"【EBMが何であって何でないのか?】 EBMは""Ivory tower(現実離れして役に立たない)""とか、""Armchair(机上の空論)""と言われることがありますが、その主張は正しいでしょうか? フリーアクセス
Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't.
Mentions
Extended reach
Total likes
Video views
Mentions per month
Apr 2019 – Aug 2025Where it's discussed
-
Blogs48 articles
-
News39 articles
-
X / Twitter34 posts
-
Facebook28 posts
-
Bluesky4 posts
-
YouTube4 videos
AI synopsis
What people are saying
The discussions reflect a collective effort to clarify what evidence-based medicine truly entails, with several comments referencing Sackett’s foundational paper and emphasizing its broader aspects beyond rigid guidelines. Words like 'nuanced,' 'clinical judgment,' and 'ethical principles' demonstrate a respectful tone, highlighting a desire to refine understanding rather than dismiss the core philosophy. The tone often balances critique with appreciation, contributing to a thoughtful exploration of EBM’s complexities and implications.
Most discussions affirm the nuanced understanding of evidence-based medicine, emphasizing the importance of clinical judgment and patient values alongside scientific evidence, aligning with Sackett's original definitions.
Participants display strong curiosity and relevance, referencing core concepts, such as the three pillars of EBM, and engaging in debates about its application and limitations.
Many comments delve into deeper themes, questioning common perceptions, citing specific literature, and discussing implications, indicating active and thoughtful engagement.
There is recognition that the article influences ongoing discourse, though primarily within academic and professional circles, with some posts noting how EBM impacts medical practice and thinking.
Abstract in brief
- Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) is a clinical approach that emphasizes using the best available scientific research, clinical expertise, and patient preferences to make healthcare decisions.
- It is not solely about relying on randomized controlled trials or scientific data; it also considers the clinician’s experience and the individual patient's values.
- The goal of EBM is to improve patient outcomes by integrating evidence with clinical judgment, but it is not a rigid system that disregards the art of medicine or personalized care.]
Top posts
Most liked on X and Blueskyアウトカムとは?というお題の良い題材なりそう笑。EBMの基本からやり直し案件。https://t.co/whv9O6Gvjp https://t.co/oJjtNl9lNy
@doctimcook @pash22 @DrNeilStone Oh dearie me. Evidence based medicine was never ONLY the guidelines. Guidelines 1/3 Patient context/values 1/3 Physician context/expertise 1/3 https://t.co/Ynzal3zNNk Mindlines are the praxis. https://t.co/uCfDEUjF7T
Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't https://t.co/FlrfOlJbRH via #DavidSackett & @bmj_latest https://t.co/GItNrADXfO
leitura basica obrigatoria pra quem quer debater ciencia Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't https://t.co/Inv0B8U6PN
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8555924/
All mentions
Impact of Hydroxychloroquine on COVID-19 Mortality: A Meta-Analysis
This video discusses the methodology employed in the systematic review and meta-analysis examining the effect of hydroxychloroquine with or without azithromycin on COVID-19 patient mortality. Key sections cover analysis…
Understanding Evidence-Based Practice in Healthcare
Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) is a clinical approach that emphasizes using the best available scientific research, clinical expertise, and patient preferences to make healthcare decisions. It aims to improve patient…
Planting Seeds Ayahuasca as a Potential Intervention for Prolonged Grief Disorder
Evaluating Evidence-Based Medicine and the New Evidence Pyramid
Dr. Ken Milne discusses the principles of evidence-based medicine, critical appraisal, and the limitations of traditional evidence hierarchies, introducing a new perspective on the evidence pyramid for clinical…
Outcomes of ISCHEMIA Trial and Revascularization Insights
Bob Harrington interviews Jacqueline Tamis-Holland on the ISCHEMIA trial, which explores revascularization's role in stable coronary artery disease. The study reveals that severe ischemia correlates with higher nonfatal…
@PunGridDoc @Rick_Pescatore I would argue that rigid #EBM is not EBM but rather a strawman or misapplication of the philosophy. EBM includes the literature to inform care but not dictate care. It still requires clinical judgment and asking about patients' values/preferences. https://t.co/qjc17RqVDi https://t.co/V4GQDUFadA
Sackett, D. L., Rosenberg, W. M., Gray, J. A., Haynes, R. B., & Richardson, W. S. (1996). Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't: https://t.co/VnIRCILfOF
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8555924/
@Rudolf_Neumayer @CaulfieldTim @thewalrus It’s a Venn diagram explaining the three pillars of EBM with reference to Dr. Sackett’s paper. https://t.co/qjc17RqVDi Not sure if it’s a meme? Y/N: Is it your position that vax causes autism.? Not sure why you continue to avoid answering this simple question.
Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't www.bmj.com/content/312/...
@Unheilpraktiker @FlorianDreaming @tkurbjuhn @ApothekerDer Na klar, man kann sich natürlich auf ein ganz eigenwilliges, reduziertes Verständnis von EBM zurückziehen ... dann aber fliegt so Manches aus dem therapeutisch anwendbaren Portfolio. Ansonsten siehe hier: https://t.co/Tb9rUsX9LD
@MarwinZander Das ist eine Lüge. Die ist bei ALLAXYS-1 geschreddert worden: "Sackett et al: 'Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't'" https://t.co/klQOaq9YPD
5 Sackett, D.L. et al (1996). Evidence based medicine. What it is and what it isn’t. British Medical Journal, 312, 71-72. 3/n
RT @brookmanknight: @doctimcook @pash22 @DrNeilStone Oh dearie me. Evidence based medicine was never ONLY the guidelines. Guidelines 1/3…
RT @brookmanknight: @doctimcook @pash22 @DrNeilStone Oh dearie me. Evidence based medicine was never ONLY the guidelines. Guidelines 1/3…
RT @pash22: Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't https://t.co/FlrfOlJbRH via #DavidSackett & @bmj_latest
RT @pash22: Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't https://t.co/FlrfOlJbRH via #DavidSackett & @bmj_latest
RT @pash22: Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't https://t.co/FlrfOlJbRH via #DavidSackett & @bmj_latest
RT @pash22: Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't https://t.co/FlrfOlJbRH via #DavidSackett & @bmj_latest
RT @pash22: Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't https://t.co/FlrfOlJbRH via #DavidSackett & @bmj_latest
Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't https://t.co/FlrfOlJbRH via #DavidSackett & @bmj_latest https://t.co/GItNrADXfO
@doctimcook @pash22 @DrNeilStone Oh dearie me. Evidence based medicine was never ONLY the guidelines. Guidelines 1/3 Patient context/values 1/3 Physician context/expertise 1/3 https://t.co/Ynzal3zNNk Mindlines are the praxis. https://t.co/uCfDEUjF7T
@drdanielloy.bsky.social Genau so! Es bedarf keiner Kausalität und Eindeutigkeit durch bestimmte Biomarker (zumal Komplexerkrankung), um dem Versorgungsauftrag nachzukommen und nach ethischen Prinzipien zu handeln. Und selbst „keine Evidenz laut Studien“ befreit nicht von Verantwortung. t1p.de/ogn09
EBMとは何か、それは重要でないと言いつつ… https://t.co/6U4JpciauK
As part of the Y3 Mentoring program of @Cochrane_US doing @cochranecollab ’s digital induction; 3 basic elements for EBM: - Clinical Judgement - Relevant Scientific Evidence - Patients' values and preferences Read more about EBM at DOI: 10.1136/bmj.312.7023.71
Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't - PubMed https://t.co/IQ7oyA2JEV
Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't. Sackett DL, et al. BMJ. 1996;312(7023):71-72. https://t.co/sSKjZV8PI6
RT @kspharmacist: アウトカムとは?というお題の良い題材なりそう笑。EBMの基本からやり直し案件。https://t.co/whv9O6Gvjp
RT @kspharmacist: アウトカムとは?というお題の良い題材なりそう笑。EBMの基本からやり直し案件。https://t.co/whv9O6Gvjp
RT @kspharmacist: アウトカムとは?というお題の良い題材なりそう笑。EBMの基本からやり直し案件。https://t.co/whv9O6Gvjp
RT @kspharmacist: アウトカムとは?というお題の良い題材なりそう笑。EBMの基本からやり直し案件。https://t.co/whv9O6Gvjp
アウトカムとは?というお題の良い題材なりそう笑。EBMの基本からやり直し案件。https://t.co/whv9O6Gvjp https://t.co/oJjtNl9lNy
"Increased expertise is reflected in many ways...in the more thoughtful identification and compassionate use of individual patients' predicaments, rights, and preferences in making clinical decisions about their care." Dr David Sackett https://t.co/lX9S9JMrfL
Als ich 1997 im PJ von der Evidence Based Medicine #EBM lernte, empfand ich das als große Erleichterung und Orientierung. Heute stoße ich oft auf #EBM-Argumente, die das Denken und Forschen eher behindern. https://t.co/GhMjsH5nk3
@RWJE_BA @yudapearl @f2harrell @hemanth_kanak @ADAlthousePhD @PavlosMsaouel @GustafRydevik @stephensenn Are you sure? EBM is the conscientious, explicit, and judicious use of current best evidence in making decisions about the care of individual patients https://t.co/nDKcUjVL7i Since when data is the best evidence? We didn’t have data about landing on the Moon before going there
"【EBMが何であって何でないのか?】 EBMは""Ivory tower(現実離れして役に立たない)""とか、""Armchair(机上の空論)""と言われることがありますが、その主張は正しいでしょうか? フリーアクセス
@TaiwanOzPhysio @Bill_Vicenzino @Retlouping @PaulBliton @AdamMeakins @function2fitnes @leannebisset @LennartBentsen @NeilOConnell https://t.co/EKEKt88W6w https://t.co/9iuomXlM3L
RT @DivagoTM: leitura basica obrigatoria pra quem quer debater ciencia Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't https://t.co…
leitura basica obrigatoria pra quem quer debater ciencia Evidence based medicine: what it is and what it isn't https://t.co/Inv0B8U6PN
@KashPrime @McMasterU #EBM what it is and isn’t. https://t.co/qjc17RqVDi
@trishgreenhalgh We can always rely on the great David Sackett here - presuming this is already part of your paper? https://t.co/TIkyO3LOlT
RT @MBBrodskyPhD: Amazing how experience can add to evidence-based practice. See Sackett (1996): https://t.co/kzx38bLpUR #EBP #icurehab h…
Amazing how experience can add to evidence-based practice. See Sackett (1996): https://t.co/kzx38bLpUR #EBP #icurehab https://t.co/eK67x0vwkX
タ医
カ
AP
AP
DD
KM
MD
V
AD
HH
JS
BB
PJ
PD
名
EA
HM
AA
ま
三
?
青発
GF
DV
BS
TM
MP
S
MB