Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages.
Paul Heggarty, Cormac Anderson, Matthew Scarborough, Benedict King, Remco Bouckaert, Lechosław Jocz, Martin Joachim Kümmel, Thomas Jügel, Britta Irslinger, Roland Pooth, Henrik Liljegren, Richard F Strand, Geoffrey Haig, Martin Macák, Ronald I Kim
July 2023 ScienceSynopsis of Social media discussions
Across the digital discussions, numerous contributors directly reference the article and debate its conclusions. For example, comments like "this study truly shifts the understanding of Indo-European origins" and critiques regarding competing theories illustrate an active discourse. Phrases such as "hybrid model" and "reconcile current linguistic and ancient DNA evidence" indicate an engaged exploration of the research's implications. The use of assertive language and terms like "debunk" and "game changer" demonstrates a high level of interest and perceived impact among the participants.
Agreement
Moderate agreementThe majority of discussions show a favorable stance towards the findings of the publication, although there are dissenting opinions about its implications.
Interest
High level of interestThere is a noticeable enthusiasm for the topic, as many participants reference the research directly and express curiosity regarding the theories presented.
Engagement
Moderate level of engagementWhile some posts engage deeply with the publication's findings, others reflect a more casual interest or dismissive tone.
Impact
High level of impactThe discussions highlight a belief in the publication's significance, with many asserting that it contributes valuable insights to the understanding of Indo-European language origins.
Social Mentions
YouTube
2 Videos
Bluesky
9 Posts
5 Posts
298 Posts
Blogs
17 Articles
News
80 Articles
8 Posts
Metrics
Video Views
331,686
Total Likes
11,674
Extended Reach
1,789,598
Social Features
419
Timeline: Posts about article
Top Social Media Posts
Iosif Lazaridis
Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper.
https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP
Heggarty et al. had proposed a different scenario of IE origins a couple years ago:
https://t.co/TopbrUEeMz
In this short thread I will comment on some of the points he makes.
view full post
Thomas Olander | @olander.bsky.social
We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages) as an eLetter in Science: https://t.co/Gc4Tt2rTWC
This figure sums up our concerns. https://t.co/SEaDNDJwtn
view full post
Nrken19
Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic
https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full post
a_south_indian
@broseph_stalin this has been disproven. IVC was Indo-Aryan speaking and steppe ancestry in Indians is female mediated. https://t.co/aj4D27SJz2
view full post
a_south_indian
@hindookissinger IVC was Vedic, hindoopissnger : https://t.co/aj4D27SbJu
view full post
Posts referencing the article
New Insights into the Indo-European Language Family Origins
Explore the Indo-European language family's complexities, challenging the notion that everything is known. Recent research indicates significant gene flow from West Asia into Anatolia, suggesting a different origin for the Indo-Anatolian language family than previously believed.
July 20, 2024
247,541 views
New Insights on Proto Indo-European Language Origins
A recently published study analyzes the origins of Indo-European languages, exploring theories of a farming expansion from Anatolia and a pastoral spread from the Pontic-Caspian Steppe. This research suggests a root age of about 8120 years for the language family.
July 29, 2023
84,146 views
-
@phaidon @WIminmisery @Kosovo_Update https://t.co/dFPiDN0srx "Steppe" was "Home". The very beginning. https://t.co/0ct6VMUTnz
view full postOctober 14, 2025
-
olti_illyr_alb
@OltiAlbIllyrian (Twitter)@grok @Torquat28352878 @radomandamanov @grok, as per timeline of the divergence of main branches of Indo-European, it is very clear when it happened or around 7000 years ago. In the timeline chart: "by ~7000 years B.P (before present) multiple major branches of Indo-European already diverged" https://t.co/jj58CVGe9t https://t.co/AGtmcxOnjk
view full postSeptember 20, 2025
-
@BharataPURU (Twitter)@Aryamemoire @aryavursh @hindookissinger Thats false. Wikipedia =/= mainstream academia. https://t.co/snjE4APOx5
view full postSeptember 18, 2025
-
@BharataPURU (Twitter)@Thfclunatic @VedicWisdom1 The word aryan was never used by europeans until the modern era
view full postSeptember 8, 2025
-
சிற்பி Sirpi
@p0daran (Twitter)@Mala_Naicker @AskPerplexity @Devasakha @grok Here’s a curated list of most influential and recent academic papers on Indo-European migration, covering linguistic, archaeological, and genomic perspectives: --- Key Recent Papers & Models 1. “Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of
view full postSeptember 1, 2025
-
சிற்பி Sirpi
@p0daran (Twitter)@Mala_Naicker @AskPerplexity @Devasakha @grok Have you read this one? Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/DZeiuYdm6B
view full postSeptember 1, 2025
-
சிற்பி Sirpi
@p0daran (Twitter)@Mala_Naicker @AskPerplexity @Devasakha @grok Maybe you ought to read something on the topic first before embarrassing yourself in public. https://t.co/dDdyJItJcy
view full postSeptember 1, 2025
-
சிற்பி Sirpi
@p0daran (Twitter)@Mala_Naicker @AskPerplexity @Devasakha @grok We don't know anything? Or we don't know something? Maybe YOU don't know madam, because clearly you've not read a single paper on the topic. So much for touting evidence based medicine!
view full postSeptember 1, 2025
-
சிற்பி Sirpi
@p0daran (Twitter)@Mala_Naicker @AskPerplexity @Devasakha @grok Not when we have ancient DNA samples that we can use as templates. Again, I suggest you read more before arriving at ill-informed opinions. https://t.co/dDdyJItJcy
view full postSeptember 1, 2025
-
Jonn
@Jonn7310 (Twitter)@br_llm_lock @Slavman1945 @a_south_indian @xamoghx buffoon just responded with more stupidity heres my actual source of information https://t.co/yJDUtXZT1t https://t.co/t7z9SlCfHJ
view full postAugust 20, 2025
1
-
BV
@zhapiiniii (Twitter)@ToedPeel89 @ttt1584951 @noraleonora94 @GlobalDiss https://t.co/nr2WExjTcZ have a read slave
view full postAugust 13, 2025
1
-
P J
@PJ11819211 (Twitter)@gamerdotweb @AspiringAntel https://t.co/BvZpuAATGn
view full postAugust 8, 2025
1
-
‼️࿗‼️ वात्स्यायन ‼️࿗‼️
@vedik_Arya_ (Twitter)RT @br_llm_lock: IVC-IE papers: Heggarty 2023 and Yang 2024 for linguistics, IVC-IE link: https://t.co/poUlPEaciG https://t.co/gAMBDlKp3P…
view full postAugust 6, 2025
15
-
Shkumbin Rama
@shkumbin_rama (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/Lr36RDzHQb
view full postJuly 30, 2025
-
Alvin
@Alvin25371351 (Twitter)@QrTHs6ugFLHPtvq @Romanistan1971 Actually it’s just science: https://t.co/tqXVNGb8gk Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science
view full postJuly 27, 2025
10
-
Āryā
@Shamrat330 (Twitter)@theparadox94528 @PortfolioPasha @a_south_indian @Anand_Venkatram @assuwatama7 https://t.co/muCIgmMfe4 https://t.co/iruFjhX2T6
view full postJuly 26, 2025
1
-
Iperus
@iperusalb (Twitter)@philosofveritas @EpiriEtAlbaniae https://t.co/JaY0YBba4y
view full postJuly 22, 2025
1
-
World ignite.
@world_ignite (Twitter)@RMV0210 @thatindicmonk https://t.co/bCiclssNDf
view full postJuly 18, 2025
-
Visar Hoti
@visartema (Twitter)@R0C23 @albtr_eagle24 https://t.co/Ih3fwZIXtB
view full postJuly 12, 2025
-
a_south_indian
@a_south_indian (Twitter)@qalzuren @hindookissinger this isn't cope. The linguistics agrees with what I am saying: https://t.co/aj4D27SbJu
view full postJuly 9, 2025
1
-
Napoleonette
@Napoleonette11 (Twitter)#Language #trees with sampled ancestors support a #hybrid model for the #origin of #Indo- #European languages https://t.co/kJ3d1AQUNI
view full postJuly 7, 2025
-
Kajoshi
@Kajoshii (Twitter)@gamw_ta @StefanBrakus93 @plischronicler Well, I know you and your Slavic brothers don’t like it but is true, you can’t hide it any more. I bet you that I have more % of Greek&Albanian DNA than you. If you have your DNA test, show it to us, i will be glad to show you mine. https://t.co/ANpTRChzuW
view full postJuly 1, 2025
-
Gucia666
@Gucia6666 (Twitter)@rfilmyer @glendowerowain @JoePostingg @MattZeitlin That's quite reductionist, there are a number of other arguments for it (Wikipedia has a list). New research has also put Albanian alongside Greek and Armenian as the oldest Indo-European languages. So Albanians are at bare minimum a paleo-balkanic group https://t.co/IHgkA1pHc2
view full postJune 24, 2025
5
-
T
@tanausis (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postJune 20, 2025
30
-
olti_illyr_alb
@OltiAlbIllyrian (Twitter)@tvojchalebrale @OGcjm263983 @slobodan_X_svoj
view full postJune 16, 2025
-
a_south_indian
@a_south_indian (Twitter)@hindookissinger IVC was Vedic, hindoopissnger : https://t.co/aj4D27SbJu
view full postJune 7, 2025
30
-
a_south_indian
@a_south_indian (Twitter)@wasteyavvaralu The IVC was Vedic : https://t.co/aj4D27SbJu
view full postJune 7, 2025
9
-
Jalə Qəribova
@jgaribova (Twitter)@renemliD Bu yazının tümüne ulaşmak kısıtlı olsa da, özet de yeterince detaylı. https://t.co/0LCEf87QMS
view full postJune 6, 2025
1
-
juanviejo
@juanviejo (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/Velo2eyY55
view full postJune 5, 2025
-
bedste forever
@Aabbppt (Twitter)@iosif_lazaridis The only genetically, archeologically, historically, answer to PIE ROOT IS WRITEN HERE. PIE is born in ZAGROS. CASE SOLVED https://t.co/KTGWOJZMOJ
view full postMay 27, 2025
-
a_south_indian
@a_south_indian (Twitter)@ThatchEffendi @Heg70412Hegde bruh. This REALLY isn't your area of expertise. https://t.co/aj4D27SbJu
view full postMay 27, 2025
11
1
-
a_south_indian
@a_south_indian (Twitter)@kartikeyablanco @TheArprlo @Michssspp82096 @SkandArya999 @iosif_lazaridis @assuwatama7 @Atacama372842 @manavparmar98 @John84795 @giac77 it's ok. We've all been there. Start by reading this paper: https://t.co/aj4D27SbJu
view full postMay 26, 2025
-
Anna Krasko
@6earth97 (Twitter)#linguistics #lexis #IECoR #indoeuropean Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/DQCD3iLYgc
view full postMay 17, 2025
1
-
a_south_indian
@a_south_indian (Twitter)@YuriABezmenov @Shamrat331 @SkandArya999 @JokerS44371534 https://t.co/aj4D27SbJu : )
view full postMay 14, 2025
-
Voice of Voiceless
@VoiceOfVoicels (Twitter)@siyah7171739032 @HadiBeArts Read this article. The most recent funding shows the Western Iran, Zagrios Mountains is the origin of the Indo-Europeans! https://t.co/mYIfBo5E2p
view full postMay 11, 2025
1
-
olti_illyr_alb
@OltiAlbIllyrian (Twitter)@Petalasandr @AlbanDardania85 @Gimi4Fred @RealHellenist
view full postMay 11, 2025
-
US - ALBANIAN MEDIA GROUP
@SocietyAlbanian (Twitter)@StariotSoSpirit https://t.co/lAbtK7G8Pj
view full postMay 6, 2025
-
kthetrat ⚡
@kthetrat (Twitter)@grok @Yperanoolon @mariakalantze @alex_velaj @grok What's the timeline for Albanian and Greek according "Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages" by Heggarty et al. (2023), Max Planck/Science? https://t.co/OrSzb2MDoQ
view full postMay 6, 2025
1
-
Pablo H. Carreño
@Sciacallus (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/rtWIdFb0hM
view full postMay 4, 2025
-
BV
@zhapiiniii (Twitter)@_Makedonuts_ @bigjohn53979259 @PallasGlaux @TheRisingFinix @Chigeorge72 @GBrezftohti @GrecoStrategos @kolonjar @TheCross_ICXCN @StopYourBsSerb @dsgsdfg51647791 @Darnakas3 @eftimia60 @G7uQ40F6VP1Rv2U @tricomtech @THE_GREEK_007 @theoperi @DinosPalaio @Konstan16204029 @andros_sk_mari @TreloKomio5 @Tutunarot1 @DirectorMKD @lolita194636511 @JordanTviterka @vladegv @No_Grik_Style @helleniccanuck1 @aleviyemem @haha_bou @APsilos @max_zek_x @Aretitheta @Ar_MA_ge_don @SrebreniKopja @OKOTOnaSE @panbog2 @YiosDia @BasilesNikolaou @MakedonPaeon @AITWLOS @dokurcev @PegoEmpresa @dondon90820793 Map one is the only reliable one here. There is a study made on linguistics by plank university. In that study they found that the Albanian language is approximately 6000 years old (if i remember my numbers). Here you have the study: https://t.co/Y7BmT5njg9
view full postMay 2, 2025
-
genti
@genti_boy_ks (Twitter)@MrTang218 @HomerPavlos You don't have a clue what science is and make stupid questions. Languages are SPOKEN MUCH before they were written. Indo-European was NEVER written language but it EXISTED and scientists know WHEN. https://t.co/4UlTiEfJTN https://t.co/1JNTDnDUU9 https://t.co/f1YGGpglOv https://t.co/cBLScgjaIh
view full postMay 2, 2025
-
Warrior of Dharma
@WoD1008 (Twitter)RT @a_south_indian: @kawsarc @Cloudwatch199 steppe ancestry in Indians is female mediated. Also you are spreading misinformation. The IVC w…
view full postApril 30, 2025
2
-
Ricardo Costa de Oliveira
@Ricardo_Cd_Oliv (Twitter)@YuriABezmenov @ArataDorkani @Ytraaash @razibkhan Heggarty model is showing Iranic as a very old branch and we can point to very ancient frontiers between Indo-European languages only in West Asia, far older than in Europe. Genetics is showing the same continuity around the Southern Caspian Sea. https://t.co/YsgGg0z6ow https://t.co/xjqJo03HJD
view full postApril 30, 2025
1
-
Purv Buddha Mahasattav
@PurvBuddhaMaha (Twitter)@VSJpyper @Niggaballs60 @SirJambavan no there are no gaps Paul Heggarty et al. ,Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages.Science381,eabg0818(2023).DOI:10.1126/science.abg0818 https://t.co/pwUSLgMi5R
view full postApril 27, 2025
2
-
Aryatva
@bennylloyd102 (Twitter)@adamteasing @Rtam86418021 Also this one. Seems to make little sense in terms of established linguistics: https://t.co/OldVPGvpJ2
view full postApril 27, 2025
-
a_south_indian
@a_south_indian (Twitter)@kawsarc @Cloudwatch199 read this: https://t.co/5Mmrs0WzTD https://t.co/aj4D27SbJu
view full postApril 26, 2025
3
-
a_south_indian
@a_south_indian (Twitter)RT @a_south_indian: @kawsarc @Cloudwatch199 steppe ancestry in Indians is female mediated. Also you are spreading misinformation. The IVC w…
view full postApril 26, 2025
2
-
a_south_indian
@a_south_indian (Twitter)@kawsarc @Cloudwatch199 steppe ancestry in Indians is female mediated. Also you are spreading misinformation. The IVC was Indo-Aryan speaking https://t.co/aj4D27SJz2
view full postApril 26, 2025
10
2
-
कविक्रतु 卐卐
@LALITADITYAARYA (Twitter)RT @a_south_indian: @broseph_stalin this has been disproven. IVC was Indo-Aryan speaking and steppe ancestry in Indians is female mediated.…
view full postApril 26, 2025
4
-
Anti-abrahamic
@RajeshK17874224 (Twitter)RT @a_south_indian: @broseph_stalin this has been disproven. IVC was Indo-Aryan speaking and steppe ancestry in Indians is female mediated.…
view full postApril 25, 2025
4
-
Vishwamitra
@DareCharm (Twitter)RT @a_south_indian: @broseph_stalin this has been disproven. IVC was Indo-Aryan speaking and steppe ancestry in Indians is female mediated.…
view full postApril 25, 2025
4
-
sivaji
@Vvsd95927246 (Twitter)RT @a_south_indian: @broseph_stalin this has been disproven. IVC was Indo-Aryan speaking and steppe ancestry in Indians is female mediated.…
view full postApril 24, 2025
4
-
a_south_indian
@a_south_indian (Twitter)@broseph_stalin this has been disproven. IVC was Indo-Aryan speaking and steppe ancestry in Indians is female mediated. https://t.co/aj4D27SJz2
view full postApril 24, 2025
41
4
-
genti
@genti_boy_ks (Twitter)@tvojchalebrale @grok @IllyriansRed @MilanSremac Illyrian names lik Shkodra are transmited through ALBANIAN language, which is the OLDEST one to have survived from Paleo-Balkan languages. https://t.co/4UlTiEfc4f https://t.co/1JNTDnDn4B https://t.co/Gue3MQucqb
view full postApril 24, 2025
-
Āryā
@Shamrat330 (Twitter)RT @br_llm_lock: IVC-IE papers: Heggarty 2023 and Yang 2024 for linguistics, IVC-IE link: https://t.co/poUlPEaciG https://t.co/gAMBDlKp3P…
view full postApril 23, 2025
15
-
Āryā
@Shamrat330 (Twitter)@bruh2082038 @yajnadevam @ladoyar777 https://t.co/muCIgmMfe4 https://t.co/PYDbyWh4b9
view full postApril 18, 2025
-
TeluguFilmFile
@TeluguFilmFile (Twitter)The critical eLetters published at https://t.co/v0R7WZRgAn aren't enough. Someone needs to publish in the same journal ('Science') a more formal critique of Heggarty et al. (2023) along with a Steppe theory-based model so that the maps like one below always end up in a trash can! https://t.co/hE9LP9yxhq
view full postApril 14, 2025
3
-
Eric Rowe
@kiwieric (Twitter)Hey @Patrick_Wyman just finished my relisten to tides prehistory/bronze age. Wondering your thoughts on this recent analysis of Indo-European language origins. https://t.co/naEoxKaGoM
view full postApril 13, 2025
-
Atul Khilari
@atulkhilari (Twitter)RT @br_llm_lock: IVC-IE papers: Heggarty 2023 and Yang 2024 for linguistics, IVC-IE link: https://t.co/poUlPEaciG https://t.co/gAMBDlKp3P…
view full postApril 13, 2025
15
-
YathAKAshTham
@YKashtam (Twitter)@Tom_Rowsell https://t.co/t9cvtlAgEE Language tree hypothesis (2023) is interesting read. Would indicate Indian presence in subcontinent during SSVC / IVC, with likely earliest presence at c.3500BCE, but firm presence by 3000BCE.
view full postApril 3, 2025
-
TeluguFilmFile
@TeluguFilmFile (Twitter)@Openatic @Abishekdulal6 Given how frequently the OIT proponents (mis)use the paper by Haggerty et al., I don't know if the eLetters https://t.co/bHPFHqZ4H9 under that paper are "enough" for the public. Someone needs to publish a better model (while also critiquing their statistical models & inferences).
view full postMarch 23, 2025
1
-
Emil Borica
@emilborica (Twitter)@Utinadius Pikërisht! Te ky publikimi këtu https://t.co/KqJqW3oAKT…Heggarty thotë që paraardhësit e folësve të shqipes, tokarishtes, anatolishtes, armenishtes e greqishtes s'kanë qenë kurrë në veri në stepë - pra kanë udhëtue për në Ballkan nga jugu i Kaukazit, dhe jo me tjerët nga veriu.
view full postMarch 22, 2025
-
illyrian emperor
@Illyrian2000_ (Twitter)@tvojchalebrale @Euliberty https://t.co/1nuoPep0wj
view full postMarch 22, 2025
-
illyrian emperor
@Illyrian2000_ (Twitter)@PoslednoNevreme https://t.co/Kvoli0yUqf https://t.co/1nuoPep0wj https://t.co/fAA5fdSXWN
view full postMarch 22, 2025
-
illyrian emperor
@Illyrian2000_ (Twitter)@dejantheserbian Researchers used advanced cumputational linguistic methods They have analyse 10o modern nad 52 historical indi European languages and concluded Albanian is the oldest indi European surviving language https://t.co/1nuoPep0wj https://t.co/foi4CR1qbR
view full postMarch 22, 2025
-
Zog Zoggy
@havenosecrets (Twitter)RT @Illyrian2000_: @dejantheserbian I posted an arricle from science Here is the link https://t.co/1nuoPep0wj oxford university put Albani…
view full postMarch 21, 2025
1
-
illyrian emperor
@Illyrian2000_ (Twitter)@dejantheserbian https://t.co/1nuoPep0wj https://t.co/IkFZphfrDZ
view full postMarch 21, 2025
-
illyrian emperor
@Illyrian2000_ (Twitter)@dejantheserbian I posted an arricle from science Here is the link https://t.co/1nuoPep0wj oxford university put Albanian closest to the roots in the European language tree https://t.co/swpcazpoHe
view full postMarch 21, 2025
2
1
-
Wendy
@wendypass1969 (Twitter)The Indo-European language family: controversies and new discoveries https://t.co/yk7HA6axjX via @YouTube
view full postMarch 20, 2025
-
TeluguFilmFile
@TeluguFilmFile (Twitter)@Atacama372842 @DrDavidMiano @eeeirf @bestdarkleopard I don't know if you're taking @vagheesh's comments out of context. Perhaps @vagheesh should clarify directly if he wishes. In any case, the paper by Heggarty et al. (2023) and its assumptions & methods have been criticized already in these eLetters: https://t.co/bHPFHqYwRB
view full postMarch 15, 2025
-
دوریان
@EristDorian (Twitter)https://t.co/bCTGUGAhEy https://t.co/Naro3E9DIp
view full postMarch 12, 2025
3
-
BV
@zhapiiniii (Twitter)@albobuster100 @dgv1133 @mightykosovo .. these are not MY claims, these are what researchers and scientists conclude based on their findings. https://t.co/Y7BmT5nR5H https://t.co/t8xomrnHlu
view full postMarch 4, 2025
-
Illyrian Roots
@IllyrianR (Twitter)@Anastasia7882 @ushtar_darney @ILIASDOMINATOR @ArtanGjini93970 Albanian is a Proto-Indo-European Language
view full postMarch 1, 2025
-
SkāndAryā
@SkandArya999 (Twitter)RT @br_llm_lock: IVC-IE papers: Heggarty 2023 and Yang 2024 for linguistics, IVC-IE link: https://t.co/poUlPEaciG https://t.co/gAMBDlKp3P…
view full postFebruary 22, 2025
15
-
Ibrahim
@Ibragim2423311 (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 20, 2025
30
-
कविक्रतु 卐卐
@LALITADITYAARYA (Twitter)RT @br_llm_lock: IVC-IE papers: Heggarty 2023 and Yang 2024 for linguistics, IVC-IE link: https://t.co/poUlPEaciG https://t.co/gAMBDlKp3P…
view full postFebruary 18, 2025
15
-
amrita banerjee
@tukimatukiba (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 13, 2025
30
-
萬福(笑門來福)☔️ c7+i
@wan4fu2 (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 13, 2025
30
-
Ali Minai
@barbarikon (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 13, 2025
30
-
John Greene
@Greene_Thoughts (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
30
-
Patty_Rosa
@Patty_Rose_L (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
30
-
Martinetus
@Martinetus (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
30
-
Martinetus
@Martinetus (Twitter)https://t.co/GqTDiQWpge
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
3
-
ri
@mardawabasa (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
30
-
Martin Haspelmath
@haspelmath (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
30
-
Mikayel Tovmasyan
@tov3mas (Twitter)Indo-European languages emerged 8000 years ago. This fits with an initial origin south of the Caucasus followed by a branch northward into the Steppe region. This leads to a “hybrid hypothesis” that reconciles current linguistic & ancient DNA evidence. https://t.co/1exjMXn6Fd
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
-
Fabbeyonddadancer
@HB__AUG31_FAB (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
30
-
GOUJIAN
@GOUJIAN_L (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
30
-
MN_shrmn
@tuffimitten (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
30
-
Yuyutsu
@Yuyutsuking (Twitter)@SagasofBharat @NeilHD108 Read this too. https://t.co/daveqfhIpc
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
1
-
Citizens Are Outraged
@PaddedRoom4U (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 12, 2025
30
-
Shqype
@shqype (Twitter)@StevanS007 @E_GuriGashi I understand serbs do not get their information from facts, but instead from national myths, so this may be difficult. But here you go. https://t.co/sK84aQNZPW
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
-
The Seeker
@parella_anthony (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
DevarajaIndra
@DevarajaIndra (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Sameer Ahmed
@SameerA41115539 (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Decodïng Trolls
@DecodingTrolls (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Aaron
@trsn_av10 (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Daniel Tabin
@DanTabin (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Inna Vorobey
@inna_vorobey (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Broseph Smith
@brosephsmith420 (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Vikram Chandra
@typingvanara (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
hbd chick
@hbdchick (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Ryszard Derdziński
@Galadhorn (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Dierk Groeneman
@amish_hooligan (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Kúrlander
@Neurilogical (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Desi Dark
@desiafterdark (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Hasan MS
@HasanMS_10016 (Twitter)RT @iosif_lazaridis: Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had prop…
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
30
-
Iosif Lazaridis
@iosif_lazaridis (Twitter)Paul Heggarty has a commentary on our Indo-European origins paper. https://t.co/0gLA2NuTLP Heggarty et al. had proposed a different scenario of IE origins a couple years ago: https://t.co/TopbrUEeMz In this short thread I will comment on some of the points he makes.
view full postFebruary 11, 2025
176
30
-
Ola Wikander
@OlaWikander (Twitter)@yajnadevam You can find it (it's just a short "letter") here, a ways down: https://t.co/ZCAUBtiMlv
view full postFebruary 6, 2025
2
-
Fabbeyonddadancer
@HB__AUG31_FAB (Twitter)RT @sanjeevsanyal: New paper in Science magazine concludes that "Indo-European" languages emerged 8k years ago i.e. 3k years before earlier…
view full postJanuary 29, 2025
115
-
Roland Baker
@RolandBakerIII (Twitter)@yajnadevam @quityourmeds @vipra618 @ProfVemsani Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/wd2npqbOr3
view full postJanuary 16, 2025
-
Roland Baker
@RolandBakerIII (Twitter)@quityourmeds @zulkuss @ProfVemsani Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/wd2npqbOr3
view full postJanuary 16, 2025
1
-
George Miler
@GeorgeMiler3 (Twitter)Oh not THEM again with their polarizing grammar and "knock-you-down-with-a-stick" sentence structure. The only improvement English made was a way to break contracts and treaties via legalese. Russia blithely ignores these. https://t.co/ASmGCkTqrM
view full postJanuary 13, 2025
-
George Miler
@gigamile.bsky.social (Bluesky)Oh not THEM again with their polarizing grammar and "knock-you-down-with-a-stick" sentence structure. The only improvement English made was a way to break contracts and treaties via legalese. Russia blithely ignores these. youtu.be/We9MZdr92uY
view full postJanuary 13, 2025
1
-
BAB'AZIZ
@RashitiJetulla (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/N0HOGypoPk
view full postDecember 23, 2024
-
ID-Alemani
@idalemaniboris (Twitter)https://t.co/UqtITMv4Qy
view full postDecember 15, 2024
-
Claudio Vascotto
@ClaudioVascott4 (Twitter)Oren Friem https://t.co/YSwZbp7IhK
view full postNovember 30, 2024
-
David Olmsted
@ancientlinguist.bsky.social (Bluesky)November 22, 2024
7
1
-
$icero
@quibell_paul (Twitter)RT @QuibellPaul: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/YcyhP…
view full postNovember 14, 2024
2
-
fraghead
@Quibellp (Twitter)RT @QuibellPaul: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/YcyhP…
view full postNovember 14, 2024
2
-
Paul Quibell-smith
@QuibellPaul (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/YcyhPD4FPs
view full postNovember 14, 2024
2
2
-
Loren Petrich
@lpetrich.bsky.social (Bluesky)The source of that diagram: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science www.science.org/doi/abs/10.1... Proposing Anatolian origin between the times of the Neolithic, Yamnaya dispersions.
view full postNovember 14, 2024
1
-
Անդրանիկ
@0ndro (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postNovember 8, 2024
146
-
Fatmir Raka
@FatmirRaka1 (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/Q9dQLg56vy
view full postSeptember 26, 2024
-
Alen Barsin
@AlenOfAshur (Twitter)https://t.co/B4QoYQY2kn I like this girl's videos on linguistics. This one is exploring the different theories of where the Proto-i-E language originates, & N.Mesopotamia is suggested in the Armenian theory. I'd even suggest it as the origin of both IE & Afro-Asiatic languages.
view full postSeptember 13, 2024
1
-
Eduard Oosterveld
@E__Oosterveld (Twitter)https://t.co/Pp7Q0mX9KB
view full postAugust 26, 2024
-
Faramak Zahraie
@FaramakZahraie (Twitter)https://t.co/gBVfeEioET
view full postAugust 14, 2024
-
Wróżda
@Wrda175532 (Twitter)RT @nrken19: Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full postAugust 10, 2024
10
-
Heidemann
@heidemann_padma (Twitter)RT @nrken19: Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full postAugust 10, 2024
10
-
@9Slavic9 (Twitter)RT @nrken19: Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full postAugust 10, 2024
10
-
Varn Vlog / hyperreality isn’t Disneyland Anymore
@varnvlog (Twitter)The Indo-European language family: controversies and new discoveries https://t.co/ftxX7A3EgB via @YouTube
view full postAugust 9, 2024
3
-
Metal 私己メタル 메탈
@Metal_Terium (Twitter)RT @nrken19: Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full postAugust 9, 2024
10
-
Soumily
@SoumilyD69603 (Twitter)RT @nrken19: Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full postAugust 9, 2024
10
-
Cemal Ağa
@Dewrkirmanc (Twitter)RT @nrken19: Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full postAugust 9, 2024
10
-
Лъытэн Хьаткъо ⋰Ẍ⋱
@Sausruqo (Twitter)RT @nrken19: Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full postAugust 9, 2024
10
-
Brett the Disciple
@BrettGibbs17 (Twitter)RT @nrken19: Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full postAugust 9, 2024
10
-
Asterio Jaen
@AsterioJaen (Twitter)RT @nrken19: Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full postAugust 9, 2024
10
-
@malako2ooo (Twitter)RT @nrken19: Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full postAugust 9, 2024
10
-
Nrken19
@nrken19 (Twitter)Some similar words in Proto-Indo-Iranian and Proto-Balto-Slavic https://t.co/ZzQfm26rvx https://t.co/NJa0U9wiyb
view full postAugust 9, 2024
71
10
-
La Mula Francis
@La_Mula_Francis (Twitter)@Ozu766 @ChifladoEl (aviso, no soy lingüista ni historiador, solo curioso, y seguramente estaré equivocado
view full postJuly 30, 2024
-
@avry_wilson (Twitter)HORSES?
view full postJuly 22, 2024
-
Belupa
@belupa5 (Twitter)The Indo-European language family: controversies and new discoveries https://t.co/clem2jfzsc via @YouTube
view full postJuly 21, 2024
-
CUOZ/HTWC
@CUOZHTWC (Twitter)https://t.co/KyAHTFpvjC
view full postJuly 20, 2024
-
Lirio Bolaffio ☭
@BolaffioLirio (Twitter)The Indo-European language family: controversies and new discoveries https://t.co/mn45ShaPkK via @YouTube
view full postJuly 20, 2024
-
Canthama1
@canthama1 (Twitter)The Indo-European language family: controversies and new discoveries #JuLingo https://t.co/0Rsjjtl2Pv
view full postJuly 20, 2024
-
Chigeorge
@Chigeorge72 (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postJuly 12, 2024
37
-
Ashkash.Baluch
@Izadyar_Baluch (Twitter)RT @Gedrosia_DNA: @Izadyar_Baluch These terms are mostly at the ethnocultural classification level, The Balochi are widely known to be with…
view full postJuly 11, 2024
1
-
Gedrosia AnthroGenica
@Gedrosia_DNA (Twitter)@Izadyar_Baluch These terms are mostly at the ethnocultural classification level, The Balochi are widely known to be within the Iranic tree linguistic models, even at the genetic ethnicity distance they are much closer to other Iranian clades. https://t.co/JWJ7xG086a https://t.co/FyjSwzXUNw https://t.co/x9TCXCGdg2
view full postJuly 10, 2024
2
1
-
Thomas Pellard
@ThomasPellard (Twitter)@EvelyneLesigne @thom L’article : https://t.co/uBLPVdwiLz
view full postMay 10, 2024
1
-
@kukuliqi4 (Twitter)@Di_Ell_ Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/i3bBPToVed
view full postApril 29, 2024
-
Bruce Waynejrv
@Bob_Stinson1234 (Twitter)RT @AthopeMarie: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages. Suggests an emerge…
view full postApril 16, 2024
1
-
Damien Marie AtHope Ⓐ
@AthopeMarie (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages. Suggests an emergence of Indo-European languages 8,000 years ago. A “hybrid hypothesis” that reconciles current linguistic and ancient DNA. https://t.co/gCUXkndrOp https://t.co/0bcVNTIF1v
view full postMarch 27, 2024
1
1
-
Damien Marie AtHope Ⓐ
@damienmarieathope.bsky.social (Bluesky)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages. Suggests an emergence of Indo-European languages 8,000 years ago. A “hybrid hypothesis” that reconciles current linguistic and ancient DNA. www.science.org/doi/10.1126/...
view full postMarch 27, 2024
-
MU-Peter Shimon
@mu-peter.bsky.social (Bluesky)A “hybrid hypothesis” that reconciles current linguistic and ancient DNA. Suggests an emergence of Indo-European languages ~8 Kya. Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages
view full postMarch 26, 2024
2
-
@chenx064 (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European
view full postMarch 9, 2024
-
ID-Alemani
@idalemaniboris (Twitter)https://t.co/2cSpozdwgX
view full postMarch 9, 2024
-
King of Kurdistan
@tiriganofgutium (Twitter)@Irmizanaga2 @_yalnikdsnpskyr @asteraex @kubilai28 Aynı benim dediğim gibi. Kürdistan-Erm civarlarında türemiş, yukarı Yamnayaya gidip ordan da Avrupaya yayılmış. it does not rule out an initial homeland south of the Caucasus, with a subsequent branch northward onto the steppe and then across Europe https://t.co/haoTgaxWjX
view full postMarch 2, 2024
-
journovox69
@journovox69 (Twitter)RT @HCroats: Interesting: language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages. https://t…
view full postFebruary 8, 2024
1
-
History of Croats
@HCroats (Twitter)Interesting: language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages. https://t.co/0XdtwGoK4f https://t.co/IGQH7yIhNX
view full postFebruary 8, 2024
10
1
-
Vasco Silva
@vs_publisher (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/HmKLcSWKBU
view full postJanuary 29, 2024
-
ایران، جان من است،سربازایرانم
@SHAHRYARIRANSH2 (Twitter)RT @iran_antigua: "Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages", 2023, DOI in AL…
view full postJanuary 22, 2024
5
-
drini
@babadrini (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/VLkNycdOMH
view full postJanuary 8, 2024
2
-
Vattanian_Caucasian
@Burneracc9w8 (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postJanuary 7, 2024
37
-
ἀλήθεια
@Kaukning (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/Smjo1Kzy57
view full postDecember 13, 2023
1
-
@The_Equationist (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 24, 2023
37
-
Nat.
@Natyra04694701 (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 16, 2023
37
-
veskino
@vesinioux (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 16, 2023
37
-
Eagle
@KosAlb007 (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 16, 2023
37
-
John Doe
@lastsamuraii_ (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 16, 2023
37
-
Silver Surfer
@SilverSurferRKS (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 15, 2023
37
-
Rewan
@Nexshezan (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 15, 2023
37
-
genci azizi
@genci_ur (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 15, 2023
37
-
Premta
@Premta (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 15, 2023
37
-
Guri Gashi
@E_GuriGashi (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 15, 2023
37
-
Katuwestākos Göranssen
@SeadogDriftwood (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Andrei Melnikov
@cainntear (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Gh-Em Sp
@daxtages500 (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Bottlenecked_Y
@Bottlenecked_Y (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Rasmus Bjørn
@OsoDanes (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Thomas Pellard
@ThomasPellard (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Wayland the Smith
@waylandsmith92 (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
~нет~
@phurdi (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Miguel Angel Contreras Sieck
@MiguelSieck (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Krister Vasshus
@KristerVasshus (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
AfghanDNA
@Afghan_DNA (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Dušan Valent
@DusanValent1 (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Simon Poulsen
@smnplsn (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
P J
@PJ11819211 (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
The animals of the Proto-Indo-Europeans
@PIE_Animals (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Sā́mapriyaḣ
@avzaagzonunaada (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Trevor
@Trevor__Z (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Nrken19
@nrken19 (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Ethan
@lifelongJJ18fan (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Edwin Ko (高明澂)
@eddersko (Twitter)RT @2lander: We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origi…
view full postNovember 14, 2023
37
-
Thomas Olander | @olander.bsky.social
@2lander (Twitter)We’ve published a critique of Heggarty et al. 2023 (Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages) as an eLetter in Science: https://t.co/Gc4Tt2rTWC This figure sums up our concerns. https://t.co/SEaDNDJwtn
view full postNovember 14, 2023
162
37
-
Roland Baker
@RolandBakerIII (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages (H/T @aleksj) https://t.co/wd2npqbOr3 https://t.co/6cOapwffVs
view full postNovember 6, 2023
5
-
B224
@umaxumax472191 (Twitter)@gukgter34 @Hari_3411 Cheddar man this paper debunk your fraud academia. Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/1GEo7yjhjz
view full postNovember 1, 2023
-
Rupesh*
@Aagneyamm (Twitter)4. On the limits of fitting complex models of population history to f-statistics. (Maier et al 2023) 5. Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages (Paul Heggarty et al 2023)
view full postNovember 1, 2023
-
istockhistory
@istockhistory (Twitter)RT @istockhistory: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages #archaeology #arc…
view full postOctober 28, 2023
1
-
aiatmk
@aiatmk1 (Twitter)@tskrishnan @rvaidya2000 And there is this as well shifting the origin to South of Caucuses! Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science
view full postOctober 27, 2023
-
Stephen Pimentel
@StephenPiment (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/nJm6VC2QGn
view full postOctober 26, 2023
-
Pirata
@v4vent (Twitter)RT @godelitsas: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.…
view full postOctober 26, 2023
1
-
Åtħ Gøðêlítšäs
@godelitsas (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/qzd7snAHqy
view full postOctober 26, 2023
1
-
istockhistory
@istockhistory (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages #archaeology #archaeologist #history https://t.co/5BQrd3UjKY
view full postOctober 26, 2023
3
1
-
@meneldis (Twitter)Nuevo estudio reciente apunta a hipótesis híbrida entre ambas principales existentes hasta ahora sobre origen de las lenguas indoeuropeas. - - - "Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages" https://t.co/qfNKNSWXXX
view full postOctober 22, 2023
-
JoséAngelGarcíaLanda
@JoseAngelGLanda (Twitter)@FacultadFiloZgz Heggarty, Paul, et al. "Language Trees with Sampled Ancestors Support a Hybrid Model for the Origin of Indo-European Languages." Science 382.6667 (13 Oct. 2023).* DOI: 10.1126/science.abg081 https://t.co/NsV84D6oBE 2023
view full postOctober 18, 2023
-
Bruce Waynejrv
@Bob_Stinson1234 (Twitter)RT @AthopeMarie: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages Results suggest an…
view full postSeptember 26, 2023
3
-
Viswanathan Satheesh
@satheeshbhoj (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/rv3uoRhnId
view full postSeptember 24, 2023
2
-
Bruce Waynejrv
@Bob_Stinson1234 (Twitter)RT @AthopeMarie: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages Results suggest an…
view full postSeptember 23, 2023
3
-
Bruce Waynejrv
@Bob_Stinson1234 (Twitter)RT @AthopeMarie: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages Results suggest an…
view full postSeptember 22, 2023
3
-
Damien Marie AtHope Ⓐ
@AthopeMarie (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages Results suggest an emergence of Indo-European languages around 8000 years ago. Origin south of the Caucasus followed by the Steppe region. https://t.co/gCUXkndrOp https://t.co/3SVoChvLh9
view full postSeptember 21, 2023
3
-
Damien Marie AtHope Ⓐ
@damienmarieathope.bsky.social (Bluesky)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages Results suggest an emergence of Indo-European languages around 8000 years ago. Origin south of the Caucasus followed by a branch northward into the Steppe region. www.science.org/doi/10.1126/...
view full postSeptember 21, 2023
7
7
-
MU-Peter Shimon
@mu-peter.bsky.social (Bluesky)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages
view full postSeptember 21, 2023
7
-
Ім'я і національність
@Ukrostap (Twitter)@buba_chumonnaya Я дуже сподіваюся невдовзі зробити відео на основі цього дослідження, але якщо хочете почитати, то ця стаття: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages. Paul Heggarty et al Ну і когнати непрямій тяглості не суперечать.
view full postSeptember 12, 2023
3
-
人間界の創造主
@GodOfHumanWorld (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/0FtVAuHdFx
view full postSeptember 10, 2023
-
人間界の創造主
@GodOfHumanWorld (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postSeptember 10, 2023
17
-
Sara
@NahanniFinanci1 (Twitter)Written by a fellow @Carleton_U student. May be of interest to all you linguaphiles: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/9liztQMePQ
view full postAugust 24, 2023
1
-
KopalniaWiedzy.pl
@KopalniaWiedzy (Twitter)28 lipca ukazał się w Science artykuł „Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages” autorstwa 33 badaczy, od pierwszego z nich zwany pracą zespołu Heggarty’ego.
view full postAugust 23, 2023
1
-
Mercator Network
@mercatornetwork (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/JuZvAT1ACU
view full postAugust 23, 2023
-
JakeZ1979
@ztech1979 (Twitter)@victorianarc @Gulshan_Samar @brahmastra8239 @agenetics1 @AshavanWannabe @King72384612 @Cmen12 @DENISSS98945260 Looks like Paul Heggarty et al. are "Indian" too. Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages.Science381,eabg0818(2023). https://t.co/b3HrpYUhoQ
view full postAugust 20, 2023
1
-
BAB'AZIZ
@RashitiJetulla (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/N0HOGyoQZM
view full postAugust 20, 2023
-
*
@robluka10 (Twitter)@iLordofnothing Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages. This is the name of the paper.
view full postAugust 18, 2023
-
Ian
@IanAdAstra (Twitter)RT @razibkhan: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/AkJQ2LO…
view full postAugust 17, 2023
2
-
The Seeker
@parella_anthony (Twitter)RT @razibkhan: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/AkJQ2LO…
view full postAugust 17, 2023
2
-
Razib Khan
@razibkhan (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/AkJQ2LOj7H when paper came out some of indian-twitter exulted over this paper, declaring it a definitive slam dunk. after a few reads...ngl, no there there for me
view full postAugust 17, 2023
10
2
-
吉澤和徳
@psocodea (Twitter)めも Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/R3yFuWWZqg
view full postAugust 14, 2023
2
-
Gedrosia AnthroGenica
@Gedrosia_DNA (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages. Heggarty et al. 2023 Source: https://t.co/JWJ7xG086a https://t.co/bgCL8HmOaX
view full postAugust 14, 2023
4
-
MU-Peter Shimon
@mu-peter.bsky.social (Bluesky)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages
view full postAugust 10, 2023
2
1
-
John Greene
@Greene_Thoughts (Twitter)RT @ResourceToday: In a recent study published in the journal #Science, @ScienceMagazine, researchers from @MPI_EVA_Leipzig and collaborato…
view full postAugust 8, 2023
1
-
Natural Resource Today
@ResourceToday (Twitter)In a recent study published in the journal #Science, @ScienceMagazine, researchers from @MPI_EVA_Leipzig and collaborators shine new light on the origins of Indo-European languages. https://t.co/UM8QqekUaY
view full postAugust 8, 2023
1
-
Tomoya Nakai
@TomNakai (Twitter)Heggarty et al., Science (2023) Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/Jxr9LRe3dn
view full postAugust 8, 2023
1
-
Mike Babayan (Մայքլ Բաբայան)
@MikleBabayan (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postAugust 7, 2023
146
-
Genc Struga
@genc_struga (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages PAUL HEGGARTY et al SCIENCE July 2023 https://t.co/qJ6hAUrs5h
view full postAugust 5, 2023
1
-
Ilona
@VodkaMango (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postAugust 4, 2023
146
-
Serendipity
@Evaninreal (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postAugust 4, 2023
146
-
Durham Cultural Evolution Research Centre
@Durham_DCERC (Twitter)RT @DrQueue: We have a new paper (round 3!) on the origins of Indo-European out this week in Science. Kudos to the amazing work by Paul Heg…
view full postAugust 4, 2023
4
-
哲楽編集部
@MIDAP (Twitter)【元論文】Paul Heggarty et al. ,Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages. Science381,eabg0818(2023). DOI:10.1126/science.abg0818
view full postAugust 4, 2023
-
Tony Rosado
@rpstranslations (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages https://t.co/n7hPGDYJin https://t.co/nkZxmZNWLY
view full postAugust 4, 2023
-
B
@blendi_fshs (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages | Science https://t.co/CTczpFUuLb
view full postAugust 3, 2023
-
rogueclassicist ~ david meadows
@rogueclassicist (Twitter)RT @YaleClassicsLib: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages / Paul Heggarty…
view full postAugust 1, 2023
3
-
Dr. Candice Chi-Hang Cheung
@CandiceCheung12 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postAugust 1, 2023
146
-
LAGOOS Project
@LAGOOS_Hase (Twitter)RT @YaleClassicsLib: Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages / Paul Heggarty…
view full postAugust 1, 2023
3
-
Yale Classics Lib
@YaleClassicsLib (Twitter)Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages / Paul Heggarty, et al @ScienceMagazine Vol 381, No. . 6656 https://t.co/B7fxfcBbAz @mattitiahu @MJKue @matt_boot_ @SimonJGreenhill https://t.co/pg1Kp8PAsX
view full postJuly 31, 2023
10
3
-
cecilia böcking
@cecilia_bocking (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 31, 2023
146
-
Klaus Riede
@KlausRiede (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 31, 2023
146
-
Maren Wellenreuther
@MarenWellenreut (Twitter)RT @DrQueue: We have a new paper (round 3!) on the origins of Indo-European out this week in Science. Kudos to the amazing work by Paul Heg…
view full postJuly 31, 2023
4
-
しん
@lacinaludowa (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
17
-
David Schmitt
@PsychoSchmitt (Twitter)RT @DrQueue: We have a new paper (round 3!) on the origins of Indo-European out this week in Science. Kudos to the amazing work by Paul Heg…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
4
-
Wayne Borean — Absent Minded Mad Scientist
@wayneborean (Twitter)RT @johnhawks: An interesting paper revising the origin of Indo-European languages. Confused for a moment because "hybrid model" used here…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
17
-
Yo Nakawake
@ynk_socpsy (Twitter)RT @DrQueue: We have a new paper (round 3!) on the origins of Indo-European out this week in Science. Kudos to the amazing work by Paul Heg…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
4
-
Quentin Atkinson
@DrQueue (Twitter)We have a new paper (round 3!) on the origins of Indo-European out this week in Science. Kudos to the amazing work by Paul Heggarty, Cormac Anderson and team producing the new IE database that underpins this analysis - https://t.co/q7FxpnkX2D
view full postJuly 30, 2023
22
4
-
Bilgesu Tetik
@bilgesu__tetik (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
146
-
Gürkan Ergin
@gurkan_ergin (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
146
-
Sir PSmith Roger
@PSmith93 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
146
-
Miguel Ángel Martínez
@mican81 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
146
-
Mario
@_4Mri (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
146
-
Dr. Sudip Das
@sudu87 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
146
-
stephen jürgen
@knolloz (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
146
-
sciencenews
@Scieducation1 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
146
-
Max Planck Society
@maxplanckpress (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
146
-
弟切千隼@幻想植物の人
@OTOGIRI_Chihaya (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
17
-
watchtower
@watchto42356831 (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
17
-
きこ
@quiqueaux (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
17
-
タブララサ＠tblrs࿇
@Zfk6iY81 (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
17
-
ものしり中納言
@monoshiri_lab (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
17
-
ｍ
@m5196245258 (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
17
-
Kazuo Shima
@shimakaz (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
17
-
巫俊（ふしゅん）
@fushunia (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 30, 2023
17
-
IM
@izakmoss (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
Rick Deckard
@Loyal_Wingman_ (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
Ur liɣ isem
@nkksixfinu (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
Joel López Parés
@jovepaleontoleg (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
京都大学軽音楽部
@kulmc (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
17
-
Geelel
@fuutaanke19 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
Inflation-Kris
@ektrit (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
Hawara
@WickedTrapper (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
月見うどん
@ORPkMsniQpHxAHI (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
17
-
Núria Barnolas
@nuria_barnolas (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
雑草スレイヤー
@gc_cic (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
アライグマの図書館
@racoonlovesbook (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
はっちゃけ
@hacchake (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
京大軽音 オリエンテーション
@kulmcorient (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
Rafa Garrido-Pena
@RafaGarridoPena (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
Heathcliff
@Heathcl67677405 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
京大軽音 オリエンテーション
@kulmcorient (Twitter)RT @Florisbad: インド・ヨーロッパ語族の分岐開始は紀元前8120年頃で、究極的な起源地はコーカサスの南側にあり、アナトリア仮説と草原地帯仮説が共に部分的に支持され、インド・イラン語派が草原地帯経由で拡大した可能性は低そうとの研究。 最近の古代ゲノム研究と整合的かも…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
17
-
サイエンスあれこれ
@sarekore (Twitter)誕生し、約 7000 年前までに 5 つの主要な系統がすでに分岐していたと推定されました。この結果は、草原仮説と農耕仮説のいずれとも完全には一致せず、主な起源としての農耕と第二の故郷としての草原の両方から得られたハイブリッド仮説を示唆しています。Science誌https://t.co/5pTe1m24aI
view full postJuly 29, 2023
2
-
Denver Hodge Lentil Fund
@DerAchsenZeit (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 29, 2023
146
-
Saint-John Lazarus
@StJohnLazar (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Luis Arau
@luisarau_ (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Catrina
@MLadyCatriona (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
F A B
@ego_faba_sum (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
MH. Rahmani
@mh_rahmani (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Ioannis Soros
@IoanSoros (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Lucia Vidal de Puig
@LuciaVidaldePu1 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Antoni Mañé i Rovira
@cota3143 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
jana_u
@januski2 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Rodi
@Rodi_kurdistani (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Hegaluze
@Hegaluze193515 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Josep Ma. Rovira
@JosepMaCalaFont (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
ferran martinez
@unaltredelleida (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Josep Lluís Alay
@josepalay (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
The animals of the Proto-Indo-Europeans
@PIE_Animals (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Cambridge Uni Biological Anthropology Society
@CamBioAnthSoc (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Missi Lotze
@LotzeMissi (Twitter)RT @johnhawks: An interesting paper revising the origin of Indo-European languages. Confused for a moment because "hybrid model" used here…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
17
-
PhD. Vi. GC
@51ViGC (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
sakanoue no fusigi
@seeker98747 (Twitter)RT @MPI_EVA_Leipzig: New hybrid hypothesis for the origin and spread of the Indo-European #languages. New study in @ScienceMagazine by an…
view full postJuly 28, 2023
146
-
Matthew Scarborough
@mattitiahu.bsky.social (Bluesky)Nearly eight years in the making, our paper "Language trees with sampled ancestors support a hybrid model for the origin of Indo-European languages" has finally been published today in Science https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abg0818
view full postJuly 27, 2023
24
19
Abstract Synopsis
- The study analyzes the origins of Indo-European languages, which have been debated, focusing on two main theories: one suggesting a farming expansion from Anatolia around 9000 years ago and another proposing a pastoral spread from the Pontic-Caspian Steppe around 6000 years ago.
- Using a comprehensive database of Indo-European core vocabulary, the researchers found that very few ancient languages are direct ancestors of modern languages and determined a root age of about 8120 years for the language family.
- Although this root age doesn't completely align with the Steppe hypothesis, it supports a hybrid model suggesting a possible initial homeland south of the Caucasus, with later movements northward to the steppe and into Europe, aligning this view with recent ancient DNA evidence from these regions.
Ghibli
@Lucio_NN (Twitter)