kBRTUuzc2c https://t.co/Q5p6gg9kZ9 https://t.co/k2Gqw4vcP6
@philosopherleo @Neko_Nighsha Them go through that. An article which addresses and states my own points but in a better formulated way: https://t.co/e3mdbHMzlB An important study from the article: https://t.co/fXMMxZYdef
@PerspectiveDeli @Messodonix @esjesjesj Since you used fucking CHAT GPT
@DaviVilhena1 @F_snowflower_S @souodudu_ https://t.co/4Y9XIcgBX8 https://t.co/HJXH6xEyST
@Rev_says_desu @nyaraVT https://t.co/Ailsq5s8FM https://t.co/t6PoTiiPuU https://t.co/mOJUZ1zX98 https://t.co/DmcDW2qFZr. https://t.co/wPQkT4rgkh
@Claire13492 @LGBwiththeT After a quick glance I’d say you’re right This one primarily uses desist but acknowledges that the two are used interchangeably. The media definitely uses it interchangeably. Maybe that’s part of my confusion. https://t.co/ewmYzqNEAk
RT @Transgendertrd: It's from this ongoing longitudinal study of fully socially transitioned children, mean age 8 yrs at recruitment. http…
It's from this ongoing longitudinal study of fully socially transitioned children, mean age 8 yrs at recruitment. https://t.co/mETmj51Ze0
@YvetteNary @MilesMosley6662 @Wantmy2dollars_ @Q_Estrada @ViewVictory2024 @EnrelChi @Bigteethyouhave @Nicoleg425 @RealDoctorT @Flattielover @giddy_bunny @scottstocker4 @2457klhu @8BrianVogel4 @jeffsmith0000 @RepublicanRehab @itisjustmebabe @HamRadioJoe @memequeenkimmy @Missy8008135 @Synyster63 @PogueMoran @whagyjr @DigitaI_SoIdier @ron_drouin @DonPeq @GrieveNSpin @FireBidenNow @Silver_Strike @howienudet @lemmabarkaloo @Caperloo5 @AggressiveDem @Nrthms1 @Bruh888888888 @patsyplantlover @BidenTour @CivilLost @PaulConfer @_Kel_Varnsen_ @TeekeeMon @Sinner_Lilith @_CapitalOffense @NoHeadSpace2024 @whodisdontcare @cl1ntonserver @Ianstrainonline @Jennie_SC1 @yanksteel @ReganLieutenant Children who identify as the opposite sex usually continue to do that. Do not let your issue with trans kids cause you to divorce yourself from reality. If for example your boy says they are a girl, expect them to
@themountaingoa1 https://t.co/btEbp13Sj9
@gsp4336 @DreamLeaf5 @stacycay This is, again, because the Cass Review rejected all evidence from those with experience in the field. 97% of them persist. https://t.co/BfVC2BRkuB The sample size was the largest thus far.
@thatsKAIZEN Child detransitions are rare, completely opposite of the claims being made in this space. https://t.co/nN81eX3j5x. https://t.co/RGhzFdtScK https://t.co/woDzTOSrTo
@Experdiza Долговременное исследование (5 лет) о СОЦИАЛЬНОЙ СМЕНЕ ПОЛА у детей. Да-да, о той самой когда мы меняем только м/ж в документах. Пять лет следили чо как чо ваще. Результат? 94% довольных. https://t.co/y7hS4vvPdr
@shula347 Stupid says what? These results suggest that retransitions are infrequent. More commonly, transgender youth who socially transitioned at early ages continued to identify that way. https://t.co/2g69OMddp4
@StephaniaNYC @HellGateNY 5/actual rate is closer to 2.5% desist over 5 yrs (detransition due to regret/gender ID shift is even lower) when going by modern diagnostic criteria as it is still the case medical transition is not rec to all, just most severe cases.https://t.co/dJlwv2GpZh
@libertyslav @thiscatg9tclaws @lisec_tut Но что там у четырёх процентов? Да ничего. Вернулись к обычной жизни. Ведь это же блокаторы! Это же не хуй отрезанный! У них все эффекты обратимы. ics/article/150/2/e2021056082/186992/Gender-Identity-5-Years-After-Social-Transition
@ThoughtfulSaint Really nice when someone LDS appreciates science. Finally there can be real discussions about gender in the church based on science and not politics! https://t.co/KaUd4aRHiL
@fulorin_ @brodi_ohh222 @Zinimeani @EliErlick Wierd because many report the opposite https://t.co/BM49UXL8sW
@Treelotl_silly @esjesjesj I don't know about the EXACT studies he's talking about but I have a couple https://t.co/u8RcjYboBf https://t.co/QhWSfUnvgY https://t.co/FDI3pOCeSx
@collyern @Nljigakulive @esjesjesj Children can struggle with their gender identity in many ways that don't involve being transgender. When you look at children who begin to socially transition, only 2.5% identify as cisgender 5 years later. https://t.co/vsmJZVPCg5
@Pickles7189 @SocialistSauce @bluebirdjam @yrysbryd @Izmeina666 @Makoto_Says @RadFemme74 @Dorasalter @LavenderBarks @cecinestpaspipe @seanieRW @latsot @wildling_wolf @theklutzydom @K60617909 @LauraDemonista @GenderNeutralWC @PolicyArtemis @HCMC1975 @crwarmuth44 @TheGoldenMask5 @BuzzzStryker @Kimberfan76 @Hereticalturf @ghostoftoast @shadowmedicpl @fem_mb @AlyssaB42021458 @forevershallon @redfollowsred @brenda_archer @CarsonSmit14601 @ramendik @badsophistry @Gazbo1990 @Purplewykr @DianaWilde95 @m_eunuch @LaneyGB80 @straycomrade @AnticommieShawn @IAmBadWolf717 @CptCrckpot @VelvetLandmine @liozh_zai @ostrasyn @Opiumbrella @ThatsMadeMyDay @PersephoneP101 We have long term studies on young children socially transitioning and the vast majority "stick with it" starting from age 4 and those that don't basically all socially detransition before age 13 https://t.co/xdfAedvaUY
@MrThaboMaleke @againstgrmrs No evidence of that but ok. https://t.co/JDw7UwK0za
@crwarmuth44 @Makoto_Says @bluebirdjam @TheGoldenMask5 @SocialistSauce @BuzzzStryker @GenderNeutralWC @RadFemme74 @Kimberfan76 @yrysbryd @PolicyArtemis @LauraDemonista @Hereticalturf @ghostoftoast @shadowmedicpl @HCMC1975 @fem_mb @seanieRW @AlyssaB42021458 @forevershallon @RoseWorthesee @redfollowsred @brenda_archer @cecinestpaspipe @CarsonSmit14601 @theklutzydom @ramendik @badsophistry @latsot @Izmeina666 @Gazbo1990 @K60617909 @Purplewykr @DianaWilde95 @m_eunuch @LaneyGB80 @straycomrade @AnticommieShawn @IAmBadWolf717 @CptCrckpot @VelvetLandmine @liozh_zai @ostrasyn @Opiumbrella @ThatsMadeMyDay @PersephoneP101 @Dorasalter @CheekyWeeBism @CyberGhostDrake @Gibson_U_Witch When I was 4 I knew I wanted to grow up to be a woman. People get extremely hostile and uncharitable about this but we have data about this too. I didn't experience a particularly negative feeling at the time I just had a
@Susan4Freedom @Higashikat16135 @DylanDyylas There is no evidence of that, in fact, kids with gender dysphoria tend to remain trans https://t.co/9kvwA7oe3E
@Ambisont_ @LaraDCookie @signoria_pros https://t.co/BCXtfbJsxa
@redfollowsred @DianaWilde95 @badsophistry @TheGoldenMask5 @theklutzydom @RadFemme74 @SocialistSauce @forevershallon @yrysbryd @latsot @brenda_archer @fear_the_kitten @ghostoftoast @Izmeina666 @PolicyArtemis @Hereticalturf @cecinestpaspipe @CarsonSmit14601 @Gazbo1990 @Kimberfan76 @K60617909 @Purplewykr @bluebirdjam @m_eunuch @seanieRW @LaneyGB80 @straycomrade @AnticommieShawn @IAmBadWolf717 @CptCrckpot @VelvetLandmine @liozh_zai @ostrasyn @Opiumbrella @LauraDemonista @ThatsMadeMyDay @PersephoneP101 @JosiahL1776 @Dorasalter @CheekyWeeBism @CyberGhostDrake @Gibson_U_Witch @nbrink77 @JIPTranslation @HCMC1975 @KrystalKat84 @Athena71XG @Abby_Lindon @DearRebelAda @BuckAngel https://t.co/xdfAedvaUY
@Ramrod91552582 @CMastrocola @naecotsol @Manu_facturing_ @disclosetv Wut? - https://t.co/N9qZDLFM35 - https://t.co/mrCBSDicM2 - https://t.co/3C3IYtMNTR - https://t.co/0EFeH0OT36 - https://t.co/L2nVuvituW - https://t.co/AO6roQWDIJ - https://t.co/HjI0LjaNJ3 https://t.co/qerD5gjhhx
@Slagathoro @mpfive0 @Emilio2763 You are referencing and citing completely debunked outdated studies which is a myth that often did not asses the causes for desistance. Here is proof: See pages 13 and 14 and if you deny their suicide still, page 15 too: https://t.co/a8WW2BBDZ9 https://t.co/VoWcSccFYy PT2:
@BrendaFaye20 @detransaqua Uh, surveys are not peer reviewed. Any papers using its data would be. Here’s some info on juvenile transitions: https://t.co/rTqHvGJUf6
@0x_bento @CelesteLaverty @DarthTrollis Research literally shows trans kids exist. https://t.co/9kvwA7nGe6
@GW950em @DaleCoo69075388 @anniesmusingson Posting AI nonsense? How about peer reviewed science? https://t.co/9kvwA7nGe6 https://t.co/DLVXOeevkg
@TekenaTravis @theserfstv One of my favorites to share as it covered a 5 year period https://t.co/nu7RWJHt2R
@gc_hedgehog @brenda_archer @RadFemme74 @DianaWilde95 @Hereticalturf @yrysbryd @seanieRW @forevershallon @SocialistSauce @Purplewykr @PolicyArtemis @TheGoldenMask5 @bluebirdjam @wallthehero @m_eunuch @CarsonSmit14601 @LaneyGB80 @fear_the_kitten @K60617909 @cecinestpaspipe @Kimberfan76 @ghostoftoast @straycomrade @AnticommieShawn @theklutzydom @IAmBadWolf717 @CptCrckpot @VelvetLandmine @liozh_zai @ostrasyn @Gazbo1990 @Opiumbrella @latsot @LauraDemonista @ThatsMadeMyDay @PersephoneP101 @JosiahL1776 @Dorasalter @CheekyWeeBism @CyberGhostDrake @Gibson_U_Witch @nbrink77 @JIPTranslation @HCMC1975 @KrystalKat84 @Athena71XG @Abby_Lindon @DearRebelAda @Zombie_Jesus_1 @TWAM163 It really depends on what you mean by old enough here. There is an effort to ever increasingly push it out. I've seen people say we should be forced to wait until we are 46. We have data showing very low desistance rates. ht
@TheRealChingron @nyaraVT https://t.co/QhWSfUnvgY https://t.co/FDI3pOCeSx https://t.co/DU9Wka5W7I cope harder you fuck
Complete and utter drivel to be precise given that it is based upon outdated studies. The latest studies debunk those fallacious older "studies". pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35505568/
@denbrp @_FlutterGirl @timwalzstan @greg0925 @CeeNoelle @KyleKulinski @BuckAngel Since you are a 1 issue voter, you actually should read up on the subject and try to debunk these https://t.co/M48IPz23kl https://t.co/WRt9SsKM7t https://t.co/0BhwpbPj44 https://t.co/M48IPz23kl https://t.co/A1oLdyHzX1 https://t.co/JkO0ifzUxE https://t.co/pyl7WCwNuG
@GoldCorpBusAdmi @upstatefederlst want to get real? do you people ever even read the S you post? here's a fun one https://t.co/HJBPtPWyN3
@nedm785_d @Tenebrael @totylkoteoria Nie, większość nie wyrasta, większość jej po prostu nie ma xD Oczywiście potwierdzają to dane: https://t.co/83k7mCeiBA https://t.co/ylOa4gwnz3 I pytanko: co z tymi, którzy faktycznie mają dysforię? Chciałbyś im odmówić leczenia, czy zaakceptowania tożsamości wbrew nauce?
@baepsaeluvr https://t.co/D2vNpLEHrK הנה השני
RT @NaistenOsa: @helsinkipride @seta_ry @TTuppurainen Yksi uusi tutkimus, johon T.T. viittaa. Olisiko mahdollista, että aikaisin aloitetut…
@lecanardnoir @springstien @TheFun96593011 @PinkNews https://t.co/0u3nggRT23
@lecanardnoir @springstien @TheFun96593011 @PinkNews Because the evidence indicates otherwise lol https://t.co/0u3nggRT23
@just____cause @RonnieRadke https://t.co/o6tsGRyan1
@17GiaSerafino37 https://t.co/jMKZsPwb48 https://t.co/EDTBTck6Oh
@Ossy_Salame @AlexAlexaBurt Here's a study on 300 trans youth 5 years after they socially transitioned and received gender affirming care... 97.5% were still happily trans... (94% binary trans, 3.5% non-binary) https://t.co/9WNZvU3flT
@Bird_OnA_Wire @SVPhillimore @panderp @wesstreeting Except (1) we do do follow up studies such as: https://t.co/xvnzstYrxt which show unambiguously positive results. (2) The experts disagree, & very clearly state that they are safe for PP use or GD: https://t.co/f37iKrPsiI
@nana_surfing @SVPhillimore @panderp @wesstreeting Oh the WPATH conspiracy theory
@DMarlborough @rodgers_si78948 @JolyonMaugham "an average of 5 years after their initial social transition... [a] total of 2.5% of youth identified as cisgender" https://t.co/R3kxzr2Efj
@Aureliemerc @Elia_alpha_moon @Antitou1 @Louisepierre786 @maestro_hell Pareil ici au bout de 5 ans : https://t.co/c6ZR6ZwUc8
@greysaregreat @SteveMcRae_ @ThenonbinaryC @SophieMolly_SG https://t.co/7BPcxNojxf https://t.co/AZHD46f1YL https://t.co/fLloqCYQYz https://t.co/1nr5xJ5pqy https://t.co/v25ZyPJ5yx https://t.co/4lyrNbk4ye https://t.co/4jgzPa4bV8 https://t.co/vFS1lgTQYD https://t.co/JdQ7sVt8Id https://t.co/joIltUukBo
@BonfireLady @The_DogWalker https://t.co/7BPcxNnLHH https://t.co/AZHD46eu9d https://t.co/fLloqCYj91 https://t.co/1nr5xJ4RB0 https://t.co/v25ZyPIxIZ https://t.co/4lyrNbjwIG https://t.co/4jgzPa3E5A https://t.co/vFS1lgTj95 https://t.co/JdQ7sVsASF https://t.co/joIltUtMLQ Happy reading.
- Julia Serano: Gender-Affirming Care for Trans Youth Is Neither New nor Experimental - Olson 2022: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition PMID: 35505568 - Puberty Blockers Reviewed: transfemscience.org/articles/puberty-blockers/
@devonlass @mamaninja https://t.co/bfytERXFvF https://t.co/ZsFeTUUpqA Trans Youth: https://t.co/Omy7TJZGAn https://t.co/LN6HU74Tgy https://t.co/ySewXLsv1B https://t.co/CvbeXq4oA1 https://t.co/cfRCPNWbTa https://t.co/2vOsmWF5U7 https://t.co/Zz2gieWsGA
@adhib @benryanwriter https://t.co/YIFlLG03iY
@Speckasand @MmMoretti1978 @FrancBiss @Hypersane23 @teganandsarafdn @teganandsara @vivekshraya @badbadnotgood @realsarahpolley @strombo @sookyinlee @WondaGurlBeats It's actually hilarious that you bring up (Steensma, et al. 2013), it has been famously debunked by credible researchers and experts. Some examples: 10.1080/15532739.2018.1456390 10.1542/peds.2021-056082
@stillgray False and misleading. Here is what the Academy of Pediatrics (science) published: https://t.co/aR7EdIm9wP.
@OliLondonTV @elonmusk https://t.co/aR7EdIm9wP.
@elonmusk Musk may well be a pathologic liar, and spirit kin to Joseph Goebbels. From: AAP https://t.co/uu1ltyM3z2 "Among peri- or postpubertal transgender youth receiving gender-affirming medications at specialized gender clinics, 1.9% to 3.5% of patients discontinued treatment. "
@wontsomeonethi2 https://t.co/dwEd75m9dc. The authors point out that their 'gender non-contentedness' is not actually analogous to gender dysphoria. You might find omore relevant data in https://t.co/r6OuyymqF4 and https://t.co/EBaUN09xYl
RT @EleanorDrapeaux: @terabyteofmemes @KatysCartoons https://t.co/75r7UqcEHe
@terabyteofmemes @KatysCartoons https://t.co/75r7UqcEHe
@UneInvisible Et tenez, sans BP, 5 ans après le début de la transition sociale chez des jeunes, seuls 2,5% des sujets s'identifiaient comme cis. https://t.co/gVbur3jtxo
Gender identity 5 years after social transition, par Kristina Olson, Lily Durwood et al. (American Academy of Pediatrics, juillet 2022) : https://t.co/J66CMbvR0T
@Susan4Freedom @DrEggFan @Dunc_Disorderly @VeritySmith19 Then you weren't paying attention. You are a reality denying, hateful person. https://t.co/v25ZyPIxIZ https://t.co/4lyrNbjwIG https://t.co/4jgzPa3E5A https://t.co/vFS1lgTj95 https://t.co/JdQ7sVsASF https://t.co/joIltUtMLQ https://t.co/x7w82t6HqZ
RT @NaistenOsa: @helsinkipride @seta_ry @TTuppurainen Yksi uusi tutkimus, johon T.T. viittaa. Olisiko mahdollista, että aikaisin aloitetut…
@BrokebuckMtn2 @HBKSOMA @Ramstein030 @slowcoreapist_x https://t.co/hw0QrDXaGh >Out of 720 patients, 16 detransitioned after 5-10 years https://t.co/YEqgkrKj0l >Most youth identified as binary transgender youth (94%), including 1.3% who retransitioned to another identity before returning to their binary transgender identity.
Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition publications.aap.org/pediatrics/a...
@johnnyerotixxx @friesneverdies @chase52411093 @M1das_OW2 @willsgardevoir A study of 317 kids between the ages of 3 and 12 who had socially transitioned were checked back on after five years after their initial social transition. 94% still identified as transgender, 3.5% as non-binary or genderfluid, and 2.5% as cisgender. https://t.co/qvT5lZkyi3
@Bar37912933Alex @steveper6688 @Kit_Kat_Cata I’ll bite. gender identity forms early: https://t.co/Q2dl6V5gVM most trans kids stay trans: https://t.co/LM4fBIWYRD transitioning helps: https://t.co/i1Lc8eHrku If you actually care about evidence there’s plenty of credited peer reviewed scientific studies on the matter.
@GreycupChump @steveper6688 @Esqueer_ (2/2
@OliviaThatB @KatyMontgomerie Sources: https://t.co/4lyrNbjwIG https://t.co/4jgzPa3E5A https://t.co/vFS1lgTj95 https://t.co/v25ZyPIxIZ https://t.co/JdQ7sVsASF https://t.co/joIltUtMLQ https://t.co/x7w82t6HqZ https://t.co/fdW6jqAysL
@TheRealKevinMac @KatyMontgomerie Are you a liar or just dumb? https://t.co/v25ZyPIxIZ https://t.co/fZbg590MkM https://t.co/vpxBnZsfFx https://t.co/mKwZyUcbm5
@MissLovelace3 @Psychgirl211 @stonewalluk I'm listening to you and pointing out that your interpretation is flawed. Here's some newer data, though: https://t.co/YXigQr05A7
@maanvis81 @JamesMo19320924 @SoupTransphobes All of it?
@AmTiredNBored @BCrowder45 @_celia_bedelia_ @muadib1981 Olson et al. (2022) found that among 280 trans youth who started social gender transition around 6 years old, 98.9% (!!!) remained transgender (opposite gender or nonbinary) at the end of the study, around 5.5 years since starting transition: https://t.co/HjI0LjblyB
@Omnitrix_12 @BargleGarg72152 @teatmaus @jimalbarano @WokeParentLs @RandEvansMD Sure here's a study saying 94% of trans youths maintain their gender identity into adulthood. https://t.co/Go9jx5nz3h.
@handritolito @LittenDraws @SallyMayweather No, I have real facts on my side, most trans people know by 6 or 7, and 94% of those children maintain their gender identity into adulthood. https://t.co/yNLWD43gZV https://t.co/Go9jx5o6SP. So again, do you have any real evidence, or are you just playing around?
RT @NaistenOsa: @helsinkipride @seta_ry @TTuppurainen Yksi uusi tutkimus, johon T.T. viittaa. Olisiko mahdollista, että aikaisin aloitetut…
RT @NaistenOsa: @helsinkipride @seta_ry @TTuppurainen Yksi uusi tutkimus, johon T.T. viittaa. Olisiko mahdollista, että aikaisin aloitetut…
RT @ThePhoenixVents: @sexonogenero @BlazeofGlory98 @Nangela72 @LGBwiththeT @animefan295 @EddieBacon9 Studies show that the overwhelming maj…
@sexonogenero @BlazeofGlory98 @Nangela72 @LGBwiththeT @animefan295 @EddieBacon9 Studies show that the overwhelming majority of trans youth are still trans years later... https://t.co/9WNZvU2Hwl
@NekoSilver @JuanAve20590830 @HUSTLECONTENT @ChristnNitemare The sources are literally mentioned in the articles I provided but here they are. Along with the detransition reasons study: https://t.co/SPScEvefT8 https://t.co/LzNdlK0xbv https://t.co/bZ8YVRRy07
@Funfems @Aaronsmith333 @rachelbaxendale The rates of detransitioning after merely “social transitioning” (median age 8.1, before puberty) are also very low too, and not always permanent. A recent study shows only around 2.5% of social transitioners go on to identify with their gender at birth https://t.co/apFZDciDgT
@HatMan2007 @John16180339887 @BrandiKruse @BillboardChris You take screenshots of studies that you think back up your opinion. Look up confirmation bias. https://t.co/9ZZzRM7cfM https://t.co/3ob331dAVG
@azazelthegoat @ryry82147145 @alexdes7621 @atRachelGilmore That's a 2013 paper. She's done much more work since then. https://t.co/EJsQSg9MgR https://t.co/ySFoeeNfzc
@KequeMage @markr360 @OECTAProv @fordnation https://t.co/BnMeYpe3pr
@PhilosophyLines @keewa @TPGRoberts No you are 100% wrong. https://t.co/TG9jfzsFq9
@OuchThatsSharp she even has a study on the effects of detransitioning both socially and medically LMAO. she clearly entertains the idea that GAC isnt right for everyone https://t.co/toN6eDdWE9 https://t.co/xZtFTtZ1ne
@gjhong52 @alsoabouteve @MadLadMarcin @atRachelGilmore No it doesn't. https://t.co/TG9jfzsFq9
@saitamahanzo @VioletteEverga8 @Damien__Gaulois @Psyhodelikus Seule 0,4 des personne trans détransitione : https://t.co/62SSrpGjGA https://t.co/X8auvW7mmH
@DicksteinCrosby @e_sequin @assignedmedia And if you think it's only temporary, this study followed trans people for 5 years and rates don't change : https://t.co/c6ZR6ZwmmA / and if you still aren't happy, this one did that for FIFTY years : https://t.co/TJOFcEa6RX
@SOCryptoKapital @SBalveda @KatyMontgomerie @Bluesoulreggae Several. Dysphoria is a well studied thing. Here are some sources https://t.co/Q4zVvOreQ5 https://t.co/TbJ6ivRyXl https://t.co/11cqilcaxJ
@Lynnemnaylor @Sidewalk_Steve @LeorSapir Trans Kids know exactly who they are. I know for a fact because I was one, and research shows us the data conforms to my personal experience. Deal with your personal bias with your own mental health care specialist because it's not supported by reality. https://t.co/g5kvDU1zn4
@KaSyl_Town @_OBZDN_ @Northern_Rich @nominalnaomi @JanglesLad Is it my turn? Can I present a study? https://t.co/azS4Q9KRrc https://t.co/LzMZFwyNx7
@WardlawSteve @VictoriaPeckham @thetimes https://t.co/TJW1Cgwh7z
@EVRTHRSHD @B_for_backup @FDPVerbot @finally_estelle @ap_schulz https://t.co/QjUesD7zL2 Mein Fehler. Hab den Link erst abgetippt und ... na ja. Und was Backup nicht weiß macht nicht heiß
@MortisCommon @stan_td @papasiixX @sactorno @byodinsfades Almost no cases of this happening. More often than not trans kids aren't simply children who don't fit gender stereotypes as seen in https://t.co/VsqHClbcbN. Being trans is NOT an easy way out, this narrative that somehow everyone is being told to be trans is beyond wrong.
@MichaelPanell @swinginjazzcat @turtlewithonee @ow_jok3r @Slippy_P @kenneyy88 @xX1TopShotXx @ElieBERGER3 @Dexerto Also the image does say teens too. You say "ask them 5-10 years after" but that also has been done in DOI:10.2196/14434 and https://t.co/VsqHClbcbN. To date, your "statistics" seem to be unsubstantiated.
Also there is already information on long-term outcomes published by Olson et al (2022). 94% of children under the age of 12 who socially transition remain socially transitioned after five years. https://t.co/TJW1Cgwh7z
@GreaterFireweed @_CryMiaRiver It's consistent with most findings. https://t.co/R3j8fO8Sck
RT @milcaber: @nayception @AAAD25 3) "Muchos testimonios de detransición". ¿Fuente? ¿Qué significa muchos? ¿Menos del 5%? La experiencia d…
@nayception @AAAD25 3) "Muchos testimonios de detransición". ¿Fuente? ¿Qué significa muchos? ¿Menos del 5%? La experiencia de quienes detransicionan son válidas, pero no invalidan las experiencias de quienes continúan. Las mayores causas de detransición son EXTERNAS.
@NicoleeO12 @ChoooCole https://t.co/xBRQCFOnMI
@csbaggage @pandabites420 @nightcorebanksy That's not true, you have fallen for the misinformation. Stop acting like you care. "If just as many people have their lives ruined the other way" this is not reality. https://t.co/mi9P1KeAez https://t.co/YDILhhXvOB https://t.co/o6q4UoVM0J https://t.co/fsJmyhzAoI
@Lwestraad @MamaK1993C @ethical_care @FirmentGabe 1 paper out of a large-scale, long-term, multi-site study funded by the American NIH https://t.co/zop7RHbKJk
@Nangela72 @MtnConservative @JanuaryDoNoHarm For example, https://t.co/zop7RHciyS
תתעלמו, זה בשביל עצמי, שיהיה לי את הציוץ הזה בשלוף https://t.co/D2vNpLEHrK.
@Marcines72 @_Pan_Pawel a tu o tranzycji za młodu: 2,5% detranzycji! to wybitnie mało! https://t.co/KPuSy6P4ug
@BobWhencer @DrJayRichards @LeorSapir @oliviakrauth Seriously? You are claiming there is a lack of research but you don’t even know about one of the largest studies ever? Then upon what did you basis your opinion about the inadequacy of research? Here are some of the latest results: https://t.co/zop7RHbKJk
RT @NaistenOsa: @helsinkipride @seta_ry @TTuppurainen Yksi uusi tutkimus, johon T.T. viittaa. Olisiko mahdollista, että aikaisin aloitetut…
RT @NaistenOsa: @helsinkipride @seta_ry @TTuppurainen Yksi uusi tutkimus, johon T.T. viittaa. Olisiko mahdollista, että aikaisin aloitetut…
@LaPetiteSatire @DaakMalek @ChaykaHackso @hackingsocialfr https://t.co/c6ZR6ZwmmA : une étude qui montre que le regret n'augmente pas avec le temps, ici après 5 ans https://t.co/TJOFcEa6RX : et ici après 50 ans (oui, 50) https://t.co/64sG80CAYr : sur 4000 personnes, 16 regrets
@MeowYorfum @classactrachael @NewEnglandDevil @GabsClark5 @MdBreathe @whitmire_john Care to cite to your source? Or should we just speculate on the basis for your claim. My numbers come from the large-scale, multi-year, multi-site study for American NIH. it does take into account your objections. https://t.co/zop7RHciyS
@f_frieza https://t.co/c6ZR6ZwmmA : after 5 years, low regret https://t.co/64sG80CAYr : out of 4000 people, only 16 regret https://t.co/TJOFcEa6RX : longitudinal study spanning 50 years shows 2% regret rate https://t.co/0wBOuL4y7Q : in the Netherlands : 1.9% regret
17/29 Did you know that research suggests that children who receive gender affirming care early have a high chance of persisting in their transgender identity? https://t.co/Ej6mAwWySo
@stormsabre22 @Brogga69 @M1chaelMorgan @gardengn0me @MattWalshBlog Is this the study that used the DSM 3 and 4 qualifications for GD? And counted all kids who didn't show back up at the research center as desisted regardless of circumstance? Here's a modern longitudinal study instead. 97% persistence rate after 5 years https://t.co/Jgwk4zeRne
@Mule71999660287 @linwithonen @Eyal_Lev @JaclynGlenn Here's and actual study recently performed that says otherwise. And Actually isn't constantly criticized for it's methodology and results. Please use your brain. https://t.co/yqF2QYaAuW
@de_stroya However, other studies show that very few children who socially transition detransition later. 2/ https://t.co/CygeUq6KL4
@Stephen_Climbs @CabsnKings 3 recent studies on social transition: US: https://t.co/KQrZFF1zBv https:// GERMANY: https://t.co/ivsucLYvIJ UK: https://t.co/zuz1kuGkqt
@JCEverett22 @wakeuphiiragi @yeatsdf @MattWalshBlog Where are you getting that info? In a recent review, it was shown the pooled prevalence of regret to be 1% (https://t.co/2WKWEr4gCQ). Also similarly low for adolescents in the most recent data (https://t.co/y1mqLKBXug).
@Mostly_Yes @fubroshi @JadeSpriggan A study published in 2022 conducted a long-term followup of 317 trans kids and found that over the course of 5 years, a resounding 94% of kids kept their trans identity. Only 2.5% detransitioned back to a cisgender identity. https://t.co/gwQ73CLwVy
@RadioFreeStPaul @FaithfullyBP Oh and in this study (median age ~8 years), desistance, even counting those who end up NB is less than 6%, but I don't think a follow time of <6 years after transition is that conclusive. https://t.co/fjdzBOfqBF
@MLorenzoFS @autisticmumifl @Glinner Not so. https://t.co/tIV8BJHqkB
@LisaSelinDavis @ZUCKERKJ Try this on for size. https://t.co/tIV8BJHYa9
@LisaSelinDavis Nope. https://t.co/tIV8BJHYa9
@Glinner Nope. https://t.co/tIV8BJHYa9
@TroIIing_memes @RolloTo99068335 @KentuckyFamily That’s not been shown in the evidence to play out. See below: https://t.co/yDiZN928XR
@NunyaBe87867194 @Hevndwlr @TinaWillard @NotScottNewgent Facts on detransition rates : 1 : https://t.co/c6ZR6ZwmmA & 2 : https://t.co/64sG80CAYr & 3 : https://t.co/TJOFcEa6RX & 4 : https://t.co/0wBOuL4y7Q & 5 : https://t.co/t6WBHYCvvt
@Brkr_Morant @EndWokeness There's a source for this 94%, though. https://t.co/mz9P7cfLL9
@EndWokeness On the other hand, 94% of kids aged 4-12 still identify as trans at age 18.
@spielblog @tunak @pickledswans @yenwoda @jessesingal https://t.co/FPWjEkzQ5n https://t.co/SO0bbOfz8U Depends on what you mean by regret! There are a whole bunch and there's a major review at Cornell: https://t.co/5wNHwz6JkV But I'd really caution you against getting too deep into the studies in an ares you're not an expert in.
RT @equalityfl: Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of youn…
RT @equalityfl: Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of youn…
RT @equalityfl: Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of youn…
RT @equalityfl: Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of youn…
RT @equalityfl: Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of youn…
RT @equalityfl: Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of youn…
RT @equalityfl: Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of youn…
RT @equalityfl: Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of youn…
RT @equalityfl: Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of youn…
RT @equalityfl: Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of youn…
Fact: Transgender children grow up to be transgender adults. A 2022 peer-reviewed study showed that more than 97% of young people who identified as transgender as children still identified as transgender after five years of social transition. https://t.co/FHIUOlCXEG
@MartinOKnight @TonyDownunder @NPR Yes medical treatments improve as time goes on. That doesn’t disprove anything. https://t.co/kKnadexfcH No data? Or just no data you’ll accept because the existence of and solutions for gender dysphoria doesn’t align with the myths you base your identity and worldview on?
@helsinkipride @seta_ry @TTuppurainen Yksi uusi tutkimus, johon T.T. viittaa. Olisiko mahdollista, että aikaisin aloitetut murrosiän jarrutus- ja hormonihoidot lukitsevat lapset transidentiteettiin 5 v. aikajänteellä? https://t.co/C9ak1LV2cX Suosittelemme tarkkailemaan näitä ukkospilviä: https://t.co/Dc2kRzrZZ5
2022 peer-reviewed study here: https://t.co/FHIUOlCXEG
95% of kids that socially transition maintain their gender identity after five years. https://t.co/dch9akZB8c
@ChoooCole @D7_Tim_Reed IF the stat you cite were true you would have a good point. The thing is it isn't. We have studies both new like this one and even old that show the rate of desistance is not anything like 80% https://t.co/fPFVPy1S7A only 2.5 % detransed in this 5 year study. https://t.co/kkTU0Qqrym
@libsoftiktok A recent study spanning 5 years and with a sample rate of 317 children and adolescents found that 94% didn't detransition, and only 1.5% went back to identifying as cisgender: https://t.co/8MP21fk7w6
@libsoftiktok A recent study spanning 5 years and with a sample rate of 317 children and adolescents found that 94% didn't detransition, and only 1.5% went back to identifying as cisgender: https://t.co/8MP21fk7w6
@libsoftiktok @yoyoel A recent study spanning 5 years and with a sample rate of 317 children and adolescents found that 94% didn't detransition, and only 1.5% went back to identifying as cisgender: https://t.co/8MP21fk7w6
@CasanyN some studies on their effects and generally talking about efficacy: https://t.co/KalENOXcPa https://t.co/Lq9xgYfFzw https://t.co/P5pQT0ZhSI https://t.co/yXvze4NxPd https://t.co/NDTixCaO7R https://t.co/oYmt75fY4Y https://t.co/DeA3G5h5Y3 https://t.co/n9kPzQJCes
@jddavisIV @jallen1985 And on overall low incidence of de transition, some some experimentation would be normal and also could be due to social pressure: https://t.co/jyhAdIbaVn
@cryptodonks59 @nbrink77 @zekouse @Esqueer_ @ChoooCole I didn't actually need Google. I've had the real statistics saved already but I was curious to test your integrity. I suspect you'll continue quoting 'your' figure regardless but if you are open to the research here it is. https://t.co/i4biHZwE8n
@MargaretJWetzel @BuckAngel @Display_Geek Not all desist. There are long term followup studies. When studying insistently transgender kids the desistance rate is a few percent. https://t.co/Un0NSoxz1b https://t.co/fPFVPy1S7A
@Gimpuslegend @PrimalScreamer @KatyMontgomerie You are talking a load of bollocks. Have a read (if you can) of this report. It covers teens undergoing hrt from 16 to age 25. Only 2% stopped (regretted) hormone therapy. Hardly most. https://t.co/W3oS4khmOf
@MasklessLass8 @ddagino @FoxNews Specifics about trans youth: https://t.co/RI3MuoHOqu https://t.co/hVEUzB7fUH https://t.co/sZE9zh8uwG https://t.co/kIlJcXRfDN https://t.co/4aKriU9TYE https://t.co/yJOswtOzBJ good luck on your path to becoming a more educated and better person
@MrCharmyPants @lifttheveil411 @DrDebraSoh And this one spanning 50 years show that 2% of them had REGRETS (not even detransitioning), and most of this regret is caused by societal pressure : https://t.co/c6ZR6ZwUc8
@MrCharmyPants @lifttheveil411 @DrDebraSoh One study on the subject : https://t.co/c6ZR6ZwmmA
@Fox_Ninja03 @ve4no_molodoi1 @ProgressiveNCD1 @KeanuNazari Here's the study about detransition : https://t.co/c6ZR6ZwmmA
@ripperread Retransitioning to a cis identity. https://t.co/FKt0UkEzgH but it appears to show the opposite in terms of detransition, with only 2.5% returning to a cis identity.
RT @RamonNogueras: El estudio que muestra que la aplastante, pero APLASTANTE mayoría de jóvenes trans no quieren detransicionar. https://t…
RT @RamonNogueras: El estudio que muestra que la aplastante, pero APLASTANTE mayoría de jóvenes trans no quieren detransicionar. https://t…
@FreakE5000 @charliekirk11 https://t.co/mNxr0ypFuA
@grzybowski__ @HebanMaja ja mam na podorędziu takie o detranzycji po tranzycji w dzieciństwie - 2,5% przypadków https://t.co/KPuSy6PCjO
@RedSoRight https://t.co/W3oS4khmOf
@BbCornet @hornybandit69 @CasuallyGreg @ZaackHunt @elonmusk This study shows that only 2.5 percent of trans kids detransitioned over five years, with 5 percent more deciding they were nonbinary https://t.co/QtZ4GRx3O1
@skoalbandit15 @GemSiobhan @fille404 @JamesEsses “At the end of this period, most youth identified as binary transgender youth (94%), including 1.3% who retransitioned to another identity before returning to their binary transgender identity. A total of 2.5% of youth identified as cisgender” https://t.co/mi9P1JWYPZ
@skoalbandit15 @GemSiobhan @fille404 @JamesEsses https://t.co/mi9P1KeAez At the end of this period, most youth identified as binary transgender youth (94%), including 1.3% who retransitioned to another identity before returning to their binary transgender identity. A total of 2.5% of youth identified as cisgender. the gif is u https://t.co/pnU5J6WNEv
@Outsider25E @Wynsickle @SilverStarBack @prageru No they don’t, and the leading cause of trans suicide is caused by being misgendered and abused because of their identity, trans suicidality drops significantly when they have support https://t.co/T8zsghrimt
RT @Transgendertrd: *New study* 5 year study shows 94% persistence rate in socially transitioned children. Compare with around 20% persis…
@JFr4ser @Nettleshippy @HJoyceGender https://t.co/aYVmRrELdg https://t.co/tgpzdI2zZd
@mehmehmehmeh000 @TheatreSpoonie @Powerlocks1 Wow, that percentage is incredibly made-up! It's actually around 2.5%, according to what's basically the only decent survey that's actually been done specifically on this exact topic. https://t.co/a8fbEfqdri Meanwhile, you have... https://t.co/mfPOBHkgVJ
@LeorSapir @FriendsRobots @SwipeWright @benshapiro @RealLastStand The points: 1) transgender adolescents have significantly higher rates Of suicide & depression 2) multiple studies show positive outcomes of treatment 3) vast majority of transgender youth do not regret or retransition https://t.co/0fkD9GYjZS
@Frollein_VogelV https://t.co/PgIJUdPfGb
@Psygrav @Marmala27217367 @SkullMutant @aqueerius8 @rickspenguin @RoronoaBayo @CritRacePapers @itsjacksonbbz @KCMiller1225 https://t.co/vXUqmVjmv6 https://t.co/o7wVjwOGXp https://t.co/dUBj51m3CR here https://t.co/2nevWApiNj
@capitalismandf1 @TheProblem @AppleTVPlus https://t.co/vEQJ3BogAx conducted a long-term followup of 317 trans kids and found that over the course of 5 years, a resounding 94% of kids kept their trans identity. Only 2.5% detransitioned back to a cisgender identity.
@capitalismandf1 @TheProblem @AppleTVPlus Cause people don't detransition https://t.co/nXtkjU51L1 And https://t.co/G6lEQFnIaG And https://t.co/vEQJ3BogAx And https://t.co/TF8Afrcn5h And https://t.co/ghDDSjJfvv
@MxLouKeemia @RadioFW @gottosayit @IsabelDiogo @DentonDanO @TheProblem @AppleTVPlus https://t.co/vXUqmVjmv6 https://t.co/VyxQy1fnSz
@Clayton_pots @LGBwiththeT @vala84no @Jen_Greenteeth You’re talking about studies that a) included any GNC kids b) pressured them not to transition for the course of the study and c) still showed that kids with a ‘persistent, consistent, insistent’ GI different to their birth sex would remain trans for life https://t.co/aYVmRrVOfg
@scrowder thats funny, I have a peer reviewed study saying 97% of kids that socially transition dont go back. Kinda silly how I have a legitimate source. https://t.co/ryF4onOUmW
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
@DenSasja @lazyb0y @ModelYendofICE @aginnt The current research done does not suggest that is an issue. https://t.co/TgxG8q6B2V
@docdocwoz @WobblyBits_X @buttonslives Data actually supports two things: 1. Transition helps those with gender dysphoria ( https://t.co/GKefYDLbt5 ) 2. Over 97% of youth folk who transition do not detransition ( https://t.co/Lhr5v4sYNU ) Furthermore almost no minors make “irreversible medical interventions.” 1/2
Early "social transition" correlates with increased persistence of gender anxiety and cross-sex identification, as per https://t.co/gYzmt8O6ak, as discussed at https://t.co/kzxKx07ZOV.
Detransitioning appears to be rather unusual (c. 1/10 of all cases), though not rare, and often caused by external factors such as a non-affirmative, discriminatory environment and lack of financial resources/support by others. https://t.co/vfW2KkV5zX; https://t.co/lF7Oy57TcL
RT @milcaber: @Mayino9513 @__erosgarcia Sí, es falso lo de cirugías en menores de edad. Muy poca gente detransiciona. Casi siempre por raz…
@Mayino9513 @__erosgarcia Sí, es falso lo de cirugías en menores de edad. Muy poca gente detransiciona. Casi siempre por razones externas a la persona (presión social, vida en peligro, desempleo, etc.). Sobre las detransiciones en niñxs, un estudio reciente de la AAP: https://t.co/ktvlBeaYBD
@LouiseGrace12 @carolgeddes @hughster https://t.co/SuE35jEFun This study has a far larger sample size, with both boys and girls ages 3–12, regular follow-up (as opposed to the other study only getting a before & after), and plans to continue follow-up into adulthood. ~2.5% "desisted," ~3.5% shifted to non-binary.
@Dagget84858147 @BeardedWisdom @tlake007 @greg_price11 Hmmm.... Who do I trust? Sexology Today? Or the American Academy of Pediatrics? https://t.co/inrB9xonIk
For anyone who needs it today. Regarding transgender kids. In the current decade <10% who transition ever desist. The reason is now there is not pressure to conform to "just be gay" or whatever. That is a good thing. https://t.co/fPFVPy1S7A
@Lin12Am @girlsademocrat @js78999 @MuppetRage @NoLieWithBTC It's likely https://t.co/5PaI5XliJc, which they are of course wrong about ("no drugs no surgery" - one in ten were medicalized at the start of it, and two thirds at the end of it).
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition https://t.co/0WYq88k2oE
Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition - PubMed 少し気になってたやつ 平均年齢8.1歳で、再移行が7.3%なのは意外かなぁ やっぱり子供って侮るんじゃなくて、きちんと個として接した方が良いんだね https://t.co/4PA6n13bxT
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
RT @DadTrans: Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor…
Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics. Olson, K. R., Durwood, L., Horton, R., Gallagher, N. M., & Devor, A. (2022). https://t.co/1mQZ3qxGZW 85/
Really great work from folks at Princeton, on the rate of detransition among children (≈8 y.o.) who self-identify as transgender. After 5 years, 94% of them continued to identify as trans. Unsurprising results but an important paper.
@Morgothbe Parce qu'en vrai, avec les chiffres concrets de retours en arrière, la réalité c'est que ce que vous évoquez ne peut tenir qu'en argument qu'en estimant que la santé d'une personne cis vaut celle d'au moins 100 personnes trans. https://t.co/gVbur3jtxo
page) https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/doi/10.1542/peds.2021-056082/186992/Gender-Identity-5-Years-After-Social-Transition
Pre-publication release of Kristina R. Olson, Lily Durwood, Rachel Horton, Natalie M. Gallagher, Aaron Devor; Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition. Pediatrics 2022; 10.1542/peds.2021-056082 currently up at https://t.co/oydvzuzNR0.
https://publications.aap.org/pediatrics/article/doi/10.1542/peds.2021-056082/186992/Gender-Identity-5-Years-After-Social-Transition
Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition https://t.co/XTF0vkC8nO #PubMed #Transgender