Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
Several posts critique the effectiveness of lifestyle advice, with one participant noting that only 3% of recommended interventions are backed by strong evidence. Another comment mentions that the article's conclusions could 'ruffle a few feathers,' indicating a lively debate about the topic. The use of words like 'questionable' and 'overestimate benefits' illustrates a critical tone toward common public health practices, showcasing diverse viewpoints among participants.
The overall sentiment reflects a mix of support and skepticism regarding lifestyle changes as an effective public health strategy.
While some express interest in the discussion, it does not appear overwhelmingly engaging to everyone.
Several participants share critical thoughts and references, indicating a moderate depth of engagement with the topic.
Many users believe that the article raises important issues that could significantly impact public health recommendations.
Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits, miss key limitations of the evidence, neglect possible harms, and don’t adequately deal with feasibility and opportunity costs. https://t.co/m3uPuPxvSe
Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health https://t.co/kVyg3oRRlP https://t.co/ypbo71FOhY
This will ruffle a few feathers! https://t.co/OGzKfEqCNF
9. Changing behaviour is challenging! Simply put, telling people to exercise etc is simply not enough . https://t.co/OGzKfEqCNF
@DrEilidhMaria @wesstreeting @LBC Does lifestyle advice actually work? Chk out "Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health" https://t.co/HtzB4JGgqW via @minnajohansson1 et al https://t.co/5FDDC1uwFS
Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health | Annals of Internal Medicine https://t.co/elvCHg7JGP
This video discusses the debate over recommending lifestyle changes to patients as a primary method for improving public health outcomes. It highlights concerns regarding the effectiveness and appropriateness of using…
This video examines the debate over recommending lifestyle changes to patients as a primary means of improving public health. It questions the effectiveness of this approach, considering its impact on diverse…
@kiityc @mancunianmedic @Burnt2020 @r1chardf1tzg3r1 @RCPath @BernieCroal @mike4path @JoMartin_path @ilovepathology @PathPresident @PathologyHouse @BritSocHaem @lengreview @NHSEnglandNMD @CMO_England @JeanetteRCR @halliday_kath @DrStephenHarden @tomroques @RCRadiologists @drrobinproctor @mgtmccartney @Abi_Rimmer @bmj_latest @NHSEngland @minnajohansson1 @RichardLehman1 @rcgp @dan1elr0ss @AJR_Radiology @UMichRadiology @MattDavenportMD Prof @minnajohansson1 & a whole host of internationally renowned clin' luminaries have recently covered this imp practical issue "Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health" https://t.co/NbXUQPOZu5
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @DerekGriffin86: 9. Changing behaviour is challenging! Simply put, telling people to exercise etc is simply not enough . https://t.co/OG…
9. Changing behaviour is challenging! Simply put, telling people to exercise etc is simply not enough . https://t.co/OGzKfEqCNF
Enjoyed your paper @minnajohansson1 https://t.co/44fe7aeBwK Embarrassed I made it to mid career and only now started to question the effectiveness of lifestyle advice by physicians.
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
The NICE in the UK recommends 379 lifestyle interventions…Of these,only 3% were supported by high-or moderate-certainty evidence that the recommended clinician intervention helps people change behavior,and another 13% by low-to very-low-certainty evidence https://t.co/1SvAn54NbW
@Clarahco @ProfJoyceHarper Do these good intentions actually work? "Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health" https://t.co/qnCpNbSIdf via @minnajohansson1 et al https://t.co/u09FnPxBAy
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
Bota vården från hälsofanatikerna Bra sammanfattning men läs gärna originalet: https://t.co/GzKRfip1oC https://t.co/rO3Apvg1FH
@JacquiCake @wesstreeting @Keir_Starmer Whether lifestyle advice works is another matter altogether @Dr__Sarmy Chk out "Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health" https://t.co/1tHcwT5MoZ via @minnajohansson1 et al https://t.co/2fYcQAN0Gt
@DrEilidhMaria @wesstreeting @LBC Does lifestyle advice actually work? Chk out "Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health" https://t.co/HtzB4JGgqW via @minnajohansson1 et al https://t.co/5FDDC1uwFS
Interesting commentary piece shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits, miss
@RogerSeheult See new article Minna Johansson, Amanda Niklasson, Loai Albarqouni, et al. Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health. Ann Intern Med. [Epub 10 September 2024]. https://t.co/WwwlxaIJM3
RT @pash22: @dochawking No! @dnunan79 @mgtmccartney @felly500 @minnajohansson1 @vmontori @GuyattGH @LoaiAlbarqouni @adamcifu @NiklassonAman…
@dochawking No! @dnunan79 @mgtmccartney @felly500 @minnajohansson1 @vmontori @GuyattGH @LoaiAlbarqouni @adamcifu @NiklassonAmanda @KarstenJuhl https://t.co/qnCpNbSIdf https://t.co/mSchAtmCin
Guías que recomiendan que los clínicos aconsejen a los pacientes sobre cambios en su estilo de vida: abordaje popular pero cuestionable para mejorar la salud pública https://t.co/2VLi54HG1y PMID 39250805
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @ArashRashidian: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Im…
Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health | Annals of Internal Medicine https://t.co/elvCHg7JGP
RT @DerekGriffin86: This will ruffle a few feathers! https://t.co/OGzKfEqCNF
RT @DerekGriffin86: This will ruffle a few feathers! https://t.co/OGzKfEqCNF
Public Health
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @DerekGriffin86: This will ruffle a few feathers! https://t.co/OGzKfEqCNF
RT @DerekGriffin86: This will ruffle a few feathers! https://t.co/OGzKfEqCNF
RT @DerekGriffin86: This will ruffle a few feathers! https://t.co/OGzKfEqCNF
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
This will ruffle a few feathers! https://t.co/OGzKfEqCNF
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
RT @GuyattGH: Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits,…
Just published commentary shows how even high-quality guidelines recommending lifestyle interventions overestimate benefits, miss key limitations of the evidence, neglect possible harms, and don’t adequately deal with feasibility and opportunity costs. https://t.co/m3uPuPxvSe
RT @AnnalsofIM: Guidelines often recommend that clinicians try to change their patient’s lifestyle. A new paper asks if this an effective &…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @AnnalsofIM: Guidelines often recommend that clinicians try to change their patient’s lifestyle. A new paper asks if this an effective &…
Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health | Annals of Internal Medicine - https://t.co/MshgLfaZqx
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
@alf_collins @SebRees1 @runnermandoc @sib313 @CraigNikolic @mancunianmedic @barrymulholland @felly500 @ADPHUK @GwynneMP @hmtreasury @minnajohansson1 2/n ... Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health" https://t.co/8FwctCQuFQ https://t.co/bbsBRJPWTQ
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
The study: https://t.co/Wz8GCuhihx
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
RT @PhysioMeScience: Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to…
Guidelines Recommending That Clinicians Advise Patients on Lifestyle Changes: A Popular but Questionable Approach to Improve Public Health https://t.co/kVyg3oRRlP https://t.co/ypbo71FOhY
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
RT @minnajohansson1: Clinicians are increasingly being recommended to try to change our patient’s lifestyle. But is our advice helping peop…
Läs hela studien här: https://t.co/Wz8GCuhihx