Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
AI synopsis
The discussions reflect widespread consensus on the relevance of Engel’s biopsychosocial model, with many citing its historical roots and ongoing debates, using tone and references that underscore its enduring influence and relevance for modern medicine.
Most discussions acknowledge the importance of the biopsychosocial model as an alternative or complement to the traditional biomedical approach, showing general agreement with the article's premise.
The topic generates high interest, evidenced by references to historical context, critiques, and calls for paradigm shifts, indicating curiosity and relevance.
Participants reference Engel's original work, recent critiques, and debates about terminology, reflecting a moderate depth of engagement with the subject matter.
While the discussions highlight the lasting significance of the model since its proposal in 1977, they suggest modest immediate impact, mostly through awareness and scholarly reflection.
Thanks @MarkLRuffalo & @PsychToday for highlighting Engel's biopsychosocial model! https://t.co/XMweLJrus0 My only reflection is that since #FND is mechanistically & etiologically heterogeneous - prefer the "functional neurological disorder" term. https://t.co/p3vMkJ3Ahj https://t.co/J7h8rhPp0f
“¿Crees que el contexto familiar y social puede detonar conductas agresivas y violencia? #Comportamiento #Neurociencia #FactoresDeRiesgo #PsicopatologíaForense #Criminología” El modelo biopsicosocial (https://t.co/T4NNyIq88V) brinda una perspectiva al respecto. https://t.co/bF4dV0rhNB https://t.co/7o4Tupiz1j
Funny how these critiques are still very much relevant. The Need for a New Medical Model: A Challenge for Biomedicine (published 1977) https://t.co/deiaVz9yzn
The biosychosocial model was proposed as early as 1977, but the biomedical model refuses to die. George Engel's original article is still well worth a read today https://t.co/qLgrbb0Zqx
@JonathanSadowsk Oh, it’s in the classic 1977 Science article. There is a section in which he talks about it https://t.co/UhtHCAzRyv
@SameiHuda https://t.co/T4YXXjrjGA
In summer 2021, Pierre experiences sudden leg weakness while working as a nurse. Initially worried about a neurological disease, diagnosis reveals psychosomatic origins linked to underlying trauma. Psychotherapy helps…
The biopsychosocial model, proposed by Engel in 1977, is essential for managing musculoskeletal pain. However, misinterpretations can lead to suboptimal care. This video discusses insights from recent research that…
The current biomedical model focuses mainly on biological factors, overlooking social, psychological, and behavioral aspects of illness. A new biopsychosocial model is proposed to better understand health and guide…
The current biomedical model of disease primarily focuses on biological factors and overlooks social, psychological, and behavioral aspects of illness. A new biopsychosocial model is suggested to better encompass these…
Who is really responsible for our mental health? In this video, we explore how societal structures, parenting, and public policy influence mental wellbeing, emphasizing the importance of comprehensive care and early…
・生物医学モデルは還元主義(reductinism)や心身二元論(mind-body dualism)に基づいている ・このモデルは研究等には有用だが、心理社会的な次元を排除することに繋がりかねない https://t.co/8vgIykTLQi
@ismailarafa9 هل اطلعت على biopsychosocial model يا دكتور هذة نظرية فى نشأه المرض كتب فيها ورقة بحثية فى السبعينات وأثرت بشكل كبير، اظن العلاج النفسي المعرفى لا يتبع هذه الفلسفة فى أن المرض النفسي بيولوجى حصرا بل يعتبر أن بالأفكار والقناعات هي الأصل الذى يجب علاجه https://t.co/wlmStkAOaQ
・1977年にG.EngelがBPSモデルを提唱 ・疾病理解とケアには生物学的要因に加え、心理的要因、社会的要因を統合して考える必要がある https://t.co/8vgIykTLQi
RT @ericgarcialopez: “¿Crees que el contexto familiar y social puede detonar conductas agresivas y violencia? #Comportamiento #Neurocienci…
“¿Crees que el contexto familiar y social puede detonar conductas agresivas y violencia? #Comportamiento #Neurociencia #FactoresDeRiesgo #PsicopatologíaForense #Criminología” El modelo biopsicosocial (https://t.co/T4NNyIq88V) brinda una perspectiva al respecto. https://t.co/bF4dV0rhNB https://t.co/7o4Tupiz1j
Engel, G.L. (1977). The Need for a New Medical Model: A Challenge for Biomedicine. https://t.co/Q0V1aPbh06
@EikoFried Take it you are referring to this from 1977 https://t.co/K3Rl85n1Ip Which was re-released and made available in 2012 https://t.co/h1IYzD3UGf
@ldndoc @Neal94G This argument has been prevalent since 47 yrs ago. Chk out the 1977 classic by #GeorgeEngel "The Need for a New Medical Model: A Challenge for Biomedicine" https://t.co/xj0AAdscDt https://t.co/lDlGlPecjL
RT @Fradbius: D'aquí també la necessitat de proposar un nou model mèdic, com el biopsicosocial proposat per Engel. Així com substituir el c…
D'aquí també la necessitat de proposar un nou model mèdic, com el biopsicosocial proposat per Engel. Així com substituir el concepte "malaltia mental" per "trastorn mental". 7/7 https://t.co/p7b4EsosMb
@sulmoney Even take in the title ‘The need for a new medical model: A challenge for biomedicine’. He was not happy with your version of the medical model.
"MUSの管理には、生物心理社会モデル(https://t.co/E4a7E5N4Em ;https://t.co/HXG0mgo4xk )が有用である。全人的評価に関連する3つの次元を使用する場合、このモデルは患者中心主義の鍵となることが示唆されている(https://t.co/SR0l3ECgcj ;https://t.co/XS5JCoNU8N )" https://t.co/AfDnhKrRvu
@JackENissen @Dreaming_AMused I didn't coin this word! It was coined by Dr. George Engel in 1977: https://t.co/HguGfXjL5Q
RT @drchrishilton: First plenary sessions at #ICIC23 with @JanDeMaeseneer reminding us of Engel (1977) "The dominant model of disease today…
RT @drchrishilton: First plenary sessions at #ICIC23 with @JanDeMaeseneer reminding us of Engel (1977) "The dominant model of disease today…
First plenary sessions at #ICIC23 with @JanDeMaeseneer reminding us of Engel (1977) "The dominant model of disease today is biomedical... A biopsychosocial model is proposed" [10.1126/science.847460] #integratedcare
Funny how these critiques are still very much relevant. The Need for a New Medical Model: A Challenge for Biomedicine (published 1977) https://t.co/deiaVz9yzn
@JRBneuropsiq Well, hard to fault them for that. I mean, Engel's little piece was published in a very minor journal and has only been cited about 18,614 times. https://t.co/02fwgkggwz
biopsychosocial modelを提唱したジョージ・エンゲルがロチェスター大学 The need for a new medical model: a challenge for biomedicine Science 1977 https://t.co/rthF9OtQAp
@Proletcultist I think George Engel coined the term, and he was trying to keep things firmly within medicine. It's never been a radical phrase. https://t.co/VSre1RrC6x
@JonathanSadowsk Oh, it’s in the classic 1977 Science article. There is a section in which he talks about it https://t.co/UhtHCAzRyv
@SameiHuda https://t.co/T4YXXjrjGA
Thanks @MarkLRuffalo & @PsychToday for highlighting Engel's biopsychosocial model! https://t.co/XMweLJrus0 My only reflection is that since #FND is mechanistically & etiologically heterogeneous - prefer the "functional neurological disorder" term. https://t.co/p3vMkJ3Ahj https://t.co/J7h8rhPp0f
Ce n'est pas une définition officielle, aucune définition officielle du modèle BPS existe d'ailleurs. Le papier original de Engel qui a créé le modèle était d'ailleurs très vague sur le sujet : https://t.co/zKaKG2IE7B
The biosychosocial model was proposed as early as 1977, but the biomedical model refuses to die. George Engel's original article is still well worth a read today https://t.co/qLgrbb0Zqx