Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
The discussions around the article emphasize the troubling notion that AI-generated faces, especially those of White individuals, are perceived as more real than actual human faces. For instance, users commented on the unsettling outcomes of the research, using phrases like 'discouraging news' and expressed a loss of trust in visual information, suggesting this technology poses profound implications for society. The tone is often a mix of intrigue and concern, indicating a recognition of the potential biases and ethical dilemmas introduced by AI's increasing realism.
Many posts reflect a general agreement with the findings, acknowledging the implications of AI hyperrealism.
There is a strong display of curiosity about the topic, with users frequently sharing links and asking questions.
While some discussions engage deeply with the research, others exhibit superficial interactions focused mostly on sharing the article.
Contributors see the findings as significant, particularly regarding the societal implications of AI-generated faces.
AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones https://t.co/QwohcaRRw3
AIが生成した白人の顔は実在の人間の顔よりも人間らしいと評価されるという研究。この誤りを最も犯した人はもっとも自信が高かった。AI顔と人間顔を区別する属性を同定したが、参加者はそれを誤って解釈し、AI顔を人間らしいと評価した。（Miller et al., 2023, Psychol Sci）https://t.co/vWOg5YObOU https://t.co/yNWoVb6QT2
Open access paper. https://t.co/jn932kNSpJ
AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones (it’s great when our recent research is replicated, and it’s even better when this new independent work is so well done !) https://t.co/b3BTLcSOEm https://t.co/b3BTLcSOEm
White AI faces can convincingly pass as more "real" than actual human faces—and people do not realize they are being fooled. Don't believe me? Check out figure 3, and tell me if you can spot the differences. A fun project with a fun research team https://t.co/tuJzc3Moyh
Twarze osób stworzonych generatywnym AI są już nie do odróżnienia od prawdziwych. Co więcej, wyglądają bardziej realistycznie niż te prawdziwych ludzi. Pytanie czy zajdzie potrzeba by ludzie używali makijażu (albo go nie używali) by wyglądać prawdziwiej? https://t.co/erEslhc4sH https://t.co/up3sozgE29
Have you ever wondered if you can differentiate between a photograph of a real person and one created by artificial intelligence (AI)? Recent studies indicate that people struggle to tell them apart and often view…
Step into the intriguing world of AI-generated human faces. We explore the evolution of AI in face generation, highlighting how these creations are often perceived as more human than actual faces. Discover the…
RT @paulericmorris: Discouraging news of the day: White AI faces are judged as human more often than actual human faces. https://t.co/ywH…
RT @paulericmorris: Discouraging news of the day: White AI faces are judged as human more often than actual human faces. https://t.co/ywH…
Discouraging news of the day: White AI faces are judged as human more often than actual human faces. https://t.co/ywHeEAdf1D
unfortunately the computer looked at my face and was like "nah this looks fake" so I haven't been able to read this yet: AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones. Psychological Science, 34(12), 1390-1403. journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/...
@chadcmulligan @The_Nikomo @IwriteOK @opinonhaver https://t.co/0QMceLLLty https://t.co/YqVFSaeDK2 https://t.co/8eIF1eB4cW. Now what spooky soul magic do you think a human imparts on their creation that can't be automated? Also why is making a movie more filled with spooky soul magic than the above examples?
[Paper] - #AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones | sagepub | By Elizabeth J. Miller, Ben A. Steward, Zak Witkower, Clare A. M. Sutherland, Eva G. Krumhuber, Amy Dawel, 2023 https://t.co/pBN15j8HJx https://t.co/NL1bHzPRda
RT @amy_dawel: Our team's new paper on AI hyperrealism for White faces just came out at: https://t.co/W74yPAZBCR You can find out more from…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
RT @myuuko: AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Ar…
AIが生成した顔は人間の顔と見分けられなくなってきていると言われているけど，すでにAI顔の方が実際の人間の顔より「人間らしい」と評価されるよという研究。しかも間違う人ほど自信満々らしい。/ AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones https://t.co/QwohcaRRw3
This research shows people perceive AI-generated faces as more human than pics of real humans & explains why. Also, people most likely to be fooled by the AI faces were the least likely to figure out they were fooled: https://t.co/nFq9xyUxm1 #HigherEd @millerlizjane #Psychology
RT @marcoessomba: #AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones | sagepub | By Elizabeth J. Miller, Ben A. Stew…
#AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones | sagepub | By Elizabeth J. Miller, Ben A. Steward, Zak Witkower, Clare A. M. Sutherland, Eva G. Krumhuber, Amy Dawel, 2023 https://t.co/jBjJ4UB6hq https://t.co/NYUfDMVsQc
#AI Hyperrealism: Why AI #Faces Are Perceived as More #Real Than #Human Ones https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/09567976231207095
#AI Hyperrealism: Why AI #Faces Are Perceived as More #Real Than #Human Ones https://t.co/0RGZcx726o
RT @prywatnik: Twarze osób stworzonych generatywnym AI są już nie do odróżnienia od prawdziwych. Co więcej, wyglądają bardziej realistyczni…
RT @prywatnik: Twarze osób stworzonych generatywnym AI są już nie do odróżnienia od prawdziwych. Co więcej, wyglądają bardziej realistyczni…
RT @prywatnik: Twarze osób stworzonych generatywnym AI są już nie do odróżnienia od prawdziwych. Co więcej, wyglądają bardziej realistyczni…
RT @lukOlejnik: The faces of people created with generative AI are already indistinguishable from real ones. In fact, they are seen as more…
The faces of people created with generative AI are already indistinguishable from real ones. In fact, they are seen as more realistic than those of real people. Will there be a need for people to use makeup (or not use it) to look more real? https://t.co/UvgEVRwGPm https://t.co/bNjcQeULHZ
Twarze osób stworzonych generatywnym AI są już nie do odróżnienia od prawdziwych. Co więcej, wyglądają bardziej realistycznie niż te prawdziwych ludzi. Pytanie czy zajdzie potrzeba by ludzie używali makijażu (albo go nie używali) by wyglądać prawdziwiej? https://t.co/erEslhc4sH https://t.co/up3sozgE29
Çalışma için
https://t.co/MUEsQr5JNX
@RonBoxmining There was a study about this recently. #GFGF https://t.co/dt1oBLGJC6
RT @ojoenlabola: ¿Personas verdaderas o falsas? Las imágenes generadas por inteligencia artificial ya son indistinguibles de fotos reales.…
¿Personas verdaderas o falsas? Las imágenes generadas por inteligencia artificial ya son indistinguibles de fotos reales. En este estudio, las imágenes falsas fueron elegidas por encima de las reales más veces. Esto se pone interesante. https://t.co/LtiuRiRwIp https://t.co/rQA8nbCfM4
RT @DegenRolf: "White AI faces are judged as human more often than actual human faces." https://t.co/GeoooCS5nC https://t.co/rFCPQxsGSj
@vanyagradoboev https://t.co/tBbqkALILn
AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones https://t.co/IKnyKqm1l2
RT @koenfucius: Research finds that (in particular) white AI generated faces can convincingly pass as more real than human faces—and people…
Research finds that (in particular) white AI generated faces can convincingly pass as more real than human faces—and people do not realize they are being fooled. It also identifies the characteristics responsible for this AI Hyperrealism: https://t.co/5NulW90H5p HT @drtcp https://t.co/3I91ZNv1z8
@JamesSurowiecki https://t.co/m3NsdKKrkS "In Experiment 1 (N = 124 adults)...we showed that White AI faces are judged as human more often than actual human faces—a phenomenon we term AI hyperrealism. Paradoxically, people who made the most errors in this task were the most confident"
https://t.co/xw9yC3pfVv Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones https://t.co/aqSoZlwvm4
AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones https://t.co/QKpe4NfG7F KI-generierte Gesichter werden immer öfter als real empfunden, insbesondere wenn es "weiße" Gesichter sind. https://t.co/J2ItHfaFqg https://t.co/VCnotHVS4s
(AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones) - https://t.co/IoULhwBPtp -
Exploring the nuances of #AI Hyperrealism in this insightful research study. AI-generated faces exhibiting more realism than human ones pose interesting implications for the future of technology. A must-read for tech enthusiasts: https://t.co/PH9K75RZQW
Open Access UCL Research: AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones https://t.co/e0vJpGy8UB
RT @mrebollo: un poco técnico, pero por si sirve: las imágenes generadas por IA se perciben como más reales que las de verdad https://t.co/…
un poco técnico, pero por si sirve: las imágenes generadas por IA se perciben como más reales que las de verdad https://t.co/wYztSEbiI0 #ComunicaXII
RT @LatentSpace2000: 人们不仅无法分辨AI人脸和真实人脸，甚至认为AI生成的白人更像真人 澳大利亚国立大学的研究员发现，人们无法分辨AI生成人脸和真实人脸的区别 (GAN 模型)，而且犯错误最多的人是最自信的。甚至AI生成的白人面孔比真实人脸更常被判断为真…
AIが生成した白人の顔は実在の人間の顔よりも人間らしいと評価されるという研究。この誤りを最も犯した人はもっとも自信が高かった。AI顔と人間顔を区別する属性を同定したが、参加者はそれを誤って解釈し、AI顔を人間らしいと評価した。（Miller et al., 2023, Psychol Sci）https://t.co/vWOg5YObOU https://t.co/yNWoVb6QT2
Los rostros generados mediante IA ya nos resultan más 'reales' que las fotos de otros humanos. AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones. https://t.co/x0DhuyRgQG
RT @ZDF: Die linke Person ist jeweils KI-generiert, die rechte echt. Die Teilnehmer einer Studie haben die KI-Bilder fast alle für ziemlic…
Die linke Person ist jeweils KI-generiert, die rechte echt. Die Teilnehmer einer Studie haben die KI-Bilder fast alle für ziemlich echt befunden. https://t.co/qRfrJ2FpIs https://t.co/sEfJI8CMwo
The uncanny mountain: AI faces are perceived as more human than human faces. https://t.co/cU7dDsT6dx https://t.co/ACUw5kzexK https://t.co/IKHTiyWpqR
The hyperrealism effect was consistent across male and female faces, indicating a strong and consistent bias toward perceiving White AI faces as more human-like. We basically can not recognize AI-generated images, and the models are biased! 4/4 Paper: https://t.co/StmPFScZQb
@ThinkWiselyMatt She was in 1989. I remember that night in the club and it was spectacular. Totally convincing on first glance. This is creepy about AI faces... https://t.co/Tya7qYPkwm
Texto interessante. A pesquisa mostra porque as faces de pessoas brancas geradas por AI são geralmente percebidas como mais reais que as faces humanas, fenômeno chamado de “AI Hyperrealism”. Vale a leitura. https://t.co/UZqGSfE55j
人们不仅无法分辨AI人脸和真实人脸，甚至认为AI生成的白人更像真人 澳大利亚国立大学的研究员发现，人们无法分辨AI生成人脸和真实人脸的区别 (GAN 模型)，而且犯错误最多的人是最自信的。甚至AI生成的白人面孔比真实人脸更常被判断为真人——他们称之为AI超现实主义现象。 https://t.co/GLpT76Q2JQ https://t.co/xugnER4VRk
@TechLinkedYT Thanks for your interest in our work on AI Hyperrealism! The article is published open-access (i.e., free to everyone) here https://t.co/ZgnmtCTFj3 and our YouTube talking through the research is here https://t.co/afqisPCqDP
RT @amy_dawel: Our team's new paper on AI hyperrealism for White faces just came out at: https://t.co/W74yPAZBCR You can find out more from…
Die Testpersonen der Studie waren grandios gescheitert: Die 5 Gesichter, die sie für echt hielten, waren mehrheitlich von einer KI generiert worden. Die 5, die sie am sichersten einer KI zuordneten, waren mehrheitlich echt! https://t.co/Je71r8ts4g https://t.co/IPGuXayBfg
RT @ZakWitkower: White AI faces can convincingly pass as more "real" than actual human faces—and people do not realize they are being foole…
AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones https://t.co/Ya3U0dvsgB White faces generated by artificial intelligence (AI) now appear more real than human faces, according to new research led by experts at The Australian National University (ANU).
The problem isn't that people are starting to find AI generated photos of people to be more real than photos of actual people. The problem is scale and the erosion of visual dependency. Only the clinically insane will say, "I'll believe it when I see it." https://t.co/gmWpvxxfnc
AI Hyperrealism: Why AI faces are perceived as more real than human ones https://t.co/wmc3OXKera | By: @SAGEPublishers
RT @emollick: Open access paper. https://t.co/jn932kNSpJ
Our team's new paper on AI hyperrealism for White faces just came out at: https://t.co/W74yPAZBCR You can find out more from our YouTube on the article at: https://t.co/afqisPCqDP @C_AMSutherland @ZakWitkower
Interesting paper on why you probably can't spot an AI generated face even if you think you can https://t.co/0AZY4EVArx https://t.co/ekwwVJoEFE
RT @ZakWitkower: White AI faces can convincingly pass as more "real" than actual human faces—and people do not realize they are being foole…
@adamrisom Found it. See the study at https://t.co/vjIdQoSggZ
RT @cfenollosa: «Recent evidence shows that AI-generated faces are now indistinguishable from human faces. However, algorithms are trained…
«Recent evidence shows that AI-generated faces are now indistinguishable from human faces. However, algorithms are trained disproportionately on White faces, and thus White AI faces may appear especially realistic» https://t.co/KXbcr0I9Us
RT @emollick: Open access paper. https://t.co/jn932kNSpJ
Open access paper. https://t.co/jn932kNSpJ
@AISafetyMemes Cool results! Now in the metaverse it will be very difficult to distinguish between human and AI... This is going to be interesting! BTW, the link to the paper: https://t.co/ay7Ct9LLOs
Interesting results from Australia on AI generated face discernment by humans. Looks like in the metaverse we will now not be able to distinguish human from AI... This is going to be interesting! https://t.co/ay7Ct9LLOs https://t.co/lYO62j5v3K
RT @ZakWitkower: White AI faces can convincingly pass as more "real" than actual human faces—and people do not realize they are being foole…
White AI faces can convincingly pass as more "real" than actual human faces—and people do not realize they are being fooled. Don't believe me? Check out figure 3, and tell me if you can spot the differences. A fun project with a fun research team https://t.co/tuJzc3Moyh
You can read the study here
Humans can't tell if a photo is generated by AI anymore https://t.co/U3E0OEDx5Y
AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones #MachineLearning #AI https://t.co/7X3eyHeIE7
RT @manos_tsakiris: AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones (it’s great when our recent research is replic…
RT @manos_tsakiris: AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones (it’s great when our recent research is replic…
RT @manos_tsakiris: AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones (it’s great when our recent research is replic…
RT @DegenRolf: "White AI faces are judged as human more often than actual human faces." https://t.co/GeoooCS5nC https://t.co/rFCPQxsGSj
RT @manos_tsakiris: AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones (it’s great when our recent research is replic…
RT @manos_tsakiris: AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones (it’s great when our recent research is replic…
AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones (it’s great when our recent research is replicated, and it’s even better when this new independent work is so well done !) https://t.co/b3BTLcSOEm https://t.co/b3BTLcSOEm
AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones (it’s great when our recent research is replicated, and it’s even better when this new independent work is so well done !) journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/...
RT @DegenRolf: "White AI faces are judged as human more often than actual human faces." https://t.co/GeoooCS5nC https://t.co/rFCPQxsGSj
RT @monsoriu: Aquí dejo el enlace a un estudio de Amy Dawel de la @ANUmedia, entre otros, que demuestra que los rostros humanos de personas…
RT @DegenRolf: "White AI faces are judged as human more often than actual human faces." https://t.co/GeoooCS5nC https://t.co/rFCPQxsGSj
RT @DegenRolf: "White AI faces are judged as human more often than actual human faces." https://t.co/GeoooCS5nC https://t.co/rFCPQxsGSj
RT @DegenRolf: "White AI faces are judged as human more often than actual human faces." https://t.co/GeoooCS5nC https://t.co/rFCPQxsGSj
Aquí dejo el enlace a un estudio de Amy Dawel de la @ANUmedia, entre otros, que demuestra que los rostros humanos de personas blancas generados por #IA resultan más creibles que los de otras razas. https://t.co/Ho3HwNMBK6
The study in "Psychological Science" the above "Guardian" article is based upon, & links to: “AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones” 2/2 https://t.co/BNPJkacS4x
AI Hyperrealism: Why AI Faces Are Perceived as More Real Than Human Ones - Elizabeth J. Miller, Ben A. Steward, Zak Witkower, Clare A. M. Sutherland, Eva G. Krumhuber, Amy Dawel, 2023 https://t.co/X8fAu0sANg
Yapay zeka tarafından üretilen beyaz yüzler artık insan yüzlerinden daha gerçek görünüyormuş. Aynı durum renkli insanların görüntüleri için geçerli değilmiş. Bunun nedeni YZ'nın orantısız bir şekilde beyaz yüzler üzerinde eğitilmesiymiş https://t.co/OuBVMRE6DE https://t.co/ldzHEyaSMR