Several discussions focus on the negative client experiences outlined in the publication, with posters pointing to issues such as therapists imposing their values, inappropriate conduct, and the potential for therapy to worsen mental health. The tone varies from cautionary to critical, with phrases like 'must-read' and references to therapist misconduct underscoring the perceived importance and impact of the findings. The choice of words, such as 'neadekvātums' (inadequacy) and terms like 'poor treatment fit,' highlight worries about the quality and effectiveness of therapy, reflecting both concern and a desire for increased awareness in the clinical community.
AgreementLow agreement
Most discussions express skepticism or highlight negative findings, suggesting a degree of disagreement or critical perspective towards the idea that therapy is universally positive.
InterestHigh interest
High interest is evident as posters emphasize the importance and relevance of the study, urging clinicians to read it and highlighting key negative aspects.
EngagementModerate engagement
Posts demonstrate some depth by discussing specific issues like therapist misconduct and poor fit, but overall, engagement remains somewhat surface-level with emphasis on awareness.
ImpactModerate impact
There is recognition of the publication's significance, especially among professionals who are encouraged to consider its implications for clinical practice.
Abstract in brief
Many clients report negative or unwanted effects from psychotherapy, which can include issues like therapist misconduct, poor treatment fit, or negative impacts of therapy.
The study analyzed 51 qualitative research papers, extracting 936 statements from clients about their negative experiences, and grouped these into 21 main categories.
These categories were organized into four main clusters: therapist misbehavior, difficulties in the client-therapist relationship, poor fit of the treatment, and overall negative effects of therapy, highlighting the wide range of adverse experiences clients may face.]
Experiências negativas em psicoterapia (perspectiva do cliente)
Mais me chamaram atenção:
terapeuta que impõe seus valores sob o cliente;
terapeuta que fala sem cuidado ‘colocando sal na ferida’
https://t.co/tOjjUzIuMx
⚠️ If you are a (mental health) clinician, this is a must-read for you! Please, book some time to give it proper attention, because this is too important. If you know a clinician, send this to them.
Link: https://t.co/omWr3gA3Kp https://t.co/YXJ3vxuwn3
Psihoterapija var palīdzēt un var arī kaitēt. Pētījumā uzrādās četri negatīvo pieredžu iemesli:
1) Terapeita neadekvātums
2) Neskaidrība terapeitiskajās attiecībās
3) Nepiemērota terapijas forma
4) Slikti terapijas blakusefekti
https://t.co/4DKr7axAeI
@seanluomdphd @Cluffalo nice meta analysis here that finds evidence in the exact opposite direction of the “everyone needs therapy” sentiment: across 19 different studies, “therapy resulted in deterioration of mental health or increased clients' interpersonal problems”
https://t.co/cf5lsM0Al8).
Negative effects of counseling include distressing but expected consequences, unintended negative experiences, and significant harms. This video explores the range of adverse outcomes clients may face during…
This video addresses concerns and clarifies doubts about side effects of counselling, highlighting potential risks including unwanted effects, side effects, and adverse effects that can impact therapy outcomes.
@seanluomdphd @Cluffalo nice meta analysis here that finds evidence in the exact opposite direction of the “everyone needs therapy” sentiment: across 19 different studies, “therapy resulted in deterioration of mental health or increased clients' interpersonal problems”
https://t.co/cf5lsM0Al8).
Experiências negativas em psicoterapia (perspectiva do cliente)
Mais me chamaram atenção:
terapeuta que impõe seus valores sob o cliente;
terapeuta que fala sem cuidado ‘colocando sal na ferida’
https://t.co/tOjjUzIuMx
Psihoterapija var palīdzēt un var arī kaitēt. Pētījumā uzrādās četri negatīvo pieredžu iemesli:
1) Terapeita neadekvātums
2) Neskaidrība terapeitiskajās attiecībās
3) Nepiemērota terapijas forma
4) Slikti terapijas blakusefekti
https://t.co/4DKr7axAeI
⚠️ If you are a (mental health) clinician, this is a must-read for you! Please, book some time to give it proper attention, because this is too important. If you know a clinician, send this to them.
Link: https://t.co/omWr3gA3Kp https://t.co/YXJ3vxuwn3