Discussions demonstrate a balanced perspective, with some posts expressing excitement about new research endeavors and others emphasizing the importance of caution due to replication challenges, as seen in phrases like 'call for caution' and references to 'failure to replicate.' The tone and choice of words reflect a nuanced debate about the reliability and implications of neurobiological markers in trauma-related psychiatric vulnerability, leading to moderate scores across all dimensions.
AgreementNeither agree nor disagree
Most discussions call for caution and acknowledge the difficulty in replicating findings, reflecting a neutral stance rather than outright agreement or disagreement.
InterestModerate interest
The discussions show some curiosity, especially around the challenges of neuroimaging research and replication issues, but the overall enthusiasm appears moderate.
EngagementModerate engagement
Participants reference specific studies, mention editors, and discuss implications, indicating a moderate level of in-depth engagement.
ImpactNeutral impact
The discourse highlights important scientific concerns but does not suggest the publication has had a transformative impact, thus a neutral impact score.
Abstract in brief
Recent research aims to classify psychiatric vulnerability after trauma using objective brain-based markers rather than subjective symptom reports, to improve personalized treatment.
A 2021 study by Stevens et al attempted to replicate earlier findings by identifying brain-based biotypes linked to posttraumatic symptom patterns, but their results showed different neural clusters not directly related to symptoms.
The study suggests that brain-based biotypes may not be easily generalizable across different populations, highlighting the need for further research to find consistent neurobiological subtypes of trauma-related mental health issues.]
Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our work that was published today in @APAPubJournals American Journal of Psychiatry!
Jan 11, 2023 · 120 likes · 40 shares · 1,284 followersView post →
JA
Journals of The American Psychiatric Association
@APAPubJournals · X
A non-replication study @PTSDStressLab @YaleDecisionLab suggests caution is warranted when attempting to define neuroimaging-based #biotypes of psychiatric vulnerability. @ZivBenZion1 @TRSpiller @RoeeAdmon @ifat_levy @harpaz_l https://t.co/LQTCL5NWGU https://t.co/Cjb9r1P8dd
Jan 11, 2023 · 14 likes · 10 shares · 11,606 followersView post →
JS
Jennifer Stevens
@DrJenniStevens · X
What can we learn from a failure to replicate? https://t.co/NlcaMOg7f6
Some thoughts... https://t.co/Ny8BnlzDsj
Jan 11, 2023 · 13 likes · 2 shares · 1,466 followersView post →
ZZ
Ziv Ben-Zion
@ZivBenZion1 · X
American Journal of Psychiatry (#AJP) Deputy Editor, Daniel S. Pine, discusses our recent work (@TRSpiller @nimrodke1 @RoeeAdmon @HendlerLab @ifat_levy @harpaz_l) in the February 2023 AJP Editor Spotlight
https://t.co/DUcE1hurqS
Feb 18, 2023 · 13 likes · 2 shares · 1,284 followersView post →
JA
Journals of The American Psychiatric Association
@APAPubJournals · X
Evaluating the Evidence for Brain-Based Biotypes of Psychiatric Vulnerability in the Acute Aftermath of Trauma,” by Ziv Ben-Zion, Ph.D., et al.
https://t.co/VPEAm2X0bN
Feb 17, 2023 · 7 likes · 3 shares · 11,606 followersView post →
ZZ
Ziv Ben-Zion
@ZivBenZion1 · X
@APAPubJournals Special thanks to @DrJenniStevens for her commendable collaboration, to my amazing colleagues @TRSpiller @nimrodke1 @RoeeAdmon and great mentors @ifat_levy @HendlerLab @harpaz_l @PTSDStressLab @YaleDecisionLab!
Feb 1, 2023 · 6 likes · 1,284 followersView post →
American Journal of Psychiatry Deputy Editor Daniel S Pine MD discusses recent research efforts to classify psychiatric vulnerability after trauma using brain-based markers, highlighting challenges in replicability and…
American Journal of Psychiatry Deputy Editor Daniel S Pine MD discusses the article Evaluating the Evidence for BrainBased Biotypes of Psychiatric Vulnerability in the Acute Aftermath of Trauma by Ziv BenZion PhD and…
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jun 15, 2023 · 40 shares · 70 followersView post →
YL
Yale PTSD Stress Lab
@PTSDStressLab · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: American Journal of Psychiatry (#AJP) Deputy Editor, Daniel S. Pine, discusses our recent work (@TRSpiller @nimrodke1 @Roe…
Feb 18, 2023 · 2 shares · 1,016 followersView post →
YL
Yale Decision Neuroscience Lab
@YaleDecisionLab · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: American Journal of Psychiatry (#AJP) Deputy Editor, Daniel S. Pine, discusses our recent work (@TRSpiller @nimrodke1 @Roe…
Feb 18, 2023 · 2 shares · 243 followersView post →
ZZ
Ziv Ben-Zion
@ZivBenZion1 · X
American Journal of Psychiatry (#AJP) Deputy Editor, Daniel S. Pine, discusses our recent work (@TRSpiller @nimrodke1 @RoeeAdmon @HendlerLab @ifat_levy @harpaz_l) in the February 2023 AJP Editor Spotlight
https://t.co/DUcE1hurqS
Feb 18, 2023 · 13 likes · 2 shares · 1,284 followersView post →
YL
Yale PTSD Stress Lab
@PTSDStressLab · X
RT @APAPubJournals: Evaluating the Evidence for Brain-Based Biotypes of Psychiatric Vulnerability in the Acute Aftermath of Trauma,” by Ziv…
Feb 18, 2023 · 3 shares · 1,016 followersView post →
YL
Yale Decision Neuroscience Lab
@YaleDecisionLab · X
RT @APAPubJournals: Evaluating the Evidence for Brain-Based Biotypes of Psychiatric Vulnerability in the Acute Aftermath of Trauma,” by Ziv…
Feb 18, 2023 · 3 shares · 243 followersView post →
ZZ
Ziv Ben-Zion
@ZivBenZion1 · X
RT @APAPubJournals: Evaluating the Evidence for Brain-Based Biotypes of Psychiatric Vulnerability in the Acute Aftermath of Trauma,” by Ziv…
Feb 18, 2023 · 3 shares · 1,284 followersView post →
JA
Journals of The American Psychiatric Association
@APAPubJournals · X
Evaluating the Evidence for Brain-Based Biotypes of Psychiatric Vulnerability in the Acute Aftermath of Trauma,” by Ziv Ben-Zion, Ph.D., et al.
https://t.co/VPEAm2X0bN
Feb 17, 2023 · 7 likes · 3 shares · 11,606 followersView post →
JA
Journals of The American Psychiatric Association
@APAPubJournals · X
AJP Deputy Editor Danny Pine highlights two articles from the February 2023 issue.
https://t.co/I1gl10bvI0
Feb 17, 2023 · 1 like · 11,606 followersView post →
DW
Dr. John M. Earl Waugh
@DrWaugh1 · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Feb 8, 2023 · 40 shares · 390 followersView post →
ZZ
Ziv Ben-Zion
@ZivBenZion1 · X
@APAPubJournals Special thanks to @DrJenniStevens for her commendable collaboration, to my amazing colleagues @TRSpiller @nimrodke1 @RoeeAdmon and great mentors @ifat_levy @HendlerLab @harpaz_l @PTSDStressLab @YaleDecisionLab!
Feb 1, 2023 · 6 likes · 1,284 followersView post →
NL
NEUROADS Lab
@neuroads_lab · X
RT @CommsPsychol: Based on new analyses testing for a conceptual replication of earlier results, @ZivBenZion1 et al call for caution when i…
Jan 19, 2023 · 6 shares · 1,062 followersView post →
O
orduek
@orduek · X
RT @CommsPsychol: Based on new analyses testing for a conceptual replication of earlier results, @ZivBenZion1 et al call for caution when i…
Jan 19, 2023 · 6 shares · 321 followersView post →
YL
Yale Decision Neuroscience Lab
@YaleDecisionLab · X
RT @CommsPsychol: Based on new analyses testing for a conceptual replication of earlier results, @ZivBenZion1 et al call for caution when i…
Jan 18, 2023 · 6 shares · 243 followersView post →
YL
Yale PTSD Stress Lab
@PTSDStressLab · X
RT @CommsPsychol: Based on new analyses testing for a conceptual replication of earlier results, @ZivBenZion1 et al call for caution when i…
Jan 18, 2023 · 6 shares · 1,016 followersView post →
ZZ
Ziv Ben-Zion
@ZivBenZion1 · X
RT @CommsPsychol: Based on new analyses testing for a conceptual replication of earlier results, @ZivBenZion1 et al call for caution when i…
Jan 18, 2023 · 6 shares · 1,284 followersView post →
CP
Communications Psychology
@CommsPsychol · X
Based on new analyses testing for a conceptual replication of earlier results, @ZivBenZion1 et al call for caution when identifying neuroimaging-based #biotypes of psychiatric vulnerability in post-traumatic participants. @PTSDStrassLab @YaleDecisionLab https://t.co/I3Q1xp4Mn7
Jan 18, 2023 · 5 likes · 6 shares · 1,393 followersView post →
NW
NP AGARWAL世界一フォローを目指しますAiming best in world.
@np_grwl · X
RT @medical_xpress: Can neuroimaging reveal the roots of #psychiatricdisorders? Not just yet, says study @yale https://t.co/Cr78oCAsfb http…
Jan 17, 2023 · 4 shares · 1,787 followersView post →
LP
Lana Ruvolo, PhD
@ScientificRuvvy · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 17, 2023 · 40 shares · 1,607 followersView post →
AD
Anat D
@zuzu4always · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 12, 2023 · 40 shares · 2,312 followersView post →
YN
yoshiyuki nishio
@nishiokov · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 12, 2023 · 40 shares · 520 followersView post →
GT
Global Collaboration on Traumatic Stress (GC-TS)
@Global_Trauma · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 12, 2023 · 40 shares · 837 followersView post →
NS
nicola sambuco
@NicolaSambuco · X
RT @DrJenniStevens: What can we learn from a failure to replicate? https://t.co/NlcaMOg7f6
Some thoughts... https://t.co/Ny8BnlzDsj
Jan 12, 2023 · 2 shares · 882 followersView post →
CN
Cognitive Neuropsychiatry
@CogNPsychiatry · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 12, 2023 · 40 shares · 2,689 followersView post →
CL
Caesar Liu
@CaesarLiu_12 · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 12, 2023 · 40 shares · 162 followersView post →
IR
Isabelle Rosso
@irosso · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 512 followersView post →
JC
Joseph Chen
@josephccchen · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 193 followersView post →
?
✌
@Iamatewo1 · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 398 followersView post →
CR
Carolyn Rodriguez
@CRodriguezMDPhD · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 4,326 followersView post →
MG
Mike Gara
@garami53 · X
RT @APAPubJournals: A non-replication study @PTSDStressLab @YaleDecisionLab suggests caution is warranted when attempting to define neuroim…
Jan 11, 2023 · 10 shares · 1,734 followersView post →
DM
Daniel P. Moriarity
@dp_moriarity · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 5,627 followersView post →
JS
Jennifer Stevens
@DrJenniStevens · X
What can we learn from a failure to replicate? https://t.co/NlcaMOg7f6
Some thoughts... https://t.co/Ny8BnlzDsj
Jan 11, 2023 · 13 likes · 2 shares · 1,466 followersView post →
Rن
Roxana Jabbarinejad(She/Her) رکسانا جباری نژاد
@RoxanaJabbarin · X
RT @APAPubJournals: A non-replication study @PTSDStressLab @YaleDecisionLab suggests caution is warranted when attempting to define neuroim…
Jan 11, 2023 · 10 shares · 193 followersView post →
CS
Corinna Schulz
@Cor_Et_Cerebrum · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 573 followersView post →
O
orduek
@orduek · X
RT @APAPubJournals: A non-replication study @PTSDStressLab @YaleDecisionLab suggests caution is warranted when attempting to define neuroim…
Jan 11, 2023 · 10 shares · 321 followersView post →
YL
Yale Decision Neuroscience Lab
@YaleDecisionLab · X
RT @APAPubJournals: A non-replication study @PTSDStressLab @YaleDecisionLab suggests caution is warranted when attempting to define neuroim…
Jan 11, 2023 · 10 shares · 243 followersView post →
YL
Yale PTSD Stress Lab
@PTSDStressLab · X
RT @APAPubJournals: A non-replication study @PTSDStressLab @YaleDecisionLab suggests caution is warranted when attempting to define neuroim…
Jan 11, 2023 · 10 shares · 1,016 followersView post →
JA
Journals of The American Psychiatric Association
@APAPubJournals · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 11,606 followersView post →
SD
Sarah Danböck
@SarahDanboeck · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 293 followersView post →
ZZ
Ziv Ben-Zion
@ZivBenZion1 · X
RT @APAPubJournals: A non-replication study @PTSDStressLab @YaleDecisionLab suggests caution is warranted when attempting to define neuroim…
Jan 11, 2023 · 10 shares · 1,284 followersView post →
SS
Sam Cooper @samcooper.bsky.social
@samcooper_phd · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 289 followersView post →
MP
Megan Paterson
@MeganEPaterson · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 23 followersView post →
JA
Journals of The American Psychiatric Association
@APAPubJournals · X
A non-replication study @PTSDStressLab @YaleDecisionLab suggests caution is warranted when attempting to define neuroimaging-based #biotypes of psychiatric vulnerability. @ZivBenZion1 @TRSpiller @RoeeAdmon @ifat_levy @harpaz_l https://t.co/LQTCL5NWGU https://t.co/Cjb9r1P8dd
Jan 11, 2023 · 14 likes · 10 shares · 11,606 followersView post →
LS
Leonhard Schilbach
@leoschilbach · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 6,748 followersView post →
NS
nicola sambuco
@NicolaSambuco · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 882 followersView post →
AP
Ariel Pridan
@Ariel_Pridan · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 22 followersView post →
เท
เซอร์ประมุท
@sombundii · X
RT @medical_xpress: Can neuroimaging reveal the roots of #psychiatricdisorders? Not just yet, says study @yale https://t.co/Cr78oCAsfb http…
Jan 11, 2023 · 4 shares · 167 followersView post →
P
PCSAS
@PCSASNews · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 1,702 followersView post →
DA
Dr. Samadov Aabdić
@samadovaabditch · X
RT @medical_xpress: Can neuroimaging reveal the roots of #psychiatricdisorders? Not just yet, says study @yale https://t.co/Cr78oCAsfb http…
Jan 11, 2023 · 4 shares · 3,367 followersView post →
MX
Medical Xpress
@physorg_health · X
RT @medical_xpress: Can neuroimaging reveal the roots of #psychiatricdisorders? Not just yet, says study @yale https://t.co/Cr78oCAsfb http…
Jan 11, 2023 · 4 shares · 7,021 followersView post →
MX
Medical Xpress
@medical_xpress · X
Can neuroimaging reveal the roots of #psychiatricdisorders? Not just yet, says study @yale https://t.co/Cr78oCAsfb https://t.co/z33h9sG0M9
Jan 11, 2023 · 4 likes · 4 shares · 172,972 followersView post →
NM
Noah S Philip MD
@NoahSPhilipMD · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 1,979 followersView post →
CX
Chelsea Xu
@cherruc · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 112 followersView post →
SH
Sarah L. Hagerty
@sarahlhagerty · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 259 followersView post →
SI
Shai Israel
@ShaiIsrael2 · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 128 followersView post →
NK
Nachshon Korem
@KoremNachshon · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 103 followersView post →
JS
Joe Wielgosz @joewphd.bsky.social
@joewielgosz · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 386 followersView post →
NK
Nils Kroemer
@cornu_copiae · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 2,718 followersView post →
O
orduek
@orduek · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 321 followersView post →
YL
Yale PTSD Stress Lab
@PTSDStressLab · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 1,016 followersView post →
YL
Yale Decision Neuroscience Lab
@YaleDecisionLab · X
RT @ZivBenZion1: Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our wo…
Jan 11, 2023 · 40 shares · 243 followersView post →
ZZ
Ziv Ben-Zion
@ZivBenZion1 · X
Can we replicate the previously identified brain-based biotypes of posttraumatic psychopathology? Thrilled to share our work that was published today in @APAPubJournals American Journal of Psychiatry!
Jan 11, 2023 · 120 likes · 40 shares · 1,284 followersView post →
N
Neurobiology and Systems Biology of Stress Resilience | PDF ...
ZZ
JA
JS
NZ
YL
YL
DW
NL
O
CP
NW
LP
AD
M
BP
CB
SS
YM
CI
SS
YN
GT
NS
CN
CL
IR
JC
?
CR
MG
DM
Rن
CS
SD
SS
MP
LS
AP
เท
P
DA
MX
MX
NM
CX
SH
SI
NK
JS
NK