The overall discussions show excitement and support for the scientific evidence revealing mammoth as a major food source for ancient Americans, with posts emphasizing terms like 'specialists,' 'direct evidence,' and 'supporting' the findings. The tone is enthusiastic and analytical, reflecting a keen interest in how this research challenges or confirms existing theories about prehistoric hunting and survival strategies.
AgreementStrong agreement
Most discussions acknowledge and support the findings that mammoth was a primary part of the Western Clovis diet, indicating strong agreement with the study's conclusions.
InterestHigh interest
The posts show high curiosity and enthusiasm for the topic, with many expressing fascination over prehistoric diets and hunting practices.
EngagementHigh engagement
Many comments reference detailed analyses, specific studies, and implications of the research, demonstrating deep engagement with the content.
ImpactHigh impact
The discussions highlight that these findings can reshape understanding of early human diets and migration, indicating a significant impact on archaeology and anthropology fields.
Abstract in brief
The study uses stable isotope analysis of the Anzick child, the only known Clovis individual, to determine their maternal diet, revealing mammoth as the primary food source, followed by elk and bison.
The findings suggest that Clovis people were mostly specialized megafauna hunters, with diets closely resembling that of a mammoth specialist like the scimitar cat, supporting the megafaunal hunter model.
This dietary pattern indicates that Clovis groups used advanced technology and mobility to hunt large prey, enabling rapid expansion across the Americas after the Ice Age.]
Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivores, subsisting primarily on mammoth, similar to other hypercarnivores like scimitar-toothed cats and dire wolves: https://t.co/N3QduA1UN2 https://t.co/brEzP6Eri7
Dec 5, 2024 · 61 likes · 18 shares · 9,022 followersView post →
SM
Science Magazine
@ScienceMagazine · X
Western Clovis people were mammoth-hunting specialists, according to a new dietary analysis in @ScienceAdvances. https://t.co/SJX3OYlytx https://t.co/VgBRuzs08e
Dec 12, 2024 · 35 likes · 6 shares · 4,547,399 followersView post →
CS
Chris Stringer
@chrisbstringer.bsky.social · Bluesky
Mammoth featured heavily in Western Clovis diet | Science Advances www.science.org/doi/10.1126/...
Western Clovis people were mammoth-hunting specialists, according to a new dietary analysis in @ScienceAdvances. https://t.co/SJX3OYlytx https://t.co/5MBQ0G1WCG
Dec 10, 2024 · 24 likes · 5 shares · 4,547,399 followersView post →
FL
Frédéric Leroy
@fleroy1974 · X
"Rather than suggesting a broad-spectrum lifeway utilizing many small- and medium-sized mammals, these analyses indicate a strong megafaunal focus, primarily on Mammuthus, followed by Cervus and Bison/Camelops."
Original study: https://t.co/J4K8OEQYZv https://t.co/WL89jWm8R6
Dec 4, 2024 · 19 likes · 1 share · 29,203 followersView post →
TJ
Thomas R. Holtz, Jr.
@arctomet.bsky.social · Bluesky
James C. Chatters, Ben A. Potter, Stuart J. Fiedel, Juliet E. Morrow, Christopher N. Jass, and Matthew J. Wooller (2024)
Mammoth featured heavily in Western Clovis diet
Science Advances 10(49): eadr3814
DOI:10.1126/sciadv.adr3814
www.science.org/doi/10.1126/...
The study explores the long-standing relationship between humans and large canids like wolves, dogs, and coyotes in northern Alaska, showing it began during the late Pleistocene period. It highlights ecological…
@thesedgehog @mchen0919 @randallwcarlson https://t.co/Dkp6k6CDPJ
They needed have killed them all off suddenly, rather it could have been a gradual decline over thousands of years, mostly imperceptible to individuals living at the time. Think less blitzkrieg and more protracted strain leading to eventual extinction.
@CosmicTruthsGal @DrTOMontgomery If indeed god made us I think he made us omnivoures and historically most of us were predominantly carnivores.
https://t.co/lTJDEL2txd
https://t.co/QqUUEAZH3M
I not saying we aren't directly responsible for the environmental destruction in just pointing out other truths
Jan 29, 2025 · 1 like · 4,134 followersView post →
TP
Thomas Weimbs, PhD
@weimbslab · X
@MohammedAlo Exactly! That’s why the North American Ice Age people died out and there ARE no native Americans. They were almost 100% carnivores, consuming mostly mammoths. Incompatible with life!
--> Podcast: https://t.co/tyocWEGgcL
- -> Study: https://t.co/IWYP4f1s0X
Dec 25, 2024 · 2 likes · 1,704 followersView post →
K
KetoCN
@KetoCNOfficial · X
RT @weimbslab: Contrary to expectations, North American Ice Age people did NOT die out because of kidney failure even though they were almo…
Contrary to expectations, North American Ice Age people did NOT die out because of kidney failure even though they were almost 100% carnivores, in ketosis a lot, and consuming mostly mammoths.
--> podcast: https://t.co/tyocWEGgcL
- -> Study: https://t.co/IWYP4f1s0X
Dec 25, 2024 · 5 likes · 1 share · 1,704 followersView post →
TW
Trevor Warner
@trevorw1953 · X
Mammoth featured heavily in Western Clovis diet | Science Advances
#anthropology
https://t.co/CFGIy4Riy1
Dec 24, 2024 · 1 like · 8,691 followersView post →
RC
Rich Collins
@richcollins · X
@r75403876 @MrsKlawitter Did the countless generations that ate nearly all meat “end up like the liver king”?
https://t.co/L2LNeWfwlZ
Dec 21, 2024 · 1 like · 2,091 followersView post →
Dג
(((Dan Graur))) ダン דן גראור
@DanGraur · X
Analyses of a bone from the only known Ancient Native American (Clovis) skeleton indicate that his mother diet was mostly mammoth, followed by elk and bison, while the contribution of small mammals was negligible. https://t.co/W58wczrnOL
Dec 20, 2024 · 1 like · 3,348 followersView post →
M
MLipivore
@MLipivore · X
I would love me some mammoth chops for dinner. https://t.co/M1VKl0KTiS
Dec 19, 2024 · 3 likes · 1,805 followersView post →
M
MLipivore
@MLipivore · X
@KenDBerryMD Ali apparently missed the recent study from December 2024, which revealed that mammoths were a substantial food source for ancient humans in North America approximately 13,000 years ago. https://t.co/M1VKl0KTiS
Dec 19, 2024 · 3 likes · 1,805 followersView post →
青
青柳
@FBWM8888 · X
RT @OyatsuMaster: #考古学のおやつ 3/3
▶ James C. Chatters
RT @ScienceMagazine: Western Clovis people were mammoth-hunting specialists, according to a new dietary analysis in @ScienceAdvances. https…
Dec 13, 2024 · 6 shares · 1,731 followersView post →
SF
Shapley Fürskyn
@shiva137 · X
RT @ScienceMagazine: Western Clovis people were mammoth-hunting specialists, according to a new dietary analysis in @ScienceAdvances. https…
Dec 12, 2024 · 6 shares · 213 followersView post →
N
NHSkeptic
@NhSkeptic · X
RT @ScienceMagazine: Western Clovis people were mammoth-hunting specialists, according to a new dietary analysis in @ScienceAdvances. https…
Dec 12, 2024 · 6 shares · 140 followersView post →
CU
CDRI-Academic Affairs Unit
@cdriacademy · X
RT @ScienceMagazine: Western Clovis people were mammoth-hunting specialists, according to a new dietary analysis in @ScienceAdvances. https…
Dec 12, 2024 · 6 shares · 693 followersView post →
SM
Science Magazine
@ScienceMagazine · X
Western Clovis people were mammoth-hunting specialists, according to a new dietary analysis in @ScienceAdvances. https://t.co/SJX3OYlytx https://t.co/VgBRuzs08e
Dec 12, 2024 · 35 likes · 6 shares · 4,547,399 followersView post →
LC
La Scienza Coatta
@ScienzaCoatta · X
Uno studio di un cranio di un bambino di 12.800 anni fa offre uno sguardo su come i primi americani trovavano #cibo e su come la loro caccia potrebbe aver portato a un'estinzione di massa.
De sicuro nun se magnavano l'hamburgher da McDonald!
#mammut
https://t.co/yCH4VXMuuE
Western Clovis people were mammoth-hunting specialists, according to a new dietary analysis. https://t.co/rtrAjrEwtB
Dec 10, 2024 · 2 likes · 1 share · 66,877 followersView post →
FD
Futurist Dog
@FuturistDog · X
RT @ScienceMagazine: Western Clovis people were mammoth-hunting specialists, according to a new dietary analysis in @ScienceAdvances. https…
Dec 10, 2024 · 5 shares · 1,686 followersView post →
LA
Lenice Arruda
@LArruda1945 · X
RT @ScienceMagazine: Western Clovis people were mammoth-hunting specialists, according to a new dietary analysis in @ScienceAdvances. https…
Dec 10, 2024 · 5 shares · 1,151 followersView post →
SM
Science Magazine
@ScienceMagazine · X
Western Clovis people were mammoth-hunting specialists, according to a new dietary analysis in @ScienceAdvances. https://t.co/SJX3OYlytx https://t.co/5MBQ0G1WCG
Dec 10, 2024 · 24 likes · 5 shares · 4,547,399 followersView post →
Dec 9, 2024 · 7 likes · 1 share · 2,091 followersView post →
A
Ausarchosaur
@ausar_the · X
Ref.
https://t.co/FlogwotNXC
Dec 9, 2024 · 8 likes · 1 share · 7,452 followersView post →
S
Sudās
@sudas1891 · X
@Leo_Abstract @cambridge_pt @KetoCarnivore @arteesun @StrengthbyMike @DrEenfeldt https://t.co/FLsJJafeY7 “we find that mammoth was the largest contributor to Clovis diet, followed by elk and bison/camel, while the contribution of small mammals was negligible” why chase small animals when you live in abundance with lots of fat
James C. Chatters, Ben A. Potter, Stuart J. Fiedel, Juliet E. Morrow, Christopher N. Jass, and Matthew J. Wooller (2024)
Mammoth featured heavily in Western Clovis diet
Science Advances 10(49): eadr3814
DOI:10.1126/sciadv.adr3814
www.science.org/doi/10.1126/...
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 7, 2024 · 18 shares · 7,486 followersView post →
GG
Gerard Govers
@gerardgovers · X
Wat aten de eerste Noord-Amerikanen ? Een lekker konijntje, een stukje fazant of everzwijn ? Toch niet: blijkt dat ze vooral mammoeten lustten. Met af en toe een stukje hert. En misschien af en toe wat bison voor de afwisseling. https://t.co/g8RF65oUTd https://t.co/zHRIFg9vTN
Dec 7, 2024 · 3 likes · 3,942 followersView post →
L
LCONCEPCION
@lconcepcionmd · X
Mammoth featured heavily in Western Clovis diet | Science Advances https://t.co/ZULbYCMRCK
Bone analysis on the Clovis Anzick-1 child indicates that roughly 40% of their diet was from mammoths, supporting the notion that they primarily specialized in hunting megafauna.
https://t.co/UGpJ8mQp3v https://t.co/dUt21QYLXm
Dec 6, 2024 · 2 likes · 1,208 followersView post →
LA
L3v1athanState
@L3v1athanS · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 6, 2024 · 18 shares · 100 followersView post →
MC
Mark Collard
@profmarkcollard · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 6, 2024 · 18 shares · 2,614 followersView post →
PB
Pascal Boyer
@PascalBoyerUSA · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 6, 2024 · 18 shares · 3,083 followersView post →
MS
MU-Peter Shimon
@mu-peter.bsky.social · Bluesky
What's for lunch?
It's mammoth... again.
Mammoth featured heavily in Western Clovis diet
Dec 6, 2024 · 6 likes · 17,563 followersView post →
MS
Marcel Salathé
@marcelsalathe · X
“Consumption of plants was negligible”
Stable isotopes analysis of a ~18-month-old male child who lived 13 thousand years ago reveals a diet dominated by Mammoths and Bison.
https://t.co/bXWLp7nJGa
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 524 followersView post →
CD
Captain BJ Dart
@CaptainBJDart · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 379 followersView post →
Z
@zanzibarpress
@zanzibarcitizen · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 837 followersView post →
IJ
Iwona Jodlowska
@JodlowskaIwona · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 732 followersView post →
N
Nemets
@Peter_Nimitz · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 108,176 followersView post →
S
Solicitor
@USASolicitor · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 970 followersView post →
CM
Creolus Magnus
@Creolus_Magnus · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 962 followersView post →
CG
Carsten Grötzinger
@c_groetzinger · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 2,404 followersView post →
XD
Xavier Duran
@xduran_e · X
RT @xduran_e: Fa 13.000 anys, els primers nadius americans menjaven sobretot carn de mamut. Coses que la química, a través dels isòtops, aj…
Dec 5, 2024 · 1 share · 3,044 followersView post →
RH
Richard Harper
@harpersnotes · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 2,197 followersView post →
CA
Carlos E Alvarez
@CarlosEAlvare17 · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 1,167 followersView post →
OS
Oca sapiens
@CoyaudSylvie · X
#zooarcheologia
Certi paper mi sollevano il morale (annus horribilis come nessun altro).
Bref, nelle ossa di un lattante di 18 mesi della "civiltà Clovis", s'è scoperto che 12.800 anni fa gli antenati dei nativi americani mangiavano in primis carne
1/2
https://t.co/kXQw3zR3eL
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 4,134 followersView post →
W
Weightymeasures
@weightymeasures · X
RT @ed_hagen: Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivo…
Dec 5, 2024 · 18 shares · 148 followersView post →
EH
Ed Hagen
@ed_hagen · X
Stable isotope evidence indicates that this Clovis population, early inhabitants of N. America c. 12.7k BP, were hypercarnivores, subsisting primarily on mammoth, similar to other hypercarnivores like scimitar-toothed cats and dire wolves: https://t.co/N3QduA1UN2 https://t.co/brEzP6Eri7
Dec 5, 2024 · 61 likes · 18 shares · 9,022 followersView post →
CH
Chris Hendel
@chrishendel · X
"Because mammoths were rich in protein & fat & migrated long distances, they would have been a reliable food source for ancient humans on the move." https://t.co/A4U8bdsFlY
This finding reminds me of a favorite episode from the TV show, Northern Exposure. https://t.co/jQyGfABPwa https://t.co/My2aP5cqgf
Toddler’s bones have revealed shocking dietary preferences of ancient Americans. It turns out these ancient humans dined on mammoths and other large animals | Researchers claim to have found the “first direct evidence” of the ancient diet.
https://t.co/aWCnxEJFnb
RT @fleroy1974: "Rather than suggesting a broad-spectrum lifeway utilizing many small- and medium-sized mammals, these analyses indicate a…
Dec 5, 2024 · 1 share · 2,303 followersView post →
XD
Xavier Duran
@xduran_e · X
Fa 13.000 anys, els primers nadius americans menjaven sobretot carn de mamut. Coses que la química, a través dels isòtops, ajuda a explicar @ScienceAdvances
https://t.co/ngRHdDwmQd
Dec 5, 2024 · 1 share · 3,044 followersView post →
So cool. We have only one set of human remains from the Clovis Culture, a small child. Now science has determined where the kid's mother got her protein from. Mainly mammoth!
https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv.adr3814
#archaeology #science
NEW SCIENCE: Mammoth featured heavily in Western Clovis diet
"Western Clovis were megafaunal specialists Our results provide direct evidence for Western Clovis diets at ~12,800 cal yr B.P."
Abstract
Ancient Native American ancestors (Clovis) have been interpreted as either https://t.co/W4yHwTHaPV https://t.co/fS1f7znssm
Dec 4, 2024 · 7 likes · 3 shares · 6,365 followersView post →
FA
Fabien Abraini
@Fabiensapiens · X
@Chez_les_taipi @NotVanVeen @AgeMoyen @Alis58805436 Soit ils s'exprimaient pour la zone de Chauvet, et effectivement, le mammouth n'était pas chassé partout. Soit ils devraient mettre à jour leurs connaissances, les études se multiplient ces derniers temps. Outre la liste que je donne plus haut :
https://t.co/iGsQOqHRby
Dec 4, 2024 · 2 likes · 13,111 followersView post →
"Rather than suggesting a broad-spectrum lifeway utilizing many small- and medium-sized mammals, these analyses indicate a strong megafaunal focus, primarily on Mammuthus, followed by Cervus and Bison/Camelops."
Original study: https://t.co/J4K8OEQYZv https://t.co/WL89jWm8R6
Dec 4, 2024 · 19 likes · 1 share · 29,203 followersView post →
N
Nrken19
@nrken19 · X
https://t.co/HViumOHWgD
Dec 4, 2024 · 9 likes · 76,655 followersView post →
F
Antropología Física para todos
Facebook
Chatters et al., Mammoth featured heavily in Western Clovis diet. Sci. Adv.10, eadr3814(2024). https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/sciadv. adr3814.
An artist's reconstruction of Clovis life [IMAGE] | EurekAlert! Science ...
News
Study reveals mammoth as key food source for ancient Americans. University of Alaska Fairbanks. Journal: Science Advances; DOI: 10.1126/sciadv.adr3814. Keywords.